Politics matters. Policy matters. Government matters. Governance matters. So do the reporters, editors & columnists who cover them right. Take a paid subscription. Invest in good journalism theprint.in/subscribe/
Himanta said that Indian police used LMG but in may video i saw Assam police used 2 LMG (5.56mm) ,Ambulance and prisoner van 🙄🙄🙄🙄smoke bomb ,tear gase,grenade
@Reality Bytes shame on you...keep away your fake story rewrite and edited by urself......also u add many conspiracy story without proof.....we all know northeast is northeast not bengal ......i think u are graduated from whatsapp university, editor of history honor🤣
@UCXdtR7kkXTBp1AmzQdq-j-g idiot you seem like you know more history about hidimba, dimapur than a dimasa. I am dimasa, and i know my history very well. We don't need like you illiterate people. Just grab any assam or northeast history book. You'll get all the information about hidimba, dimapur and dimasa. 👍
@Reality Bytes The Lushais (Mizo's) are Independent tribes till the British annexed and proclaimed as a part of dominions on the 6th September, 1895. (Vide proclamation-Gazette of India, September, 7, 1895). The concept of absolute state ownership of lands was prevalent in the Lushai Hills during the Chief’s rule. The Mizo Chief regarded himself as the absolute proprietor of all lands within his territorial jurisdiction (Lal ram).The British Army Lushai Expedition of 1871 to 1872 was a punitive incursion under the command of Generals Brownlow and Bourchier. The objectives of the expedition were to rescue British subjects who had been captured by the Lushais in raids including a six-year-old girl called Mary Winchester. On the 1st April, 1898 the Lushai Hills District was formed and placed under the administration of the Chief Commissioner of Assam Col. J. Shakespear. The then Superintendent of the Lushai Hills District, formulated the Land settlement policy which envisaged that each chief would get certain area within which his people or subject could move about and cultivate land as they like. In doing so the area under each chief and his people was clearly demarcated. The British Officers left the land revenue system as they found it. The entire area that formed the domain of the chief was known as ‘Ram’. The superintendents of the then Lushai Hills District recognized the right of the chiefs. The whole territory of Lushai Hills district was divided into 16 circles with an officer in charge and one interpreter posted in each circle. The interpreter’s duty was to facilitate smooth relations between a chief and the officer in-charge of the circle. The circle officers were responsible to the superintendent of the District. The Superintendent on behalf of the Government, was empowered to interfere in the demonstration of the chiefs only when they went beyond their respective jurisdictions. Practically, the system of chieftainship was not stable and strong as it was in the Pre-British days in Mizoram.
@R during 2009 mizo burn down brus house becos their millitant killed mizo farmer known as zarzokima from hachhek range, they even keep letter and write that if mizoram dont granted ADC to them they will continue killing mizos.....and religion has nothing to do with bru mizo conflict......also last week those peaceful brus burn down chorei house and village, they dont even spare their plantation, crop, animal, pig, cow goat even their dog, now chorei are homeless and staying in karimgaj assam camp, even india today publish this inhuman incident....dont mislead anyone, shame on you
with all due respect he is also missing one very important info - When the border line was first drawn in 1875 - British, Assamese & Mizoram were all involved/Consulted/Informed But when the border line was redrawn in 1933 the Mizo leaders were NOT EVEN INVOLVED/CONSULTED/NFORMED .. That is the main reason why Mizoram cannot accept 1933
So true right and because of this Assam police personal and people from Assam died and are injured. Tell me who created violence and who fired openly. What nonsense fool.
thank you dada for your interest in the NE, i'm a mizo and i'm also a proud Indian, every culture and tradition are define by our birth, we are tribal by birth, a minority and one of the least develop state in India, if we are great in number we would not fear whatsoever, but as you know we are very less and very little, but our littleness does not define us, dont take it the wrong way, we are and always will be mizo a tribal, who value their land and tradition, but still we are a proud indian, can't we be both ,, we do fear of assimilation because of the dominant buy still we love our identity, our values and tradition,,can't there be more develoment on this side, cant we be a priority for the nation, cant these two lines brought together,, afterr all we dont want arsony but harmony
@@srinivasvyasarao1708 ILP removal will come eventually.. It's the truth... But not at present... We dont want to disappear in our own lands, overcomed by outsiders... Listen to Shekhar gutpa.. Tribal population combined is less than population in Assam... It's frightening... Our own land matters to us the most...
@@srinivasvyasarao1708 Hello mate, the reason people do not want ILP removed is mainly because of the bad examples that we see. For instance, Tripura has just about 25% of its original tribe now and Assam as around 40% assamese tribe and the fact that they have not turned these areas into Bangalore or like Noida, but instead it has turned into over populated, polluted and corrupted areas... Bangalore flourished because it became the IT hub, the acceptance of other people came after that.. See, if the 'look-east policy' such as connecting India to South East Asia through Mizoram is to be a success, then people would definitely wont mind because big companies or educated and best Indian would come. But as of now, who do we get? the immigrants from Bangladesh? I dont think the people want that as we have seen in Tripura and Assam, plus this way, we can still have this green healthy and environmentally clean state with natural beauty.
I am an ethnic Telugu from state of Andhra Pradesh and a proud Indian and I support inner line permit for the north east. Let the north east integrate at its own pace and let us, the rest of the Indians make them feel at home in rest of India. Maintaining unity in diversity is hard work and we will have to indulge in much give and take, but as long as people from all parts of the country are willing to make it work, one day we won't need inner-line permits anymore.
Yes. I was waiting for a more focused coverage. (The last one was little too broad) Mainstream media can be very misleading. Hoping for the best. Much love to The Print from Mizoram!
READ BETWEEN THE LINES AND THE REPORT CAN PORTRAY A DIFFERENT STORY. Mizoram MP didnt say that any Assamese will be killed... He said "If they come into our territory again, we shall kill them all". The MP was talking about the particular incident and refering it to the police forces and not any assamese. Such sensitive statement should be quoted and not twisted and interpreted in ur own terms. I've always been amused with his meticulous style of picking words used in his reports, but this time there seems to be inconsistency may be for some reason or may be not. And what is this Small State Syndrome about? Bringing up that hypothetical term and associating it with Pakistan, is indirectly pointing to the direction that Mizoram has a Small State Syndrome and is just like pakistan. That's already every reason for people to hate mizoram. Well the knowledge of history and NE seem to be factually accurate but there seem to be a hint of biasness that clevery string together the facts. PEOPLE HAVE ADMIRED AND BOUGHT PROFOUNDNESS OF THE FACTS. BUT CAN THAT PREVILEDGE BE USED THAT AS A LEVERAGE TO SELL A BIASED STORY?
@@eWorm3249 Talk about bias, look at almost all the other medias, even their correspondents are bias, thats the first impression i got personally, almost seems like assam defending news especially arnab goswami......small state syndrome🤣, we are happy with our small state until the assam who has big state syndrome (rolf) disturb peace in NE. nope im afraid you are wrong, its not about leverage we aint trying to play any tricky and dirty politics like HBS, we are peaceful,quiet and calm, which is obviously underestimated, we are fed up of it and we are just speaking the truth to the world which is also diverted by assam cheap tricks, do you honestly think we like killing people, we are christians, we are just defending ourself, fake allegations and Drug traficking🤣🤣.we have NGOs, YMA,MHIP, so many internal organisations fighting drugs inside Mizoram in every district,,,..ill tell you a secret, 95% of processed and capped Drugs trafficked inside mizoram came from Assam🤣🤣🤣infact they are known as Baga pills ....theres nothing to look in between the lines, all you'll ever find there is fake allegations and dirty politics of assam......people of mizoram inside assam(big state syndrome) are threatened and lathicharged by crowds and even the policeman just protect them half heartedly for namesake and still dare to play the victim card, whereas the assamese people and all the other non mizos inside mizoram(small state syndrome) doesnt even need protection they are well fed and given shelter and treated equally just like a real human being should which we never mentioned.....not a single one of them is harmed nor abused verbally nor physically, you can see them here right now happily without insecurities and a big smile on their face, cus they know who we are and that we wont harm them at all unless provoken, the truth is right infront of your eyes but you choose to divert it with Assam's dirty cheap tricks.....Do you still want to look in between the lines, that is your choice .
@@ItachiUchiha-jg5ff Sir/Ma'am I think u didnt get me cleary. I was only saying that the print might be trying to portray mizoram in a negative way cleverly. For instance, misquoting the MP of Mizoram and comparing mizoram to pakistan by using the the term small state syndrome...Please read the message again although it is lengthy and not well articulated. I meant no ill for Mizoram.
13:25 with due respect sir, he doesn't say that every assamese who entered to mizoram would be kill. What he said was, if a force who threatened the public and the security of the state.
Sir... Come to mizoram... You could find the real truth and speak out to the whole india..... Besides mizoram beautiful place you'll love it for sure ☺
@@saffron1977 it's a long story sir.. So many times Assam make troubles before ..destroying mizo land even beaten our village women also sometimes burnt farmer's hut... We, mizo people and our leaders tried to make peace with them many times as we are smaller state and less in number.. To make it short, on that particular day of 26th july... Assam police men, more than 200 with fully armed entered mizo village, making troubles and runover mizo police post.. Even opened fire first...so the firing happened and unlucky those police men lost their life...The real problem is... CM of Assam hid the truth to the media and spread false story to all over india... Actually, these assamese are not native people...they were illegal Bangladeshis....the vote banks of CM of Assam....its all his dirty politics!! Before, mizoram is known for its peace and harmony!! You could find the more detail in India today news channel sir.....
I have always wanted to come to northeast for a vacation. But i have only managed to go upto sikkim and assam. I want to visit the rest of states too. Is it same to visit in the near future?
Assam CM is just trying to demonise Mizoram to win favours from India. Mizos are not savages who beat other civilians like Assam. There are thousands of Assamese in Mizoram who make a living there, no one is having a problem but the Assam CM is spreading hatred and fear to solidify his stance. If India wants the truth, why don't the Government of India go inside Mizoram and dig the truth and not just listen to Assam's side of the story?
Assam people leh Assamese hi hriat pawlh ziah suh u, Mizoram vai hnathawk ho leh Assam a Bangladeshi vai ho hi, Assamese an ni lo, Assamese ho chu an tlem lutuk tawh, an chief minister pawh Bengali a nih hi, Assamese a ni lo
@@healthylifestyle6082 Sarmah/Sarma hi Assamese anni e. Assamese ho hian an title ah Sharma tiin an ziak ngailo. Ziak chhun pawh tlem te tâk2 anni. HBS hi Assamese diktak chu a ni e. Amaherawhchu Ahom ani lo thung.
@@RohitKumar-pc7tu He is also missing one very important info - When the border line was first drawn in 1875 - British, Assamese & Mizoram were all involved/Consulted/Informed But when the border line was redrawn in 1933 the Mizo leaders were NOT EVEN INVOLVED/CONSULTED/NFORMED .. That is the main reason why Mizoram cannot accept 1933
@@endisnear306 No such reason mentioned or in record which we can know today.. also no such fight etc between Assam and Mizoram that time.. it was just done out of the knowledge of Mizo at that time.. which Mizo as a boundary sharing state cannot be a right thing or acceptable thing in this matter
This is a brilliant news piece. If I may add, Mizoram could not accept or concede to the new demarcation 1933 is because no Mizos were consulted at the time.
Travel advisory is just a gimmick . . We have lots of Assam people making a living here in Mizoram. They all are safe and happy.. and your quote about Mizoram MP.. he is addressing the aggresive actions of the Assam police..not the assamese people 🙏
Mizoram MP never stated that any Assamese will be killed. He stated that if they tried to enter again in Mizoram illegally with armed than only will be killed as an act of self defence. Mizoram is the most peaceful state in India. We just dont want intrusion by Assam govt and constantly expanding its territory illegally.
@@dibakardutta9573 One idiot with a banner does not represent the entire people of the state. That guy's action was condemned very strongly by the local people in social media.
There is no insecurity from Mizoram, thing is that we are harrassed repeatedly. The main reason is that these 4 states are Christian states. Bjp wants to inflirtrate the religion and put Hinduism in these states using these Bangaldeshi immigrants with CAA. Bjp wants all the states to have Hindu as the relgion. Assam wants a separate states for the immigrats for his political gain. Assamese in Mizoram are roaming and enjoying the peace there and they know they are safe. You are a very learned man but you choose to take the other side. Vanlalvena was referring to the people who come inside Mizoram to harras Mizo. Why don’t you watch what really happen?
@Anti Christ can't do anything, missionaries have converted almost all the native tribes in the Northeast during 1960-80. They are taught to hate the Indian State.
As a person living in the three states i.e. Mizoram, Assam and Meghalaya, I find that you have a detailed knowledge of the North Eastern states. Thank you for sharing it to the world without being biased.
The travel advisory is a joke! We, Mizos do not want to harm our fellow brothers and sisters. We want peace at the border , not war between the communities. The media and the Assam CM may tell you otherwise. Harming the non-mizos has never been and will not be our aim. All we want is peace and our to be heard at a national level without any biasness. We do not want this issue to be further manipulated by some politician for his political gains. (Though that's the case already)
That sounds a bit hollow brother .. considering LMG was fired and Assam policemen lost lives I never knew that state police any state for that matter carry LMG with them .....
@@bidyutbikashsaikia1140 first ask yourself HOW did the assam police Cross the CRPF duty post and enter Vairengte which is part of Mizoram??? The assam police came with AMBULANCE, so ready for it. When the assam police shot fire at the mizo civilians, the mizoram police had to retaliate in order to protect its people. The mizoram police were caught off-guard. Have u seen the video that went viral? Before retaliating, the mizoram police told the assam police to GO BACK, WE WILL GIVE U 5MINS BEFORE WE RETALIATE. But the AP continued firing and used tear gas.
@@jalajraha5374 tell me was there prove of it or just allegations given by the Assam CM ? The assam police shot the first fire and in order to protect the mizo civilians, the mizoram police retaliated. The status quo was never maintained by the Asaam side as they said they would've. It is very unfortunate that lives were loss.
@@jalajraha5374 first off LMG's were used by both parties involved, not just by the Mizoram side, there are plenty of videos and pictures to proof it. Secondly, Assam policemen tragically lost their lives because the Mizoram police simply had better positions, because the shooting took place at Mizoram police border outpost and not Assam border outpost as the Assam side came inside Mizoram. We Mizo's want peace and are willing to negotiate, but dont take that for weakness, we are willing to fight back if we are forced to. When a burglar comes to your house and tries to steal your belongings, would you just run away, no, you would fight for whats yours, and that is simply what we are doing.
I want to ask Mr Himanta Biswa why did he sent armed police forces to Vairengte, a village bordering Assam with 200 armed police?? Forcefully occupying Mizoram police post??
@Mrit Medhi most of the traditional tribal lands were declared as reserved forest by the govt to claim legitimacy to take it away. This has to be revisited in an amicable way.
@@elihauhnar5271 so the question is who fired with light machine gun ??? I can understand if the is an ethanic or border issues but open firing with a machine gun to fellow citizens is unbelievable and unacceptable
I don’t know why but I still got few questions in my head. 1. What was the need for the Assam officials to come to border along with 200 policemen, with arms and fully prepared. Was it a pre planned scenario expected from their side? 2. How come the officials not even respected the neutral forces and crossed it !! 3. In the same day in some part of Meghalaya Assam border, that same incident took plaice. Was it an order from the minister to act such violently?
About Tripura and it's indigenous or native people, we feel sorry for them. They are the minority now. And, we don't want to become another Tripura in any of the four states...We want to protect and are proud of our identity..cultures..habits..customs..
@Aditya mishra lol..brus aren't thrown out,they ran out on their own,the mainstream media won't cover it,the mizoram govt.make many attempt to bring the original bru settler back and many of them are brought back,don't accuse someone on an issue you don't fully understand,and chhinlung is just a folklore legend,u really believe people would come out from a rock 😂😂
The Mizo MP threatened the Assam Police. Please watch the ANI news in length...Don't misquoted him. He did not say anything against the People of Assam..
Yes there are a lot of Assam people in Mizoram living peacefully, Assam police shooting the Mizo people and police and they shoot back, if they were trying to do it again we will do the same thing that's what Mizo Mp saying about, it's about defending its people, not threatening the people
The Assam CM threatened the Mizo people saying that he will send 4000 commandos to which the Mizoram MP answered "If they come again,we will kill them all" yes bit extreme but he was responding to the threat of Assam CM
Well said...but by listering to your analysis it seems to be like that...Bu that is not the case... Let me ask you questions 1. What would you do..if your crops which was hardly cultivated overs years were destroyed forcibly by your neihbour? 2. What would you do if your children sons/daughters were kept on threatening by strangers. 3. What would you do. If your house were burndown by some people whom you know them clearly. Will you keeping quite and looking at them or blame them that they are not protecting their own. Those are the threatening and problems face by whom you mention of having small state syndrome. Please have atleast alittle empathy....imagine yourself as the one cultivating and your crops have been destroyed...then only i will accept your analysis..i hope it change the way you speak...actually those mizo families were killed without guns or with any materials. They chops off their head without knife
You miss the point Sir when The Mizoram MP say "if they come again we shall kill them all" he (Mizoram MP) didn't mean that if they come to visit Mizoram they will be killed but he meant that if they come again to encroch the Mizo's lands and to take it by force to gain control over it they will be suffering same consequences. Present the truth not your assumption. As a journalist you have to read his mind not to express your own emotions. Support Mizoram from #Khasiland MEGHALAYA
@@MAC-vi7fy, you're still a slave of Brutish. Even British failed to unify the subcontinent. If you don't acknowledge the different cultures you can't hold them under 1 umbrella called India.
Even before Modi, minor non violent clash happened every year. But those were at the border. So no one is sneaking inside others territory. This time, it was different, They reached Vairengte..15 kms past the buffer zone. This was unique because, its like some burglars entered Mizoram, nothing we could do. No other options
with all due respect you are missing one very important info - When the border line was first drawn in 1875 - British, Assamese & Mizoram were all involved/Consulted/Informed But when the border line was redrawn in 1933 the Mizo leaders were NOT EVEN INVOLVED/CONSULTED/NFORMED .. That is the main reason why Mizoram cannot accept 1933
@@mad_reeves8117 with all due respect you are missing a very important point, he's not talking about the borders and boundries,...hes talking about the economic routes blocked by assam on the central highway 306 i believe...
Having said that I would like to express my appreciation and gratitude for your tremedous knowledge and understanding from first hand experience of the North East and telling the world the reality of the incidents that have taken place here in recent and the more distant past. Salute to your unbiased journalism and outlook.
Another brilliant piece from Shekhar Gupta,thank you for bringing to light the basic issues. I do want to rectify one thing though,in the statement made in front of parliament house ,the Mizoram MP Vanlalvena was specifically refering to the Assam police personnel and not civilians. His statement was 'Assam police more than 200 of them entered Mizoram territory and they pushed back our policemen from our own post and they gave firing order first before we fired at them, they are lucky that we didn't kill them all ,if they come again we shall kill them all.' Assamese living in Mizoram are safe and sound,in fact i just came back from my regular evening walk with my friend Sanjay Das a Bengali gentleman from silchar,assam and one flat of my three-story house is rented by an Assamese youngman who has a transport business carrying goods from Guwahati and Silchar
Arunachal was never a part of Assam. Till 1972, NEFA was administered by an adviser to the Assam governor. Practically, NEFA was administered by centre through d adviser, with some offices at Shillong. Assam govt. had no part. Then ultimately, NEFA became union territory + Arunachal Pradesh n lastly a full fledged state.
@@junpreet9261 haha....we are not interested in your history, our history is different and we(Arunachali) were never ruled by any King or dynasty. Please check and search, I guarantee you won't get any source of information.
@@BAKTUL Lol. We have every piece of information we need. You people did not have any habit of writing books or letters in the past thats why every piece of info you need can be found from other people's writing. Go check them. Dont bark without knowing $hit.
another excellent piece.....a little research will tell you that, the current conflict is near the 1933 line, and inside of Mizoram from the line. The 1875 border is now well within Assam. This fact may change the narrative of this piece a bit.
Kind attention sir, if you check the facts Mizos were not a part if Assam in those times (1875 ) The 1875 boundary was for the benefit of Assam, drawn in consultation with the princely states of the then Lushai Hills. At that time the Lushai Hills were neither British subjects, much less of Assam. In other words the Lushai Hills was not carved out of Assam. It was never a part of Assam.
@@shekhargupta3911 @ThePrint Sir! with all due respect you are missing one very important info - When the border line was first drawn in 1875 it was under the knowledge of British, Assamese & Mizoram But when the border line was redrawn in 1933 the Mizo leaders were NOT EVEN INVOLVED/CONSULTED/NFORMED .. That is the main reason why Mizoram cannot accept 1933
Questions that needs to be answered 1. Why are national media not allowed inside Mizoram, why are they stopped at Lailapur, Assam? 2. Is Mizoram not a part of India that Indian media are not allowed to enter? 3. Are the people of Mizoram so hostile that they shoot people at sight? 4. Is Mizoram declared a disturbed area? Is AFPSA in force in Mizoram? 5. Is Mizoram alienated from India that media are not allowed entry? 6. On which ground and sections of the law that the ‘Freedom of Press’ is suppressed? Or is it - 1. If media are allowed entry they will find out the facts about the July 26 incident? 2. That the version of the CM of Assam will be proved wrong on many counts? 3. That the fact will be established the incident took place inside Mizoram and not at the border? 4. It will be established that it is the Assam side that is at fault and not Mizoram? 5. It will be proved that the AP made the first shot and Mizoram Police retaliated in defense? 6. The country will come to know it is the misadventure of Assam government that leads to the death of their jawans? Best is - 1. Let the media allowed entry inside Mizoram. 2. Let the Freedom of the Press be upheld. 3. Stop feeding bias message and news to the media in Assam. 4. Allow the media and the press to listen to the version of Mizoram. Why is Assam - 1. Afraid of the media getting ground reports. 2. Not allowing media entry into Mizoram. 3. Playing the bully and authoritarian. 4. Afraid the media of knowing the truth.
Know this... We Mizo are Headhunter. Like Nagaland. When we are angry we never Fear Dead. Thats why all Mizoram people united and very strong to fight agains the problem/threat to Mizoram. Even if we are Headhunter (killing machine). Particularly we are not Dangerous to another state etc. We want peace on our land and our Mother India. 🇮🇳
@@monojeetdey7409 ooo another illegal Bangladesh ...you came to Assam and want to take other state land and playing victim part, a greedy Leader to greedy people... The N.E will reunion wait and see you don't have place to call home instead you want to steal it...hope other foreigner like me will never come to assam.
Thank You Shekhar Gupta, for you are the only journalist from Delhi, who I see understands the essence of NE and throwing a light on the issues here. I pray sense prevails over the leadership and my NE is back to its beauty and peace.
Hi Shekhar/The Print. Really really appreciate in depth coverage into regions of our country that are chronically under-covered, albeit in unfortunate circumstances. A bit of feedback, I think that comparison of maps/borders of the 1933 and 1875 would have been a nice touch and perhaps helped us learn a bit more.
Very informative and I really (almost fully) enjoyed this one. Being a native from my homeland/state, I am inspired to share a few points from my perspective with someone I believe worth sharing with. First, I would like to use the word indigenous /original inhabitants. Because being an original inhabitants of the land implies to us that the land is our ancestral land (or ancestral motherland) and the land is ours particularly because it has always been ruled and occupied by us right from our fore fathers. This brings us to the second point. Second, the word 'carved out' is sometimes a little insulting. (eventhough though I know it was un-intentional). Since we consider our ancestral land as a hard earned motherland , a land that was fought and earned by the sweat and blood of our fore fathers. It is insulting when someone talks about it as a slice of cake that was freely given to us. Please note that any original inhabitant in Mizoram, Nagaland, Arunachal, Meghalaya or anywhere else in the world will feel offended if someone describes their ancestral land as a slice of cake given freely to them. This bring us to the third point. Third point names like Assam or NEFA are names used by outsiders and they are foreign lands to us. For us is was never NEFA or Assam (or Part of it) our ancestral land is always our land. Just as Scotland belongs to the Scots or Wales belongs to the Welsh.(And they were not carved out of England.) Similarlly, Nagaland , Mizoram (Literally Mizo land) belongs to the original inhabitants. Fourthly, the concept of being an Indian and a native. Just as the American Indians would have felt that America was their Ancestral homeland. (The fact that they lost to the Europeans is irrelevant because for them America will always be their ancestral land). Similarly, for us (or any other original inhabitan, our ancestral land is our motherland. It is like living in a smaller motherland within a larger motherland i.e. India. Just as the Americian Red Indian is no lesser an American Citizen. And a Scottish or a welsh is no lesser a British Citizen. We are as Indian as any other Indian on the mainland and it is rather insulting when someone thinks we are not Indians or tell us to leave India and go our home land.
@15:28 "very relaxed view of Indian nationalism and very strong sense of identitiy" sums up most of the NE communities' thought process. Shrkhar ji on point again and also loved that Shekharji points the insecurities of NE folks on CAA. Hope we have India where North Easts demographies are protected.
@@md3336 sorry for bad English. I strongly believe he is doing balanced journalism instead of journalism. That's why he omitted the Amit Shah recent visit to North East and initial aggression of Assam police and the firing from Mizoram police.
@@md3336 whenever he asked questions he asked why 6 Assam police men died and have many injuried men to the Mizo representative, as if he is trying to blame Mizoram for life lose while ignoring the fact that the Assam Police came over to Mizoram and started the gun fire first. When the Mizo representative state the fact he asked again why did the Assam police started the fire did the Mizo police provoke them....... As if he already decide to put all the blame on Mizoram and cover up the fact that the Assam police men have done, just because there's no single death from the Mizoram side.
@@endisnear306 the population and advancement of assam is 3 times the combined population of other states of ne....let's see We also have the blood of lachit....
Haha keep crying CRPf is responsible for stable North east over decades. Yaa crpf is not doing job of interviewing in assam police or mizo police work, what an ashole ur
Ironically it's not their mission their mission was disintegrate as much as they can and then integrate loyal voters who irrespective of governance they always votes for them
@Gadkari4PM I would want Gadkari to be the PM right now and have all his men in the PMO. He will bring big time efficiency by first and foremost getting rid of theseDivisionsAndFactionalismRifeAllOverIndiaAnd focus on the REAL JOB of governance with consensus and efficiency
No no no, it's because u don't like bjp govt n also ur churches also don't like bjp and himanta as cm of Assam in particular. U don't like him because he is eliminating drug trade...
Assam under CM HBS is busy collecting money in the name of Covid. If you come to Assam 🙏🏽 you are forced to take RT-PCR test by paying Rs.500.00. long queues and very annoying. No state has done this. BJP whether in Delhi or Assam is busy stealing from the pockets of its citizens just to stay in Power in the name of Development. But Where are the development 🙄
Our MP didn’t say any Assamese entering Mizoram will be killed. What he meant was if the Assam Police attacked us again inside our state (it was not the boundary), our police will protect at all cost. Know the difference
@Lalduh Kima I have a friends in Kerala from northeast.They r good friendly people.Dont know y central government n north Indians hate them.South Indians majority of them really like northeastern people because of their appearance.North eastern people r so polite n well behaved in public.
Respect to you Sir. You are one of the best I have seen and heard, who understands the real situation of the NE and many others. I just wished you pondered a bit deeper before colonial era. You are impartiality is admired. Thank you
Sir we Mizo aren't against Assamese,its just a bad politic played by Mr Himanta Sarma to take our land and to let those Bangladeshi illegal immigrants setlled in our border.If you come with good intentions,we will give you the best experience you'll ever have,but if you come with bad intentions like the Assam Police,we will defend ourselves and fight till the last drop of our blood
ALL ABOUT VOTE BANK POLITICS FOR HIMANTA: JAVED ANSARI "Its all vote bank. Its all about politics. Mr Himanta Biswas Sarma...wants to emerge and be seen as the strongman of the Northeast" - Javed M Ansari, veteran journalist and political analyst
Amit Shah has a knack of presiding over trouble twidling thumb like CAA blockade in Delhi and subsequent riots, Red fort riots, post poll progrom in West Bengal and now this
@@rravisankar3355 Yes. For keeping quiet. So too the PM. Not a word uttered. After all, it was the people who had visited his meetings who are being slaughtered. Not a word!
@Comrade Joseph Stalin Salaam Comrade. No I am not talking about Kerala Gulags of SFI. why don't you record your statement in on-going cases in Kolkata High Court and Supreme Court where more than 40 rape victims have now recorded their statements.
Delhi violence is riots where 55 people died and Bengal post poll violence where hardly anyone died is a pogrom. This year since bjp is involve the post poll violence becomes Hindu-Muslim and the post violence of higher magnitudes which happened earlier were just post poll violence. Rip logic !!!
I admire your honest attempt to be helping in these trying times. I'd like to add that Mizoram was never curved out of Assam. Mizoram was an independent country for the last thousands of years untill it was defeated by the Britishers in 1890. Mizoram was a colony of British just like India till 1947. Suddenly in 1947 the British gave independence to India and Mizoram which was separated into three parts for divide and rule policy plus administrative convenience by the British continued - present Mizoram with India, Chittagong Hills Tracts with Bangladesh and Chin Hills with Myanmar. The Zo People dreams is a united Zoland combining all these three segments of Zoram.
@Yugesh Patnaik Entering neighbour state and even dared to pull the trigger? I wonder how you react if the same incident happened inside your state. I don't think you would receive the bullet happily. If you still believe we shouldn't have fought back. I can't help you there.
Could you plz tell me why assam police cross over CRPF and even takout mizo police camp with full armed after all The CM in NE state having a peaceful meetin in shillong🙄🙄🙄🙄 assam representative even said to media that there were no CRPF they arrive only in the evening
Nobody talk about the dispute sprung up just after HM visit to North East. May be this is the plan of BJP, like their strong and decisive plan to solve many problems.
@@kevincastelino3209 No secret pact ... Now dynasty is not in rule to give him away lakhs of square km of land.... xi is checking on it from past one year....
I know brother, your ethnicity is more linked with Myanmar. But now you are a Indian and If you go after history, then there will ne no country as we known today.
@@shaktiman9831 Bro, what you said all are true. In past each and every state, region had their own history and own customs and many other. But what i am trying to said is different. Hope you got my point. 👍🙏
Tribal unity and solidarity. All NE land belong to tribal people. We are one in physically and spiritually. Long live tribal unity and tribal solidarity.
Thank You, Shekhar for very articulate flash back of the north east border issue to explain the current problems and also giving your sense to the GOI to settle the issue.... You have done your part through neutral journalism opining out your point of view as Solution.... Keep up the Fourth Pillar of our Democracy like what you had done through the above....
Leveraged Buyout!! Classic.. I never knew this could be used in a political context.. I learnt something new from you today Shekar Gupta :) P.S I have worked under a private equity
Wow nice one ! All the NE CMs should see this video esp HBD dangoria. The best and unbiased News Channel. The Print....the best example of Good Journalism. Keep it up ! Mr. S. Gupta, a think tank gentleman thorough with the NE India. Love u bhaiya ji❣️
By and large the analysis is quite correct but there are certain mistakes. The question of these states being carved out of Assam. The language somewhat seems to suggest that Assam was magnanimous by giving their land for these states. This is quite wrong. These states already had their own semi governments called District Council's and this approach was also during the British times. I would rather say these states left the Assam state. Secondly you have missed out the fact that the particular Forest reserve was actually under the then Lushai Hills District Council looked after by Assam Forest Dept as the District Council did not have a forest department. And was never handed back when the Mizoram was formed.
As an extension video, if possible, as a request I would like to see from this channel, as a part of the analysis, what could be the possible impact (economically, politically, and geographically)on the people of both sides and the neighbouring states.
The travel advisory was just a gimmick of the assam politics to play the victim game. Such a profound journalism sir, i admire your enthusiasm. A very serious man who is willing to dig deep, i like hearing your talk, you make it interesting. Come to mizoram to have deeper insight on the issue😊👍
Keep posting every day what is happening at North East. Its unfortunate that Media is busy with Raj Kundra and ignoring burning North East. Please post every day at present if you report that today no reportable news from NE, then it would be big pleasant news. Thank you very Much Shekharji
SG forgot to mention that because of overwhelming majority of Bengalis in Tripura, Tripuris (indigenous tribes of Tripura) demands a separate state. When BJP was in opposition, they even supported this demand.
Shekhar sir, I respect you a lot. But this analysis of yours concerning the NE States complexity lacks inclusiveness and conclusiveness, you forgot certain crucial prehistoric/pre British regime issues. For instance, Meghalaya was never ever a State within India, it was totally an independent Kingly nation/country of its own; and I think Mizoram, Nagaland etc too were of the same position like Meghalaya esp. the Khasi/Hynñiewtrep Race/People. It was the White Political Devils from Europe (WPDE) that have doomed us into this chronic malady of being crafted/grafted into Assam and India. Formerly we were a proud Khasi Race but now we have been reduced into a mere Tribal Community of India through the FORCED INSTRUMENT OF ACCESSION etc etc and the Constitution of India. So, in my understanding, the WPDE and the Constitution Framers of India are the Maha Culprits for all the mess of the NE States. Simple as that! Now, with Hindutva-BJP (Brutal Justice Politics) as GOI and NEDA as BJP's Project for the NE States with HE-MAN-TA Sarma as its (NEDA!) boss, BJP's hypocrisy has come to light. BJP's secret agenda is NOT National Interest, BUT Hindutva-BJP's interest. Now, to worsen our sentiment and bitterness, We Christians are being insulted by the arrogant Hindu bigots as "Rice Beggers" when we were never ever at all believers in Hinduism. Our Doxological Faith is 'God Almighty the Creator of all things' since time immemorial. However, you understand better than the crafty/cunning Indian Politicians about the many many complex issues of the People of NE Modern India. Keep it up, sir!
There is a demand for katchatheevu in TN from the time they have given it to sl. There have been debates in the state assembly related to it. TN fishermen think that having this Island as border could save fishermen from being captured by srilankan navy as there have been cases of srilankan navy capturing TN fishermen saying that they have crossed the maritime border
1 thing I believe you missed out is that even Assam is not homogenous ethnically. The area where the conflict took place bw Mizo and Assam police , is largely a tribal area on both side. Cachar district in Assam being land of the Dimasas who holds swaths of land as compared to their meager population and Bengalis who now occupies the rest of the lands. Even in Vairengte, in the Mizoram side, the area is populated by Hmar communities of Mizoram who have been driven out of Mizoram by Lushais during the height of Mizo Insurgency and hence their insecurity till today. Significant Hmar migrants from Mizoram can be found in Cachar and Dima Hasao District of Assam today. It is rumored that Mizoram is trying push Mizo refugees from Myanmar to be pushed into these areas.
Mizoram shooting Assamese entering in the territory, while they are inviting Myanmar refugees into their territory, these model of secularism and democracy only thriving in India 🤔
@@venugopalbk4144 Mizoram Police shot back when Assam police harrased civilian with tear gas and gun and shot the civilian @Vairengte not even in the border! fact check bruh !
@@venugopalbk4144 Mizo killed the Assam force and inviting Myanmar refugee! it’s simple, the Assam force comes with fully armed, lathi charge and fired the civilians, the Mizo force didn’t have other choice but to fire back… whereas the Myanmar refugee didn’t come with armed and never threatened the Mizo’s. They come in searching of peace.. that’s why they are invited /welcome in the state…not only that, they got helped by the community/NGO’s in every possible way. Remember Mizos love peace, as long as you don’t threaten the people and disturb the peace of that region, everyone is always welcome in the state.. Please note that, there are many Assamese living peacefully in the state, while their govt issued travel advisory against the Mizoram… Answer me why/how the Assam force overrun the CRPF (a neutral force)and Mizoram police post?.
Mizoram MP's statement was addressed towards illegal encroachment and the travel advisory appears to be a disguise for the economic blockade which the bigger neighbour continues to deny is happening....another interesting discourse👍
North Eastern Indigenous people including Assamese are very peaceful ang loving people, the influx from Bangladesh and Nepal creates many problems.. Assam govt instead of protecting its own indigenous peoples like Assamese, Boro, Rabha, Kuki, Karbi etc.. they are more interested in protecting the illegal immigrants fron another country just for the vote Bank.. this has created lot of problem not only in Assam but in the other Northeastern states also..
Some Mizos are accusing Biswa of wanting to take their land to settle Bangladeshi refugees, mainly Hindus refugees. But in reality Mizoram accepted about 1 lakh Chin people from Burma in 1988 and is still accepting Burmese refugees despite the order of HM. don't blame others
@@glor5978 and so let take an assumption take they are still here . They did come here and settle here but not every month or year.From Bangladesh they come every year settle act and vote while being foreigners.
Haha..the world knows that Myanmar are facing hardship because of the military coup and the agression shown by their military forces against their own people..the people seek refuge to neighbouring countries..but BJP ruled India refuses to accept them as refugees..on the other hand there has been a continual efforts on the part of the BJP led Govt. to.give illegal Bangladeshi immigrants citizenship in India..do you see the irony here?
Because it is theirs, the area Mizoram is fighting for is exactly why they fought the British, which you will never see in the Indian School lesson. I am not being bias but that is the truth
Already too much of Land has been granted to other states. Dimapur, the capital of Kachari kingdom with such historical importance in Assam was gifted away. This Assamese generosity has made us hollow today inside out as we just give and give to the point of starvation and extermination. We are never United for long and get on with our lives, stay pragmatic and have a long history of cultural assimilation. But it's too much now.
@@luit361 You are not Dimasa nor you are not spoke person of Dimasa. Dimasa automous land (Dima hassao) land in encroached by nepali, Bangladeshi, adivasi. Why don't you demand cachar dist. For Dimasa which is now occupied by Bangladeshi bengali.
Sirji, I became your fans after I used to read your articles while you were in Indian Express. I don't want to miss your weekly WALK THE WALL series and I was an ardent reader of your writings. I also read this episode of yours on Business Standard last sunday, as it always was, it was a great piece again. Thank you so much sir for showing the true facts and reality about this complex issue on your platform. In this day and ages where mis-info and fake news bombarded our life. Where one sided news and bias news engulf our surrounding, a true journalist, a great journalist like you is a gems to us.
Good history and geography lesson by SG about the NE. We never learnt all this in school. . and btw the NE ( the 7 sisters as we often call them) has been long neglected despite its beautiful topography , cultural diversity and so on. The NE was always looked upon as an ‘ appendage’ to the larger part of our nation. People from NE were called ‘ chinkies’ / chinese and so on coz they didnt look like the ‘ regular Indian’ … which is b sad. And mind you - in the recent Olympics they have sent the most number of competing sportsmen. What BJP is trying in the NE is akin to what Xi-Jing Ping is forcing on China- a homogeneity China and inIndia - in language/ culture/ politics/ policies you name it
There is suspicion on this whole incident time will open up the things ,people from both the sides will know, otherwise why north eastern brothers and sisters will fight in such a inhuman way.
Thank you sir..your perspective on the reality is spot on.. this BJP propoganda will never work..it is evident from history that whenever particular community following a particular belief started agressing another particular community with another particular belief..they make the other community that they agress stronger and more united..However,your comments on Mizoram Mp was a little off,so dear sir,analyse the situation,the reason why that statement was made,and the context of the words used..you will find that Mizoram Mp addresses the Assam Police not the people..
Politics matters. Policy matters. Government matters. Governance matters. So do the reporters, editors & columnists who cover them right. Take a paid subscription. Invest in good journalism
theprint.in/subscribe/
Himanta said that Indian police used LMG but in may video i saw Assam police used 2 LMG (5.56mm) ,Ambulance and prisoner van 🙄🙄🙄🙄smoke bomb ,tear gase,grenade
@Reality Bytes shame on you...keep away your fake story rewrite and edited by urself......also u add many conspiracy story without proof.....we all know northeast is northeast not bengal ......i think u are graduated from whatsapp university, editor of history honor🤣
@UCXdtR7kkXTBp1AmzQdq-j-g idiot you seem like you know more history about hidimba, dimapur than a dimasa.
I am dimasa, and i know my history very well. We don't need like you illiterate people. Just grab any assam or northeast history book. You'll get all the information about hidimba, dimapur and dimasa. 👍
@Reality Bytes The Lushais (Mizo's) are Independent tribes till the British annexed and proclaimed as a part of dominions on the 6th September, 1895. (Vide proclamation-Gazette of India, September, 7, 1895). The concept of absolute state ownership of lands was prevalent in the Lushai Hills during the Chief’s rule. The Mizo Chief regarded himself as the absolute proprietor of all lands within his territorial jurisdiction (Lal ram).The British Army Lushai Expedition of 1871 to 1872 was a punitive incursion under the command of Generals Brownlow and Bourchier. The objectives of the expedition were to rescue British subjects who had been captured by the Lushais in raids including a six-year-old girl called Mary Winchester.
On the 1st April, 1898 the Lushai Hills District was formed and placed under the administration of the Chief Commissioner of Assam
Col. J. Shakespear. The then Superintendent of the Lushai Hills District, formulated the Land settlement policy which envisaged that each chief would get certain area within which his people or subject could move about and cultivate land as they like. In doing so the area under each chief and his people was clearly demarcated. The British Officers left the land revenue system as they found it. The entire area that formed the domain of the chief was known as ‘Ram’. The superintendents of the then Lushai Hills District recognized the right of the chiefs. The whole territory of Lushai Hills district was divided into 16 circles with an officer in charge and one interpreter posted in each circle. The interpreter’s duty was to facilitate smooth relations between a chief and the officer in-charge of the circle. The circle officers were responsible to the superintendent of the District. The Superintendent on behalf of the Government, was empowered to interfere in the demonstration of the chiefs only when they went beyond their respective jurisdictions. Practically, the system of chieftainship was not stable and strong as it was in the Pre-British days in Mizoram.
@R during 2009 mizo burn down brus house becos their millitant killed mizo farmer known as zarzokima from hachhek range, they even keep letter and write that if mizoram dont granted ADC to them they will continue killing mizos.....and religion has nothing to do with bru mizo conflict......also last week those peaceful brus burn down chorei house and village, they dont even spare their plantation, crop, animal, pig, cow goat even their dog, now chorei are homeless and staying in karimgaj assam camp, even india today publish this inhuman incident....dont mislead anyone, shame on you
All of these unfortunate things are happening when talents from NE are winning Olympic medals for the country. Let's hope for peace and tranquility.
Such a positive reply--loved it.
Ya... there seem to be some kind of ulterior motive.
Amen, I'd say Minhaj....I had never imagined we'd see this in 2021...tks for writing in
with all due respect he is also missing one very important info - When the border line was first drawn in 1875 - British, Assamese & Mizoram were all involved/Consulted/Informed But when the border line was redrawn in 1933 the Mizo leaders were NOT EVEN INVOLVED/CONSULTED/NFORMED .. That is the main reason why Mizoram cannot accept 1933
The culprit is Assam C m Himanta.if he is Assam Cm,the so called seven sister is nonsense.
All the Northeast states are with you Mizoram, Assam CM Himanta and Assam police is the Black sheep here creating violence and hatred among us.
Haah why encrich forest of assam state
Not all bro...we r not same bro
So true right and because of this Assam police personal and people from Assam died and are injured. Tell me who created violence and who fired openly. What nonsense fool.
@@mrinmoykumarsarmah5253 Tumne fire khola aur humne ma giraya...
@@hemantsajjan3181 100 salon se tumhare forest nahi tha... abhi keise tumhare hone laga... Tum kabhi aaya aur dekha hai kya..
thank you dada for your interest in the NE, i'm a mizo and i'm also a proud Indian, every culture and tradition are define by our birth, we are tribal by birth, a minority and one of the least develop state in India, if we are great in number we would not fear whatsoever, but as you know we are very less and very little, but our littleness does not define us, dont take it the wrong way, we are and always will be mizo a tribal, who value their land and tradition, but still we are a proud indian, can't we be both ,, we do fear of assimilation because of the dominant buy still we love our identity, our values and tradition,,can't there be more develoment on this side, cant we be a priority for the nation, cant these two lines brought together,, afterr all we dont want arsony but harmony
@@srinivasvyasarao1708 ILP removal will come eventually.. It's the truth... But not at present... We dont want to disappear in our own lands, overcomed by outsiders...
Listen to Shekhar gutpa.. Tribal population combined is less than population in Assam...
It's frightening... Our own land matters to us the most...
@@srinivasvyasarao1708 Hello mate, the reason people do not want ILP removed is mainly because of the bad examples that we see. For instance, Tripura has just about 25% of its original tribe now and Assam as around 40% assamese tribe and the fact that they have not turned these areas into Bangalore or like Noida, but instead it has turned into over populated, polluted and corrupted areas... Bangalore flourished because it became the IT hub, the acceptance of other people came after that.. See, if the 'look-east policy' such as connecting India to South East Asia through Mizoram is to be a success, then people would definitely wont mind because big companies or educated and best Indian would come. But as of now, who do we get? the immigrants from Bangladesh? I dont think the people want that as we have seen in Tripura and Assam, plus this way, we can still have this green healthy and environmentally clean state with natural beauty.
I am an ethnic Telugu from state of Andhra Pradesh and a proud Indian and I support inner line permit for the north east.
Let the north east integrate at its own pace and let us, the rest of the Indians make them feel at home in rest of India. Maintaining unity in diversity is hard work and we will have to indulge in much give and take, but as long as people from all parts of the country are willing to make it work, one day we won't need inner-line permits anymore.
Yes. I was waiting for a more focused coverage. (The last one was little too broad) Mainstream media can be very misleading. Hoping for the best. Much love to The Print from Mizoram!
READ BETWEEN THE LINES AND THE REPORT CAN PORTRAY A DIFFERENT STORY.
Mizoram MP didnt say that any Assamese will be killed... He said "If they come into our territory again, we shall kill them all". The MP was talking about the particular incident and refering it to the police forces and not any assamese. Such sensitive statement should be quoted and not twisted and interpreted in ur own terms. I've always been amused with his meticulous style of picking words used in his reports, but this time there seems to be inconsistency may be for some reason or may be not.
And what is this Small State Syndrome about? Bringing up that hypothetical term and associating it with Pakistan, is indirectly pointing to the direction that Mizoram has a Small State Syndrome and is just like pakistan. That's already every reason for people to hate mizoram. Well the knowledge of history and NE seem to be factually accurate but there seem to be a hint of biasness that clevery string together the facts.
PEOPLE HAVE ADMIRED AND BOUGHT PROFOUNDNESS OF THE FACTS. BUT CAN THAT PREVILEDGE BE USED THAT AS A LEVERAGE TO SELL A BIASED STORY?
@@eWorm3249 Talk about bias, look at almost all the other medias, even their correspondents are bias, thats the first impression i got personally, almost seems like assam defending news especially arnab goswami......small state syndrome🤣, we are happy with our small state until the assam who has big state syndrome (rolf) disturb peace in NE. nope im afraid you are wrong, its not about leverage we aint trying to play any tricky and dirty politics like HBS, we are peaceful,quiet and calm, which is obviously underestimated, we are fed up of it and we are just speaking the truth to the world which is also diverted by assam cheap tricks, do you honestly think we like killing people, we are christians, we are just defending ourself, fake allegations and Drug traficking🤣🤣.we have NGOs, YMA,MHIP, so many internal organisations fighting drugs inside Mizoram in every district,,,..ill tell you a secret, 95% of processed and capped Drugs trafficked inside mizoram came from Assam🤣🤣🤣infact they are known as Baga pills ....theres nothing to look in between the lines, all you'll ever find there is fake allegations and dirty politics of assam......people of mizoram inside assam(big state syndrome) are threatened and lathicharged by crowds and even the policeman just protect them half heartedly for namesake and still dare to play the victim card, whereas the assamese people and all the other non mizos inside mizoram(small state syndrome) doesnt even need protection they are well fed and given shelter and treated equally just like a real human being should which we never mentioned.....not a single one of them is harmed nor abused verbally nor physically, you can see them here right now happily without insecurities and a big smile on their face, cus they know who we are and that we wont harm them at all unless provoken, the truth is right infront of your eyes but you choose to divert it with Assam's dirty cheap tricks.....Do you still want to look in between the lines, that is your choice .
@@ItachiUchiha-jg5ff Sir/Ma'am I think u didnt get me cleary. I was only saying that the print might be trying to portray mizoram in a negative way cleverly. For instance, misquoting the MP of Mizoram and comparing mizoram to pakistan by using the the term small state syndrome...Please read the message again although it is lengthy and not well articulated. I meant no ill for Mizoram.
@@eWorm3249 lol ...oh really i didnt comment all those words personally for you, maybe u get me wrong...
13:25 with due respect sir, he doesn't say that every assamese who entered to mizoram would be kill.
What he said was, if a force who threatened the public and the security of the state.
Sir... Come to mizoram... You could find the real truth and speak out to the whole india..... Besides mizoram beautiful place you'll love it for sure ☺
What is the true story sister
@@saffron1977 it's a long story sir.. So many times Assam make troubles before ..destroying mizo land even beaten our village women also sometimes burnt farmer's hut... We, mizo people and our leaders tried to make peace with them many times as we are smaller state and less in number.. To make it short, on that particular day of 26th july... Assam police men, more than 200 with fully armed entered mizo village, making troubles and runover mizo police post.. Even opened fire first...so the firing happened and unlucky those police men lost their life...The real problem is... CM of Assam hid the truth to the media and spread false story to all over india... Actually, these assamese are not native people...they were illegal Bangladeshis....the vote banks of CM of Assam....its all his dirty politics!! Before, mizoram is known for its peace and harmony!! You could find the more detail in India today news channel sir.....
@@Tetei002 it's more easier to go abroad than Mizoram for mainland indians..
Too many processes to deal with it
👍!! Very well worded . Proud of ur maturity to convey things aptly and softly
I have always wanted to come to northeast for a vacation. But i have only managed to go upto sikkim and assam. I want to visit the rest of states too. Is it same to visit in the near future?
Assam CM is just trying to demonise Mizoram to win favours from India. Mizos are not savages who beat other civilians like Assam. There are thousands of Assamese in Mizoram who make a living there, no one is having a problem but the Assam CM is spreading hatred and fear to solidify his stance. If India wants the truth, why don't the Government of India go inside Mizoram and dig the truth and not just listen to Assam's side of the story?
Himanta Biswa Sarma is a cheap man. Power hungry with low integrity. I don't trust him.
Assam people leh Assamese hi hriat pawlh ziah suh u, Mizoram vai hnathawk ho leh Assam a Bangladeshi vai ho hi, Assamese an ni lo, Assamese ho chu an tlem lutuk tawh, an chief minister pawh Bengali a nih hi, Assamese a ni lo
Var mein ja tu..!
@@healthylifestyle6082a mad analyst,just bla bla bla
@@healthylifestyle6082 Sarmah/Sarma hi Assamese anni e. Assamese ho hian an title ah Sharma tiin an ziak ngailo. Ziak chhun pawh tlem te tâk2 anni. HBS hi Assamese diktak chu a ni e. Amaherawhchu Ahom ani lo thung.
correction, Mizoram MP does not threaten all Assam to be killed,he only threaten those who came to encroach.
U r m absolutely right … thr should never be twist of words .
@@RohitKumar-pc7tu He is also missing one very important info - When the border line was first drawn in 1875 - British, Assamese & Mizoram were all involved/Consulted/Informed But when the border line was redrawn in 1933 the Mizo leaders were NOT EVEN INVOLVED/CONSULTED/NFORMED .. That is the main reason why Mizoram cannot accept 1933
@@mad_reeves8117 why weren't the mizos consulted during borderline redraw?
@@endisnear306 we don't know. Ground verification was never done also except 1875
@@endisnear306 No such reason mentioned or in record which we can know today.. also no such fight etc between Assam and Mizoram that time.. it was just done out of the knowledge of Mizo at that time.. which Mizo as a boundary sharing state cannot be a right thing or acceptable thing in this matter
This is a brilliant news piece. If I may add, Mizoram could not accept or concede to the new demarcation 1933 is because no Mizos were consulted at the time.
True
True, this is the fact
Very true
Then why did your people accepted Mizo Peace Accord where 1971 borders are accepted?
@@junpreet9261 Accepted by insurgents. Not official. Read history, please. It was never sign with the Mizoram state government.
Mr K. Vanlalvena never threatened Assamese. He just said that if they come again(to invade!) we will fight back... Just that.
Not 'Assamese' it's 'Immigrants'
Keep calm!
He Said the truth
Travel advisory is just a gimmick . . We have lots of Assam people making a living here in Mizoram. They all are safe and happy..
and your quote about Mizoram MP.. he is addressing the aggresive actions of the Assam police..not the assamese people 🙏
@AJ B do you mean to say that in a gun fight.. people die only by the first shots 🤦🤦
I always like it when Shekhar Gupta 'talks' to us and does not 'read' to us. It is more engaging. Thank you.
Mizoram MP never stated that any Assamese will be killed. He stated that if they tried to enter again in Mizoram illegally with armed than only will be killed as an act of self defence. Mizoram is the most peaceful state in India. We just dont want intrusion by Assam govt and constantly expanding its territory illegally.
CORRECT
True
Sikkim is most peaceful. Then comes other.
"Welcome China bye bye India"... Also comes from this so called peaceful State!!!????
@@dibakardutta9573 One idiot with a banner does not represent the entire people of the state. That guy's action was condemned very strongly by the local people in social media.
There is no insecurity from Mizoram, thing is that we are harrassed repeatedly. The main reason is that these 4 states are Christian states. Bjp wants to inflirtrate the religion and put Hinduism in these states using these Bangaldeshi immigrants with CAA. Bjp wants all the states to have Hindu as the relgion. Assam wants a separate states for the immigrats for his political gain. Assamese in Mizoram are roaming and enjoying the peace there and they know they are safe. You are a very learned man but you choose to take the other side. Vanlalvena was referring to the people who come inside Mizoram to harras Mizo. Why don’t you watch what really happen?
Spoken like a true missionary 😘😘
@Anti Christ can't do anything, missionaries have converted almost all the native tribes in the Northeast during 1960-80. They are taught to hate the Indian State.
Lmao
As a person living in the three states i.e. Mizoram, Assam and Meghalaya, I find that you have a detailed knowledge of the North Eastern states. Thank you for sharing it to the world without being biased.
So you are thre person like the Trinity... ? Lol
The travel advisory is a joke! We, Mizos do not want to harm our fellow brothers and sisters. We want peace at the border , not war between the communities. The media and the Assam CM may tell you otherwise. Harming the non-mizos has never been and will not be our aim. All we want is peace and our to be heard at a national level without any biasness. We do not want this issue to be further manipulated by some politician for his political gains. (Though that's the case already)
Mizos try to bring peace by firing fellow countrymen
That sounds a bit hollow brother .. considering LMG was fired and Assam policemen lost lives
I never knew that state police any state for that matter carry LMG with them .....
@@bidyutbikashsaikia1140 first ask yourself HOW did the assam police Cross the CRPF duty post and enter Vairengte which is part of Mizoram??? The assam police came with AMBULANCE, so ready for it. When the assam police shot fire at the mizo civilians, the mizoram police had to retaliate in order to protect its people. The mizoram police were caught off-guard. Have u seen the video that went viral? Before retaliating, the mizoram police told the assam police to GO BACK, WE WILL GIVE U 5MINS BEFORE WE RETALIATE. But the AP continued firing and used tear gas.
@@jalajraha5374 tell me was there prove of it or just allegations given by the Assam CM ? The assam police shot the first fire and in order to protect the mizo civilians, the mizoram police retaliated. The status quo was never maintained by the Asaam side as they said they would've. It is very unfortunate that lives were loss.
@@jalajraha5374 first off LMG's were used by both parties involved, not just by the Mizoram side, there are plenty of videos and pictures to proof it.
Secondly, Assam policemen tragically lost their lives because the Mizoram police simply had better positions, because the shooting took place at Mizoram police border outpost and not Assam border outpost as the Assam side came inside Mizoram.
We Mizo's want peace and are willing to negotiate, but dont take that for weakness, we are willing to fight back if we are forced to. When a burglar comes to your house and tries to steal your belongings, would you just run away, no, you would fight for whats yours, and that is simply what we are doing.
I want to ask Mr Himanta Biswa why did he sent armed police forces to Vairengte, a village bordering Assam with 200 armed police?? Forcefully occupying Mizoram police post??
@Mrit Medhi bull crap💩
@Mrit Medhi pls know that whatever comes out of your CM’s mouth is a lie. Don’t be a sheep 🐑 Use your brain 🧠
@Mrit Medhi most of the traditional tribal lands were declared as reserved forest by the govt to claim legitimacy to take it away. This has to be revisited in an amicable way.
@@elihauhnar5271 so the question is who fired with light machine gun ???
I can understand if the is an ethanic or border issues but open firing with a machine gun to fellow citizens is unbelievable and unacceptable
Because that is assam's land
I don’t know why but I still got few questions in my head.
1. What was the need for the Assam officials to come to border along with 200 policemen, with arms and fully prepared. Was it a pre planned scenario expected from their side?
2. How come the officials not even respected the neutral forces and crossed it !!
3. In the same day in some part of Meghalaya Assam border, that same incident took plaice. Was it an order from the minister to act such violently?
About Tripura and it's indigenous or native people, we feel sorry for them. They are the minority now. And, we don't want to become another Tripura in any of the four states...We want to protect and are proud of our identity..cultures..habits..customs..
You assam??
Fair
Whom are you referring to while mentioning "we"
@Aditya mishra lol..brus aren't thrown out,they ran out on their own,the mainstream media won't cover it,the mizoram govt.make many attempt to bring the original bru settler back and many of them are brought back,don't accuse someone on an issue you don't fully understand,and chhinlung is just a folklore legend,u really believe people would come out from a rock 😂😂
@Aditya mishra they ran from the Indian Army and the insurgents fighting during the insurgency which lasted 20 years
1. MP did not say "any Assamese will be killed" - please look at the footage again correct
2. bamboo flowers every 50 years
Rightly pointed out
The Mizo MP threatened the Assam Police. Please watch the ANI news in length...Don't misquoted him. He did not say anything against the People of Assam..
Yes there are a lot of Assam people in Mizoram living peacefully, Assam police shooting the Mizo people and police and they shoot back, if they were trying to do it again we will do the same thing that's what Mizo Mp saying about, it's about defending its people, not threatening the people
If they came angain. We'll ate them all😂😂😂
The Assam CM threatened the Mizo people saying that he will send 4000 commandos
to which the Mizoram MP answered
"If they come again,we will kill them all"
yes bit extreme but he was responding to the threat of Assam CM
Well said...but by listering to your analysis it seems to be like that...Bu that is not the case... Let me ask you questions
1. What would you do..if your crops which was hardly cultivated overs years were destroyed forcibly by your neihbour?
2. What would you do if your children sons/daughters were kept on threatening by strangers.
3. What would you do. If your house were burndown by some people whom you know them clearly.
Will you keeping quite and looking at them or blame them that they are not protecting their own.
Those are the threatening and problems face by whom you mention of having small state syndrome. Please have atleast alittle empathy....imagine yourself as the one cultivating and your crops have been destroyed...then only i will accept your analysis..i hope it change the way you speak...actually those mizo families were killed without guns or with any materials. They chops off their head without knife
You miss the point Sir when The Mizoram MP say "if they come again we shall kill them all" he (Mizoram MP) didn't mean that if they come to visit Mizoram they will be killed but he meant that if they come again to encroch the Mizo's lands and to take it by force to gain control over it they will be suffering same consequences. Present the truth not your assumption. As a journalist you have to read his mind not to express your own emotions.
Support Mizoram from #Khasiland MEGHALAYA
So true...
It seems that under the current BJP government, India is more fractured than ever....!
@@MAC-vi7fy lawda unifer 😁😁😁
@@MAC-vi7fy yes he is your hindu saviour. But not saviour of north east people
@@MAC-vi7fy, you're still a slave of Brutish. Even British failed to unify the subcontinent. If you don't acknowledge the different cultures you can't hold them under 1 umbrella called India.
Even before Modi, minor non violent clash happened every year. But those were at the border. So no one is sneaking inside others territory. This time, it was different, They reached Vairengte..15 kms past the buffer zone. This was unique because, its like some burglars entered Mizoram, nothing we could do. No other options
@@Indoalthist, lol.. use your brain dud.. it's easy to loot from 1 big country than a 600+ small small countries.
Whatever the political reasons be.But blocking the essential supplies coming to Mizoram is not fair.
with all due respect you are missing one very important info - When the border line was first drawn in 1875 - British, Assamese & Mizoram were all involved/Consulted/Informed But when the border line was redrawn in 1933 the Mizo leaders were NOT EVEN INVOLVED/CONSULTED/NFORMED .. That is the main reason why Mizoram cannot accept 1933
@@mad_reeves8117 with all due respect you are missing a very important point, he's not talking about the borders and boundries,...hes talking about the economic routes blocked by assam on the central highway 306 i believe...
@@ItachiUchiha-jg5ff with all due rsspect he is surely taking about the case of the border and the history .. if u underatand basic english ✌️
Assam is claiming, illegally, lands of smaller NE States by bullying and bushing.
I disagree, but ok. 🙂
Having said that I would like to express my appreciation and gratitude for your tremedous knowledge and understanding from first hand experience of the North East and telling the world the reality of the incidents that have taken place here in recent and the more distant past. Salute to your unbiased journalism and outlook.
Another brilliant piece from Shekhar Gupta,thank you for bringing to light the basic issues. I do want to rectify one thing though,in the statement made in front of parliament house ,the Mizoram MP Vanlalvena was specifically refering to the Assam police personnel and not civilians. His statement was 'Assam police more than 200 of them entered Mizoram territory and they pushed back our policemen from our own post and they gave firing order first before we fired at them, they are lucky that we didn't kill them all ,if they come again we shall kill them all.' Assamese living in Mizoram are safe and sound,in fact i just came back from my regular evening walk with my friend Sanjay Das a Bengali gentleman from silchar,assam and one flat of my three-story house is rented by an Assamese youngman who has a transport business carrying goods from Guwahati and Silchar
Arunachal was never a part of Assam. Till 1972, NEFA was administered by an adviser to the Assam governor. Practically, NEFA was administered by centre through d adviser, with some offices at Shillong. Assam govt. had no part. Then ultimately, NEFA became union territory + Arunachal Pradesh n lastly a full fledged state.
Indeed
Arunachal never part of Assam? Are you a fool. The ancient name of Arunachal is SADIYA. Go learn some history stupid so called journalist.
@@junpreet9261 haha....we are not interested in your history, our history is different and we(Arunachali) were never ruled by any King or dynasty. Please check and search, I guarantee you won't get any source of information.
@@BAKTUL Lol. We have every piece of information we need. You people did not have any habit of writing books or letters in the past thats why every piece of info you need can be found from other people's writing. Go check them. Dont bark without knowing $hit.
Who is Ahom king? Who ruled Assam for than 600 year? They were from Myanmar and mongoliod race.
another excellent piece.....a little research will tell you that, the current conflict is near the 1933 line, and inside of Mizoram from the line. The 1875 border is now well within Assam. This fact may change the narrative of this piece a bit.
I think your story is only floating within mizoram and no where else.
@@soumitradutta7600 well here u are commenting from outside mizoram 😂🤣😂🤣😂😂🤣😂
Kind attention sir, if you check the facts Mizos were not a part if Assam in those times (1875 )
The 1875 boundary was for the benefit of Assam, drawn in consultation with the princely states of the then Lushai Hills.
At that time the Lushai Hills were neither British subjects, much less of Assam. In other words the Lushai Hills was not carved out of Assam. It was never a part of Assam.
Thanks for writing in Puja. The NE has a complex history. That's why identity and tradition issues must be handled most sensitively...best wishes
@@shekhargupta3911 @ThePrint Sir! with all due respect you are missing one very important info - When the border line was first drawn in 1875 it was under the knowledge of British, Assamese & Mizoram But when the border line was redrawn in 1933 the Mizo leaders were NOT EVEN INVOLVED/CONSULTED/NFORMED .. That is the main reason why Mizoram cannot accept 1933
@@shekhargupta3911 Puia Ko Puja bana diya. Bande ka Gender hi badal diy.
Questions that needs to be answered
1. Why are national media not allowed inside Mizoram, why are they stopped at Lailapur, Assam?
2. Is Mizoram not a part of India that Indian media are not allowed to enter?
3. Are the people of Mizoram so hostile that they shoot people at sight?
4. Is Mizoram declared a disturbed area? Is AFPSA in force in Mizoram?
5. Is Mizoram alienated from India that media are not allowed entry?
6. On which ground and sections of the law that the ‘Freedom of Press’ is suppressed?
Or is it -
1. If media are allowed entry they will find out the facts about the July 26 incident?
2. That the version of the CM of Assam will be proved wrong on many counts?
3. That the fact will be established the incident took place inside Mizoram and not at the border?
4. It will be established that it is the Assam side that is at fault and not Mizoram?
5. It will be proved that the AP made the first shot and Mizoram Police retaliated in defense?
6. The country will come to know it is the misadventure of Assam government that leads to the death of their jawans?
Best is -
1. Let the media allowed entry inside Mizoram.
2. Let the Freedom of the Press be upheld.
3. Stop feeding bias message and news to the media in Assam.
4. Allow the media and the press to listen to the version of Mizoram.
Why is Assam -
1. Afraid of the media getting ground reports.
2. Not allowing media entry into Mizoram.
3. Playing the bully and authoritarian.
4. Afraid the media of knowing the truth.
Our reporter Ananya Bhardwaj and photo editor Praveen Jain are there. Pls track their coverage on ThePrint.in ...tks
Now i know, at the tine of i write this comment i didn't know that. Thank you
Know this...
We Mizo are Headhunter. Like Nagaland.
When we are angry we never Fear Dead.
Thats why all Mizoram people united and very strong to fight agains the problem/threat to Mizoram.
Even if we are Headhunter (killing machine).
Particularly we are not Dangerous to another state etc. We want peace on our land and our Mother India. 🇮🇳
Wise man. To the point. Not a single offensive work spoken.
We the North east states of Mizoram, Meghalaya, Tripura, Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh don't want Himanta Biswa as our Leader. He is a joke. NO way!!
Whatever you say he gonna cm for 5 yrs
@@monojeetdey7409 ooo another illegal Bangladesh ...you came to Assam and want to take other state land and playing victim part, a greedy Leader to greedy people... The N.E will reunion wait and see
you don't have place to call home instead you want to steal it...hope other foreigner like me will never come to assam.
Dumbass he is not your leader ...he is a very popular leader of Assam and the current CM and for good reason
😂👌👍
You're a joke kid,
Himanta is the leader of Assam not the other states😂😂😂
Thank You Shekhar Gupta, for you are the only journalist from Delhi, who I see understands the essence of NE and throwing a light on the issues here. I pray sense prevails over the leadership and my NE is back to its beauty and peace.
Thank you very much, my friend..l thanks for writing in...
Listening to you talk is enlightening and insightful.. Thank you The Print for your amazing journalism..
This is true journalism. Wish you all success, Sir. Truth always prevail. With love from Manipur. ❤️❤️
Hi Shekhar/The Print. Really really appreciate in depth coverage into regions of our country that are chronically under-covered, albeit in unfortunate circumstances. A bit of feedback, I think that comparison of maps/borders of the 1933 and 1875 would have been a nice touch and perhaps helped us learn a bit more.
im from mizoram, thanks for making an episode on it.
Thank you, kalawme my dear friend... stay well and happy always
Such a wothy explanation Sir, yes nobody wants dadagiri, nobody wants to be underestimated.. lets try to live peacefully... Much 💕 from Mizoram
CBI needs to come in to Assam an investigate million of Illegal immigrants here an all this problem will be solve
This problem has nothing to do with illegal immigrants.
@@bm19411 Yes it has. Ya Govt want to provide land for Illegal Immigrant in our land that is why this Issue is coming up dude thats fact period.
@@zoremsangasanga1972 thats exactly why all these dramas are created by the Assam CM..rightly said..👍
@@zolollipop we need to speak truth right
CBI can not be trusted anymore.
Very informative and I really (almost fully) enjoyed this one. Being a native from my homeland/state, I am inspired to share a few points from my perspective with someone I believe worth sharing with.
First, I would like to use the word indigenous /original inhabitants. Because being an original inhabitants of the land implies to us that the land is our ancestral land (or ancestral motherland) and the land is ours particularly because it has always been ruled and occupied by us right from our fore fathers. This brings us to the second point.
Second, the word 'carved out' is sometimes a little insulting. (eventhough though I know it was un-intentional). Since we consider our ancestral land as a hard earned motherland , a land that was fought and earned by the sweat and blood of our fore fathers. It is insulting when someone talks about it as a slice of cake that was freely given to us. Please note that any original inhabitant in Mizoram, Nagaland, Arunachal, Meghalaya or anywhere else in the world will feel offended if someone describes their ancestral land as a slice of cake given freely to them. This bring us to the third point.
Third point names like Assam or NEFA are names used by outsiders and they are foreign lands to us. For us is was never NEFA or Assam (or Part of it) our ancestral land is always our land. Just as Scotland belongs to the Scots or Wales belongs to the Welsh.(And they were not carved out of England.) Similarlly, Nagaland , Mizoram (Literally Mizo land) belongs to the original inhabitants.
Fourthly, the concept of being an Indian and a native. Just as the American Indians would have felt that America was their Ancestral homeland. (The fact that they lost to the Europeans is irrelevant because for them America will always be their ancestral land). Similarly, for us (or any other original inhabitan, our ancestral land is our motherland. It is like living in a smaller motherland within a larger motherland i.e. India. Just as the Americian Red Indian is no lesser an American Citizen. And a Scottish or a welsh is no lesser a British Citizen. We are as Indian as any other Indian on the mainland and it is rather insulting when someone thinks we are not Indians or tell us to leave India and go our home land.
These are excellent points. Would you mind if we published these as an article on ThePrint? Kalawme, Pu Vanlalthakima...
@15:28 "very relaxed view of Indian nationalism and very strong sense of identitiy" sums up most of the NE communities' thought process. Shrkhar ji on point again and also loved that Shekharji points the insecurities of NE folks on CAA.
Hope we have India where North Easts demographies are protected.
Why Assam police entered into Mizoram territory? I think this is not part of balanced journalism.
If u think journalism done by shekhar gupta sir not balanced....u seriously have a problem
BJP dogs always defend
Himanta biswa
@@md3336 sorry for bad English. I strongly believe he is doing balanced journalism instead of journalism. That's why he omitted the Amit Shah recent visit to North East and initial aggression of Assam police and the firing from Mizoram police.
@@md3336 whenever he asked questions he asked why 6 Assam police men died and have many injuried men to the Mizo representative, as if he is trying to blame Mizoram for life lose while ignoring the fact that the Assam Police came over to Mizoram and started the gun fire first. When the Mizo representative state the fact he asked again why did the Assam police started the fire did the Mizo police provoke them....... As if he already decide to put all the blame on Mizoram and cover up the fact that the Assam police men have done, just because there's no single death from the Mizoram side.
Journey with 200 armed forces, ambulance, prison van. That a strange journey. 😂😂😂
Assam is behaving like china expansionist behaviour. Not in the interest of sisterly states.
All the sisters should stand against assan or else it will bully you
@@endisnear306 OK, kill our people. 😁
@@anshuman4678 why not if they will infiltrate someone's land with arms!
@@endisnear306 👌
@@endisnear306 the population and advancement of assam is 3 times the combined population of other states of ne....let's see
We also have the blood of lachit....
The CRPF posted there literally fail to do their only job assigned to them.
Haha keep crying CRPf is responsible for stable North east over decades. Yaa crpf is not doing job of interviewing in assam police or mizo police work, what an ashole ur
@@hemantsajjan3181 if they are responsible,nothing would have happened.Calling someone asshole!!at least know the spelling😂
BJP mission to integrate India has also gone wrong
ItHasNOTGoneWrongBecauseItWasNEVERthatMissionToBeginWith.
InFactItWasALWAYSexactlyOppositeToItSoThatTheyCouldDIVIDEandRULE...
@Gadkari4PM EXACTLY 👍👌
Ironically it's not their mission their mission was disintegrate as much as they can and then integrate loyal voters who irrespective of governance they always votes for them
@Gadkari4PM I would want Gadkari to be the PM right now and have all his men in the PMO. He will bring big time efficiency by first and foremost getting rid of theseDivisionsAndFactionalismRifeAllOverIndiaAnd focus on the REAL JOB of governance with consensus and efficiency
@@surajmaurya2553 EXACTLY... Agree with you 1000%
ThePrint is the only channel that gives proper representation to the north-east, great job !
the problem is not with assam the problem is himanta biswa sharma and the illegal immigrants
No no no, it's because u don't like bjp govt n also ur churches also don't like bjp and himanta as cm of Assam in particular. U don't like him because he is eliminating drug trade...
Assam under CM HBS is busy collecting money in the name of Covid. If you come to Assam 🙏🏽 you are forced to take RT-PCR test by paying Rs.500.00. long queues and very annoying. No state has done this.
BJP whether in Delhi or Assam is busy stealing from the pockets of its citizens just to stay in Power in the name of Development.
But Where are the development 🙄
You sure there's no development in North East?
Well said, but what about travelling from Assam to Meghalaya ? Same story
Our MP didn’t say any Assamese entering Mizoram will be killed. What he meant was if the Assam Police attacked us again inside our state (it was not the boundary), our police will protect at all cost. Know the difference
I want to visit mizoram
@@honestsouthindian1748 you are very welcome to visit Mizoram.
@@verotyzawtha8959 thank you so much
@@verotyzawtha8959 don't worry.South Indian s r with you.South Indian s won't allow central government to play their dirty politics there
@Lalduh Kima I have a friends in Kerala from northeast.They r good friendly people.Dont know y central government n north Indians hate them.South Indians majority of them really like northeastern people because of their appearance.North eastern people r so polite n well behaved in public.
Respect to you Sir. You are one of the best I have seen and heard, who understands the real situation of the NE and many others. I just wished you pondered a bit deeper before colonial era. You are impartiality is admired. Thank you
Very well informed analysis and suggestions.He knows NER better than many leaders and players of North East politics itself
Thank you The Print from Mizoram 👍
Sir we Mizo aren't against Assamese,its just a bad politic played by Mr Himanta Sarma to take our land and to let those Bangladeshi illegal immigrants setlled in our border.If you come with good intentions,we will give you the best experience you'll ever have,but if you come with bad intentions like the Assam Police,we will defend ourselves and fight till the last drop of our blood
The fact that NE matters in 'national interest' is bliss to me as an Indian.
The time when the national anthem was written , northeast was not a part of india( british raj)
ALL ABOUT VOTE BANK POLITICS FOR HIMANTA: JAVED ANSARI
"Its all vote bank. Its all about politics. Mr Himanta Biswas Sarma...wants to emerge and be seen as the strongman of the Northeast" - Javed M Ansari, veteran journalist and political analyst
Amit Shah has a knack of presiding over trouble twidling thumb like CAA blockade in Delhi and subsequent riots, Red fort riots, post poll progrom in West Bengal and now this
@Abhirup, you shove responsibility of mamata's Bengal victory pogrom of Hindus to the Union Home Minister!
bro, you are correct
@@rravisankar3355 Yes. For keeping quiet. So too the PM. Not a word uttered. After all, it was the people who had visited his meetings who are being slaughtered. Not a word!
@Comrade Joseph Stalin Salaam Comrade. No I am not talking about Kerala Gulags of SFI. why don't you record your statement in on-going cases in Kolkata High Court and Supreme Court where more than 40 rape victims have now recorded their statements.
Delhi violence is riots where 55 people died and Bengal post poll violence where hardly anyone died is a pogrom. This year since bjp is involve the post poll violence becomes Hindu-Muslim and the post violence of higher magnitudes which happened earlier were just post poll violence. Rip logic !!!
I admire your honest attempt to be helping in these trying times. I'd like to add that Mizoram was never curved out of Assam. Mizoram was an independent country for the last thousands of years untill it was defeated by the Britishers in 1890.
Mizoram was a colony of British just like India till 1947. Suddenly in 1947 the British gave independence to India and Mizoram which was separated into three parts for divide and rule policy plus administrative convenience by the British continued - present Mizoram with India, Chittagong Hills Tracts with Bangladesh and Chin Hills with Myanmar.
The Zo People dreams is a united Zoland combining all these three segments of Zoram.
You misinterpret MP Vanlalvena
..he didnt threatened Assamese,he threatened only Assam Police if they cross border for war again
@Yugesh Patnaik Entering neighbour state and even dared to pull the trigger? I wonder how you react if the same incident happened inside your state. I don't think you would receive the bullet happily.
If you still believe we shouldn't have fought back. I can't help you there.
Why did Assam sent huge armies inside Mizoram ? They sent Commandos and bullet proof vehicles and so on..they are the ones who made it like a war zone
@@Mariana-sn5wn this blame game doesn't solve any issue it only aggravates, instead sit & talk down your issues
@Yugesh Patnaik and your CM has nothing to send 4000 commandos
How can you say Threatening police department is less than threatening citizens?
Every answer is simpler when Mr. SG tells us
Could you plz tell me why assam police cross over CRPF and even takout mizo police camp with full armed after all The CM in NE state having a peaceful meetin in shillong🙄🙄🙄🙄 assam representative even said to media that there were no CRPF they arrive only in the evening
Yes .. every answer starts as if he is so unbaised and then just towards the end it's BJP and RSS...
So simple
@@jalajraha5374 you mean the central BJP involve in this?
Gupta ji knows it all..... :-)
Sir,you make it so clear as always. Admire your views and indept knowledge. Respect and love fr Mizoram.
Nobody talk about the dispute sprung up just after HM visit to North East. May be this is the plan of BJP, like their strong and decisive plan to solve many problems.
Correct ✔️✔️✔️
All this are planned during HM visit to NE as part and preparation for upcoming Tripura election.so sad that Assam police become victim
My favourite news channel Since 2017.... thank you Mr. Shekhar Gupta for all the info. And stories you and your team has provided on this channel....
I wish SG could give same advice to China and settle all current border disputes with neighbors 🙄
Hahaha LOL so true!
😂😂
What advice did Modi give to Xi on the Jhula.
@@kevincastelino3209
No secret pact ...
Now dynasty is not in rule to give him away lakhs of square km of land....
xi is checking on it from past one year....
And if SG goes to China, to make a representation, he might go missing from the airport, in a stopover flight, on his way back..😆😆
There was no way Mizo people was under Assam state in the last 500 years also... we are totally different in ethnicity and culture.
I know brother, your ethnicity is more linked with Myanmar. But now you are a Indian and If you go after history, then there will ne no country as we known today.
@@Indoalthist There are no Rohingyas or Bengalis in Mizoram.
As per 2011 census, Mizoram is inhabited by Mizos, Chakmas, Brus. No bengali or rohingya.
@@shaktiman9831 Bro, what you said all are true. In past each and every state, region had their own history and own customs and many other. But what i am trying to said is different. Hope you got my point. 👍🙏
@@pkapk2517 assam have no history
This year 2021 Oscar awards best actor in negative role goes to Himanta biswa sharma.juthi CM
Tribal unity and solidarity.
All NE land belong to tribal people.
We are one in physically and spiritually.
Long live tribal unity and tribal solidarity.
This means we have failed to make a strong national identity .
Thank You, Shekhar for very articulate flash back of the north east border issue to explain the current problems and also giving your sense to the GOI to settle the issue.... You have done your part through neutral journalism opining out your point of view as Solution.... Keep up the Fourth Pillar of our Democracy like what you had done through the above....
Leveraged Buyout!! Classic.. I never knew this could be used in a political context.. I learnt something new from you today Shekar Gupta :) P.S I have worked under a private equity
Thank you Mario! We don't always use analogies from cricket...
Wow nice one ! All the NE CMs should see this video esp HBD dangoria. The best and unbiased News Channel. The Print....the best example of Good Journalism. Keep it up ! Mr. S. Gupta, a think tank gentleman thorough with the NE India. Love u bhaiya ji❣️
By and large the analysis is quite correct but there are certain mistakes. The question of these states being carved out of Assam. The language somewhat seems to suggest that Assam was magnanimous by giving their land for these states. This is quite wrong. These states already had their own semi governments called District Council's and this approach was also during the British times. I would rather say these states left the Assam state.
Secondly you have missed out the fact that the particular Forest reserve was actually under the then Lushai Hills District Council looked after by Assam Forest Dept as the District Council did not have a forest department. And was never handed back when the Mizoram was formed.
this is the non biased media we can have found this days (personal thought)
As an extension video, if possible, as a request I would like to see from this channel, as a part of the analysis, what could be the possible impact (economically, politically, and geographically)on the people of both sides and the neighbouring states.
The travel advisory was just a gimmick of the assam politics to play the victim game. Such a profound journalism sir, i admire your enthusiasm. A very serious man who is willing to dig deep, i like hearing your talk, you make it interesting. Come to mizoram to have deeper insight on the issue😊👍
HIMANTA BISWA SARMA
The shame of NE India
#shameonassamcm
#shameonhimantabiswasarma
Keep posting every day what is happening at North East. Its unfortunate that Media is busy with Raj Kundra and ignoring burning North East. Please post every day at present if you report that today no reportable news from NE, then it would be big pleasant news. Thank you very Much Shekharji
SG forgot to mention that because of overwhelming majority of Bengalis in Tripura, Tripuris (indigenous tribes of Tripura) demands a separate state. When BJP was in opposition, they even supported this demand.
Watch Your Shows daily Shekhar Ji . As Always you did a great job breaking it down . Ty
Real good insight on the current issue. Respect 👍👍
Except the remarks made by MP is misinterpret and misquote.
Joy ho shekhar jiki , bah kya analysis hein aapki ... ham logo ko bohut bohut janne ko mila.bhagwan aapke muche aur lambi hone ki bardan de...
Shekhar sir, I respect you a lot. But this analysis of yours concerning the NE States complexity lacks inclusiveness and conclusiveness, you forgot certain crucial prehistoric/pre British regime issues. For instance, Meghalaya was never ever a State within India, it was totally an independent Kingly nation/country of its own; and I think Mizoram, Nagaland etc too were of the same position like Meghalaya esp. the Khasi/Hynñiewtrep Race/People. It was the White Political Devils from Europe (WPDE) that have doomed us into this chronic malady of being crafted/grafted into Assam and India. Formerly we were a proud Khasi Race but now we have been reduced into a mere Tribal Community of India through the FORCED INSTRUMENT OF ACCESSION etc etc and the Constitution of India. So, in my understanding, the WPDE and the Constitution Framers of India are the Maha Culprits for all the mess of the NE States. Simple as that!
Now, with Hindutva-BJP (Brutal Justice Politics) as GOI and NEDA as BJP's Project for the NE States with HE-MAN-TA Sarma as its (NEDA!) boss, BJP's hypocrisy has come to light. BJP's secret agenda is NOT National Interest, BUT Hindutva-BJP's interest. Now, to worsen our sentiment and bitterness, We Christians are being insulted by the arrogant Hindu bigots as "Rice Beggers" when we were never ever at all believers in Hinduism. Our Doxological Faith is 'God Almighty the Creator of all things' since time immemorial.
However, you understand better than the crafty/cunning Indian Politicians about the many many complex issues of the People of NE Modern India. Keep it up, sir!
Always Insightful.....love your channel
Thanks Huxley. If I remember correctly the last Colney I'd heard of had the first name Malsawma! Stay well and happy...
There is a demand for katchatheevu in TN from the time they have given it to sl. There have been debates in the state assembly related to it. TN fishermen think that having this Island as border could save fishermen from being captured by srilankan navy as there have been cases of srilankan navy capturing TN fishermen saying that they have crossed the maritime border
1 thing I believe you missed out is that even Assam is not homogenous ethnically. The area where the conflict took place bw Mizo and Assam police , is largely a tribal area on both side. Cachar district in Assam being land of the Dimasas who holds swaths of land as compared to their meager population and Bengalis who now occupies the rest of the lands. Even in Vairengte, in the Mizoram side, the area is populated by Hmar communities of Mizoram who have been driven out of Mizoram by Lushais during the height of Mizo Insurgency and hence their insecurity till today. Significant Hmar migrants from Mizoram can be found in Cachar and Dima Hasao District of Assam today.
It is rumored that Mizoram is trying push Mizo refugees from Myanmar to be pushed into these areas.
sad to see religion brought into a border issues... its so desparaging to see social media these days
Mizoram shooting Assamese entering in the territory, while they are inviting Myanmar refugees into their territory, these model of secularism and democracy only thriving in India 🤔
@@venugopalbk4144i like your categorisation makes a hell lot of sense ....
Sad to see border brought to a religious issue lol
@@venugopalbk4144 Mizoram Police shot back when Assam police harrased civilian with tear gas and gun and shot the civilian @Vairengte not even in the border! fact check bruh !
@@venugopalbk4144 Mizo killed the Assam force and inviting Myanmar refugee! it’s simple, the Assam force comes with fully armed, lathi charge and fired the civilians, the Mizo force didn’t have other choice but to fire back…
whereas the Myanmar refugee didn’t come with armed and never threatened the Mizo’s. They come in searching of peace.. that’s why they are invited /welcome in the state…not only that, they got helped by the community/NGO’s in every possible way.
Remember Mizos love peace, as long as you don’t threaten the people and disturb the peace of that region, everyone is always welcome in the state.. Please note that, there are many Assamese living peacefully in the state, while their govt issued travel advisory against the Mizoram…
Answer me why/how the Assam force overrun the CRPF (a neutral force)and Mizoram police post?.
Mizoram MP's statement was addressed towards illegal encroachment and the travel advisory appears to be a disguise for the economic blockade which the bigger neighbour continues to deny is happening....another interesting discourse👍
North Eastern Indigenous people including Assamese are very peaceful ang loving people, the influx from Bangladesh and Nepal creates many problems.. Assam govt instead of protecting its own indigenous peoples like Assamese, Boro, Rabha, Kuki, Karbi etc.. they are more interested in protecting the illegal immigrants fron another country just for the vote Bank.. this has created lot of problem not only in Assam but in the other Northeastern states also..
Well said Mr. Gupta, India need more honest and brave people like you. Keep up the good work. Salute The Print.
Some Mizos are accusing Biswa of wanting to take their land to settle Bangladeshi refugees, mainly Hindus refugees. But in reality Mizoram accepted about 1 lakh Chin people from Burma in 1988 and is still accepting Burmese refugees despite the order of HM. don't blame others
They are refugees and most of them has gone back
but illegal migrants from Bangladesh are count as civillian in order to win election
@RI also talk about them too
@@luahpuiatlau5370 They are still living in India. Visit their website
@@glor5978 and so let take an assumption take they are still here . They did come here and settle here but not every month or year.From Bangladesh they come every year settle act and vote while being foreigners.
Haha..the world knows that Myanmar are facing hardship because of the military coup and the agression shown by their military forces against their own people..the people seek refuge to neighbouring countries..but BJP ruled India refuses to accept them as refugees..on the other hand there has been a continual efforts on the part of the BJP led Govt. to.give illegal Bangladeshi immigrants citizenship in India..do you see the irony here?
Tq theprint your news is calm and cool and unbiased we need more journalist like you
So according to you. All these disputed areas should be handed over to smaller states like Nagaland, Mizoram because elder brother should compromise??
Because it is theirs, the area Mizoram is fighting for is exactly why they fought the British, which you will never see in the Indian School lesson. I am not being bias but that is the truth
Shut up
Understand the larger play
Kashmir should be handed over to fak bcz baap is baap
Already too much of Land has been granted to other states. Dimapur, the capital of Kachari kingdom with such historical importance in Assam was gifted away. This Assamese generosity has made us hollow today inside out as we just give and give to the point of starvation and extermination.
We are never United for long and get on with our lives, stay pragmatic and have a long history of cultural assimilation. But it's too much now.
@@luit361
You are not Dimasa nor you are not spoke person of Dimasa.
Dimasa automous land (Dima hassao) land in encroached by nepali, Bangladeshi, adivasi.
Why don't you demand cachar dist. For Dimasa which is now occupied by Bangladeshi bengali.
Sirji, I became your fans after I used to read your articles while you were in Indian Express. I don't want to miss your weekly WALK THE WALL series and I was an ardent reader of your writings. I also read this episode of yours on Business Standard last sunday, as it always was, it was a great piece again. Thank you so much sir for showing the true facts and reality about this complex issue on your platform. In this day and ages where mis-info and fake news bombarded our life. Where one sided news and bias news engulf our surrounding, a true journalist, a great journalist like you is a gems to us.
Good history and geography lesson by SG about the NE. We never learnt all this in school. . and btw the NE ( the 7 sisters as we often call them) has been long neglected despite its beautiful topography , cultural diversity and so on. The NE was always looked upon as an ‘ appendage’ to the larger part of our nation. People from NE were called ‘ chinkies’ / chinese and so on coz they didnt look like the ‘ regular Indian’ … which is b sad. And mind you - in the recent Olympics they have sent the most number of competing sportsmen.
What BJP is trying in the NE is akin to what Xi-Jing Ping is forcing on China- a homogeneity China and inIndia - in language/ culture/ politics/ policies you name it
Hi KP, happy to note you liked this edition of #NationalInterest.
Thank you Murali ji. What you say is very correct. There's enormous talent in the NE...thanks for writing in
What an enlightening information! Thank you Mr Shekhar Gupta
It's interesting how the whole story changes when we see that small state theory if we see India by Chinese spectacle
Hahaha... true
There is suspicion on this whole incident time will open up the things ,people from both the sides will know, otherwise why north eastern brothers and sisters will fight in such a inhuman way.
Arey bhai sob sarkaror policy heibur. So we should be smart and stay safe.
Thank you sir..your perspective on the reality is spot on.. this BJP propoganda will never work..it is evident from history that whenever particular community following a particular belief started agressing another particular community with another particular belief..they make the other community that they agress stronger and more united..However,your comments on Mizoram Mp was a little off,so dear sir,analyse the situation,the reason why that statement was made,and the context of the words used..you will find that Mizoram Mp addresses the Assam Police not the people..