Why.? Just because the vehicle is in his name? Every vehicle in any state used by police , will registered under Commissioner of police of that state and city.. You don't see name of particular person. You only find DESIGNATION LINE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE..
His chief duty is to provide protection to the citizens from whom he gets his salary and perks. But he is acting like personal employee of the CM and terrorising the very same citizens!! Typical East India Co. product.
Evidence destruction/Tampering case must be filed against WB State, police and health. Murder case can't be solved without solving the Evidence destruction case first.
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
Yes absolutely it is a strong case which shd be investigated and a trial of any offcials or ministers involved in it shd be tried and sent to jail if proven guilty - of obstruction of justice. at the very least negligence.
They wants to get away with evil murder actions, that's why even though doctors marching peacefully, but criminal police & West bangalore mamatha & her leaders try to destroy peaceful marches to shut them up to close the case??? What a shame, even media cowards never questioned police commissioner or police or mamatha benarge, what a shameless ruthless police arrested one man that to he's a friend of police , its tremondously shameful to the country on this planet earth, even anybody cuts their neck for justice in India never ever get justice, its an a open secre?????????
Habitual criminal like sanjoy roy r posted as civil police volunteers. They have been provided with exclusive vehicles of police dept and registered in the name of police commissionar. Salary is also given from public exchequer. No exam or employment exchange seniority as the criteria for their selection in a state where unemployment rate is on the rise.This system is the real problem. Surprisingly, youth organisations r not raising voice against this corrupt system
Barkha Maam,, kudos to you for ur fearless and transparent coverage of the kolkata horrific saga Mamata banerjee should be named and shamed for her inept handling and her dadagiri
Sorry to say cbi is not able to came conclusion since past three weeks.its hopless situation for doctors, what else they can do get justice for victim. Even a normal resident of Calcutta knows the story, the expect cbi will came forward by some solid evidence and culprits will be published, but story is roaming around only one culprit.all social media and youtubers are making stories only for their viewership,and in name of investigation only POLITICS is Cooking ..and serving....but i am sure our CBI officials are more qualified and capable .will get justice soon ..
If everyone is angry in Kolkata there is a valid reason. Ask yourself that Question mamta banerjee why are the Public so annoyed with you. Why are you not punishing those monsters, rapist and criminals. Instead you are paying lawyers a sum of Rs. 15,50,000/- per hearing to fight the RG kar case and offering the parents of the deceased a compensation of Rs 10laks. What would you do if she was your sister or Daughter. Answer my Question mamta banerjee????
Dear protesting doctors - our support is full with you - but what we doubt is how far will CBI do justice to this heinous crime - as v have seen CBI's role in sushant singh rajput case - pl go directly to cji - also SC shd directly take action on Kolkata police, and mamata govt - who is acting cruelly on protesting doctors/public today
Dear protesting doctors, please go to the CBI with all your evidence rather than to media channels. The CBI is getting ready to file a chargesheet soon and as per reports there is only one suspect with them - Sanjoy Roy.
Does police have rights to hit civilians inwhich law it has written. Culprits are still out, how many people are involved and did this crime, and if they are drs then how this society is safe? And if with power one dr moving to different hospitals than in Kolkata or in our country which hospital is safe? Culprits are still out
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
Barkha, your shows are really descent and good. You do not indulge in shouting and falsehood. All other TV channels media are horribly indulging in false and cooked narratives. Keep it up Barkha and keep your name and fame not tarnish. God bless you.
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
The East India Co.(role model of successor systems in India) created a very elaborate body of crininal laws, sections, sub- sections and procedures. But they did not make any provision at all of registration of FIR against itself howsoever criminal acts they might be indulging in themselves. How shrewd !!! And how convenient it is proving now!!
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
The Motive to elinimate the wistelblower ... rape not motive of murder. The murder was motive, the rape is to divert the investigation. Jo accused he, civic volenteers jyadatar TMC sarkar ke police ka paltu gunda he, us se yh kand karwaya gya he.
The entire focus is shifted to the dramas created by different political parties each day,, it seems they have all declared war against each other,,, but where is the real issue? Cbi is facing problem as evidences related to the crime are all destroyed, even the polygraph tests seem to b not helping,, where are we heading to,,, towards justice for the lady doctor or the free of cost circus show that we r seeing on road everyday?
Barkha, please watch the video, Hothat Jodi Uthlo kotha. The RG Kar doctors have detailed how they stood up against the authorities to protect the crime area.
CBI will NOT tell you the detail. They would tell it to their masters in Center Govt - that that is bjp. After that negotiations between tmc and bjp on the cards.
There must be justice for the departed soul and real changes on the ground in the near future. Media too should show restraint and not make matters worse by spreading wild unverified rumours.
Very very sad. Mamataji has been caught on the wrong foot. She has only herself to blame for all this tragedy. The criminal of criminals is none other than this Principal, Ghosh ! It is only because of him that Sanjay stooped to such a level of depravity ! Now the opposition party ie the BJP will seize this opportunity to the hilt to play their dirty games. How & why was the CM protecting this goon Ghosh ! There must be someyhing more deep in these dirty peoples connections.! Jai Hind !
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
The case filed by Ali Akthar who was investigating if was investigated this day wud not hve happened sum1 also MUST TAKE FULL RESPONSIBILITY FOR THIS NEGLIGENCE.
Super active police... Shame to bengal government and police... The same police faces appeared in media during Sandeshkhali case again got active in RG kar agitation and justice case today and started appearing in the media...police was inactive during RGKar hospital maccare case before the independence day .....Bengal misses competent police officers like Damayanti Sen....police has Indercetly confirmed viral video regarding presence of forensic expert, lawyers, doctors of other hospital etc. in the crime area , later on from where the lady doctor body was found...Hard to get justice in Bengal... Doubtful about what CBI may able to dig out...
Keep up the pressure on the system until full justice is served. No worker can be happy while working in fear of her life. No family is happy when fear hovers in society, fear to speak up for justice against humanity.
I appreciate the efforts taken by all to give a minute to minute account to help an Indian lady who was raped and murdered. I wish that all the women raped and murdered in Manipur had the same justice. If that had happened this may have been avoided. Unfortunately depending on the Govt in power pressure is put. 😢
When we hire a maid the police is given her details so that they can do a police verification. Isn’t it strange that a guy working for the West Bengal police wasn’t properly investigated by them? Or is it normal for West Bengal police to hire goondas?
CBI has said to SC that the scene of the crime was altered. The parents of the victim were led to the scene after impatiently waiting outside for3 hrs. after so many people were seen to have accessed there earlier The parents said they didn’t see that the room ,where the dead body of their daughter was laying ,had been protected by tapes . On the contrary a senior lady Police officer said on camera that the crime scene was protected by tapes. Such Contradictions to be resolved .This apart, Permission to break a wall inside the seminar room for renovation when every inch of the room needed to be protected in the interest of the investigation ,also needs to be questioned.
Kudos to Barkha dutt for standing up for a victim. She possesses amazing integrity. There are several reports of a gang attack - ranging from 5 to 7 to 10 individuals. We need forensic analysis of DNA samples to ascertain how many culprits are involved and who all. West bengal govt shd be dismissed over this gruesome crime. The cover up angle shd further be investigated. If any officials, ministers or even member of judiciary are involved in it, they shd be tried for obstruction of justice and if found guilty, shd be sent to jail. At the very least negligence is there.
Bahut taklif hoti hai,gussa aata hai,jab justice bhi nahi milta.sorry,lekin mujhe koi hope nahi,CBI ki reputation bhi kahan achchi hai,phir aaj kal court bhi bahut jyada interfere karne lagi hai
Leaders are bothered about Their post position and survival of their party by divide and rule,at the cost of people's life and country's progress.All people irrespective of caste creed and religion must unitedly fight against those corrupt leaders. Gruesome incident ,mass protest in Bengal is the eye opener to the entire nation to carry on this moment of public protest till we get justice.
Please untangle this riddle for me: didn't the doctor in question know, as would any individual know, that with hostile people around her, it would be nothing short of suicidal for her to go into a lone, unprotected room, leave the entrance unsecured, and then go to sleep there?
Initially Bengali were quit when other illegal things were happened in other parts of WB and giving raise to gudas, political party become hand and glow with them, the Bengali masses were quite or mute spectators. Now the tiger has come to thier home now they to face the music.
12:10 Once again Barkha tries to incite speculation as usual, but the doctor knows better, kudos to the doctor. Shame on Barka for inciting speculation and violence
Kolkata Commissioner of Police needs to be interrogated
No. He needs to be dismissed.
Why.?
Just because the vehicle is in his name?
Every vehicle in any state used by police , will registered under
Commissioner of police of that state and city..
You don't see name of particular person.
You only find DESIGNATION LINE
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE..
BENGAL POLICE should be totally disbanded and interrogated in jail
because it does not follow Indian Laws.It follows dictates of few individuals.@@maheshrachakonda4322
His chief duty is to provide protection to the citizens from whom he gets his salary and perks. But he is acting like personal employee of the CM and terrorising the very same citizens!! Typical East India Co. product.
Pure Autocracy carried out in Kolkata, it's high time to initiate President rule
Cm mamta banerjee should resign immediately. And also mamta banerjee polygraph test should be done first. . Coz she is trying to protect someone
Evidence destruction/Tampering case must be filed against WB State, police and health. Murder case can't be solved without solving the Evidence destruction case first.
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
Yes absolutely it is a strong case which shd be investigated and a trial of any offcials or ministers involved in it shd be tried and sent to jail if proven guilty - of obstruction of justice. at the very least negligence.
They wants to get away with evil murder actions, that's why even though doctors marching peacefully, but criminal police & West bangalore mamatha & her leaders try to destroy peaceful marches to shut them up to close the case??? What a shame, even media cowards never questioned police commissioner or police or mamatha benarge, what a shameless ruthless police arrested one man that to he's a friend of police , its tremondously shameful to the country on this planet earth, even anybody cuts their neck for justice in India never ever get justice, its an a open secre?????????
Habitual criminal like sanjoy roy r posted as civil police volunteers. They have been provided with exclusive vehicles of police dept and registered in the name of police commissionar. Salary is also given from public exchequer. No exam or employment exchange seniority as the criteria for their selection in a state where unemployment rate is on the rise.This system is the real problem. Surprisingly, youth organisations r not raising voice against this corrupt system
The police commissionar should be arrested and tried in court..for issues related to evidence tampering, illegal lathi charge on citizens etc. etc
JAILED FOR LIFE
CM must resign
Barkha Maam,, kudos to you for ur fearless and transparent coverage of the kolkata horrific saga
Mamata banerjee should be named and shamed for her inept handling and her dadagiri
Barkha - this is about people. Politics is about polity or people. How can politics be out of this issue,?
Aptly said
Sorry to say cbi is not able to came conclusion since past three weeks.its hopless situation for doctors, what else they can do get justice for victim. Even a normal resident of Calcutta knows the story, the expect cbi will came forward by some solid evidence and culprits will be published, but story is roaming around only one culprit.all social media and youtubers are making stories only for their viewership,and in name of investigation only POLITICS is Cooking ..and serving....but i am sure our CBI officials are more qualified and capable .will get justice soon ..
If everyone is angry in Kolkata there is a valid reason. Ask yourself that Question mamta banerjee why are the Public so annoyed with you. Why are you not punishing those monsters, rapist and criminals. Instead you are paying lawyers a sum of Rs. 15,50,000/- per hearing to fight the RG kar case and offering the parents of the deceased a compensation of Rs 10laks. What would you do if she was your sister or Daughter. Answer my Question mamta banerjee????
Mamtha banerjee should not be elected again as a CM.
She will not be able to answer any question. Her only answer would be that you are a CPM cadre & that's y you are asking this question
The world is watching very closely how the Indian government is going to handle this horrific horrendous crime against this young doctor.
Modi has a thick skin. Momota Begum criminal has been emboldened by inactions and political patronage from Modi.
Dear protesting doctors - our support is full with you - but what we doubt is how far will CBI do justice to this heinous crime - as v have seen CBI's role in sushant singh rajput case - pl go directly to cji - also SC shd directly take action on Kolkata police, and mamata govt - who is acting cruelly on protesting doctors/public today
CBI not to be trusted even 5%.
Ha MC dikh raha hai what the fcuk kinda support you're giving to the protestors.
Dear protesting doctors, please go to the CBI with all your evidence rather than to media channels. The CBI is getting ready to file a chargesheet soon and as per reports there is only one suspect with them - Sanjoy Roy.
What is stopping the CBI to interrogate the protesting Doctors?
all evidence has been cleared by kolkata tmc goons and police . what evidence ?
Why not both? Best to have an insurance policy, right?
The suggestion makes sense👍🏻As it is a lot of time has been wasted by the misreporting by TRP hogging TV & Social Media Channels. Shame😢
Very valuable suggestion. 👌
Does police have rights to hit civilians inwhich law it has written. Culprits are still out, how many people are involved and did this crime, and if they are drs then how this society is safe? And if with power one dr moving to different hospitals than in Kolkata or in our country which hospital is safe? Culprits are still out
KEEP MARCH TO GET JUSTICE
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
That police commissioner also botched up a brutal ₹ape and murder in Kandhuni as IG of CID. He needs to resign
Barkha, your shows are really descent and good. You do not indulge in shouting and falsehood. All other TV channels media are horribly indulging in false and cooked narratives. Keep it up Barkha and keep your name and fame not tarnish. God bless you.
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
Good luck protesting students.God bless you
Thanks for pursuing on this matter
Justice Now
Kolkata police commissioner must resign faltu baten it's not at all a crime report 👎👎👎👎👎
Corruption in police and hospital admin
please Mamta banerjee have some shame...
Word Shame is not there in the Congress directory
ruclips.net/video/OPeclgI5BE8/видео.htmlsi=ikWs_UvyGe7envxf
It is not his bike .He use a police
bike..
It's great that you guys are hopeful on CBI. I am not. For me, its Corrupt Bikai hai Individuals ...just like they behaved in SSR case.
Let chief justice of India take decision irrespective of tampered
evidence
Corrupt top police men didn't do their job right and hence all this mess. He must be tossed out of his position or better jailed.
The East India Co.(role model of successor systems in India) created a very elaborate body of crininal laws, sections, sub- sections and procedures. But they did not make any provision at all of registration of FIR against itself howsoever criminal acts they might be indulging in themselves. How shrewd !!! And how convenient it is proving now!!
Full support to the Doctors rightful protest for justice 👍
It's BJP which is fighting the politics not the Dr's really
@@philomenathomas1619 Wrong.
They were not students they were all old men
Writing is on the walls of Bengal....physically reaching Nabanna or not is not the question. Providence has it all written down, already
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
I must say students were not violent or neither they carried any weapons, but Mamata's cops were brutal.
looks like this case will go Arushi murder case and Sushant Singh Rajput case, CBI not helpful and SC is intimidated by Mr Sibil😢
The Motive to elinimate the wistelblower ...
rape not motive of murder. The murder was motive, the rape is to divert the investigation.
Jo accused he, civic volenteers jyadatar TMC sarkar ke police ka paltu gunda he, us se yh kand karwaya gya he.
Successfully conveying political angle of rape , wasting time.
The entire focus is shifted to the dramas created by different political parties each day,, it seems they have all declared war against each other,,, but where is the real issue? Cbi is facing problem as evidences related to the crime are all destroyed, even the polygraph tests seem to b not helping,, where are we heading to,,, towards justice for the lady doctor or the free of cost circus show that we r seeing on road everyday?
Barkha, please watch the video, Hothat Jodi Uthlo kotha. The RG Kar doctors have detailed how they stood up against the authorities to protect the crime area.
seems like this case will be brushed off just like SSR ....No faith in Political system
Thank you Ms. Dutt
CBI will NOT tell you the detail. They would tell it to their masters in Center Govt - that that is bjp. After that negotiations between tmc and bjp on the cards.
Not transerred to calcutta medical college, rather to natinal medical college calcutta.
बच्चों हिम्मत नहीं हारना ! पब्लिक तुम्हारे साथ हैं, डॉक्टर बेटी को न्याय मिलना चाहिए बच्चों धरना प्रदर्शन जारी रखे, Mamta should resign
There must be justice for the departed soul and real changes on the ground in the near future. Media too should show restraint and not make matters worse by spreading wild unverified rumours.
Finally found a sensible comment 👍
@@titirrr Thanks.
Kolkata should become its own state.
Will the culprits and their supporters be punished ..? They shall all be given a free hall pass.
The world is demanding justice for Abhaya
Police are the goons of politicians in this country. Not the protectors of common men
Very good channell.
Thankyou for honest facts
We strongly demand mamata resign
The TMC POLITICIANS continue to defend criminals.
Very very sad. Mamataji has been caught on the wrong foot. She has only herself to blame for all this tragedy. The criminal of criminals is none other than this Principal, Ghosh ! It is only because of him that Sanjay stooped to such a level of depravity ! Now the opposition party ie the BJP will seize this opportunity to the hilt to play their dirty games. How & why was the CM protecting this goon Ghosh ! There must be someyhing more deep in these dirty peoples connections.! Jai Hind !
Watching from USA
Who is trying to help the corrupt ex principal? Mamata banerjee is the health minister she is incharge of this.
MCI and IMA ought to have cancelled Sandip Ghosh's practicing licence long back @ 2021... they also must be questioned by the SC @ CJI... for this inaction...
Mamata main culprit and complicit in this hernious crime.
The case filed by Ali Akthar who was investigating if was investigated this day wud not hve happened sum1 also MUST TAKE FULL RESPONSIBILITY FOR THIS NEGLIGENCE.
Justice and only justice true stay far away from politics. Politics is poison . ❤👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Students ??????
Justice for doctors needed
Reporting issues from West Bengal does not fit the Mojo business model, but this time they have to 😊
Not just strove to break barriers but actually broke barriers. There are also videos of protesters pelting stone at police.
Super active police... Shame to bengal government and police... The same police faces appeared in media during Sandeshkhali case again got active in RG kar agitation and justice case today and started appearing in the media...police was inactive during RGKar hospital maccare case before the independence day .....Bengal misses competent police officers like Damayanti Sen....police has Indercetly confirmed viral video regarding presence of forensic expert, lawyers, doctors of other hospital etc. in the crime area , later on from where the lady doctor body was found...Hard to get justice in Bengal... Doubtful about what CBI may able to dig out...
Only justice for the Dr 🙏🙏
It's high time that the CBI should come out with the verdict.... Arrest both the culprits and check out if there's a third party involved.....
Keep up the pressure on the system until full justice is served. No worker can be happy while working in fear of her life. No family is happy when fear hovers in society, fear to speak up for justice against humanity.
I appreciate the efforts taken by all to give a minute to minute account to help an Indian lady who was raped and murdered.
I wish that all the women raped and murdered in Manipur had the same justice. If that had happened this may have been avoided.
Unfortunately depending on the Govt in power pressure is put. 😢
Authority can bully ..so now justify the police actions .. students in a peaceful protest .. would they inflict violence .. make sense of this pls
Let's stick to the Priorities - THE ENFORCERS must FAST-TRACK the investigations and bring the laws into force
Justice delayed for Abhoya is Justice denied for sure...
When we hire a maid the police is given her details so that they can do a police verification. Isn’t it strange that a guy working for the West Bengal police wasn’t properly investigated by them? Or is it normal for West Bengal police to hire goondas?
It seems the police hires goondas 😮😮
We the world are in support for all the medical staff and citizens that are protesting
Strict action has to be taken against Kolkata Police by the directly by the honorable SC
CBI has said to SC that the scene of the crime was altered. The parents of the victim were led to the scene after impatiently waiting outside for3 hrs. after so many people were seen to have accessed there earlier The parents said they didn’t see that the room ,where the dead body of their daughter was laying ,had been protected by tapes . On the contrary a senior lady Police officer said on camera that the crime scene was protected by tapes. Such Contradictions to be resolved .This apart, Permission to break a wall inside the seminar room for renovation when every inch of the room needed to be protected in the interest of the investigation ,also needs to be questioned.
Also all KP personnels should be checked . Where all they visit....
Good to see you are doing it neutrality..keep the protest..
Police is most ineffective inefficient department in India
political move is divirging your attention from actul incidence its very misterious and big shorts must b involved😢
Kudos to Barkha dutt for standing up for a victim. She possesses amazing integrity. There are several reports of a gang attack - ranging from 5 to 7 to 10 individuals. We need forensic analysis of DNA samples to ascertain how many culprits are involved and who all. West bengal govt shd be dismissed over this gruesome crime. The cover up angle shd further be investigated. If any officials, ministers or even member of judiciary are involved in it, they shd be tried for obstruction of justice and if found guilty, shd be sent to jail. At the very least negligence is there.
Jio Barqha
Time to ignore politicians 👍
Bahut taklif hoti hai,gussa aata hai,jab justice bhi nahi milta.sorry,lekin mujhe koi hope nahi,CBI ki reputation bhi kahan achchi hai,phir aaj kal court bhi bahut jyada interfere karne lagi hai
Her questions are good,but she spoils it all by asking loaded questions,putting words in the guest's mouth.
Police commissioner must resign as a moral responsibilty
Transferred not to CMC but to NMC. Plz correct yourself Barkha
Protecting Brig Bhushan was the cause of downing of BJP in Haryana .A similar cause has arisen now for TMC in Bengal.
Situation very bad in West Bengal.
Every wherein Gundas, Mastan and Jihadis and Rohingas
Leaders are bothered about Their post position and survival of their party by divide and rule,at the cost of people's life and country's progress.All people irrespective of caste creed and religion must unitedly fight against those corrupt leaders. Gruesome incident ,mass protest in Bengal is the eye opener to the entire nation to carry on this moment of public protest till we get justice.
No words at the degree of corruption…. Shocking that this is where governments and police land the citizens. They deserve nothing less than jail.
Politicians and govt officials should not be given so much importance
Bangladesh has to repeat here.
Please untangle this riddle for me: didn't the doctor in question know, as would any individual know, that with hostile people around her, it would be nothing short of suicidal for her to go into a lone, unprotected room, leave the entrance unsecured, and then go to sleep there?
DO NOT WORRY EVERY XCUSE ACCEPTABLE.....?? MAY BE EVERY ONE IS IN HURRY TO CLOSE THE CASE MAY BE YOU HAVE TO FORGET JUSTICE
Initially Bengali were quit when other illegal things were happened in other parts of WB and giving raise to gudas, political party become hand and glow with them, the Bengali masses were quite or mute spectators. Now the tiger has come to thier home now they to face the music.
At the last, people reins shiv bathinda
all these type of malpractise happens in all govt and pvt medical colleges
12:10 Once again Barkha tries to incite speculation as usual, but the doctor knows better, kudos to the doctor. Shame on Barka for inciting speculation and violence
But stone nahi dikh rha
No one likes to live under the damaged house. As well as, under the leadership of people. Law maker should not be a law breaker.
CBI will do nothing.
What kind of governance
Definitely