tier ranking every book to movie adaptation i’ve seen
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 авг 2020
- Click here cen.yt/functionclockwork to get 20% off your custom formula from Function of Beauty. Available in the US, GB, EU, CA, AUS, NZ & more! Function of Beauty makes unique personalized hair care that is vegan and cruelty-free. Thanks,
Function of Beauty for sponsoring this video!
i'm back with another tier ranking video! i hope you all enjoyed watching me judge all these movies and tv shows lolll. i’d love to know your thoughts on any of these adaptations!!
~ my tier list: tiermaker.com/create/book-ada...
thank you all for being the best! i love you lots and i’ll be back with a new video soon 😌
s o c i a l m e d i a:
twitter: / clockwork_reads
instagram: / clockwork_reads
goodreads: / aclockworkreader
tumblr: / aclockworkreader
snapchat: @clockwork_reads
business inquires: aclockworkreader@gmail.com
thank you so much for watching 💛
RIGHT AS I POSTED THIS I REALIZED THAT I FORGOT TO INCLUDE THE I C O N I C FILM FOR BEASTLY!!!! i'm so disappointed in myself omfg. anyway, beastly would be in its own tier for greatest bad movie of all time ✌🏼
omg i love your videos!! 🥺❤️❤️
If haven’t read it so won’t know anything about what apparently seems like a book which is also movie too but since you mentioned it I would definitely try to read it and watch it (just in case I be as disappointed as you are) ✨
Hannah...you are amazing. Pls don't ever stop.♥️♥️♥️. Love from Kerala😉
Love from India ! Keep making these awesome videos, and maybe one day I will actually want to read something hahaha.
that movie was a fever dream istg
I hate when people always say 'the books are always better' or 'the movies are always better' because it depends!!
Same..
Buuuuut the book is often better in my experience
This rule for the classics is absolute. Not because they change the story to attract the female audience to the cinema that the film is better. It is only more commercial to make money, offering women what they want and not something well written and reflective.
same
Still way too often the book is better, and It's still disrespectful to the original vision if it's not faithful. My ideal world is a world where each work that is adapted should always get at least one super faithful adaptation. Then do whatever you want with other adaptations after.
I hate 13 Reasons Why, but it does have a single redeeming quality. My art teacher is a recurring extra in the show since it was filmed at a high school two towns over. He walked onto the set and basically snuck into as many crowd shots as possible. There’s a crowd shot at a football game in the third season where he did his best to wave his arms around like a maniac and make crazy faces. My art teacher is such a fantastically chaotic person.
This one sparks joy
Basically a more exciting version of Where's Waldo. I wish I had teachers like that!
This and the pretty much it commentary tracks are the only good things if come from 13RW
The weirdest part of The Fault in Our Stars was that Shailene and Ansel had just been in a movie together as siblings...
megz_riley do I see a real life reference to the mortal instruments
Yeah.....so true
ikr in the divergent
I Dont Care yes lol and I feel like I saw them back to back so I was v uncomfortable
I don't get how that's weird tho?? Like it's just the same actors idk they don't even have the same personality :/
Percy Jackson on “source material?" wow you're being generous.
Like I appreciate it bc the movie was fun enough that I picked up the series in the first place THEN I realised how off it was lol, 2nd one should definitely NOT exist tho, fingers crossed the tv show does well
@@aimun5255 hi friend your comment shows that you are interested to read. So please check out our Facts Reading Channel. Give your review
Exactly what I was thinking. There are infinite problems, but one of my biggest was the fact that Hades is the villain. And the second movie is like switching the dial from 'ignore the source material and everything good about it' to 'spray on mist.' Yes. SPRAY ON MIST.
For a second, I thought you said that she was being genius and I was like "Umm, what? This book should not exist. These are the worst on the list. Why are you calling her a genius for putting it on source material." But then I read it correctly and my exact thoughts were, "YAAAAAS!! PREEEEEACH!" Which was strange.
Source material is fine for both movies
The last Divergent movie wasn't even made. They planned on turning the second half of Allegiant into a tv show 🙄 but the actors said that wasn't what they agreed to and so it never happened.
Not even a tv show just a TV movie
@@sophiam4165 I've heard it was supposed to be a show. But tv movie makes it even worse.
I always wondered if they finished it??? I rembeber watching the last one and then forgetting about it lmao
Haven’t even watched this yet but I already know Percy Jackson will be at the bottom
I had the same prediction. I also knew she’d put pride and prejudice at the top
I quite like the hunger games films, but the books are a MILLION times better. I think that the films where romanticized way too much
I agree! And I don't like the fact that they casted actors who were way older than the characters. I understand that its standard Hollywood practice to avoid legal troubles but one of the biggest themes of the books was how these children were being forced to do such terrible things simply for the entertainment of those in power. The fact that these 16 year olds were forced into this make believe romance just to increase their chances of survival.
@@TalkAsSoftAsChalk would cost so much money and time to use younger actors
@@TalkAsSoftAsChalk I STRONGLY AGREE
I haven’t even watched the video yet and I already know the 2005 film adaptation of Pride & Prejudice is going to be top tier on Hannah’s list.
😌
As it should be.
Dont want to be negative but i just dont understand how people can say its better than the book?? It literally does not understand the book at all 😭 it turns a book about understanding your faults (like lizzys predjudice) and reflecting on them into a corny romance. The characters are just.. wrong, Lizzy for example is a clever and witty characters, who knows how to be sassy without being rude. Keira Knightleys Lizzy is just bratty and immature. I dont even want to talk about Mr. Darcy..
I get why people love the movie, it has beautiful cinematografy and some ppl enjoy the romance, but it really has nothing to do with the source material..
@@taiszar I haven’t read the book, so I can’t really discuss the differences. But I don’t think there’s anything wrong with Hannah loving the movie more or you loving the book more. We should all just be respectful of other’s opinions.
Finally someone gets how terrible the Divergent movie franchise is. They literally take everything somewhat good part of the book and ruin it.
i think its univerally accepted that the divergent movies are trash i mean they didn't even finish it 😭😭😭
I mean, I LOVE the first book and the film but... it's not accurate and Hannah said it right: the actress that plays Tris is too old, but I still like it, don't come at me. Kinda sad about their first kiss in the movie because in the book it's just 😘. But I only think that probably because I guess I'm a sucker for first kisses?
Kiki Zajdova I can see how some people would like it if they were looking at it like a movie they were watching without any knowledge of the book. I was watching it with an already formed opinion in my mind, so maybe I wasn’t open to enjoying it, just criticizing it.
@@kirawoodford620 yeah, I also look at it like that sometimes, but I gotta admit I first saw the movie and then read the book. 😄
I liked the first movie and then hated the others. I literally haven't seen them since they were in theaters though, so my opinion isn't really valid anymore 😅
i l o v e d Jennifer as Katniss. i definitely didnt like how they got rid of katniss and peetas disabilities, but i think the movies are great. (i definitely think the first movie is the best out of the franchise)
what disabilities?
@@user-bk8qv4lv6o katniss was deaf in one ear, and peeta had one fucking leg in the books
I liked her acting, but was kinda mad that they made her white bc in the books she’s described as having ‘olive’ skin,, which is I think middle eastern not Caucasian???
@@salva8066 she's definitely Mediterranean looking, not Caucasian... and I think so was gale. Yikes
Elias Apollo yeah that is why they were able to pass as cousins for the capitol. There was also discussion in the books about how the people from the seam all mostly looked poc, with features like Gale & Katniss, and the people from the ‘richer’ parts of 12 were more caucasian-looking. The movies completely erased it, which I was pretty mad about.
One thing I REALLY wish they'd kept in "Love, Simon" was how Blue was revealed. They really just had Simon force Blue out to the whole school in the movie, even thought Blue was never really comfortable coming out to just Simon. The book handled that SO much better with Simon and Blue meeting privately and taking things slow for Blue. Also wish the movie would've kept more true to the book version of the relationship. That said, "Love, Simon" is incredibly beloved by me since it helped me accept myself and come out and is one of my favorite movies. For those reasons, I'd say read the book/will re-watch for "{Love, Simon."
I lovedddd the book, and the movie wasn’t bad, but it was underwhelming imo... I’d still give it a very good rating... like a 7/10 or something, but the book was a solid 8-8,5/10 to me
Simon didn't force Blue to come out though. It was still up to Blue to decide whether he should meet him at the ferris wheel or not. Simon would've understood either way.
queen is back but better than ever 🥰
Dear Brothers and Sisters, welcome to our Channel Daily Read It. We are Creating Reading Channel for Readers. It's contains Facts about Everything like Amazing Facts, Psychology Facts, Life Hacks, Did You Know Facts, Zodiac Facts, Motivational Quotes etc etc.. These Category our Covered all the Topics for the above Facts Content. So we are searching for True Facts Lover's and Readers. Yes, Definitely Readers can change the world. Please give your Ratings, Reviews and Experience. Thankyou I'm waiting for your Interest 👍❤️ and Reply. THANK YOU. You like it. Click our Channel Icon and Review our Channel. Once Again Thank You.😄 Check out
u literally look like this: 👸🏻💃🏻
🥺🥺🥺
Unpopular Opinion: I’m always so embarrassed to admit that I LOVE the Mortal Instruments movie. It holds such a special place in my heart. It is not a good film by any means and it doesn’t follow the source material, but it is so entertaining. The actors are just so likable and I wish we had gotten at least one or two more because yikes the ending needed to be cleared up for people who didn’t read the books 😂😂😂😂😂
Well I do agree with you. I loved the movie but hated the show.
I absolutely love the movie but it's purely because this is the first thing that introduced me to the shadowhunter world and I am now obsessed. I think it's just such a good feel good movie even if it isn't the best
@@pritiguria7717 I hate the movie love the show.
I liked the movie until I saw Valentine had a rat tail braid and I actually cried when I saw that 😂😂😂😂😂 And why is hair black? Why is he shirtless? Why is hodge 300 years old when he’s younger than Valentine? Why is Bach a shadowhunter?????
Okay, let’s be real. The main reason why Twilight is Perfection is because of the soundtrack !
YES LMFAO
I love that Robert Pattinson contributed to it
I agree 100%
Yes the soundtrack for all of the films are pretty dang good.
and the epic baseball scene
I was offended when you said you don’t like the maze runner books. You redeemed yourself when you said you like the movie and Dylan O’Brien because who doesn’t. But I’m still hurt.
the first book is overall good but at some points in the book, i couldn’t understand what was being portrayed
Mom like the books and made me read the first one and I didn’t like it, then I watched the movie since Stiles was the MC actor and disliked how far away from the source material it was even though I didn’t like the book.
I strongly disagree. Jennifer Lawrence is a stuning actress and for me, she is the best Katniss that could've been chosen (sorry if my english is bad i'm spanish)
also the fact that jennifer lawrence single handedly made the hunger games franchise popular. I cannot think of anybody else playing Katniss. She practically gave it her all
@@sabornisaha8962 100% agree. And she doesn't regret being on a mainstream series, she is proud and thankful unlike many others. Tbh anyone could be Gale but for me Peeta and Katniss are perfect
@@maestercraig3990 i reread the books this week and while they left a lot of things out (mostly in catching fire and the beginning of the hunger games) they are perfect adaptations tbh. Tho i agree with her, if you haven't read the books you won't understand the movies. I watched the 2 first before reading them and didn't understand shit about the world😂
Jennifer Lawrence was a great Katniss, but it pisses me off that they conveniently ignored that Katniss is supposed to have olive skin and picked a white actress.
@@user-dq6hk7co8w idk about the english ones but in the spanish copies she is described as white (a bit grey) and grey eyes, so is Gale and blue eyes for Peeta. None of those things are on the films and it's ok
Who is this JK Rowling you speak of? Daniel Radcliffe wrote Harry Potter, you can’t tell me otherwise.
Yeah that's what I thought
I was always under the understanding that it was Hagrid that wrote the series... teamwork makes the dream work!
This is sort of weird. Just accept the fact that she wrote it even if you dont agree with her ideologies. No one does that with bigoted male authors why are they suddenly doing it with JK Rowling
Rowling completely ruined the series for me... I guess I'll just have to think it was written by Dennis Creevey based on Hermione's journal(Cause Harry obviously wouldn't have kept one).
@@licherally212 I was more pissed off with how she achieved absolutely nothing in the second FBWTFT movie - what is she going to do for the next three? She should've made it shorter instead of dragging the series along for more money.
But the worst of course was how ignorant she is of other cultures. Nagini is a Hindu girl's name and it is supposed to be originated in Indonesia, but she cast a KOREAN actor to play the role. It doesn't fit the character description at all. Not to mention that Nagini's says like three words in the second film, one of them being Credence's name. Her tweets about how she's all for diversity really just bring out how ignorant she is.
I have loved Rowling and all her works for a long time, but her ignorance of minor cultures, diversity and sexuality is just too much. If she wants to be a role model for women like she always says, she should start acting like one.
Hannah: The You TV show doesn't do a good job at depicting Joe as the villain
Penn and some other people involved on the show: You should stop romanticizing Joe, he is the villain
In my opinion, the show does a good job at depicting Joe as the villain who is the perfect man in his own eyes. I think the audience who roots for him missed the point.
You have FARAMIR FOR YOUR RUclips ICON?
@@user-rs7xf5tm9s yes!
I can totally agree....
"I could do a whole series on how the hunger games movies are trash" QUEEN PLEASE I BEG YO-
I would actually love to see Hannah analyze the hunger games movies because I need to hear how awful it was splitting the last book between 2 movies and then doing fuck-all with the source material. Please Hannah!
@@Kaiheart The first one was good, second one was okay, but the last two were absolutely terrible.
The first one was okay, the second was brilliant and the last two... wHy?!
Yes, please! I need the validation 🤣
김주연 the second one was the best out of them all
I actually prefer the mini series of Pride and Prejudice with Colin Firth. Incredible.
Yes! Definitely! I do enjoy both, but the miniseries is so faithful to the book and the Mr Darcy in my head is and will always be Colin Firth :-P
@@taniwalters4999 For me it's hard to decide because Matthew McFadyen just look so antisocial and gentle. But again Colin has that something that I love. It's hard. Life is hard.
Tealu 2007 Ha ha, they are absolutely both swoon worthy 😂
Yess that’s the only one for me! It’s such a masterpiece!
I completely agree, that’s my favorite adaption. I mean I love the 2005 movie but I prefer the bbc series with Colin
* *a clockwork reader has posted a new video* *
me: clicks instantly and likes the video even before it has started.
Honestly, I would love to hear your full opinions on The Hunger Games movies
Love this tier ranking! TYSM for this!! ♥♥
I feel like the problem with the hunger games is honestly just with the marketing... the first movie is such a good adaptation imo. I’ve watched the movie then read the book then rewatched again and then listened to the audio book and everything cut made sense to me since the movie obviously has to be smaller and simpler. Of course the book offers a lot more context and depth to the whole thing but the movie did everything without narration and just showed you everything you needed to see to understand and then speculate until you’ve decided to read the book that is.
Yeah, I agree. The first movie didn’t offend me, but I thought the marketing was weird- then the sequels came out and everything went downhill real fast. Felt like they were trying their hardest to make action movies out of what should’ve been a war tragedy…
me : **is supposed to work on my masters research**
also me: hannah’s video is more important 👀❤️
Good luck on your research!
Amira Ebrahim thanks!!
I think The Fault in Our Stars really stuck to the book to the extent that it should have, apart from the age of the actors. It really gave me the same vibe as the book, and also it included all the important parts of the book
Finally someone is talking about it I was like the movie is good it represented the book perfectly not like some movie which doesn't even follow.
Percy Jackson Movies shouldn't exist!!
I was really excited when The Lightning Thief was about to begin on TV. But then the first few minutes made me so mad I could not stay long enough to watch the whole movie.
YES MALEC in shadow hunters was the most high quality aspect of the show 😍
If you haven't seen the adaptation of The Book Thief, I would recommend it. I love the book, and I thought the movie followed it really well.
I saw the movie in theaters with my sister and friend when we were in high school, and I swear we were the only people in the theater under the age of 65 lol
I agree!
We had to read that book in class and I will tell you right now that my class will STRONGLY disagree with you on that one. It was so slow and just felt like the author was dragging it on for no reason other than to tell you about a book Liesel stole every few chapters.
There's something about you that is Soo uplifting ❤️❤️❤️
thank you, you’re so sweet 💛
i also hate how the handled the katniss, peeta and gale situation in the movies - i h a t e love triangles with a burning passion but i felt like it was very well done.. in the books and only in the books. At least for me, it always had a way deeper meaning that went beyond just gale vs. peeta (it's been awhile since i read the book or watched the movies but imma try my best), where gale wasn't just gale but also kind of her wish to get away from the capitol and everything as far as she can and the whole thing with peeta and how that started showcasing how you couldn't just escape because the capitol traps people in very unfortunate circumstances and calling it freedom, giving them no real choice but to go along with it; idk it just further drove the point home for me of how bad the capitol was and how unfair and cruel everthing that happened to those kids was..
while in the movies they just went like "which cute boy is she gonna choose haha"
I LOVE HER EVEN MORE WHEN LITTLE WOMEN AND PRIDE AND PREJUDICE ARE ON TOP OF HER LIST LIKE YEEESSS QUEEEEN ❤
"Don't ask me why I watched this movie. I was in a dark place." Lmaooo same
I love the Maze Runner Trilogy, both the movies and books!
same!!!!
ILHAAM LADHA I personally hated the second movie, so much so that I would go and put it in shouldnt exist. The acting is incredible but there was no reason to go that far off the source material.
I remember I read the death cure on the way to watch the movie and screamed when I got in the car... I honestly don't remember why I might have to re-read and watch Maze Runner but Maze runner is my favorite series I've read. Though i do suck at reading series lol
Aspen Kelly maybe due to uh...**cough cough** newt **cough cough**
@@_byte__ We do not talk about page 250🥺😪🤧but I'll let it slip this time, not that the page even exists, I will not acknowledge it😤
The Hunger Games Movies are fantastic in a cinematic sense, but in regards to how they reflect the books, the books are much better.
the queen has posted again
i'm here!! and trying to be back with semi-consistent content ✌🏼
A Clockwork Reader omg u responded!! 😽
Hannah’s content is the only thing I stop my Spotify playlist for
I would just easily put shadowhunters in "should not exist" its a pain to watch 😤
SAME ugh I hate it so much I could go on for hours about all the things they did wrong :/
@@EllaIngram the struggle is real 😭
The cast in the show is better than the movie but the plot ????? I am confusion.
@@Cinia18 idk about that, I honestly prefer to picture the movie's cast when I read the books.. but then again.. the plots on both ends were 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
I mean... I haven't read the books so I thought the show was pretty awesome. I love the actors and especially Magnus and Alec.
We all know where Percy Jackson is going!
Yes! I'm glad Percy get his own series
I URGE you to watch the 2020 Emma movie adaption! Simply amazing! I honestly haven’t read the book so I don’t know if it’s accurate or enough research done to do this movie, but the colors are amazing, incredibly funny and the clothes are amazing! A must-see! Xxx
Yes please make an entire series about the hunger games movies I would love that
Haoul's moving castle was perfection, I totally agree. Hisaishi Joe is a GENIUS
I hate the Shadowhunters show not as the show but as “based on TMI” . It wasn’t just the plot it was the characters they got wrong in personality and looks
I'm so nervous that people are saying this because the creators of the Shadow Hunter show just bought the rights to House of Night series and are making it into a show. This has been a favorite series of mine since it first came out over 10 years ago. So I'm WORRIED they're gonna screw it up😭
Disagree. The looks and personally are quite fitted.
honestly better than the movie... i mean can't go worse than that ig
@@neta4768 The Shadow Hunters show just didn't follow the nature or characterization of the books. Clary wasn't suppose to be this model stunner for men to drool over - she was 15 (almost 16) & short AF, and Katherine McNamara was already 20-21 when the the show started.
Overall, the whole series cast was way too old to be playing these characters - the eldest SH main group character (out of the teens anyway) was Alec, and he was only 18 at the start of the books. And it didn't help all of theses supposed teenagers were sexualized TF out of in the first few episodes.
That's not even getting into the story changes, but honestly I could write an essay on how badly done the series (& movie, as it is not being left out of this either) was on story changes and mis-characterization. Don't get me wrong, I'm not a fan of Cassie Clare (she's on my shit-list as much as JKR, for obvious reasons), but I read the first 3 books in this series during a dark time in my life and they were something I loved. Seeing what the showrunners did to them just makes me upset.
The acting was SO bad too! The girl who plays Clary can't act at all 🤦🏽♀️
I fell in love with the lotr movies as a kid, and when I read the books this past year I can honestly say I think the books are better. The movies are of course incredible, but the iconic characters and stories missing from them give the books the edge up. Tom Bombadil, Faramir and Eowyn’s love story! These are too good to miss
Me Before You being put into the "shouldn't exist" rank just broke my heart.😢😂😂
Anyways, I was happy to see your video agian😁
Me too!! I loved the book and thought the movie was one of the best adaptations I’ve ever watched...
Bonnie Cooper watch her videos on popular books she doesn’t like. In one of those she talks about me before you
@@bonniecooper9539 Same!! I honestly don't understand her
I love the vibes you give off so much! Makes me want to read all the time
I kind of like the Shadowhunters show, but mostly because it made me read the books. And I also liked Magnus and Alec the most. They where really the only reason I watched in the end.
I think Perks of Being a Wallflower is probably the single best book adaption because the authour wrote and directed the movie, he knew what to do with his story and it paid off so well
Your outfit and makeup vibes are always so dreamy ✨
Oh my god!! A literally gasped with delight when I got the notification! Please post more tier ranking videos hannah!
We love that Hannah is really snapping in this video😂 she’s not holding her tongue at all she’s talking and doesn’t care about what anybody has to say and we love it
I LOVE Pride and Prejudice and I completely agree with you about the movie. If someone were to say they didn't want to read the book but want to know what it's about, I would direct them to this movie.
So so good to see you back!
So glad you're doing well and are backkk❣️❣️❣️
I'm currently rewatching Howl's moving castle for the 10000000x time, have read all the books, and I agree with you. I liked the books, they're okay, but the movie... that's just one of my favorite movies
Same!!
"they literally got rid of both peeta's and katniss's disabilities"
I haven't read the books in 8 years but have seen the movie several times and i don't remember that but whattgefuc
peeta lost his leg in book 1 but in the movie they just made that medicine cure it like it was just a scratch lol
Yep Katniss loses her hearing in one ear and peeta literally loses a LEG in book 1 but the movies were like “ehh the consequences of war and violence? Nah too real and not the standard of beauty for Hollywood”
I’m pretty sure that in the book capitol technology fixes katniss’s hearing though. But it’s true that Peeta is supposed to have a prosthetic.
@@lynsiedaniels3275 I remember Katniss also getting a prosthetic ear though??? At least that they had to put something mechanical inside so it could work normally again
im pretty sure these things weren't left out because the filmmakers were ableist or sg, but because the story was understandable without them. the films were as detailed as we can wish for imo, not everything can be adapted the same way as we read it. I agree that some things are overromanticized in the movies tho
Oh, I'm so excited for this video. I loved your last tier ranking one
I agree with all except one thing...the only good thing about Eclipse would easily be the Clearwater siblings! Seth and Leah are my faves and I’m not ashamed of it!
SETH CLEARWATER IS MY ALL TIME FAVORITE!!!! I have(mostly) outgrown twilight, but Seth will always have a place in my heart.
The Hobbit already went wrong when they made THREE movies of 400-page book!
You know, I actually thought there was only one movie, but when I read the book and wanted to watch the movie and found out, my first reaction was 'why?'
Okay but in keeping with this theme : Would you want a book to film adaptation of The Night Circus and, if yes, then who would you want to cast? Who would you want to direct the film?
I enjoy your videos so much, your voice is so calming, I usually can't sit through an 30min yt video without breaks because it's too much, but with you it's different!
And, I agree with you on almost everything you've mentioned ( on those I both read&watched too) so, awesome!
I was literally binge watching your stuff yesterday, I'm so happy you posted! Hope you're doing well :)
Lol I always feel bad for Penn when he has to explain that his character isn’t supposed to be someone you root for
I really was expecting You to be in the “better than the book” category. That’s where I would have put it, anyway. I haven’t read the second book so I can’t compare it to the second season. But I watched the first season and then read the book. The tv adaptation was soooo much better, in my opinion. Yes, people romanticize Joe way too much. But I think it’s unfair that you categorized it the way you did because you felt that the show didn’t make it clear enough that Joe is the villain. Joe is the narrator in the show, so of course he’s not going to describe himself as a villain. He thinks of himself as a good guy and a hero. So it’s not that the show itself is justifying Joe’s actions and romanticizing him, it’s Joe himself that does it. This is also why they added Paco into the TV series. It tricks the audience into thinking that Joe might actually not be as bad as he seems. They want the audience to figure out for themselves that Joe is the villain and that his actions are not justifiable even though he constantly tries to tell the audience that they are. It’s just like the book and movie adaptation of Lolita. It’s told by Humbert’s perspective just like You is. This is why Humbert’s actions are portrayed as “not so bad”. He is the one telling the story. Just like Joe.
I also personally strongly disagree with the fact that the show doesn't portray Joe as the villain. I think they do a great job of narrating from Joe's perspective and also condemning his actions. There's all these little hints scattered through so many scenes to highlight Joe's hypocrisy and lack of self-awareness. The first really obvious one that jumped out at me the first time I watched it is when Joe follows Beck and Peach to Peach's country house, and there's the scene where he's spying on Peach spying on Beck and he's like "omg can you believe she's violating your privacy like this??" and it's so blatantly in your face hypocritical. You cannot ignore that he's judging Peach for the exact same thing that he is doing and it's ridiculous. And then another really obvious one is in Season 2 when (I won't say their name in case of spoilers but) he meets the person who is just as crazy as he is and instead of being like "omg we're perfect together" he's like "wtf is wrong with you, you're insane, how could you possibly think this is normal?" Season 3 is imo the best season and the whole season is full of stuff like that, and then Season 4 the whole season's plot is about finally making him confront that he is not the good guy. Ofc, that is newer and I think Seasons 1 and 2 were the only ones out at the time of this video so those aren't as relevant. And also I can definitely recognize that You is not to everyone's tastes. But I really think the show does a great job of showing Joe as a villain even when he's allowed to tell the story from his perspective.
@@optimisms Worded perfectly! (Warning: mild spoilers ahead!)
I hated season 4 at first (because he was portrayed as a hero and didn’t seem like Joe at all), but when the twist was revealed, it all made sense and fell perfectly in line with Joe’s character. I ended up loving that they gave us even more insight to how Joe’s mind works and this fake glorified version of him that he truly believes is himself. I can’t wait for the next season. As for the books, I only read the first two and may or may not finish them after the show has concluded. The first one was okay. The second one, in my opinion, was all over the place to the point where it didn’t make much sense.
@@hannahbanana415 I didn’t hate it but I was not a huge fan of Season 4 before the second half, it was by far my least favorite season so far. I was so impressed by how they turned it around with the twist! I was also so mad at myself bc Joe has proven over and over that he is an unreliable narrator, but I still just believed his version of events instead of being like “hmm this doesn’t make sense” 🤦🏽♀️
Love your tier ranking videos! Keep them coming!!
Yayyy another video from Hannah! I hope you’ve been well!
I thought I was the only one who preferred the city of bones movie to the show (edit: not that I like the movie)
The show was just soooo bad the acting omg
I feel like anyone who read TMI just doesn’t like the show at all. I started reading the books because I heard about the show and it sounded interesting. Obviously the plot is different from the books but I actually like the show
I liked the show a lot and even though it was different form the books i think it holds the general principles of the books and i think it is still a very interesting series. The books are better but the series is good and i think the actors were really good and tbh i wasn't going to read the mortal instruments the. i saw the show and i loved it. Yeah the story line is a bit messed up but pretty much any adaptation you watch there are going to be things wrong and i personally loved the show.
the show is definitely really good if you dont think of it as an adaptation
I agree. The first season is cringey but from the second, it is better. But I can see why people hate, I would too if my fave books series was adapted like that
bro honestly this was so needed school started yesterday and I have swim tryouts so super stressed yk. Glad I get to come here for a breather.
I’ve been waiting for a new video since forever 💕💕
The hunger games is a weird one for me because it's like, they got some things very right, and I feel that suzanne collins' writing translated pretty well to the screen for the most part. but all of it is undone by the ridiculous merch that missed the point, and the whitewashing of the cast that totally glossed over any points the books could have been making about racism.
Good afternoon Hannah! Hope you're doing well! Have a good day.
I love your curls!! And your personality, ofc!❤️
Im so happyy for this new upload
literally I just texted my crush "happy birthday
What happened? :)
When I saw she uploaded I screamed so loud my mum came asking what was wrong😭
i love your tier-ranking videos!!! please make more!🤍🤍 ily. 🤍🤍
It’s insane how much I agree with all of your videos, I keep watching aaaall of them just to see if i found something i might dislike about your opinion but I haven’t, I love your videos ❤❤
There’s a trilogy adaptation of Ayn Rand’s ‘Atlas Shrugged’ that somehow manages to fit into “shouldn’t exist,” “source material??,” and “better than the book” all at the same time. It’s a dumpster fire, but a more tasteful one than the book.
I would like to add that the only reason you should watch Eclipse is because of Jasper’s amazing hair
Yes.
I really don’t like tier ranking videos BUT I always watch yours cause I love you
the way you said that we, as an audience of the movie of the hunger games, is the capitol is so savage. like 'omg the realization is strong'
it hurts my heart actually 😢😭
omg Im OBSESSED with dylan obrien. i think it started when the maze runner came out and thats also when i started teen wolf and to this day, now 19 years, Im still OBSESSED with him haha
I have never met anyone who has such strong feelings towards 13 reasons why like i do!
So glad you're back, stay lovely💛
I absolutely LOVE your Tier ranking videos
I honestly just watched the promos and clips of shadowhunters TV show and I was like WHAT DID THEY DO TO IT??!!
I am not even sure they read the book like at all
The perks of being a wallflower remains one of my favourite movies of ALL time. I don’t know it just means so much to me.
OMG yesss a new hannah videoooo im so exited even stopped drawing :)
I literally rewatched Pride and Prejudice (2005) today! It is my favourite adaptation ever made. Pride and Prejudice is my all time favourite novel and to me the film is just as good. It's just so perfect in every way that it makes my heart sing 💖
about Me Before You, you're actually one of the few people I heard that didn't like the movie. I still have friends that swear by it and would rewatch it every single day, and I never understood why...
girl we NEED a series on why the hunger games movies suck like-
yesssss sHE’S BACK!!!! it’s so funny how similar our tastes are (in literally everything)! and our personalities are also really similar. anyway, i love you 💜🤍 also, can we maybe perhaps possibly get a video review for dynamite? it’s up to you and totally okay if you don’t, but i’d totally be down the rewatch that millions of times over!
Ahhhh I'm so happy you're back, YAY❤️
OMG Howl’s moving castle is one of my favourite movies ever (along with maze runner and ever after) but I also love the book with all my heart, honestly I can’t decide between the two cause the movie changed some things but it worked but the original worked. That makes no sense lmao
Am I the only one who disagrees on her opinion about me before you movie
I loved both the book and movie I also think it helps if your English because you would understand then vibe better
I personally enjoy it but I watched her explanation of why she doesn’t like the book and I see her point of view regardless
Yeah, but I fully get where Hannah is coming from. The story is questionable but I love Lou so much as a character that I look at the series through rose-tinted glasses. She's my everything character.
I dont like the end message too. But the movie was really good tbh. And the soundtrack was amazing coz of ed sheeran
That movie made me cry so much
welcome back Hannah! i hope you are doing great!
im sooo happy you posted 💓💓💓