I Tested Bose & Sony's Premium Earbuds - HUGE differences!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 сен 2024

Комментарии • 384

  • @Andyhandle
    @Andyhandle 11 месяцев назад +51

    Really appreciate the different noisy conditions testing. Most reviewers seem to treat noise cancellation as just one thing.

  • @Belgarath777
    @Belgarath777 11 месяцев назад +123

    I just got the Bose. Fortunately I don't hear any left ear hiss and after trying the Sony, I completely disagree about how the Bose is more likely to fall out. These are lodged in my ear, yet, still comfortable. There could be a 10.0 earthquake and these things ain't falling out. Also disagree about the Bass comments.

    • @Kavyavyas363
      @Kavyavyas363 10 месяцев назад +2

      Hii.. can you please compare bass of these two.. using xm4 for two weeks now.. and i feel bass is not as punchy as bose soundsport which i used for an year. Now planning to go for bose qc2 purely for bass. Is it recommended ??

    • @XxZcorpionXx
      @XxZcorpionXx 9 месяцев назад +17

      Have both and can confirm that bose are better at everything except call quality!!

    • @Kavyavyas363
      @Kavyavyas363 9 месяцев назад +2

      @@XxZcorpionXx thanks a ton !

    • @PurposeTravel
      @PurposeTravel 9 месяцев назад +8

      The hiss/squeal/buzz in the left earbud is a total deal breaker for me. They were returned.

    • @geekinhard343
      @geekinhard343 9 месяцев назад +8

      It's different for everyone. Everyone's ears are shaped differently. For me the sony will not ever fall out I barely ever adjust them. Where the bose I have had one fall out into a bucket of water 2 times now lmao. It's not really opinion based, it's based on your ear shape and size

  • @StefanConstantinDumitrache
    @StefanConstantinDumitrache 9 месяцев назад +41

    A word on replacing Sony's foam tips for silicon ones: the protection which covers the tube is NOT on the tube itself, but on the foam tip, so you need to look for silicon tips with the same protection on them, otherwise in time you risk getting the buds filled with all sorts of gunk or earwax.

    • @jk6078
      @jk6078 4 месяца назад

      Sony is Asian company and Asians have dry ear wax. so they dont really think that through....

    • @evolution5052
      @evolution5052 Месяц назад

      Did u find any such eartips ?

    • @StefanConstantinDumitrache
      @StefanConstantinDumitrache Месяц назад

      @@evolution5052 I did not look for such tips.

    • @flexor212000
      @flexor212000 Месяц назад +1

      Which will probably void the warranty. Not that the warranty is that long but still.

  • @blakegara7841
    @blakegara7841 6 месяцев назад +10

    Had the Bose for 2 weeks and every single phone caller I had told me I sound horrible as if I’m speaking through a paper towel roll and that they are not interested in having a long conversation with me if this was persistent. Which is unfortunate because I use my earbuds for work every day. This video seems to be exactly what the callers on the other end were experiencing with me.

    • @JorgeReyesMD
      @JorgeReyesMD Месяц назад

      Buddy domt get either if you want phone calls quality. They both suck

  • @Hookmeister
    @Hookmeister 11 месяцев назад +42

    Bose are so comfortable! I’m just not a fan of buds that require deeper insertion to get a good seal.

    • @771shadowolf
      @771shadowolf 6 месяцев назад

      See there new open earbuds ??

    • @apox5308
      @apox5308 2 месяца назад +2

      That’s what she said

  • @prettyflowers9956
    @prettyflowers9956 10 месяцев назад +21

    Why don't earbud testers like yourself test for wind noise cancellation? For anyone that uses audio outdoors I would think wind noise would be the number 1 issue!

  • @Ashlord
    @Ashlord 11 месяцев назад +23

    You mentioned crackling sounds at one point in the video, and I've experienced that with my Galaxy Buds Pro recently. It's happened maybe twice, but it is pretty noticeable and sightly annoying. However though, I've just put them in the case and out again and that's fixed it both times :)
    Anyway, great video! 😂

  • @milton8769
    @milton8769 11 месяцев назад +36

    Looks like bose still havent figured out the mic quality thing. Comfortable, light, great anc but awfull call quality (have the qc700s and tested the old version of esrbud). The complaints were that it felt i was moving in and out of a microphone or that it sounded like I was inside an empty water tank

  • @jameslobsinger7326
    @jameslobsinger7326 11 месяцев назад +60

    The foam tips on the Sony are a no-go for me which, as stated above are what gives them the edge in the NC results. They were also rather unsecure and uncomfortable for me with the many silicone type tips that I prefer, at least until I found a set of tips that work for me. The NC with all of the silicone tips I tried was nowhere as effective as that of the Bose, which are much more comfortable, secure and effective for NC (I own both). Once I settled on a set of tips that work for me on the Sonys I like them quite well and they sound amazing! However the Bose are my go-to when I want the most effective NC, and sound great to boot.

    • @cy5214
      @cy5214 11 месяцев назад +5

      I agree. Sony's ear tips are garbage. I swapped them out with Airfoams Pro Universal ear tips and they are best combination. Smart having silicone and memory foam together. Too bad they don't make one for Bose.

    • @BishieBishie
      @BishieBishie 11 месяцев назад +1

      The biggest problem Sony have with the tips and ANC is not that the tips do all the work, its been tested and they dont, the ANC is superb. BUT. If you dont like the tips so you change them, you lose some ANC, why would you spend that money to lose some of the ANC when the Bose just work? And to me the Bose are more comfy. The most odd thing is that if you switch to other foam tips like the Comply ones, you lose more ANC than you do switching to Silicone like azla... So its not just the foam, but that Sony tuned the ANC to work with their tips so much, switching them out will give very varied results. Source is AREGINA.

    • @CocoXLarge
      @CocoXLarge 11 месяцев назад +3

      @@BishieBishie Until a year in your Bose stops working for no goddam reason.

    • @ThcBanaman
      @ThcBanaman 10 месяцев назад +1

      I hated the Sony foam tips for the XM4s, just got the XM5 and the foam tips are amazing. I already ordered silicone tips in advance that I don’t need now. No more hurting ears

    • @MrAhuraMazda
      @MrAhuraMazda 10 месяцев назад +2

      Foam tips arent for noise canceling theyre for frequency response, specially mid bass

  • @LoyalSol
    @LoyalSol 11 месяцев назад +29

    I would have given the XM5 a try if it wasn't for the fact that Sony actively screwed up the XM4s with their firmware. I thought it was just my pair, but apparently multiple people had their $300 earbuds ruined because Sony sent out defective firmware and then tried to pretend they didn't have to replace them despite it being their problem. The firmware actively ruined the battery and actually caused some people's to overheat.
    I don't know if I trust Sony enough to not mess up another $300 pair of earbuds when the last pair says they aren't that competent when it comes to firmware. They soured me on their products with that one.

    • @Steve211Ucdhihifvshi
      @Steve211Ucdhihifvshi 11 месяцев назад +3

      Yeah they arent the typical japanese company sadly. I wish Toyota made headphones, sonys are made by idiots in the philipines and other crappy third world countries and all these problems across both brands are common.

    • @wadep5100
      @wadep5100 11 месяцев назад +3

      +1 also another Sony user here who had their XM4s killed by Sony's firmware update. I also don't know if I can trust Sony again. But it doesn’t look like the Bose is the superior choice so it’s a tough call. If I go down the Sony route, I’ll be taking extended warranty!

    • @TigerKittay
      @TigerKittay 11 месяцев назад +1

      I had to replace the right battery on my XM4s. I believe the firmware update did it.

    • @treborrrrr
      @treborrrrr 11 месяцев назад +2

      *raises hand* Yup, happened to me. They wouldn't replace them for me. Ended up buying new batteries and replacing them only to have a hum appear in the right earbud whenever ANC is on (which apparently has happened to people that have _not_ opened the earbuds up at all as well). I really don't want to give Sony any more money but they seem to be what ticks most boxes for me. I'm more than a little bummed out.

    • @gaelsg1547
      @gaelsg1547 10 месяцев назад +2

      Totally agree! SONY NEVER AGAIN

  • @STUDSrUS333
    @STUDSrUS333 8 месяцев назад +6

    After having the Sonys for only 3 weeks before them becoming nothing more than a paperweight due to “water damage” , I picked up the Bose and find them to be way more comfortable and very very similar sound quality

  • @peurpaelen3261
    @peurpaelen3261 9 месяцев назад +14

    I love the comfort of the Bose over the Sony Foam tips, but the left earbud of the Bose Ultras makes is a constant static and feedback noise that bugs me, especially when listening to calm music in the library (b/c I can hear the static more and it's hard to ignore it once you realise it).
    Does anyone else have a problem with a static noise in the left earbud of the Bose? Doesn't seem like there is a solution to it.

    • @georginagates6553
      @georginagates6553 7 месяцев назад +2

      I've also had the same problem! I've gotten 2 pairs, both had that static hissing noise and it's super disappointing. I'm most likely going to pick up a pair of the sony's.

    • @peurpaelen3261
      @peurpaelen3261 7 месяцев назад

      @@georginagates6553 I tried the Sony xm5 earbuds as well. But, personally they are less comfortable than Bose and a less secure fit. Plus, because of how deep they are inside your ears if you're running or even walking, each footstep makes a bass thud that gets annoying over time.
      I really wish that Bose didn't have that static sound and I tried very hard to overlook that, but I couldn't get myself to ignore it.

  • @hopeseekr
    @hopeseekr 2 месяца назад

    When I first demoed the Bose QuietComfort Ultra earbuds in The Mall of Dubai in October 2023, it literally changed my life. I bought a pair right then and I have traveled around the world with them two times since. Literally changed my life as an introvert programmer. Now I can walk the busy streets of NYC or The Mall of The Emirates and totally zone out the noise of crowds. Totally life changing for me!

  • @geekinhard343
    @geekinhard343 9 месяцев назад +5

    You can just tap 4 times and hold to increase the volume more with the Sony. I think its funny how many people miss this detail.

  • @rolins3279
    @rolins3279 11 месяцев назад +13

    Zero words on how the Bose QC Ultra is a slot trap 🤦🏽‍♂️
    Instead of providing the software update to all QC 2s, Bose preferred to do it only on those not yet sold, added a coat of silver paint to the earbuds, and wants to make it look like a new product, leaving the previous buyers behind in the process.
    And the media and youtubers pretend not to know or understand it, it's really nasty.

    • @Fredo.heavyy
      @Fredo.heavyy 11 месяцев назад +1

      I was honest on my review and I’m getting slaughtered by the NPC😅

    • @conheo4
      @conheo4 11 месяцев назад

      I agree with you.

    • @SibTiger33
      @SibTiger33 11 месяцев назад

      I know right. Not a single reviewer is talking a out this.

  • @isaacwutkee11
    @isaacwutkee11 11 месяцев назад +16

    I’m glad you mentioned that crackling in the left Bose earbud at 2:07! I mentioned this in the comments of your initial Bose review a couple days ago, but I 100% have the exact same experience with mine. I think it’s honestly going to be all of their earbuds.
    I love everything else about them. Incredible transparency, incredible Immersive sound, and very good bass and all around sound. But I hate that faint crackling.

    • @ponymushama
      @ponymushama 11 месяцев назад +5

      My Bose Ultra's left earbud is crackling all the time. Sigh 🥲

    • @Steve211Ucdhihifvshi
      @Steve211Ucdhihifvshi 11 месяцев назад

      Sonys over ear xm3 xm4 and xm4 alllll do the same. its due to diferences in pressure. and the membrane of the actual speaker.

    • @ponymushama
      @ponymushama 11 месяцев назад

      Airpods Pro 2 does not have this annoying crackling sound. @@Steve211Ucdhihifvshi

    • @melvinp1324
      @melvinp1324 11 месяцев назад +1

      i get the same - its like a BT connection loss - pretty sure mine are going back and ill get the B&O EX

    • @treborrrrr
      @treborrrrr 10 месяцев назад

      @@Steve211Ucdhihifvshi My XM4s did not do that, until the battery died in my right one and I replaced it, now it's making noise constantly when the ANC is on. I've seen others mentioning the same thing without opening them up so I'm not quite sure what causes it. It's annoying though as they were basically dead silent before, even with ANC on.

  • @sharatmuthyala
    @sharatmuthyala 11 месяцев назад +6

    Brand wise BOSE the way they value their customers you feel like respected
    I had issues with unequal battery drains of rt earbud in Sony 1000xm4 just after 6m and customer care gave me a nightmare I felt like somehow they were trying to escape from replacement n make profits to their company felt cheated
    As a customer who paid 300$ for a small pair of ear buds which hardly lasted 1/2 yr as opposed to bose products which easily last a decade real value for money and trust worthy quality
    For now I will never go back to sony
    Happy with earbuds 2 pro❤

  • @bffmrk
    @bffmrk 11 месяцев назад +7

    The fit was the otherway around for me. The xm5 foam tips dont work for me, with x/xs when my head moves a bit it lets in sound and when the m is in, it kinda uncomfy. So i have to use my extra silicone tips. With the bose, its perfect and doesnt move no matter what i do.

  • @dandavis5533
    @dandavis5533 Месяц назад +6

    Just to let you know, Bose has added multi-point Bluetooth connectivity.

    • @jbhines
      @jbhines 24 дня назад

      They did, with this unit? That’s the only thing I don’t care for in my QC.

    • @dandavis5533
      @dandavis5533 24 дня назад +1

      @@jbhines From the Bose website under the FAQ: "Yes. The Ultra Earbuds have the Bluetooth multipoint feature allowing them to connect to two source devices at the same time. This is a recent update as of July 2024, so be sure to set up your earbuds with the Bose app to receive software updates."

  • @donaldmaynor
    @donaldmaynor 11 месяцев назад +8

    My personal favorite earbuds right now are the technics AZ 80s for $300 these are overall the best pair of anc earbuds on the market right now they have great anc not as good as bose and sonys but really close and transparency just as good as the airpods pro audiophile quality sound great battery life ldac codec small case really responsive touch controls witch are very customizable 3 way industry leading multipoint so you can connect to any 3 devices at the same time and it works flawlessly and they have wireless charging so overall these are the best and they been my daily drivers and will continue to be my daily drivers for a long time

    • @Steve211Ucdhihifvshi
      @Steve211Ucdhihifvshi 11 месяцев назад +3

      why would anyone pay close to spny or bose price for a no name chinese brand thats riding on the name of a long defunct company... pfft $300 for junkstore rubbish.

    • @donaldmaynor
      @donaldmaynor 11 месяцев назад +3

      @@Steve211Ucdhihifvshi no name Chinese brand huh let me tell ya technics have been in the game for a very long time now and always make great products and I would say maybe u should give them a shot before u give a negative review without trying them

    • @SibTiger33
      @SibTiger33 11 месяцев назад +1

      100 percentage. Agreed. The best buds on the market right now

    • @SibTiger33
      @SibTiger33 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@Steve211Ucdhihifvshiyou do know that technics is a japanese company right?? Wow u are seriously uneducated

    • @SibTiger33
      @SibTiger33 11 месяцев назад

      ​@@donaldmaynortechnics are japanese and the previous commenter is just uneducated

  • @jordanking7711
    @jordanking7711 11 месяцев назад +12

    A lot of people would say that obviously the Bose have FAR superior ANC, but I bought a pair of XM5's a couple of days ago, tested the ANC out with those and compared to the WH-1000XM4's I have, I think they do an awesome job, without the pressure feeling in your ears that you get with Bose.

    • @brwa5176
      @brwa5176 11 месяцев назад +4

      Strange I feel no pressure with the Bose, maybe our ear shapes are different.

    • @Bob-x2u9b
      @Bob-x2u9b 10 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@brwa5176I felt the obvious pressure with Bose-quite annoying.

    • @Fozzee.1970
      @Fozzee.1970 7 месяцев назад

      Same here no pressure from the Bose ​@@brwa5176

  • @TakashiSulzberger
    @TakashiSulzberger 11 месяцев назад +8

    It would be interesting to see how the Sony Inzone Buds would rank in this test :)
    In my first impression, they could even establish themselves in everyday use.

    • @falcongames6465
      @falcongames6465 11 месяцев назад +1

      I heard that the ANC on them is bad? Is that true?

    • @StefanConstantinDumitrache
      @StefanConstantinDumitrache 9 месяцев назад

      @@falcongames6465 The ANC quality is not that much different between XM5 and INZONE. I oscillated between these two models, eventually decided to buy the INZONE and returned them the same day and got the XM5 instead. They both have the same drivers, so should sound the same, but INZONE are limited in their connectivity and that's baked in, unlikely to be "fixed" with updates.
      They come packed with a USB-C adapter which ensures low latency and best possible sound, but without it the use-case is VERY limited. I have a laptop without USB-C, so no adapter, but I still could not connect the buds via BT LE (which is their ONLY BT protocol). Same with two Android phones, which both have BT LE capability, and while in their case I could plug the adapter, I don't see myself using the buds this way.
      On the plus side is the longer battery life when compared with XM5 (at least as advertised, since I did not spend enough time with them), and the lower audio latency is beneficial in games, BUT some games do compensate for this and I did not notice delays or discrepancies with the XM5.
      All in all I think the XM5 is a better pick for general use, even if they are a bit more expensive while having somewhat less battery life.

  • @Imperialbbuilding
    @Imperialbbuilding 11 месяцев назад +13

    After owning x
    Wf4 i thought id try the bose based off good reviews. One day after owning the bose i took them back and exchanged for wf5. The sonys are unmatched. The only thing i liked about the bose was that they are extremely comfortable

  • @lol3ndir
    @lol3ndir 6 месяцев назад +2

    Still using the XM4 earbuds and I think it's so good that upgrade can wait for several years. Thanks for the video review!

    • @Mike335is
      @Mike335is 6 месяцев назад +1

      I absolutely love my xm4s... However, the battery over time is horrible... They're dead after about 4 hours... Where it used to be about 8 hrs...

    • @lol3ndir
      @lol3ndir 5 месяцев назад

      @@Mike335is that's the downside of the XM4. I use it everyday for calls and it only last for around 2 hrs.

    • @lol3ndir
      @lol3ndir 5 месяцев назад

      @@Mike335is and here I am after updating my XM4 to latest firmware my battery on my right earbud dies within an hour. Of course I over after a year so no more warranty! This is my 2nd unit of XM4 (same battery issue) so no more Sony for me!

  • @TigerKittay
    @TigerKittay 11 месяцев назад +18

    I don’t buy premium earbuds for phone call quality but sound and ANC. I don’t remember the last time I used them on for phone calls.

  • @hueyh5637
    @hueyh5637 10 месяцев назад +1

    I like the nod or shake your head to answer and cancel calls on the sony. Great when your at work and your hands aren’t free.

  • @teddytanalski3926
    @teddytanalski3926 10 месяцев назад +3

    I got both of these also to try em out...Bose more comfortable to have in ear longer but the Sony was better for nose cancellation in a shop environment with an airgun. The Bose tended to make static when using air hose. I also had momentum wireless s3s which had good noise cancelation but less than both of these. And is worse with air gun.

  • @johnmartin8481
    @johnmartin8481 11 месяцев назад +9

    I must admit I am Bose fan and purchased my first QC headphones for the expressed purpose of air travel. The Bose QC saved my sanity when flying. Based on your review both products are excellent. For me the Bose AC Ultra earbuds would be my purchase choice. Thank you for another well balance and informative review comparison.

  • @Technosquid
    @Technosquid 11 месяцев назад +5

    I tried the XM5 but returned them. They need more user customizable options and better single bud operation. I actually prefer my Pixel Buds Pro to the XM5. Trying the Bose next.

  • @curtiscrawford5696
    @curtiscrawford5696 9 месяцев назад +2

    2:16 yes. absolutely there is a left ear hiss in the Bose QC 2 & ultra. I have replaced mine twice to the same effect, the Left always having the worst issue. Unless you’re in a noisy environment or have constant loud music playing (possibly why the preset volume is pretty high) or have ear damage, I suspect you’ll hear it too.
    Such a shame.

    • @JuliusTurner-hm6ff
      @JuliusTurner-hm6ff 7 месяцев назад

      Its the ghost of your wallet. Haunting you for paying $300 for earbuds.

    • @StuWright
      @StuWright 7 месяцев назад

      damn that sounds like a problem,but i`m not finding the sonys comfortable

  • @daftvadered
    @daftvadered 11 месяцев назад +4

    With the Sony ear buds XM4 and XM5 could you do some basic comparisons with silicon ear tips, im not a fan of foam tips generally but interested to see how well they perform noise cancelling and sound quality wise.

  • @blalesnail3098
    @blalesnail3098 4 дня назад

    The mid-body on the Bose are just so enormous. If you have the wrong sized ear they hurt no matter what, even if you buy the size-0 stability band kit.

  • @momentarilylapse
    @momentarilylapse 6 месяцев назад +3

    Are the charts from 1:02 available anywhere online with all the devices you've tested? They are super helpful (particularly the high-frequency ANC charts) but sometimes I want to compare two devices that might not be compared in the same video.
    Great content! I have watched a bunch of these to help me narrow down my next purchase.

  • @wb3213
    @wb3213 11 месяцев назад +2

    just bought the xm5s they're so small but Amazing !

  • @Reventrant
    @Reventrant 5 месяцев назад

    I just bought these and while the right side Buds Pro wanted to fall out on me while chewing, the Bose are locked in, no matter what I'm doing. The sound quality in great and the Immersion Mode is slightly mindblowing.

  • @ajl3791177
    @ajl3791177 9 месяцев назад +2

    I read that bose ultra does support wireless charging,, is that true?

  • @NathanThrower
    @NathanThrower 7 месяцев назад +1

    I do hear the hissing in the left hear. Sounds like coil whine or some sort of RF interference. Fine when listening to music but less fine when I they are in without audio playing.

  • @Elysian-III
    @Elysian-III 10 месяцев назад +1

    Im seeing alot of reviews in th comments saying that the XM4 struggled with battery life in the longrun and that the foam earpieces arent comfortable. I can agree to this. I hate how foam feels over long uses and i currently own a pair of galaxy buds pro. They wree good for a while, but the quality in battery life went down drastically and i feel like the quality of audio went down as well. While I, also on the other hand, own a pair of 1st gen QC bose, they still remain very good in battery life and still have maintained there sound quality. And thanks to this video, i can reliably say that I'll be making the permanent move from Sony to Bose from now on. I will be sacrificing audio quality, but at least I'll have a more comfortable time with them and they'll also stand the test of time

  • @cirecomputers
    @cirecomputers 11 месяцев назад +7

    The thing I cant stand about the Sony Xm4s and Xm5s are the foam eartips which is essentially what gives them the leg up on the Bose offerings when it comes to NC . They are too rigid and uncomfortable in my ear and if I take them off in favor of silicone ear tips there is a substantial drop in passive nc and noise cancelling in general. Taking this into consideration, I very MUCH prefer the Bose QC IIs and Ultra (the same thing in my book) which are way more comfortable, have better true ANC without the foam eartips and stay in my ears more securely with their wings.

    • @jordanking7711
      @jordanking7711 11 месяцев назад +1

      It depends on the ear. I bought a pair of XM5's the other day and had zero problems. As for ANC, Flossy Carter said in his review of these ear buds that the ANC in those was 'scary quiet' and I have to agree with him. As I said, it depends largely on the ears and what size tips you put on them.

    • @cy5214
      @cy5214 11 месяцев назад +1

      try the Airfoams Pro Universal ear tips. It works because it has both silicone and memory foam so you get that seal and not the rigid and comfortable without the NC drop off.

  • @kittealand
    @kittealand Месяц назад

    I had the dreaded battery drainage issue after firmaware update with my Sony WF1000XM4 and I figured never Sony again. Well, I couldn't resists picking up the XM5 a couple of days ago and I love them to bits. I was first disappointed with the sound as I was with the XM4's but realized the problem was the same - I was using too small tips. The mic is very much improved also when making phone calls.

  • @humeyboy
    @humeyboy 11 месяцев назад +5

    Bose want you to pay £50 for the Wireless Charging Mod and £10 for the Extra fit kit.

  • @Ianmundo
    @Ianmundo 11 месяцев назад +6

    why is the Bose case so massive? 😂

  • @mohmushtaq77
    @mohmushtaq77 10 месяцев назад +2

    I have both of them but still craving to have more out of them. There is no perfect headphone or earbud.

  • @Bernd123
    @Bernd123 6 месяцев назад

    Tbh for calls in noisy environments Huawei Freebuds Pro 3 are currently the boss. Mostly due to their much superior bone conduction tech. Some youtuber tested them against 5 other top tier earbuds (like these here) in various standartised noisy environments where you can judge for yourself.

  • @brwa5176
    @brwa5176 11 месяцев назад +5

    I returned my XM5s and am keeping the Bose QC Ultras. Probably the biggest reason is the Bose has a more oval eartip shape while the Sony is round. For my ears at least I could never get a good seal with the XM5s leading to crappy noise isolation and audio quality (for others this may not be an issue). With the Sony's I'd have to massage the eartips each time before putting them in, Ultra's can go in instantly. Noise cancelling for me was far superior on the Bose. XM5s and Ultras both have a surround sound option but the XM5s requires special content that is very limited and expensive. The Ultras work with any stereo music (usually great but occasionally not so great). It would be nice if the Ultra's had wireless charging built into the case (available as a sleeve) and multipoint would be nice, but I use my earbuds with three devices and the Sony's only multipoint with two so it didn't help much.

  • @Idocare1893
    @Idocare1893 8 месяцев назад +1

    @Mike O'Brien: thanks for this. Why did you not include Jabra Elite and Active buds in your comparison?

  • @joncarr2222
    @joncarr2222 11 месяцев назад +2

    I had the XM4s and the battery didn’t last 3 years. Replacing with Bose.

    • @AndrewUKLondon
      @AndrewUKLondon 10 месяцев назад

      I've still got my xmf3 and they're fine. Maybe you had a duff battery. I haven't tried but it's possible to replace the xmf3 battery.
      Better still are Shure's bluetooth earhooks. They connect to Shure's mmcx detachable earbuds, which also attach to cables (3.5mm, lightning, usb C). I've had my Shure earbuds for 10 years now (only had the shure earhooks for 2 years). Also means that when Shure produce aptx lossless earhooks I can carry on using my top notch earbuds.

  • @blandruss
    @blandruss 2 месяца назад

    I’ve just watched your review of these Bose ones as well as the Marshall ones. I’m toying with buying either but having tested both (and recommended both!) which would you go for? Thanks

  • @gaurlglmistrz
    @gaurlglmistrz 10 месяцев назад +4

    Hi! Which ones will better reduce the noise like footsteps in a room above? Trying to choose one of these for sleeping, would really appreciate any help!

  • @mavricxx
    @mavricxx 11 месяцев назад +1

    Sony for the win, only thing is I don't like how bulky the Sony are. Just wish the Sony were smaller and had the wings like the Beats Fit Pro. One thing that caught my attention with Bose QC Ultra Earbuds mentioned in this review was the crackling or something from the left earpiece at 2:06. I have the Bose QC2 earbuds and that crakling or whatever it is even hurts my ears. If you're like me that likes earbuds to workout DO NOT get the Bose, especially when you're doing activities like working out, jumping, running etc that horrible sound is at its worse. Another thing I hate about the Bose is that it feels cheap like it could break easily. As a comparison I have a pair of Jabra Elite Active 75t and I much prefer those to workout in. Love the physical buttons, fit (except for no wings as well) and the sound is decent.

    • @Mattp-y1p
      @Mattp-y1p 9 месяцев назад +1

      Sony doesn’t stay in ur ear to workout in them. Bose don’t move.

  • @watchluver
    @watchluver 8 месяцев назад +1

    Battery life? or did i miss it?

  • @Peakabike
    @Peakabike 11 месяцев назад +1

    Good comparidon, thanks. Any plans to test the Jabra 10, c'est Jabra earbuds so far.

    • @apox5308
      @apox5308 2 месяца назад

      Owned 2 jabras and they are no where as good as these two plus they break

  • @timquain5341
    @timquain5341 5 месяцев назад

    Sony sound like they'd suit me more. How would they go with a S23 ultra? I've been looking at the samsung earbuds, as well. You can track them if you lose them and they make a noise if you walk away from them.

  • @donnagathers6979
    @donnagathers6979 11 месяцев назад +1

    Great video, thanks

  • @pengsm
    @pengsm 17 дней назад

    I can hear that noise on the left ear, it's wierd i thought it was just me. Also the Bose after putting it in the case, it's still connected to my phone. I'll have to wait for 5-10 minutes for it to disconnect. I returned the Bose and got the Sony.
    It's a bummer because i have Bose speakers and their headphones both works well, but their earbuds are horrible. My other Bose quiet comfort earbuds wont even connect, keeps flashing red and white.....

  • @khalideljamilelalaoui3613
    @khalideljamilelalaoui3613 11 месяцев назад +2

    I wanted to know if you were going to do a test on the Jabra Elite 10.

    • @StuWright
      @StuWright 7 месяцев назад

      the what lol

  • @scubainstructor
    @scubainstructor 11 месяцев назад +1

    Great review👌

  • @nawalsingh9159
    @nawalsingh9159 6 месяцев назад

    I have samsung S24 ultra mobile which ear phone should I buy which suitable with this mobile? Should I go for samsung earbuds pro 2 or Sony or bose?

  • @alirodriguezm
    @alirodriguezm 11 месяцев назад +5

    I just returned my ultra to Bose, the Audio during phone calls was extremely low, tried everything with tech support but nothing

    • @xxgodsxx4618
      @xxgodsxx4618 11 месяцев назад

      samething that happened to me during a call they sounded very low where I can't barely hear them and plus they pick up to much background noise.

    • @alirodriguezm
      @alirodriguezm 11 месяцев назад

      @@xxgodsxx4618and is working normal again?

    • @xxgodsxx4618
      @xxgodsxx4618 11 месяцев назад

      @@alirodriguezm it just happen randomly i wear 1 earbuds but the sound come out very low idk y​

  • @gpeking01
    @gpeking01 10 месяцев назад +1

    Can you do a review on the Noble Audio Fokus Prestige True Wireless IEMs

  • @NamirYAH
    @NamirYAH 11 месяцев назад +6

    The Bose case looks like a Diaper.

  • @noidea796
    @noidea796 11 месяцев назад +2

    Is jabra next?

  • @aaronyounger452
    @aaronyounger452 Месяц назад

    I bought the Sony m5 and was very disappointed in the bass and overall comfort for me. I tried different sized tips but nothing helped. It's also super annoying that the Sony has a slippery surface and made them difficult to remove from the case. I ended up getting the jabra elite 8 active gen 2 and they are night and day different with comfort and quality. The bass is way better and the ANC is just as good as the Sony

  • @RCvanKessel
    @RCvanKessel 11 месяцев назад +11

    Would love the Bose for the ANC, but no multipoint for a $300 pair of earbuds in 2023? Just baffling in my opinion.

    • @Winter4lifer
      @Winter4lifer 10 месяцев назад

      The ANC tech is the best of its kind, you're always going to pay up for that.

    • @hopeseekr
      @hopeseekr 2 месяца назад

      The ANC is out of this world. I've demoed them both, and this blew the Sony XM5 out of the water.

  • @MeowMeowBeans69
    @MeowMeowBeans69 11 месяцев назад

    Your comment at the 2:10 mark about the sound you hear in the left bud when there is nothing playing...I had that in my left bud as well. I took them back. To me, it sounds like Morse code.

  • @advaitc2554
    @advaitc2554 5 месяцев назад

    Very helpful, thanks.

  • @Harley.1
    @Harley.1 10 дней назад

    I had the Bose and the build quality was shocking.. Constantly dropping out, unable to connect, unable to be discovered, rarely working seamlessly. After 2 replacements I'm with the Sony now.

  • @dariusdareme
    @dariusdareme 10 месяцев назад +1

    Because of comfort - I vote BOSE.
    Sony xm4 were very uncomfortable, couldn't ware them for more then 10 minutes.
    Returned them, got the Airpods pro , even on android.
    Bose had a ridiculously large case back then, never considered them because of that.
    The Ultra seem better in all aspects. I think you will soon find 3rd party foam tips for the Bose.
    They're cheap to produce.

    • @geekinhard343
      @geekinhard343 9 месяцев назад

      Yeah but the case is the same size still lol. Not a deal breaker but it's annoying. Especially when u get the sonys and it's like half the size

  • @DanAllen1
    @DanAllen1 11 месяцев назад +4

    The Sony's are great, except they fit for crap. They hurt your ears. So that's a total no-go.

    • @jordanking7711
      @jordanking7711 11 месяцев назад

      It depends on the shape of your ears and the ear tips.

  • @Jiren0420
    @Jiren0420 10 месяцев назад

    Wow😮🤯 I was surprised to see that Sony voice call sounds way better than Bose. I did not! Expect that

  • @user-oj8ss4zq3x
    @user-oj8ss4zq3x 8 месяцев назад

    I’m returning my Sony xm5 and getting the Bose tomorrow. My Sonys keep losing connection which is annoying.

  • @OrlandoGonzalez-o2d
    @OrlandoGonzalez-o2d 10 месяцев назад +1

    Sony earbuds are equivalent to $20 earbuds, bose earbuds are the best earbuds I've ever had. 4.5/5

  • @JoeyBeeFit
    @JoeyBeeFit 10 месяцев назад +2

    Hello everybody! I'm really trying to save you when I'm telling you that the Sony's have just one earbud that dies after less than a year of use! I do believe that Sony probably is the best out of the two models talked about in this video but it is extremely unreasonable that one will die on you while the other one won't in less than one year on top of that!

    • @2greenify
      @2greenify 10 месяцев назад

      Got the Sony's, they are good.
      Also have the previous versions, they are fine also. Used them every day in rain, with sports, etc.

    • @JoeyBeeFit
      @JoeyBeeFit 10 месяцев назад

      @@2greenify I'm glad your right one hasn't died on you yet. Takes about 6 months. Mine worked great too until they didn't and now I'm looking to buy a new pair unfortunately.

    • @2greenify
      @2greenify 10 месяцев назад

      @@JoeyBeeFit If it's only 6 month old, you still get them replaced free of charge right?

    • @JoeyBeeFit
      @JoeyBeeFit 10 месяцев назад

      @@2greenify yes, I think that under warranty you can but for me I didn't realize that this was an ongoing issue and thought that a firmware update would fix the problem until I found out that this was a major issue with this model. Either way now I need to buy a new one. I reached out to Sony and they're claiming that they'll give me my money back if I jump through hoops in order to get it so I'm currently jumping through those hoops and I ordered a pair of bose in the meantime.

    • @2greenify
      @2greenify 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@JoeyBeeFit okay, that's what you meant. I was afraid you lost money on a faulty product. Great to hear this wasn't the case. Sad that you have to go through al those hoops to get your money back though.

  • @binman5233
    @binman5233 10 месяцев назад +1

    Absolutely gutted with the poor noise cancelling performance of my Sony buds. I removed the foam tips and replaced with silicon which made a big difference. However, the wax guard is built into the tip and not the bud themselves and so replacement silicon tips with wax guards are few and far between and expensive. I now have the Bose Ultra, no contest. Bigger sound and noise cancelling that works.

    • @jackroy9094
      @jackroy9094 10 месяцев назад

      I didn’t think the noise cancellation worked on Sony xm5 either. Gave them to my daughter.

    • @ManapuaMan187
      @ManapuaMan187 8 месяцев назад

      Does yours have a white noise hiss like everyone is talking about

    • @jackroy9094
      @jackroy9094 8 месяцев назад

      @@ManapuaMan187 I didn’t notice that. I have AirPod pro 2nd gen now and they make noises sometimes and go all weird when they try to cancel some noises. Overall I liked the Sony better except for convenience.

    • @binman5233
      @binman5233 8 месяцев назад

      I have just got mine back from Sony following a reset and update, something I had already tried. They are now working fine. I have not noticed any background noise. Hopefully the blutooth stability will have improved also.
      ​@benjamingaspar1872

  • @budgrzo3361
    @budgrzo3361 19 дней назад

    Im on my second set of the Sony 1000XM5 in 1 year. Same problem both times right earbud failure. Started with volume loss and quality of sound issues then useless. Im done with Sony

  • @JB54379
    @JB54379 5 месяцев назад

    When buying earbuds I personally only care about sound quality and noise cancellation.
    IMO the BOSE kill the Sony's overall in sound quality and noise cancellation, both in full and aware modes on the BOSE.

  • @thrillseeker7
    @thrillseeker7 11 месяцев назад +1

    I just got these. They are amazing, but i have 1 problem. The voice assistant sound feedback, its so low. I press the right earbud to turn on the voice assistant on to make a call but i barely hear the sound. Cant even tell if I activated the voice assistant. Can you please tell me if you are experiencing low sound feedback when you activated voice assistant. Thank you

  • @parmindermaan1700
    @parmindermaan1700 10 месяцев назад

    I’m confused mostly i use for calls i’m crane operator and driver currently using airpods pro 2 but mic is trash specially when background noise is more it keep cutting my voice i have to repeat every time on call my friends always complaining about my voice i had Samsung buds pro before never had this issue

  • @timvlogtv512
    @timvlogtv512 11 месяцев назад +1

    Is there a Bose QC Ultra vs XM5 video coming?
    Will be waiting for it 👍👍

    • @italydude515
      @italydude515 7 месяцев назад +3

      That's what this is.. tf? Lol

  • @joncruz
    @joncruz 9 месяцев назад

    Min 2:00 vs Min 10:30 Can you please make up your mind on ANC ???

  • @michaelsong4939
    @michaelsong4939 7 месяцев назад

    i have airpods pro 2 and galaxy buds pro, i like buds pro better . overall more comfultable

  • @edwardcliftonbrown2120
    @edwardcliftonbrown2120 7 месяцев назад

    who does'nt remove their earbuds when talking to someone?

  • @denieldaukshevich
    @denieldaukshevich 6 месяцев назад

    great review

  • @AC-SlaUkr
    @AC-SlaUkr 8 месяцев назад

    Bose sounded very tinny outside in the call test.

  • @Lightemerging
    @Lightemerging 2 месяца назад

    I tell you, you used the wrong size of the "Wingtip". It is crucial to use the right size to have proper fit and by that experience the maximum Noise Cancelation.
    And Boes DOES connect to two devices. That info is wrong.
    I wore the Bose for 8 hours without pain, that is impossible with any other earphones and I testet all major brands.

  • @dontdoit468
    @dontdoit468 11 месяцев назад +1

    Not buying Sony buds ever again after the issue with battery drain on the XM4s. Highly recommend to watch Louis Rossman's video on this issue before buying the XM5s.

  • @dvil51
    @dvil51 11 месяцев назад +20

    If you have both of these buds, why don't you tell us which you think is better. I feel like that was the purpose of watching this. lol

    • @brwa5176
      @brwa5176 11 месяцев назад +4

      I have both, just returned the Sony's but mainly because for my ears the Bose fit far better providing far better sound and noise cancelling. The Ultras seem even better than the QC IIs and they were way better than the Sony's in my informal noise cancelling testing.

    • @johnkasianowicz6536
      @johnkasianowicz6536 11 месяцев назад +4

      Did you watch the review? He described the pros and cons of the two different earbuds for different criteria. He can’t predict which of those criteria best fit your needs.

    • @brwa5176
      @brwa5176 11 месяцев назад

      @@johnkasianowicz6536 yep but there are additional factors he didn't discuss such as Bose and many others use oval eartips vs Sony's round and for many/most ears you get a better seal with oval eartips. Other factors he didn't highlight include for most music the Bose approach is better, for movies the AirPods are better, and Sony's solution is terrible as it works with very little content and requires a subscription.
      There are other factors such as when I'm on a call Bose has an option to feed back some of my speech to me so I don't shout. And frankly I think many reviewers make it seem like the noise cancelling is close between the brands but for me the Bose are way ahead.

    • @SideEffects297
      @SideEffects297 10 месяцев назад

      ​​@@brwa5176but sony has hi res and ldac. Is the ultra still better?

  • @gustavodiaz7010
    @gustavodiaz7010 8 месяцев назад

    So bose is better right?

  • @jamesdavis3528
    @jamesdavis3528 9 месяцев назад

    no Marshalls on the list?

  • @Cerealkiller824
    @Cerealkiller824 11 месяцев назад

    Where does the SENNHEISER MTW3 fall between these? Loking for a good set 250-300. Any advice. Android user.

  • @iGoldenBen
    @iGoldenBen 8 месяцев назад

    Do you get high quality audio codecs on android with the Bose Ultra?

  • @Fredo.heavyy
    @Fredo.heavyy 11 месяцев назад

    Lets be honest SONY > BOSE and I’ve tried them all (also if the Sony don’t fit your ears like mine check out the Tozo Golden X1) 👍🏽

    • @brwa5176
      @brwa5176 11 месяцев назад

      Being honest I greatly prefer the Ultra over the XM5s. I had both but returned the XM5s.

    • @JeffinThomas-kv6rf
      @JeffinThomas-kv6rf 11 месяцев назад

      @@brwa5176 no I returned ultra last week.. sony is way better

    • @SideEffects297
      @SideEffects297 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@brwa5176why did you return xm5? I want to buy earbuds, but I don't know which one

  • @juzlys
    @juzlys 9 месяцев назад

    which product is iPhone user friendly? Hey Sir?

    • @chills_tiny_mom
      @chills_tiny_mom 9 месяцев назад

      AirPods

    • @juzlys
      @juzlys 8 месяцев назад

      @@chills_tiny_mom but the battery drains quickly which means I have to recharge devices quickly

  • @am23mj
    @am23mj 11 месяцев назад +4

    Very good comparison! 👍🏽Overall Sony seems to be slightly better but the foam is not quite comfortable for me. Also, the Bose buds look far better hence that's my choice!

    • @JuliusTurner-hm6ff
      @JuliusTurner-hm6ff 8 месяцев назад

      Screw these. $300 not worth it. Got my Galaxy buds pro 2 for 160 on sale and they're better than both of these.

  • @newfnshow031
    @newfnshow031 11 месяцев назад

    please do the new galaxy buds fe vs the pixel buds a both under $100

  • @rainy2299219
    @rainy2299219 11 месяцев назад +1

    But I don't know why I tried sony in Subway. I hear Crowd Voice clear, but bose actually blocked them... sony fell in the angry body and complaining wife testing to me...

  • @Manuel-rl6um
    @Manuel-rl6um 11 месяцев назад +2

    Hey Mike, are you gonna try the Pixel Buds Pro with the latest update? It would be interesting to see it your rankings with the rest.

    • @MMWechsler
      @MMWechsler 3 месяца назад

      They are not close in the same league. Unfortunately, Google didn't include a high quality codec. Very disappointing.

  • @shagoofagharoob
    @shagoofagharoob 10 месяцев назад

    Bose anc has annoying white noise , can’t let me focus on low frequency music

  • @dami007
    @dami007 11 месяцев назад

    Hey Mike! Why aren't you wearing the xm5s correctly in almost every shot? They look like they're about to fall off your ears every time!😂

  • @mikehancock6280
    @mikehancock6280 7 месяцев назад

    You should update your video after the firmware updates.