Eye-for-an-eye sharia justice returns to Afghan courts | AFP
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 янв 2023
- At the Ghazni Court of Appeal in eastern Afghanistan, an old man sentenced to death for murder pleads for his life. The 75-year-old admits to having killed a relative. Under the strict interpretation of Islamic sharia law ordered by the Taliban's supreme leader, he faces public execution -- with the sentence carried out by a relative of his victim. AFP had rare access to a court in Ghazni to see how sharia justice is being administered since the Taliban returned to power in August 2021.
Interested in licensing this video ? Get in touch 👉 u.afp.com/wvnD
N.B.: AFP’s services and content are for professional use only
I garuntee they have the lowest crime rate in the world despite thier economic situation
You couldn't be more wrong
You are right.
@@mimmiekgaditse1517it is actually safe
It‘s now some of the most safest countries
Yes. You are right. In fact, the inner cities of the US are the world's safest places. Because here if you murder, kill, rape, rob, you are automatically "mentally ill" and sent to rehabilitation. LOL!@@mimmiekgaditse1517
Why extreme Sharia laws? Should it be the justice system like the West where rapists and murderers get bailed because of the corrupt system?
"bail" is an american thing not western
Yes , if you got money and better lawyer. You can leave the case innocent and free from any punishment.
Who ensures that the judges aren't being bribed in Afg? One of the qazis demanded young boys for him to pleasure in exchange for swinging his judgement in favour of one party.
In europe - kill your enemy, go to jail for 5-10 years, now you are free and you can mock the victim's family
Its not a strict system. Its a fair system. Ask the relatives of the wronged if it is strict.
It's a low-IQ system run by barbarians with the brains of children. It's not a coincidence that the most successful countries in the world have the most liberal policies.
In England..a child killer can be out of prison in 10 yrs.and we are civilised.....apparently.
This is the only way you can remove rape case 100% from the society.
Muhammad was some sort of a rapist
@@enigmaticphantom8389can you elaborate
@@enigmaticphantom8389how ?
@@gamekid2420the rapist is punished by death
The rapist were not only punish to death but also hanged with cranes and they took their bodies and show to all Afghanis if they commit rape that would happen. Just check 2 months ago the 3 men rape against a girl.
Finally, a justice system that actually lives up to the world justice. Where I live, it's not what is right, but what you can prove. Shameful.
I dont get it.
Dont u have to prove something before justice can be done?
@@theallseeingeye9388why do we have to assume that they dnt consider that. Unlike secular law where men are charged without evidence.
You mean when you have money justice will always on your side....
Sharia actually has strict requirements for providing acceptable proof as well. It is more direct. The punishments are severe and fast-tracked/immediate relative to Western ones. However, mercy is heavily emphasized on the part of all those involved, apart from the judges who must dispense the ruling of the law once a matter is set before them, they only consider the facts. There's no concept of going past a few days or weeks at the latest.
@@MODEST500and gays are given rights 😂
As if France has 100% pure Judiciary.
"cuties" for everyone 😂
Hhhhhhhh
Go back to your Islamic countries then
Get lost
@@MODEST500 little too old for their prophet.
@@SonOfMorningyes because you prefer sodmozing boys instead since your lgbt as what the Talmud demands
Taliban police don’t drag women into the streets half naked though
😂😂😂😂😂 they also dnt make movies for ped©s. Aka cuties .
Who does??
Media try to portrait them as barbaric 😂. But, listen to what they’ve said.
Look at them. They’re so serious to uphold the justice as best as they can, through the guidance and the wisdom of the one true God
2 years ago the top ten in corruption and now no corruption.
Amazing.
And why?
Rule of the laws of Allah, may Allah cause is to be implemented
Because they told you so😂😂😂
Eye for an eye should be the law.
The moral high ground of forgiving should be the exclusive right of the aggrieved party, no president or prime minister or king should have right to pardon a criminal
Why there are questions against Islamic Shariya laws?? Same laws are in Tora and Bible. Punishment is necessary to keep the society in order. Take an example of Pakistan where there is no punishment, no justice and therefore rate of corruption is the highest.
Corruption and crime, both are increasing minute by minute.
Do you think western Christians follow the old testament rules for punishment and "justice"?
They don't. The archaic views of both Christianity and Islam are no longer compatible with society as a whole.
When your women are treated with the same rights as a man enjoys, then you can preach about justice. Until then, you Muslims will still be backwards savages as far as the world's concerned.
the US is pretty corrupt and leans towards forgiving whites. there is no social order.
May this system be implemented in all Muslim countries.Ameen
May your wish be met and may you live in those systems.
@@Joe_2347
I’m a muslim “woman” living in a muslim Arab country
I, and many many of my female friends, WISH to Allah our country implements Sharia Law, a-lot of the problems we face as Arab women would be solved in a minute.
If only!
Aameen ❤
امين
Ameen
Lovely System. in Italy, migrants are forced as free labour for as low as 7 years, in Portugal and all parts of Europe, migrant workers are expoited.... we need a system like these barefooted people has
Come to Taliban
I thought only Emirati countries exploit their migrant workers not Europeans.
They're not barefoot
then dont go there go to afghanistan
@@ajmaeenmahtab8456The difference IS in Europa they have rights. They dont know Them so they are exploited.
For the readers of this comment, I'd like to clarify a few things:
- Sharia law assumes people are innocent until proven guilty by clear evidence or overwhelming testimony. The Islamic Sharia laws are fairly easy to understand, and therefore no lawyer is often needed. Lawyers are a "right" in Western societies because your laws, court systems, and justice officials are laced with corruption and contrived complexity.
- Sharia court proceedings are quick and decisive to minimize anguish over looming sentences. In the United States, prisoners can be kept on death row for decades, in the perpetual anguish between life and death.
What shameful narration and choice of words. Shame on your, for misrepresenting these people's wishes, desires, religion and tradition. Shame on you for expending no effort to understand the reason why these people believe what they believe and do what they do. You display clips of judges explaining their viewpoints, and immediately criticize them with no basis, nor respect for the culture in which, and for which, they operate. As long as biased media outlets such as yours exist, people and communities across the globe will fail to recognize,, understand, and ultimately respect each other.
There is not a single more just system then sharia law. A system with the lowest crime rates.
The French believe the woman should be more naked.
@@spotonnls3538 that is a false hadith made by the enemies of the prophet Mohammad pbuh. Pedophilia is haraum. One hadith says 19 years old the ohter one says 9 the ohter says 6 and so on. It’s all made up. And we see the shias cursing ummul momineen Aisha (RA) so it’s clear who the people were who fabricated these narrations.
@@spotonnls3538punishment which will be for ram marrying sita in 6 year age and destroy his life
@@spotonnls3538Muhammad PBUH respected the younger wife and cared,he had given great respect and rights to women that anyone can ever gave
Better then the western rotten system.
Rather "laws based on Quran and sunna are perfect in all sense...
That's why so many Islamic "refugees" flee to the "western rotten system," yes? 🤡
It's based on a rumour
@@tradhesivethey actually are. Islam is all about Justice
@@asharahmad1068yeah sure 😂
In America we have been taught to see the Taliban as heartless wild eyed fanatics, but I just see people with a different world view. Their is good and bad in any system.
But their no bad in Islamic system.
That is because you are Muslim,,,I presume. You see it as God's word. As a Christian I view it objectively and draw my own conclusions. Not to argue the point or anything. I believe the same about Christianity as you do Islam. 🙂
@@kennethshaheenjr.1164 I understand
@@taichi258😂😂😂
@@kennethshaheenjr.1164 you know, you would make for a good Muslim. You're in the wrong religion :). Islam is the religion for rational people like yourself.
Its not about human rights its how exactly what islam says,i wish for the same justice system in every muslim country
Please see this question only as a querry of a non Muslim not in an insultive way.
1. Are non muslims allowed to build their place of worship and practice their religion in shariya?? ( Zakir Naik said no)
2. Can a guy leave islam and still live in a shariya country?? ( Muslim scholars have prescribed death to apostate))
@@anubhavgangwar1383yes for both
Zakir naik only said muslims can’t donate for non muslim houses of worship..
The apostasy thing is when the person commits treason.. historically whenever a person changed his religion he also joined opposite side in war and committed treason.. for that is death penalty
@@albabkabir soory but u need to see the video again. Zakir clearly said that non muslims should not be allowed to have places of worship in shariya countries but non muslims countries should build mosque. The statement sounds hypocritical.
And regarding apostasy he said that any person who changes religion should be killed. Either he commit treason or not. He even quoted a hadeeth in defence of his statement.
@@anubhavgangwar1383 bro there are thousands of churches and synagogues in the muslim countries…. Non muslims can practice their religion freely in an islamic state
Regarding apostasy, i just explained it the hadith which you are talking about is related to treason.. any person historically changing his religion also changed his alliance and thus committed treason… simple as that
Excellent 👌
Well done Taliban
Your poor public can sleep with calm and peace
i dont like the Taliban but even americans sentence murderers to death so wats the big deal wen the talibanis do it explain it to me
Best legal system in world i wish to be a citizen under islamic sharia.
Go live there then
@@ArthurShelby481 we would like to, but unfortunately you destroyed this beautiful nation with your bombs and your soldiers, yet you no longer really hide from saying that you have trashed this nation
@@ArthurShelby481criminal
@@Merguez40006Excuses. Broken buildings can be fixed. The state of your society is a result of your decisions.
@@ArthurShelby481 I talked to their embassy in my country. There's no immigration Visa.
This is the best justice system and deep down in there hearts everyone knows it
If you honestly and mercifully apply laws of Quran no other or secular system is of any consideration.
Islam is not as you think. no sharia. only sex. you will need women to save your life.
no alcohol. but many times powerful intoxicants.
Move into Afghanistan fast. Don’t delay
then please move to Afghanistan as soon as possible 😂
Move there , fast.
When are you moving to Afghanistan or KSA?
The difference between English Common Law and Shariah with respect to retributive justice is that under English Common Law a person found guilty of first degree murder has to be punished by state or forgiven by state. Under the Shariah as applied in Pakistan a person guilty of first degree murder has to be punished by state or he can also be forgiven by the legal heirs or deceased or matter can also be compromised with punishment of Diyat blood money, in Shariah applied by Taliban in Afghanistan the Taliban give an option to the legal heirs of the deceased to actually execute the guilty person under supervision or compromise or for give.
Since 1800 we have been following in Pakistan English Common Law and since 1980s same has been coupled with Shariah and since introduction of Shariah there has been only one dacoit and murderer Mr. TAHIR Khan who was forgiven by mr. General Pervez Musharaf as President of Pakistan to please Mr. Tony Blair. If the narrator is talking about retributive justice to be an extreme form of Shariah than she is mistaken same doctrines exist in English Common Law, American Civil Law, Russian Criminal Code and Chinese Criminal Code. So BBC should get mature when reporting on Shariah.
That’s why Pakistan and Afghanistan are international pariahs
BBC never will - the hatred of Islam is too strong - thanks for explaining to other people who actually care about truth
@@user-MissKhan80you can show off your emotion to everyone. But facts are facts.
Eye for an eye
Is the best justice system
Who could have guessed that strict punishments lead to less crime?
We need this justice system
In the American justice system, a mass murderer of seventeen students and wounding seventeen. The murderer was sentenced to life imprisonment. One Muslim lawyer agreed to the life imprisonment sentence to appease the unjust ruling. The parents of the murdered students and teacher have to be traumatized for the rest of their natural life. add insult to injury one of his defense team was laughing with the mass murderer.
that's plain white culture. its in their blood.
What will killing that murderer achieve? Bring the kids back to life?
@@aravindsureshthakidayilit will surely send a message in the mind of the corrupt that he will lose his life if he did such
Same is the case for rapists.
If proven, he's unalived under sharia. So the one who has such disease in his heart would think twice before committing such
@@aravindsureshthakidayil
He will not kill second time .. snd it will send a massenge
@@aravindsureshthakidayilIndia...😂 bilang saja kamu membenci Islam...🤣 salam dari Indonesia 🇮🇩
This is what America needs
Love Taliban and love the perfect Sharia laws...❤
Very fair system. Where justice actually prevails. If you look at this court system, compared the western secular system, this one is much fairer and punishments are actually given.
When you have the PERFECT justice system, then you can CRITICISE others,,,
This is the law of Allah ❤
This is the law of Mullahs from the Jewish Bible/Torah !
@@salmanhyder1655kafir
mou ham mad's alah, the butcher doesn't have anything on satan...same, same
@@simsfish8728 why you wear a profil picture of a church in turkey ,aMuslim country ?
Ironic
I can not understand why westren media is interfaring their laws and affairs?after such a bad defeat they did not feel shy to come there
That is way Afghanistan now the safest cauntry in world
It's not, but soon it will be.
Perfect. 400k "refugees" in Germany can return to their own land soon and help rebuild it along with the Taliban
@@Knight_riderxyzbecause of the foreign interference
@@Magicallstore what do you mean?
@@Knight_riderxyz problems and criminality are the results of usa and other countries fighting in Afghanistan
Allah swt wants majority sleep with their doors open , kids enjoy their childhood in parks on streets without fear by this law , an eye for an eye . Its also in Torah , Bible and off course Quran which is labeled only for shria law . Few hands chopped is mercy of Allah swt for mankind rather then 900 billion dollars prision and criminal justice system still people live in fear and children's are not saved .
masha allaah
good job
quran best constitution for all mankind.
Why us muslim women can't have 4 husbands at the same time
@@happybunny6152 If she will deliver a baby who will b the father.
Sharia is most justice and effective and preventive system. No bulshit like other systems.
😂😂
@@klaiblond8291it's TRUE Clown
@@mouademalki680 yeaaah, of course it is 😂 just be careful to not get stoned!
Allah Pakistan mei b aisi courts qaim ho jaein
I am from india
عافیت و خیریت کے ساتھ، آمین
All countries should make Shariat applicable to every Muslim citizen of theirs, and to Muslims only, who will be happy with Shariat and the rest with the prevailing law of the country.
Wt if criminal is from non Muslim background and victim from muslims
Application of Sharia of Allah is the best
@@Informedmuslim000Law of the land prevails. Non muslims have the same right,, unlike India and ISrael.
West should not interfere on what they want for their own culture.
So what law was George Bush and Tony Blair applying when they invaded Afghanistan, "looking for those responsible for 9/11 to extract justice"?
Most required justice system.
Where did your "Human rights" groups go when the most philanthropist US and its Allies invaded Iraq and Afghanistan.
great system
How the law in Afghanistan is conducted is up to the Afghanis Can you imagine that some American women are allowed to kill their unborn babies?
Such corrupt and misleading translation.
the lowest crime rate in world now in afghan
Well there’s definitely nothing of value to steal. Everyone is poor AF.
@@lestercombs1871crime is more prevalent among poor people not the rich
As long as you are not scared of laws u vll continue to commit .
Not for long under these rules. Steal? No arm. Kill? No life. Rape? No life.
"Eye for an Eye" is a Jewish rule... Under Islamic rule victim can deman "eye for an eye" but pardon is most preferable
TALIBAN will succeeded to reduce the crime rate in their society..... they have good Law and judiciary
Very good...work
I respect this
What kind of trial dod they hive the accused?
75 years old ! Good to go
😂not yet. One victim family forgive him. If that’s confirm , that penal law can not be carry😂😂😂.
That’s why lowest crime rates in Afghanistan
I wish if i could live under Shariah Law.❤
For me the system in any and all countries must be "Tooth for an eye. Eye for a head". 😂
Eye for an eye thats legal for me
Allah hu Ackbar
I as muslim support their rule eye for an eye but not with women education they have to allow women education in university because without women society is incomplete doctor's teacher they have to allow women education sorry for my bad English from Iran 🇮🇷
No free-mixing between unmarried men and women. You can't claim to be a Muslim and advocate Western-style debauchery. We all can see how the West is degenerate and there is no family life there anymore. Every girl is a wh0re in the West starting in middle school.
Don't you see the current state of the world because of women? Men are being deprived in every country of the world in the name of women's freedom. Even to give freedom to women now in India there is such a law that if a wife commits peekia then the husband can stop it.
The most important thing is a hadith of our prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam where he said Satan will use women as proxies. And most women will go to hell.
they will allow soon as they are re-constructing the education system.
Stop apologising for that. It's not a crime to make mistakes in writing English
What do you mean by education? Going to schools, getting a degree and job and enjoying free liberated promiscuous life without marriage?
Even without formal education, Muslim women are more educated than any other women. They know the Islamic values and train and discipline the kids to be good Muslims.
Justice is most important factor to get rid of many problems, in our society now justice a joke for poor.
At least these people ready to provide justice for all and punishment for the criminals.
I wish that justice serve to Americans for destroying poor countries
Once a man was up in a tree plucking fruit when he slipped and fell to the ground. He fell on an An unfortunate bystander who was killed by the impact of the fall. The wife of the man who died demanded the dead penalty for the tree climber under the AN EYE FOR AN EYE CODE OF JUSTICE. The judge tried to reason with the widow that he had not intentionally murdered her husband and that it was an accident. But the lady was stubborn and demanded the tree climber’s death as was her right under muslim law. The judge thought long and hard and then gave his verdict. He sentenced the tree climber to death but he could only be killed in the same way that he had killed the widow’s husband. The only way he could be put to death was by the widow climbing up the same tree and falling on him just as he had slipped and fallen and killed the other man. Needless to say that the man was set free when the widow was unable to comply.
Every description and explanation is wrong - but that's what happens when there is an agenda. Qisas does not mean 'eye for an eye' but you know that already!!
Lol. All those holy books and prayers, people will just start bribing the judges with money or women 😂
Extreme thats vadic qidas
Great rule of law ❤❤❤
why 75 year need lawyer he killed man on allegations for having sex with his daughter in law
where is proof she had sex
even she had sex who is he to shoot
and now he ask lawyer for what?
what lawyer will do change the verdict as they always do in western system
when law is sold in public what justic we will get
Damn. Straight up biblical shit going on here.
Enjoy your wife cheating and the taking half your stuff then 🤷♂️and go watch the 100s of poeple who are in prison wrongly. ..
Not Biblical. Much less severe - Quranic.
use respective words when talking about a way of life of billions. and it's Quranic
Europe has an insane history and present This is nothing compared to it turn your head around and stfu
@@rashid8646 ahh actually all the books, talmud, bible (Leviticus) and quran have the eye for an eye concept. Can't quote the exact verses from talmud or Quran tho since I'm not a Jew or Moslem.
Sharia should be applied on every muslim men... irrespective of the country they belong to..
Ellhamdullilah here comes Justice to world
Its fair justice system ❤
Well done something saudi has too and china and russia. Capital punishments
The word extreme should not be there. Taliban is upholding Justice.
Justice
If this is implemented in for muslims living in Bharat 🇮🇳 the crime rate would become zero in Bharat
Can u elaborate?
Mashallah
سبحان اللہ
❤❤❤ sharia law from 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Have you noticed how people only take the bit that matters to there course, a eye for a eye a tooth for a tooth achieves nothing I asked the speaker at my church to finish the saying and he went blank infront of the congregation.
I pray to Allah that he gives justice to the people hoping this government will gone forever hoping my god Allah give them what they deserve
This is a fair system. What are you trying to prove to us
Zindabad Afanistan Zindabad 😅😊😂
Well what you suggest for an eye?
A two three years or perhaps more, of trial, a lawyer, a court and then what in the end?
One month or let say a year, of jail for an eye?
I wont want this for my eye...
Simple but effective
Rare Sharia W
Free the old man. He did the right thing
He was protecting the holiest of holies 😢
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Long Live Afghanistan
Biased and low level documentary about the true justice system where quick justice is available. Islamic justice system is very natural and universal and doesn't allow any wrong means to flourish.
The Taliban executes a murderer and its "widely condemned by human rights groups and foreign governments, yet tons of countries like the US also have the death penalty and it's fine? Am I missing something or is there really that much of a double standard?
Islam Solutions to all the problems of the world ❤
Imagen the stench in that room!
France has plenty of laws and many constitutions, it hasn't stopped their decline, has it? The truth is that laws are preceded by the people who have internalized their morals, the laws merely being an after-the-fact documentation of the sensus populum. This is why you can have French laws in places where people are not French, and those laws will just collect dust as people in power select what laws are convenient to enforce; and in France having people step on its magical dirt won't make them suddenly secular and fearful of French laws.
Pity the women in this God forsaken country.
Quran best system
stone age law for stone age people.
Killing innocent civilians by west is not condemned ? Why IRAQ