Clearly, morality and ethics have no place in the US's foreign affairs policies, but world domination does. It's the age old Colonialist's paradigm that saw slavery, poverty, discrimination, plunder, famines and genocides being held high by them. The US is no exception as having committed these atrocities on the US Mainland, they now seek to commit it elsewhere in the name of Democratic providence. They are just following on the heels of the Brits, Spanish, Belgians, French and the Dutch who now also ride on the US bandwagon to commit the same.
"It is at the heart of US Foreign Policy to use Fascism to preserve Capitalism, while claiming to safeguard Democracy from the Communists" Dr Michael Parenti Professor of Economics.
9.35 I totally agree with Mr Sibal. I am from the west and shocked and horrified with what our leaders are up to and how weak and monstrous at the same time they are. I do hope DJ Trump will not disappoint his voters and our hope. Thank you for a great interview. The only fault is the sound quality.
At 27:15, Ambassador Sibal is speaking of the region of Galicia. He is right about everything except for the huge influence which Nazi ideas had in this part, the 14th Waffen Grenadier Division of the SS was created by recruiting the Galicians, who slaughtered over a hundred thousand Poles, who were also Catholics, in the middle of 1943. These creatures from Western Ukraine are the real toxins.
An important, hitherto unanswered question is, how did the Region of Galicia get to become a part of Western Ukraine after the end of WWl under the Western League of Nations?
“Hypocrisy” is the jewel of geopolitics and every country showcase it whenever it’s possible!! So India should learn to move on with it and every country will pursue their national interest which doesn’t necessarily should align with india ✌️ so only way to handle it is build interdependence and have Indian influence on their citizens and political system
@ Right!! Why you cry when someone talks about anything, does the West care about what you write or complain about 🤷♂️😂 grow up and better your game, when you reach that level these outside noise doesn’t matter
I am Canadian The India / China relations is the key for a global peaceful future History between these nations is huge, animosity escapes me. Two nations that prescribe peaceful coexistence must solve their grievances Sort it out already I follow geopolitics and wonder how the FM;s interact - Jaishankar/Yi/Lavrov BRICS is a formidable movement but the India/China question, dilemma worries me. Is India intimidated. jealous of China's primacy within BRICS? China is the driving force, the BRI. Is India okay with that?
Regarding the war .Ukraine are short of men and this is going to get worse. If trump continues to support Ukraine, at best it will delay, bbut the war is lost . For the west the looming elections should bring new governments . The current set have too much ego invested on the losing side
मास्को में लेफ्टिनेंट जनरल इगोर किरिलोव की हत्या की जिम्मेवारी यूक्रेन ने लिया है और पश्चिमी देशों ने यूक्रेन की कार्यवाही का समर्थन भी किया है। सिब्बल एक समझदार और देशभक्त राजनयिक है। रूस फिलहाल कुछ कदम पीछे की ओर चल रहा है, लेकिन इसका अर्थ यह नही है कि रूस पराजित हो गया है। रूस कुछ बड़ा करेगा ऐसा लगता है।
Excellent insights as usual from Sh Sibal. It'll be interesting to see how Trump plays his cards. It'll be good for the world if the US gets over it's obsssession of destroying Russia & the Russian Uke war ends.
The most important question is, what do you mean by "WEST"? Is America included in this "WEST" word? Obviously speaking it is. And then, America is the one which the most active in all actions around the world rather than as so called "WEST". So why not address the main player if you want to seek any answer or result?
A Hindu publication inviting Kanwal Sibal as an expert guest is beyond surprising. Kanwal Sibal's approval of Modi Govt and indeed his proximity to them would badly prick the Hindu editorial team.
India has to stop dithering and take its rightful place in the world, and not repeat its role as it did in assisting the west onto the helm of world domination as it did in the 18th century to its own eventual detriment!!!
100 Billion for US is nothing and the truth is most of that money goes straight to US Defense manufacturer's who send Ukraine older weapons' in their stocks.
When Russia wins in Ukraine then Europe will be safe from Nazi Fascist Ideological Domination for the second time in over a century! "We have Liberated Europe from Fascism, and they will never forgive us for doing so!" General Zhukov Marshall of the Red Army in WWll.
Jiske haath me talvar....vohi pehenega aachi salvar. Its the age old mantra.......you need to be powerful and showcase your power for the world to talk with you with respect.... else you are only asking to be taken advantage off. India's soft stance is the reason why we have been at the receiving end of bs from all over the world.
ty, good interview. russia will go on selling oil & gas to china in yuan, north korea may become much stronger 💪 with russian help, india can't buy too much russian oil in rupees...stalemate
The west does not have a choice in the matter of Russia and China getting closer, and BRICS choice to introduce a financial architecture or its expansion depends on the will of its members. Russia is also not as weak as you argue, Russia is not fully mobilised for war neither is it in love with Europe especially given Europe’s behaviour since 2014. Russia’s economy is weakened during its re-orienting its markets and trade away from mostly Europe, but once this is completed it will grow again even if slowly. It is a resource rich nation and its reserves will make sure it will not suffer too much no matter what is thrown at her.
This interview shows Indian Opportunism=Total Opportunism= Fair enough. But good to listen to these comments. Indian stand on Gaza? Silent. The West also Oportunistic. But PM Mody smooches up to the Americans when it suits him to get Visas for Indians and when it suits his political stance. But Mody like Trump is a Populist but all Populism is based on the OTHER. And fear of the Other.
India stand on Gaza is clear teo state solution. What do expect scream everyday. it is not opportunistic it is India first policy as is the case with every country. Just because India does not toe the west line does not mean Modi and India take political stand when it suites India. Indian policy is very clear India strategic and economic interest first. Everyone knows the CIA/ MI6 are constantly destabilising the world to control and put their puppets in place. Ukraine war was unnecessary but to weaken Russia in return Europe and America are destroyed. Interest on American debt is more than One trillion that is more than all African countries GDP, more than majority of Asian Countries GDP and eve more than majority of European countries GDP. A banckrupt country fighting wars printing useless money cannot last long.
The Hypocrisy is people forget 'Ukes gave up Nukes' in 1990, the agreement signed it would be protected from russia & its aggression , may b sibal has age related amnesia .
So you are brainwashed Ukraine first was not on path to Nato membership but EU membership....then Agression was not shown by Ukraine against Rusdia...rusdia is bully broke agreement ...As neither ukraine or nato attacked Russia..have done common sense@easwaransanthakumar297
Russia does not have to persuade China. China has no courage to invade India in fact after 5 years of face to face stand off first time in history CCP has withdrawn. India is not a weak country to bow down to Chines pressure. India does not even care for American pressure India purchased S400 against American wishes India was not sanctioned when NATO partner Turkey purchased S400 America sanctioned Turkey and Turkey was kicked out of F35 program. India purchased Russian oil what did America and Eu did nothing. India built and manages Chabahar port in Iran despite American and EU sanctions on Iran. Educate yourself on India before you make comments.
India and China do not have an ideological dispute, it's only territorial. Hopefully, they can one day become one entity like the European Union. We need an Asian Union.
I'm tired of these intellectual talking bla bla bla ! common hindus vote hindu leader like Modi but he turnbout to be MK Gabdhi 2.0 . Still caste systems, millions of illegal Bangladeshi, burmese kuki across 🇮🇳
a very experienced take by Ambassador Sibal. Thank you
Clearly, morality and ethics have no place in the US's foreign affairs policies, but world domination does. It's the age old Colonialist's paradigm that saw slavery, poverty, discrimination, plunder, famines and genocides being held high by them. The US is no exception as having committed these atrocities on the US Mainland, they now seek to commit it elsewhere in the name of Democratic providence. They are just following on the heels of the Brits, Spanish, Belgians, French and the Dutch who now also ride on the US bandwagon to commit the same.
"It is at the heart of US Foreign Policy to use Fascism to preserve Capitalism, while claiming to safeguard Democracy from the Communists" Dr Michael Parenti Professor of Economics.
Imagine reasonable experts like this on our mass media. Just a dream i guess.
It is a pleasure to listen and learn to such brilliant minds diplomats who have in-depth knowledge of geopolitics 🙏
Excellent discussion.
Excellent and knowledgeable guest speaker.
9.35 I totally agree with Mr Sibal. I am from the west and shocked and horrified with what our leaders are up to and how weak and monstrous at the same time they are. I do hope DJ Trump will not disappoint his voters and our hope. Thank you for a great interview. The only fault is the sound quality.
Brilliant analysis by Mr Sibal. I wish more Americans and Europeans would listen to people like him, perhaps this whole mess would have been avoided.
At 27:15, Ambassador Sibal is speaking of the region of Galicia. He is right about everything except for the huge influence which Nazi ideas had in this part, the 14th Waffen Grenadier Division of the SS was created by recruiting the Galicians, who slaughtered over a hundred thousand Poles, who were also Catholics, in the middle of 1943. These creatures from Western Ukraine are the real toxins.
Thanks for the information 👍
An important, hitherto unanswered question is, how did the Region of Galicia get to become a part of Western Ukraine after the end of WWl under the Western League of Nations?
I listened with fascinating to the most realistic view from India.
“Hypocrisy” is the jewel of geopolitics and every country showcase it whenever it’s possible!! So India should learn to move on with it and every country will pursue their national interest which doesn’t necessarily should align with india ✌️ so only way to handle it is build interdependence and have Indian influence on their citizens and political system
Bingo!! These people r just discovering it 😂😂. Others have been playing that for millennia. Need to catch up.
Not only to play the same game but also to call out West's hypocrisy and that is what Bharat is doing ( two folks here).
No need to give advice.
@@mahavirbhartiya9932 🤦🤣 buddy getting mad!! Cool hypocrisy is everywhere now go grow up, same as these two should ✌️
@ Right!! Why you cry when someone talks about anything, does the West care about what you write or complain about 🤷♂️😂 grow up and better your game, when you reach that level these outside noise doesn’t matter
I am Canadian
The India / China relations is the key for a global peaceful future
History between these nations is huge, animosity escapes me. Two nations that prescribe peaceful coexistence must solve their grievances
Sort it out already
I follow geopolitics and wonder how the FM;s interact - Jaishankar/Yi/Lavrov
BRICS is a formidable movement but the India/China question, dilemma worries me. Is India intimidated. jealous of China's primacy within BRICS? China is the driving force, the BRI. Is India okay with that?
Regarding the war .Ukraine are short of men and this is going to get worse. If trump continues to support Ukraine, at best it will delay, bbut the war is lost . For the west the looming elections should bring new governments . The current set have too much ego invested on the losing side
Wisdom from the best. Thank you sir
Kanwal, Thank you for telling us THE TRUTH.
Interesting perspective; thank you.
मास्को में लेफ्टिनेंट जनरल इगोर किरिलोव की हत्या की जिम्मेवारी यूक्रेन ने लिया है और पश्चिमी देशों ने यूक्रेन की कार्यवाही का समर्थन भी किया है। सिब्बल एक समझदार और देशभक्त राजनयिक है। रूस फिलहाल कुछ कदम पीछे की ओर चल रहा है, लेकिन इसका अर्थ यह नही है कि रूस पराजित हो गया है। रूस कुछ बड़ा करेगा ऐसा लगता है।
Excellent insights as usual from Sh Sibal.
It'll be interesting to see how Trump plays his cards.
It'll be good for the world if the US gets over it's obsssession of destroying Russia & the Russian Uke war ends.
The most important question is, what do you mean by "WEST"? Is America included in this "WEST" word? Obviously speaking it is. And then, America is the one which the most active in all actions around the world rather than as so called "WEST". So why not address the main player if you want to seek any answer or result?
A great interview with Ambassador Sibal, 100% agree
Excellent analysis.
Very smart man
Smart to the Indian. But stupid to the rest.
@ I am not from India 🇮🇳, So I think he is an incredibly smart man.
Excellent & very educating.
A Hindu publication inviting Kanwal Sibal as an expert guest is beyond surprising. Kanwal Sibal's approval of Modi Govt and indeed his proximity to them would badly prick the Hindu editorial team.
You don't think Hindu should value his general input, for the greater good of their readership ?
Hindu should, and all Indian 'leftist' press should- that IS the point he is contrasting with the Hindu's general editorial orientation.
@@aryaman05
@@ak-rx1ui
Ok, but it appears that his language flow was kinda going the other way though.
100% better than def talks 🎉
😅 When the West grabs your land, this is called 'Security' plan. When you steal their land, they called it 'Genocide or Grand Theft or Communism 😅😅😂
India has to stop dithering and take its rightful place in the world, and not repeat its role as it did in assisting the west onto the helm of world domination as it did in the 18th century to its own eventual detriment!!!
Jai Bharat
But thanks to social media it is there for all to see and even better it is there for all time
100 Billion for US is nothing and the truth is most of that money goes straight to US Defense manufacturer's who send Ukraine older weapons' in their stocks.
When Russia wins in Ukraine then Europe will be safe from Nazi Fascist Ideological Domination for the second time in over a century! "We have Liberated Europe from Fascism, and they will never forgive us for doing so!" General Zhukov Marshall of the Red Army in WWll.
Jiske haath me talvar....vohi pehenega aachi salvar.
Its the age old mantra.......you need to be powerful and showcase your power for the world to talk with you with respect.... else you are only asking to be taken advantage off.
India's soft stance is the reason why we have been at the receiving end of bs from all over the world.
ty, good interview. russia will go on selling oil & gas to china in yuan, north korea may become much stronger 💪 with russian help, india can't buy too much russian oil in rupees...stalemate
abdool u r naive
What will happen if Trump doesn't withdraw
If frontline wants viewers get some experts to make videos. The sound is hardly audible
Hypocrisy Diplomacy
Same to Same saar.
The west does not have a choice in the matter of Russia and China getting closer, and BRICS choice to introduce a financial architecture or its expansion depends on the will of its members. Russia is also not as weak as you argue, Russia is not fully mobilised for war neither is it in love with Europe especially given Europe’s behaviour since 2014. Russia’s economy is weakened during its re-orienting its markets and trade away from mostly Europe, but once this is completed it will grow again even if slowly. It is a resource rich nation and its reserves will make sure it will not suffer too much no matter what is thrown at her.
Still in service.
Poor audio but excellent information
Adani is put on warrant arrest by FBI
Mic problem... Very serious issue with indian you tubers.
Cost factor
Too low volume to follow this very interesting discussion
This interview shows Indian Opportunism=Total Opportunism= Fair enough. But good to listen to these comments. Indian stand on Gaza? Silent. The West also Oportunistic. But PM Mody smooches up to the Americans when it suits him to get Visas for Indians and when it suits his political stance. But Mody like Trump is a Populist but all Populism is based on the OTHER. And fear of the Other.
India stand on Gaza is clear teo state solution. What do expect scream everyday. it is not opportunistic it is India first policy as is the case with every country. Just because India does not toe the west line does not mean Modi and India take political stand when it suites India. Indian policy is very clear India strategic and economic interest first. Everyone knows the CIA/ MI6 are constantly destabilising the world to control and put their puppets in place. Ukraine war was unnecessary but to weaken Russia in return Europe and America are destroyed. Interest on American debt is more than One trillion that is more than all African countries GDP, more than majority of Asian Countries GDP and eve more than majority of European countries GDP. A banckrupt country fighting wars printing useless money cannot last long.
India standing on Gaza is exactly same as West standing on Pak terrorism in Indian Kashmir
weak audio
👁️🔱
The Hypocrisy is people forget 'Ukes gave up Nukes' in 1990, the agreement signed it would be protected from russia & its aggression , may b sibal has age related amnesia .
Isnt it 1 sided amnesia..
Provided there's no NATO expansion. This shows how brainwashed you are😂
So you are brainwashed Ukraine first was not on path to Nato membership but EU membership....then Agression was not shown by Ukraine against Rusdia...rusdia is bully broke agreement ...As neither ukraine or nato attacked Russia..have done common sense@easwaransanthakumar297
@@easwaransanthakumar297so If Nato expand Russia can attack militarily tearing up agreement?that's wat yu say??
Ukraine pokes and NATO expansion to Russia 🪆 doorstep 'who would tolerate that,
Immensely enjoyed indepth analysis of Mr.Sibbal . What a difference between two brothers !!
Kapil Sibal is clever. But for the wrong causes
Can Russia persuade China not to invade and occupy India ?
And also not to enslave Indians ?
Russia does not have to persuade China. China has no courage to invade India in fact after 5 years of face to face stand off first time in history CCP has withdrawn. India is not a weak country to bow down to Chines pressure. India does not even care for American pressure India purchased S400 against American wishes India was not sanctioned when NATO partner Turkey purchased S400 America sanctioned Turkey and Turkey was kicked out of F35 program. India purchased Russian oil what did America and Eu did nothing. India built and manages Chabahar port in Iran despite American and EU sanctions on Iran. Educate yourself on India before you make comments.
India and China do not have an ideological dispute, it's only territorial. Hopefully, they can one day become one entity like the European Union. We need an Asian Union.
What about Indian hypocrisy in dealing with Russian aggression in Ukraine and in Indian reaction to the ouster of Indian puppet Hasina of Bangladesh?
A brilliant man
I'm tired of these intellectual talking bla bla bla ! common hindus vote hindu leader like Modi but he turnbout to be MK Gabdhi 2.0 . Still caste systems, millions of illegal Bangladeshi, burmese kuki across 🇮🇳