TheDeenShowTV talks about the Quran Contradictions
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 сен 2024
- @TheDeenShowTV recently reviewed my discussion with popular Muslim apologist Sneako where they brought on Imam Fadel Soliman to discuss the 10 different Qurans (Qira'at) in his book "Bridges Translation of the 10 Qira'at of the noble Quran". Are there different meaning in the 10 different Qurans? Or do they all say the same thing? Are there contradictions in the meaning? Let's find out...
God bless you Chris and our Muslim brothers and sisters who are trying to live a good life despite the lies that they have been taught.
The problem is No Holiness, No Righteousness and No Salvation. I wish that these good folks would send a memo to Nigeria and others.
@samuelflores1419 yes. And they don't shout loudly against it. And then they too are horrified when the extremists take over and either tow the line, or escape to my country and build mosques. And so it continues
this was a qiraat apologetics masterclass.
Sahih Muslim 1452b Aisha says her quran contained the 5 suckling verse. Today's quran does not.
This hadith is weak
And there was 3 other narrators before aisha for it
Nah. Your religion is weak. @@yahyaahmed530 Humans decide whether a hadith is weak or strong. LOL Poor Allah.
@yahyaahmed530 no it isn't - it's in a sahih collection
Then all of your hadith are weak.And so is your Quran. All lies. Leave Islam while you can.
@yahyaahmed530
@@yahyaahmed530
So let's thrown the mother of the ummah under the bus
Which is more likely, that mohammed had the quran revealed in 7 "modes" or mohammed forgot what he said (like he admits to elsewhere) and then had to stop his followers killing each other over his bad memory?
Funny. I had a martial arts teacher that was like this. Taught slightly differently as the generations changed and he forgot what he taught earlier. If u look into WingChun history, Ip Man did the same...
Looking forward to your being on the Deen Show, Chris 😊
I think they invited you!
Chris will absolutely annihilate him!
@inquisitivemind007 yes. As he did Hamza. And Adnan Rashid. And Uthman. And Sneako. And anyone else who dared to talk to him before they knew he knew his stuff.
@@ProfYaffle you should see the clip Chris made of Hamza. What a coward Hamza is!
@@inquisitivemind007Isreal are genocidle terrorists oppressing Palestine’s!!!!!
@inquisitivemind007 the one where he broke his agreement to debate because of the "toxic" comments in Chris's video 😀?
The man is a ridiculous hypocrite. Based on that reasoning he should close his den!
6:00 "All six dialects were abrogated" Never heard of this before!
That's what I thought: a new lie. They are inventive if nothing else
@@ProfYaffle around and around they go, where their Lies stop nobody knows. You know the thing!
@@ProfYafflewhat's even more embarrassing is that they just skip over that part that says they are from the same tribe 😂that means they would have spoken the same way, but they still cling on to this lie😂
@greghilton6718 the miracle of the Quran is that people believe...and risk their lives for it
@@ProfYaffle Not just their lives, but the taking of other's lives.
Been watching Chris since he came to SP. How have I not Subbed to the channel is beyond 😐. Subbed n liked bro
I like how you started the vid with a clap out at the beginning. Gets the attention like u got that juicy knowledge to share with us lol I think it should be a feature of the starting/end of your videos, kinda like David Woods "tick tock, time ta rock" lol Anyway keep up the good work. Maybe if I come to the park I might tap u on the shoulder to say hi lol 👋
Allah sends 7, and muslims decided to abrogate allah and only have one.
Exactly, this was my contention. Very very confusing.
The new twist according to the scholar is that mohammed abrogated the 6 Ahrufs leaving one, but is there a hadiths to back his claim?
So which one is it? Did mohammed abrogate the 6 Ahrufs and allowed one according to allah's command or was it Uthman who standardized it into one dialect according to mohammed's instructions?
What about the qiraats (recitations)? After standardizing the quran into one dialect when did the 7+3 qiraats come into existence? Was it before standardizing it or later?
Glad you have your own channel, Chris!
Excellent breakdown Chris. God bless you brother.
Wait, he said there were 10 qirat for each of the 7 Arabic dialects? (10×7=...) 6 were abrogated. Man alive! Allah sure do like to change his mind!
God bless you @Chris.
really hope there will be a conversation with you and Fadel Soliman
Shabir Ally on Let the Quran Speak today metaphorized just about everything the Quran says that offends modernity. Ants speaking? Metaphorical. Dhul Qarnayn's wall? Metaphorical. The desperation to make it make sense is showing.
Yet the quran says it is a clear book, in clear arabic, which provides a complete explanation of everything. In all those embarrassing cases there is not a single case where it says "the following is a metaphorical story, and any resemblance to real people or events is purely accidental".
When their Allah is metaphoric, what do you expect from those uneducated Muslims?
Great work Chris!
The miracle of the Perfectly Preserved Holey qur'an is that folks actually believe that it's Perfectly Preserved. When you must Lie or make excuses for your beliefs, Red Flag! God bless you brother Chris and your ministry!
This is music to my ears!
And there are so many of them... Remember the one I showed in our video together on my channel? Between Warsh and Hafs? On the topic of something so important of redeeming fasting... "How many poor people should one feed? Or just 1 person?"
Once again Chris makes mincemeat of the cult ! God bless! 😅😅😅😅
It looks like you are serious, you guys, destroying this cult. You leave no stone unturned. You are exposing the cult and it will be hsrd to recover
God Bless :)
"May your quality be known among your enemies, should ever you meet them".
So the sheikh used the same excuse as Yasir Qadhi (after the 'holes in the narrative" disaster). The new excuse is that they are ALL the quran. But this is so disingenuous. Qira'at is late (10th century), and arose because of significant differences (that remain!) in the Qurans. It was left, apparently, to ibn Mujahid and others to solve these problems by establishing different, but equally canonical readings. Who gave them authority to do that? If the Quran was perfectly preserved, there would be no need for Qira'at. [Gabriel Said Reynolds, The Quran in Its Historical Context. London: Routledge, 2007]
And how ridiculous to simply use a decree to call them all 'the same'!
If you'd asked all these liars 20 years ago if the quran was 'perfectly preserved' they would have agreed - and claimed that was a miracle. Now they are desperately trying to find excuses. Without lies, islame dies.
It's a joke as the same variants can be found in pre-Islamic poetry! This means that there is nothing special and unique about the Qiraat at all!
The new twist according to the scholar is that mohammed abrogated the 6 Ahrufs leaving one, but is there a hadiths to back his claim?
So which one is it? Did mohammed abrogate the 6 Ahrufs and allowed one, was it allah who abbrogated it or was it Uthman who officially standardized it into one dialect on his own accord?
What about the qiraats? After standardizing the quran into one dialect, when did the 7+3 qiraats come into existence? Was it before standardizing it or later? What about the present 20 qiraats in print?
All this needs to be investigated and who better than you Chris.
Lovely Chris. Deconstructed Islam is in a panic.
Amen my brother, there is a better way that requires no dishonesty to defend it. 💪✝️ Excellent work once again Chris. I love the precise, yet easy to understand way that you make your points. It really puts their argument in the corner and makes it impossible to refute.
Did Allah reveal ONE verse ONE time, or did he reveal ONE verse SEVEN different times and in SEVEN different modes? Which is it?
"only al-lah knows" (LOL). But probably his wife Al-Lat and daugher Manat gave him a help out with the different versions - just for fun!
@@toddbeamer6131 Should have been 360 modes, each for their false gods. Then Allah got tired of the up and down traffic.
Thanks!
Brother Chris.
They need salvation.
The same tribe has 7 different dialects? Come on. Was Koresh Babylon?
I hope he decides to debate you.
Brother Chris, Thank you for being a shining beacon of our Christian faith. ✝️
They won't debate Chris. They like to cherry 🍒 pick easy opponents to make Islam look good.
@inquisitivemind007 at what point do they realize. They are committing a sin.
I got a used copy of the Bridges. I look forward to looking into it.
I try to buy used whenever I don't want to support the author or printing company with continual funding.
Each day goes by, i am finding more evidence that everything Lord Jesus Christ said is the truth, while everything islam claims is pure ''trust me bro'' sources - thank you chris for teaching me about the preservation of the quran, it has helped me win debates against many muslims who can't explains what happened to all the ahruf dialects after uthman burned all the older qurans
Chris is doing a fantastic job and it won't be long before he takes out all of the so called best Muslim Apologists in the world 🌎
both are not real, but I agree Islam needs to be gone
Sura 9 verse 5 tells to kill the disbelievers, but sura 109 verse 6 tells to accept them as they are. Isn't it a contradiction?
Didn’t Uthman abrogate the modes? Muhammad was deceased so… didn’t he just call Uthman a prophet if Allah used Uthman to abrogate?
Yes, according to the standard sunni narrative Uthman decided which version to use and destroyed all previous texts, including the muhammed quran, in order to erase the differences from history. He was truly a partner of al-lah! Even worse, he or some reformer like him thought it a good idea to re-order the verses from their original chronological order and put them into chapters that were largely ordered according to length of text (excepting the first sura). Longest to shortest. This means the quran is not in the order 'sent down' by their al-lah. I have not yet found a muslim willing to identify the person responsible for such blasphemy against their moon god. Whoever it was should be held together with Aisha's tame sheep and both should be severely punished for altering the totally preserved book that is protected from all corruption by, whoever he is.
He didn’t claim that. Christians love to strawman people for Paul.
@@toddbeamer6131
How do you know about Uthman? Who told you? Do you rely on chains of transmission?
The same chains of transmission you reject for the Quran.🤥🤥
@@AlonzoHarris235we rely on what you tell us about Uthman or are you now going to say that Uthman never existed?
@@inquisitivemind007
You are cherry picking.
You accept the chains of transmission for the reports about Uthman. The chains of transmission from our sources.
But you reject the chains of transmission for the Quran from our sources. You are just cherry picking and inconsistent.
Because you can’t even present a methodology for preservation.
If your methodology is textual transmission. You shouldn’t use chains of transmission at all. You shouldn’t even mention uthman. Before you even try to challenge preservation. Why don’t you present a methodology first instead of cherry picking from our sources.
Discussing what the ahruf are. That has nothing to do with preservation. Preservation is based on chains of transmission.
Chris is waffling. He is also twisting the words of Soliman.
Thanks so much Chris for confronting thr Deen Show like even recently they made disgusting lies about Jesus and the Bible by taking verses and scriptures out of context completely. Not enough people confront Eddie from the Deen Show.
The host of the Deen show is a naive fool who was conned into believing in Islam. All he needs is an antivirus software downloaded in his head by Chris and all will be OK.
Eddie is a fool who got conned into Islam. Hopefully one day Chris will talk some sense into him and he can leave this con called Islam ☪️
I would like to hear his answer on ibn Masuds mushaf which states in the verse 37:12 " allah is amazed while they laugh "....while standard quran says "You are amazed while they laugh.....And ibn Masud is the one for whom Mohammed said ,That people should learn Quran from him.....He was also from the tribe of Qurayish on his mothers side and he worked for Qurayish chieftain from the time of his young age ....
If the switch is 'canonical', then al-lah and muhammed are one and the same person!
The guy from The Deen Show looks like wallmart Pablo.
The guy from the Deen show has been conned into Islam. He needs a vaccine to clear that software called Islam ☪️ that is downloaded in his head.
Ayah al-Baqarah (The Cow) 2:106. If We ever abrogate a verse or cause it to be forgotten, We replace it with a better or similar one. Do you not know that Allah is Most Capable of everything? Any verse [from the previous Books] We cause to be abrogated or forgotten; We will replace it with one like it or better.
Way to keep owning each and every channel. Not everyone is taking advantage of the algos. Muslim Lantern is now complaining about being throttled, because he’s been caught running too many times. He’s one of the biggest liars.
A religion based on lies and aggression should not be allowed to exist!!!!
A religion that supports slavery should not be allowed to exist!!!!
They're always 😭
The claim is that Quran is perfectly preserved. Narrative destroyed. Any honest Muslim brother should be asking for answers, cuz scholars don't know which Quran is from Allah given blank piece of paper to write on.
Hi Chris, off topic:
There is some slight crackling in the sound mostly when you speak in this and some of your other videos, something in the mic or the recording setup.
Think it might be when I move the microphone or the cable - will look into this
@@chrisatspeakerscornerhi Chris, there is an abdul constantly writing "Chris believes in 3 gods" in the comments. Why do you give these abduls a free platform on your channel?
@@chrisatspeakerscorner
According to the Bridges Translation of the Ten Qira'at of the Noble Quran, in surah Baqarah 184, six of the Qira'at say that you can make up a missed fast by feeding a poor man, but 4 other qiraats say that you must feed [an unspecified number of] poor *men.*
@TAQIYYA_ALERT just shows you how Muhammad can't make his mind up or somewhere along the line there was a mistake in the transmission of the Quran.
Looks like abdul fidel Castro sillyman got upset watching you schooling sneako on islam using the abdul's own book 😂
Greetings Chris, I trust you are well. You made a video of the 10 Readings of the Qur'an and mentioned the app - I downloaded it but its not in English. Does the app have the English translations of the 10 Readings of the Qur'an?
These differences are self generating schisms that indicate the potential for violence!
The Lah is the greatest propagator of confusion
why not say king and owner... if it were perfect then the grammar and meaning would be complete.
"the grammar" Don't mention the grammar. There are so many grammatical errors that the book is an embarrassment.
To save paper and ink is what Fadel Soliman will say
Both muslim and non muslim scholars who examined the quranic manuscripts found that the very small amount of differences in those manuscripts compared to standard quran are dialectal differences ,majority of differences are claimed as scribal errors by the muslim scholars....
Over 30 different arabic qurans on sale in the world today, with over 93,000 text differences. Different words with different meanings that change the theology of entire sentences. Have you ever looked to fact check what your lying clerics tell you? There are online websites (e.g. Corpus Coranicum) that show you the differences. Do you need an example?
Amen! Come to Jesus!
THE BIBLE: The Bible was originally written in three different languages (Hebrew, Greek, and Aramaic), on three different continents (Europe, Asia, and Africa), in a time-spend of over 1500 years, by over forty different authors among whom were kings, peasants, philosophers, fishermen, poets, statesmen, scholars, a herdsman, a general, a cupbearer, a doctor, a tax collector, and a rabbi. Without contradicting one another, each author wrote on the common theme of God’s enduring love for mankind, and God’s redeeming plan of salvation through His Son - Jesus Christ.
*
Unlike the Quran written in a period of about 23 years in Mohammed’s native tongue (the Quraishi dialect and then translated into the Arabic language), the forty plus different authors of the Bible were moved by the Spirit of God to write down truths about God in their own ways of thinking, in their own ways of understanding, and in their own ways of reasoning truths. Each author also wrote down the truths of God in his own style of compositions - be it essay, music, or poetry.
*
Critics of the Bible claimed the Bible contains contradictions. How? - Because two different authors living hundreds and hundreds of years apart on two different continents, and whose writing styles (essay, music, or poetry) in two different languages did not use the same word or phrase to describe the same event. How ridiculous the claim!
Owner and king - but not a single letter, word or dot has changed.
So, mohamed abrogated stuff?
Chris, you are wrong about the verse 10:16. The two recitations are not contradictory.
The first recitation means:
"Had Allah willed, i would not have read it to you, nor would Allah have informed you about it"
The second recitation is:
"Had Allah willed, I (myself) would not have read it to you, and He would have informed you about it (via somebody else)."
Both recitations are complimentary because the verse starts off with "Had Allah willed"; hence BOTH of Allah's choices are mentioned.
I.e. had Allah willed, then x, or if He willed otherwise, then y.
This is NOT a contradiction.
Somebody else is later added original script dontbhave it stop the taqiya mate please
@@AdmiringAstronaut-ep7qk try writing that again please
@@Wassalaam92 bracketed verse isn't there in the original script
@@AdmiringAstronaut-ep7qk the bracketed part is just there for you to understand the overall meaning.
Even without the brackets, it makes sense.
That's the whole point of brackets.
@@Wassalaam92 nope bracketed verses is to cover up the differences
But the fact it was
Please add surah 36:38.
The sun runs on its a fixed course AND The sun doesn't run on its fixed course.
Well, the sun has bad days and good days, and sometimes it just needs a break from the strict discipline. As the hadiths and scholars describe, after it drops into that refreshingly hot, muddy pool it likes to hang around prostrating in front of al-lahs throne, probably expecting a pat on the head and a 'good doggy' response before heading off to the place it rises from in the flat Earth.
@@toddbeamer6131 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Excellent work, the whole “perfectly preserved” argument is so educationally and historically irrational it’s cringe worthy. Variance in citations and ‘modes’ is not perfect, dual meanings of opposites is not perfect hahah, so weird at this point. The internet is their doctrines biggest enemy, truth will always overcome. Jesus is Lord.
It's a joke as the same variants can be found in pre-Islamic poetry! This means that there is nothing special and unique about the Qiraat at all!
That's a really salient point. Could you elaborate more please.@@inquisitivemind007
@paulthomas281 Anything transmitted orally whether it's religious or not religious like poetry will have mistakes in transmission. The different types of variants of the Quran can be found in Pre Islamic poetry which means variant readings is nothing unique or special to the Quran.
You could see Eddy's head exploding
Hatun has identified something like 30 differing Qurans. How does that fit in with their 7/10 theory? Where did all the rest come from?
Let no one of you say that he has acquired the entire qur'an, for how does he know that it is all?
Much of rhe qur'an has been lost.
Thus let him say "I have acquired what is available.
- IBN UMAR
As-Suyuti, Al-Itaqan f, Ulum Al-Qur'an
You copied this out of context text from non academic garbage websites.
As suturing confirmed the Quran. He is talking about the abrogated verses. They are also Quran but not applicable anymore. Keep trying to twist the views of people for your Paulien ideology.
@AlonzoHarris235 you have to admit that when Uthman banned all variant Qurans and standardised the Uthmanic codex that he ordered the rest of the variant Qurans to be burned. Some of what was in those codices are preserved in Islamic literature but we don't know if all of it has or has some of it been lost forever.
Seeing those guys faces when you started talking about this the other day at speakers corner was priceless. All the air leaked out of their balloons😅
Ask them which one is in the Lawh Mahfooth?
The correct translation. First chapter of the Quran, Surah Al Fatiha
is a preface of the Quran in which Allah is
defined as a Sustainer of all worlds, Who
has Motherly and Fatherly hood for
everything in the universes including us
Who is the Master of the Day of
Transaction (dealing). We obey Him and
seek help from Him. We seek His guidance
to the straight path that is the path of
those upon whom He bestowed His
blessing without those upon whom He had
outrage and without those who are
misguided.
this only gets better and better. the shaikh from Egypt looked almost comedic when he said there are 7 kirats, 10 modes and then all were abrogated but one. what is the point of this foolishness?
Fadel Soliman adopts the "having your cake and eating it too" approach: They're all right! Pharaoh apparently repeated himself and said the same thing twice in a row, changing only one word. LOL!
PFF audio Chris
"O how are they deluded!"
Hmm . . . How is a book that is eternal able to be abrogated?
Don't forget havf is not karses
Muslim should listen Ex Muslim Spartacus about
Contradictions in Quran on you tube
They make it up as they go hilarious
The QRN is what?
Toiletpaper.
Hello, what is your book? And I have to repeat an excellent comment from here below: "Which is more likely, that mohammed had the quran revealed in 7 "modes" or mohammed forgot what he said (like he admits to elsewhere) and then had to stop his followers killing each other over his bad memory?"
*slap* "welcome back..."
_Al-Anfal __8:35_
_ وَمَا كَانَ صَلَاتُهُمْ عِندَ ٱلْبَيْتِ إِلَّا مُكَآءً وَتَصْدِيَةًۚ فَذُوقُوا۟ ٱلْعَذَابَ بِمَا كُنتُمْ تَكْفُرُونَ _
_And not was their link at the house was except whistling and handclapping. So taste the punishment by what you disbelieved._
Is that your refutation of Chris's points?
Chris, why do they call you iceman?
Because he is cool, calm and collected when he debates.
Coz of the cold hard facts he uses to ice the abdoools !
There are no contradictions in the Quran. You only have confusion because of your ill intentions and inadequate knowledge of the Arabic language.
Maalik is the original recitation; Malik was given in additional recitations to Prophet Muhammed by Angel Gabrial. Hence both are authentic & preserved. This is in chapter 1, it has 7 verses, 29 words, and 139 letters in it.
You just check the precision-construction of this chapter by God, almighty, who has left some signs for us to reflect:
7 + (2+9) + (1+3+9) = 31
1st words of all the verses have a total of 31 letters
2nd words of all the verses have a total of 31 letters
3rd words of all the verses have a total of 31 letters
Allah’s name is mentioned 6 times in this chapter, using a total of 31 letters
If you go to 31st chapter (it has 34 verses) of the Quran, it starts by saying 3 letters, i.e. Alif, Lam, Meem (it’s not a word, just 3 letters)
The first letter “Alif” is used 31 times in the first words of all 34 verses in total.
The first letter “Alif” is used 31 times in the second words of all 34 verses in total.
The second letter “lam” is used 16 times in the first words of all 34 verses in total.
The second letter “lam” is used 16 times in the second words of all 34 verses in total.
This kind of precision construction of statements is impossible today, but the Quran was given 14 centuries ago, and revealed spoken form. Many of these verses were revealed at different times in different orders. Prophet Muhammed will just say, this verse goes to this chapter before or after this verse. Once said, a verse has never been revised or edited. People around him will memorize it.
The Quran is the word of God. Be sincere, open your heart, and read it yourselves.
Showing enmity to God or his words or to his guidance will not help you, as we are all going to die one day and will be judged.
The biggest problem with the Quran, it's a l l a h can't be the same as Yehovah of Abraham and Moses despite what they claim.
qutham, his real name, "received" 5 different qurans from "allah" cause he always said "my people are to stupid to understand" in between we know about 30+ different qurans and not anyone of them is completed cause utham burned all manuscripts. This "book" is full of errors, mistakes and contradictions.
Which quiraat is on the uncreated tablets in heaven 😂
So the illiterate knew/spoke 7 dialects?
Just stop it
10?? bart ehrman ' there are 50000 biblical manuscripts no two alike. and none of the gospels were write by any apostle. John 3 16 and mark resurrection story were added in much later ' case closed. your own biblical scholars have debunked christianity
How does that refute the point Chris is making?
@@inquisitivemind007 think about it pastor Bosworth smith after learning arabic and researching quran for 11 yrs concluded ' the quran is the only scripture preserved in its original language ' in the hands of the people as each verse revealed. bible made illegal for the laity to own from 325ad trinity vote until 16th century William Tyndall the last man burnt at the stake by the church for owning a bible 1532
Also Bart ehrman, the crucifixion is a historical fact.
In the Qur'an, Surat Al-Ankabod - it says that ALLAH AND ISA are "One"
👇
So they LIE and they have 2 gods in Islam 😂😂
Chris believes in three gods.
How many times 😂 Islam's Trinity Allah 1 muhammed 1 black stone 1 =3 😂😂😂
How does that refute the point Chris made?
@@inquisitivemind007
Chris didn’t make a point. He is just waffling.
He is also trying to strawman Soliman. Soliman said that the prophet abrogated it.
Chris claims that Soliman claims that the companions abrogated it.
Chris is deliberately trying to strawman Soliman.
What have Ahruf and Qiraat got to do with preservation?
How is this related to preservation? All Muslims agree on the chains of transmission all the way back to the prophet.
He is just waffling.
@@inquisitivemind007
Is this a serious question?
Chris didn’t make any point. He is only waffling.
Did he present a methodology to measure preservation? The answer is no.
If a text is transmitted through chains of transmission. They all accept it. But they disagree what the ahruf exactly are? How does that disprove the transmission through chains?🥴🤣
How is this even related?
Chris is only making assertions and claims. He has no logical justification for his claims. Did he present a methodology by which to measure? The answer is no.
He talks about Uthman. How does he know about Uthman? Does he accept the chains of transmission that tells him about Uthman. If the answer is yes. He has debunked his whole claim.
The Qiraat are also transmitted through chains of transmission. This means he has accepted the Qiraat. Your movement is incoherent.
@@AlonzoHarris235 call Fadel and tell him Chris is waiting for him.
King and owner are two different words
Abdools🤣🤣 In 2024 people are stil doing dawah
malik and maalik is a perfect example of the wisdom of qiraat. The arabic language is not like english i don't know if you took linguistics, but morphology is huge in arabic. Words enriched through extra vowels or short vowels and stuff. Malik means king, Maalik means owner. And these two meanings are not different they are complementary. That's something you won't find in any other book.
"complementary" They are two different words with two different meanings. They alter the meaning and theology of the entire sentence. A King is a very different type of person compared to a mere owner. It also begs the question about the vowel markings being errors (a simple dot difference), particularly given that the original arabic had no vowel markings and that the vowel marking conventions were added at abmuch later date. Then we have the usual excuse that verbal recitation made any corruption impossible yet such a difference in word sound should have easily been detected and avoided. It wasn't. The quran says it is protected from any corruption yet Uthman eliminated all variants except the version he chose. Who gave him that right? After his standardisation there should have been no variants at all - not because of anything stated in the quran but because Uthman destroyed all earlier texts and commanded that his standardised version be distributed to all major islamic cities. The Malik/Maalik difference is only one of tens of thousands amongst all the different arabic qurans.
@@toddbeamer6131 yes complementary. That's the point. And uthman was a saint... totally beyond your comprehension
'comprehension' You obviously have no idea what the meaning of that word is. read my post again.
@@toddbeamer6131 Beyond your comprehension means to have the ability to comprehend. That means the ability to understand or grasp it with you intellect. So i need to teach you arabic and english now too... and christianity and islam... like you need to do some effort too bro
Explain the wisdom of the variant reading about Lot's wife. One reading says Lot left his wife behind and the other says he took her with him!
no contradiction, Allah did cause and was the effect of any outcome, if ya thinking ? And even if you were'nt. lol. Each Kalipha has its own kehilla (communities of meanings), be your own understanding, being yourself reality. knowledge makes a man unfit to be a slave to cause and effect. rather he should surrender to peace than to create mischief in the land..
It's a joke as the same variants can be found in pre-Islamic poetry! This means that there is nothing special and unique about the Qiraat at all!
Every king is an owner dude...
Exactly! Which king 🤴 in the world doesn't own anything? What a retarded explanation by Fadel Soliman.