American Idol Season 2 Finalists Elimination My Way

[@graysonthomas1433]

My rankings:
12) Carmen
11) Charles
10) Corey
9) Julia
8) Rickey
7) Vanessa
6) Kimberly C
5) Josh
4) Kimberley L
3) Ruben
2) Trenyce
1) Clay

[@Geffreu]

Someone with sense about Trenyce and Clay’s placements! Definitely the top 2 vocally.

[@machoman1016]

My rankings
12) Carmen
11)Julia
10)Corey
9)Charles
8)Vanessa
7)Kim C.
6)Josh
5)Rickey
4)Trenyce
3)Kim L.
2)Ruben
1)Clay
100% agreed with the top 7 placement.

[@sauloferreira3027]

This is the correct order!

[@rdhaley96]

12. Corey
11. Julia
10. Charles
09. Carmen
08. Vanessa
07. Rickey
06. Josh
05. Kim C.
04. Trenyce
03. Kim L.
02. Ruben
01. Clay

[@azzz7279]

R.I.P Rickey Smith

[@celebrityqueen713]

12.Corey
11.Carmen
10.Charles
9.Julia
8.Vanessa
7.Kim C
6.Josh
5.Rickey
4.Trenyce
3.Ruben
2.Kim L
1.Clay

[@lateramae]

Did you hear that there was complete silence when Carmen was eliminated? Like no one cared. I kinda felt bad for her.

[@machoman1016]

At least they weren't cheering like with Sanjaya's elimination (though I would like to believe the cheers were more for Lakisha being safe).

[@mathewk6026]

@@machoman1016I kinda wish Sanjaya made it further. I wasn’t big on Lakisha’s voice. I would’ve been fine if Sanjaya made top 4