Another excellent conversation, I'd just started on the Muwatta a few days before this conversation was announced. I will read with more enthusiasm after this.
Literally studying the life of Imam Malik i felt i had no choice but to adopt the Maliki Madhab, the evidence and the ideology of Amal of the people of Madinah and how he actually inherited the practice of the religion and its legal practice was acted upon it completely convinced me
Agree. Also, Imam e Azam (Abu Hanifa رحمة الله) met Imam Malik and he studied from couple of Sahabas directly and lived with Tabaeens including Imam Bakr رحمة الله and Imam Abu Jafar as Sadiq رحمة الله. So Amal e Mutawatir and truth is with these two scholars. I am a Hanafi. Alhamdulillah!
Yes, I do, it was actually the reason why I discovered the Maliki way of understanding the implementation of Islamic jurisprudence, just wanted to know why there were many different positions of the hands in the prayer, I mean the Salaah was practiced daily, but so many different positions, and I was coming from learning Islam according to the current"Salaafi" adaptation of acting solely on Ahadith to perform the salaah, being a revert, you basically learn from a particular book, lavished in praise for being the correct way according to Hadith,
@@richardanthony3267 are you familiar with Safina Society and Shaykh Shadee Elmasry? Worth checking out if you want to study traditional Maliki fiqh texts.
Very beautiful indeed, I feel as if I travelled back in time. I felt the fragrance of the early Muslims epoch. How every aspect of life was moral, spiritual and beautiful.. Thanks for this wonderful, informative lecture
This is such a great talk show. Not dragging at all. Straight to the point. You're amazing, Mr Paul. Alhamdulillah. And all your honourable guests. Please keep it up..always looking forward to your videos. Salam from Penang.
Well, Paul I heard it all. And enjoyed it as always.👍 I heard Bayyina chanel (don't know its proper spellings) Sheikh Salman, a young man I think from USA. That was more in depth, actually all the four imams. Secondly, I would request you to invite Professor Rafique Akhtar. He keeps visiting Europe. Its a treat listening to him. Looking forward to that. Thanks.
That's a very interesting point about what counts as evidence in secular critical scholarship and traditional Islamic scholarship. The Muwatta is a monumental text. I'm glad he delved a bit into the politics of the time as well. May I also humbly request that you consider going through the great narrators of Hadith as well with the sheikh or even the seven fuqaha of Medina? I really enjoy these videos. I always am struck by new things I didn't hear of before.
A nostalgic and inspirational episode to say the least. More than just a Hadith collection , It seems like the Muttawa is a time capsule which allows reader to experience the life of the early generation knowledge seekers. Excellent episode!
33:30 it is also worth remembering that Abu Hurayra RA was among the poor companions and so perhaps that’s why he didn’t want to miss the meal, may Allah be pleased with him. He narrates many stories of his hunger and poverty and I think sometimes we forget what the companions went through in order to deliver this message to us may Allah be pleased with them all.
Thank you Shaykh Hamza for your insights on Imam Malik bin Anas. One of the reasons why Blogging Theology is a must listen is the honest, humble conversations. 49:54 onwards is a must listen to learners, students of knowledge.
His story is just beautiful, and qadarullah.. he actually was the first of 4 imam Madzhab which i learned his life of (from a channel named as Islamic Guidance) His stance to not stating opinions and prefer to say "i don't know" despite a man has to travel far away from his land just to ask for some fatwa regarding Things on behalf of his people , it says a lot of his piety
Jazak Allah, both gentlemen. I learned about the chain of custody from this conversation : a new and important piece of information indeed. I shall be sharing this video with my teenaged children, so they can see the intricate process of the preservation of the Sunnah and the culture of scholarship during the Khair al Qaroon.
Oh Allah Imam Dar Al-Hejra; Imam al-Madinah Te author of AL-Muttaw What a great choice for this great scholar and one of the four major Imams Magnificient Effort
Please don’t forget to look into the Jaferi (Shia itnasheri) madhab & jurisprudence as this has been declared as a valid madhab (by Al-azhar university) along with the hanafi Maliki shafee & hambli
there is also The Sahifa Of Hammam bin Munabbih ( written around the mid-first AH/seventh century.) and The Musannaf of `Abd al-Razzaq al-San`ani (authentic ahadith of the first century AH. )
Al-Dhahabi reported: Ibn Wahb, may Allah have mercy on him, said, “Were it not for Malik and Al-Layth, I would have been ruined. I used to believe that everything narrated about the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, should be acted upon.” Source: Siyar Aʻlām al-Nubalāʼ 8/148 Ibn Wahb reported: Malik, may Allah have mercy on him, said, “Verily, when a man starts praising himself, his honor will disappear.” Source: Tārīkh al-Islām 2731
Who were the teachers ~ I understand Imam Jaffer Sadiq RA (great grandson of the Prophet SAW), who is the same person whose explanation is for the Shia ithnasheri madhab
I am actually pissed off, the Muwatta has been pushed to the side, very disrespectful! I'm just now learning about all these things this past few days about Imam Malik.
Imam Malik bin Anas was not a Maturidi, a Sufi, or a Shiite, but rather a Salafist in the faith Imam Malik expelled someone who was asking the same questions and philosophy as the Ash'aris
Excellent presentation, except for the introduction, which needs to be more accurate. AFAIK the schools of Mu'tazilah, Syi'ah, Murji'ah, Khawarij, Maliki, Hanafi, Syafi'i, Hambali, etc., were invented far after that time.
As you mentioned earlier in your post , why there are no historical criticism on Islam , like we have on Septuagint ? 🤘 I did ,,, for few days from your post , through comments. 🤭 The Quibla for Islam ( Sunni & Sufi ) mentioned in Qur'an , Paul. And not from Mecca like Post Modern Muslims today believes. 🤭 Read Qs. Al-Baqarah 125 & Qs. Al-Hajj 27. Read it and use your logical understanding. Reads all the tafseer & use your personal interpretation , til you found the answer. The correct answer , Paul. Post modern muslims never READ Qur'an. Don't relied on them , too much. They are CHIMPS like the majority Christians who never READ their own Gospels. 🤭 Post Modern Muslims never READ like their FALSE PROPHET , The Conman - JC who changed the name to Nabi ﷺ and claimed born in Arabian Peninsula , 14 centuries ago. 🤭 Last , Do you know the 1st word from Malaika Jibreel عليه السلام when teach JC at HIRA's cave , Paul ? تقراء What did JC replied ? I CAN'T READ IT. Like post modern muslims today, Paul ,,, am i right ? Once you follow the False Prophet like Post Modern Muslims today, you will end up like them. ruclips.net/video/wCkerYMffMo/видео.html ☠️MERRY CHRISTMAS☠️
These two gentlemen are chained to a holy book they believe is the inspired words of a barbaric Hebrew god named Yahweh they have never seen but only believed - using the shared power of their own imaginations.
Not a very impressive presentation by Hamza Karmali. Hesitant and broken chain of thought. Also very troubling was the use of English names for the Arabic and original names like using Caliph instead of Khalifah and Gabriel instead of Jibrael. Overall very disappointed.
Either Islam is true or evolution is true. We know evolution is irrefutable. We have irrefutable evidence of evolution. Paleontology, anthropology, biology, geology. genealogy and archeology all agree. You have a book written by a man who claims an angel spoke to him in a cave.
Islam doesn't have anything against Micro evolution. But only problem with macro evolution. And science doesn't have enough evidence to back macro evolution.
For god sake man don't go into details.even for a smart guy like you books worm you will got confused and mis guided not to mention that you confuse your audience too.
I learnt alot from your videos. May Allah reward you.
Than you Brother Paul for your amazing channel.
Many thanks M. Farih!
Great episode ماشاءالله
Another excellent conversation,
I'd just started on the Muwatta a few days before this conversation was announced. I will read with more enthusiasm after this.
Fantastic!
@@BloggingTheology
Time to get Shaykh Hamzah Maqbul al-Maliki on BT 👌🏾
Literally studying the life of Imam Malik i felt i had no choice but to adopt the Maliki Madhab, the evidence and the ideology of Amal of the people of Madinah and how he actually inherited the practice of the religion and its legal practice was acted upon it completely convinced me
Agree. Also, Imam e Azam (Abu Hanifa رحمة الله) met Imam Malik and he studied from couple of Sahabas directly and lived with Tabaeens including Imam Bakr رحمة الله and Imam Abu Jafar as Sadiq رحمة الله. So Amal e Mutawatir and truth is with these two scholars. I am a Hanafi. Alhamdulillah!
Do u put your hands on your side in prayer?
Yes, I do, it was actually the reason why I discovered the Maliki way of understanding the implementation of Islamic jurisprudence, just wanted to know why there were many different positions of the hands in the prayer, I mean the Salaah was practiced daily, but so many different positions, and I was coming from learning Islam according to the current"Salaafi" adaptation of acting solely on Ahadith to perform the salaah, being a revert, you basically learn from a particular book, lavished in praise for being the correct way according to Hadith,
The virtue of his Madzhab and view is that he exclusively set it based on the people of Medina
@@richardanthony3267 are you familiar with Safina Society and Shaykh Shadee Elmasry? Worth checking out if you want to study traditional Maliki fiqh texts.
What an amazing interview. Thank you so much Professor Karamali.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Great video Paul
Great video! The role of Umar Ibn Abdalaziz in the preservation of Hadith is significant as well.
masha'Allah
Many thanks for the amazing learning experience with all your great guests , Jazak Allah khair and bless your efforts 👌
Very beautiful indeed, I feel as if I travelled back in time. I felt the fragrance of the early Muslims epoch. How every aspect of life was moral, spiritual and beautiful.. Thanks for this wonderful, informative lecture
Great video!
This is such a great talk show. Not dragging at all. Straight to the point. You're amazing, Mr Paul. Alhamdulillah. And all your honourable guests. Please keep it up..always looking forward to your videos. Salam from Penang.
Well, Paul I heard it all. And enjoyed it as always.👍
I heard Bayyina chanel (don't know its proper spellings) Sheikh Salman, a young man I think from USA. That was more in depth, actually all the four imams.
Secondly, I would request you to invite Professor Rafique Akhtar. He keeps visiting Europe. Its a treat listening to him. Looking forward to that.
Thanks.
That's a very interesting point about what counts as evidence in secular critical scholarship and traditional Islamic scholarship.
The Muwatta is a monumental text. I'm glad he delved a bit into the politics of the time as well. May I also humbly request that you consider going through the great narrators of Hadith as well with the sheikh or even the seven fuqaha of Medina? I really enjoy these videos. I always am struck by new things I didn't hear of before.
Thank you both
A nostalgic and inspirational episode to say the least. More than just a Hadith collection , It seems like the Muttawa is a time capsule which allows reader to experience the life of the early generation knowledge seekers.
Excellent episode!
Really great and beneficial interview. Amazing to have an insight into isnads' details. Fantastic analogy of isnad to the chain of custody.
Imam Malik, the Star 🌟 for all the Imams and Shaykhs.
That was...........FASCINATING!!!!!
33:30 it is also worth remembering that Abu Hurayra RA was among the poor companions and so perhaps that’s why he didn’t want to miss the meal, may Allah be pleased with him. He narrates many stories of his hunger and poverty and I think sometimes we forget what the companions went through in order to deliver this message to us may Allah be pleased with them all.
Great work 💞💞
thx for this 1. allahyhafdek
Thank you Shaykh Hamza for your insights on Imam Malik bin Anas.
One of the reasons why Blogging Theology is a must listen is the honest, humble conversations. 49:54 onwards is a must listen to learners, students of knowledge.
His story is just beautiful, and qadarullah.. he actually was the first of 4 imam Madzhab which i learned his life of (from a channel named as Islamic Guidance)
His stance to not stating opinions and prefer to say "i don't know" despite a man has to travel far away from his land just to ask for some fatwa regarding Things on behalf of his people , it says a lot of his piety
Proud Maliki 🙋♂️
As I’m Moroccan and Moroccan are following Imam Malik
Jazak Allah, both gentlemen. I learned about the chain of custody from this conversation : a new and important piece of information indeed. I shall be sharing this video with my teenaged children, so they can see the intricate process of the preservation of the Sunnah and the culture of scholarship during the Khair al Qaroon.
MashAllah
Thanks
Thank you Shafee!
Thanks for your contribution. Perhaps consider walking us through Jaafar As Saadiq’s life and legacy
THANKYOU SIR.
Oh Allah
Imam Dar Al-Hejra; Imam al-Madinah
Te author of AL-Muttaw
What a great choice for this great scholar and one of the four major Imams
Magnificient Effort
Jazakallahu khairan
Your final question was interesting.
I would like to see this explored more
Please don’t forget to look into the Jaferi (Shia itnasheri) madhab & jurisprudence as this has been declared as a valid madhab (by Al-azhar university) along with the hanafi Maliki shafee & hambli
too bad you missed ‘La Adri’ Paul.
‘La Adri’ = ‘I dont know’, Imam Malik most famous phrase ❤
But maybe next time 😊
there is also The Sahifa Of Hammam bin Munabbih ( written around the mid-first AH/seventh century.)
and
The Musannaf of `Abd al-Razzaq al-San`ani (authentic ahadith of the first century AH. )
Al-Dhahabi reported: Ibn Wahb, may Allah have mercy on him, said, “Were it not for Malik and Al-Layth, I would have been ruined. I used to believe that everything narrated about the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, should be acted upon.”
Source: Siyar Aʻlām al-Nubalāʼ 8/148
Ibn Wahb reported: Malik, may Allah have mercy on him, said, “Verily, when a man starts praising himself, his honor will disappear.”
Source: Tārīkh al-Islām 2731
Who were the teachers ~ I understand Imam Jaffer Sadiq RA (great grandson of the Prophet SAW), who is the same person whose explanation is for the Shia ithnasheri madhab
Paul sir please do invite schlors from Al Azhar University Egypt.
I am actually pissed off, the Muwatta has been pushed to the side, very disrespectful! I'm just now learning about all these things this past few days about Imam Malik.
Zubair is also cousin of the prophet saws
Imam Malik bin Anas was not a Maturidi, a Sufi, or a Shiite, but rather a Salafist in the faith
Imam Malik expelled someone who was asking the same questions and philosophy as the Ash'aris
Man these lady of heaven ads in RUclips sucks.
Is it true that imam Malik was an albino?
Many scholar considered Umar Abdul Aziz as the fifth Khalifah al-Rashidin.
Excellent presentation, except for the introduction, which needs to be more accurate. AFAIK the schools of Mu'tazilah, Syi'ah, Murji'ah, Khawarij, Maliki, Hanafi, Syafi'i, Hambali, etc., were invented far after that time.
As you mentioned earlier in your post , why there are no historical criticism on Islam , like we have on Septuagint ?
🤘
I did ,,, for few days from your post , through comments.
🤭
The Quibla for Islam ( Sunni & Sufi ) mentioned in Qur'an , Paul.
And not from Mecca like Post Modern Muslims today believes.
🤭
Read Qs. Al-Baqarah 125 & Qs. Al-Hajj 27.
Read it and use your logical understanding.
Reads all the tafseer & use your personal interpretation , til you found the answer.
The correct answer , Paul.
Post modern muslims never READ Qur'an.
Don't relied on them , too much.
They are CHIMPS like
the majority Christians who never READ their own Gospels.
🤭
Post Modern Muslims never READ like their FALSE PROPHET , The Conman - JC who changed the name to Nabi ﷺ and claimed born in Arabian Peninsula , 14 centuries ago.
🤭
Last ,
Do you know the 1st word from Malaika Jibreel عليه السلام when teach JC at HIRA's cave , Paul ?
تقراء
What did JC replied ?
I CAN'T READ IT.
Like post modern muslims today, Paul ,,, am i right ?
Once you follow the False Prophet like Post Modern Muslims today, you will end up like them.
ruclips.net/video/wCkerYMffMo/видео.html
☠️MERRY CHRISTMAS☠️
koen iku ngisin-ngisini ae, posting koyok ngene
Make one good argument what on earth is this strawman. You can’t even put a sentence of English together
@@muhammadsanjaya80 biasa orang jahil bang
i lost it at تقراء lol. you butchered our language very well
These two gentlemen are chained to a holy book they believe is the inspired words of a barbaric Hebrew god named Yahweh they have never seen but only believed - using the shared power of their own imaginations.
better than 'believing' men were monkeys without 'seeing' actual evidence of it right ?
Not a very impressive presentation by Hamza Karmali. Hesitant and broken chain of thought. Also very troubling was the use of English names for the Arabic and original names like using Caliph instead of Khalifah and Gabriel instead of Jibrael. Overall very disappointed.
I thought it was well spoken and very informative
Either Islam is true or evolution is true. We know evolution is irrefutable. We have irrefutable evidence of evolution. Paleontology, anthropology, biology, geology. genealogy and archeology all agree. You have a book written by a man who claims an angel spoke to him in a cave.
Read the book and see for yourself . Your enemy is ignorance .
@@elalabensaad2748 and your enemy is indoctrination. Read a science book.
What does geology have to do with evolution?
Islam doesn't have anything against Micro evolution. But only problem with macro evolution. And science doesn't have enough evidence to back macro evolution.
@@laputa4825 geology is how they determine the age of fossils, by aging the layer of sediment the fossils were found in.
For god sake man don't go into details.even for a smart guy like you books worm you will got confused and mis guided not to mention that you confuse your audience too.
Thanks