Who Sang The Legendary "Lovin' You" WHISTLE The Best?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 сен 2017
- Watch the other videos of the original series "Who Sang It Best?" here: ► • Who Sang It The Best?
Follow me on my social media accounts!:
► Twitter: bit.ly/2Cy2QFJ
► Instagram: bit.ly/3zBx2v7
► TikTok: bit.ly/3A9BLWd
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
edited by me with the software Sony Vegas 18.0
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#vocals #singer #highnotes 
Видеоклипы
Minnie's version is so sweet and chill. She wrote the song with her husband and they seemed so so in love. She doesn't go all crazy and doesn't applaud herself for it. She just goes on singing the rest of the song. Best hands down.
Agree
Right? These people are like trying to achieve something. That's the crappy part. Minnie's was the only real one.
Yep that one by the d twinz was horrible
she actually wrote it for her daughter
@@tina-jt7pj www.songfacts.com/facts/minnie-riperton/lovin-you
1:21 Chante shut the game down. She sung the whole verse in whistle. Game over. Thank the rest of you for coming.
Yobachi2007 Chante you stay!
Yobachi2007 RIGHT?
Dmitri Alcantara I’m crying at this comment, oh my gosh. 😂
It's true . Most of these aren't even whistles. Just falsettos
Yobachi2007 she won
A lot of these are an example of just because you can hit the note doesn’t mean you should.
Exactly.
Yes
If l had to choose, l would say Shanice Wilson was the best out of all, but she isn't better than Minnie. In my opinion, Minnie is still the best and will forever be.
😄
@@josephclegg3562 yeah Shanice and Chante Moore did the best out of the others and they both were back up singers together on a bunch of laface songs but Minnie is the best of all time! All time!🤷🏽♀️😀
Minnie will always take the crown. Her voice was so light and sweet, like a bird.
Not to mention it's Minnie's song, so I agree she was the best, hands down!
3:37 she thought she slayed...
Ikr it's awful btw we have the same username lol
beebo's forehead omg 😂
@@beebosforehead9869 the singing makes me low-key kinda make me vomit
beebos forehead 😂😂😂😂
It was horrific, which makes her arrogance all the more hilarious
The pair of black girls singing lmao when the afro one started doing weirdass extra runs the other girl was judging so hard
Hanting Chen
She be like “ sis don’t hog the spotlight... this is a team effort..’’
The side eye at 1:05 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hanting Chen and they didn’t even do a whistle. That’s a high head voice. It’s a way to “fake” a whistle. It’s common for people who can’t do it.
@@blairwoods Well, it was an octave (possibly more, if their whole version was lowered) lower than the original, no matter what register it was done in.
Kaitlyn Guthre Bruh nobody thought that it was a whistle. If anything people would think it’s falsetto.
4:27 the dancers are killing me 💀 .
if they kill you you should watch a compilation of dua lipa dancing😭
Lol 🤣🤣
They dance like they are butterflies or trees
@@sryzzle6465 For real, I'm pretty sure she was doing a dance just like this 🤣
Mariah’s backup dancers from 2009 are just like them lmao
Nobody is gonna talk about Chante Moore really sounds like a bird chirping in the trees. I love it
I love her and Jane Zhang's version.
I over loved Chante's bold take on it....she shut it down
Right!?
Whistle note is chante Moore she killed it
3:24 OMFG I WAS HOWLING HAHA
Are you a wolf? Jk I was howling too😂
Ya'll, I was yodeling
so was she
Alyssa Mendiola BAHAHAHAH
lmfaooo sameeee
*you mean who sang it best... "BESIDES" Minnie right???? is this question even for real...*
Ofc
🤦 obviously that's what was meant...
Ong
I know right! Who would ask such a question as that? Ain't nobody besides Minnie who could sang it best. Nobody can sing it best, but the original artist.
@@josephclegg3562 right that question was a big joke only the original can do it effortlessly most of the singers they featured in this video was only doing falsetto and not whistle
Can't believe I just watched 10:56 minutes of "Lalalalala"...
But, THEY WERE GREAT!!
you're funny wth 😂
Kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk lalalalala
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I dont care how they sound. Minnie is still the master of this song.
lol, me too.. but i thought they would sing some part of the song, i didn't see the "hustle" in the title of the video.
WHAT is that real?!? 6:03 forget about everything else she’s sitting on a bull
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nah im screaming🤣🤣🤣🤣
wtf
Leave bernie alone he just wants to show his friends that bulls can be famous
It's a Thai Buffalo
“do en do dooooooo.... *AHHHHHHHHHH* !!”
love ur profile picture
3:33
a l e x same
Saw this comment just as it got to that part 😂
I'm sorry, but I can't take the lady with the backup dancers seriously 😂😂😂
Speccy SquareGoLike me either. Too much modern dancing
GetReal 4Real it ain’t even modern tho it’s dancing that you’d expect in a foxy brown song 😂😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣😪🚮
It’s a Brazilian TV show where the dancers are just always there. They used to dance before all the time until this date, before commercials, after commercials, in the middle of the competition, when someone is talking.
4:27
Damn 1:30 she even continued in whistle register, I think that’s the most impressive and appreciative of all of them 👍🏻
Exactly chante Moore killed it
Every time Minnie whistles, she does it for fun and not for her to show off. The others are like "wait till I whistle and ya'll gonna applaud me"
Lol 😂 so true and it’s off putting to be honest
😂
Chiara, girl....You Trippin.🙁
Janae Miller Media 😂😂😂😂😂
Lmao
yeah like wtf was that 😂
Time?
MRGT KNHP 3;30
@3:24 ... what the hell was that
laynaa! It was good I think
ally idk i mean opinions are opinions but during what she called a whistle note, she sounded like weasel
It was so bad 😂
laynaa! She really thought she did something...look at the pose she strikes as if she’s actually sounding good or something...gurl u wish that sounded good but it didn’t🤷🏽♂️
hahahahahaha
20% of the comments: Minnie’s was the best
80% of the comments: WHAT WAS THAT AT 3:23
Shes copying keah mcfall
@@aquilshangout214 who is?
@@jossyo6448 the girl at 3:23
Joss Yo the girl at 3:25
#SQN
I can't believe how many people can actually hit these notes. I am impressed.
when a dude can sing a better whistle note than you
투모로우바이투게더 how is 4:08 not a whistle note
투모로우바이투게더 and 8:44
투모로우바이투게더 oh no no but yeah he didn’t do whistle notes still pretty tho
Let’s just all go die 😂
Im 14 (male) i can g7 thats my max and still trying to increase it
Well, I can tell you who did the worst.
3:24
She thought she was doing something.
synysterjazmyngates And the second one doing a really bad and unnecessary run The Whole time
synysterjazmyngates ikr it was flat and uncontrolled
i wrote about her a while back but i cant find my negative comment anymore :/
synysterjazmyngates shes a goat
A lot of these aren’t even whistles, they’re just really high head voice
That's what Minnie is doing, though. It's just called a 'whistle' because of the tone and breathiness she uses.
Do you even know the definition of whistle?😂
@@NgocAnh-ch2vr it's actually kinda complicated but let me explain it in simpler terms if it's OK hahaha. Head voice is usually a tone produced by the head or the pressure is something felt on the head. It's not as airy as a falsetto. As a whistle note uses more air so it's like a very high falsetto. That's nit the exact explanation but that's how I can out it on simpler terms. Whistle tones are mostly high notes at least a5 and an example ie Mariah Carey's signature style 🙂
@@aquilshangout214 whistle actually like a vocal cracks that you can control. LOL whistle doesnt need more air. Infact you have to really close your vocal chords that almost no air can pass through. You just have to make it flap 1 side of your vocal chords to produce a sound
@@fanboybiggynlhong3537 and whistles are disconnected from your ordinary voice register.
Why are the two girls in the second spot even on the list? They didn’t whistle and were just there doing scales and pretending to look professional
Quite a few didn't do a whistle?
They’re not in any kind of order
They were awful
I honestly do think it is still really good and it shows you dont need the whistle for it to hit.
Maddy Angell Yh they made it their own
The background dancers at 4:30 are freaking me out with their ritualistic witchery
This made ne laugh so hard omg!!! You don't understand!!! I can't😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
You should get an Academy Award for that
Sugar Booger OMG LOL this in a Brazilian TV show and is normal dance like this... now I can't see it the same way 😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
Sugar Booger LMASKSKSKS
My night had been made 😂😂😂
2:11 doooding doooding do doooo
am I the only one laughing at this?
Dudeing lol
Dafuq!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Omg 😂😂😂😂
Yeah, you're the only one
Minnie was the only one who didn’t do too much in my opinion
I agree, but think about the great skill that you have. Compare it to the originator of that skill. Are you doing too much?
Thats one good opinion
6:47 , someone should notice her. Shes pretty good
She is very famous because of her range.
8 octaves, the biggest for a female.
I totally agree with you.
She barely opened her mouth!
*she hit the highest note in the world probably - G#10*
10:20 LOVE HOW THE AUDIENCE ATTEMPTED THE WHISTLE HAHA
someone they are all like AHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Sounds like a massacre, it's amazing, hahaha
I'm laughing my ass off, they do sound like they're being massacred lol
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAA
MrVeeesss jajajah
1. the original
2.Chante
3.Leah
IIKHALAII lol Leah was just a regular FALSETTO tho. Not even a whistle
L L
Not really .
Mia Z is amazing at falsettos lmao
I liked Adam Lopez too!
I didnt like leahs
Don’t know if you guys have watched her full performance of the song, but if you haven’t, ruclips.net/video/sfjFx-wMiy4/видео.html ,at 1:54, that was definitely a whistle!
I feel like a lot of these don’t get the mood that Minnie does. She seems so relaxed and dreamy and others add too much. Idk
I agree! Absolutely
3:31
Her: Duh.
Also her: Oh.
Omg this one. This is the best comment here. Actually crying hahahaha
Ok. Can we all discuss how the hell Adam hit the exact note?
voice over dubbed. Duh.
By training of course. World record holder for singing the highest note for a man
steve bigler you're a dumbass...
Because he can hit every note he wants
Just one of those lucky men that can reach up there. The note is an F#6, yeah? That’s incredible. The highest I can do, as a male as well, is an E6 and I have problems trying to hit it sometimes. Seeing him be able to do it with ease is amazing.
3:25 is the fergie equivalent of the national anthem at the all stars.
Jajjahahhahhahahh lit!!!
Oh geezus
Very true lol
Honestly just dying a different way of singing
Lmao that was pitchy 😂
10:09 bro am I the only one who died when the whole audience tried to sing the notes😂😂😂😂
Most of these versions were very nice, but no body, and I mean NOBODY does it better than Minnie! YOU GO GIRL‼️
No question. Minnie Ripperton. She was mad natural and did not have to go into contortions to reach those elusive notes
🤣🤣🤣You said contortions
Jesus I’m going to hear this bloody noise in my sleep
Elsimtu sleep well
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣
No one:
Absolutely no one:
Adam lopez: Shalalalalala😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣A whole Shalalala😪
Georgia Brown wasn't even trying, I usually don't like her voice, but I watched the full version and it was so relaxing.
Yeah her voice isnt bad but most of the time she doesn't use it well
O whistle é sempre impecável
Minnie...then Minnie...then MINNIE followed by Chante Moore. Nobody else.
viveka watch the full video of KLARISE and JONA
Facts
Minnie and Leona Lewis had an unbelievably pure quality to their voices; Chante was mindblowing and Georgia Brown had the most ease 👏
GarageStudio I'm quite surprised that Mariah has never covered this song or any of her songs considering she influenced her 🤔 or maybe she just thought that it didn't need to be covered due to how perfect it already is :)
@@codywalsh2075 we have to admit, Mariah knows respect when do, she literally says when she was performing with Aretha on divas live, she was only a backup singer to her majesty while everyone else was trying to vocal fight our resting queen
@@Starisborne yes I already know all of that, Patti Labelle even said Mariah did the right thing when Mariah didn't "challenge" Aretha.
Cody Walsh I think Mariah just wanna stay original. She has tons of songs with whistle already 😂
Cody Walsh Are you just assuming Minnie Influences Mariah? I’ve never heard or read that.
Nothing like the queen herself. Minnie’s will forever be perfection
anyone that can hit those notes deserves an award. I loved singing my whole life and was never good at it. If I could just be blessed to hit that note just once in my life, I would burst into tears
How could nobody talk about Jane Zhang's supported and resonant head voice at 10:20? Brutally underrated here!
Her version reminds me of Mariah's whistle. I forgot what song.
@@mcglitter07 is it emotions?
@@theawessum1 never too far away whistle... when Mariah sing the "Never Too Far" with whistle notes.
That last clip and not by Mrs. Minnie chile.... 💯
I got an ad for the Dora movie when I clicked this.😂
They're all fairly decent and unique but Minnie is the one and only
Sofia Nygara Couldnt agree more!!!
Sofia Nygara agree
lol no hate but Minnie hit those notes in head voice not whistle, yea sure they were whistle NOTES, but they weren’t executed in whistle TECHNIQUE, the only ones who did it in TRUE whistle voice are Von Smith, David Lopez and Chante Moore, like if u get it, feel free to ask questions..
yeah 3:33 is so unique lmfao
Tbh Adam did it the best for me. Relax face, perfect tongue placement, wasn’t shaky and perfect excution!
Chantel Moore took it there and swam in that register.
Minnie makes it sound as natural as breathing.
Minnie's is so smooth, it's just like honey.
Weird comparison but ok
The only true whistle notes in here are Minnie, Georgia, Chantle, and Adam. A few of them got really close or started out in a whistle and then switched to falsetto but all of the are really nice.
The Seven Year Twitch Chante. No L
Actually most of them switched to head voice, not falsetto
Whistle register doesnt exist.
Ruben de Groot yes it does
You mean except the d twinz lmao
There's nothing better than the original. Minnie was by far the best.
Modern versions are fine to listen to but Minnie sang with a purity and feeling that tells you in no uncertain terms how much she is in love and she will always be my choice .
1- Minnie, so effortless and relaxing
2- Chanté, amazing
2- Leona, I couldn’t choose between her and Chanté oops
3- Klarisse, very nice and controlled
4- Georgia, sounded quite natural
Klarrise is 💕
2222222222
Laura's was nice and natural too
georgia sounded natural because i'm pretty sure she has the world record for highest note from a woman
I think the second one should be ana Cristina
3:25 dafuq she really feelin it with dem high notes 😂
She looks like Tae in his Boy In Luv era
@@kimberly-lt9gc hahahahahha omg😂😂😂 kinda🤣🤣🤣
Kim Taehyung is heartue💜💜🖤🖤
@@kimberly-lt9gc Don't do tae so dirty like that, boy doesn't deserve it 😂
HAHAHAHHA UTAS
Hands down Chante Moore. She made it her own and did an incredible job.
Another : Struggle to whistle...
Minnie : hit whistle while sitting...
Chante, you stay
Hideki Arata 🤣😂
RuPauls Drag Race!!!!!!!!!
😂
Everybody else sashay away 😂
Holy shit 💀
WAS NOT EXPECTING 4:06
Sophie Jones He actually holds the Guinness world record for the highest whistle note sang.
Rey Rivera georgina brown has taken the place
Gloffario Elanore by a man.
Nope Mariah!
@@Kengklayd mc is actually not that high at all
but her whistle register agility is COMPLETLEY in her own league. (plus she can even make her whistle note airy)
I remember Minnie so many years ago. I still cry hearing that voice. It was @So Natural and cannot be replicated. I wished it could but it cannot.
@Mister Go Lightly-A substantial "Runner Up" vote undoubtedly, goes to the incredible vocals of Chante Moore, @ 1:22 who made the Whistle notes seem almost effortless...!
2:52 her tongue made it so awkward 😂
Camille Gill i thouhgt she was gonna bite her tongue 😂
mane i had to go back just to peep that shi 💀
Camille Gill glad I'm not the only one who was hella uncomfortable of her tongue
looks like a hamburger 🍔
All yaw needs to put respek on Shanice's name. They showed her in her late 40s to 50s, so her singing style has changed somewhat. But she did the song maaad justice when she sang it back in 1992 on one of her albums when she was 19 years old. You can't tell me that she didn't hit the high note perfectly here.....ruclips.net/video/wfQ2LQOQDbU/видео.html
10:23 aw she sounds lovely
She does, I like her connection with the audience😊
Yeah I love her version too.
One of the most beautiful and original, looks like something Minnie would do.
Came back. Loved the vid. Some talented people. Minnie’s still my fave, soft, sweet, effortless, enchanting. Chante’s voice and control is amazing. Different style completely, but amazing as well.
The original is soo chill and relaxing, she doesn't force her voice like the rest
well, I can't say that they all use whistle tone here... most of them attempt the notes using falsetto 🤔
Luthfiah Farsya Dini Mardi trueeee like wtf why are these people in here, the duo or the second clip didn’t even try doing it LOLLLL
Garreth EXONavarro ikr!!! omg why am I so mad 😂
Which is more difficult, falsetto up to F6 is more difficult to hit than wistle
@@Gisaround You have to understand that, runs with whistles are the hardest things ever.
@@crydoesstuff9155 It definitely is 😂
7:27 = the best one😂
AHAHAHHAHA
Muahahahahha
🤣🤣
LMFAO
I'll see y'all in hell 🤣😂😅
Wow I didn't even know I was featured in this video. Thank you!
You did really good 👍
There’s no comparison to the naturalness of the one and only Minnie, so beautiful, her spirit shines through effortlessly with happiness and grace.
Minnie. Period. The polish and control she has over her voice is several heads above everyone else. You can't even hear her switching registers her vocal tone is so well placed from top to bottom. Her classical training really pays off in this song.
3:54 clean whistle + clean vibra
*Hands down*
• Pepe • Filipino proud here ! 🤚
Proud Filipino 😊💛💛💛 here .sad bad shes one of the underrated singer in the Philippines
💪klarisse 👐👐👏👏👏
Klang klang is the best for me
First thank you for taking the time to put this and so many other "who sang it better (s) " together. I enjoy them so much. There were so many stunning and outstanding voices singing this beautiful song. But Minnie, Minnie, Minnie is the queen. SHE does it all day every day for me.
Minnie of course . But Chante Moore was amazing! But you can never take “THE BEST” from Minnie cause she was so 👏🏽
Since when did the lyrice became "shalalalala"?😂😂 3:57
Pakihanap ng pake ko
@@duzled_blue1996 walang may pake kung wala kang pake
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Atleast he reached the whistle note...lyrics does not matter if your note is out of order...
bryleee i thought i was the only who noticed that 😭.
I/2 of these could not even get the LA LA's right... edit!!
5:55 sounds so beautiful🥺
Chante Moore whistle just kept on whistling 🙌🏾 Props to Shanice (Lady in Bangs) who can hit every note run and whistle known to man!!
Mariah Carey never covered this song though she can nail those high whistles and runs because she pays high respect to Minnie which is one of her inspirations.
Covering a song isn't a sign of lack of respect.
@@judybudy5921 Nowhere in that comment did she say that?? 💀
@@dallasdegourville7046 Or maybe she just hasn't recorded herself singing it. No one can do this whistle better than Minnie.
Nowadays she can’t do it anymore
Irene van der Linden excuse me: could you explain that a little more, please. How is it even possible? I don’t get it, I’ve always wonder how Mariah just jump into whistle but never does any soprano showing like disco stars would. Sounds unbelievable to me that someone can hit the whistle register and at the same time couldn’t hit some opera notes.
3:34 Basically yodeling... She needs more control over her voice :/
hahahaha
Jxsl3n3 definitely
Yodeling is controlled rapid swapping between chest and head. It's super difficult to do. That was just unsupported and out her range lol
@@razrv3lc that was the point
park baekhyun chogiwa kkaebsong no it wasn’t. She said that was yodeling which it wasn’t. Yodeling is a difficult technique that no one accidentally does.
9:53...... CLEAN!!! AMAZING:)
As much as I love all of the covers, they can’t just replicate the romance Minnie exuded whenever she performed this song. This song is about being so madly in love and having butterflies in your belly, yet being sensual. I feel like most singers who sing this forget about the meaning of the verses and focus too much on the whistle part. But they are all great vocalists!❤️
I know everyone's talking about the chick at 3:24 -(and rightfully so, that was... something)-
But I'm sorry, the two girls at 0:43 were just as off and all over the place, especially/mainly the second girl who absolutely refuses to hold a note for more than a millisecond and just jumped all over the scale with extra runs for no real reason
There's a reason. ITS A VERSION, NO A COPY. Just saying
@@SofiaGomez-ub3uz I understand that, but they didn't really execute it too well in my opinion. There were other people who added runs and were quite successful, but I guess it was too all over the place for my tastes (btw, nice TWICE profile pic, hell yeah)
@@OnionFairy99 well I understand your opinion so, it's ok. I still like it, but I think what you said it's true.
Pd: no twice no life
TheOnionFairy99 the both of them were judging each other and trying to outdo each other
@@SofiaGomez-ub3uz Hey, if you like it more power to you! We will agree to disagree. Have a great day my dude!
The first girls was doin TOOOO DAMN MUCH
3:41 was the best girl to me and her whistle sounded like Minnie’s!
Ya no she was using a falsetto
@@justinmaryland1081 she's using a headvoice.
Guys are jealous
@@lexitnute1306 no one's jealous ur mad cuz they're spitting facts
@@justinmaryland1081 i’m a singer and i can tell you for a fact only 2 vocalists in the entire compilation were not using a head voice and it’s because they obviously have a really wide range and have been very strictly vocally trained. it’s extremely difficult to belt out notes that high at some point you have to go into your head voice, not even necessarily because it’s easier but it just sounds better
Chanté Moore's take on it (1:23) was crazy. She changed it up to fit her style and made it way better in my book.
3:24 she really thought she did sum there huh LMFAOOOO
Fun fact: Duong Hoang Yen is actually the voice of Elsa in Frozen, and you'd be surprised to hear her voice there for it sounds very guttery and deep, almost like a contralto!
rishabhrox1 I need to hear that!
you realize "she" is a dude right? lol
rishabhrox1 isn't Indina Menzel the voice of Elsa?
+Emmy and Elle Johnson
Duong voiced Elsa in Vietnamese language, Idina did in English.
rishabhrox1 oh yeah. OK thanks.
You forgot "Richard Stamos' South Park" cover (simply the best) :D
🤣
3:24 WTF??? LMFAO
Pines Universe I. Was screaming
she tried it
Better than u I bet
Candy Gurl NO JUST NO
Candy Gurl if ur going to do a cover do it well
It's nice to see a variety of male voices here
Nah
The original singers voice was unique, hard to replicate
girl be whistling and everyone just applauds as hard as possible
There's only one Millie.....Chante Moore (1:23) however hit some supernatural notes!!!
Minnie is #1 without a shadow of a doubt. Then the only ones of any impression on me are: Chante Moore>Leah McFall>Ally>Everybody else
Actually I kinda liked Twinnie tbh
minnie > georgia brown > all
I was amazed with sarah main, it was like .. Its sooo clean and perfect!
There are inventors of songs and then there're excellent singers who can enhance original works with unique spins. Imagine what they all might be singing if Minner Ripperton had never created this song. This was an amazing collage of people who performed the song so well.
for me alot of them sounded to rushed, just trying to reach the whistle part, without putting enough soul and effort into capturing the dreaminess and floatingness of the parts leading up to it. My favourite will always be the original.
Tonia Reeves you clearly skipped chante moore or you’re just biased. Minnie is a legend, but chante did great as well.
I agree with this comment :)
Watch the full performance of klarisse on Wish 107 5
Minnie Riperton - Maya Rudolph’s mom.
ds99 heck yeah! When I found out about this, it made sense to me how Maya actually has some singing chops
ds99 I knew it!!!
4:26 those backup dancers!! I can't breathe 😭🤣💀
Loved all of them, they all hit that high note, wow, that was a grand tour of performances, I enjoyed them all ❤❤❤❤❤