Its funny how you people are so into reviving a language thats dead, its interesting to know the history but why am i not seeing the same enthusiasm in unearthing the tribal traditions of people who live in the jungles of Odisha ?..or the obsession to find the roots of the nomads of Rajashthan...who must have a history thats older than any other city in northern india ...And documenting... What is this obsession with only one language and things associated with it... Wjy arent we seeing the same enthusiasm about bhuddism or Jainism.....and ofcourse there is TAMIL THE OLDEST LANGAUGE IN THE WORLD ...AND STILL HAS CRORES OF PEOPLE SPEAKING IT ....why no one is doing underwater excavation in the coastal Tamil nadu to find poombuhaar and other such human settlements that are under sea which will change the way india looks at south india ..
@@onetrueindian1 Oldest Tamil literature came after the oldest sanskrit literature and also uses sanskrit in its vocabulary. Sorry to burst your bubble but Tamil is not the oldest language.
Why Indian universities could not produce someone Yagnadevam? Hope the government is watching this and start giving grants to Indian universities for research
Because Indian universities don’t want happy and curious people with idle time for hobbies. They want weary and overwhelmed people with no time for anything beyond mugging pages and pages of random facts and tables.
It's so sad we Indians r not valuing our own history language our people who r doing such hard work to find out the truth n busy propaganda of west ...our people r totally blinded by western.. I came here after Abhijit chavda had mentioned in a podcast abt a man is working hard on decoding india script a year ago
Anand N., it is upto you to not just continue this debate but make it more immersive.The vested nay sayers will certainly drown this man's voice. He needs to be heard across the board and be debated threadbare and most critically brought into the paradigm of strict scientific scrutiny. Once his work attains that milestone it will be safe. That is the service you must extend this fine researcher. Please do not fail him.
it's pretty solid science. cryptanalysis is conclusive. as the gentleman says if you sprinkle a little random information in and you get drastically different results then you're on the wrong trail. he explained inputting all kinds of languages and only sanskrit matches. the only thing left is to simply accept the findings.
@@jocr1971 It more like I create a script that is very unique and the model just because of the bias will tell me... O it's a Roman Script... The people who used the dummy script used to talk in roman language... Model are biasly trained... although we can adjust the input parameters... but that doesn't makes any sense though not in the very least.
@@Pontiff03If you claim so, then do the same for Tamil or some other language with Indus script and challenge him. Burden of proof lies on you since you are making the claim, he did his part and he's explained it well in channel. I trust him more than armchair yt comment experts.
@Pontiff03 this is quite complex and many factors had to fall into place to get the result. all languages have rules both for constructing words from sounds and sentences from words. each language has rules about allowable consonantal clusters and long/short/accented/not accented syllables. no two languages are the same. if something fits a pattern then it's identified.
Actually this is a very important research . Unfortunately so called progressives in India will sideline it . Anyhow , one must appreciate this research which used information theory to decode . It has a Mathematical base .
Don't use the word savage. Savage refers to the Europeans who brutalized every other culture. Hunter gatherers aren't savage, you can sit with them and dine or converse if you're welcomed into their community.
Anand Narsimhan, request you to do an interview with Parisalan and Mannarmannan, who are very knowledgeable. Probably arrange a debate or discussion with them along with Yajnadevam. Are you listening, Anand???
Those people dont know anything but telling stories as History! They never tell any proof! These people playing to the Dravidian gallery of Tamil Nadu!
I have seen dna research papers of American(harvard) guy, Turkish scientist and European scientists. They all have different results and conclusions. In American(harvard) studies done by jewish guy he find continuous small migrations into india over 1200 bce to 100ce. In Turkish research paper they find Caucasus hunter gatherer and Iranian dna going to europe and in european research papers they find 30% south asian ancestry going to Yamnaya. So don't hold your breath for west to be honest. They need aryan dravidian theory to keep divisions in india.
The only people that are keeping endians divided are the endians ,stop playing the victims ,if what this guy is telling is true and he can prove it ,the rest of the world will accepted but if is just another hendutva conman goon that sell pies in the sky than tell him to f*ck off with his stupid lies...
@urgenlama7302 it's complicated. Some are same but In zend avesta many of them become villians and demons since they didn't take their side in the war.
Dear Yajnadevam, please publish your work in a journal ASAP! Else people with discredit this work as one of the many who tried to decipher this code and could only manage to only partially do that.
Nonsense... Do you know about the cave of el castillo ...those are 40,000 years old in Spain .. gobekli tepe in turkey those are some of the oldest human settlement area still in use ... Know the world before you make such stupid remarks ... It's because of people like you that Indians are being looked down today in the west ... Such useless trumpeting of some nonsense
@@Bhatti_Saab_7773 I think this is just revisionist history. There is no evidence of what you are suggesting. This myth was started to create the notion of Akhand Bharat, but it is just politics. It is not based on reality.
in greek mythology. dionysus 9th book. zeus wants to defeat indians as they worship elephant headed god. yazidis in iraq have rituals similar to hindus, zoroastrians have thread ceremonies like hindus used to practice and today only few brahmin communities do. syria had mitanni kingdom who's court language was sanskrit. we were well connected than we think we were.
In the Rig Ved there is no mention of an urban civilization similar to the Indus Valley Civilization. The vedas describe a pastoral and rural life consisting of cattle herding, cows, sacrifices, lord Indra, Varun etc.
पश्चिमी इतिहासकार कुटिल और कुख्यात हैं और जो इतिहास वे चाहते थे उसे बनाने के लिए तथ्यों को तोड़-मरोड़ कर पेश करने के लिए जाने जाते हैं। मुझे सिर्फ भारतीय इतिहासकारों पर भरोसा है.
It is high time that Indian scholars came together and demolished the misuse of the language problem by Westerners to serve the political agenda. In this regard, an old book titled ' Adhibhasha' by Chattampi Swamikal is significant. It says that Sanskrit is not a naturally evolved language but something created like a programmed language. It was made out of the Prakrit language. Prakrit evolved from languages stemming from the Mooladravida language brought to the North by people who migrated from the South of India.
What stands out is the brilliance and dedication of Yagnadevam. The mystery of the Indus Valley civilization and its undeciphered script is incredibly captivating, creating a sense of connection that feels almost umbilical. As a result, anything that sheds light on this subject naturally sparks curiosity. Yagnadevam seems to be making a concerted effort to present the intricate technical details in a way that is accessible to the average person. However, I believe this would benefit from a different approach. Rather than an interview format, a narrative structure could be more effective. A documentary-style presentation would allow the research and findings to unfold gradually, starting with the basics and progressing step by step. By incorporating actual inscriptions and symbols at the site, alongside the methods used to decode them, viewers could witness the process firsthand. The narrative could then demonstrate the hypothesis in action by applying it to a new inscription, showing how the theory holds up. This approach would likely offer a clearer and more engaging understanding for the audience. I had a tough time wrapping it around my head and hence was looking for something more simpler and easy to understand. Given the immensity of impact this theory has, I would request Anand and Yagnadevam to consider the request to explore a way of making this groundbreaking research more accessible and engaging for a wider audience.
Its funny how you people are so into reviving a language thats dead, its interesting to know the history but why am i not seeing the same enthusiasm in unearthing the tribal traditions of people who live in the jungles of Odisha ?..or the obsession to find the roots of the nomads of Rajashthan...who must have a history thats older than any other city in northern india ...And documenting... What is this obsession with only one language and things associated with it... Wjy arent we seeing the same enthusiasm about bhuddism or Jainism.....and ofcourse there is TAMIL THE OLDEST LANGAUGE IN THE WORLD ...AND STILL HAS CRORES OF PEOPLE SPEAKING IT ....why no one is doing underwater excavation in the coastal Tamil nadu to find poombuhaar and other such human settlements that are under sea which will change the way india looks at south india ..
o funding for Tamil history, they are afraid of what they are going find. Keezhadi samples sent for radio carbondating were those which were exvacted closer to the surface level, but not deeper than that. Poombuhar exploration was held, gremany does more for tamil than india or TN.
Yajnadevam is collaborating with the Archeological Survey of India according to his recent tweet….expect more insights into this in the months to come..
Indus Valley, Sumerian(Su(Tall) +Meru(Mountain) are Tamil cultures. Sanskrit no way connected with these Civilizations. After Kumari Continent submerged or swallowed by repeated Tsu(Tall) nami(tides)'s. people started moving towards tall places and started their living in groups. Indus Valley, Sumerian and oldest tribal groups in Australian continent are Tamils. Indus Valley has Sivan, Murugan and Kotravai symbols and the letters script called as Tamizhi. Dear Central Government, as per the research, please visit current Poompuhar city in Tamil Nadu (only half out of sea, another half inside the sea), travel 45KMs inside the ocean from the seashore, you can find a submerged city with tall building structures that includes a gigantic lighthouse which is nearly 15000 years old. Researchers confirmed these findings... If possible, invest on this... Thank you
The original name (and correct pronunciation) of Kumari Kandam is Kumari Khand / Khandam. Both words (kumari and khandam) are Sanskrit and mean "virgin territory".
he says its impossible that new words can be added or replace old words? there is historical evidence of such events happening, like the battle of hastings, which changed the english language. even many chinese regional languages and scripts were culled by Qin emperors to standardize the chinese language. things like this have happened before. would be good to put these analyses to the test! good luck!
The so called Indus valley Civilisation is not the origin of Hindu/Indian civilisation. It was just a township in ancient India not a new civilisation. Indian Civilisation/ Hindu Civilisation is much older than the Indus people.
Bear in mind that Sanskrit Language is the youngest language of the all. So called Vedic language literatures are actually Nalanda e t l Buddhist universities have contributed in its full use and development.
See he just wants to prove that the Vedic civilization is the start of the Indian continent. If he talked about Kiladi how would he be able to prove that vedic is the oldest civilization.
There’s a few flaws in his theory .howcome ,people from Indus region flourished their culture in gangetic plains when clearly at the peak of their civilization they were settled in Indus region(Punjab )and south(sindh)
Of poor taste and factually incompatible at many instances. nothing much about reading of the script but general loose comments on features of indus civilization.
he should have peer reviews and publish on historical archeological journals, it could prove to be breakthrough of this decade because indus script were never been Cracked
A great work by Mr. Yajnadevam. However there is one point used by proponents of Aryan invasion / migration theory, to disassociate IVC from Vedic civilization. This is the fact that horses are mentioned even in the Vedas, whereas there appeared to be no proof of horse usage at IVC sites. How can this be explained
There is a village called sinauli, U.P. few years back, ASI found a chariot which goes back to harrapan time. Sinauli is a recently discovered IVC site. So it has already proved that point wrong that we didn't have horses. By the way that village is just adjacent to my village.
@subalsaroha5463 that's great, but it will help if historians put forward proper proof as to where the horses came from to draw the chariots. Though we as Indians intuitively know certain things to be true, the damage done by the earlier narrative cannot be undone unless the facts are presented in a proper manner
It's a predetermined interview to glorify sanskrit over Tamiz. These guys only r reason for South North divide. Just don't want to accept reality of skewed North indian false mindset
Yajnadevam himself is a Tamilian. To disprove him, you need to mathematically disprove him. It's not him but you and your conspiracy theories of Aryan invasion that is the cause of North South divide.
The lack of intellectual curiosity in comments is utterly befuddling. Politics apart, this is widely acknowledged to be the greatest unsolved script decipherment challenge in the world.
I think his decoded message will not be accepted by Govt, there is a possibility that real truth will come out which will be a headache for his claims and others. But my understanding is that Prakrat is older than Sanskrit which disapprovea his theory.
One of the big problems with Yajnadevams “decipherment” is the conflation of symbols. If you look at the website where the deciphered text is displayed, you can see symbols that are totally different (not merely in style), are considered as a single symbol. Furthermore, the purported decipherments do not give any indication of the use of the seals. It simply does not make sense. Finally, according to his paper, the words can be algorithmically deciphered, but the pace of decipherment seems to show otherwise. If it was algorithmic, then the decipherment would be obvious. Lastly, the interviewer is already biased. His questions contains assumptions that are highly controversial but he mentions it as if they are truth.
@@npatel7775is it possible for pa and ma and sha and ha to all have the same symbol? Looking at the yajnadevam decipherment, there are many examples where widely varying symbols are assigned the same “letter”
@@cerebral1095well I think you are highly biased.Did he not say this in the draft stage being checked by experts? If they find discrepancies that will stop the paper from being published. I assume all these experts are better informed than you. What agenda are you trying to push?
@@cerebral1095i have seen his paper the so called different words are like different varietal of single letter its like u M has Fish symbol but fishes are of different variety nd one can makes variations to look it unidentical to its Simpler form
Why Sanskrit should be Indus Language? And Why it isn't? Comparison with Vedic Society... -> Firstly, no ruler based society --- Vedic Society based on King oblique Rajas or Pati. -> Equality amongst citizens --- Vedic Society was Patriarchal -> Lack of Warfare, except for Sinuali Rider's Grave --- Vedic Society based on warfare, used to war against themselves or panis for cow -> No Huge Temples Dedicated to Gods, Despite Knowing about Sumerian Gods such as Gilgamesh, Inanna and Enkidu(Seals are found in Indus) --- Although Temples where not constructed in Vedic Times... But Later we find huge temples dedicated to Gods. -> Classist Society --- Vedic Society was not so classist as they followed similar patterns as that of the Vikings... which was raiding. Although there were 4 classes Priest, King, Commoners and Slaves. -> Language is unknown, could be the obscure Dravidian language in Pakistan --- Vedic Society was contemptuous in using Vedic Sanskrit... which was cognate with Avesta and Old Persian... Both had roots in Indo European Language. -> Migration yes... Indus and Sumeria both migrated and intermarried each other(Happened only in middle east and Iran) --- Somewhat valid because dasrajan war talks about expelling few aryan tribe to the west... But migrated in whole world from that is an overstatement and this means that the right wing historians are just lying to you.
The reason his paper has not been published is because he has not deciphered the Indus script as he claims to have done. He cannot show what he claims to be the case, is the case. It's a mere claim with no proof.
Why IIT & IIS are not focusing on technology and science? Involved in archeological studies? Still India is not having TOP 100 institutes list. Dung mind people 😂
Come down to Tamil researchers and scholars and to Tamil people , who can prove that the INDUS SCRIPT is TAMIL and not SANSKRIT.The entire INDIAN history is belongs to Tamil , we can prove it..The INDUS SCRIPT is related to the archeological evidences found in KEELADI.
The original name (and correct pronunciation) of Kumari Kandam is Kumari Khand / Khandam. Both words (kumari and khandam) are Sanskrit and mean "virgin territory".
There is one chapter (chapter 10) dedicated to Paisachi Prakrit in Prakrita Prakasha, a grammar book of Prakrit languages attributed to Vararuchi.[6] In this work, it is mentioned that the base of Paisachi is Shauraseni language. It further goes on to mention 10 rules of transforming the base text to Paisachi. These are mostly rules of substitution of letters - Chapter 10 of Prakrita Pariksha
So instead of an invasion from outside India, now he’s claiming an invasion from IVC to South India, and then adopted the language of that region. Dravidian substrate in Sanskrit also needs to be explained, and is not explained by this model.
It easily is...IVC traded not just with mesopotamia but also with cultures south of Godavari. Marathi is the last Indo-Arya language....from karnataka onwards we have Sanskritised native languages. Tamil itself has 40% sanskrit vocabulary,grammar etc meaning Tamil was a fusion language devised by the Sages to propogate Dharma in southern regions. Ppl accepted Dharma as it was Knowledge based and not some belief system like Abrahamic fables. If someone doesnt believe in Gravity or Electromagentism it means nothing and has no effect on Gravity. And accept the fact that the geeatest Tamil kings propogated Sanskrit as an International,Cultured and Universal language. Sanskrit was always a scholarly language and not anybodys mother-tounge. Same way as programming languages have to be learned so also was Sanskrit a precise language learnt by students.
When did he mention invasion of IVC on southern India, could you share timestamp, i listened carefully I did encounter that claim he just mentioned people moved south and assimilated.
Migration, dear,Migration. They settle and intermarried the locals. They brought their Indus culture and mixed with the local. But not all migrants can coexist with their natives for a long time, especially food, and women become scarce.
You should read his paper on it. He firstly considered Tamil as the candidate for his research but Tamil is not fitting with the script. Thats why he took Sanskrit as 2nd candidate.
Tbh , this indus valley civilisation is way different then todays religion . Sanskrit is core language, what a joke , 🤣 . The script of indus is unique in itself . There is no written Sanskrit , on any Stone , Script etc .
Poompukar and Keeladi sites dates back even before Sindu Samaveli(Indus Valley) civilization. Kindly tell the logic of migration again.which is old?aren't we good at maths.have you found Kumari kandam that Tamil Scriptures describes.Tholkappiam,Silapatigaram,Agananooru,Purananooru...All respect to you sir please feel free to research and see how big Bharat is or was🙏
I am a telugate native as tamil nadu for more than 10 generations I believe Tamil should be the first..... aryans migrated they crossed Indus valley then after landed in India. According consideration of mannar mannan theory also I understood that aryand migrated is true, and he Also mentioned there were aseevagham before it gives conclusion that aryans God is our Hindu God now. But our Tamil is more older than sanskrit we might have spreaded allover India later we all came and settled in south india.... we can't believe everyone's theory 100% but whatever is common and we believe that must be true.....
I agree Tamil is an Old language, Poompugar is indeed older than Indus Valley , But that does not take away the fact that indus vally spoke and wrote sanskrit in the indus script. Dravida is even mentoined in the Rig veda, in fact the current manu for this manvantara (Age of Manu)is from Dravida(TN+Andra+karnataka+kerala). Vaivasvata Manu or styavratha(Speaker of truth) is the name given to him. Agastiyar is mentioned both in rig vedas and All the tamil sangam literature. If you consider Agastiar to be a part of Tamil culture then you have to accepet that tamil culture was part and parcel of Bharath(Bharatha Varsha) and an integral part of sanathana Dharma. Tamil was a parallel language that was spoken during during and before the indus like sanskrit was , Tamil was developed by Agastiar along with Sanskrit in parallel. Agastiar was one of the greatest scholars of the vedas as he was of the Tamil Sangam. He is revered all over india irrespective of language. There was a developed world during indus vally and before it, We just dont have proof of it yet. Both indus and tamil kings ofthose times were in Trade with Greeks of that time period. the evidence from poompugar tells us that much.
pff haha lol are you freaking serious.. show me the dating proof of poopuhar civilization and keeladi? these both were dated to close 6 BCE and you are saying they are older than IVC? are you mad? what your govt replaced facts with ganja? lol
Rightwing Fundamentalistic agenda of the ruling party in Delhi! Beware! Script (written form), Language family, Racial Grouping - these three are different things but can come in any mix! Different language families can use the same script - example English and Finnish! Same language family can use different scripts - English and Russian. And even English and Hindi too! One can continue. As for the script - all Indian scripts (North and South ) and SE Asian scripts are Brahmi based. Cambodian, Thai language etc are different from Indian languages, but their script seems to be based on Brahmi. Script basis is not the same as language family. Today Indonesia has accepted Roman script. But their language is not European based at all. For convenience they accepted that. Indus Valley language is not Sanskrit based at all. Brahui in Pakistan is Dravidian based ! Did the Bhrahmi script originate in Indus Valley? We don‘t know. No one has proved that.
Where else do you see it branching out the most? It's only in Bharata that Brahmi has gone on to develop into other major scripts which means that it was being used from a long time to be modified by the people who were using it to develop a script for their language
@@sidvoxx Any idiot can claim a newer thing in a place is the evolution of an older thing. Brahmi is not the issue here. The topic is : Deciphering Indus Script. And many stalwarts had problems here. And it is undebtable that Indus Valley Civilization had no connections to Indo-Aryan Languages. Hre Yagnadevan is either a puppet of the new Fundamentalist Lobby in India or he has been folled by them. Crap logic will not prove anything.
@mudrarakshasa My Ancestors were good people not like duryodhan types, you know those stayed in India from ancestors to now are the seeds of duryodhana
Listened from beginning to the end but could not make head or tail of what Mr. Yojnadevam trying to say. The name of Panini who supposed to have developed the Sanskrit script was not even mentioned. I am from Sri Lanka with an Indo-ariyan language. If you take hindi words and remove the line at the top the letters down below has similar structure to Sinhala letters. And the alphabet of Malayali and Sinhala almost the same. Some tamil letters also have similar structure. In Sri Lanka's east we have irrigation structures which are engineering marvels made with bricks similaf to what you get in Mohenjo Daro beloning to same period 2000 BCE. It appears an advanced civilisation vanished about 1300 years ago, perhaps due to disease like Malaria. Perhaps Mohenjo Daro vanished due to desertification as they may have cut down all trees to make burnt clay bricks and funeral fires.
Let , experts, linguusts, and scientific people accept it. Only after that you can tell and inform the people. Don't serve half cooked food. Or food under preparation or food on the flame.
It is untenable to think of Vedic society and Samskrita as two unrelated entities. IVC’s material culture available so far, does not resemble Vedic society at all. So, assigning Samskrita/Vedic/IE to IVC script is very anachronistic. It is also cultural misappropriation. Perhaps some bilingual material in the Middle East will one day turn out to be the Rosetta Stone for IVC decipherment.
Periyarists have no hope they can continue to shout scream and defile Dharma. The sun is out its daylight no one can deny the sun since the book Breaking India was published around 2010-11
@@RupeshKumar-lw8fb 😂😂😂😂 Baby 😂😂 The underlying hate for North India translates into this stupid conclusion. You better be chanting mantras and doing your Vandana's in Tamil. IF YOU ARE A HINDU. YOU BETTER CONVERT TO ISLAM YOU HAVE PERFECT MINDSET FOR IT 😂😂 ASK YOUR PERIYAR BROTHERS TO LEAVE SANATAN DHARMA TOO 😂
Such claims have been done since decades and until such discovery is peer reviewed by expert linguists; this should not be taken seriously (exactly why other people were not taken into consideration).
Bunkum for trying to brahminise indus which is crap theory as it is known that it was more ofndadivasi first language . Stop pedalling all.sorts pf people as historians and archeologists to further own.agenda
How come all the ancient sites get covered in soil? This is a question which I haven't been able to find answers to. How do they get buried? I think this will also hold a key to our understanding the times and their "disappearance"!
Winds. They buried the whole body of the sphinx with sand. The summer winds in India also do the same thing. Leave your house shut for a month and see the amount of dust that gets accumulated even in a closed space. What chance do these open spots stand once people stop inhabiting the place due to climatic or other conditions??
He should be given the highest award of the country. He has done something which nobody could do for more than 100 of years.
Its funny how you people are so into reviving a language thats dead, its interesting to know the history but why am i not seeing the same enthusiasm in unearthing the tribal traditions of people who live in the jungles of Odisha ?..or the obsession to find the roots of the nomads of Rajashthan...who must have a history thats older than any other city in northern india ...And documenting... What is this obsession with only one language and things associated with it...
Wjy arent we seeing the same enthusiasm about bhuddism or Jainism.....and ofcourse there is TAMIL THE OLDEST LANGAUGE IN THE WORLD ...AND STILL HAS CRORES OF PEOPLE SPEAKING IT ....why no one is doing underwater excavation in the coastal Tamil nadu to find poombuhaar and other such human settlements that are under sea which will change the way india looks at south india ..
@@onetrueindian1 Oldest Tamil literature came after the oldest sanskrit literature and also uses sanskrit in its vocabulary.
Sorry to burst your bubble but Tamil is not the oldest language.
@@onetrueindian1 daudi oldest tamiz saar
@@onetrueindian1because indus valley was a vedic civilization
@@onetrueindian1your hatred for north and India in general is clear
Why Indian universities could not produce someone Yagnadevam? Hope the government is watching this and start giving grants to Indian universities for research
In India people are desperate in making money not interested in academic research and thought process.
its sad. Indians only want to send their children to IIT/ Medicine
Because Indian universities don’t want happy and curious people with idle time for hobbies. They want weary and overwhelmed people with no time for anything beyond mugging pages and pages of random facts and tables.
Indian universities do produce lot of garbage in the name of academia.
It's so sad we Indians r not valuing our own history language our people who r doing such hard work to find out the truth n busy propaganda of west ...our people r totally blinded by western.. I came here after Abhijit chavda had mentioned in a podcast abt a man is working hard on decoding india script a year ago
Brilliant and amazing. I hope the world take’s cognisance of Yajnadevam’s work and is awarded the highest prize for his work.
May his claims become well set true thing
Yajnadevam; a legendary personality emerging .
...a legendary person emerging ,what does that means ,if is legendary it means that is not just emerging ,what a twisted logic....
Salute to Tamil Brain. We are proud of you. Simply Pranam.
Better to consider as hindu brain
Yagna Devam Sir is Telugu person
Salute to "Sanatani bharatiya" brain 🧠🕉️🇮🇳🟠🛕🚩🙏
Anand N., it is upto you to not just continue this debate but make it more immersive.The vested nay sayers will certainly drown this man's voice. He needs to be heard across the board and be debated threadbare and most critically brought into the paradigm of strict scientific scrutiny. Once his work attains that milestone it will be safe. That is the service you must extend this fine researcher. Please do not fail him.
it's pretty solid science. cryptanalysis is conclusive. as the gentleman says if you sprinkle a little random information in and you get drastically different results then you're on the wrong trail.
he explained inputting all kinds of languages and only sanskrit matches.
the only thing left is to simply accept the findings.
@@jocr1971 It more like I create a script that is very unique and the model just because of the bias will tell me... O it's a Roman Script... The people who used the dummy script used to talk in roman language...
Model are biasly trained... although we can adjust the input parameters... but that doesn't makes any sense though not in the very least.
@@Pontiff03If you claim so, then do the same for Tamil or some other language with Indus script and challenge him. Burden of proof lies on you since you are making the claim, he did his part and he's explained it well in channel. I trust him more than armchair yt comment experts.
@Pontiff03 this is quite complex and many factors had to fall into place to get the result.
all languages have rules both for constructing words from sounds and sentences from words.
each language has rules about allowable consonantal clusters and long/short/accented/not accented syllables.
no two languages are the same. if something fits a pattern then it's identified.
Actually this is a very important research .
Unfortunately so called progressives in India will sideline it .
Anyhow , one must appreciate this research which used information theory to decode . It has a Mathematical base .
Great talk. I liked the way the interviewer asked questions, questions were well designed and he did not interrupt.
What the hell...Why people are not talking about this..this could be the greatest research in Indian history. That's Huge 😮
Because it doesn't help anybody politically
The problem is, there seems to have been no peer review unfortunately. We should help this get peer-reviewed; it could then be accepted/rejected.
Don't use the word savage. Savage refers to the Europeans who brutalized every other culture. Hunter gatherers aren't savage, you can sit with them and dine or converse if you're welcomed into their community.
Management of Savagery
Anand Narsimhan, request you to do an interview with Parisalan and Mannarmannan, who are very knowledgeable. Probably arrange a debate or discussion with them along with Yajnadevam. Are you listening, Anand???
👌
Those people dont know anything but telling stories as History! They never tell any proof! These people playing to the Dravidian gallery of Tamil Nadu!
Don't judge before the debate with them
Mannar mannan and paari has huge knowledge than YAJNADEVAN
Manner mannanand Paarisalan cook up the most hideous stories and call it history without proof. Don't waste your time with them.
his name is so cool and great research
Very frustrated with BJP. Even after 10 years, our history books have not changed to reflect the truth.
Y;es.
Bureaucracy is still under the control socialist communist "khangress"
Absolutely
Modi is Mohamad
I have seen dna research papers of American(harvard) guy, Turkish scientist and European scientists. They all have different results and conclusions. In American(harvard) studies done by jewish guy he find continuous small migrations into india over 1200 bce to 100ce. In Turkish research paper they find Caucasus hunter gatherer and Iranian dna going to europe and in european research papers they find 30% south asian ancestry going to Yamnaya. So don't hold your breath for west to be honest. They need aryan dravidian theory to keep divisions in india.
The only people that are keeping endians divided are the endians ,stop playing the victims ,if what this guy is telling is true and he can prove it ,the rest of the world will accepted but if is just another hendutva conman goon that sell pies in the sky than tell him to f*ck off with his stupid lies...
Aryan and Dravidian are not the same people tho
@@jamesboth3785 Modern people are same. half half dna. If u go 10-20000 years there common ancestor will be same.
Do you know that Zent Avasta and Rig veda has 60% similarity in language and dieties?
@urgenlama7302 it's complicated. Some are same but In zend avesta many of them become villians and demons since they didn't take their side in the war.
Dear Yajnadevam, please publish your work in a journal ASAP! Else people with discredit this work as one of the many who tried to decipher this code and could only manage to only partially do that.
Thank you for your information and revealing information about the Indus Valley Script🌹💐🙏🙏
He shouod be interviewed in every news channel
Jai Bharat. India civilized the world . This is the truth. Please make a movie on this topic.
Nonsense... Do you know about the cave of el castillo ...those are 40,000 years old in Spain .. gobekli tepe in turkey those are some of the oldest human settlement area still in use ... Know the world before you make such stupid remarks ... It's because of people like you that Indians are being looked down today in the west ... Such useless trumpeting of some nonsense
There was no India in those days. Smaller, independent nations existed at that time.
Their was india from last 2500 years and Bharat from last 5000 years@@QabilAGhor
@@Bhatti_Saab_7773 I think this is just revisionist history. There is no evidence of what you are suggesting. This myth was started to create the notion of Akhand Bharat, but it is just politics. It is not based on reality.
@@Bhatti_Saab_7773 you wrong we exist 10000000000yrs
in greek mythology. dionysus 9th book. zeus wants to defeat indians as they worship elephant headed god. yazidis in iraq have rituals similar to hindus, zoroastrians have thread ceremonies like hindus used to practice and today only few brahmin communities do. syria had mitanni kingdom who's court language was sanskrit. we were well connected than we think we were.
In the Rig Ved there is no mention of an urban civilization similar to the Indus Valley Civilization. The vedas describe a pastoral and rural life consisting of cattle herding, cows, sacrifices, lord Indra, Varun etc.
That's why vedic time was before Indus Valley
Nilesh Oak and Yajnadevam collaboration
Nilesh oak is fraud
Both are fake and fraud. Nilessh oak is stealing Dr pv Vartaks research and presenting as his own.
Then It will be brilliant🥂
पश्चिमी इतिहासकार कुटिल और कुख्यात हैं और जो इतिहास वे चाहते थे उसे बनाने के लिए तथ्यों को तोड़-मरोड़ कर पेश करने के लिए जाने जाते हैं। मुझे सिर्फ भारतीय इतिहासकारों पर भरोसा है.
It is high time that Indian scholars came together and demolished the misuse of the language problem by Westerners to serve the political agenda. In this regard, an old book titled ' Adhibhasha' by Chattampi Swamikal is significant. It says that Sanskrit is not a naturally evolved language but something created like a programmed language. It was made out of the Prakrit language. Prakrit evolved from languages stemming from the Mooladravida language brought to the North by people who migrated from the South of India.
Yes we should make Sanskrit official language for India
@@iqbal21no make it for hindi speaking states.
Our nation has linguistic pride. Can't even think about of having one official language
How much this guy has paid to the TV news channels? How coukd he decode without a rosetta stone?
He has explained that in Part 1, try that you may get an idea ...
yea non of these ever tell you what written on the those seals
Great work, Sir
सत्यमेव जयते
What stands out is the brilliance and dedication of Yagnadevam. The mystery of the Indus Valley civilization and its undeciphered script is incredibly captivating, creating a sense of connection that feels almost umbilical. As a result, anything that sheds light on this subject naturally sparks curiosity.
Yagnadevam seems to be making a concerted effort to present the intricate technical details in a way that is accessible to the average person.
However, I believe this would benefit from a different approach. Rather than an interview format, a narrative structure could be more effective.
A documentary-style presentation would allow the research and findings to unfold gradually, starting with the basics and progressing step by step. By incorporating actual inscriptions and symbols at the site, alongside the methods used to decode them, viewers could witness the process firsthand. The narrative could then demonstrate the hypothesis in action by applying it to a new inscription, showing how the theory holds up.
This approach would likely offer a clearer and more engaging understanding for the audience.
I had a tough time wrapping it around my head and hence was looking for something more simpler and easy to understand.
Given the immensity of impact this theory has, I would request Anand and Yagnadevam to consider the request to explore a way of making this groundbreaking research more accessible and engaging for a wider audience.
Its funny how you people are so into reviving a language thats dead, its interesting to know the history but why am i not seeing the same enthusiasm in unearthing the tribal traditions of people who live in the jungles of Odisha ?..or the obsession to find the roots of the nomads of Rajashthan...who must have a history thats older than any other city in northern india ...And documenting... What is this obsession with only one language and things associated with it...
Wjy arent we seeing the same enthusiasm about bhuddism or Jainism.....and ofcourse there is TAMIL THE OLDEST LANGAUGE IN THE WORLD ...AND STILL HAS CRORES OF PEOPLE SPEAKING IT ....why no one is doing underwater excavation in the coastal Tamil nadu to find poombuhaar and other such human settlements that are under sea which will change the way india looks at south india ..
o funding for Tamil history, they are afraid of what they are going find. Keezhadi samples sent for radio carbondating were those which were exvacted closer to the surface level, but not deeper than that. Poombuhar exploration was held, gremany does more for tamil than india or TN.
There r reseachers doing such research
Try to search such research & researchers
cope dravidian kalue
U do it bastard
Oooh!! Another crazy Tamil chauvinist!! Will never agree that Sanskrit supersedes tamil.. find out the meaning of “karunanidhi” its Sanskrit origin!!
Brilliant and amazing.
I am sure that some day or the other Yagyadevam's theory and conclusions will definitely be accepted. VandeBharatMataram.
Yajnadevam is collaborating with the Archeological Survey of India according to his recent tweet….expect more insights into this in the months to come..
Great work of the Researcher👍👌✋
Indus Valley, Sumerian(Su(Tall) +Meru(Mountain) are Tamil cultures. Sanskrit no way connected with these Civilizations.
After Kumari Continent submerged or swallowed by repeated Tsu(Tall) nami(tides)'s. people started moving towards tall places and started their living in groups.
Indus Valley, Sumerian and oldest tribal groups in Australian continent are Tamils.
Indus Valley has Sivan, Murugan and Kotravai symbols and the letters script called as Tamizhi.
Dear Central Government, as per the research, please visit current Poompuhar city in Tamil Nadu (only half out of sea, another half inside the sea), travel 45KMs inside the ocean from the seashore, you can find a submerged city with tall building structures that includes a gigantic lighthouse which is nearly 15000 years old.
Researchers confirmed these findings...
If possible, invest on this...
Thank you
The original name (and correct pronunciation) of Kumari Kandam is Kumari Khand / Khandam. Both words (kumari and khandam) are Sanskrit and mean "virgin territory".
Legend ❤❤❤❤
Brilliant work. Reawakening of India has just started and it is going to be long process in time frame.
he says its impossible that new words can be added or replace old words? there is historical evidence of such events happening, like the battle of hastings, which changed the english language. even many chinese regional languages and scripts were culled by Qin emperors to standardize the chinese language. things like this have happened before. would be good to put these analyses to the test! good luck!
The so called Indus valley Civilisation is not the origin of Hindu/Indian civilisation. It was just a township in ancient India not a new civilisation. Indian Civilisation/ Hindu Civilisation is much older than the Indus people.
Hinduism is a descendant of the Vedic culture which itself came from outside of India in central Asia. Stop the l///ies.
Then why swastika symbol found in indus valley civilisation is still sacred symbol for hindus?
Yoga was originated in indus valley civilisation. For hindus yoga is core philosophy
@@bpmalanadu7136 no, it's not. You have nothing but tales, myths and legends.
Pass me the weed bro
Salutations to Yajnadevam ji
Dont fogrt amd.take note of which community both come.from then it is easy to understand the agenda they are pushing
Bullshit komayam ...samasanakiruthuruvam has nothing to do with Indus harappa civilization ..there was no such language that time .all big lies
Bear in mind that Sanskrit Language is the youngest language of the all. So called Vedic language literatures are actually Nalanda e t l Buddhist universities have contributed in its full use and development.
First explore poompuhar and rest the History will start from Tamilnadu
What about the indus script found in Keeladi? This guy never explains and the interviewer never asks..😢
See he just wants to prove that the Vedic civilization is the start of the Indian continent. If he talked about Kiladi how would he be able to prove that vedic is the oldest civilization.
Does anyone give authentic evidence that those who are all blindly supporting this insensible talks
They love to speak with zero evidence 😀
psedoscience has now become mainstream in India.
Credibility is not something that is concocted but is self evident just as Sun does not need anyone's acceptance for its value, because it is evident.
There’s a few flaws in his theory .howcome ,people from Indus region flourished their culture in gangetic plains when clearly at the peak of their civilization they were settled in Indus region(Punjab )and south(sindh)
don't do cheap narrative and literally you are begging someone cultures blindly without any sense and any shameless
Of poor taste and factually incompatible at many instances. nothing much about reading of the script but general loose comments on features of indus civilization.
He says ot is guptha type sanskrit .
So, Panini 2000. BCE. ?
he should have peer reviews and publish on historical archeological journals, it could prove to be breakthrough of this decade because indus script were never been Cracked
I think it's already there, he has published
Bina video dekhe kyu comment karte ho yaar
🙏🌺 it is written that this is the second part, where is the first ?
Estika is " Itika " in Telugu. Means brick
all indian languages taken word from sanskrit for brick
In that case...it is also called itike in kannada....
@@Agnostic7773 it shows our roots are same
This guy is half cooked
News 18 is trying hard to appease the Vedic culture
A great work by Mr. Yajnadevam. However there is one point used by proponents of Aryan invasion / migration theory, to disassociate IVC from Vedic civilization. This is the fact that horses are mentioned even in the Vedas, whereas there appeared to be no proof of horse usage at IVC sites. How can this be explained
There is a village called sinauli, U.P. few years back, ASI found a chariot which goes back to harrapan time. Sinauli is a recently discovered IVC site. So it has already proved that point wrong that we didn't have horses. By the way that village is just adjacent to my village.
@subalsaroha5463 that's great, but it will help if historians put forward proper proof as to where the horses came from to draw the chariots. Though we as Indians intuitively know certain things to be true, the damage done by the earlier narrative cannot be undone unless the facts are presented in a proper manner
Watch the episode Secrets of Sinauli @@raghumani3814
Dude just showed IVC deciphered script on the screen right now and chariot word is used so horse usage is shown. U need a new set of eyes clearly.
There are horse remains at all levels in multiple Indus sites.
It's a predetermined interview to glorify sanskrit over Tamiz. These guys only r reason for South North divide. Just don't want to accept reality of skewed North indian false mindset
Yajnadevam himself is a Tamilian. To disprove him, you need to mathematically disprove him. It's not him but you and your conspiracy theories of Aryan invasion that is the cause of North South divide.
Did anybody get any information about what he deciphered and how he deciphered or this hollow story telling is enough to accept him as discoverer?
Jambudvīpa is one Civilization
Sanskrit was only a religious ritual language ....it was never a language of people...........
The lack of intellectual curiosity in comments is utterly befuddling. Politics apart, this is widely acknowledged to be the greatest unsolved script decipherment challenge in the world.
How long are these guys going to fool people or fool themselves?
I think his decoded message will not be accepted by Govt, there is a possibility that real truth will come out which will be a headache for his claims and others. But my understanding is that Prakrat is older than Sanskrit which disapprovea his theory.
While podcast could you please stop the behind screen, it is distracting me from conversation 😢
Who ever has the power, people praise them. They is no truth.
One of the big problems with Yajnadevams “decipherment” is the conflation of symbols. If you look at the website where the deciphered text is displayed, you can see symbols that are totally different (not merely in style), are considered as a single symbol.
Furthermore, the purported decipherments do not give any indication of the use of the seals. It simply does not make sense.
Finally, according to his paper, the words can be algorithmically deciphered, but the pace of decipherment seems to show otherwise. If it was algorithmic, then the decipherment would be obvious.
Lastly, the interviewer is already biased. His questions contains assumptions that are highly controversial but he mentions it as if they are truth.
Even now we have some letters which have a very distinctive way of writing.
@@npatel7775is it possible for pa and ma and sha and ha to all have the same symbol? Looking at the yajnadevam decipherment, there are many examples where widely varying symbols are assigned the same “letter”
@@cerebral1095well I think you are highly biased.Did he not say this in the draft stage being checked by experts? If they find discrepancies that will stop the paper from being published. I assume all these experts are better informed than you. What agenda are you trying to push?
@@cerebral1095i have seen his paper the so called different words are like different varietal of single letter its like u M has Fish symbol but fishes are of different variety nd one can makes variations to look it unidentical to its Simpler form
@@FLXFLX-xm7mphe must be some Mujeet or tamil Nationalist
Don't spread the false news I think doesn't fit for that
Why Sanskrit should be Indus Language?
And Why it isn't? Comparison with Vedic Society...
-> Firstly, no ruler based society --- Vedic Society based on King oblique Rajas or Pati.
-> Equality amongst citizens --- Vedic Society was Patriarchal
-> Lack of Warfare, except for Sinuali Rider's Grave --- Vedic Society based on warfare, used to war against themselves or panis for cow
-> No Huge Temples Dedicated to Gods, Despite Knowing about Sumerian Gods such as Gilgamesh, Inanna and Enkidu(Seals are found in Indus) --- Although Temples where not constructed in Vedic Times... But Later we find huge temples dedicated to Gods.
-> Classist Society --- Vedic Society was not so classist as they followed similar patterns as that of the Vikings... which was raiding. Although there were 4 classes Priest, King, Commoners and Slaves.
-> Language is unknown, could be the obscure Dravidian language in Pakistan --- Vedic Society was contemptuous in using Vedic Sanskrit... which was cognate with Avesta and Old Persian... Both had roots in Indo European Language.
-> Migration yes... Indus and Sumeria both migrated and intermarried each other(Happened only in middle east and Iran) --- Somewhat valid because dasrajan war talks about expelling few aryan tribe to the west... But migrated in whole world from that is an overstatement and this means that the right wing historians are just lying to you.
The reason his paper has not been published is because he has not deciphered the Indus script as he claims to have done. He cannot show what he claims to be the case, is the case. It's a mere claim with no proof.
Are you just making that claim, or do you have a proof for your claim?
Awe lil 🍑 hurt petty person 😂😂😂. He said right off the bat that his paper is in the draft stage.
The DNA remains found in harappa Indus is tamil irula tribe and no traces of steppe DNA
@@PS-ej2xn Yes I have proof for my claim. But I'm not the one on TV.
@@cskcmp5009 What does DNA have to do with deciphering the Indus script?
Would request yagnadevam to refer IVC as Saraswati civilization because you have another later work of IVC script dialect deciding
Excellent discourse. Shedding new lights, as old people say.
Another desparate attempt to establish sanskrit and vedic period
eIn every video I ask where the paper is published, and who has peer reviewed it, and there is no answer.
Why IIT & IIS are not focusing on technology and science? Involved in archeological studies? Still India is not having TOP 100 institutes list. Dung mind people 😂
Come down to Tamil researchers and scholars and to Tamil people , who can prove that the INDUS SCRIPT is TAMIL and not SANSKRIT.The entire INDIAN history is belongs to Tamil , we can prove it..The INDUS SCRIPT is related to the archeological evidences found in KEELADI.
The original name (and correct pronunciation) of Kumari Kandam is Kumari Khand / Khandam. Both words (kumari and khandam) are Sanskrit and mean "virgin territory".
@stufftobenefittheworld9371
Sangi spotted. Sanskrit means refined Prakrithm. How the unspoken Sanskrit is ancient and mother of languages..
Joker.
There is one chapter (chapter 10) dedicated to Paisachi Prakrit in Prakrita Prakasha, a grammar book of Prakrit languages attributed to Vararuchi.[6] In this work, it is mentioned that the base of Paisachi is Shauraseni language. It further goes on to mention 10 rules of transforming the base text to Paisachi. These are mostly rules of substitution of letters - Chapter 10 of Prakrita Pariksha
So instead of an invasion from outside India, now he’s claiming an invasion from IVC to South India, and then adopted the language of that region.
Dravidian substrate in Sanskrit also needs to be explained, and is not explained by this model.
It easily is...IVC traded not just with mesopotamia but also with cultures south of Godavari.
Marathi is the last Indo-Arya language....from karnataka onwards we have Sanskritised native languages.
Tamil itself has 40% sanskrit vocabulary,grammar etc meaning Tamil was a fusion language devised by the Sages to propogate Dharma in southern regions.
Ppl accepted Dharma as it was Knowledge based and not some belief system like Abrahamic fables.
If someone doesnt believe in Gravity or Electromagentism it means nothing and has no effect on Gravity.
And accept the fact that the geeatest Tamil kings propogated Sanskrit as an International,Cultured and Universal language.
Sanskrit was always a scholarly language and not anybodys mother-tounge.
Same way as programming languages have to be learned so also was Sanskrit a precise language learnt by students.
When did he mention invasion of IVC on southern India, could you share timestamp, i listened carefully I did encounter that claim he just mentioned people moved south and assimilated.
Petty person desperate to push your agenda 😂😂😂
Brainwashed, hope you have ask question in all direction.
Selective blindness will not help.
Migration, dear,Migration. They settle and intermarried the locals. They brought their Indus culture and mixed with the local.
But not all migrants can coexist with their natives for a long time, especially food, and women become scarce.
He is not clear
He is approaching predetermined
He is wrong
You should read his paper on it. He firstly considered Tamil as the candidate for his research but Tamil is not fitting with the script. Thats why he took Sanskrit as 2nd candidate.
Awww Dravida munetream stopped because of his claim. i smell vaithu eruchal.
Muthu Tamil ? Then you are correct because you are a scientist of your own.
He is clear.
Please present your paper and refute him
Universities, Researchers and other knowledge industry workers must follow global and proven protocols.
Tbh , this indus valley civilisation is way different then todays religion . Sanskrit is core language, what a joke , 🤣 . The script of indus is unique in itself . There is no written Sanskrit , on any Stone , Script etc .
He doesn't mention Tamil inscriptions. Very sly 😮😢
Sterling effort.
Can he use his same method to decipher any written script in the world?
Poompukar and Keeladi sites dates back even before Sindu Samaveli(Indus Valley) civilization. Kindly tell the logic of migration again.which is old?aren't we good at maths.have you found Kumari kandam that Tamil Scriptures describes.Tholkappiam,Silapatigaram,Agananooru,Purananooru...All respect to you sir please feel free to research and see how big Bharat is or was🙏
I am a telugate native as tamil nadu for more than 10 generations I believe Tamil should be the first..... aryans migrated they crossed Indus valley then after landed in India. According consideration of mannar mannan theory also I understood that aryand migrated is true, and he Also mentioned there were aseevagham before it gives conclusion that aryans God is our Hindu God now. But our Tamil is more older than sanskrit we might have spreaded allover India later we all came and settled in south india.... we can't believe everyone's theory 100% but whatever is common and we believe that must be true.....
I agree Tamil is an Old language, Poompugar is indeed older than Indus Valley , But that does not take away the fact that indus vally spoke and wrote sanskrit in the indus script. Dravida is even mentoined in the Rig veda, in fact the current manu for this manvantara (Age of Manu)is from Dravida(TN+Andra+karnataka+kerala). Vaivasvata Manu or styavratha(Speaker of truth) is the name given to him. Agastiyar is mentioned both in rig vedas and All the tamil sangam literature. If you consider Agastiar to be a part of Tamil culture then you have to accepet that tamil culture was part and parcel of Bharath(Bharatha Varsha) and an integral part of sanathana Dharma. Tamil was a parallel language that was spoken during during and before the indus like sanskrit was , Tamil was developed by Agastiar along with Sanskrit in parallel. Agastiar was one of the greatest scholars of the vedas as he was of the Tamil Sangam. He is revered all over india irrespective of language. There was a developed world during indus vally and before it, We just dont have proof of it yet. Both indus and tamil kings ofthose times were in Trade with Greeks of that time period. the evidence from poompugar tells us that much.
pff haha lol are you freaking serious.. show me the dating proof of poopuhar civilization and keeladi? these both were dated to close 6 BCE and you are saying they are older than IVC? are you mad? what your govt replaced facts with ganja? lol
@@sidvoxx where? show me the proof that poompuhar is older IVC?
@sidvoxx thank you.I research on Pandian emperor and his lost kingdom and you won't believe what he did.I am waiting for right time to publish them
Narrative of invasion is because of the Paleo language commonality all over the world. Which could indicate a common ancestory and not invasion.
Rightwing Fundamentalistic agenda of the ruling party in Delhi! Beware! Script (written form), Language family, Racial Grouping - these three are different things but can come in any mix! Different language families can use the same script - example English and Finnish! Same language family can use different scripts - English and Russian. And even English and Hindi too! One can continue.
As for the script - all Indian scripts (North and South ) and SE Asian scripts are Brahmi based. Cambodian, Thai language etc are different from Indian languages, but their script seems to be based on Brahmi. Script basis is not the same as language family. Today Indonesia has accepted Roman script. But their language is not European based at all. For convenience they accepted that. Indus Valley language is not Sanskrit based at all. Brahui in Pakistan is Dravidian based !
Did the Bhrahmi script originate in Indus Valley? We don‘t know. No one has proved that.
Brahmi is the evolution of the indust script. Yagnadevam provides mathematical proof of it in his paper. Give it a read .
Where else do you see it branching out the most? It's only in Bharata that Brahmi has gone on to develop into other major scripts which means that it was being used from a long time to be modified by the people who were using it to develop a script for their language
@@sidvoxx Any idiot can claim a newer thing in a place is the evolution of an older thing. Brahmi is not the issue here. The topic is : Deciphering Indus Script. And many stalwarts had problems here. And it is undebtable that Indus Valley Civilization had no connections to Indo-Aryan Languages. Hre Yagnadevan is either a puppet of the new Fundamentalist Lobby in India or he has been folled by them. Crap logic will not prove anything.
Indian is the palace where the first generation lived particularly south india
N what about ur ancestors
@mudrarakshasa
My Ancestors were good people not like duryodhan types, you know those stayed in India from ancestors to now are the seeds of duryodhana
Jealousy is often spotted in your kind
@@whitelotus2960
Maybe I am human not god
Exactly tamil. First human born in kumari kandam but Aryans crying 😂
Why is the government not working towards making Sanskrita an official language of India
@@iqbal21
Why for deciding people on varnas and spoil the whole nation like they doing for thousands of years ?
Because it’s a useless dead language that almost nobody used even a thousand years ago
It almost reached the end
The government is anti Hindu
Imagine how insecure one can be about their race, that he created a fake/delusional narrative.
Sanskrit during Indus valley, what a joke😅😅😂
😂😅😊
Great work 👌
Prakrit has the oldest evidence and oldest written sanskrit was in bhrami script , what is he talking about?
This is a new research, your understanding is old
So basically Indus Valley people were malayalis. We also say ishtika.
This is Not published in journal. As far recent nature journal paper IVC is dravidian langauge.
Listened from beginning to the end but could not make head or tail of what Mr. Yojnadevam trying to say. The name of Panini who supposed to have developed the Sanskrit script was not even mentioned. I am from Sri Lanka with an Indo-ariyan language. If you take hindi words and remove the line at the top the letters down below has similar structure to Sinhala letters. And the alphabet of Malayali and Sinhala almost the same. Some tamil letters also have similar structure.
In Sri Lanka's east we have irrigation structures which are engineering marvels made with bricks similaf to what you get in Mohenjo Daro beloning to same period 2000 BCE. It appears an advanced civilisation vanished about 1300 years ago, perhaps due to disease like Malaria. Perhaps Mohenjo Daro vanished due to desertification as they may have cut down all trees to make burnt clay bricks and funeral fires.
Fake narrative 😂😂 Baised report
Aweee because he denies aryan invasion and that doesn't sit well with your cheap dravidian politics 😂😂😂😂
Enda da Kanna? Vaithu eriyutha ? kavala padathe gelusil saptalum pogathu 🤣🤣🤣
Let , experts, linguusts, and scientific people accept it. Only after that you can tell and inform the people. Don't serve half cooked food. Or food under preparation or food on the flame.
It is untenable to think of Vedic society and Samskrita as two unrelated entities. IVC’s material culture available so far, does not resemble Vedic society at all. So, assigning Samskrita/Vedic/IE to IVC script is very anachronistic. It is also cultural misappropriation. Perhaps some bilingual material in the Middle East will one day turn out to be the Rosetta Stone for IVC decipherment.
ALL THE PERIYAR FOLLOWERS ,DRAVIDIANS AND TAMIL SUPREMACISTS NEED TO LISTEN TO THIS GUY.THE MOTHER LANGUAGE IS SANSKRIT.
No 😂 Indus scripts words matches to kelladi 😂ask bjp to research kumari kandam don’t run again
Periyarists have no hope they can continue to shout scream and defile Dharma. The sun is out its daylight no one can deny the sun since the book Breaking India was published around 2010-11
Yet to dig more. sanskrit is just a baby when compared to Tamil
@@RupeshKumar-lw8fb 😂😂😂😂
Baby 😂😂
The underlying hate for North India translates into this stupid conclusion.
You better be chanting mantras and doing your Vandana's in Tamil.
IF YOU ARE A HINDU.
YOU BETTER CONVERT TO ISLAM
YOU HAVE PERFECT MINDSET FOR IT 😂😂
ASK YOUR PERIYAR BROTHERS TO LEAVE SANATAN DHARMA TOO 😂
@@RupeshKumar-lw8fb thats why you have sanskrit name lol
Please don't spread rumours/ Guess works.
This is not even published as a paper.Just a crap study
Such claims have been done since decades and until such discovery is peer reviewed by expert linguists; this should not be taken seriously (exactly why other people were not taken into consideration).
Keep crying in the corner
Bunkum for trying to brahminise indus which is crap theory as it is known that it was more ofndadivasi first language .
Stop pedalling all.sorts pf people as historians and archeologists to further own.agenda
How come all the ancient sites get covered in soil? This is a question which I haven't been able to find answers to. How do they get buried? I think this will also hold a key to our understanding the times and their "disappearance"!
Winds. They buried the whole body of the sphinx with sand. The summer winds in India also do the same thing. Leave your house shut for a month and see the amount of dust that gets accumulated even in a closed space. What chance do these open spots stand once people stop inhabiting the place due to climatic or other conditions??
Floods and sediments deposit over, North Indian rivers bring lot of mud and sediments during floods, over 1000s of years 100s of flood
How do you think you get dust on floor? Do not clean that floor for centuries and you will have your house buried under soil. It's deposition of soil.