1. France has the lowest inflation in Europe. 2. Oil companies are private. Salary negociations are out of scope of French government. 3. Aid for Ukraine is constantly provided. 4. Usage of French nuclear weapons is defined in the law.
To be fair tot he French, I don't see why that was a controversial statement. Neither the US or UK will nuke Russia if Russia was to deploy a tactical nuclear weapon in Ukraine. They simply don't need to. They have specifically said that and that any response would be conventional in nature
In the UK, I accept higher price's for a free Ukraine, despite our family being on a low income. No one is bombing me and I don't have to worry about my wife being on the frontline, I say I have it easy. Freedom does have a price, let's see if Putin is correct in thinking Europe is soft and will
Freedom as a price but for ordinary citizens not the people in power. Also it’s hilarious you think that even before the war Ukraine was a free society. Now They banned opposition parties and media and ban the culture of minorities in Ukraine not to mention bombs them. If that is a free country then so is Russia
If Ukraine implemented the Minsk agreement, we would not see what's happening now. But instead they bombarded the population of the east just because they have Russian culture. We're you not shocked then. Double standards as usual.
Same as the united states we paying the most out of any country. I say if France wants to leave nato That great That save a bunch of money on US taxpayers we can pull our 190,000 troops out of France. Leaving there 200,000 military to defend against Russia. Don't ask for help remember you chose to do this on your own I feel no pity for you. The United States should remove their troops from your borders and allow you to defend yourself. When you don't have sympathy for other Innocent people dying then you really don't matter. You are what we like to call a coward. I say good riddance
Not hungry or cold. Haha and on low income. Ukrainian clown want it joint nato. Now he tries involve nato. Such a pathetic man. Putin on other side completely lost his mind and million people suffer. Those two needs to be in prison.
France less dependent on Gas for Electricity so mainly heating. Inflation is around 6% which is much lower than the 10% in other countries. So it is muscle wrestling between its left wings and workers and private industry. This need for many to get involved in protest is what makes France unique!
@@justice2375 Really.. did you know Putin made protesting illegal in Russia? Right before he declared full scale war on innocent Ukraine. Protesting against the Kremlins decisions will lands you in prison.
The extra costs I suffer in France pale into insignificance compared to what the innocent Ukrainians are enduring just because one ignorant man's desires to compare himself to Peter the great.
Blaa blaaa does that mean France people deserve to be suffering... Next try to compare Ukrainian with middle East people where the warmonger US government want to be dominated the world
@@304Hibachi Absolutely, maybe ask Saudi Arabia about that, at last it seems that the US is stopping munition supplies, but it has nothing to do with energy shortages in France.
@@304Hibachi If your asking me then yes I do care about the people of Yemen. They have went through alot for years it's a tragedy, and alot of humanitarian aid is finding its way into Yemen. All one can do is give what you can and hope it all ends soon. Seven years is a long civil war, but it's a bit different than Ukraines war no? Yemen is fighting a internal civil war vs Ukraine being innocent and invaded by its neighbor.
In 🇦🇺, prices have also risen - but we are not in the severe position of EU countries facing winter. So I say thank you to the Europeans who understand that it is necessary to make sacrifices on behalf of Ukraine. 👍 Can't be sure, but it might prevent Putin from extending beyond Ukraine too, maybe starting WW III.
5:45 @CRUX. You are mixing up the EU and NATO. The UK is also a European power with Nuclear Weapons. What matters is what NATO will do not what France would do. Putin has been warned that if Russia uses any nuclear weapons in Ukraine, NATO will respond militarily against the Russian military in Ukraine and the Black Sea.
@@firefly4907 Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances in connection with the Republic of Belarus'/Republic of Kazakhstan's/Ukraine's accession to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons in 1994 also signed by USA, UK and the Russian Federation. It guaranteed the then existing Ukrainian borders on the basis that Urkraine gives up her nuclear weapons to Russia. If Russia now uses nukes in Ukraine a response will have to be made, however not necessarily have to be nuclear one.
The statement from Pdt Macro during an interview on how to use or not use our nuclear capabilities was a strategic and military mistake that weakened our deterrence power... Also regarding the increased cost of living and the war in Ukraine: there is almost no correlation. The poll suggesting that the sanctions against Russia don't work and in fact increase the cost of living (esp. energy) is mainly due to uneducated French people who don't know how energy power is generated in France (gas represents 8% of energy power generated in FR, btw). The real reason for energy price surge is due to multiple factors: how the energy price is computed on the local market (not based on offer/demand), the issues on nuclear power plants (corrosion, long regular maintenance window), poor green energy transition strategy, etc. The rest of the explanation is very good, thumbs up.
Your journalism is slightly disingenuous. Firstly, the EU led the way in imposing sanctions against Russia. Secondly, even if it’s slipping, the majority of French people still support them. Thirdly, the US has also hinted that they would respond conventionally to a nuclear attack on Ukraine. Fourthly, France is not the only European nation to have nuclear weapons, the UK also has them.
@@StreamMediaSkeptic when someone speaks truth you will say it is probaganda channel. There are videos published in favor of West, he says the truth. Only you have to grow up to accept the truth. It is hard to accept truth. But it is necessary to do .
@Endrum Ungaludan No, I don't determine the truth just because it agrees with my opinion or desires. Truth is objective, but this channel is not. And I never said all western channels were true, there are propaganda channels there too, and most of them are just as easy to spot as this one. Edit: Spelling correction.
Germany to follow, peope were protesting to open NS 2 but our partners USA blew it. People are stil protetsing though and getting bigger protests. Europes interest is not USA interest, we have to follow our own interest not getting even more energy and military dependent on USA!
And you didn't even get that the whole video is a clickbait mess and a mix of topics that aren't related to each other ? That just dumb and you just get out your 2003 US-built propaganda against France, so weak. France is increasing its help to Ukraine both financial and military, the country votes all the new sanctions packages against Russia + Iran and its gas stocks are full for winter. So no fear of being cut with hydrocarbon supplies, they were already stopped in july
France doesn't really contribute Nato The United States has been forked in their bills forever. That great That will save a bunch of money on US taxpayers we can pull our 190,000 troops out of France. Leaving there 200,000 military to defend against Russia. Don't ask for help remember you chose to do this on your own I feel no pity for you. The United States should remove their troops from your borders and allow you to defend yourself. When you don't have sympathy for other Innocent people dying then you really don't matter. You are what we like to call a coward. I say good riddance
@@pamelajohnson4011 Loool France sent back home all the US soldiers of its soil in 1945. The country was and is thanksful for the big help but they aren't stupid: a country can't be considered independent with US bases ans thousands of soldiers inside its borders. And of course France doesn't pay any bill to the US: the French developed a complete and local defence industry so they don't buy anything to the US or to anybody else that doesn't involve French compnies except very specific products like Hawkeye or carrier catapult. Anyway, France doesn't need your support but other NATO countries do so keep your promises
it's not unusual most of the European suffers inflation because of higher gas prices except Norway and the middle east. if Macron wants to confront NATO it's up to him or leave NATO.
France leaving NATO isn't going to change matters in Europe. But the French will do what they always do when times are hard (having lost any backbone since Napoleon times)
And you didn't even get that the whole video is a clickbait mess and a mix of topics that aren't related to each other ? That just dumb. France is increasing its help to Ukraine both financial and military, the country votes all the new sanctions packages against Russia + Iran and its gas stocks are full for winter. So no fear of being cut with hydrocarbon supplies, they were already stopped in july
I mean Kazakhstan is leaving CSTO russias knock off nato and refusing to help russia Azerbaijan invaded armenia who is CSTO member and russia did not do a thing about it 😂Azerbaijan is about to attain a land bridge straight to turkey and increase oil and gan flow to west
Putin will prove a better economist and politician than general. The battlefield has been an embarrassment and the assault on civilians and infrastructure requires stronger adjectives. But as this war continues, NATO and EU will crack and the petrodollar / world reserve currency status of the US$ will also weaken. The BRICS will emerge bolstered by the shift of Saudi Arabia and OPEC+ away from the West toward Eurasia. Kinetic war kills and destroys. Energy and inflation change alliances, wreck economies and political establishments. Putin has unleashed war and the dependency about which Trump confronted and warned Merkel of is now apparent. But Merkel somehow can look past the invasion as recently as last week and call Russia the only answer. Trump consigned himself to dustbin on 1/6 and since. But he was right about a number of things and the liberal establishment hated him accordingly. The questions this piece pose go to the European mindset of the Merkel generation. Putin understood this from the outset and is succeeding in breaking the Eurozone. Merkel was easily duped, a product of far left statism herself. After this is over, years from now, the destruction of Ukraine will be secondary to the economic and political destruction of the Eurozone. Merkel will still be preaching obsequious reliance on Russia and her followers will still be following. Gorby said buffer zone. NATO said no. Putin and Merkel took it from there. When you do the postmortem on Europe, begin in '46. NATO did achieve the longest period of stability in the history of Europe. But Gorbachev was betrayed and the outcome of the Merkel and Putin venture was a foregone conclusion though it took awhile and enjoyed a productive interim. NATO should have responded on February 24, 2022. They didn't and that was the day Europe and the UK were lost. Or one could argue Blinken could have brought a longer view of the history. Well it's academic at this point. The neocons got what they wanted but the outcome won't be what they wanted. They were neither generals, politicians nor economists.
And then what? It's not like those protest or the resignation will gain anything It's pointless, it's not gas will simple return back and cheap at the snap of anyone fingers, this is why everyone should have moved on to green energy and became full self sufficient in all country's
@@loonowolf2160 I'm dead sure that will call for some celebration in the Kremlin and Beijing. All the lousy US chihuahua allies leaders must be kicked out for compromising their nations to appease the US. Oh I will also celebrate
France surrender to Hitter without setting a good fight dus probably it will happen again. People of France we understand your way of living have been affected by the Putin war and we won’t blame you to surrender to that 4 feet monster. Bonne chance chers amis
Historical lack of knowledge as usual. The Germans lost 80000 soldiers, half of their planes and 1/3 of their tanks in 1940 against France (Brits had already vanished). Thanks to the US/UK made anti-French propaganda after the clever move made by the French in 2003 about Irak
@@remistiegler5302 How could the nazis lost so many soldiers in six weeks, i need to check that. About Ukraine i understand that soon most Nato countries won’t have stomach anymore to keep helping Ukraine and I believe Putin is counting on that. It will be his chance to keep moving until war break down in Europe again. I believe Macron will be the first the say good bye as the uprising in France won’t allow him to stay in the alliance against Putin. After that the remaining Nato countries will also break away.
@@Savetheplanet802 the reason is simple: the "France all surrender" BS is a lie that has been created by Vichy collaborators for their propaganda then reused by US/UK for their own propaganda, especially after the 2003 decision to not participate in the doomed Second Gulf war. And again you're wrong if you believe France would lower the sanctions because of the strikes: what you call an "uprising" is something very common here in France and the pandemic just slowed the social activity of unions and civil society that become branch strikes, blockades, .... until now. The trend is even the opposite for Paris, by increasing the military support and boost the financial one through the EU funding support. And 73% of the French still support the sanctions against Putler's regime, unlike in Serbia or in Czech Rep., nobody strike against the sanctions/for Putin (out of very few hardcore supporters)
We're not surrendering, the majority of french still support military aid to Ukraine and we've been sending equipment to them since before the war, the fact is that protests are extremely common in France, this has nothing to do with the war.
When France' Jacque Chirac refused the UN Resolution for a second Persian Gulf War which forced the US to form a Coalition of the Willing, it saved the world from an early Gog and Magog. Chirac had consulted the University of Laussane's foremost theologian, Thomas Rom who told Chirac, the temple has to be rebuilt first.
My cost of living has risen by 30% and, on my low very income. it is a real burden. I am content in the knowledge that it is for a good cause while Ukrainians are dying for freedom and democracy. France has left NATO before so let them now. They want to go so good riddance. They should need to reapply though. That would make them a target for Russia or anyone else.
Won't be the first time the French sold out in the face of war. They did it in WW11. It was the French partisans' who assisted the Allied Powers during that war.
Europe IS NOT CAVING to American pressure. If America stopped with them, Europe would impose them anyway. What is this stupid “America is the only reason for Europe’s action” idea? Greetings from heart of Europe- Prague!
France does not represent the rest of Europe much. Europe East from France is really big, huge, populous and much more serious in helping Ukraine than France is. It’s France who is on the periphery here
Such a waste of time. Instead of pulling in together on complex issues at a extremely dangerous time, politicians agitate, people march in anger, and short term objectives take precedence. Although leaders must work on plans and take action that give people confidence that immediate financial worries will be addressed.
Hey Big Brain leaders. Please sit together, cooperate with each other on priority and negotiate. Why need war, let's cooperate and make the relationship, and live peacefully.
I would like to see France just being France..independent,NATO doesn't have good name anymore for what all they left behind in world.. to leave this organization is definitely a good choice.
2011 was the year for the Arab Spring. 2022 is the year to break up with North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Will America support the will of the people in the name of democracy? Not a chance. Democracy in America is within double standards. 😄
The rage inside protestor can definitely win Ukraine war . Dont waste the energy on protesting , use the energy wisely and aim at the one who create this crisis . Mr 💩tin
The prosperity of the EU and Europe in general has been in essence buoyed for years by Cheap Energy from RUSSIA NOT from anything sponsored by he USA . You are biting the hand that has been feeding you and May God bless and Protect RUSSIA and the Russian People from people like you
Actually NATO ought to dump Macron he is nothing but a guy looking for the limelight his few minutes of fame..he's not worth having as the leader of the great country of France
This happen when your country depend on others country for everything's. Now you Neither stand strongly support with Ukraine & NATO nor against Russia.
A bad sign is that France has increased production of its white flag factories - they may be going to declare a pre-emptive surrender to Putin. I wonder if France would support NATO more if France had a border with Russian federation ?
Ah, the good old bad US-made jokes about France are back ! If you believe France will leave NATO or abandon the Ukrainians because of this clickbait video, it mean you don't understand anything in this conflict
@@remistiegler5302 I believe that France avoids any of the worlds problems, despite boasting about their military prowess, Their military will never get dirty from being used, it will stay in the box with its shiny paint intact until it is scrapped for some new, shinier stuff.
@@chrissmith2114 so I was right, you have no idea of what you're talking about. Build yourself a general knowledge and find out what Daman, Daguet, KFOR, Kapisa, Harmattan, Serval, Barkhane, Chammal, Sangaris, Lynx, Aigle... are. Then you will understand France has one of the most active armed force in the world and is one of the very few countries able to project its forces abroad in a very short period of time
882 year of the "Tale of Bygone Years", and Oleg sat down to reign in Kiev, and Oleg said: "May it be the mother of Russian cities." And he had Slavs, and Varangians, and others, nicknamed Rus.
France is a great democratic country. President Macron is a great, honest, democratic, liberal, munificient, charismatic,handsome and intelligent leader. He was upfront in countering Kremlin's aggression. World needs such strong and honest leaders. Hail President Macron's leadership. French values of freedom,democracy, liberalism, secularism and human rights are great ✝️✝️😇😇👍👍
Very approximative informations about France...Those who are in the street or on strike earn twice or more than the minimum. Strikes aren't about inflation or something else, syndicats only use the crisis with gas to obtain sympathy of the labors. CGT (huge syndicat) often create trouble to justify its existence and doesn't Care about casualties for the citizens. The attitud of this syndicat is disrespectful for Ukrain, by using gas crisis, when ukrainians suffer of everything (life in danger, lack of energy, cities in ruins, no Windows or Doors to prevent winter,...) I'm french, i earn less than those who strike (no need to earn more), ans i stand for ukrainians.
@@justice2375 No they only beat them with sticks and shock them with cattle prods, but that of course only if it is a peaceful protest, if it was an actual riot...live ammunition.
The US doesn’t OWN the gas companies here. They are all corporate owned. You should be screaming at them and the Saudis since they own the second largest in Texas. And now slowed down production to jack up the prices. It’s all about Greed. We have the highest prices here to. In Ca it’s been $6.10. Those evil bastards😢.
I would love to see either member of NATO alliance leaving. Truth be told I wish to see the whole of NATO alliance disintegrating. Why in today's world you need military alliance. The very existence of such military alliance is the reason for instability of global peace and order.
1. France has the lowest inflation in Europe.
2. Oil companies are private.
Salary negociations are out of scope of French government.
3. Aid for Ukraine is constantly provided.
4. Usage of French nuclear weapons is defined in the law.
fresh people is just weak and surrender like in ww2 and now
excellent points....but doesnt fit the russian propaganda agenda.....LOL
I am happy someone said it.
I still don't believe this news is posted on crux channel.....it's impossible
They never put this on their news videos. They always put this protest news in either shorts or analysis video intentionally.
When they say some truth you can't believe , this is how you have been brought up.
I think to not use nuclear weapons as a response is sensible, and quite another thing entirely to not responding at all.
What do you think Putin will do when he watches his army being slaughtered from the sky by NATO supremacy like pigs in Idaho?
A response will not be nuclear, it will be conventional. If Russia goes nuclear then that deterrent is over.
To be fair tot he French, I don't see why that was a controversial statement. Neither the US or UK will nuke Russia if Russia was to deploy a tactical nuclear weapon in Ukraine. They simply don't need to. They have specifically said that and that any response would be conventional in nature
That can happen, but do we really want that to happen?
Fun fact;
France and Germany defense ministers are women🤣🤣
Really??
Woman !! ☕️
Women nowadays have harder balls than men.
And?
Fun fact you are from 3rd World.
In the UK, I accept higher price's for a free Ukraine, despite our family being on a low income. No one is bombing me and I don't have to worry about my wife being on the frontline, I say I have it easy.
Freedom does have a price, let's see if Putin is correct in thinking Europe is soft and will
Freedom as a price but for ordinary citizens not the people in power. Also it’s hilarious you think that even before the war Ukraine was a free society. Now They banned opposition parties and media and ban the culture of minorities in Ukraine not to mention bombs them. If that is a free country then so is Russia
If Ukraine implemented the Minsk agreement, we would not see what's happening now. But instead they bombarded the population of the east just because they have Russian culture. We're you not shocked then. Double standards as usual.
So, are you cold or hungry? Perhaps, your income is not so low as you might think which is a good thing for you...
Same as the united states we paying the most out of any country.
I say if France wants to leave nato
That great That save a bunch of money on US taxpayers we can pull our 190,000 troops out of France. Leaving there 200,000 military to defend against Russia.
Don't ask for help remember you chose to do this on your own I feel no pity for you.
The United States should remove their troops from your borders and allow you to defend yourself. When you don't have sympathy for other Innocent people dying then you really don't matter.
You are what we like to call a coward. I say good riddance
Not hungry or cold. Haha and on low income.
Ukrainian clown want it joint nato. Now he tries involve nato. Such a pathetic man. Putin on other side completely lost his mind and million people suffer. Those two needs to be in prison.
France less dependent on Gas for Electricity so mainly heating. Inflation is around 6% which is much lower than the 10% in other countries. So it is muscle wrestling between its left wings and workers and private industry. This need for many to get involved in protest is what makes France unique!
@@mth9267 You're not wrong! They often forget they've got it pretty good in their country compared to most other places on Earth.
Crisis that people facing is really horrible devastating and massive unforgiven
Did you know that Russia is the only country in Europe that has never used gas and rubber bullets against protesters?
@@justice2375 Really.. did you know Putin made protesting illegal in Russia? Right before he declared full scale war on innocent Ukraine. Protesting against the Kremlins decisions will lands you in prison.
@@justice2375 You can estimate how free a society is by how much a leader gets criticized on national media
@@justice2375 oh yes, they just use torture, rape and live bullets instead.
You are right, Ukrainian people do suffer devastating terror caused by Russia.
You can estimate how free a society is by how much a leader gets criticized on national media
Putin is criticized in international media you can’t tell me you think they are a free society
@@againstviralmisinformation510 "National media" means within a country
@@georgia2727 yes exactly we even made fun of how some of Putin’s pals were saying the war wasn’t going to plan. You surely remember
so US isnt free at all since we never see much criticism about Biden funding ukraine
@@againstviralmisinformation510 and they all had windows vacations
The extra costs I suffer in France pale into insignificance compared to what the innocent Ukrainians are enduring just because one ignorant man's desires to compare himself to Peter the great.
👏 Well said
Blaa blaaa does that mean France people deserve to be suffering...
Next try to compare Ukrainian with middle East people where the warmonger US government want to be dominated the world
@@304Hibachi Absolutely, maybe ask Saudi Arabia about that, at last it seems that the US is stopping munition supplies, but it has nothing to do with energy shortages in France.
@@304Hibachi If your asking me then yes I do care about the people of Yemen. They have went through alot for years it's a tragedy, and alot of humanitarian aid is finding its way into Yemen. All one can do is give what you can and hope it all ends soon. Seven years is a long civil war, but it's a bit different than Ukraines war no? Yemen is fighting a internal civil war vs Ukraine being innocent and invaded by its neighbor.
In 🇦🇺, prices have also risen - but we are not in the severe position of EU countries facing winter. So I say thank you to the Europeans who understand that it is necessary to make sacrifices on behalf of Ukraine. 👍 Can't be sure, but it might prevent Putin from extending beyond Ukraine too, maybe starting WW III.
Bro! I like the guy whos talking, please keep doing videos like this=*(
From America 🍻 cheers
I did also, surprised when someone else took over
Such a critical time we found ourselves
5:45 @CRUX. You are mixing up the EU and NATO. The UK is also a European power with Nuclear Weapons. What matters is what NATO will do not what France would do. Putin has been warned that if Russia uses any nuclear weapons in Ukraine, NATO will respond militarily against the Russian military in Ukraine and the Black Sea.
Lmao, Where's the source for this info?
No actions will be taken against Putin if he uses nukes in Ukraine.
Those 'cheese eating surrender monkeys' again....what is the use of having a large military if you do not have the will to use it in good cause ?
@@firefly4907 Budapest Memorandum
on Security Assurances in connection with the Republic of Belarus'/Republic of Kazakhstan's/Ukraine's accession to the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons in 1994 also signed by USA, UK and the Russian Federation. It guaranteed the then existing Ukrainian borders on the basis that Urkraine gives up her nuclear weapons to Russia. If Russia now uses nukes in Ukraine a response will have to be made, however not necessarily have to be nuclear one.
The statement from Pdt Macro during an interview on how to use or not use our nuclear capabilities was a strategic and military mistake that weakened our deterrence power...
Also regarding the increased cost of living and the war in Ukraine: there is almost no correlation. The poll suggesting that the sanctions against Russia don't work and in fact increase the cost of living (esp. energy) is mainly due to uneducated French people who don't know how energy power is generated in France (gas represents 8% of energy power generated in FR, btw). The real reason for energy price surge is due to multiple factors: how the energy price is computed on the local market (not based on offer/demand), the issues on nuclear power plants (corrosion, long regular maintenance window), poor green energy transition strategy, etc.
The rest of the explanation is very good, thumbs up.
If he is smart he would back out of NATO while he can but even then he would still be in the EU which would make it hard for him to get Russian energy
Your journalism is slightly disingenuous. Firstly, the EU led the way in imposing sanctions against Russia. Secondly, even if it’s slipping, the majority of French people still support them. Thirdly, the US has also hinted that they would respond conventionally to a nuclear attack on Ukraine. Fourthly, France is not the only European nation to have nuclear weapons, the UK also has them.
They repeating CIA talking point as always
Real Indians know better about independent journalism.
#FreeJulianAssange
#PardonEdwardSnowden
Only slightly? Lol. You are right though, and it is not surprising. This is and has always been a Russian propaganda channel.
@@StreamMediaSkeptic when someone speaks truth you will say it is probaganda channel. There are videos published in favor of West, he says the truth. Only you have to grow up to accept the truth. It is hard to accept truth. But it is necessary to do .
@Endrum Ungaludan No, I don't determine the truth just because it agrees with my opinion or desires. Truth is objective, but this channel is not. And I never said all western channels were true, there are propaganda channels there too, and most of them are just as easy to spot as this one.
Edit: Spelling correction.
Drink that kool aid boy
Germany to follow, peope were protesting to open NS 2 but our partners USA blew it. People are stil protetsing though and getting bigger protests. Europes interest is not USA interest, we have to follow our own interest not getting even more energy and military dependent on USA!
If it weren't for the USA, & UK + colonies you quacks would be speaking Russian right now. Sad people like you didnt learn from the Rape of Berlin
And what is so bad about speakng Russian? Actually I speak Russian I learned at school..my boyfriend is Ukrainian and speaks Russian too!
Excellent reporting thanks
Hello Tania keen
So NEO Vichy France wants to dump NATO..... I would expect no less....
And you didn't even get that the whole video is a clickbait mess and a mix of topics that aren't related to each other ? That just dumb and you just get out your 2003 US-built propaganda against France, so weak.
France is increasing its help to Ukraine both financial and military, the country votes all the new sanctions packages against Russia + Iran and its gas stocks are full for winter. So no fear of being cut with hydrocarbon supplies, they were already stopped in july
France doesn't really contribute Nato
The United States has been forked in their bills forever.
That great That will save a bunch of money on US taxpayers we can pull our 190,000 troops out of France. Leaving there 200,000 military to defend against Russia.
Don't ask for help remember you chose to do this on your own I feel no pity for you.
The United States should remove their troops from your borders and allow you to defend yourself. When you don't have sympathy for other Innocent people dying then you really don't matter.
You are what we like to call a coward. I say good riddance
@@pamelajohnson4011 Loool France sent back home all the US soldiers of its soil in 1945.
The country was and is thanksful for the big help but they aren't stupid: a country can't be considered independent with US bases ans thousands of soldiers inside its borders.
And of course France doesn't pay any bill to the US: the French developed a complete and local defence industry so they don't buy anything to the US or to anybody else that doesn't involve French compnies except very specific products like Hawkeye or carrier catapult.
Anyway, France doesn't need your support but other NATO countries do so keep your promises
One can break a stick of broom with bare hands, but not a bundle. He who leaves the 'pack' must be ready to fight alone in the 'jungle' !
it's not unusual most of the European suffers inflation because of higher gas prices except Norway and the middle east. if Macron wants to confront NATO it's up to him or leave NATO.
Inflation has been the highest since the EU formed in Europe. This is a test for European unity
France leaving NATO isn't going to change matters in Europe. But the French will do what they always do when times are hard (having lost any backbone since Napoleon times)
This is not because of the war in Ukraine. There are other forces at work here.
The French buckled quick, Putin has them in the palm of his hand. What a shame.
And you didn't even get that the whole video is a clickbait mess and a mix of topics that aren't related to each other ? That just dumb.
France is increasing its help to Ukraine both financial and military, the country votes all the new sanctions packages against Russia + Iran and its gas stocks are full for winter. So no fear of being cut with hydrocarbon supplies, they were already stopped in july
Everyday items have gone up 2x-3x but inflation is at 6%? What a load of crap
Thank you for sharing your knowledge in these ❗
They normally quit easily tbf
Eheh
good , now identified those protestors leader and send them to ukraine front lines
How will Breaking from NATO or USA will help France.
Saves them money?
This will open door to welcome russians
National security is always a priority. It is NOT that easy pulling out of NATO.
France is the EU's only nuclear power but not Europe's, stop conflating the two.
i want to see France leave nato 😅
Me too
I mean Kazakhstan is leaving CSTO russias knock off nato and refusing to help russia Azerbaijan invaded armenia who is CSTO member and russia did not do a thing about it 😂Azerbaijan is about to attain a land bridge straight to turkey and increase oil and gan flow to west
Putin will prove a better economist and politician than general. The battlefield has been an embarrassment and the assault on civilians and infrastructure requires stronger adjectives. But as this war continues, NATO and EU will crack and the petrodollar / world reserve currency status of the US$ will also weaken. The BRICS will emerge bolstered by the shift of Saudi Arabia and OPEC+ away from the West toward Eurasia.
Kinetic war kills and destroys. Energy and inflation change alliances, wreck economies and political establishments. Putin has unleashed war and the dependency about which Trump confronted and warned Merkel of is now apparent. But Merkel somehow can look past the invasion as recently as last week and call Russia the only answer. Trump consigned himself to dustbin on 1/6 and since. But he was right about a number of things and the liberal establishment hated him accordingly.
The questions this piece pose go to the European mindset of the Merkel generation. Putin understood this from the outset and is succeeding in breaking the Eurozone. Merkel was easily duped, a product of far left statism herself.
After this is over, years from now, the destruction of Ukraine will be secondary to the economic and political destruction of the Eurozone. Merkel will still be preaching obsequious reliance on Russia and her followers will still be following.
Gorby said buffer zone. NATO said no. Putin and Merkel took it from there. When you do the postmortem on Europe, begin in '46. NATO did achieve the longest period of stability in the history of Europe. But Gorbachev was betrayed and the outcome of the Merkel and Putin venture was a foregone conclusion though it took awhile and enjoyed a productive interim.
NATO should have responded on February 24, 2022. They didn't and that was the day Europe and the UK were lost. Or one could argue Blinken could have brought a longer view of the history. Well it's academic at this point. The neocons got what they wanted but the outcome won't be what they wanted. They were neither generals, politicians nor economists.
Europe should introduce the odds and even system for petrol control
I hope they force him to resign
And then what? It's not like those protest or the resignation will gain anything It's pointless, it's not gas will simple return back and cheap at the snap of anyone fingers, this is why everyone should have moved on to green energy and became full self sufficient in all country's
@@loonowolf2160 I'm dead sure that will call for some celebration in the Kremlin and Beijing. All the lousy US chihuahua allies leaders must be kicked out for compromising their nations to appease the US. Oh I will also celebrate
They are always protesting something in France.
france? I’m not surprised
If I was Macron I would keep my head down.He has made himself look stupid more than once by his ridiculous announcements.
time to suck it up
France surrender to Hitter without setting a good fight dus probably it will happen again. People of France we understand your way of living have been affected by the Putin war and we won’t blame you to surrender to that 4 feet monster. Bonne chance chers amis
Historical lack of knowledge as usual. The Germans lost 80000 soldiers, half of their planes and 1/3 of their tanks in 1940 against France (Brits had already vanished).
Thanks to the US/UK made anti-French propaganda after the clever move made by the French in 2003 about Irak
@@remistiegler5302 How could the nazis lost so many soldiers in six weeks, i need to check that. About Ukraine i understand that soon most Nato countries won’t have stomach anymore to keep helping Ukraine and I believe Putin is counting on that. It will be his chance to keep moving until war break down in Europe again. I believe Macron will be the first the say good bye as the uprising in France won’t allow him to stay in the alliance against Putin. After that the remaining Nato countries will also break away.
@@Savetheplanet802 the reason is simple: the "France all surrender" BS is a lie that has been created by Vichy collaborators for their propaganda then reused by US/UK for their own propaganda, especially after the 2003 decision to not participate in the doomed Second Gulf war.
And again you're wrong if you believe France would lower the sanctions because of the strikes: what you call an "uprising" is something very common here in France and the pandemic just slowed the social activity of unions and civil society that become branch strikes, blockades, .... until now.
The trend is even the opposite for Paris, by increasing the military support and boost the financial one through the EU funding support.
And 73% of the French still support the sanctions against Putler's regime, unlike in Serbia or in Czech Rep., nobody strike against the sanctions/for Putin (out of very few hardcore supporters)
We're not surrendering, the majority of french still support military aid to Ukraine and we've been sending equipment to them since before the war, the fact is that protests are extremely common in France, this has nothing to do with the war.
I think France in or out is mostly irrelevant anyway.
The gynecologist granny said send all bills for expensive energy to Putin. The head of the Eurokolkhoz essentially signed her own impotence.
hahaha
Confirmed French people would be the first to waive the white flag. Classic.
Sir Emanuel Macron good great and wise leader,God bless Sir Emanuel Macron,LONG LIVE EMANUEL MACRON,,,,,,,*****,,,,,,*****,,,,,,*****,,,,,,*****
When France' Jacque Chirac refused the UN Resolution for a second Persian Gulf War which forced the US to form a Coalition of the Willing, it saved the world from an early Gog and Magog. Chirac had consulted the University of Laussane's foremost theologian, Thomas Rom who told Chirac, the temple has to be rebuilt first.
The protest of French immigrants shouldn't be taken seriously since they aren't even French
MACRON is already politically weak. Just like Truss, who will be gone in a few days, MACRON will follow!
Mark rutte too
My cost of living has risen by 30% and, on my low very income. it is a real burden. I am content in the knowledge that it is for a good cause while Ukrainians are dying for freedom and democracy.
France has left NATO before so let them now. They want to go so good riddance. They should need to reapply though. That would make them a target for Russia or anyone else.
Nope France can join BRICS
@@censoredbyyoutubeagain4569 So what? BRICS is NOT a military or defence alliance. All of the constituent countries are in the G20 as well.
The video description is a textbook example of a bad-take.
...not going to happen!
Macron is a smart guy. He won't leave NATO. 🙄
Which is more important? Fondest wish of countrymen or dictation from NATO?
Won't be the first time the French sold out in the face of war. They did it in WW11. It was the French partisans' who assisted the Allied Powers during that war.
Vivas pueblos francia 🇫🇷💖💯🕊🕊🕊
Few leaders would deliberately cripple own populace. To do so is irresponsible and inhumane.
Europe IS NOT CAVING to American pressure.
If America stopped with them, Europe would impose them anyway.
What is this stupid “America is the only reason for Europe’s action” idea?
Greetings from heart of Europe- Prague!
France does not represent the rest of Europe much. Europe East from France is really big, huge, populous and much more serious in helping Ukraine than France is.
It’s France who is on the periphery here
Macron stands for good not for the evil.
Ukraine is not a member of NATO so why would anyone assume a French nuclear response to a Russian nuclear attack on Ukraine ?
Such a waste of time. Instead of pulling in together on complex issues at a extremely dangerous time, politicians agitate, people march in anger, and short term objectives take precedence. Although leaders must work on plans and take action that give people confidence that immediate financial worries will be addressed.
Please do so other EU nations to follow and avoid future involvement in wars
Peoples power ✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿
Hey Big Brain leaders. Please sit together, cooperate with each other on priority and negotiate. Why need war, let's cooperate and make the relationship, and live peacefully.
I would like to see France just being France..independent,NATO doesn't have good name anymore for what all they left behind in world.. to leave this organization is definitely a good choice.
The vichy mentality lives on in france. Let someone else have all the problems
Ukraine has no benefits for France lol it’s not their fight nor ours. Just like Taiwan isn’t our fight
2011 was the year for the Arab Spring. 2022 is the year to break up with North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Will America support the will of the people in the name of democracy? Not a chance. Democracy in America is within double standards. 😄
The rage inside protestor can definitely win Ukraine war . Dont waste the energy on protesting , use the energy wisely and aim at the one who create this crisis . Mr 💩tin
The prosperity of the EU and Europe in general has been in essence buoyed for years by Cheap Energy from RUSSIA NOT from anything sponsored by he USA . You are biting the hand that has been feeding you and May God bless and Protect RUSSIA and the Russian People from people like you
France govt should think about french people
If he is a President for the France 🇫🇷 people he needs to proof them Nato out and make peace with the Russia.
Actually NATO ought to dump Macron he is nothing but a guy looking for the limelight his few minutes of fame..he's not worth having as the leader of the great country of France
This happen when your country depend on others country for everything's. Now you Neither stand strongly support with Ukraine & NATO nor against Russia.
France.must look for zaire DRC not ukirain this is a true point
France will not leave NATO for Russia. Don't be silly.
A bad sign is that France has increased production of its white flag factories - they may be going to declare a pre-emptive surrender to Putin. I wonder if France would support NATO more if France had a border with Russian federation ?
Ah, the good old bad US-made jokes about France are back ! If you believe France will leave NATO or abandon the Ukrainians because of this clickbait video, it mean you don't understand anything in this conflict
@@remistiegler5302 I believe that France avoids any of the worlds problems, despite boasting about their military prowess, Their military will never get dirty from being used, it will stay in the box with its shiny paint intact until it is scrapped for some new, shinier stuff.
@@chrissmith2114 so I was right, you have no idea of what you're talking about. Build yourself a general knowledge and find out what Daman, Daguet, KFOR, Kapisa, Harmattan, Serval, Barkhane, Chammal, Sangaris, Lynx, Aigle... are.
Then you will understand France has one of the most active armed force in the world and is one of the very few countries able to project its forces abroad in a very short period of time
@@remistiegler5302 LOL.......
Yes. Because he's appallingly selfish and is concerned solely about his own position.
882 year of the "Tale of Bygone Years", and Oleg sat down to reign in Kiev, and Oleg said: "May it be the mother of Russian cities." And he had Slavs, and Varangians, and others, nicknamed Rus.
Where is this from
Hmmm interesting
He leaves NATO and he's screwed.
Vichy comes to mind...
France is a great democratic country. President Macron is a great, honest, democratic, liberal, munificient, charismatic,handsome and intelligent leader. He was upfront in countering Kremlin's aggression. World needs such strong and honest leaders. Hail President Macron's leadership. French values of freedom,democracy, liberalism, secularism and human rights are great ✝️✝️😇😇👍👍
Then India should follow France and sanction Russia. 🤔🤔🤔
Very approximative informations about France...Those who are in the street or on strike earn twice or more than the minimum.
Strikes aren't about inflation or something else, syndicats only use the crisis with gas to obtain sympathy of the labors.
CGT (huge syndicat) often create trouble to justify its existence and doesn't Care about casualties for the citizens.
The attitud of this syndicat is disrespectful for Ukrain, by using gas crisis, when ukrainians suffer of everything (life in danger, lack of energy, cities in ruins, no Windows or Doors to prevent winter,...)
I'm french, i earn less than those who strike (no need to earn more), ans i stand for ukrainians.
most of those people don't look French.
No surprise!!! The French are still acting like the French always do...... They better hope they don't need help someday!!! 🇩🇪🇪🇺🇬🇧🇩🇪🇪🇺🇬🇧
Whatever happened to elections being the sole arbiter of legitimacy.
That has nothing to do with NATO but French have never been smart
Has everything to do with nato dummy lol
Let the French leave NATO.
It's time for EU to stand alone no to any under Organization. Grouping and Monopoly bring the world under unstable position frequently.
France already surrenders😂😂😂
#BoycottHalalMafia
Lots and lots of pro-Russia protesters! Who paid them?
Their communist party. Who else?
France is not Europe's only nuclear power
Ukraine is suffering a shortage of fertilizer.....I guess it takes awhile for russian bodies to decompose in the winter.
Did you know that Russia is the only country in Europe that has never used gas and rubber bullets against protesters?
@@justice2375 Yeah because they use regular bullets and grenades 😂
It would be British, American and Canadian volunteers bodies.
@@dimitrijaaaaa5951 68,000 plus orcs and still counting.
@@justice2375 No they only beat them with sticks and shock them with cattle prods, but that of course only if it is a peaceful protest, if it was an actual riot...live ammunition.
Now collapsing Poor NATO
IDIOT France is collapsing not NATO.nato don't need France,France need NATO.hahaha
Would the French prefer to speak Russian? If they’re lucky enough to not be ethnically cleansed? Hmmmmm?
Not good
for the safety of your country no.
Go with Liz to ukrain to serve a presedent,they need you there
Maybe US wull sell you cheap gas? Lol
The US doesn’t OWN the gas companies here. They are all corporate owned. You should be screaming at them and the Saudis since they own the second largest in Texas. And now slowed down production to jack up the prices. It’s all about Greed. We have the highest prices here to. In Ca it’s been $6.10. Those evil bastards😢.
@@momwithaplan1287 US companies earn even 10 times more selling LNG to Europe
5:30 No reaction =/= no atomic reaction.
He better, other wise they dump him.
I would love to see either member of NATO alliance leaving. Truth be told I wish to see the whole of NATO alliance disintegrating. Why in today's world you need military alliance. The very existence of such military alliance is the reason for instability of global peace and order.
Much better ur out of NATO macron
Why they some NATO rely on Russia oil,there is Norway natural gas dam ass.