This song is a nightmare to sing not only from a notes perspective but also breathing technique. Sing it yourself and see. I respect her for doing it live. It would be easy to want to do this one pre-recorded.
She's just trying too hard to sing here, and her breathing is atrocious, this song isn't any harder to sing than any of her other ballads. She can do the softer higher pitched stuff but she tends to fallback on this kind of sound for some reason. I also don't get the way she kept singing the "er" sounds during this era "do you want to go highERRR" it just sounded really weird.
@earlusmcdivett, I have to agree... this song is very difficult to sing. Actually most of her songs from the ROL album are considered very hard to sing, especially Ray of Light. I tried to sing it a few times and breath control is the key to make it work. The range is also quite wide as well. Madonna has a 4 octave range which is quite wide for a pop singer to have. That's why most people have a hard time finding her keys while singing karaoke cause of her wide range.
@@furbl4345 Madonna is not known for her range vocally lol. She can sing the higher softer notes when she wants to but she generally just falls back into the deeper sound because it's easier for her I'm sure. None of the songs on Ray of Light are harder to sing than any other. The fact is during this performance she never hit the right note once and she was standing still, there is no reason for her to not have control of her breathing.
@@clojap Madonna is not known for her vocal capabilities but she does have a wide range at 4 octaves to be exact. After she got her intensive vocal coaching for her award wining role in "Evita", Madonna said she discovered a new vocal register she didn't know she had before. Also, for regular karaoke singers, we all know it is very hard to find Madonna's keys due to her wider range. Try singing "Live to Tell" or "Take A Bow", they are all over the place in terms of range. Even great singer like Julie Andrews and Idina Menzel only have 2 octaves.
I know.. this was just the first rehearsal, we're not expecting it to be perfect but yet she did an amazing job. She even did a few sound checks during the performance 0:31 . The final aired version was even more perfect than this version.
I wish she'd sing it well just once, she used this style every time she sang it and it's terrible. She's running out of breath doing nothing and she is pushing too hard instead of singing softly like the real song. That "do you want to go higheRRR" sounds terrible too lol. I love the song and I love her, I know she can sing it live properly if she really wants to.
I remember at the time people asked her if her voice ever challenged her. And she almost couldn't answer. I think she has a wonderful voice, but the status quo tried to make her think she couldn't sing. She's a very good singer, it's just that the pressure is so high. And also, that was the era of early Celine Dions and Mariah Careys and such. Must have been hard for her. She had to find a specially good emotion to her singing. Which is really the most important thing.
She also didn’t step on the scene as a singer. She did it for money and ended up loving it. Her voice is so unique that it stands out. It has imperfections you won’t find in someone like Beyoncé or lady Gaga.. kinda reminds me of JLo but better and more groundbreaking because JLo stepped on the scene as a dancer as well.
@@lukasblur3500 she can sing pretty good. I've seen her live. Watch her performance of Live to Tell on the Confessions Tour, and then keep telling yourself she can't sing. Check out Evita while you're at it.
@@lukasblur3500 She can sing bro. Obviously, it's not her core as an entertainer but she can definitely sing. Is this performance good? No. There's plenty of performances out there where she nails it. I personally love hearing Madonna sing, because she has so much emotion in her voice. Way more than most talented technical singers. But again, this performance is crap, I agree.
*Although i was critical when it aired all those years ago, I've learned to appreesh all of her live performances (especially in milan). madonna may hit a bum note once in a while, but there are VERY few artists who possess the ability to deliver emotion-laden vocals & visuals so effortlessly. Madonna just has 'IT' like none before her or since. The Queen goddamned earned that title!*
I missed the old Madonna so so much. I loved her old songs so much. I looked at her now and then…I don’t recognize the new her after so many plastic surgeries. Yes, the power of good bye.
Wow she's mostly on key here. This is probably the best version of this song live from her. She's challenged with technique singing this and limiting herself not to use that much head voice when she shouldn't be. The struggle with her chest voice is painful to hear as she goes deeper and deeper with her riffs.
@@pallafox agreed this is the best live version so far. you def do have a point as far as technique failure , I think it's mostly her nerves... they affect her breathing her muscles tighten (control freak Madonna here doesn't work well unlike when she is a control freak on the dancing) it's paradoxical the woman who exudes physically confidence the most when it comes to singing ballads in front of her peers chokes
Your heart is not open, so I must go The spell has been broken, I loved you so Freedom comes when you learn to let go Creation comes when you learn to say no You were my lesson I had to learn I was your fortress you had to burn Pain is a warning that something's wrong I pray to God that it won't be long Do ya wanna go higher?
Remember, this was a rehearsal & Madonna's testing different techniques to see how her vocal worked. At one point, she even moved her head to check the sound 0:31. This might just be the first take of her rehearsal so we're not expecting it to be perfect but yet she did an amazing job. The final version of this live performance can also be found on youtube & of course, she did even a much better job than this rehearsal.
@@AlexK-fx1hq Madame X was a hot mess, what was meant to be a more personal tour without gimmicks became just a non-cohesive tour in smaller venues. basically it was a lazy tour with smaller venus vs a more intimate less fuzz tour (what it should have been)
My favourite song of Madonna and sadly the one that I also find harder to listen to for the lyrics...only cause of the memories as the talent is undeniable, I still find some peace when I listen to the sound of the seagullls somewhere.
No issues with that what so ever ... no backing track and all live vocals plus it was a rehearsal. Sound quality today is much move advanced and she was testing the mic and sounds I think that was amazing 👏
She has always struggled while singing this song live. I think it's a result of the vocal lessons. She expanded her range and had to face more difficult songs. It worked initially (Ray of Light and Little Star at Oprah or Frozen live) but then as the Ray of Light era progressed she started to have issues and had quite a few number of fails in several shows which is a pity. She is certainly nervous AF, maybe terrorized by the idea of making mistakes. When I watch the Blond Ambition Tour or the Girlie Show Tour I see someone that is very confident and sure, vocally speaking as well.
You are so right, i always wondered why she DIDN'T include "The Power of Goodbye" on the Drowned World Tour if it was the biggest song of the album after Frozen and Ray of Light, but now i see. Madonna is a very proud and perfectionist woman (I love her), but i do think that now we i have the answer of my question of so many years regarding this. When Madonna recorded this song, her voice still had that "training" that she had developed for Evita, but she lost it as the months went by and this song is the most demanding of her in that aspect.
![Madonna - The Power Of Goodbye (Live) [AI Remaster HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FQTjFnzK93U/mqdefault.jpg)
This song is a nightmare to sing not only from a notes perspective but also breathing technique. Sing it yourself and see. I respect her for doing it live. It would be easy to want to do this one pre-recorded.
She's just trying too hard to sing here, and her breathing is atrocious, this song isn't any harder to sing than any of her other ballads. She can do the softer higher pitched stuff but she tends to fallback on this kind of sound for some reason. I also don't get the way she kept singing the "er" sounds during this era "do you want to go highERRR" it just sounded really weird.
@@clojapso agree. this happened too with the MTV Europe Music Award. she should sing more relaxed. more head-voicy and less straining.
@earlusmcdivett, I have to agree... this song is very difficult to sing. Actually most of her songs from the ROL album are considered very hard to sing, especially Ray of Light. I tried to sing it a few times and breath control is the key to make it work. The range is also quite wide as well. Madonna has a 4 octave range which is quite wide for a pop singer to have. That's why most people have a hard time finding her keys while singing karaoke cause of her wide range.
@@furbl4345 Madonna is not known for her range vocally lol. She can sing the higher softer notes when she wants to but she generally just falls back into the deeper sound because it's easier for her I'm sure.
None of the songs on Ray of Light are harder to sing than any other. The fact is during this performance she never hit the right note once and she was standing still, there is no reason for her to not have control of her breathing.
@@clojap Madonna is not known for her vocal capabilities but she does have a wide range at 4 octaves to be exact. After she got her intensive vocal coaching for her award wining role in "Evita", Madonna said she discovered a new vocal register she didn't know she had before. Also, for regular karaoke singers, we all know it is very hard to find Madonna's keys due to her wider range. Try singing "Live to Tell" or "Take A Bow", they are all over the place in terms of range. Even great singer like Julie Andrews and Idina Menzel only have 2 octaves.
Love the imperfections of live performance. Makes it real. And she performed this beautifully even for a rehearsal when one knows you hold back. Bravo
I know.. this was just the first rehearsal, we're not expecting it to be perfect but yet she did an amazing job. She even did a few sound checks during the performance 0:31 . The final aired version was even more perfect than this version.
I miss the old madonna. This song and the album just amazing
Porque después de 12 años abriste los ojos. Contame
Well she's still here ,but in another guise. The quality of songwriting has been long abandoned.
Such a hard song to sing; this is my favourite song of Madonna’s, so much depth and meaning.
This is also my all time favourite Madonna song, but it is also very challenging for her to do.
hard to listen..yes:)))
I find it so emotional
She sounds better in this rehearsal.
Love this! This is 100% live. Wish she’d sing this song again it one of my all time favourites
There might be a chance
I wish she'd sing it well just once, she used this style every time she sang it and it's terrible. She's running out of breath doing nothing and she is pushing too hard instead of singing softly like the real song. That "do you want to go higheRRR" sounds terrible too lol. I love the song and I love her, I know she can sing it live properly if she really wants to.
I remember at the time people asked her if her voice ever challenged her. And she almost couldn't answer. I think she has a wonderful voice, but the status quo tried to make her think she couldn't sing. She's a very good singer, it's just that the pressure is so high. And also, that was the era of early Celine Dions and Mariah Careys and such. Must have been hard for her. She had to find a specially good emotion to her singing. Which is really the most important thing.
She also didn’t step on the scene as a singer. She did it for money and ended up loving it. Her voice is so unique that it stands out. It has imperfections you won’t find in someone like Beyoncé or lady Gaga.. kinda reminds me of JLo but better and more groundbreaking because JLo stepped on the scene as a dancer as well.
Which status quo? 🙄
Well she cant sing so not sure start you're talking about. She's a performer not a singer.
@@lukasblur3500 she can sing pretty good. I've seen her live. Watch her performance of Live to Tell on the Confessions Tour, and then keep telling yourself she can't sing. Check out Evita while you're at it.
@@lukasblur3500 She can sing bro. Obviously, it's not her core as an entertainer but she can definitely sing. Is this performance good? No. There's plenty of performances out there where she nails it. I personally love hearing Madonna sing, because she has so much emotion in her voice. Way more than most talented technical singers. But again, this performance is crap, I agree.
Shes pure BEAUTY
Wowwww!OMG...never ever seen this!
I seen it when it aired
*Although i was critical when it aired all those years ago, I've learned to appreesh all of her live performances (especially in milan). madonna may hit a bum note once in a while, but there are VERY few artists who possess the ability to deliver emotion-laden vocals & visuals so effortlessly. Madonna just has 'IT' like none before her or since. The Queen goddamned earned that title!*
I missed the old Madonna so so much. I loved her old songs so much. I looked at her now and then…I don’t recognize the new her after so many plastic surgeries. Yes, the power of good bye.
Yes! Totally agree
Oh please you can recognize her!!!!!
She looks STUNNING here! 🖤
it would be great if this song enters madame x tour
Pssst... she don't even remember the words
@@nicolemonrue pssst...how do you know that?
SHE IS A LEGEND! 💕💕💕
U dont have ears or what...great song but for god sake...she has awful voice..my dog is better singer..
@@fujisamasensei7314 u got no brain, to bad...
@@fujisamasensei7314 does your momma have taste? look at what she breeds with
so beautiful with this hair....
Mi Tema Despues de 12 años abri los ojos
Madonna Te Amo
great song just a masterpiece performed by Madonna, the vocals are super
Sounds raw and full of soul. I loooove her broken voice. It makes me feel all the sorrow that the lyrics bare.
Splendide voix en solo de Madonna !❤
I 💕Madonna! My favourite Song!
Por siempre Madonna!! Grandiosa!!! Te amo!!
I love it
Beautiful emotional song, xxx 😥
She is the real and only queen of pop!!
Forever
Simplesmente amo...amo desde que me conheço por gente...😍😍😍😍
Wow she's mostly on key here. This is probably the best version of this song live from her. She's challenged with technique singing this and limiting herself not to use that much head voice when she shouldn't be. The struggle with her chest voice is painful to hear as she goes deeper and deeper with her riffs.
On key? Are you deaf? She sounds awful
Dean Ellison LoL. Mostly, if you’ve seen her other live performance of this track, it’s way worse.
@@pallafox agreed this is the best live version so far. you def do have a point as far as technique failure , I think it's mostly her nerves... they affect her breathing her muscles tighten (control freak Madonna here doesn't work well unlike when she is a control freak on the dancing) it's paradoxical the woman who exudes physically confidence the most when it comes to singing ballads in front of her peers chokes
@@deanellison9206 She didn't sound awful. You're so used to hearing studio produced music that no live performance is ever going to match up to that.
@@jusssayin480 Absolute rubbish, you're clutching at straws with this. She sounds terrible. Period.
No entiendo por qué no le sacó más provecho a esta hermosa canción...
I ❤️ her voice & ❤️ this song.
I love this song.
I' ve never seen this video. Great vocals even better than the VH1 performance. I love her.
@Marvin Morawski Puede ser...uno no siempre esta al 100%.
Sounds better than the actual performance on VH1.
AMAZING:))) WE LOVEEEE MADONNA
Your heart is not open, so I must go
The spell has been broken, I loved you so
Freedom comes when you learn to let go
Creation comes when you learn to say no
You were my lesson I had to learn
I was your fortress you had to burn
Pain is a warning that something's wrong
I pray to God that it won't be long
Do ya wanna go higher?
My favorite singer at all time !
Singer?
Wow raw everthing that makes it pure beauty 🎉❤
I'm definitely your biggest fan! Love you and love how real you are in the song, and credits to the ones helping make this magic.
SHE IS THE ETERNAL QUEEN.....
You have to be madonna the great pop artist not to dare to sing this song so bad many times even though people's critics. Love madonna!!!
My all time Favourite song
Remember, this was a rehearsal & Madonna's testing different techniques to see how her vocal worked. At one point, she even moved her head to check the sound 0:31. This might just be the first take of her rehearsal so we're not expecting it to be perfect but yet she did an amazing job. The final version of this live performance can also be found on youtube & of course, she did even a much better job than this rehearsal.
This is what I WISHED the Madame X tour would be like
The Madame X Tour was AMAZING
@@AlexK-fx1hq it was a HOT MESS.
IThinkTheFuckNot YoutrickassBitch sorry but it wasn’t .Im talking about the performance
@@AlexK-fx1hq Madame X was a hot mess, what was meant to be a more personal tour without gimmicks became just a non-cohesive tour in smaller venues. basically it was a lazy tour with smaller venus vs a more intimate less fuzz tour (what it should have been)
IThinkTheFuckNot YoutrickassBitch well. It was great
The biggest female artist ever
Magnifique
I adore this woman...
no entiendo como se descuidó tanto en su voz, cuando tuvo una epica presentación en los Oscars de 1991 y clases de canto para su pelicula Evita.
Nossa Madonna maravilhosa, diva. Não é a toa que é considera a rainha do pop.
Me encanta esa canción al igual que frozen ‼️‼️💚💜💛💙💓🥰😍
always i will love Madonna
without autotune :D
but with filters later on
There's no greater power
Than the power of goodbye 💙
Wow!!!! I have never seen this......😍😍😍
she looks beautiful 😍😍😍😍 MadonnA legend !!!!!
Let go
"Always evergreen💖"
Hermosamente bella
Madonna mi amor por ti
The Best Perfomance I Like It Song And Video
Very good ❤ live ❤
Ez most 2024-ben is HATALMASAN dübörög.❤❤Madonna elképesztő a gyerekkorom egyik nagy kedvence. A hangja ŐRÜLTEN szép.❤❤
Wonderful song Nastalgia
She looks beautiful.
Amazing!
Maravilhosa demais 👏👏
The kids playing the violin 💙🤍💙🤍my favourite Madonna song
very hard song to sing but she did - with conviction.
Hermosa mi Madonna 🖤😍
OMG !!!
I loved you so!❤
My favourite song of Madonna and sadly the one that I also find harder to listen to for the lyrics...only cause of the memories as the talent is undeniable, I still find some peace when I listen to the sound of the seagullls somewhere.
Maravilhosa ❤
This song helped me through a bad relationship
Be Quiet! ITS obviously a difficult song to sing.. she does a great job of it...
What a woman!
No issues with that what so ever ... no backing track and all live vocals plus it was a rehearsal. Sound quality today is much move advanced and she was testing the mic and sounds I think that was amazing 👏
PERFECTA!!..👑😍👍💋❤️
Madonna linda
Linda voz... linda Madonna... ❤
Jeferson Farinazzo linda voz? Jajajaja
@@andresan7762 asi es, linda voz.
@@kevinelgueta2839 uhhhh amigo URGENTE un estudio de oído.....LA DESAFINO TERRIBLE y eso que es HERMOSA LA CANCIÓN
Jaaaaa TERRIBLE DESAFINADA LE DIO AL TEMAAA y eso que es Hermoso pero ella la sepultó
I love goth Madonna
The audio is from Séptimo caballería
😍
😍😍😍😍
Thanks
🇧🇷👏👏👏🌷💞👑magnifica
😍😍
Really good vocal on a very difficult song to sing. Beautiful tho
Linda musica
Founding mother of music
Sorry pero antes de Madonna ya habia existido Florence Foster Jenkins
The audio is from the live version and not this rehearsal video !!
Por que as pessoas envelhecem 😭😭😭😭
Very good !
😬 I’m glad we have a studio version
Both versions are nice.
Its easy to criticise ...
❤❤❤
It’s not perfect but not bad by any means
Do you wanna go highuuuuur....
In fact she is a recording artist.
She has always struggled while singing this song live. I think it's a result of the vocal lessons. She expanded her range and had to face more difficult songs. It worked initially (Ray of Light and Little Star at Oprah or Frozen live) but then as the Ray of Light era progressed she started to have issues and had quite a few number of fails in several shows which is a pity. She is certainly nervous AF, maybe terrorized by the idea of making mistakes. When I watch the Blond Ambition Tour or the Girlie Show Tour I see someone that is very confident and sure, vocally speaking as well.
You are so right, i always wondered why she DIDN'T include "The Power of Goodbye" on the Drowned World Tour if it was the biggest song of the album after Frozen and Ray of Light, but now i see.
Madonna is a very proud and perfectionist woman (I love her), but i do think that now we i have the answer of my question of so many years regarding this.
When Madonna recorded this song, her voice still had that "training" that she had developed for Evita, but she lost it as the months went by and this song is the most demanding of her in that aspect.
If you look at her other lives with this songs she sings it fine and I think she sings it wonderfully in this also
She started the song with a very loud and difficult voice!
i have always liked the live rawness of her voive its much more soul touching etc ,,,,,nothing takes the past away like the future
Every song
I would like to listen to Enya singing this masterpiece, the key is to high for a normal singer
❤️
Sounds great but odd vowel choices and not sticking on the vowel when she sings… why sing Highurrrrrrrr instead of Higheeeeaaar?
So sorry mondDa ,
"Freedom comes where you learn to let go" i have a tatoo whit that line❤
Magnifica interpretación y la música Dios mío preciosa ‼️‼️💚🧡💙💛💜😍😍🥰🥰
Vamos ....no fue magnífica tampoco tampoco....la desafino TERRIBLE!!! y eso que el tema es hermoso....
🌷YT Forever 🪽🧚♀️🦄