Victory and Defeat - The Tragedy of Ceasefire الانتصار والهزيمة - مأساة وقف إطلاق النار

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 дек 2024

Комментарии • 163

  • @Dakini31
    @Dakini31 3 дня назад +47

    Thank you so much Dr. Wilf, historically accurate and very clear 🙏🏻

  • @krishnaveganathar
    @krishnaveganathar 3 дня назад +22

    You have been a guiding light through this conflict, illuminating the path forward.

  • @stevenbrown9275
    @stevenbrown9275 3 дня назад +44

    Everything you say is not only true, but absolutely obvious.

  • @moalerivu2139
    @moalerivu2139 3 дня назад +34

    That's why the Lebanese were celebrating the recent ceasefire, and Hezbollah is now calling it a victory. To them, they haven't lost yet even though they have been badly pummeled by the IDF.

    • @northwind8821
      @northwind8821 День назад

      Reminder that Lebanese are returning to their homes while Israelis are unable to. 😂

    • @moalerivu2139
      @moalerivu2139 22 часа назад

      Just shows the Lebanese have nowhere to go to stay alive while the Israel government finds places to keep its citizens safe until the danger passes.

    • @northwind8821
      @northwind8821 22 часа назад

      @@moalerivu2139 Why is there still danger if Hezbollah is not victorious? Hezbollah told Israel that a condition of the ceasefire was that Israelis can't return to the north which was the stated goal of the war against Hezbollah.😆

    • @1543m
      @1543m 10 часов назад

      اعترفوا اولا ان ارض فلسطين للفلسطينين فقط وانتم قوى احتلال تم هزيمتكم وسحقكم وطردكم من اوربا ،اذهبوا لجذوركم وحققوا انتصارتكم المزعومه فيها ،لا سلام مع الصهاينه

    • @moalerivu2139
      @moalerivu2139 10 часов назад

      There has never been a state of Palestine in history.

  • @geertje1947
    @geertje1947 3 дня назад +15

    Thank you very much Dr Wilf. I agree with you 100%.

  • @Yorac-l5n
    @Yorac-l5n 2 дня назад +13

    So sensible when looking at the analogy to WWII. Well articulated!

  • @chiaramuscianisi780
    @chiaramuscianisi780 3 дня назад +21

    She say the simply clear TRUTH !!! Thank you Lady 👏🙏🇮🇱🙏🇮🇱🙏🇮🇱🙏

  • @razcohen5590
    @razcohen5590 3 дня назад +30

    עינת את מדהימה! סוף סוף מישהו מדבר בצורה ברורה!

    • @theblackhand6485
      @theblackhand6485 День назад

      She spoke for the UN as well. You should see that one. Even better then this one!

    • @razcohen5590
      @razcohen5590 День назад

      @ I would love to. Can you link it please?

  • @goog2231
    @goog2231 3 дня назад +30

    I live in the UK and have been taking more interest in the situation in the middle east as it is now affecting Europe as a whole due to uncontrolled immigration and is not far away from turning into a conflict here as well. I am not religious but I believe that Israel is the home of Jewish/Christian people who were around for a long time before Islam and also it's not the home of Islam either. Also I am looking at the history of Islam via a group of people doing research into it's history and invention and it seems to me that Islam is a jealous,envious and childish religion that will never allow for any peace despite the fact that it's basically a copy of Judaeism and Christianity and wouldn't otherwise exist. Islam has got most of the middle East to itself but they want it all and I don't see there being peace unless Islam goes through a reformation but this also seems unlikely as muslims are not allowed to question and think for themselves.

    • @ElectroPlatingExpert-i7z
      @ElectroPlatingExpert-i7z 3 дня назад

      As long as they dont have mass destruction weapons they will learn it faster then the europeans learned it thru many centuries of War. The World need to make Muslim brotherhood their evil enemy and help progressive, peaceful Islam to flourish. Its there. Need help against the villains.

    • @Femmeaesthetic
      @Femmeaesthetic 3 дня назад +2

      Christianity also copied judaism however they acknowledge jewish prophets/mythologies they worship, Islam on the other hand seems to completely rewrite history. Judaism and Christianity are both Judaic religion while Islam is Arabian.

    • @annaportnoy
      @annaportnoy 3 дня назад +3

      Thank you so much for understanding the complexity of this conflict. Its root cause lies in a form of primitive Islamism. Indeed, if the Palestinian Arabs had acknowledged their defeat, they could today rival Germany in terms of development. However, being predominantly Muslim, they refuse to accept that we are now in the 21st century, not the 15th.

    • @konradschargel5314
      @konradschargel5314 3 дня назад +2

      Not only that Sir, they want even Spain, Al Andalus, because it was a Islamic province, and Islam is mandatory that any provine lost be re conquered…

    • @JeffKohn
      @JeffKohn 2 дня назад

      A copy and absolute and ugly falsification.

  • @veredp.6779
    @veredp.6779 2 дня назад +6

    Who is listening?
    Thanks Einat! I hope you’re heard, understood, and followed!!!

    • @danielbanini4386
      @danielbanini4386 2 дня назад

      Ask again. Who is listening!! This woman, Einat, deserves a medal of honour. God bless you, Einat. You are a light to the world.

  • @LaurieSummer-k7s
    @LaurieSummer-k7s 3 дня назад +33

    ترجمة ممتازة وواضحة. شكرا لك أستاذة عينات 👌🏻

    • @alpha-2235
      @alpha-2235 3 дня назад

      "Laurie summer" very arabic name😂😂😂😂 zio bot

    • @brynawaldman5790
      @brynawaldman5790 3 дня назад

      ​@@alpha-2235There are plenty of Arab speakers who are pro-Israel.

    • @AaronGeller
      @AaronGeller 3 дня назад +4

      ⁠@@alpha-2235Brian Wiles speaks fluent Arabic on his RUclips channel. To Laurie’s credit, she never claimed to be Arab.

    • @alpha-2235
      @alpha-2235 3 дня назад

      @@AaronGeller its a zio bot with google translate

    • @LaurieSummer-k7s
      @LaurieSummer-k7s 2 дня назад

      @@alpha-2235 Zionist for sure but not a bot. I studied Arabic years ago and can still read MSA and hold a conversation in spoken Palestinian dialect. On the other hand, you ain't a bot and you sure are dumber than one

  • @katomeoawa
    @katomeoawa 3 дня назад +10

    אני עוד מעט בן 47, וזו הפעם הראשונה שבה אני שומע את הנקודה הזו מנוסחת כל כך טוב. זה הפך להיות מאבק של "מי ימצמץ ראשון", אחרי שפעם אחר פעם ישראל מכה את האויבים שלה מכה ניצחת, אבל כל העולם מאפשר למפסידים להבין שזה עדיין לא נגמר. יש למדינות אירופה ולארה"ב חלק ענק בהמשכיות הסכסוך ובסבל שנגרם פה כבר 100 שנים. תנו לנו לשים נקודה בסוף, ואל תשימו לנו שוב שלוש נקודות.

    • @elimeir8558
      @elimeir8558 2 дня назад

      ‏זה בדיוק למה הממשלה האמריקאי של באיידן מנסה להוציא את ביבי מהממשלה בכוח

  • @MorEshed-pq5ss
    @MorEshed-pq5ss 3 дня назад +8

    The Islamic state of mind proves to feed on denying reality and logic, therefore your point on the "Palestinians" being convinced into thinking that they haven't lost the war (which is not even over yet, although it began many times) makes perfect sense.

  • @memzepper6096
    @memzepper6096 3 дня назад +14

    Always on point …
    A Star amongst stars ..

  • @zmanologia8760
    @zmanologia8760 2 дня назад +2

    Thank you very much for the clarity of thoughts and formulation

  • @ehudshapira2745
    @ehudshapira2745 День назад +2

    All of this cannot happen without a national future for the Palestinians. So long as Israel's official position is that Plaestinians will never have their own state (not to mention the far worse things our current ministers are into), there can be no accepted defeat and deradicalisation as you speak of. Nazis were erased, germany was respected, same goes for Japan. This is the real difference between ww1 and ww2, not that the Germans didn't surrender hard enough in ww1.

  • @AntoineNaim-do5ml
    @AntoineNaim-do5ml День назад

    I agree with you 100%.
    This war must end with a peace agreement between Lebanon and Israel. As a Christian Lebanese this is dream come true.

  • @stansaks3704
    @stansaks3704 3 дня назад +5

    Why doesn’t your totally sane truth get through. Einat is a fine Upstander.

  • @annalouisepaul
    @annalouisepaul 2 дня назад +3

    You are fantastic. Prime Minister Wilf please.

  • @joge2468
    @joge2468 3 дня назад +8

    Bravo.

  • @pepinoeabacaxicomgarapa
    @pepinoeabacaxicomgarapa 3 дня назад +8

    Einat 😉

  • @Jack-my4zj
    @Jack-my4zj 2 дня назад +3

    Easy to tell others what they should do to bring peace closer. Not a good starting point to reach agreements if you ask me.

  • @alonb1
    @alonb1 2 дня назад +1

    Brilliant as always! Thank you!

  • @mel1553
    @mel1553 3 дня назад +4

    Excellent thought process. Thanks.

  • @DanaTokerNadler
    @DanaTokerNadler 2 дня назад +1

    Exactly

  • @rajaratnamsadasivam6789
    @rajaratnamsadasivam6789 2 дня назад +1

    Thank you

  • @johnnyforeigner11
    @johnnyforeigner11 2 дня назад +1

    Well said.

  • @hsserry5289
    @hsserry5289 День назад

    She forgot to mention the difference between a defeat of one power against the other, the Allies vs the Axix, and the struggle between two nations for land both lived on for milliinea! A big difference!

  • @noa-wu9sn
    @noa-wu9sn 3 дня назад +4

    great clarity 💯

  • @ערןלבל
    @ערןלבל 2 дня назад +1

    דבר ראשון: סרטון מאוד טוב.
    דבר שני: הבעיה העיקרית היא שיש פה מלחמת דת, ככה שזה קצת יותר מסובך מיפן וגרמניה.

  • @sarahledoux3786
    @sarahledoux3786 3 дня назад +3

    💯 agreed !!!

    • @martinfischer2663
      @martinfischer2663 3 дня назад

      They call it HASBARA...

    • @sarahledoux3786
      @sarahledoux3786 2 дня назад

      Your ignorance is pitiable

    • @jalemairliha
      @jalemairliha 2 дня назад

      ​​​@@martinfischer2663which means "explanation."
      Meanwhile, Ps have the ability to propagandize and radicalize the world via Al Jazeera. Further, American and European college students are being indoctrinated by Qatari-funded ME Studies and other programs. To the tune of billions.

    • @TheAshube9
      @TheAshube9 2 дня назад

      @@martinfischer2663 yeah. Hasbara means explaining the truth to the people whor not aware of it. Like the people claiming "76 years of occupation" or that isrsel isnt a democrscy, or that israel does actions comparable to october the 7th, let alone for 76 years

  • @arminschwartzman4437
    @arminschwartzman4437 2 дня назад +1

    כל הכבוד

  • @alexjohnson9630
    @alexjohnson9630 День назад

    Thank you, Einat.

  • @kathrinlarsson5804
    @kathrinlarsson5804 2 дня назад +1

    bravo!

  • @YerushalayimShelZahv
    @YerushalayimShelZahv 2 дня назад +1

    Agree

  • @pegasusflameheart6479
    @pegasusflameheart6479 3 дня назад +1

    Thank you einat

  • @PritiKhan-pf9pw
    @PritiKhan-pf9pw День назад

    And say: "Truth has (now) arrived, and Falsehood perished: for Falsehood is (by its nature) bound to perish."
    (Quran 17:81)
    It was narrated from Abu Hurairah that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
    “There will come to the people years of treachery, when the liar will be regarded as honest, and the honest man will be regarded as a liar; the traitor will be regarded as faithful, and the faithful man will be regarded as a traitor; and the Ruwaibidah will decide matters.’ It was said: ‘Who are the Ruwaibidah?’ He said: ‘Vile and base men who control the affairs of the people.’”

  • @malkyleah8802
    @malkyleah8802 2 дня назад +2

    💯‼

  • @uri_k
    @uri_k День назад

    מדהימה

  • @vicihuizinga8157
    @vicihuizinga8157 День назад

    Right on

  • @briandriedger1221
    @briandriedger1221 3 дня назад +1

    You a a wise lady. Makes perfect sense to me.

  • @francisfabian6577
    @francisfabian6577 2 дня назад

    Hope the Palestinians understand.

  • @mic9771
    @mic9771 3 дня назад +3

    This woman gets it. Israel needs to win. But even after that, will the ishmaelites ever live peacefully with a jewish state next to it? I dont see it.

  • @hono-lu8sf
    @hono-lu8sf 3 дня назад +1

    באמת למה זה ככה לגבי מלחמות ישראל ? יש עוד מדינות שגם עבורן העולם דורש הפסקות אש במקום להכריז על ניצחון והפסד ?

  • @rene2223
    @rene2223 2 дня назад +1

    Why this stupid "music" in the background that covers the speaker ????

  • @beta_testing_gone_right
    @beta_testing_gone_right День назад

    Interesting

  • @heinidirr7980
    @heinidirr7980 3 дня назад +1

    💪🏻

  • @jamesoliver5688
    @jamesoliver5688 День назад

    NO CEASE FIRE WITHOUT COMPLETE SURRENDER.

  • @Ps.85
    @Ps.85 2 дня назад

    yes, and.
    Why precisely why did you just agree to a ceasefire?

  • @Levin67
    @Levin67 2 дня назад +1

    Words ok terrible background Music
    We are talking about people’s lives it is not a Hollywood movie . A bit of sensitivity . In war we all lose. But yes they do need to change their teaching education ideology if any coexisting can be achieved.

  • @mazin16091969
    @mazin16091969 3 дня назад +2

  • @gregorykent3482
    @gregorykent3482 2 дня назад

    Bad on!

  • @BijunaJ
    @BijunaJ День назад

    what about the hostages

  • @AbaddonianG
    @AbaddonianG 3 дня назад +5

    That's the wrong analogy to draw. Conversely, you are deriving the wrong lesson. The Allied victory came after Germany's capacity to wage war was completely eradicated and the country was occupied. It was premised on total military dominance-unconstrained operationally, politically, and strategically.
    That is not the case in the Middle East.
    You won't win the war in the South without achieving total control over Gaza's territory, and you won't win in the North until Hezbollah's capacity to wage an offensive war is destroyed-both tactically, as seen in the type of attacks carried out by Palestinians on the 7th, and strategically, by severing Hezbollah’s connection to Iran.
    Law means little when it cannot be enforced, as demonstrated by the UN resolution you mentioned.
    The ceasefire, in effect, is the result of a diplomatic power play and has nothing to do with international law.
    There is no point to a mere cessation of fire when the underlying disputes remain unresolved-it is simply an interregnum before the next round of conflict.
    If a military solution is the chosen path, as it appears to be, only an unequivocal display of military dominance will achieve the kind of peace you envision.
    The dispute is political, rooted in religion, and there will never be any lasting peace unless the other side is convinced of its enduring military inferiority.
    Nothing less will suffice.

    • @EddyBasch
      @EddyBasch 3 дня назад +2

      I applaud your analysis. My fear is that lasting peace under conditions you describe as accepting 'enduring military inferiority' would ring hollow to in the ears of Jihadists who draw their inspiration from the Koran. Hope springs eternal for these fanatics and this is what makes the problem so difficult.

    • @jalemairliha
      @jalemairliha 2 дня назад

      ​@@EddyBaschdefinitely. They have a 1000 yr plan.

  • @rippong9164
    @rippong9164 3 дня назад +2

    The logic applies the other way too. Israel could accept defeat of its aspiration for continued settlement expansion with no violent resistance.
    And Israel could embrace the word 'resistance' instead of 'terrorism' to characterise opposition to its settler colonialism.
    Israel could accept defeat of its professed aim to achieve a status quo where Palestinians never attack it; and, in accepting that defeat, it could grant whatever the Palestinians say would constitute a just peace. The conflict has been going on for a century, and continues, so clearly no one has won. So Israel could accept that has been defeated.

  • @MonjeziShaban
    @MonjeziShaban День назад

    Don't lie

  • @Jack-my4zj
    @Jack-my4zj 3 дня назад

    Can you explain why Israel kills aid workers? Yesterday five aid workers killed by IDF. Thank you.

    • @AaronGeller
      @AaronGeller 3 дня назад +3

      Why don’t you read into it yourself? Not trying to be rude, but I doubt Einat will respond to you nor is it up to her to defend the IDF’s decision to strike a vehicle with an alleged terrorist in it. It also seems the vehicle was unmarked. You can decide which facts to believe but I know if you saw the headline, you can dig into the details.
      Thank you

    • @Jack-my4zj
      @Jack-my4zj 3 дня назад

      ​@@AaronGellerthe IDF will be proud of themselves; cowards. I read he was followed for some time, so they could know he worked for wck. Why not just take this person and leave the rest alone? Its all to frustrate aid to Gaza

    • @AaronGeller
      @AaronGeller 3 дня назад +2

      @@Jack-my4zj It also seems the WCK did not coordinate with the IDF nor was the vehicle marked.

    • @Jack-my4zj
      @Jack-my4zj 3 дня назад

      @AaronGeller cant imagine that, they had a leading wck person on board. The IDF had bad intentions or they are just plain stupid, I suppose the first.

    • @AaronGeller
      @AaronGeller 3 дня назад +3

      @@Jack-my4zj welp, it seems like you made up your mind before you even commented.

  • @TsurT
    @TsurT 3 дня назад

    לדעתי אחת הבעיות העיקריות עם מה שעינת מציעה היא שלא ממשלת לבנון צריכה להכריז על כניעה, אלא חיזבאללה. (לבנון אפילו לא נלחמה איתנו).
    כיצד נשיג כניעה של חיזבאללה? כיצד השיגו בנות הברית כניעה של גרמניה?
    על ידי פלישה וכיבוש מלא.
    כעת, האם אנחנו מעוניינים להיכנס רגלית לכל שטחי לבנון לכבוש ולהשתלט עליה? לא נראה לי.
    לכן הפתרון המוצע יפה על הנייר, אך כלל לא מעשי.

  • @martinfischer2663
    @martinfischer2663 3 дня назад

    She will be in prison soon for being complicit in genocide.

  • @MrCph2200
    @MrCph2200 3 дня назад +2

    There are some problems with her conclusions.
    A peace deal must also give Palestinians human rights, their own country 100 % free from Israel. Also with a military .
    And Israel must at least stop the settlements if not withdraw
    I am not sure that is what Israel wants..”?

    • @julianzukmann2110
      @julianzukmann2110 3 дня назад +1

      Israel will destroy all your obscene fantasies.
      No Palestine has ever existed. It’s always been
      Israel for 3500 years and always will be. No
      such thing as “Palestinians” never has
      been. They are a 1964
      Soviet kGB propaganda
      invention to destroy Israel from within but it
      will never work. They are nothing but identical
      to all other garden variety Arabs-genetically, culturally and linguistically, And
      Israel will have Ferocious New Jewish
      Warrior Leadership that will hurl all Arabs out of Israel at last. Israel will be Free from the River Nile to the River Euphrates. Stick around
      and find out. I dare you to see all your nonsense
      destroyed.

    • @Femmeaesthetic
      @Femmeaesthetic 3 дня назад +7

      You seem to come from a western perspective about this conflict.
      How many times should Israel give rights to palestinians before they deal with terror attack like they have for decades?
      Israel time and time again offered 2 states rejected by Palestinians!
      Your very naive to think that Palestinians deserve military independence since it would be suicide for Israel dealing with another bloody war started by Arabs.
      When Palestinians talk about occupation there not just talking about Gaza or West Bank but entirety of Israel.
      At this point Israel wants to protect there own citizens.
      *And Palestine was never established as country but a region under Ottomans and British mandate, the palestinian flag originally represented pan arabism* , these people are hijacking themselves under *human rights*

    • @TheAshube9
      @TheAshube9 3 дня назад

      No. We can talk about rights and a path to independence after a thorough process, but not a military. Israel cannot be suspected of intentions toc. 0nq4. 3r other countries the way palestinians have been doing. If palestine is independent, israel wont att. @ck it. And people who've been following history know it to be true. On the flipside, palestinians have been known to use every opportunity to str!ke the independent state of Isrsel. Also, Einat was talking about Lebanon. Not the palestinians

    • @keepussafeUSA
      @keepussafeUSA 3 дня назад +1

      You think the Palestinians will be happy with just a Palestinian state? Or the Iranian regime who helps fund Hamas, Hezbollah and the Houthis? Heck no. This is a unicorn Disney fairytale of the Dems.

    • @Femmeaesthetic
      @Femmeaesthetic 2 дня назад

      @@TheAshube9 If Einat is talking about Lebanon than why are you mentioning Palestine in the first place. Stick to topic than

  • @martinfischer2663
    @martinfischer2663 3 дня назад +1

    Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ♥

  • @howard3921
    @howard3921 3 дня назад +1

    For more details, see the recent book by Daniel Pipes, “Israel Victory.”

  • @TalkativeApe-gl1ex
    @TalkativeApe-gl1ex 3 дня назад +1

    Einat, a lovely Canaanite name, I love that, even if the called lady is blue eyed European. Ms Einat, what the heck do you want exactly from the Palestinians? You don't want to give them a state, and you don't want to grant them citizenship. What do you want?

    • @cboz3712
      @cboz3712 3 дня назад +13

      You really don’t get it, do you?
      The Palis never were interested in their own state NEXT to Israel.
      They only care about Israel vanishing.
      Israel offered a two state solution again and again and again.

    • @rufescens
      @rufescens 3 дня назад

      Einat is not opposed to a Palestinian state, and here's proof: ruclips.net/user/shorts3zLervNucDE?si=jswPq6v0Ud32Fah7
      You shouldn't make assumptions, and you shouldn't open your mouth before you properly inform yourself. (Idiot racist.)

    • @untubus
      @untubus 3 дня назад +3

      She said more than clearly that she wants them to surrender.
      What she - or Israel - wants must depend on what "Palestinians" propose: Their own nation, which guarantees that no more war over territory ever be fought, or a right to citizenship in a nation of Israel that covers all the land from the river to the sea.

    • @joehutchinson24
      @joehutchinson24 3 дня назад

      Do 21st century racists who ally themselves with Muslim Brotherhood Jihadists really believe they are any different than the Nazis? Without the Nazis there would be no Hassan Al Banna, without Hassan Al Banna there would be no Hamas and Khomeini. Lets not forget that it was the father of the "Palestinian Arabs," Amin Al Husseini who was behind the rape, slaughter and dismemberments of Jewish civilians in Hebron Massacre in 1929 and the Farhud rape, slaughter and dismemberments of Jewish civilians in Baghdad in 1941. Amin Al Husseini, like the vast majority of Arabs who sided with the Nazis did not care if those Jews were part of the ancient Jewish communities who were ethnically cleansed from Arab and Muslim lands, who now make up the majority of Israelis or not. By the way you racist bigot, ten of thousands "Palestinians" have blue eyes.

    • @mikev4621
      @mikev4621 3 дня назад

      @@cboz3712 Israel never intended anything but total possession of Palestine( despite their claims to be happy to live side by side) . Look up what Jabotinski actually wrote about this

  • @luiz.nazario
    @luiz.nazario 3 дня назад

    Brilliant! I love your intelligence.

  • @zeechef1958
    @zeechef1958 День назад

    7 Oct was a sample Scene trial and Certainly the show soon must go on in a full scale ...from the river to the sea the olives tree will be free

  • @DMFOOTBALL04
    @DMFOOTBALL04 День назад

    And then is Trump is back, and now the win win win.