I have a screwdriver in my box that has a fuzzy handle. Sprayed it with brake cleaner after a job. Just a quick spray softened the plastic so much that when I wiped it with a shop towel it pulled fibers out of the paper. The fact that screwdriver survived overnight in brake cleaner impresses the shit out of me.
Great review, Ty. Your analysis is VERY helpful. Next time, also try a screwdriver in battery acid, paint thinner, and Berryman B-12 (these chemicals also appear around my work bench and in the warehouse). Wonder how these handles deal with extreme heat (like on a hot manifold or near an acetylene rig) or a hard freeze?
Since your into automotive I'd like to see you do a review on a torque multipler. They are great for taking lug off tractors and semis. Around 4,200 ft.Lbs. of torque. No air or electric needed just a simple crank on the handle with your hands. Great for when your away from power and in need lots of torque .
I have seen those, I dont typically work on huge things like buses or semis, but it is interesting to see that much torque being applied by hand with one of those low gear ratio hand crank multipliers. I think they would be more effective at removing lugs than installing them, since it would be so easy to damage the studs by overtightening them.
Torque multipliers come in handy on some automotive applications but very few that I have come across. I forget which car I was working on but it had a crank dampener bolt that had 400ish ft/lbs torque requirement. It had to be torqued back to same spec. Since we did not have a 3/4" torque wrench an ex diesel tech had a multiplier with a 4:1 ratio and with an adapter and a smaller torque wrench we were able to multiply the small output torque to the greater required spec. P.S. I wish I could afford all Proto grade tools but because they are more industrial grade I usually have to settle for the BlackHawk or Stanley. Commitment to the Mac truck scared me.
Great video! Thinking of getting the Mac version of these but undecided on whether to get the Mac (hard) vs the Soft (rubberized) grip. I work on cars and seems like the Mac handle will hold up better over time. Thoughts?
I would have liked to see you continue with more trade based chemicals (since these are "industrial" tools, they may come into contact with many types of industrial chemicals) i.e. Lacquer thinner, paint thinner, some type of caustic (drain cleaner), alcohol and even hot water - as hot as would come from a hot radiator. Great video. Thanks
The best tip in the world is useless if the handle is dissolved. He was testing Proto's claim about the durability of the handle, not just doing a tool review.
I've seen brake cleaner take of the Mac name on a screwdriver handle but Mac replaced the tool free of change because they were suppose to be corrosive resistance.
Ok, so they have superchemical resistant handles, how are they as screwdrivers? how's the fit, feel, balance? tips durable? I noticed you didn't have the bolstered set. perhaps a second test aimed as screwdriver function is needed. good job!!
Fedwrench - The Duratek line is based around the newly designed nylon handles. I dont think that there is anything extra-special about the shanks/tips themselves that would be much different from other pro-grade screwdrivers, and I thought that adding clips of me installing/removing screws was a bit much. I did talk about the feel at the end of the video, and I do like them a lot....they are very comfortable to use.
***** With this being on the same track as Fedwrench's comment, the Duratek line is different because of the nylon injected handles that are extremely chemical resistant. If chemical resistance isnt a big deal to you, then these most likely are not the choice you would go with anyway.....or it would at least knock a HUGE selling point off the table. That being said, keep in mind ALL of the people who question reviews authenticity on a regular basis (i.e -- you didnt use "new fluid" or "how do we know what you poured in the jars"). By showing me pouring the liquids, there would be no question that the video was faked.
Quick question. What is the chrome like on yours? I bought the 8 piece combo set, and the chrome one the #1 Phillips has a strange look to it. Almost like it was over chromed. And a couple of the others are kinda dinged up. Kinda bummed. Spent like $75.
Good video bro! You didn't mess around with these tests. Poor screwdrivers.Great stuff. Next time you do a similar test throw some ordinary screwdrivers that weren't designed for this type of abuse just to see how much better something like these are if at all.
Thanks! I actually tried that with a couple of them.....regular screwdrivers literally melted & turned to mush when placed in the brake cleaner, it was quite a weird site. Think of chewing gum on hot pavement. The problem was that it leached all of the color out of the cheapo screwdriver & turned the fluid red.
Jordan Ponce Brake cleaner will completely eat away all oils/grease/etc on anything & then evaporate....leaving it exposed. It wouldnt be the brake cleaner that would cause bolts/metal to rust....it is the absence of the protective layer of oil that allows the rust to form quickly. Bare metal will rust almost instantly (i.e. -- a cast iron engine head will immediately rust once you clean one to the bare metal with brake cleaner).
+Richard Cowtails I think that they are good.....get the split beam style if you pick one up, you never have to "unload" the pressure off of them & they stay very accurate.
I think thease are the same as the Mac grip handle?? look identical , I have a question about Mac grip vs snap on instinct grip , I do love the snap on instinct but would love some Mac so I my question is which is better? can u do a video on this dilemma, cheers love u vids ,from Dublin Ireland
They are the same, Stanley owns both mac and proto and there are a lot of the same tools throughout both lines. The upgraded models of these with the hex bolster on the shaft are about the same price from both companies, maybe 20 bucks more from Mac for a set. I have a couple ratcheting Mac grip screwdrivers and I love em
+kg king I have some of those too. I wouldn't say they're better. If you're a snap on guy then I'd say go for snap on. I also got the Mac grip version of this set with the bolsters because they just came up on promo sale. These are more resistant to harsh chemicals for sure, but the snap on's are more comfortable to use. Either way you get a great driver, but if you don't mind the extra 20-30 bucks for the set than get snap on.
Did you use neat glycol or a premixed coolant solution ? My biggest concern with flammables indoors isn't fire but explosion. I know it's not PC, but in the past I've used solvents that would soften ANY handles; you can't do it now wiz OSHA - thank God. Good mechanics' screwdrivers!
Jester Mclarpet The coolant was just a regular 1 gallon jug of universal antifreeze from Advance Auto Parts. I didnt store any of these inside for the 24 hour test.....I kept them in a covered carport, for that very reason.....I want zero fire risks. And I do have multiple fire extinguishers around the shop just in case ;)
Why is your gasoline so yellow? Really, it should be almost clear. There is a slight hint of a different color in premium compared to regular though. AV100 has a nice blue color to it though.
An Awesome and Interesting Review! Thanks! Do you know what the name PROTO stands for? I always thought of PROTO meaning Profession Tools. I've been using Proto tools since the 1970's and I never regretted spending my money for any Proto tool. They are tough and not ridiculously priced for such a well built "darn great" tools. I have never have a negative thought about passing them down the family line".
+Real Tool Reviews do you test big tool boxes/work carts? I've only seen a couple of videos on tool storage from you. thanks man. keep it up! you're one of the best real world review guys I've seen yet
+luddaman924wsi Thanks! Which models/brands did you have in mind? I have a couple more planned, but am not trying to overload the garage with wall-to-wall toolboxes if I can help it :)
+Real Tool Reviews I love the snap on 1033 box. the depth and drawer layout. just something with a similar/customizable layout for less money. I'm an industrial tech so my box doesn't move a lot but I want a big quality box.
Race gas, safety kleenex, and carb cleaner will do more damage to screw driver handles than anything I've came across. The crc brake kleen is crappy it's mostly water.
KamiCrit I guarantee you they are the most chemical resistant! :) I would guess feel-wise it will boil down to personal preference, but I really like them.
They are similar.....the shanks & colors are different (as well as different sizes/types).....but they are made in the same factory (both owned by Stanley Black & Decker).
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
I have a screwdriver in my box that has a fuzzy handle. Sprayed it with brake cleaner after a job. Just a quick spray softened the plastic so much that when I wiped it with a shop towel it pulled fibers out of the paper. The fact that screwdriver survived overnight in brake cleaner impresses the shit out of me.
Great review, Ty. Your analysis is VERY helpful. Next time, also try a screwdriver in battery acid, paint thinner, and Berryman B-12 (these chemicals also appear around my work bench and in the warehouse). Wonder how these handles deal with extreme heat (like on a hot manifold or near an acetylene rig) or a hard freeze?
Since your into automotive I'd like to see you do a review on a torque multipler. They are great for taking lug off tractors and semis. Around 4,200 ft.Lbs. of torque. No air or electric needed just a simple crank on the handle with your hands. Great for when your away from power and in need lots of torque .
I have seen those, I dont typically work on huge things like buses or semis, but it is interesting to see that much torque being applied by hand with one of those low gear ratio hand crank multipliers. I think they would be more effective at removing lugs than installing them, since it would be so easy to damage the studs by overtightening them.
Torque multipliers come in handy on some automotive applications but very few that I have come across. I forget which car I was working on but it had a crank dampener bolt that had 400ish ft/lbs torque requirement. It had to be torqued back to same spec. Since we did not have a 3/4" torque wrench an ex diesel tech had a multiplier with a 4:1 ratio and with an adapter and a smaller torque wrench we were able to multiply the small output torque to the greater required spec. P.S. I wish I could afford all Proto grade tools but because they are more industrial grade I usually have to settle for the BlackHawk or Stanley. Commitment to the Mac truck scared me.
Great video! Thinking of getting the Mac version of these but undecided on whether to get the Mac (hard) vs the Soft (rubberized) grip. I work on cars and seems like the Mac handle will hold up better over time. Thoughts?
I would have liked to see you continue with more trade based chemicals (since these are "industrial" tools, they may come into contact with many types of industrial chemicals) i.e. Lacquer thinner, paint thinner, some type of caustic (drain cleaner), alcohol and even hot water - as hot as would come from a hot radiator. Great video. Thanks
+prgoza I just used the various chemicals that they made claims about in their advertising.
Great review, I’m sold and have decided to buy a set. Thanks!
my hub jj really enjoys you're tool reviews as he's addicted to tools also .so keep up the good work and we are subscribing!
More than I care about how the handles hold up. I'm more worried about the performance of the tip of the screwdriver.
Randall Krebbs same here
The best tip in the world is useless if the handle is dissolved. He was testing Proto's claim about the durability of the handle, not just doing a tool review.
I've seen brake cleaner take of the Mac name on a screwdriver handle but Mac replaced the tool free of change because they were suppose to be corrosive resistance.
Wish they put the hex on like snap on
non yobussiness They do under the MAC versions (MAC & Proto are both owned by SBD - Stanley Black & Decker).
Sweet. I've been looking at they're nut drivers, they look awesome as well
They do actually have a hex version of them too.
Ok, so they have superchemical resistant handles, how are they as screwdrivers? how's the fit, feel, balance? tips durable? I noticed you didn't have the bolstered set. perhaps a second test aimed as screwdriver function is needed. good job!!
Fedwrench - The Duratek line is based around the newly designed nylon handles. I dont think that there is anything extra-special about the shanks/tips themselves that would be much different from other pro-grade screwdrivers, and I thought that adding clips of me installing/removing screws was a bit much. I did talk about the feel at the end of the video, and I do like them a lot....they are very comfortable to use.
***** With this being on the same track as Fedwrench's comment, the Duratek line is different because of the nylon injected handles that are extremely chemical resistant. If chemical resistance isnt a big deal to you, then these most likely are not the choice you would go with anyway.....or it would at least knock a HUGE selling point off the table.
That being said, keep in mind ALL of the people who question reviews authenticity on a regular basis (i.e -- you didnt use "new fluid" or "how do we know what you poured in the jars"). By showing me pouring the liquids, there would be no question that the video was faked.
Quick question. What is the chrome like on yours? I bought the 8 piece combo set, and the chrome one the #1 Phillips has a strange look to it. Almost like it was over chromed. And a couple of the others are kinda dinged up. Kinda bummed. Spent like $75.
Very nice video. Those look great!!
Thanks Jeff! :)
Good video bro! You didn't mess around with these tests. Poor screwdrivers.Great stuff. Next time you do a similar test throw some ordinary screwdrivers that weren't designed for this type of abuse just to see how much better something like these are if at all.
Thanks! I actually tried that with a couple of them.....regular screwdrivers literally melted & turned to mush when placed in the brake cleaner, it was quite a weird site. Think of chewing gum on hot pavement. The problem was that it leached all of the color out of the cheapo screwdriver & turned the fluid red.
That would've been awesome to see the cheapo screwdrivers melt. You should include that next time
Would the brake cleaner rust new bolts overnight?
Jordan Ponce Brake cleaner will completely eat away all oils/grease/etc on anything & then evaporate....leaving it exposed. It wouldnt be the brake cleaner that would cause bolts/metal to rust....it is the absence of the protective layer of oil that allows the rust to form quickly. Bare metal will rust almost instantly (i.e. -- a cast iron engine head will immediately rust once you clean one to the bare metal with brake cleaner).
Thank you i appreciate your insightful help
what did you do with all of these chemicals after?
Recycled at the landfill.
Correct me if im wrong but aren't these the same thing as the Mac Grip screwdrivers by Mac Tools?
Essentially they are the same except for the shanks/various sizes/color scheme.
What do you think about cdi torque wrenches?
+Richard Cowtails I think that they are good.....get the split beam style if you pick one up, you never have to "unload" the pressure off of them & they stay very accurate.
ok, thank you
Do you have any wera tool reviews in the future like their joker wrenches and ratchets?
Yep, I am working on getting some Joker wrenches & the new all metal Zyklop ratchets. Stay tuned.....hopefully sooner than later ;)
I think thease are the same as the Mac grip handle?? look identical , I have a question about Mac grip vs snap on instinct grip , I do love the snap on instinct but would love some Mac so I my question is which is better? can u do a video on this dilemma, cheers love u vids ,from Dublin Ireland
They are the same, Stanley owns both mac and proto and there are a lot of the same tools throughout both lines. The upgraded models of these with the hex bolster on the shaft are about the same price from both companies, maybe 20 bucks more from Mac for a set. I have a couple ratcheting Mac grip screwdrivers and I love em
+Everett Clunie cool thanx but are they better than snap on instinct grip ?
+kg king I have some of those too. I wouldn't say they're better. If you're a snap on guy then I'd say go for snap on. I also got the Mac grip version of this set with the bolsters because they just came up on promo sale. These are more resistant to harsh chemicals for sure, but the snap on's are more comfortable to use. Either way you get a great driver, but if you don't mind the extra 20-30 bucks for the set than get snap on.
+Real Tool Reviews do you pay for all these tools you review?
+luddaman924wsi Here is our Disclosure....it explains how everything works --> www.realtoolreviews.com/disclosure/
+Real Tool Reviews thanks. yall hey some amazing tools. not going to lie... I'm a little bit jealous lol
Did you use neat glycol or a premixed coolant solution ? My biggest concern with flammables indoors isn't fire but explosion. I know it's not PC, but in the past I've used solvents that would soften ANY handles; you can't do it now wiz OSHA - thank God. Good mechanics' screwdrivers!
Jester Mclarpet The coolant was just a regular 1 gallon jug of universal antifreeze from Advance Auto Parts. I didnt store any of these inside for the 24 hour test.....I kept them in a covered carport, for that very reason.....I want zero fire risks. And I do have multiple fire extinguishers around the shop just in case ;)
Why is your gasoline so yellow? Really, it should be almost clear. There is a slight hint of a different color in premium compared to regular though. AV100 has a nice blue color to it though.
No clue....it was cheap 87 octane.
An Awesome and Interesting Review! Thanks!
Do you know what the name PROTO stands for? I always thought of PROTO meaning Profession Tools.
I've been using Proto tools since the 1970's and I never regretted spending my money for any Proto tool. They are tough and not ridiculously priced for such a well built "darn great" tools. I have never have a negative thought about passing them down the family line".
Hawaiian F150 that’s what Proto means. PROfessional TOols.
They are exactly the same as Mac-Grip screwdrivers from Mac Tools.
Great test.
Thanks! :)
Why about some parts washer chemical?
+Real Tool Reviews do you test big tool boxes/work carts? I've only seen a couple of videos on tool storage from you. thanks man. keep it up! you're one of the best real world review guys I've seen yet
+luddaman924wsi Thanks! Which models/brands did you have in mind? I have a couple more planned, but am not trying to overload the garage with wall-to-wall toolboxes if I can help it :)
+Real Tool Reviews I love the snap on 1033 box. the depth and drawer layout. just something with a similar/customizable layout for less money. I'm an industrial tech so my box doesn't move a lot but I want a big quality box.
No such thing as too many toolboxes..
very well done.
Thanks Victor!
WELCOME
Race gas, safety kleenex, and carb cleaner will do more damage to screw driver handles than anything I've came across. The crc brake kleen is crappy it's mostly water.
Dewey Sturgill the red cans don't evaporate
I have the mac version which looks the same
87 octane? I've never seen anything like that in the UK.
Sure you have. In UK they call it 92 octane, which is 87 US octane. Same regular fuel, we just use different scale.
Andy Chow Oh so they use a different system? I see. Honestly I don't remember the last time I saw 92 octane fuel. Everywhere sells 95-97-99 now.
no skydrol?
They look like the MAC Screwdrivers👍👍
good test well made screwdrivers.
+BADD400 CB700 drums Thanks!
US made, nice!!
Best screwdrivers made yet?
KamiCrit I guarantee you they are the most chemical resistant! :) I would guess feel-wise it will boil down to personal preference, but I really like them.
Sold!
Only knock that i can see with this tool is there is no place on the screwdriver shaft to put a wrench on.
They do offer bolster screwdrivers also....this set was the plain ones though. The handles would be the same on all of them.
You must be a ford guy with that ATF transmission fluid.
Haha....just what I had laying around when I made this. But yes, I do have multiple fords ;)
These look like the Mac screwdrivers
They are similar.....the shanks & colors are different (as well as different sizes/types).....but they are made in the same factory (both owned by Stanley Black & Decker).
mac owns proto
@@oren7494 I think it's The other way around. PROTO owns mac.
Same as Mac.
nylon alloy.
Mac tools
No hex bolsters available. Absolute fail.
Duthiel Ottomann FYI --- The MAC versions of these do have some of them available with Hex Bolsters.
Duthiel Ottomann There are two versions ones with bolsters and ones without the j1208scp has bolsters the j1208sc has no bolsters.
👍🖒👍🖒👍🖒👍💘💘💘
Bull shit, I would be spraying them off with brake clean or put it in the wash tank before I put it in my box.
my hub jj really enjoys you're tool reviews as he's addicted to tools also .so keep up the good work and we are subscribing!
my hub jj really enjoys you're tool reviews as he's addicted to tools also .so keep up the good work and we are subscribing!