Another win for the "I have always loved you", the sign language makes you read the subtitles. So you're not hearing it in anyone's voice but your own, making it that much more personal
@@CinemaWins PLEASE! Do an "Everything Great About" video on Legend of the Guardians The Owls of Ga'Hoole! Gorgeous visuals, a good story, a mythically beautiful soundtrack! That movie is SCREAMING for the treatment!
Sometimes when I sneeze I sneeze again right afterwards, also I sneeze like *insert the loudest noise making animal on earth here* and I snore in my sleep sooooooooo...... R.I.P me ;-;
Not sure if its allergies, but I am susceptible to sneezing fits, and will have 2 or 3 moments a week where I will just sneeze for 10-15 seconds straight. Sometimes I can catch it, and at least muffle the sound, but usually the first one gets through without warning! So I'd probably be in the same boat!
Mary Clare Mayo I think children can understand it to an extent. I know that when I become a father I’ll want to try to show my kids how much I love them but I know It’ll also never be enough.
I lost my dad a year ago. The fear goes both ways. The regret that I hadn't known somehow to call and say "I love you" sooner before his death haunts me. I hope my dad knew how much I adored him.
Yahhh, my mom died a month ago and I haven't even told her I loved her because in our family affection isnt all that normal, now I regret it and wished I said I loved her but all im sure is she loves me deeply. Mom died from a stroke and later was pronounced braindead
My mom has always had a hard time conveying to my siblings & I that she loves us. My dad however, is a completely different story. My father has always been the type of man who believed in our dreams, sometimes even more than us. He was always a very involved parent when I was growing up, I mean; he went to every parent teacher conference there was throughout each school year to check up on how we were doing in school, he volunteered to chaperone field trips on his days off from work, he came to all of our games/shows/etc. whenever we were involved in something in school. I remember there was this one time he told my sisters & I to get dressed up in our prettiest dresses and he took us to the fanciest restaurant I’ve ever been to in my life. He told us to order whatever we wanted and that the sky was the limit, needless to say we went berserk and ordered a bunch of food that we couldn’t even finish, but my dad didn’t care. He just wanted us to enjoy ourselves. Once dinner was over, he tipped our server $100 and we left the restaurant. The man was so shocked, he literally chased us out of the restaurant, telling my dad that he’d given him far too much money. My father just laughed and told him he’d given him just the right amount because he was such a great server to us that evening. When we got in the car to go home that night, my dad told us that if a man can’t treat us the way we were treated that night, not to even waste our time on dating him. Fast forward to now and my dad hasn’t been in the best health lately, he had a stroke in August last year and hasn’t really been the same, but when I went to visit him and my mom a couple of weeks ago, he made sure to tell me that my sisters and I are the best things to have ever happened to him and that he’s grateful and happy to be our father. It made me bawl my eyes out.
"Treating a battery operated toy like a live grenade with a pin removed" For some reason, I just really like the way you phrased that. You're really good at saying things in a way that's able to emphasize just how important some of these smaller moments are
@@earthisabignigga2026 Taking it a bit too literally, there. He meant like they were treating it like the thing could go off at any moment and kill them all. Cuz it could
@@booty_hunter4207 There's a lot of self congratulation in bad faith film criticism. It's some childish "I want to be cleverer than this movie" attitude and is so, so dumb.
I can attest to the fact that people find plot holes in real life stories. In college, I wrote an experience of mine as a creative writing project, and half the class found plot holes with it. It was a story about finding out that a high school friend of mine had committed suicide and my reaction, but the thing my classmates focused on was the *way* I found out. They insisted that “the main character” should have found out sooner. When I told them I had written it exactly as it had happened, they insisted it just wasn’t believable in a story.
I had done a similar project. I wrote about when the locks of my dad's old car broke and I was stuck inside. I am diabetic and had a low glucose at the time. I was about five or six when it happened. "If she was really that weak, the adrenaline would have helped her break the window." "Well why didn't he just smash the window with a rock?" "Why wouldn't he have snacks inside for her?"
I think it's due to things like "r/thathappened" People are so unwilling to believe anything interesting, and I think it's because they don't want to be wrong
Sadly, if that is a thing that all your readers are going to think, then that is something you're going to have to pay heed to. It doesn't matter if it's true if it's detracting from the reader's experience. Unless you have "A true story" in the title or something.
Something you said about people finding plot-holes in real stories made me laugh, because in high-school we had to write stories about overcoming adversity, and I wrote about an experience my family had gone through years before (the only thing I changed was names). I was told by my teacher that it wasn't realistic enough and wasn't very creative xD I was like... um... sorry my life is so unrealistic????
Generation kill is a TV miniseries about a reporter and a company of marines in the Iraq ( good series) it was written by the actual reporter it was based on who in an interview said they actually had to get rid of the some the stuff that actually happened so that it didn't look to unrealistic.
I just finished writing that essay! I haven't gotten my grades back but I also used a personal experience with my family. My teacher is nice so I hope she doesn't poke too many holes in it haha
The first time I watched this movie, I was at a friend's house and it was around midnight. Nobody else in the house was awake so the only sound was coming from the TV. When the lamp shattered towards the beginning, my friends dogs started barking from downstairs because of the sudden noise. I was so on edge and scared from the loud barking that I screamed without making noise, made the same face that Emily made and hid under my blanket. After the dogs stopped barking, I peeked out from under my blanket, and my friend who was on her phone laughed at me and I quickly shushed her. Long story short, the use of sound in this movie is phenomenal.
I watched the first hour of the movie with the volume playing on the speakers outside. My friend and I thought it was LITERALLY a quite place until my dad came home from work and asked why we had it playing outside. Yep.
Isn't it interesting how we take cues from people around us. I would guess from your comment that you normally scream out loud, but you were following the example of another person, Emily Blunt's character. We humans have awesome survival instincts that we don't realize we have until something like your experience shows that they exist.
yeah i remember after leaving the cinema i struggled to remember that it was all fiction! So i was speaking a little as possible and walking as steadily as possible. 😭
I really hate drawing attention to myself in class, so I've kinda trained myself to sneeze super quiet to the point that no one says bless you. People don't realize, but living in a world where you're essentially forced to be quiet, makes you start habits whether you like it or not (such as the mom's muffled scream even though she stepped on a nail). I feel like it's just cheap to call that a plot hole because those are loud things that can be easily trained out of.
-Yelling in pain= Can be trained to be locked off or muffled into silence -Sneezing= Some people are incredibly loud (myself included), but in times of need you can clamp your mouth shut and sneeze through your nose (more snot but quieter) or clamp your nose and mouth (causes it to go more for your ears which could cause infection issues and hurts, but is even quieter). My sneezes _hurt_ if I try anything to reduce them, but I can... -Yawning= Not too loud but to silence it, you can yawn with your mouth closed. -Burping= Again, mouth closed followed by a slight exhale. -Farting= This is where my brother would die... But if you clench your muscles hard, you can halt it in it's escape and either cause it to reverse direction for a time or it'll be more able to be controlled in short, quiet releases. The biggest downside is it's kind of painful inflating your intestine for a period of time. -Hiccoughing= Mouth shut, chest muscles clenched. Now you just have to deal with painful diaphragm contractions causing you to twitch/spasm... -No comment on labor...
@@DraconicDuelist my yawning is downright silent, with my mouth wide open. I don't even know why I do it like that. My burps are closed mouth, only sound being the ones I can't control.
This is so true. (rant below somewhat related) I've been thinking about this channel even more recently because of all the dumbass critic reviews of Bohemian Rhapsody, which is a fantastic film that did exactly what it set out to do and yet the critics are just determined to shit on it (though the audience seems to be loving it anyway, reminds me of the split that happened with Venom). Too many people go into a movie wanting to dislike it, like they think it makes them seem smart or something. With Bohemian Rhapsody, it takes 2 seconds of watching interviews to see how hard the actors worked to do the band justice. And all their dedication pays off, the movie is a celebration of Freddie, hugely entertaining and appropriately private a lot of the time. The critics who are mad that the film itself isn't more of an artsy rip-him-apart thing are just?? No one was setting out to upstage Mercury or exploit his story, it's a tribute and it's beautiful? Fuck off @ those critics. It's a total blast of a movie. TLDR this channel is a beautiful act of positivity & appreciation for art in a world that thinks it's cooler & smarter to be immune to all enjoyment. Joke's on them because like a great man once said "liking things is more fun than disliking things"
Ophelia W i don’t think all critics or people in general go into movies wanting to dislike them I think sometimes there’s just dumb things in movies people cannot get past but let’s be realistic here no one is going to like literally everything in the world And critics are still important it’s their job to make points about movies music games books etc in a argumentative way souly for arguments sake it’s kinda an acquired taste to have someone challenge the things you like and I think that’s a great thing because it leads to (ideally) new ideas and people going out of their comfort zone and questioning the things they do and don’t like. At the end of the day everything is opinionated for example you clearly really enjoyed the movie bohemian rhapsody if I go see it I may not like it and that’s okay if everyone liked the same things there would be no new ideas there would just be the same thing being created over and over sorry I typed a book at you.
Talking about your "People will find plot holes in real life accounts" point, my Grandfather was born just shortly after the turn of the century and so he lived through a LOT of history. After he retired, he and Grandma were living near a university that offered a free course for senior citizens, so Grandpa (who, btw, had for a number of years written a column for the local paper) decided to take a class on writing (he figured that you can always learn something new). So as he began this course on writing, he decided that he'd draw on his own experiences and write accounts of events from his life. The students that were with him in the class (a bunch of 20-something college students) told him multiple times that his writing wasn't good because the stories he wrote just weren't believable (again, he was writing about things that had happened to him during his life). So, yes, you are completely accurate with that statement.
True, but it is also a lot less black and white than that. The thing is, it's possible that your grandfather's life events wouldn't always make great storytelling. Life isn't a narrative; random things happen without any buildup, there's no rhyme or reason and people die without having achieved a successful character arc. Everyone's life is a TV show that gets cancelled mid-season. The problem is that inexperienced students still often pride themselves and place way too much stock in the concept of stories being "realistic" or "believable". These are toxic words for writers and a good teacher should stamp them out early. It is very possible to tell a story with the inherent randomness of everyday life, but other aspects need to be have some consistent narrative to satsify people's placement on patterns. So, things like, tone, setting, themes, motifs, etc. have to be little creative licenses that keep some form of structure. The randomness of life can make stories feel alive and pulse with ingenuity, it's a shame your Grandfather was with people who didn't understand that or a teacher who maybe hadn't had the chance to explain how to balance the two.
Why do the both of u talk for sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooolong
@@dannyanderson4385 I mean for them, yeah. But imagine your grandpa who might have thought "B-But its real!". People in general should just stop criticizing too much on facts and their version of "Realistic", your perspective of what's "real" can never be the same even to your twin......
Sir Turtle The Great your comment is literally better than this movie and I am laughing so hard right now omg Dear Mr.raccoon you lived a good life, of eating garbage and attacking buddy the elf rest in peace
8:12 He's not doing something stupid in this scene. Upon second viewing I realized that the tire in the corn field is perfectly placed, and it is an escape strategy that the family probably had in case someone was stuck in the middle of the sand path. It takes too long to run either way, so it's like a bunker in the middle of the path to wait things out and stay safe. He even shines the torch at the sand path later on, like it's something he's been told to do. It's another case of Krasinski trusting his audience, and it's a beautiful way of storytelling with set design.
I have a deaf cousin and I know from first hand experience. Deaf people have no idea how LOUD they are. They don't know that dropping things makes noise. They don't know that stomping around makes noise. They don't know hitting things makes noise. They can vocalize without really knowing they're making sounds. They can learn all these things, and the most determined can even learn to speak and read lips and seem able to hear to the average person. The sad thing is that those who try are often shunned by the deaf community.
I highly recommend the British RUclipsr Jessica Kellgren-Fozard, who is lovely and passes for hearing but is almost completely deaf because of a connective tissue disorder. She has so much to say about living with disabilities in general, and with the cultural realities of deafness in particular.
that is true i did a deaf course and learned that the deaf has a difficult time making the decision to hear or speak because there are members of the group that think being deaf should not be fixed or that they shouldn't aspire to learn vocalization since speech shouldnt be the ideal to reach for.
LOVED this movie, for all the things you brought up. One little detail I really liked that I noticed you didn't mention was that Reagan (the daughter) walked so carefully in comparison to the other characters, which makes sense seeing as she can't hear and wouldn't know how loud she was being so she would take extra precautions to be as quiet as she could
Oh I did. i had to take a good 10 minutes before I could do anything else, and was still thinking about the rest of the day. Or Maybe Im just really emotional...
Theres actually a bit when we see the dad working on the hearing aid that shows hes been increasing the sensitivity, which is why her aid specifically was affecting them and not, yknow, anyone elses. He was hot modding a sound device and just managed to find the frequency that would cause that feedback. That big plot hole is literally explained BY THE MOVIE in that scene if people bothered to pay attention and not just complain about something they missed.
Oh man, NEVER apologise for not being cynical enough. There's more cynics than we know what to do with; we need unashamed positivity. Especially about this movie. I honestly don't think I've related to anything more than the "people saying they would act perfectly rationally post-apocalypse so why can't the characters" mini-rant. And seriously, were people really complaining about the "(not) getting sucked into grain"? Did they also wonder why Rose didn't sink when she got on top of the door in Titanic..?
I tend to roll my eyes at the "i'm prepared for the apocalypse" rants, they take away the humanity, the reactions, the unexpectancy, no one can predict when something like that will happen so no one can be perfectly prepared or react fast enough to put their plan into action (and a lot of those people give WAAAAAAAAAY too much credit to themselves about what they can and can't do), An example that was given at school, someone asked "what would you do if you woke up and it was suddenly a zombie outbreak? his first response was "I'd get a gun" I butted in and asked "where would you get the gun from?" he said "from the gun store" I talked about how the nearest gun supplier is about an hour walk away so how would he get past the crowd............his answer was "with a gun".................this may be a bad example, but it just shows that just because you think you can do it.........doesn't mean you actually can
@@experiencemaster1743 Good point... also a gun is one of the worst weapons for something like that. The noise attracts everything for miles and the need of ammo makes it extremely limited. People are always smartasses about such things, including me, but I have no doubt that all that rational thinking goes right out the window in the stress of an actual crisis with actual stakes and with no extra lives/rewind option. Once the adrenaline kicks in you'd have to be highly trained and experienced with fear to keep a straight head. 99% of people won't though... no matter what they claim on the internet. That includes me. I'd probably be one of the first to go down, to be honest. :D
@@experiencemaster1743 Tell me about it... Let's be honest, come apocalypse time, the vast majority of us would be toast relatively quickly, no matter how smart we like to think we would be. Human error, irrational decision making, heck even just something like not looking where you're going or getting distracted by a fly or tripping over at the wrong time...people can pretend they'd act perfectly all they want but that in itself is not realistic (for a completely hypothetical scenario, anyway). At least I know myself well enough to know that it would take a miracle for me to survive in an apocalypse... Dammit, now I'm being cynical...
You learn them in the credits, unless you are openminded and don' know who Krasinski and Blunt are...then you might think John is named Millicent pr something like that lol
The Quiet Place just made me feel sad when the boy died. Not just because “Holy shit they actually went there they killed a young child nobody is safe now fuck”, but because, I have several younger siblings. A four year old, a two year old, and an eight month old. I can totally see the two year old grabbing a toy car, not knowing the consequences. I can imagine and FEEL the panic running towards him as he stands there innocently with a car in hand. I can see him in the boy’s place, gone instantly with a blur and splatter of blood. I can see the four year old just not being able to learn to be quiet. She’ll be screaming for something, she’ll be roaring as a dinosaur or a dragon, she’ll let out a loud laugh. She’d be gone too. The eight month old would just be crying or fussing. She’d be letting out loud wails inside our house, and suddenly, they’re inside. She’s gone, and no matter how hard we tried to be quiet, we’d start hyperventilating or just crying from fear, and since they’re *right there*, the house is suddenly empty. (Jeez I don’t even want to think about my dogs)
I loved this movie, it was one of the rare horror movies that wasn’t predictable, it had such a better approach, I often find things with simple themes the best, like, in this case, silence, or my favorite movie of all time, Alice in wonderland, based after insanity
Mark Grant but they can’t hear a pin drop 1 mile away, and it was light breaths, you can breathe without making sound and after *more than a year* Im sure they perfected that skill
Mark Grant it’s not all bad there’s still like amazing parts like the sound design and directing the plot is also quite good overall but there’s sum rlly shit holes in it
Dwight is living it up in his bomb shelter right now with Mose, Angela,and Phillip, eating canned foods, and meditating every morning and afternoon for one hour.
Can I just say, thank you? This was the first video of yours I saw, and I feel in love. A Quiet Place is one of my favorite movies of all time, and hearing the way you talked about it changed my entire view on the movie, especially the scene where Lee sacrificed himself. You do such an amazing job really just, explaining everything in such good detail, it leaves me completely satisfied with the movie, and all others you explained. This one just really.. really hit me.
What I love about this channel is I find it will often either go places I didn't consider, or farther with things I did consider with films I love- or just points out the things I love and it's wonderful to see someone else appreciates those aspects... OR- It will make me appreciate movies I think are bad by helping me see the good in them. Like- I can appreciate things in Origins Wolverine asides from the opening montage and some camera work, and when I clicked on the everything great with I thought the idea of having that much good (I forget the length) was absurd and would need serious padding- and it was honest, with great points and no padding. In fact- come to think of it- I think that was the first one I clicked on because of how bad and disappointing I thought it was going to be an effort I would find funny and full of fail- and instead I was amazed that I actually agreed with the points made. I don't want to really compare channels- but I would rather watch something that's playing as I do things that's designed to make you see good things in such a range of movies, including ones that really weren't that great, than ones that just tear movies down. I'm not singling out a channel I'm sure most people automatically jump to with that description- truth is there are many channels who gain viewers by tearing things down, and in ways that just aim to be funny by being mean. This, Movies with Mikey... they really talk about the things to love and appreciate about SO many movies- Though it is funny one one of FilmJoy channel's ongoing releases where they specifically try to find the good in bad movies, when they end up with movies that are so bad they struggle to find the good in it... that doesn't happen often, and it helps me appreciate films more.
I absolutely loved the scene where they dance with the earbuds because I think it demonstrates how strong their bond is, the apocalypse hasn't destroyed their relationship, but strengthened it
It is actually so satisfying when you talk about cinematography It just makes me appreciate it in films so much more Also I love your logic and reasoning and time for research Like a lot of people never think about the bigger picture
Did you know it was originally "I love you" and Millicent, the actress playing Regan, suggested that it should be "I have always loved you"? Made John cry too.
At the end of the day, people need to realize that the stories we tell are about people and people ain’t perfect. I do dumb things all the time and often I’m not under the stress brought on by an alien invasion. The fact is that we have a bias. When I do stupid things, I have excuses. When other people do stupid things, they have no excuse. Side note: Can we make up our minds, everyone? Do we want exposition or do we not want it? I hear people constantly yelling about “show not tell,” but as soon as something isn’t explicitly stated everyone cries plot hole.
Is it really that hard for people to just use their head for like, 5 minutes instead of crying out "This was a crappy script, the writer/director is a hack, I hope they never find work again!" as soon as a question presents itself? It betrays a real lack of imagination. Honestly, if you're too lazy to pay attention instead of childishly nitpicking/ranting, that's your fault, not the film-makers'. It's not rocket science, people....
I know, right? I feel like Internet movie critics have no ability to draw implications or inferences. There was this one video analyzing Rey and Kylo's relationship over TFA and TLJ, and a bunch of people in the comments were saying that nothing in the video was stated in the movies. Of course, everything in the video was based on the movie's implications, not explicit statements, because the movies don't go into psychological explanations of their characters.
The scream the father does to save the children has so much feeling it, honestly made me cry. It wasn't just about making noise because anything could do that, the scream conveys so much in it, the pain of it all so speak.
I...yeah. The "plot holes" people bring up here bother me more than they usually do too. Maybe it's because I grew up on a farm. I know a little something about corn/grain safety. I know how much a person can get done in a 14-hour day. I know what it's like to live near acres of sand. Blah. Thank you for being a beacon of positivity for this tremendous film!
So I know this comment is super old, but I'm here anyway. You were agreeing to him saying that no matter how 'bad' what's happening in the movie is, if it made you feel how the director intended, it's a 'good' moment. I absolutely agree too. I'll never understand people who get angry at authors/screenwriters for doing bad things in movies; specifically killing off beloved characters. An example that springs to mind is The Hunger Games books. Towards the end of the final book, a central and beloved character is killed off in a brutal and heartbreaking fashion, and readers were so upset that this happened that many stopped reading out of outrage at the author. But? If you were so invested in this character that their death upsets you this much, then the author did a great job? And as upsetting as this is, if it's making you feel something real, then it's a great moment? It's like how I feel about my favourite tv show (which I won't name because saying this is sort of a giant spoiler). The final episode ends with almost everyone outside of the main character dying, and this one character having to live on after losing everything important to him. This is Not the satisfying conclusion I wanted and expected for my favourite character, but I'm Glad it ends this way, because if I can be this heartbroken over people that don't really exist, then it's true art. I could go on about this forever, but bottom line is: no matter how objectively good or bad a movie is, I usually only judge it based on whether it made me feel anything. Whether that be simple enjoyment of a fun but simple story, or bawling-my-eyes-out heartbreak, if I felt something and wasn't just passive, then it's a good movie.
Something that Cinema Therapy pointed out: John is one of the best expression actors on the planet. He can convey so so so so so much with just a look; just with his eyes. What an actor
I was scared to make a single sound during this movie. The entire theatre was dead silent. Even breathing was hard. You could've heard the drop of a pin two streets away. This is how intense this movie is. Even this video, where I can hear you talking it still feels intense. It's so sad that almost every horror movie today is either about demonic possession, ghosts or serial killers. And they're all the same
Eh- I think cornmeal staying like that would be harder to believe, even if the animals eat it- that stuff breaks down pretty quickly and any amount of moisture would just make it mush... And continuing to grind it would be noisy. My feeling was they were either near sand naturally- you can find it in rocky areas 'cause it's just ground rocks really, or if there's a sand/salt storage place for winter storms, they would have access to sand that would seriously last 1 family laying little trails for years and years... and there's a mix of both. They're by a waterfall- likely there's sand around and by the water they can scoop out and dry in a pinch. Though my feeling was probably just getting it from where it's stored for bad weather. Even in places that may get ice a couple of times every few years they usually have piles of sand somewhere just in case, even if they don't spend the money on mountains of salt...
-I remember thinking about how the military apparently hadn't come up with anything to fight back against the aliens, but before the video I started thinking: With how fast the aliens are and how loud the military is, they would be too panicked and focused on defense rather than offense. I also thought about how the movie only shows ONE town and never really mentions another, for all we know another state could be heavily fortified and have actually found a way to fight back somehow, but are too afraid to contact anyone else in case they endanger someone or themselves. -I also love how this movie is both vague and explanatory with it's scenes. For example, two scenes: the old man screaming and the other families not responding to the beacon. The first scene with the old man is explanatory but no one mentions a thing. He's lost his wife and has nothing else to live for, he's old and probably a bit loose in the head so he just gives up and screams. The second scene is a bit vague but not a giant plot hole. We're led to believe that the other survivors have been killed since they didn't respond. But given how much noise is coming from outside and the pure chaos happening, why would anyone want to go outside? For all we know they could be huddled down in a bunker? Or maybe they are dead. And I just love that mystery of it.
jacob=that was not a PLOT==if people would just enjoy the movie instead of trying to figure out a PLOT that did not exist===the movie would not ever been made====geesh !
Honestly, I DO think that he would write “WEAKNESS” on the whiteboard. I’ve done it when writing both creatively and on math papers out of pure frustration in that I don’t know what to do.
Tabby Cat I’ve definitely wrote “FUUUUUUUUCCCCCCKKKKK” on essay papers when I can’t think of what to write out of sheer frustration so definitely agree
Definitely one of your best videos yet. There's nothing wrong with analyzing a movie and pointng out story problems when needed, but sometimes it feel like people would rather prove themselves intellectually superior than actually get invested in media.
Spongey444 I super agree with this. I do appreciate people who look at films, books, or video games with a critical eye(it’s something I’m learning to do myself) but I also feel that if someone is talking about a plot hole/story issue they should actually check if it’s actually one/is explained in said media before declaring its one right off the bat.
For example (if your still confused about the ear piece and the alien) it's like when you pit a microphone really close to the speaker, it's two amplifiers reacting to each other
well i understand what u mean its like a magnet. let me explain: so the alien is a + and the noise is -. so when + hears - it goes toward it but the ear piece is also a + so when to +´s are near they push away from each other
Raccoons are like honey badgers. But instead of being brutish and defensive like one, they are sneaky and agile. It's like a honey badger is a warrior build while a raccoon is a rouge build. I absolutely love raccoons, they are like cats, but more funny.
@@antonmariusiulian6942 Because for one it would increase your bulk carrying stuff to throw, meaning its alittle more difficult to move quietly, maybe not by much but whats the point of taking an unnescessary risk and there is not guarantee the sound would be off putting enough to make the alien run after it. "Why not carry something that could make sound to throw?" Once again, unnescessary risk, you risk the noise maker drawing them to you more or it may go off randomly while you carry it.
@@williamaldred335 it doesn't have to be something big. For example you could carry something like some small rocks, maybe 4 for every monster and they could be used in emergency situations
@@williamaldred335 Well the dad is a pretty good engineer from what we were shown in the film so maybe he could set up some devices that could be turned on in the bunker to draw away the monsters with sound
@@antonmariusiulian6942 Like I said, whats the point of carrying extra weight when you can just stop and let it pass and there is no guarantee they would go for that sound over another
John and Emily's first movie together and they NAIL it!! The chemistry btwn them is insane!! The entire movie is so suspenseful, and actually terrifying due to lack of any noise!! DEF one of THE best movies of 2018!!
Everything great about The Prince of Egypt PLZ. That movie needs some recognition. The music. The voice acting. The story. All brilliant. It's too good to gloss over as just a religious film and the celebrity voice actors aren't too distracting. It's one of DreamWorks' first animated movies and it shows that they have lots of potential in 1999. Sure the company made some bad films, but remember, they're the ones that made the How to Train your Dragon movies & those are also masterpieces. So please, give this movie the recognition it deserves.
As someone who works on a farm, the silo scene is not only realistic, but realistically terrifying. That and falling through holes in the hayloft are top 2 fears
When I first saw this movie in theatres, the sound cut out like 10 minutes from the ending and we all just thought it was a part of the movie since some of it was completely silent anyways. It wasn't until after the movie I heard someone say it wasn't supposed to be like that lol.
Ok, so about the baby. It's my belief that Emily and John's characters wanted to have the child. John has long stated that this movie is a sort of love letter to his children, and it's my belief that the baby is Johns way of saying to his real life children, "You matter to me, and I would never regret having you". Or something like that.
I like how they grow corn because it’s pretty loud lived between two fields that regularly grew corn and especially on windy days it would make a lot of noise and allow for them to live a normal life
I know your comment is two years old now, but I hope you don't mind lol. You actually do bring up a really interesting question. How would wind affect this world? Strong winds can make hearing things more difficult for the monsters just like it does with humans.
The way you described how the aliens were affected by the EMF's was very well done also very good job on explaining the plot holes it really makes me appreciate this movie Alot more than I already do😄
@@hazardous8301 His roles rarely fit him properly, but he brings a *ton* of energy to most of his roles and is generally fun to watch. I'd say he was readily available and willing to work with whoever. He's a genuinely good guy, so that may have added to it. These are only guesses though, based on how he's practically in at least one movie per year since '81.
You need to watch his finest performances: Joe, Matchstick Men, Adaptation, Leaving Las Vegas, Moonstruck, Lord of War. Nicholas Cage is top tier when he is more toned down, but he likes to experiment with his acting doing weird accents, ticks, noises, exaggerated moves. He's a performance artist, but he is a solid actor too.
Another great thing about the movie that some people might not understand is why the old man waited for them to be near him before screaming. His scream was intentional, after of course his wife was dead right beside him. He had just lost his own wife and was alone. He wasn't trying to get the father and son killed, but screamed so he wouldn't have to live without his wife.
I agree that it's a dick move. But tbh if I'd just lost someone I've dedicated my life and love to I wouldn't honestly be concerned with this "random" child and father in front of me. I'd be in emotional pain and I'd just be ready to die. Like I said I agree it's a dick move, but it's not completely unrealistic.
okleigh I would be concerned, especially for the child. I'd motion them to run away before joining the dead, if I decided to make the decision at all to die.
@@fredericksaxton9782 good for you, you're not overwhelmed by your emotions. That's commendable but not everyone will have that kind of thought process in the middle of an apocalyptic world where their wife just died.
I have exactly one complaint to do with this movie, and it's nothing to do with the movie itself. And it's actually not really that much of a complaint. A sequel has been confirmed, set in the same world with the same characters (and, right now, it _is_ looking like it comes after this movie chronologically, so, a sequel, not a prequel). I'm absolutely more than okay with that. My only real concern is how they're going to keep the tone from this film while still having it make sense for the characters. Like, this movie ends with the implied tone of "Now that we've figured out these things' weakness, we're gonna go hunt them down and take back our world." Which I, personally, think sounds like a pretty dang awesome idea for a story. The only question I have is how/if they could make a movie based on that premise that still falls under "horror thriller" category. Like, I'm sure there are plenty of successful series that changed genres between movies, but I can't think of any off the top of my head. However, at the same time, I can't really think of how they could put the same characters in the same setting and still have it be a "horror thriller" without undoing their arcs and making Lee's sacrifice less impactful. If I could pick, I'd be 100% okay with the first movie being a thriller story about a family quietly surviving an alien invasion together, and the second being an action story about the same family loudly stomping around the world, challenging the aliens to avenge those they've lost. Call it "A Louder World" or something equally cheesy and fun. If Krasinski is good enough to pull it off - which I think he's proven he can - it'll be pretty awesome.
Some film series do that though. Like the. Unbreakable - Split - Glass, Trilogy Unbreakable was a drama/mystery. Split was a thriller psychological horror. and Glass was a drama/fantasy film. it went from. im a vigilante, to im gonna kidnap and eat girls alive, to oh super heros are real btw, and we have organisations designed to take them down and pretend that they are dillusional coz we hate super heros. my point being it can work habing sequels in different genres.
it’s like harry potter, for example. the first movie is over, and it gives soooo much closure, but it’s not over yet, they haven’t defeated the ‘bad guy.’ movie and book makers tend to make you think ‘ok, problem solved! how much more could go wrong?!’ but they always find something. take stranger things. season two’s ending: ok, the hate is closed, it’s just like it was before, because nothing else can come out of the upside down! but we knew there were more season, and we knew that the duffer brothers were going to think of something. and they did.
that didn’t really get to the point at all, but what i’m saying is there’s still plenty of problems that could come up in the sequel, and it definitely could still be horror.
Okay, so they expect us to buy that they only thought to bring 20 lifeboats for all 2000 passengers, and not even fill them all the way? And then a piece of ice just sinks a 50 THOUSAND ton ocean liner made of mild steel, on her maiden voyage, with a decorated captain at the helm? And I'm just sick of them hitting us over the head with the message. We get it: Titanic, slain by the gods for getting too cocky. 'Unsinkable,' human hubris, lol we're so educated. Here's a hint, Cameron. Subtlety. Use it. Try tying it into the story next time instead of spoonfeeding us with pretentious highschool philosophizing. What else is playing?
@@williamaldred335 They were trying to explain a real scene in a sarcastic way showing that people wouldn't believe a real event if they didn't know it was real. I think either you didn't understood the meaning of the comment or you did and made a funny comment which I didn't understand.
@@williamaldred335 I mean, 80% of why Titanic sunk was because someone forgot something burning inside and fucked everything up from there. That could be a movie on its own to be fair
When my family first watched it, I think I was the only one actually watching it since we were playing a board game while it was on. After it was over, I told them that I thought it was one of the best movies I have ever seen. They said it was alright, so I dont think they were even really watching it.
Ugh! I hate when people only second-hand watch movies/tv! I get why it happens, I'm guilty of it myself, but sometimes it really irks me. I usually do it with shows I know well/ aren't exactly "high art" lol. Like, if a friend is showing you a movie they really enjoy and want you to enjoy, don't be on your fucking phone half the time! Sorry, it's just a big pet peeve of mine I guess.
By far THE BEST video you’ve EVER put out! Well done on sharing your personal thoughts and experiences as a parent and how this movie displayed them! Even though I do not have kids, nor have I seen the movie, the self-sacrifice scene gets to me because I would do ANYTHING to save my family from such a fate. When I first watched this video about a month ago, your commentary almost made me cry because of how thoughtful, personal, relatable and well-written it was. Keep making videos of this caliber. Your other videos are also fantastic, but this one is REALLY next-level!
Their son dying at the beginning was heartbreaking but _absolutely_ necessary to take the story to a whole other level It defines all the characters from that moment on, and makes the movie more about their love and emotion and not just about danger
I normally hate scary movies. Refuse to watch them. But my boyfriend brought me to see this one and I actually kinda liked it. But watching this video made me appreciate the movie even more and now I actually like the movie. Thank you for helping me to realize the genius that is this movie.
This is the first movie in such a long time that, after I collected myself from watching it for the first time, I immediately watched it again... and have watched several times since. I'm in love with the love story that Emily and John portray in this movie and the strength this family has despite literally everything going wrong. Probably one of the most beautiful and relatable 'horror' movies to date.
@@paytoncordova8598 While I thought Kubo's art style was stunning and the moral of the story was a good one, I'm not a fan of the sometimes choppy animation style it uses and the story itself is extremely predictable (While watching it I could literally tell how scenes would play out at the start of a scene), so while overall it is a beautiful looking (and sounding) movie, it played it a bit too safe imo
@@runefish1043 Yeah, I'll agree with you on that, vut the sheer amount of work that was put into the animation (i.e. building a 9 foot tall sekeleton puppet) is currently unparalleled. But the imagination put into Coraline and The Boxtrolls was incredible. And the Horror genre jokes in ParaNorman and that super emotional ending was awesome. Each movie has their own faults, they are by no means perfect, but still they deserve the attention.
Payton Cordova Couldn't agree more! tbh, I didnt know they put that much effort in it, I guess I'll just have to rewatch it someday to truely appreciate it.
ive been seeing everywhere that this movie is a 'Plot hole withe a story' but literally everything they say can be debunked pretty easily. People just like to act smart instead of being smart by doing stuff like poke holes in movies
IMO, the waterfall is still a logic issue to me, but it’s not a plot hole per se. I can enjoy the movie while ignoring the waterfall, but it would have been nice to get something in the movie explaining that.
2E the first That is what truly bothers me too, sure some of it can’t be answered and it’s not always realistic but then you wouldn’t have so many great stories to chose from.
N8 Dawg Waterfall creates noise that the creatures know that it isn’t some person or animal, if a snake attacked a warm rock it would just be wasting energy and hurting itself. These creatures know enough to tell the difference between one noise from another and it seemed to have been a pretty recent discovery and it would just be too much work and time and noise to move everything that they have that has been working out great for them. Even then the waterfall is certainly not a perfect system that they certainly didn’t have the time to test out considering the potential loses that could come from it failing.
I never understood why the dad took the son with him and not the daughter but you said it: the daughter needed to be home if the mother went into labor and the son needed to overcome his fear. Perfect!
Also it’s not impossible to believe that they didn’t conceive the child before the aliens came, or even before they knew it hunted by sound. And if you will notice the mother wasn’t supposed to give birth for another month. They were still working on the soundproof room, because they thought they still had time, they didn’t work on it sooner because other things likely took precedence over an event that was still months away from being an issue. Also regarding the nail. I’m sure she knew she pulled it up, but she’s like 8months pregnant and carrying a large load of laundry she had other concerns, I’m sure she was originally planning to bend the nail down again, but before she got there she went into labor
She got pregnant some time after losing their 4y/o showed by it going from day ~89 to day ~470, about 100 days after as she was about 38 weeks pregnant. Also to add to your point, i assume that knowing you're pregnant in an apocalyptic scenario is hard at first as you won't have a pregnancy test easily available. So they would have lost some time due to that, like a month or so
I agree with everything after your first sentence. There is literally no way she got pregnant before the aliens attacked or after they knew they hunted by sound. They were already months into the "apocalypse" when their son died, and then they skipped to past day 400. Pregnancies only last 9 months, so no, she couldn't have been pregnant before.
Can't believe 311 other idiots don't realize pregnancy is 9 months or about 270 or so days...the youngest died on day 89...day 472 is 383 days later. that is one year and 23 days LATER...idiots
If we did a CinemaWins vs CinemaSins battle, how would it work, would it be in the style of Jeremy's Conversations with Myself or would it be a video with the two sides going back and forth retracting each other's points until one side had a clear victory? Either way, it would be amazing to see.
TheHero136 Cinemawins would win not because he would compliment jeremy's narration but because he would me the listeners feel that they arnt stupid because they dont see Why something is wrong in a film or the video he would show us also what we may have missed
@@mokies7811 I feel like people continue to miss the point. The Cinemasins guys don't hate movies, the videos are just jokes and a lot of the sins are stupid inconsequential things that don't matter but they're trying to come off as "this is what an asshole would say." If you listen to their podcast, they really love movies and don't at all talk down to people. In fact they were going to start something like cinemawins but Lee just happened to start his first. I want to support cinemawins too, and for the most part I like his work when he goes into the overviews and stuff, but he did basically copy/paste this format and just do the opposite. It seems like cheating and a weird extra dig when he mocks or steals specific jokes (like the Prometheus school of running away from things) which really feels cheap. But overall, the quality is good so I'll continue to watch
everybodyloveshigh5s Yeah. I love CinemaSins. I usually watch the videos of movies I’ve seen and/or enjoyed. It’s funny to watch them “tear movies apart” because I know it’s just nit picky things that don’t really matter and that it’s all sarcasm and snarky-ness.
@Samaritan WHAT!? They actually take the time to read the stupid articles in newspapers on screen and watch of continuitu errors. You are probably an oversensitive person who cries offensive over everything.
John Doe Watch bobvids video called “why cinemasins is terrible.” Only then you’ll realize that cinemasins tricks their viewers, lies about the things that are happening, and tricks their mindless fans into thinking it’s “satire.”
I love how Lee is a great father who tries to teach and protect his kids in the new world, and especially how he sacrifices himself to save his kids in the end... Kinda sounds familiar
I enjoyed this movie so much. It was actually the first time the entire audience was dead silent. I watched it on premiere day and the theatre was packed and it was the biggest theatre (both the number of seats and the size of the screen) in my state and 200 something people didn't even make a sound after the first 10 min.
MariktheGunslinger Probably. Same thing with some of the Dark Knight trilogy movies and The Last Jedi (though the hate towards the latter has more racism/sexism directed at it....).
@@d.j.2408 I wouldn't say most of the TLJ hate is for racism/sexism reasons. Some of it is, but there are many who hated the movie for legitimate reasons. Also, why would someone hate TLJ because they're racist when the black guy in the movie is useless and is only there for comic relief?
It did well box office wise and critically. I saw it with a bunch of people from work, and we all loved it. I think the perceived abundance of negative criticism is simply that people who like to tear stuff down are usually louder than those that like it.
@@micah4029 Yeah but you can't always take what the critics say, I'm saying what they say is bad or that they don't know what they're talking about, but look at Venom it did wonderful at the box office yet critics hated it. And yes people who are negative and tear stuff down are usually louder then those with positive views (looking at you news people) but the opposite can also be said I mean look at all movies that are/were bad yet now have more of a cult following then some movies that did good.
@@belisauriusfish9406 as a kid I was playing hide and seek in the dark in our school daycare and there was a thumbtack left on the ground. I was crawling under a desk and it went straight into the center of my hand. I sat there silent the entire time, won the game, and only then did I say something about it to an adult. obviously a thick nail in your foot is like x10 that, but I still felt like the biggest little badass for doing it
I didn't even know people thought the waterfall thing was a plothole until now. Before the birth, their life was fine relatively speaking. They didn't live by the waterfall because they didn't have to. They had a nice, warm house and all they paid for it was their voices. Having a deaf daughter, they probably didn't care that much that they couldn't talk. And what would they even do in the winter? If they lived at the waterfall, the house would be unprepared for when they moved back. It's so stupid.
In a world of people championing the nitpick some have lost sight on what it means to just ENJOY a movie. I love this channel so much for being a vehicle to remind people to chill and have fun. There’s a place for CinemaSins for a laugh but CinemaWins makes me love movies even more. It even helps me find gems in movies I don’t like. AND CinemaWins gives love to the scores. This channel is a national treasure.
frostmagemarii pssst. Did you see where I said I enjoy CinemaSINS as well? The channel isn’t just popular because of me. I often watch both for the same movie. But it’s fashionable to nitpick enjoyment even out of good movies too, regardless if you think this one is garbage.
frostmagemarii Ok, let me answer the question then. Yes, I know you can criticize a movie and still enjoy it. Most people do. Honestly, you’re not making much sense.
frostmagemarii Oh, so I did understand you the first time. I clearly stated that SOME people have forgotten how to ENJOY movies. So, there is a segment of the population who can’t see beyond perceived and actual plot holes. Who are overly critical to the point they admit not liking a movie because they don’t know where the “sand” came from. I never said you can’t do both or because you find issues with a movie you can’t enjoy it. Psst...I was pretty clear in my original post. You want to nitpick my sentiment and it stands regardless of how badly you want to prove me wrong.
11:01 When i saw this scene for the first time I cried like a baby. Its so powerful and the actors and score give it so much more weight. Absolutely outstanding scene!
Have you read the original script treatment? John’s death is even more heartbreaking. He screams “I love you” instead. Yeah, the final version is obviously a lot better, but I obviously imparted those lines upon the actual ending.
that's not heartbreaking. i'd have burst out laughing if thats how it went. you could not make that not look dumb as hell or super corny/awful. it wouldn't fit at all. I really dislike this movie for multiple reasons but i can still admit that it's amazingly acted and there are plenty of scenes that i still find very tense. the way it ended is probably the best that death could be done. if he screamed "I love you" that wouldn't work at all in my opinion. i cant see it even coming close. Signing it in silence as the music came in was a much more impactful way of doing it i think.
I hate how armchair movie critics pick one plot "hole" and they just pick that hill to die on, never ever conceding. Why didn't they live near the waterfall? Have you ever noticed that basically nobody does? Try building a house right next to running water like that and see how long it lasts before the wood goes all soft and it falls apart, gets mouldy etc etc. It's a dumb idea because you'd get used to it and be desensitized to the danger of the "real" world. Another one I've seen people say is that it's convenient that John's character could engineer the hearing aids, like holy cow what a massive convenience that is, terrible writing.Even though he clearly couldn't? He quite clearly spent months trying to understand how ears work just to try help his daughter, maybe he had some technical skill beforehand but...seriously? That's impossible? That's one criticism I hate about movie critics "Oh he just _happens_ to know how to do that?" Uh...yeah? People know how to do things. If the world went to shit like this there'd be engineers that can build solar panels, doctors with extremely helpful medical knowledge, mechanics that can fix up vehicles.It's like characters for some reason have to be these unemployed blank slates that don't know how to do anything and that they're only allowed the tools of the movie to survive, it's so stupid.
mrcheesemunch to a certain degree there are some people's who suspension of belief is too shallow to accept that this is the world where all of those coincidences collide
one? ONE? Ok let`s count plot holes: - we have aliens that navigate by sound, so why they`re still alive? Military didn`t figure that out and used sound as bait to kill them? It`s not like they`re immortal or smth. We can clearly see that shotgun is a good weapon, so why the rockets and bombs are not? -their way of living at farm doesn`t work and we can see it why, how the hell they lasted for so long? For year there was not a single cough, fart or sneeze? -they have electricity so just use that in car audio system in a metal cage to attract aliens and live calm. -the range monsters can hear humans is so vast and not defied at all, sometimes they can hear a distant clap and sometimes they don`t hear a thing, so convienet -The girl...that stupid girl, she needed 4 times to learn that hearing device on her ear can repel aliens -pregnancy (having unsafed sex) during time when bringing kids will make you suffer to survive. Can`t they do in the ass if they were so horny? They had like 4-3 kids and God knows how many were massacered because of their stupidity before them. -Jewish actor sacrificing himself to save kids is the dumbest thing in whole movie. So instead of trwoing axe at metall shed near - he screams? Why? So that people with one brain hemisphere can feel sorry and shed some tears on the dad of the year. That was so cheap I was hoping that monster rip kids apart as well as punishement for his idiotic sacrifice. I was hoping that this film would be good, but god awful script just ruined it, it`s like they had a great idea "silent horror movie where everyone need to stay quiet to survive" and what we got was a cheese drama moments, bad screenwriting and I guess Blunt was dragged by her husband begging "oh please please Emily star in my shitty movie, you`ll atract people" and it worked. I don`t understand either people became dumber and they can`t see all the major flaws or i`m used to movies with detailed stories? You know what makes a good horror movie? Not the jumpscares, not the family against monsters - a good solid plot (even simple stories can be detailed and interesting to watch) detailed world and last, but not least - heroes that try to survive, all I saw that Emily Blunt tried to survive and her falimy had a death wish. And that shotgun cocking in the end...Jesus. I hope someone bitch slaped director for this non-sense. I can go on forever why this movie had a great idea and awful realisation, but it`s internet so nobody cares. PS: downvote all you want, It`s my IMHO...Oh and you, grammar nazis, commenting on my grammar is another nail to the coffin to all answers that were thought through by CinemaWins and not the fucking screenwriters, when all the explanations consist of "we don`t know, we were never told, so plausible" is a shitty exuse for you liking a shitty movie. Instead of counter-argumenting you look like a bunch of kids . Jeez...one thing is to like a bad movie and acknowledging it, and an opposite thing is to like a bad movie and find all the answears in your head not the movie - that`s just sad. First is just your taste, second is eating shit and never knowing it. Watch good horror classics like The Thing where almost everything was logical, damn even 1st predator is a better written story that this garbage.
LPrussia07 Did...did you watch the video? These plot holes were answered. At least I think they were. Your grammar is so awful that I can’t even tell what the hell your saying, so you could be pointing out plot holes or just rambling. I can’t tell because you can’t write proper grammar. And don’t call it an ode to autism. I’m so sick of people conflating stupidity with autism. There are just as many high functioning autistic as there are low functioning, and calling something autistic because you thought it was dumb only shows you as the shortsighted idiotic one.
The foley for the aliens hearing sound followed by a close up of their ear was a grape being tasered and slowed right down so you can hear each individual electrical wave
Another win for the "I have always loved you", the sign language makes you read the subtitles. So you're not hearing it in anyone's voice but your own, making it that much more personal
ok i know this is ridiculously late but i love this comment, it makes perfects sense but i never thought about it like that before
to add on him signing was in time with the music which I thought was a fun touch
Hmmm. You've never been in my head. My in head voice is never my own.
god damn you made this scene a whole lot sadder.
wow what a thought just watched both yday and this seriously added to that scene!
John said this movie was a love letter to his children and you can really feel that.
If I were his children, I'd hug him and cry quietly never dar to do that again.
If you consider the death of a child in the beginning then it is also a hate letter
@@Dylanjjensen no, he tried to save him as he could. If he leave that child to dead it would be a hate letter.
@Colin Mcfatridge creep
Agreed, just one that they shouldn’t open for a while given its horrifying implications.
“Emily Blunt is a national treasure...”
*drinks tea angrily*
Dual treasure-ship allowance for that comment.
@@CinemaWins PLEASE! Do an "Everything Great About" video on Legend of the Guardians The Owls of Ga'Hoole! Gorgeous visuals, a good story, a mythically beautiful soundtrack! That movie is SCREAMING for the treatment!
@@JMObyx tbh i dont wanna be screaming for anything after this video
@@araknidude Good call! On second thought, DON'T CALL!
@@JMObyx dude shhh
6:48
Lee: ‘Emily Blunt is a national treasure. That’s right, England! I’m claiming her for America!’
Me: **angry British noises**
*sputtering*
"Well, I never!"
I feel like there’s a cheep joke about America there😂
Unbelievable!*sips tea*
Tutting
Well an American got her! A fellow Bostonian to make it even better.
My allergies would kill me. Literally, I’d sneeze in the first five seconds of anything happening
Same
Sometimes when I sneeze I sneeze again right afterwards, also I sneeze like *insert the loudest noise making animal on earth here* and I snore in my sleep sooooooooo...... R.I.P me ;-;
I don’t have any allergies, but I know I’d sneeze really loud and die.
my breathing bruh moment
Not sure if its allergies, but I am susceptible to sneezing fits, and will have 2 or 3 moments a week where I will just sneeze for 10-15 seconds straight.
Sometimes I can catch it, and at least muffle the sound, but usually the first one gets through without warning!
So I'd probably be in the same boat!
"Even worse, the fear of your children not knowing how much you love them." This made me weep. Trust me, even childless adults understand this.
even childless childs understand this to a point (being an only child)
Mary Clare Mayo I think children can understand it to an extent. I know that when I become a father I’ll want to try to show my kids how much I love them but I know It’ll also never be enough.
I lost my dad a year ago. The fear goes both ways. The regret that I hadn't known somehow to call and say "I love you" sooner before his death haunts me. I hope my dad knew how much I adored him.
Yahhh, my mom died a month ago and I haven't even told her I loved her because in our family affection isnt all that normal, now I regret it and wished I said I loved her but all im sure is she loves me deeply.
Mom died from a stroke and later was pronounced braindead
My mom has always had a hard time conveying to my siblings & I that she loves us. My dad however, is a completely different story. My father has always been the type of man who believed in our dreams, sometimes even more than us. He was always a very involved parent when I was growing up, I mean; he went to every parent teacher conference there was throughout each school year to check up on how we were doing in school, he volunteered to chaperone field trips on his days off from work, he came to all of our games/shows/etc. whenever we were involved in something in school.
I remember there was this one time he told my sisters & I to get dressed up in our prettiest dresses and he took us to the fanciest restaurant I’ve ever been to in my life. He told us to order whatever we wanted and that the sky was the limit, needless to say we went berserk and ordered a bunch of food that we couldn’t even finish, but my dad didn’t care. He just wanted us to enjoy ourselves. Once dinner was over, he tipped our server $100 and we left the restaurant. The man was so shocked, he literally chased us out of the restaurant, telling my dad that he’d given him far too much money. My father just laughed and told him he’d given him just the right amount because he was such a great server to us that evening. When we got in the car to go home that night, my dad told us that if a man can’t treat us the way we were treated that night, not to even waste our time on dating him. Fast forward to now and my dad hasn’t been in the best health lately, he had a stroke in August last year and hasn’t really been the same, but when I went to visit him and my mom a couple of weeks ago, he made sure to tell me that my sisters and I are the best things to have ever happened to him and that he’s grateful and happy to be our father. It made me bawl my eyes out.
"Treating a battery operated toy like a live grenade with a pin removed" For some reason, I just really like the way you phrased that. You're really good at saying things in a way that's able to emphasize just how important some of these smaller moments are
Pikaman20008 well if it was a grenade with the pin removed they would throw it, not slowly deal with it
@@earthisabignigga2026 not if the spoon hadn't been released
@@earthisabignigga2026 Taking it a bit too literally, there. He meant like they were treating it like the thing could go off at any moment and kill them all. Cuz it could
@@earthisabignigga2026 r/wooosh
Pikaman20008 I’m not trying to hate on him and expose him, I’m just saying
The solar panel comment was a direct answer to cinema sins.
I feel like it's the same people.
Everyone gets pissy about shit without thinking about it at all. Just how it works
@@booty_hunter4207 There's a lot of self congratulation in bad faith film criticism. It's some childish "I want to be cleverer than this movie" attitude and is so, so dumb.
@@dannyanderson4385 exactly man
@@dannyanderson4385 ikr for some movies it's fine, but for serious hardworking movies that a lot of people enjoyed, it's hard to watch.
I can attest to the fact that people find plot holes in real life stories. In college, I wrote an experience of mine as a creative writing project, and half the class found plot holes with it. It was a story about finding out that a high school friend of mine had committed suicide and my reaction, but the thing my classmates focused on was the *way* I found out. They insisted that “the main character” should have found out sooner. When I told them I had written it exactly as it had happened, they insisted it just wasn’t believable in a story.
I had done a similar project. I wrote about when the locks of my dad's old car broke and I was stuck inside. I am diabetic and had a low glucose at the time. I was about five or six when it happened.
"If she was really that weak, the adrenaline would have helped her break the window."
"Well why didn't he just smash the window with a rock?"
"Why wouldn't he have snacks inside for her?"
I think it's due to things like "r/thathappened"
People are so unwilling to believe anything interesting, and I think it's because they don't want to be wrong
Fiction have to make sense. Reailty is free from that rule.
@@TwinFlower90 then why doesn't the corn just swallow itself? plot hole!!1
Sadly, if that is a thing that all your readers are going to think, then that is something you're going to have to pay heed to. It doesn't matter if it's true if it's detracting from the reader's experience. Unless you have "A true story" in the title or something.
Something you said about people finding plot-holes in real stories made me laugh, because in high-school we had to write stories about overcoming adversity, and I wrote about an experience my family had gone through years before (the only thing I changed was names). I was told by my teacher that it wasn't realistic enough and wasn't very creative xD I was like... um... sorry my life is so unrealistic????
you totally made this story up
TVtropes has an article on that. It's called "reality is unrealistic".
@@mickud5184 😂😂😂 dude
Generation kill is a TV miniseries about a reporter and a company of marines in the Iraq ( good series) it was written by the actual reporter it was based on who in an interview said they actually had to get rid of the some the stuff
that actually happened so that it didn't look to unrealistic.
I just finished writing that essay! I haven't gotten my grades back but I also used a personal experience with my family. My teacher is nice so I hope she doesn't poke too many holes in it haha
The nail going into the foot scene literally sends a chill down my spine and you kept replaying it, minus a win for you cinemawins
Ikrrr
The only scene in this movie I hate
I couldn’t watch that scene 😭
omg you read my mind!
A quiet place 2 topped it. 😳 If ya know ya know.
can we just talk about how they used leaves instead of plates because of how much noise plates make
Me:
Laughs in South indian.
They could have used paper plates
@@leelaanandabhavan3083 lol malayalia?
@@0BV10USLYALEXX They aint easily renewed, after whatever might have been around was used up they went to leaves
Also, I think that scene happened on day 200 something, so there's a good chance they already used all paper plates in the area
The first time I watched this movie, I was at a friend's house and it was around midnight. Nobody else in the house was awake so the only sound was coming from the TV. When the lamp shattered towards the beginning, my friends dogs started barking from downstairs because of the sudden noise. I was so on edge and scared from the loud barking that I screamed without making noise, made the same face that Emily made and hid under my blanket. After the dogs stopped barking, I peeked out from under my blanket, and my friend who was on her phone laughed at me and I quickly shushed her. Long story short, the use of sound in this movie is phenomenal.
I watched the first hour of the movie with the volume playing on the speakers outside. My friend and I thought it was LITERALLY a quite place until my dad came home from work and asked why we had it playing outside. Yep.
I bet you've "Immersed" yourself in the movie so much, it happened in reality
You were practicing
Isn't it interesting how we take cues from people around us. I would guess from your comment that you normally scream out loud, but you were following the example of another person, Emily Blunt's character. We humans have awesome survival instincts that we don't realize we have until something like your experience shows that they exist.
yeah i remember after leaving the cinema i struggled to remember that it was all fiction! So i was speaking a little as possible and walking as steadily as possible. 😭
I really hate drawing attention to myself in class, so I've kinda trained myself to sneeze super quiet to the point that no one says bless you. People don't realize, but living in a world where you're essentially forced to be quiet, makes you start habits whether you like it or not (such as the mom's muffled scream even though she stepped on a nail). I feel like it's just cheap to call that a plot hole because those are loud things that can be easily trained out of.
-Yelling in pain= Can be trained to be locked off or muffled into silence
-Sneezing= Some people are incredibly loud (myself included), but in times of need you can clamp your mouth shut and sneeze through your nose (more snot but quieter) or clamp your nose and mouth (causes it to go more for your ears which could cause infection issues and hurts, but is even quieter). My sneezes _hurt_ if I try anything to reduce them, but I can...
-Yawning= Not too loud but to silence it, you can yawn with your mouth closed.
-Burping= Again, mouth closed followed by a slight exhale.
-Farting= This is where my brother would die... But if you clench your muscles hard, you can halt it in it's escape and either cause it to reverse direction for a time or it'll be more able to be controlled in short, quiet releases. The biggest downside is it's kind of painful inflating your intestine for a period of time.
-Hiccoughing= Mouth shut, chest muscles clenched. Now you just have to deal with painful diaphragm contractions causing you to twitch/spasm...
-No comment on labor...
Totally agree. And somepeople are just born that way. No one has ever heard me fart or burp. I just never do those things loudly or in shared spaces
John Krasinski explained that if they needed to fart/cough they would be smart and use a pillow to cover themselves
@@sushidashi6152 Hopefully not the same one...
@@DraconicDuelist my yawning is downright silent, with my mouth wide open. I don't even know why I do it like that. My burps are closed mouth, only sound being the ones I can't control.
can we all just take a minute to appreciate this amazing channel and this guy's love for movies.
Indeed, it's such a refreshing change from the negativity and apathy that I see with film discourse and culture nowadays.
@@ryanrobotham7696 absolutely!
This is so true. (rant below somewhat related)
I've been thinking about this channel even more recently because of all the dumbass critic reviews of Bohemian Rhapsody, which is a fantastic film that did exactly what it set out to do and yet the critics are just determined to shit on it (though the audience seems to be loving it anyway, reminds me of the split that happened with Venom). Too many people go into a movie wanting to dislike it, like they think it makes them seem smart or something. With Bohemian Rhapsody, it takes 2 seconds of watching interviews to see how hard the actors worked to do the band justice. And all their dedication pays off, the movie is a celebration of Freddie, hugely entertaining and appropriately private a lot of the time. The critics who are mad that the film itself isn't more of an artsy rip-him-apart thing are just?? No one was setting out to upstage Mercury or exploit his story, it's a tribute and it's beautiful? Fuck off @ those critics. It's a total blast of a movie.
TLDR this channel is a beautiful act of positivity & appreciation for art in a world that thinks it's cooler & smarter to be immune to all enjoyment. Joke's on them because like a great man once said "liking things is more fun than disliking things"
Ophelia W i don’t think all critics or people in general go into movies wanting to dislike them I think sometimes there’s just dumb things in movies people cannot get past but let’s be realistic here no one is going to like literally everything in the world And critics are still important it’s their job to make points about movies music games books etc in a argumentative way souly for arguments sake it’s kinda an acquired taste to have someone challenge the things you like and I think that’s a great thing because it leads to (ideally) new ideas and people going out of their comfort zone and questioning the things they do and don’t like.
At the end of the day everything is opinionated for example you clearly really enjoyed the movie bohemian rhapsody if I go see it I may not like it and that’s okay if everyone liked the same things there would be no new ideas there would just be the same thing being created over and over sorry I typed a book at you.
Don’t people do that by subscribing?
Imagine him looking at the camera like Jim every time someone died lmaooo
He should do a short parody of it with The Office guys, and let Creed be the sole survivor lol
@@rodrigoodonsalcedocisneros9266 he wouldn't even know anything was happening he'd be off scuba'ing
Dwight Or Creed Would Definitely Survive
Insert the "Bruh!?" voice clip to it as well!!🤣
Meredith would be fine too.
Talking about your "People will find plot holes in real life accounts" point, my Grandfather was born just shortly after the turn of the century and so he lived through a LOT of history. After he retired, he and Grandma were living near a university that offered a free course for senior citizens, so Grandpa (who, btw, had for a number of years written a column for the local paper) decided to take a class on writing (he figured that you can always learn something new).
So as he began this course on writing, he decided that he'd draw on his own experiences and write accounts of events from his life. The students that were with him in the class (a bunch of 20-something college students) told him multiple times that his writing wasn't good because the stories he wrote just weren't believable (again, he was writing about things that had happened to him during his life).
So, yes, you are completely accurate with that statement.
True, but it is also a lot less black and white than that. The thing is, it's possible that your grandfather's life events wouldn't always make great storytelling. Life isn't a narrative; random things happen without any buildup, there's no rhyme or reason and people die without having achieved a successful character arc. Everyone's life is a TV show that gets cancelled mid-season.
The problem is that inexperienced students still often pride themselves and place way too much stock in the concept of stories being "realistic" or "believable". These are toxic words for writers and a good teacher should stamp them out early. It is very possible to tell a story with the inherent randomness of everyday life, but other aspects need to be have some consistent narrative to satsify people's placement on patterns. So, things like, tone, setting, themes, motifs, etc. have to be little creative licenses that keep some form of structure. The randomness of life can make stories feel alive and pulse with ingenuity, it's a shame your Grandfather was with people who didn't understand that or a teacher who maybe hadn't had the chance to explain how to balance the two.
Why do the both of u talk for sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooolong
Mckenzie Stokes when you grow past the age of 11 you’ll understand
GraffitiTurtle that’s a big oof
@@dannyanderson4385 I mean for them, yeah. But imagine your grandpa who might have thought "B-But its real!". People in general should just stop criticizing too much on facts and their version of "Realistic", your perspective of what's "real" can never be the same even to your twin......
Can we all share a moment of silence for Mr. Raccoon who was taken by the Death Angel may he rest in...... puddles, pile of mush, somthin like that
Sir Turtle The Great your comment is literally better than this movie and I am laughing so hard right now omg
Dear Mr.raccoon you lived a good life, of eating garbage and attacking buddy the elf rest in peace
May he rest in pieces.
May he rest in mush.
RIP Mr. Raccoon.
thats like what cars do every day
@@LittleTurtleCake Cars have secret arms that crush raccoons if they make a sound?? Who knew. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
This was a nice contrast to Cinema Sins.
Yeah. Honestly I got sick of cinema sins because of how nit picky they are.
@@angelsquier2290 why bring something down to elevate another? both are original and cool ideas executed well
@@angelsquier2290 are you kidding me??? Thats the point
@@angelsquier2290 yet CinemaSins say everything we think with every movie. Nit-picky yes but we still enjoy the movies even knowing the problems.
@@alexfrance8864 oh no hate to the channel, it's just not my thing 😅
8:12 He's not doing something stupid in this scene. Upon second viewing I realized that the tire in the corn field is perfectly placed, and it is an escape strategy that the family probably had in case someone was stuck in the middle of the sand path. It takes too long to run either way, so it's like a bunker in the middle of the path to wait things out and stay safe. He even shines the torch at the sand path later on, like it's something he's been told to do. It's another case of Krasinski trusting his audience, and it's a beautiful way of storytelling with set design.
But wouldnt that monster kill him while he was running through the very noisy cornfield?
I have a deaf cousin and I know from first hand experience. Deaf people have no idea how LOUD they are.
They don't know that dropping things makes noise. They don't know that stomping around makes noise.
They don't know hitting things makes noise. They can vocalize without really knowing they're making sounds.
They can learn all these things, and the most determined can even learn to speak and read lips and seem able to hear to the average person.
The sad thing is that those who try are often shunned by the deaf community.
I highly recommend the British RUclipsr Jessica Kellgren-Fozard, who is lovely and passes for hearing but is almost completely deaf because of a connective tissue disorder. She has so much to say about living with disabilities in general, and with the cultural realities of deafness in particular.
that is true i did a deaf course and learned that the deaf has a difficult time making the decision to hear or speak because there are members of the group that think being deaf should not be fixed or that they shouldn't aspire to learn vocalization since speech shouldnt be the ideal to reach for.
Exactly. And don't even start on cochlear implants.
Doken Boken same i have a deaf dad
@Ghastly Grinner it's about connecting with people you relate to. They would still be struggling.
LOVED this movie, for all the things you brought up. One little detail I really liked that I noticed you didn't mention was that Reagan (the daughter) walked so carefully in comparison to the other characters, which makes sense seeing as she can't hear and wouldn't know how loud she was being so she would take extra precautions to be as quiet as she could
woah...
I'm partially deaf and I noticed that detail immediately. It would be something I would have to consider if I was in that situation.
moonflower843
What do you mean partially deaf? Is your hearing just bad or you can only hear with one ear?
@@steelbear2063 I'm deaf in my right ear and use a bone conduction hearing implant.
I almost cried when John sacrificed himself to save his kids...
I did cry it's so sad 💔
i did cry even tho i knew it was coming, the way it was preformed really made my tears jerk
I did watching it again in this video.
Oh I did. i had to take a good 10 minutes before I could do anything else, and was still thinking about the rest of the day. Or Maybe Im just really emotional...
Almost???
Theres actually a bit when we see the dad working on the hearing aid that shows hes been increasing the sensitivity, which is why her aid specifically was affecting them and not, yknow, anyone elses. He was hot modding a sound device and just managed to find the frequency that would cause that feedback. That big plot hole is literally explained BY THE MOVIE in that scene if people bothered to pay attention and not just complain about something they missed.
Right? and he even explains it to Reagan even tho she kept telling him to stop.
Oh man, NEVER apologise for not being cynical enough. There's more cynics than we know what to do with; we need unashamed positivity. Especially about this movie. I honestly don't think I've related to anything more than the "people saying they would act perfectly rationally post-apocalypse so why can't the characters" mini-rant.
And seriously, were people really complaining about the "(not) getting sucked into grain"? Did they also wonder why Rose didn't sink when she got on top of the door in Titanic..?
i feel oddly targeted here...
Joking aside I fully agree! Having these forms of positive media is always a welcome in my life
I tend to roll my eyes at the "i'm prepared for the apocalypse" rants, they take away the humanity, the reactions, the unexpectancy, no one can predict when something like that will happen so no one can be perfectly prepared or react fast enough to put their plan into action (and a lot of those people give WAAAAAAAAAY too much credit to themselves about what they can and can't do), An example that was given at school, someone asked "what would you do if you woke up and it was suddenly a zombie outbreak? his first response was "I'd get a gun" I butted in and asked "where would you get the gun from?" he said "from the gun store" I talked about how the nearest gun supplier is about an hour walk away so how would he get past the crowd............his answer was "with a gun".................this may be a bad example, but it just shows that just because you think you can do it.........doesn't mean you actually can
@@experiencemaster1743 Good point... also a gun is one of the worst weapons for something like that. The noise attracts everything for miles and the need of ammo makes it extremely limited. People are always smartasses about such things, including me, but I have no doubt that all that rational thinking goes right out the window in the stress of an actual crisis with actual stakes and with no extra lives/rewind option. Once the adrenaline kicks in you'd have to be highly trained and experienced with fear to keep a straight head. 99% of people won't though... no matter what they claim on the internet. That includes me. I'd probably be one of the first to go down, to be honest. :D
@@experiencemaster1743 Tell me about it... Let's be honest, come apocalypse time, the vast majority of us would be toast relatively quickly, no matter how smart we like to think we would be. Human error, irrational decision making, heck even just something like not looking where you're going or getting distracted by a fly or tripping over at the wrong time...people can pretend they'd act perfectly all they want but that in itself is not realistic (for a completely hypothetical scenario, anyway). At least I know myself well enough to know that it would take a miracle for me to survive in an apocalypse...
Dammit, now I'm being cynical...
Agreed. Besides, it's hard to make reasonable decisions in such situations.
Wait a minute. In a movie all about deafness and silence, the family grows *ears* of corn?
*sigh* take your thumbs up and get out
No this is just wrong
They have ears of corn to hear the creatures coming lol
Oh my Fucking GO- *explodes out of rage*
I suppose you think that was terribly clever.
Yes. Loved this movie. One of the most unique and engaging theater viewing experiences I've ever had.
Yeah, we don't get a lot of original films in Hollywood nowadays.
all good and all too bad it doesn't make any fucking sense
@@willemboele2079 what do you mean?
@@willemboele2079 what?
@@willemboele2079 It makes plenty of sense.
is nobody gonna talk about how the monsters are just giant mutant librarians
sHhHhHHHh
Welcome to nightvale :)
Ye librarian demogorgons
Ohhh my god
This makes it all much less scarier xD
That should not have made me laugh so hard
"We never learn the characters names"
We do though!
When... uhh…
*Oh*
How did I not realize that...
Fr! I don't remember their names.
I literally watched it like an hour ago and can't remember-
@@kaushikassagur769 isn't the deaf girl Reagan? what's he talking about not knowing the characters name?
You learn them in the credits, unless you are openminded and don' know who Krasinski and Blunt are...then you might think John is named Millicent pr something like that lol
These videos contradict everything said in the “everything wrong” videos in a passive agressive way and I LOVE IT
14:33 I love that someone actually explains why living near the waterfall would've been a terrible idea.
The Quiet Place just made me feel sad when the boy died.
Not just because “Holy shit they actually went there they killed a young child nobody is safe now fuck”, but because, I have several younger siblings. A four year old, a two year old, and an eight month old.
I can totally see the two year old grabbing a toy car, not knowing the consequences. I can imagine and FEEL the panic running towards him as he stands there innocently with a car in hand. I can see him in the boy’s place, gone instantly with a blur and splatter of blood.
I can see the four year old just not being able to learn to be quiet. She’ll be screaming for something, she’ll be roaring as a dinosaur or a dragon, she’ll let out a loud laugh. She’d be gone too.
The eight month old would just be crying or fussing. She’d be letting out loud wails inside our house, and suddenly, they’re inside. She’s gone, and no matter how hard we tried to be quiet, we’d start hyperventilating or just crying from fear, and since they’re *right there*, the house is suddenly empty. (Jeez I don’t even want to think about my dogs)
All I thought when the boy turned on the toy was ''thank fuck for darwinism'' lol.
I'm really glad that those aliens aren't real.
Kate Brown how do know they’re not real?
@@OfficerFriendly2006 Well my musical loving sister isn't dead yet so....
Kate Brown maybe they live on the other side of the universe and, like us, haven’t created a way to come to our planet.
I loved this movie, it was one of the rare horror movies that wasn’t predictable, it had such a better approach, I often find things with simple themes the best, like, in this case, silence, or my favorite movie of all time, Alice in wonderland, based after insanity
Mark Grant but they can’t hear a pin drop 1 mile away, and it was light breaths, you can breathe without making sound and after *more than a year* Im sure they perfected that skill
@Mark Grant did u even watch the video
Not really a horror film tho more of a thriller
Mark Granyou edited your comment...
Mark Grant it’s not all bad there’s still like amazing parts like the sound design and directing the plot is also quite good overall but there’s sum rlly shit holes in it
OH PLEASE
If Dwight is dead, they’ve been dead for weeks. 😏
Dwight is living it up in his bomb shelter right now with Mose, Angela,and Phillip, eating canned foods, and meditating every morning and afternoon for one hour.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who appreciated all of his office references.
grace avila no I’m in space dumb ass
Nuclear Nerd Mose ran
@@balisamon4270 right on Dwight!
Can I just say, thank you? This was the first video of yours I saw, and I feel in love. A Quiet Place is one of my favorite movies of all time, and hearing the way you talked about it changed my entire view on the movie, especially the scene where Lee sacrificed himself. You do such an amazing job really just, explaining everything in such good detail, it leaves me completely satisfied with the movie, and all others you explained. This one just really.. really hit me.
Ikr. I come here whenever someone says the movie is bad
What I love about this channel is I find it will often either go places I didn't consider, or farther with things I did consider with films I love- or just points out the things I love and it's wonderful to see someone else appreciates those aspects...
OR-
It will make me appreciate movies I think are bad by helping me see the good in them. Like- I can appreciate things in Origins Wolverine asides from the opening montage and some camera work, and when I clicked on the everything great with I thought the idea of having that much good (I forget the length) was absurd and would need serious padding- and it was honest, with great points and no padding.
In fact- come to think of it- I think that was the first one I clicked on because of how bad and disappointing I thought it was going to be an effort I would find funny and full of fail- and instead I was amazed that I actually agreed with the points made.
I don't want to really compare channels- but I would rather watch something that's playing as I do things that's designed to make you see good things in such a range of movies, including ones that really weren't that great, than ones that just tear movies down. I'm not singling out a channel I'm sure most people automatically jump to with that description- truth is there are many channels who gain viewers by tearing things down, and in ways that just aim to be funny by being mean. This, Movies with Mikey... they really talk about the things to love and appreciate about SO many movies-
Though it is funny one one of FilmJoy channel's ongoing releases where they specifically try to find the good in bad movies, when they end up with movies that are so bad they struggle to find the good in it... that doesn't happen often, and it helps me appreciate films more.
I absolutely loved the scene where they dance with the earbuds because I think it demonstrates how strong their bond is, the apocalypse hasn't destroyed their relationship, but strengthened it
It is actually so satisfying when you talk about cinematography
It just makes me appreciate it in films so much more
Also I love your logic and reasoning and time for research
Like a lot of people never think about the bigger picture
"Hey, there IS symmetry in this shot! Yeah, it really DOES look beautiful when the camera pans like that!"
Hey. Got any grapes?
unlike a channel I can talk about
"I have always loved you." Such a heart-wrenching scene... Makes me cry every single time. Such a good movie.
I don’t think I’ve ever heard so much emotion displayed in a simple scream.
Did you know it was originally "I love you" and Millicent, the actress playing Regan, suggested that it should be "I have always loved you"? Made John cry too.
At the end of the day, people need to realize that the stories we tell are about people and people ain’t perfect. I do dumb things all the time and often I’m not under the stress brought on by an alien invasion. The fact is that we have a bias. When I do stupid things, I have excuses. When other people do stupid things, they have no excuse.
Side note: Can we make up our minds, everyone? Do we want exposition or do we not want it? I hear people constantly yelling about “show not tell,” but as soon as something isn’t explicitly stated everyone cries plot hole.
SAY IT LOUDER FOR THE HYPOCRITES AT THE BACK
Is it really that hard for people to just use their head for like, 5 minutes instead of crying out "This was a crappy script, the writer/director is a hack, I hope they never find work again!" as soon as a question presents itself? It betrays a real lack of imagination. Honestly, if you're too lazy to pay attention instead of childishly nitpicking/ranting, that's your fault, not the film-makers'. It's not rocket science, people....
CoughCinemaSinsCough
So agree with you! Especially about the exposition part.
I know, right? I feel like Internet movie critics have no ability to draw implications or inferences. There was this one video analyzing Rey and Kylo's relationship over TFA and TLJ, and a bunch of people in the comments were saying that nothing in the video was stated in the movies. Of course, everything in the video was based on the movie's implications, not explicit statements, because the movies don't go into psychological explanations of their characters.
The scream the father does to save the children has so much feeling it, honestly made me cry. It wasn't just about making noise because anything could do that, the scream conveys so much in it, the pain of it all so speak.
I...yeah. The "plot holes" people bring up here bother me more than they usually do too. Maybe it's because I grew up on a farm. I know a little something about corn/grain safety. I know how much a person can get done in a 14-hour day. I know what it's like to live near acres of sand. Blah. Thank you for being a beacon of positivity for this tremendous film!
scottishrob13
I dig your vibe
2:34 EXACTLY SOMEONE GETS IT. that's how i judge a good or bad movie too.
So I know this comment is super old, but I'm here anyway. You were agreeing to him saying that no matter how 'bad' what's happening in the movie is, if it made you feel how the director intended, it's a 'good' moment.
I absolutely agree too. I'll never understand people who get angry at authors/screenwriters for doing bad things in movies; specifically killing off beloved characters. An example that springs to mind is The Hunger Games books. Towards the end of the final book, a central and beloved character is killed off in a brutal and heartbreaking fashion, and readers were so upset that this happened that many stopped reading out of outrage at the author. But? If you were so invested in this character that their death upsets you this much, then the author did a great job? And as upsetting as this is, if it's making you feel something real, then it's a great moment?
It's like how I feel about my favourite tv show (which I won't name because saying this is sort of a giant spoiler). The final episode ends with almost everyone outside of the main character dying, and this one character having to live on after losing everything important to him. This is Not the satisfying conclusion I wanted and expected for my favourite character, but I'm Glad it ends this way, because if I can be this heartbroken over people that don't really exist, then it's true art.
I could go on about this forever, but bottom line is: no matter how objectively good or bad a movie is, I usually only judge it based on whether it made me feel anything. Whether that be simple enjoyment of a fun but simple story, or bawling-my-eyes-out heartbreak, if I felt something and wasn't just passive, then it's a good movie.
Jacinta Smith
POSSIBLE SPOILER
You were talking about Merlin weren’t you? 😭
@@belladonna869 Haha you got me ;)
Something that Cinema Therapy pointed out: John is one of the best expression actors on the planet. He can convey so so so so so much with just a look; just with his eyes. What an actor
I was scared to make a single sound during this movie. The entire theatre was dead silent. Even breathing was hard. You could've heard the drop of a pin two streets away. This is how intense this movie is. Even this video, where I can hear you talking it still feels intense. It's so sad that almost every horror movie today is either about demonic possession, ghosts or serial killers. And they're all the same
1.) It's "foolproof", not "full proof"
2.) I just realized where they get all the sand. It's not sand.
It's cornmeal.
Eh- I think cornmeal staying like that would be harder to believe, even if the animals eat it- that stuff breaks down pretty quickly and any amount of moisture would just make it mush... And continuing to grind it would be noisy.
My feeling was they were either near sand naturally- you can find it in rocky areas 'cause it's just ground rocks really, or if there's a sand/salt storage place for winter storms, they would have access to sand that would seriously last 1 family laying little trails for years and years... and there's a mix of both. They're by a waterfall- likely there's sand around and by the water they can scoop out and dry in a pinch.
Though my feeling was probably just getting it from where it's stored for bad weather. Even in places that may get ice a couple of times every few years they usually have piles of sand somewhere just in case, even if they don't spend the money on mountains of salt...
eventhorizon Your comment is underrated.
@@sangria-margarita - Aw! Thank you!
How do you make cornmeal without making noise tho?
That's odd because cornmeal makes squeaky noises.
-I remember thinking about how the military apparently hadn't come up with anything to fight back against the aliens, but before the video I started thinking: With how fast the aliens are and how loud the military is, they would be too panicked and focused on defense rather than offense. I also thought about how the movie only shows ONE town and never really mentions another, for all we know another state could be heavily fortified and have actually found a way to fight back somehow, but are too afraid to contact anyone else in case they endanger someone or themselves.
-I also love how this movie is both vague and explanatory with it's scenes. For example, two scenes: the old man screaming and the other families not responding to the beacon. The first scene with the old man is explanatory but no one mentions a thing. He's lost his wife and has nothing else to live for, he's old and probably a bit loose in the head so he just gives up and screams. The second scene is a bit vague but not a giant plot hole. We're led to believe that the other survivors have been killed since they didn't respond. But given how much noise is coming from outside and the pure chaos happening, why would anyone want to go outside? For all we know they could be huddled down in a bunker? Or maybe they are dead. And I just love that mystery of it.
Tazzykiki Still my favorite film of the year.
@SatyrToon Animation haha xD
@@tomjohns5146 Totally unnecessary buddy, people in this comment section have put more effort into coming up with plot holes
jacob=that was not a PLOT==if people would just enjoy the movie instead of trying to figure out a PLOT that did not exist===the movie would not ever been made====geesh !
Honestly, I DO think that he would write “WEAKNESS” on the whiteboard. I’ve done it when writing both creatively and on math papers out of pure frustration in that I don’t know what to do.
Tabby Cat I’ve definitely wrote “FUUUUUUUUCCCCCCKKKKK” on essay papers when I can’t think of what to write out of sheer frustration so definitely agree
It may also be a goal. I know I've written something down, and then stared at what I'd written trying to figure out how to achieve it.
The echolocation sounds they make was a taser against wet grapes. Foley artists are the unsung heroes of cinema
And other veggies too!!
Foley artists are so cool and talented!
Definitely one of your best videos yet. There's nothing wrong with analyzing a movie and pointng out story problems when needed, but sometimes it feel like people would rather prove themselves intellectually superior than actually get invested in media.
Spongey444 I super agree with this. I do appreciate people who look at films, books, or video games with a critical eye(it’s something I’m learning to do myself) but I also feel that if someone is talking about a plot hole/story issue they should actually check if it’s actually one/is explained in said media before declaring its one right off the bat.
I cried so hard when John sacrificed himself for his kids, especially when he signed to his daughter that he loved her no matter what.
For example (if your still confused about the ear piece and the alien) it's like when you pit a microphone really close to the speaker, it's two amplifiers reacting to each other
CookieChik 434 not quite. There is no sound at all. It's just in the movie to let us know somethings happening. But I see what you're getting at
well i understand what u mean its like a magnet. let me explain:
so the alien is a + and the noise is -.
so when + hears - it goes toward it but the ear piece is also a + so when to +´s are near they push away from each other
Thank you, that did help me understand it more
@@emmay2158 ur welcome
@@diamondkid2226 I think this is the best way to explain it.
"There's only one angel in this movie and it's the Angel of Verdun"
Nice reference to another alien movie
Reference to "Edge of Tomorrow" with Emily Blunt and Tom Cruise, another incredibly good movie.
4:02 Raccons aren't scared of anything, but that little, helpless squeal did yank on the heart strings a little. Wait, you own chickens?
*owned (until they were stolen by racoons)
:(
Raccoons are like honey badgers. But instead of being brutish and defensive like one, they are sneaky and agile. It's like a honey badger is a warrior build while a raccoon is a rouge build. I absolutely love raccoons, they are like cats, but more funny.
But where is the mage?
skunks are the mages
they def. steal chickens and chicken eggs :)
Ultimate Weapon
Throwing something far away
Wait, could that actually work? Cause I think you are a genius, damn I didn't think about that.
@@antonmariusiulian6942 Because for one it would increase your bulk carrying stuff to throw, meaning its alittle more difficult to move quietly, maybe not by much but whats the point of taking an unnescessary risk and there is not guarantee the sound would be off putting enough to make the alien run after it. "Why not carry something that could make sound to throw?" Once again, unnescessary risk, you risk the noise maker drawing them to you more or it may go off randomly while you carry it.
@@williamaldred335 it doesn't have to be something big. For example you could carry something like some small rocks, maybe 4 for every monster and they could be used in emergency situations
@@williamaldred335 Well the dad is a pretty good engineer from what we were shown in the film so maybe he could set up some devices that could be turned on in the bunker to draw away the monsters with sound
@@antonmariusiulian6942 Like I said, whats the point of carrying extra weight when you can just stop and let it pass and there is no guarantee they would go for that sound over another
Quiet place-can’t talk 🙊
Hush-can’t hear 🙉
Birdbox-can’t see 🙈
...you dead
Imagine if all four movies were combined... no sight, no sound, the only senses you hav is touch, smell, and taste
k
Vine-can't flush the toilet after they've taken a shit
@@vancitycastiel I signed into youtube just so I could like this comment. God BLESS
Me: *sneezes*
Monster: So you have chosen death.
The part we’re the dad sacrificed himself for his children still gets me....
You're the dad?
John and Emily's first movie together and they NAIL it!!
The chemistry btwn them is insane!! The entire movie is so suspenseful, and actually terrifying due to lack of any noise!!
DEF one of THE best movies of 2018!!
Definitely on my Top Ten of the year.
don't you mean... *DEAF* one of the best movies?
I mean they are married after all.
Everything great about The Prince of Egypt PLZ. That movie needs some recognition. The music. The voice acting. The story. All brilliant. It's too good to gloss over as just a religious film and the celebrity voice actors aren't too distracting. It's one of DreamWorks' first animated movies and it shows that they have lots of potential in 1999. Sure the company made some bad films, but remember, they're the ones that made the How to Train your Dragon movies & those are also masterpieces. So please, give this movie the recognition it deserves.
I could not agree more my dude, I adore that movie
yes PLEASE
As someone who works on a farm, the silo scene is not only realistic, but realistically terrifying. That and falling through holes in the hayloft are top 2 fears
i swear Emily Blunt has a contract that requires her to use a shotgun at least once in every movie she's in
If that's the case, I'm really looking forward to Mary Poppins Returns.
Ah, yes, my favorite scene in The Devil Wears Prada is where she pulls out a shot gun and shoots a dress mannequin. :p
@@moonbowie or her horrible boss
So that she can inflict some Blunt force trauma.
lol why did this get like 70 upvotes in a day?
I love the fact that the deaf daughter is played by a deaf actor. People with disabilities are so misplayed in media and it jut feels so personal.
When I first saw this movie in theatres, the sound cut out like 10 minutes from the ending and we all just thought it was a part of the movie since some of it was completely silent anyways. It wasn't until after the movie I heard someone say it wasn't supposed to be like that lol.
23:18
This is where all men and women cried
Just Some Guy without a Mustache rip jim halpert 1980-2020
Ok, so about the baby. It's my belief that Emily and John's characters wanted to have the child. John has long stated that this movie is a sort of love letter to his children, and it's my belief that the baby is Johns way of saying to his real life children, "You matter to me, and I would never regret having you". Or something like that.
I like how they grow corn because it’s pretty loud lived between two fields that regularly grew corn and especially on windy days it would make a lot of noise and allow for them to live a normal life
I know your comment is two years old now, but I hope you don't mind lol.
You actually do bring up a really interesting question. How would wind affect this world? Strong winds can make hearing things more difficult for the monsters just like it does with humans.
The way you described how the aliens were affected by the EMF's was very well done also very good job on explaining the plot holes it really makes me appreciate this movie Alot more than I already do😄
Cinemawins: *claims Emily Blunt as a "national treasure"*
Nicholas Cage: "am I a joke to you?"
National Treasure 3 has been announced to be in production!
Don’t personally find Cage to be a good actor and will never understand why he was so praised in the early 2000s
@@hazardous8301 His roles rarely fit him properly, but he brings a *ton* of energy to most of his roles and is generally fun to watch. I'd say he was readily available and willing to work with whoever. He's a genuinely good guy, so that may have added to it. These are only guesses though, based on how he's practically in at least one movie per year since '81.
You need to watch his finest performances:
Joe, Matchstick Men, Adaptation, Leaving Las Vegas, Moonstruck, Lord of War.
Nicholas Cage is top tier when he is more toned down, but he likes to experiment with his acting doing weird accents, ticks, noises, exaggerated moves. He's a performance artist, but he is a solid actor too.
He's going to kidnap Emily Blunt for his next National Treasure movie
Another great thing about the movie that some people might not understand is why the old man waited for them to be near him before screaming. His scream was intentional, after of course his wife was dead right beside him. He had just lost his own wife and was alone. He wasn't trying to get the father and son killed, but screamed so he wouldn't have to live without his wife.
I agree that it's a dick move. But tbh if I'd just lost someone I've dedicated my life and love to I wouldn't honestly be concerned with this "random" child and father in front of me. I'd be in emotional pain and I'd just be ready to die. Like I said I agree it's a dick move, but it's not completely unrealistic.
okleigh I would be concerned, especially for the child. I'd motion them to run away before joining the dead, if I decided to make the decision at all to die.
@@fredericksaxton9782 good for you, you're not overwhelmed by your emotions. That's commendable but not everyone will have that kind of thought process in the middle of an apocalyptic world where their wife just died.
I have exactly one complaint to do with this movie, and it's nothing to do with the movie itself. And it's actually not really that much of a complaint.
A sequel has been confirmed, set in the same world with the same characters (and, right now, it _is_ looking like it comes after this movie chronologically, so, a sequel, not a prequel). I'm absolutely more than okay with that. My only real concern is how they're going to keep the tone from this film while still having it make sense for the characters.
Like, this movie ends with the implied tone of "Now that we've figured out these things' weakness, we're gonna go hunt them down and take back our world." Which I, personally, think sounds like a pretty dang awesome idea for a story. The only question I have is how/if they could make a movie based on that premise that still falls under "horror thriller" category. Like, I'm sure there are plenty of successful series that changed genres between movies, but I can't think of any off the top of my head. However, at the same time, I can't really think of how they could put the same characters in the same setting and still have it be a "horror thriller" without undoing their arcs and making Lee's sacrifice less impactful.
If I could pick, I'd be 100% okay with the first movie being a thriller story about a family quietly surviving an alien invasion together, and the second being an action story about the same family loudly stomping around the world, challenging the aliens to avenge those they've lost. Call it "A Louder World" or something equally cheesy and fun. If Krasinski is good enough to pull it off - which I think he's proven he can - it'll be pretty awesome.
I didn't know I needed this so bad
Some film series do that though. Like the. Unbreakable - Split - Glass, Trilogy Unbreakable was a drama/mystery. Split was a thriller psychological horror. and Glass was a drama/fantasy film.
it went from. im a vigilante, to im gonna kidnap and eat girls alive, to oh super heros are real btw, and we have organisations designed to take them down and pretend that they are dillusional coz we hate super heros.
my point being it can work habing sequels in different genres.
The direct sequel to Alien has a different tone than the original one and it is considered one of the best sequels of all time
it’s like harry potter, for example. the first movie is over, and it gives soooo much closure, but it’s not over yet, they haven’t defeated the ‘bad guy.’ movie and book makers tend to make you think ‘ok, problem solved! how much more could go wrong?!’ but they always find something. take stranger things. season two’s ending: ok, the hate is closed, it’s just like it was before, because nothing else can come out of the upside down! but we knew there were more season, and we knew that the duffer brothers were going to think of something. and they did.
that didn’t really get to the point at all, but what i’m saying is there’s still plenty of problems that could come up in the sequel, and it definitely could still be horror.
Okay, so they expect us to buy that they only thought to bring 20 lifeboats for all 2000 passengers, and not even fill them all the way? And then a piece of ice just sinks a 50 THOUSAND ton ocean liner made of mild steel, on her maiden voyage, with a decorated captain at the helm?
And I'm just sick of them hitting us over the head with the message. We get it: Titanic, slain by the gods for getting too cocky. 'Unsinkable,' human hubris, lol we're so educated. Here's a hint, Cameron. Subtlety. Use it. Try tying it into the story next time instead of spoonfeeding us with pretentious highschool philosophizing. What else is playing?
I think you are talking about the wrong movie pal😂
@@williamaldred335 They were trying to explain a real scene in a sarcastic way showing that people wouldn't believe a real event if they didn't know it was real. I think either you didn't understood the meaning of the comment or you did and made a funny comment which I didn't understand.
@@NaveenAlpha It was a mix of both
this is accurate because there are actually people out there who think the titanic was "just a movie"
@@williamaldred335 I mean, 80% of why Titanic sunk was because someone forgot something burning inside and fucked everything up from there. That could be a movie on its own to be fair
18:08 “Babies cries are tiny, cute, little noises. Babies are the best!” I want to hear him say that when his baby is crying at 3 in the morning
He probably doesn't realize how lucky he is. Out of three sons I was lucky about 1.5 times, which is a lot.
Baby cries are PTSD inducing lol. Especially when they're in crowded spaces like trains or plains.
Uh....yea. This comment in the video made me entirely confused when I heard it lol I was like, "I wonder what species of baby he's raising?"
@@autumnshaymartin XD
When my family first watched it, I think I was the only one actually watching it since we were playing a board game while it was on. After it was over, I told them that I thought it was one of the best movies I have ever seen. They said it was alright, so I dont think they were even really watching it.
Ugh! I hate when people only second-hand watch movies/tv!
I get why it happens, I'm guilty of it myself, but sometimes it really irks me. I usually do it with shows I know well/ aren't exactly "high art" lol.
Like, if a friend is showing you a movie they really enjoy and want you to enjoy, don't be on your fucking phone half the time!
Sorry, it's just a big pet peeve of mine I guess.
ok?
@@CherryBomb_Games
I get exactly what you mean dude
By far THE BEST video you’ve EVER put out! Well done on sharing your personal thoughts and experiences as a parent and how this movie displayed them! Even though I do not have kids, nor have I seen the movie, the self-sacrifice scene gets to me because I would do ANYTHING to save my family from such a fate. When I first watched this video about a month ago, your commentary almost made me cry because of how thoughtful, personal, relatable and well-written it was. Keep making videos of this caliber. Your other videos are also fantastic, but this one is REALLY next-level!
thanks for debunking the "plot holes". I loved the movie but my cousins didn't cause of stuff they considered stupid
Their son dying at the beginning was heartbreaking but _absolutely_ necessary to take the story to a whole other level
It defines all the characters from that moment on, and makes the movie more about their love and emotion and not just about danger
I normally hate scary movies. Refuse to watch them. But my boyfriend brought me to see this one and I actually kinda liked it. But watching this video made me appreciate the movie even more and now I actually like the movie. Thank you for helping me to realize the genius that is this movie.
3:20 COME ON LMFAO. We all know Dwight was the alien queen all along.
Alien walking up to
You have your back against the wall
It's gets to your face decides to walk off
You fart
You hear it coming back
unearthly place3 Then the alien steps back and goes away after smelling the taco bell you’ve eaten
Cliché the Cat they cant smell. Though they would likely stick around to investigate the sound and give up after they couldnt hear it anymore.
unearthly Reap3r imagine having diarrhea during this💀
This is the first movie in such a long time that, after I collected myself from watching it for the first time, I immediately watched it again... and have watched several times since. I'm in love with the love story that Emily and John portray in this movie and the strength this family has despite literally everything going wrong. Probably one of the most beautiful and relatable 'horror' movies to date.
Everything Great About Kubo and the Two Strings. It's such a fantastic film that, like all Laika films, never got enough recognition.
Something funny I personally found the movie extremely boring and expected more but the stop motion was neat
All of the Laika movies on their own are amzing.
@@paytoncordova8598 While I thought Kubo's art style was stunning and the moral of the story was a good one, I'm not a fan of the sometimes choppy animation style it uses and the story itself is extremely predictable (While watching it I could literally tell how scenes would play out at the start of a scene), so while overall it is a beautiful looking (and sounding) movie, it played it a bit too safe imo
@@runefish1043 Yeah, I'll agree with you on that, vut the sheer amount of work that was put into the animation (i.e. building a 9 foot tall sekeleton puppet) is currently unparalleled. But the imagination put into Coraline and The Boxtrolls was incredible. And the Horror genre jokes in ParaNorman and that super emotional ending was awesome. Each movie has their own faults, they are by no means perfect, but still they deserve the attention.
Payton Cordova Couldn't agree more! tbh, I didnt know they put that much effort in it, I guess I'll just have to rewatch it someday to truely appreciate it.
ive been seeing everywhere that this movie is a 'Plot hole withe a story' but literally everything they say can be debunked pretty easily.
People just like to act smart instead of being smart by doing stuff like poke holes in movies
or you know, maybe there are acutall holes and people try to defend it with "they are just trying to act smart or cynical"
IMO, the waterfall is still a logic issue to me, but it’s not a plot hole per se. I can enjoy the movie while ignoring the waterfall, but it would have been nice to get something in the movie explaining that.
*poking holes in movies
😏
Jk
2E the first
That is what truly bothers me too, sure some of it can’t be answered and it’s not always realistic but then you wouldn’t have so many great stories to chose from.
N8 Dawg
Waterfall creates noise that the creatures know that it isn’t some person or animal, if a snake attacked a warm rock it would just be wasting energy and hurting itself. These creatures know enough to tell the difference between one noise from another and it seemed to have been a pretty recent discovery and it would just be too much work and time and noise to move everything that they have that has been working out great for them. Even then the waterfall is certainly not a perfect system that they certainly didn’t have the time to test out considering the potential loses that could come from it failing.
I never understood why the dad took the son with him and not the daughter but you said it: the daughter needed to be home if the mother went into labor and the son needed to overcome his fear. Perfect!
6:23 “No, thank you” had me rolling😂😂😂
6:21*
Also it’s not impossible to believe that they didn’t conceive the child before the aliens came, or even before they knew it hunted by sound. And if you will notice the mother wasn’t supposed to give birth for another month. They were still working on the soundproof room, because they thought they still had time, they didn’t work on it sooner because other things likely took precedence over an event that was still months away from being an issue. Also regarding the nail. I’m sure she knew she pulled it up, but she’s like 8months pregnant and carrying a large load of laundry she had other concerns, I’m sure she was originally planning to bend the nail down again, but before she got there she went into labor
She got pregnant some time after losing their 4y/o showed by it going from day ~89 to day ~470, about 100 days after as she was about 38 weeks pregnant.
Also to add to your point, i assume that knowing you're pregnant in an apocalyptic scenario is hard at first as you won't have a pregnancy test easily available. So they would have lost some time due to that, like a month or so
I agree with everything after your first sentence. There is literally no way she got pregnant before the aliens attacked or after they knew they hunted by sound. They were already months into the "apocalypse" when their son died, and then they skipped to past day 400. Pregnancies only last 9 months, so no, she couldn't have been pregnant before.
@@Tinkertotz13 Well hopefully they aren't questioning wether they are the father of their own kids now.
Can't believe 311 other idiots don't realize pregnancy is 9 months or about 270 or so days...the youngest died on day 89...day 472 is 383 days later. that is one year and 23 days LATER...idiots
cfj003 child still could’ve been conceived before they knew it hunted by sound and that may of been the reason they liked my comment. Idiot.
If we did a CinemaWins vs CinemaSins battle, how would it work, would it be in the style of Jeremy's Conversations with Myself or would it be a video with the two sides going back and forth retracting each other's points until one side had a clear victory? Either way, it would be amazing to see.
TheHero136 Cinemawins would win not because he would compliment jeremy's narration but because he would me the listeners feel that they arnt stupid because they dont see Why something is wrong in a film or the video he would show us also what we may have missed
@@mokies7811 I feel like people continue to miss the point. The Cinemasins guys don't hate movies, the videos are just jokes and a lot of the sins are stupid inconsequential things that don't matter but they're trying to come off as "this is what an asshole would say." If you listen to their podcast, they really love movies and don't at all talk down to people. In fact they were going to start something like cinemawins but Lee just happened to start his first. I want to support cinemawins too, and for the most part I like his work when he goes into the overviews and stuff, but he did basically copy/paste this format and just do the opposite. It seems like cheating and a weird extra dig when he mocks or steals specific jokes (like the Prometheus school of running away from things) which really feels cheap. But overall, the quality is good so I'll continue to watch
It would be the first good cinemasins video and the first bad cinemawins video
everybodyloveshigh5s Yeah. I love CinemaSins. I usually watch the videos of movies I’ve seen and/or enjoyed. It’s funny to watch them “tear movies apart” because I know it’s just nit picky things that don’t really matter and that it’s all sarcasm and snarky-ness.
so it just gonna be like youtube's comments?
such a good channel, such a good film. yay.
yeah he spends soooo much more effort on his videos then CinemSins
@Samaritan WHAT!? They actually take the time to read the stupid articles in newspapers on screen and watch of continuitu errors. You are probably an oversensitive person who cries offensive over everything.
such a good comment. yay :)
+John Doe no need to be a dick about it
John Doe Watch bobvids video called “why cinemasins is terrible.” Only then you’ll realize that cinemasins tricks their viewers, lies about the things that are happening, and tricks their mindless fans into thinking it’s “satire.”
I love how Lee is a great father who tries to teach and protect his kids in the new world, and especially how he sacrifices himself to save his kids in the end...
Kinda sounds familiar
I enjoyed this movie so much. It was actually the first time the entire audience was dead silent. I watched it on premiere day and the theatre was packed and it was the biggest theatre (both the number of seats and the size of the screen) in my state and 200 something people didn't even make a sound after the first 10 min.
Do you think this movie would've made more of an impact if we didn't live in an age of cynical, defeatist, caustic movie criticism?
MariktheGunslinger
Probably. Same thing with some of the Dark Knight trilogy movies and The Last Jedi (though the hate towards the latter has more racism/sexism directed at it....).
@@d.j.2408 I wouldn't say most of the TLJ hate is for racism/sexism reasons. Some of it is, but there are many who hated the movie for legitimate reasons. Also, why would someone hate TLJ because they're racist when the black guy in the movie is useless and is only there for comic relief?
@@ermisgrivas8280 "the black guy in the movie is useless" And he's useless how, exactly?
It did well box office wise and critically. I saw it with a bunch of people from work, and we all loved it. I think the perceived abundance of negative criticism is simply that people who like to tear stuff down are usually louder than those that like it.
@@micah4029 Yeah but you can't always take what the critics say, I'm saying what they say is bad or that they don't know what they're talking about, but look at Venom it did wonderful at the box office yet critics hated it. And yes people who are negative and tear stuff down are usually louder then those with positive views (looking at you news people) but the opposite can also be said I mean look at all movies that are/were bad yet now have more of a cult following then some movies that did good.
As soon as I saw the damn nail on the stairs I was cringing thinking about the pain 😂
Jailan Simon I know, right? I’ve stepped on a nail before, and I can only imagine stepping on one and trying not to make any noise.
@@belisauriusfish9406 as a kid I was playing hide and seek in the dark in our school daycare and there was a thumbtack left on the ground. I was crawling under a desk and it went straight into the center of my hand. I sat there silent the entire time, won the game, and only then did I say something about it to an adult. obviously a thick nail in your foot is like x10 that, but I still felt like the biggest little badass for doing it
When I watched it in the cinema there was a woman sitting two rows in front of me shouting "no sister! No!" I wanted to throw her down those stairs
i love how the title card of the movie actually fit in musically with the opening sequence. as a band person that was really satisfying.
I didn't even know people thought the waterfall thing was a plothole until now.
Before the birth, their life was fine relatively speaking. They didn't live by the waterfall because they didn't have to. They had a nice, warm house and all they paid for it was their voices. Having a deaf daughter, they probably didn't care that much that they couldn't talk.
And what would they even do in the winter? If they lived at the waterfall, the house would be unprepared for when they moved back. It's so stupid.
So Jim divorced Pam married some new girl while Dwight is the ruler of the aliens and is getting back at jim for all the pranks
Zeus Actual what about Jim and Pam’s kids and Angela and Dwight’s marriage
Malia W Kids got eaten. Dwight knew what he had to do so her sacrificed Angela to show he’s the alpha.
Nether thought of that
Zeus Actual that’s why they’re called angels
TheNinthGeneration that makes Dwight god.
In a world of people championing the nitpick some have lost sight on what it means to just ENJOY a movie. I love this channel so much for being a vehicle to remind people to chill and have fun. There’s a place for CinemaSins for a laugh but CinemaWins makes me love movies even more. It even helps me find gems in movies I don’t like.
AND CinemaWins gives love to the scores. This channel is a national treasure.
Vicky Bagley Ikr !! The positivity of this channel is so fresh !! And organic !!
frostmagemarii pssst. Did you see where I said I enjoy CinemaSINS as well? The channel isn’t just popular because of me. I often watch both for the same movie. But it’s fashionable to nitpick enjoyment even out of good movies too, regardless if you think this one is garbage.
frostmagemarii Ok, let me answer the question then. Yes, I know you can criticize a movie and still enjoy it. Most people do. Honestly, you’re not making much sense.
frostmagemarii Oh, so I did understand you the first time. I clearly stated that SOME people have forgotten how to ENJOY movies. So, there is a segment of the population who can’t see beyond perceived and actual plot holes. Who are overly critical to the point they admit not liking a movie because they don’t know where the “sand” came from. I never said you can’t do both or because you find issues with a movie you can’t enjoy it. Psst...I was pretty clear in my original post. You want to nitpick my sentiment and it stands regardless of how badly you want to prove me wrong.
@@frostmagemarii I think you're reaching but you can interpret comments how you want.
Or is that art i'm thinking of?
22:57 You don’t need to apologize for that. Honestly, this sort of analysis is the reason that I love your videos.
11:01 When i saw this scene for the first time I cried like a baby. Its so powerful and the actors and score give it so much more weight. Absolutely outstanding scene!
Have you read the original script treatment? John’s death is even more heartbreaking. He screams “I love you” instead. Yeah, the final version is obviously a lot better, but I obviously imparted those lines upon the actual ending.
that's not heartbreaking. i'd have burst out laughing if thats how it went. you could not make that not look dumb as hell or super corny/awful. it wouldn't fit at all. I really dislike this movie for multiple reasons but i can still admit that it's amazingly acted and there are plenty of scenes that i still find very tense. the way it ended is probably the best that death could be done. if he screamed "I love you" that wouldn't work at all in my opinion. i cant see it even coming close. Signing it in silence as the music came in was a much more impactful way of doing it i think.
I hate how armchair movie critics pick one plot "hole" and they just pick that hill to die on, never ever conceding.
Why didn't they live near the waterfall?
Have you ever noticed that basically nobody does? Try building a house right next to running water like that and see how long it lasts before the wood goes all soft and it falls apart, gets mouldy etc etc.
It's a dumb idea because you'd get used to it and be desensitized to the danger of the "real" world.
Another one I've seen people say is that it's convenient that John's character could engineer the hearing aids, like holy cow what a massive convenience that is, terrible writing.Even though he clearly couldn't? He quite clearly spent months trying to understand how ears work just to try help his daughter, maybe he had some technical skill beforehand but...seriously? That's impossible?
That's one criticism I hate about movie critics "Oh he just _happens_ to know how to do that?"
Uh...yeah? People know how to do things. If the world went to shit like this there'd be engineers that can build solar panels, doctors with extremely helpful medical knowledge, mechanics that can fix up vehicles.It's like characters for some reason have to be these unemployed blank slates that don't know how to do anything and that they're only allowed the tools of the movie to survive, it's so stupid.
mrcheesemunch to a certain degree there are some people's who suspension of belief is too shallow to accept that this is the world where all of those coincidences collide
one? ONE? Ok let`s count plot holes:
- we have aliens that navigate by sound, so why they`re still alive? Military didn`t figure that out and used sound as bait to kill them? It`s not like they`re immortal or smth. We can clearly see that shotgun is a good weapon, so why the rockets and bombs are not?
-their way of living at farm doesn`t work and we can see it why, how the hell they lasted for so long? For year there was not a single cough, fart or sneeze?
-they have electricity so just use that in car audio system in a metal cage to attract aliens and live calm.
-the range monsters can hear humans is so vast and not defied at all, sometimes they can hear a distant clap and sometimes they don`t hear a thing, so convienet
-The girl...that stupid girl, she needed 4 times to learn that hearing device on her ear can repel aliens
-pregnancy (having unsafed sex) during time when bringing kids will make you suffer to survive. Can`t they do in the ass if they were so horny? They had like 4-3 kids and God knows how many were massacered because of their stupidity before them.
-Jewish actor sacrificing himself to save kids is the dumbest thing in whole movie. So instead of trwoing axe at metall shed near - he screams? Why? So that people with one brain hemisphere can feel sorry and shed some tears on the dad of the year. That was so cheap I was hoping that monster rip kids apart as well as punishement for his idiotic sacrifice.
I was hoping that this film would be good, but god awful script just ruined it, it`s like they had a great idea "silent horror movie where everyone need to stay quiet to survive" and what we got was a cheese drama moments, bad screenwriting and I guess Blunt was dragged by her husband begging "oh please please Emily star in my shitty movie, you`ll atract people" and it worked.
I don`t understand either people became dumber and they can`t see all the major flaws or i`m used to movies with detailed stories?
You know what makes a good horror movie? Not the jumpscares, not the family against monsters - a good solid plot (even simple stories can be detailed and interesting to watch) detailed world and last, but not least - heroes that try to survive, all I saw that Emily Blunt tried to survive and her falimy had a death wish.
And that shotgun cocking in the end...Jesus. I hope someone bitch slaped director for this non-sense. I can go on forever why this movie had a great idea and awful realisation, but it`s internet so nobody cares.
PS: downvote all you want, It`s my IMHO...Oh and you, grammar nazis, commenting on my grammar is another nail to the coffin to all answers that were thought through by CinemaWins and not the fucking screenwriters, when all the explanations consist of "we don`t know, we were never told, so plausible" is a shitty exuse for you liking a shitty movie. Instead of counter-argumenting you look like a bunch of kids . Jeez...one thing is to like a bad movie and acknowledging it, and an opposite thing is to like a bad movie and find all the answears in your head not the movie - that`s just sad. First is just your taste, second is eating shit and never knowing it. Watch good horror classics like The Thing where almost everything was logical, damn even 1st predator is a better written story that this garbage.
LPrussia07 Did...did you watch the video? These plot holes were answered. At least I think they were. Your grammar is so awful that I can’t even tell what the hell your saying, so you could be pointing out plot holes or just rambling. I can’t tell because you can’t write proper grammar. And don’t call it an ode to autism. I’m so sick of people conflating stupidity with autism. There are just as many high functioning autistic as there are low functioning, and calling something autistic because you thought it was dumb only shows you as the shortsighted idiotic one.
@@LPrussia07 i think that was the most stupid thing i have ever read. Your points are just beyond dumb.
@@cartoonnetworkdisneyxdsupe6864 *you're
The foley for the aliens hearing sound followed by a close up of their ear was a grape being tasered and slowed right down so you can hear each individual electrical wave