Turning Point: 1979 Egypt-Israel Peace Treaty
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 июл 2024
- On 19 November 1977 Egyptian president Anwar Sadat, and once sworn enemy of Israel, made history by becoming the first Arab leader to step foot onto the Israeli state.
The visit paved the way for an agreement between Egypt and Israel; the deal, however, was negotiated without Palestinian representation and left them feeling gravely betrayed.
In this episode of MEE’s history series Turning Point, we take a look at how the 1979 Egypt-Israel peace treaty legitimised Israeli occupation and how it impacted the Palestinian struggle for liberation.
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEastEye_TG
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
In geopolitics, there are no permanent allies, only permanent interests.
Arabs used to say: there is no peace without syria and there is no war without Egypt!
Indeed!
This is a quote made by Henry Kessinger btw
For all here, why Turkiye army stay in Syria yet?
@@lauradelacosta because of their own interests.
Sadat betrayed with the blood of those soldiers who sacrificed their lives in Yom kippur war , six day war , suez crisis. May Allah grant jannah to the soldiers who died to free Palestine 😥😥😥
they did not die to free palestine, they died to free Sinai
@@lail_vinciguerra wrong and even if it were true that still leaves all the wars prior to 1973. Thousands died for Palestine before Sinai was occupied
the route cause was Palestine in 1948 the other wars we were attacked because of our support to them but when you say for Palestine that means a lot and most important that they were never grateful so better for them to say that we had those wars for us and we made peace to stop the spelling of the Egyptian blood in order to serve the Palestnians@@eiadessam1
@@eiadessam1 true. Everyone is now blaming Egypt but other powerful Muslim countries like Pakistan didn't even send a troops or weapon to Arabs when they were fighting against Israel and it's European and american ally
A key factor missed in this report was Kissenger's involvement in double crossing both Egypt and Syria
Where can I get more info on Kissinger's involvement. Somehow, giving into outrageous demands, getting nothing in return but future promises and then being betrayed on those promises seems to be the pattern of Zio-Arab deals.
@@Seeker024 HyperNormalisation documentary by Adam Curtis it's on my page
Well u lost the war
@@anshuraj4277 Well you lost your ability of comprehension! I know context is an alien concept for the cow beer people!
@@Seeker024 HyperNormalisation documentary by Adam Curtis
Points to Israel: Egypt recognized and signed a peace deal with Israel: number of conflicts between Israel and Egypt since then: 0
Very informative and real journalism
great work Aaya .. and friends. with context comes reason. always question legitimacy 🌹
Thank you exprene all this timk❤❤❤
better called Treachery Treaty
Nothing treacherous about it. Without it Palestinians would be resisting in port Fouad not Gaza. Egypt took back Sinai Israel couldn’t get a warm peace with Egypt in return. Egypt got the better end of the stick. Palestinians should have joined Egypt, we wouldn’t be where we are.
Indeed. This treaty opened the door for the assasination of King Faisal after Sadat devastated the Arab unity. Also Palastinians started scrambling to get a deal after the betrayl of the big brother.
@@alaanasser3243 Sadat didn’t devastate Arab unity 😂 if anything Sadat was the only red pilled leader of his time. He knew very well how the world functions for real and tricked the system by taking back his lost territory. The fact that Arabs (who betrayed him during war time) went mad that he went to sign a treaty is a different story. King Hussein of Jordan went to Israel to tell them of zero hour, and Syria had already withdrawn from the golan with a secret deal with Israel long before camp David. Fact is Sadat knew Israel was sitting with Arabs behind his back and all he did was publicize the one for Egypt.
Arab unity took a hit when the war in Yemen took place (which Nasser helped prolong) and when the Algerians funded the Polisario front against their neighbors Morocco (Nasser also played a role in that). You want to blame disunity in Arab world blame Nasser who was an anti royalist and pig headed about turning every arab country into a republic not Sadat 😂
@@almaghnatees Palestinians don't need Egypt
Egyptians shouldn't be dreaming about defeating Israel and trow Israelis into the sea
they gut stupid and lost very badly
and it is a betrayal because they recognized Israel in return of Arab Muslim lives and lands they could stay and fight and get back their lands from tiny little Israel but they choose to sell their kin
Sadat got back Egyptian territory because he represented EGYPT. I don't understand the obligation outside of Egyptian citizens.
He's already burning in fire 🔥
For this terrible decision
I truly don't understand why Egypt gets it's balls broken for making a deal with Israel to get EGYPT'S territory back. Sadat represented the citizens of Egypt, not every Arab or Muslim on earth.
Because pan Arabism was prominent back then and many Arab states fought israel
@@suleyman8696 of course I'm familiar with the movement, of course if it was called pan Europeanism it would be labeled a hate group. I don't understand the need for an identity outside of the individual and their family, this kind of thinking causes the world's ills.
The real intention of Israel was to avoid any conflict with Egypt in the future for the sake of its interest.
“Peace treaties” in Israeli dictionary mean “stalling”!!!
Great video thanks a lot
For some reason, the Arabs despite being powerful, seem to have considered themselves on the backfoot in every deal with the Zios. For instance, clearly Israel would have badly wanted to have Suez access, yet somehow Sadat back in the day, didn't seem to think this a good enough concession to force the Zios to yield. Same with Yasser Arafat in the Oslo deal. He was offering them security which they did badly want. But yes, there is the factor that the US was a hidden player in the game.
The real intention of Israel was to avoid any conflict with Egypt in the future for the sake of its interest.
This was NEVER or will it EVER be a so-called jewish homeland. Got it!
Did she call it the Jewish homeland???
😮
No
Israel after Yom kippur war forced to sit on negotiation table
relevant history. 1. Roam booted jues.
2. Jues went to Isaiah 42 mt selah Medina.
3. Most jues reverted to Islam & returned to Quds under Umar w/ no Ioss of Iife.
4. Kahzers in the 800s converted... these are the Zl0s today, no tie to the Iand.
5. Saudis & Egypt in 73 did oil boycott to get back sanai, lran in 79 helped bibi by going after lraq like they did in yemen..
To say bibi belongs in Palestine due to his faith is like saying he should be in a native American camp because he started to worship trees
bibi in 2019 even said support Ham@z as an excuse to take Iand
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
5 is wrong. Iran didn't attack Iraq, Iraq attacked Iran. Stop lying. Iran did more for the Pals than any other country.
It's the biggest prize given to Israel! If Egypt returned to the equation, everything would change!
It cannot today, Egypt is heavily dependent on US aid due to this desl
As much as I like Sadat, as much as I hate camp David agreement, it shouldn't happen at all, now we all can see the consequences.
As an Egyptian born in the 2000s, I still see Israel as the real enemy even if I was born in the false peace era brought by the camp david treaty that does not represent the true Egyptian opinion. My father was still a kid at the time and he wasn't supporting the treaty as well as the majority of the Egyptians but, Egypt was - and still - not lead by a leader who speaks in the name of the people, it is always lead by a leader who is coward and just a USA follower. I hereby address that I don't approve of the peace treaty and that I - and my generation - will not forget the IOF crimes and atrocities and I will not forgive them. I also believe that in the end we will win the war and Palestine will be free.
Most Egyptians don’t mind Israel despite the Ztresty. But recognise that their economy would collapse without the yearly US aid if they left the Treaty.
Also Palestinians are a security threat to Egypt. Just as the Palestinians causes civil wars in Jordan and Lebanon in the past.
Time to face reality and move away from false pride.
May Allah rewards you more in this world snd the hereafter you speak the absolute true. But mr Mohamad Morsi was a great president❤
@@WahedaRajbally
Ameen and to you too sister. I agree with you, he was the only one who came by true and fair elections. I forgot to address that but he truly was a true man and real president.
Today Gaza. Tomorrow Egypt and every Egyptian will curse both Sedat and Sissi.
Nope. If Morsi was around, Egypt would be a Balkanized country with Sinai gone and Cairo seiged like Gaza. Jog on
@@almaghnateescope
@@soulsmouls anyone coping it’s you Ekhwanis 😂
The Israelis couldn't even take two tiny Egyptian cities during the last war with Egypt ' yom kippur war' although the Egyptian army was much weaker than the current one, so please go read some military magazine or something to know what a conflict with Egypt can cost not just to Israel but to America and to the European supporter, before making a laugh out of yourself!
@@almaghnatees ekhwa what? Speak english buddy
Those territories were not illegally captured. They were captured in a defensive war which is legal under international law.
1967 war wasn’t a defensive war, Zionist regime/Nazi criminals attacked their neighbours first!
Still,the state of Israel created in 1948 resulted in the forced expulsion of Palestinians known as the Nakba.I wonder If the territories you mentioned were already captured before the Six Day War.History isn't so simple.It's not black and white.Maybe there should be more research on this,this time from an Arab Perspective.
The 1948 was a war in which the arab countries attacked, and thereafter lost territory. It's better to read history from more than one source.
@@beniluv3250
Arab countries attacked in response to ethnic cleansing of Palestinian by Irgun-Lehi-Haganah terrorists “whom later became the IDF” 🇮🇱terrorists massacred Palestinian villagers in Deir Yassin, Lydda, Hebron & Safed in 1948.
….besides it is illegal under UN guidelines to build settlements or claim sovereignty on captured land during conflict!
@@beniluv3250 Maybe it's because of the Nakba,the event of what the Zionists did to the Palestinians.
Great information thank you ✊💔✊❤️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 Save Gaza
Egypt will be drawn into action at some point
This focuses too much on Egypt however it should be understood that it was also a major missed opportunity for Israel which could have unilaterally given the territories autonomy on its own terms thereby sidelining the PLO
#freePalestine #ProtectGazaWomen #saveCongo #saveSudan
@TheMiddleEastLIE
Diplomatic relations with Egypt in exchange for 60,000 km is no deal 😢😢😢 so what Israel did not have any diplomatic relations with Egypt 👍👍 so what Egypt’s area would’ve been around 990,000 km 👍👍👍 it was a loss deal for Israel from the start 😢😢😢😢
The Israelis figured out they can't sustain a long term war with Egypt, not just because of Egypt's size but Because Egypt is too influential in both the Arab and the Muslim world so when Egypt goes to war against Israel, many countries join the "holy expedition" and things might escalate into a f***in world war III !
It happened in the times of the crusades and it might happen again in the future, who knows!
Israel was forced lindu to give back sinai by force
Egypt was desperate for Suez Canal which takes huge part of national GDP. Israel only used Sinai as buffer zone. Both win win situation
@@tarekadelmohamedmohamed1750 lol force Sinai campaign will be only campaign where the victor gives territory to the looser pissfool
@@tarekadelmohamedmohamed1750 don’t bark on matters you don’t know pissfool
Sadat was killed by a egyptian.
Worth mentioning that the Palestinian and other Arab states were offered a seat in the r table to come and negotiate but they chose to boycott the negotiations
I still don’t get why Egypt didn’t accept to take back the Gaza Strip in addition to the Sinai! If they did the situation for Gaza wouldn’t be what it is today! Israel probably couldn’t touch them!
Egypt exchanged the Holly land of Jerusalem with uninhabitable land of Sinai peninsula. Too cheap too cowardice action from the only mighty military at that time. Better days are for the most resilient citizens on Earth, namely Palestine
Nope. Egypt didn’t have Jerusalem to exchange Sinai with. Nothing cowardice, smart. If only Palestinians were this smart and not driven by stupid Ekhwan
@@almaghnateesEgyptians are cowards
Egypt realized that it couldn’t win a war with Israel. 😂 😂
Munich ahhhh treaty💀
What a traitor who sold Palestine for crumbs of bread from the United States.
relevant history. 1. Roam booted jues.
2. Jues went to Isaiah 42 mt selah Medina.
3. Most jues reverted to Islam & returned to Quds under Umar w/ no Ioss of Iife.
4. Kahzers in the 800s converted... these are the Zl0s today, no tie to the Iand.
5. Saudis & Egypt in 73 did oil boycott to get back sanai, lran in 79 helped bibi by going after lraq like they did in yemen..
To say bibi belongs in Palestine due to his faith is like saying he should be in a native American camp because he started to worship trees
bibi in 2019 even said support Ham@z as an excuse to take Iand
they say occupying is Zl0 defense not offense.
False. Pre & post 1948 Zl0 oppressors Iie on Arabs, etc. Key incidents include 1948 K. David HoteI, 54 Iavon affair, Iiberty & O9 - OlI, lraq wmd Iies etc. Bibi even said the last 2 are good for us answering the qui bono w/ audio on yt!
Some ppl claim the bible says it's their land, 1st it's no authority & what verse?
Read point 4 and rev 2.9 & 3.9.
The children of Abraham are Ismailis who learned Arabic and jues who learned Arabic and became Muslim.
Even eldest lsraeIi prime m's have Palestine certificates ...
- King Saud Told FDR, the longest usa president, to be anti ZlO, he agreed but FDR mysteriously passed.
- Iobby of ZlOz was influential after, JFK & RFK both opposed them as well but both passed.
- Saudis & Egypt in 73 did oil boycott to get back sanai, lran in 79 helped TeIl Aveav by going after lraq like they did in yemen..
- in the 2000s She'uh neo cons like Chalabi Iied on lraq wmds.
israel fired on the usa and covered it ip to get the upper hand on egypt. otherwise egypt would have the golan heights. what else would on except.
How can you say the peace treaty hasn't brought much peace?
That's stupid
Why Israel violate not respect egypt may be if Pres Mohamad Morsi he respect. Sisi he is good friend in money. Peace not ummah but in hell
Allah with them Palestine will be free insha Allah
#ICC4ISRAEL #BoycottIsrael #BDS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Stop worrying
These problems will end globally naturally with out a single los of life or resources in every culture and society to personal or individual levels.ok
This was a treaty of shame for the coward Egyptians.
they say occupying is Zl0 defense not offense.
False. Pre & post 1948 Zl0 oppressors Iie on Arabs, etc. Key incidents include 1948 K. David HoteI, 54 Iavon affair, Iiberty & O9 - OlI, lraq wmd Iies etc. Bibi even said the last 2 are good for us answering the qui bono w/ audio on yt!
Some ppl claim the bible says it's their land, 1st it's no authority & what verse?
Read point 4 and rev 2.9 & 3.9.
The children of Abraham are Ismailis who learned Arabic and jues who learned Arabic and became Muslim.
Even eldest lsraeIi prime m's have Palestine certificates ...
it was a blank peace, that's what real peace is. Give Israel the lands back to Palestine, otherwise there will never be peace
In this treaty Egypt played very well and got rid of the Palis. Very clever move.
Gaza could join Egypt, get full Egyptian citizenship rights, but have their own autonomy. Egypt in return can have a share of oil in Qaza. West bank can also join Jordan but having their own autonomy and citizenship. Monarchy investment in their region will improve their lives. Indigenous people never treated equally in colonized states even after apartheid ends. Europeans are racist in vein. Pls are better off with their own. Disabled Pls will be distributed to the countries provide arm to Isr to be under their care for the rest of their life.
Egypt👎
Without this peace. Palestinians would be out of Palestine already. Egypt is an old civilization. Do not underestimate Egyptian ways and strategies. Knowing that all Arab countries are whether occupied, have civil wars, or rely mainly on Anglo-Saxon.
Very evil point of view, which is based on Palestinian lies this is really bad
This is really cute, starting from the peace treaty, and who do you think fought and died for Palestine before that treaty on multiple wars?, it was Egypt. I don't really understand what ME gets out from its constant smearing campaign of Egypt. But your agenda is very clear.
Just a few things:
Israel didn't want gaza snd wanted egypt to take it. Saddat refused. There were more settlements in Sinai than in Gaza.
Saddat was eventually assasinated, as common in the arab world.
Egypt been fighting the muslim brotherhood, which Hamas is a branch of, for many years. It's a peace based on joint goals and common enemy, allthough the egyptian won't say it, that's why the Gazans have so little support from egypt.
Both Egypt and Israel can be good neighbours to Gazans if they put down their arms and chose development instead of death.
Egyptian allready have problems with Isis and mb in Sinai, they don't need more redicals.
Here we go again ; another Arab crying about how the deal was an injustice; never mind Arabs rejected the first two state proposal. Get outta here with your crying…
They rejected giving their lands to foreign, murderous colonizers that came out of nowhere and getting nothing in return. Like most sane people would.
"Give me 50% of everything you own. I'll give you nothing in return. I'll also do unspeakable things to your loved ones." Would you accept this deal? No? Congratulations, you're an Arab.
like your cry on the H0e- Iocust?
why not question it? It's not true?
double standards or no free taIk?
yet there is no show biz like shoah biz!
why not question? Is it untrue?
double standards or no Iiberty?
@@marxistsabusegermansatn-bu38 Thats why everyone that matters doesn't support the Palestinian cause; they do it to themselves.
@Sunopeek Why is it theirs? Israel bought the land legally yet Arabs wanted to take it by force
Superb research. Shame on that traitor and current traitors signing a deal with the devil over the blood of the Palestinian children. Be prepared of God's wrath. Shame on you all.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Sorry but Palestinians biggest mistake is not taking the same deal that Sadat fought for and secured. Now their best hope is 10% of the land that they could have had back then. Israel played them into thinking they can have it all back.
This report fails to explain why the 5 years interim period didn’t lead to an independent Palestinian state as per the framework. It was because Palestinians were played like a fiddle by the Israelis as they managed to undermine the PLO’s authority and incited divide between Palestinians to make them believe that they can have all their land back and not just Gaza and the West Bank. Sorry but they should have taken the deal and remained united. That is not Egypt’s fault. Egypt got every inch of their land back. Sadat was a hero.
- King Saud Told FDR, the longest usa president, to be anti ZlO, he agreed but FDR mysteriously passed.
- Iobby of ZlOz was influential after, JFK & RFK both opposed them as well but both passed.
- Saudis & Egypt in 73 did oil boycott to get back sanai, lran in 79 helped TeIl Aveav by going after lraq like they did in yemen..
- in the 2000s She'uh neo cons like Chalabi Iied on lraq wmds.