The Woke Left's HYPOCRITICAL Pact With Islam - Faisal al Mutar | heretics. 64

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 авг 2024

Комментарии • 772

  • @andrewgoldheretics
    @andrewgoldheretics  2 месяца назад +103

    Have you had personal experience with friends linking arms with Islam? Is this driving you nuts? Let me know below - and hit like and sub!

    • @NeraBuffy
      @NeraBuffy 2 месяца назад +14

      When it comes to integration there's also a problem with successful integration called late onset jihad.

    • @michellemooresings
      @michellemooresings 2 месяца назад +10

      It is so painful to me that I am not wanting to see things they're posting. :(

    • @souxcasa
      @souxcasa 2 месяца назад +20

      I just can't talk to most people about it which is crazy. I saw some of the videos on Oct 7th broadcast by Hamas, this was not propaganda they showed us what they did and those images will never leave me

    • @saszablaze1
      @saszablaze1 2 месяца назад

      no, i have many many friends who stand for freedom from oppression, and most of my friends are not religious, i don't have too much in common with religious people coz to be religious you have to be stupid
      I have many friends who support the palestinians, and I support palestine, not zionists, not israel state, not israeli violators. i stand again religions that cut their children, including judaism, and islam, and any african tradition.

    • @michellemooresings
      @michellemooresings 2 месяца назад +5

      @@souxcasa my understanding is that because of bias, People are not able to look that direction. They just push it aside almost unconsciously. This is what the damage of disinformation has caused, sadly.

  • @SouthernRayLA
    @SouthernRayLA 2 месяца назад +352

    I’m a 26 year old black woman who studied sociology in college. When I think back to my college days, I am so happy that I was able to see things for what they were instead of what I was being taught. I remember taking a race and ethnicity class. It was a pretty high level class and I loved it because I thought it was challenging and the professor was great. One day he had wrapped up his lesson for the day and I stayed behind to talk to him. He talked a lot about racism towards black people and he discussed a lot of socialist ideas, but I wanted to know what the other side thought so I asked him if he could refer some books to me that were basically counter arguments. His response to me was I don’t know why you would want to hear anything those guys have to say, and it stunned me. In my head, I was like why wouldn’t I want to know what the other side believes. I was new in the sociology space so I didn’t question him, however I did think his response was odd.
    I did feed into the ideology for a while because sociology definitely teaches you what to think, not how to think. I was very observant to my surroundings and I think that prevented me from becoming a radical. My lived experience didn’t quite match up with the things I was being taught and I began to question those beliefs. I am now light years away from the person I was at 21 thank goodness. I can acknowledge that as a country we have some work to do when it comes to race relations, however we have come so far as well and that shouldn’t be ignored or forgotten. Although it’s really hard when you have college professors who teach that you shouldn’t listen and be open to counter arguments. Everything you are taught is presented in a matter of fact way, even when they call it a theory.

    • @Sarahmarknz01
      @Sarahmarknz01 2 месяца назад +69

      as a woman of indigenous background your journey seems very similar to mine. I was into all things woke until I realized how hateful my radical leftist university friends were and how they didn't want to address reality and conveniently ignored anything that didn't align with their narratives. Hooray for us!

    • @amusedbemused7223
      @amusedbemused7223 2 месяца назад +39

      I’m sure you’ve read Thomas Sowell by now, but he would have been a good recommendation from your professor.

    • @Sarahmarknz01
      @Sarahmarknz01 2 месяца назад

      @@amusedbemused7223 yup got 2 of his books. He's awesome.

    • @prof.jezebel
      @prof.jezebel 2 месяца назад

      to be fair to your prof, they probably were seeing "the other side" as white supremacy (and there is no reasonable basis for those arguments so not worthy of university study), and didn't know about scholars like Thomas Sowell

    • @gisellemagraibhaigh8342
      @gisellemagraibhaigh8342 2 месяца назад +21

      It appears (to me) that part of the problem is how long it takes ideas to filter through to authorities - some of the stances they take would of been great 40+ years ago...meanwhile the real world has muddled through these issues in various ways, and academics are posturing in bubbles of ideology that are forced, fake and embarrassing

  • @rachelneal2886
    @rachelneal2886 2 месяца назад +395

    I've made it my mission to learn all I can about Islam from ex Muslims. I have in a previous career travelled to the middle East and Pakistan both before and after 911 and as a Woman I was deeply disturbed by the undercurrents even back then. I now live in a city with a significant Pakistani population and their behaviour is deeply disturbing....they clearly hate the west and western values....and I'm talking about 3rd generation!

    • @sanniepstein4835
      @sanniepstein4835 2 месяца назад +42

      Please comment on leftist channels such as Democracy Now and Jimmy Dore.

    • @enshrinehd
      @enshrinehd 2 месяца назад +1

      There are many great sources.

    • @NeraBuffy
      @NeraBuffy 2 месяца назад

      There's also JihadWatchVideo channel with a brilliant historian

    • @NeraBuffy
      @NeraBuffy 2 месяца назад +17

      Robert Spencer's history books are amazing .

    • @user-xc6wd3hb4s
      @user-xc6wd3hb4s 2 месяца назад

      What do you know about Zionism and how Zionists view goyem like us?

  • @jakhulley7171
    @jakhulley7171 2 месяца назад +204

    The ignorance of history will haunt the future.

  • @YonieZukowsky51
    @YonieZukowsky51 2 месяца назад +183

    Woke and Islam a toxic mixture indeed.

    • @jj-yi1ne
      @jj-yi1ne 2 месяца назад +5

      add christianity too

    • @theinngu5560
      @theinngu5560 2 месяца назад +20

      @@jj-yi1ne no The founder of Christianity preached only love and forgiveness ( I am not Christian ) and the founder of Islam preached hatred and subjugation…massive difference.

    • @richardingamells7213
      @richardingamells7213 2 месяца назад

      Yet we have the fxcking audacity to criticise China for being tough on its Islamic terrorists. Namely the Uighur so called separatists

    • @FocusedFighter777
      @FocusedFighter777 2 месяца назад +1

      ​@@jj-yi1ne
      100%
      Any religion are used by crazies.

    • @user-hp9xs1tu9l
      @user-hp9xs1tu9l 2 месяца назад

      Islamic fundamentalists must be laughing their arses off that anyone who opposes them is shouted down by blue hair genderbots.

  • @Uncivilize
    @Uncivilize 2 месяца назад +84

    I live in far Northern California in one of the most liberal and activist towns in the country. Almost everyone here is pro-Palestine. People believe the world will literally end in 2 years from climate change. This used to be an extremely creative and innovative area which developed organic gardening, cannabis cultivation, grass fed animals, one of the first farmer's markets, alternative dwellings/structures, Human powered vehicles, food co-ops, an ingenious sewage management system integrated with the natural wetlands which were restored....it was the Hippies who did all of this. Very forward looking. Now the students at the university just want to burn it all down. It's crazy.

    • @jj-yi1ne
      @jj-yi1ne 2 месяца назад

      does your dog suck you off?

    • @ca8944
      @ca8944 2 месяца назад +18

      They’ll be fine living under Sharia🥴🤣

    • @ca8944
      @ca8944 2 месяца назад +7

      Humboldt?

    • @jacobdiden8967
      @jacobdiden8967 2 месяца назад +5

      well said.

    • @JACKDAWFISH
      @JACKDAWFISH 2 месяца назад

      Oh dear. The hippie movement was created by the CIA like other destructive movements.

  • @karekarenz4713
    @karekarenz4713 2 месяца назад +46

    "An appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last." --- Winston Churchill.
    _When Winston Churchill said this, he was criticising the policy of appeasement that was prevalent before World War II. More specifically, he aimed this at those who hoped to maintain peace by giving into the aggressive demands of dictators like Hitler. However, these days it is a perfect analogy of the Left's alliance with Islam._

  • @cir-pe
    @cir-pe 2 месяца назад +82

    When Israel withdrew from Gaza they left behind all the infrastucture that would assure that the Gazan had what they needed to build a good life with both greenhouses, factories, waterpipes, schools, hospitals etc. but then they elected Hamas and they destroyed everything and stole ressource from the Gazans and invested in war instead.
    It is not Israels responsibilty to make sure that the Gazans have good lives. They tried that and the Gazans chose islam and jihadists over productivity and peace. So unless the Gazans turn on Hamas and start chosing buliding good lives instead of supporting jihad then no amount of money and aid will change anything for them.
    Change ALWAYS have to come from within. So it's all up to the Gazans themselves.

    • @victoriacritchlow9069
      @victoriacritchlow9069 2 месяца назад +3

      Well said !!

    • @karenrobertson1673
      @karenrobertson1673 2 месяца назад +8

      You are right, and it certainly isn’t Canada’s or America or any free democratic country’s responsibility to make sure gazan’s have a good life especially when they destroy everything they touch! DEFUND DISMANTLE UNRWA 75 years of our inappreciated billions in aid has been a disaster and complete failure.

    • @johnrogers5399
      @johnrogers5399 Месяц назад

      Yes.......we do not hear anything from the MSM that tells us how the Israelis left so much incredible infrastructure when they withdrew from Gaza all those years ago.
      The Arabs..Hamas deliberately destroyed it all .
      Farming, houses etc .. a great way to live .
      Gone.
      In it's place right from the beginning....fear and destruction.
      Misery.

  • @liatsotto1378
    @liatsotto1378 2 месяца назад +123

    The main problem that Israelis struggling to "talk" to the palestinians is the realisation that the most of the palestinians are much more radical and not willing to live along side of Israel. There was a shift to the right because of the Oct. 7 attack.

    • @lisalilu5275
      @lisalilu5275 2 месяца назад +36

      I used to be left.
      Until 7th Oct.
      My son lived on kibbutz kfar Aza...
      I will never forgive them for biting the hand that feeds them!!

    • @Lou-mr7kf
      @Lou-mr7kf 2 месяца назад

      It isn't just the Fakestinians. The Muslims in Israel have created aggressive no-go areas. God help any Jew who accidentally ends up in one of those Muslim enclaves.

    • @joce11
      @joce11 2 месяца назад

      ​@@lisalilu5275Exactly, they, bite the hand that feeds them. I once thought of myself as left leaning politically speaking but then the so called left started pushing all manner of nonsense and that's when I realised the left is not what it seems. I've never seen so much division and hate in my life and it's more often than not being pushed by the Left. Sadly, I was not surprised at the response from the so-called Left to Oct 7th.

    • @tumslucks9781
      @tumslucks9781 2 месяца назад

      @@lisalilu5275
      The fake Ashkenazi Jews invaded Palestine in the 1940s. They used terrorism to evict a million indigenous Semitic Palestinians from their homes before destroying 500 Palestinian villages so the real Semites could never return to their homeland. The Zionists then spent the next 70 years bombing their neighbours while screaming about their right to self defence.
      An illegal occupier has no right to self defence.
      The Palestinians have done nothing to be forgiven for!!
      FREE PALESTINE!!

    • @theinngu5560
      @theinngu5560 2 месяца назад +5

      @@lisalilu5275 Yes ..they are foolish…incredibly foolish but hating back doesn’t work either. We can be strong and say ‘No’ without hatred.

  • @joge2468
    @joge2468 2 месяца назад +60

    38:25 This is the crux of the problem and why Israelis are so anti-UNRWA. UNRWA’s existence and the inheritance of refugee status has perpetuated the delusion that someday Israel will disappear and everyone will go back to their great grandparents’ villages. UNRWA has also functioned as a de facto civil administration in Gaza, allowing Hamas to get away with zero investment in building infrastructure and an economy.

    • @rukk_tx5285
      @rukk_tx5285 2 месяца назад

      Yes, rivers of money flowing. But unrwa is hamas, no doubt and worring. The un is a joke nowadays, an abode of despots.

  • @karenrobertson1673
    @karenrobertson1673 2 месяца назад +56

    Good point that people tend to protest for what they are against rather then what they are for.

    • @jwsuicides8095
      @jwsuicides8095 2 месяца назад +1

      Yep. I'm getting that thought tattooed in to my brain.

    • @saszablaze1
      @saszablaze1 2 месяца назад +1

      yeah it's a really dumb way of doing things. but to be heard to say NO to something is pretty powerful. it's just half a job, and while you're saying NO, you could be co-creating the alternative which will inevitably attract people if it's good.

    • @Ghalion666
      @Ghalion666 2 месяца назад

      They never protest against common sense though, which they are clearly against.

  • @neildunford241
    @neildunford241 2 месяца назад +64

    Glad youre speaking to Faisal - he's amazing.

  • @MrLiamHenderson
    @MrLiamHenderson 2 месяца назад +38

    My little sis joined a free Plasticine march. And yes, it drives me mad

    • @ca8944
      @ca8944 2 месяца назад +21

      Tell her about what happened in Iran and Lebanon.

    • @thetechnocrat4979
      @thetechnocrat4979 2 месяца назад +8

      Challenge her beliefs in a civil, non confrontational way. There is hope that she will be able to understand the danger of her beliefs.

    • @vmarshall
      @vmarshall 2 месяца назад +4

      The young people do not know the big picture. At their age, they empathize strongly with innocent people being bombed. The only way to end their angst is to end the war.

    • @wheathusk2499
      @wheathusk2499 2 месяца назад

      Tell her what happened to kashmiri hindus. Google Girja Tickoo 😢

    • @mahmoodabbasi6120
      @mahmoodabbasi6120 2 месяца назад

      Respect for your sister, brave lady

  • @ddh9308
    @ddh9308 2 месяца назад +40

    The protesters don't know the background of their protests BUT they know that they have to hate any moving jew or israeliand are prepared to go very far in their actions 🤨

    • @theinngu5560
      @theinngu5560 2 месяца назад

      It’s a mental imbalance to hate anyone….and sadly the Palestinians and other Arab Muslims and many on the left have hate in bucketloads and project it onto external objects rather than seeing its real source and so instead of resolving the hate, it grows and violence is the result,

  • @Aijan100
    @Aijan100 2 месяца назад +47

    Have never come across Faisal’s work. Thank you for introducing these important voices to the public.

  • @sarahamorris1480
    @sarahamorris1480 2 месяца назад +66

    Really interesting insight to the genesis of our Islamist issue in the West. The wise would study Islamism, understand motives and mechanisms for spreading and find the Achilles heel of the movement, then use it against these religious extremists in the same way Islamists have used our tolerance against us. That has been our Achilles heel. Thanks for posting this discussion.

    • @arnowisp6244
      @arnowisp6244 2 месяца назад

      The West is weak and no longer believes in itself. I've seen more belief in the West from Conservative Christians than anyone else.
      You can't beat Islam if you don't believe in your own Civilization

    • @SugaryPhoenixxx
      @SugaryPhoenixxx 2 месяца назад +19

      Absolutely. This attitude of "We must have tolerance for absolutely every thing that people do in the name of expressing themselves" is driving us into the ground. It is absolute nonsense. No, we dont have to be accepting & tolerant of absolutely anything & everything. In fact, we should be cautious about what we accept & even endorse.

    • @kelvinmeneely3116
      @kelvinmeneely3116 2 месяца назад +3

      @@SugaryPhoenixxx these are great insights and must be applied to ever religion regardless.

    • @ddz1375
      @ddz1375 2 месяца назад +7

      ​@@SugaryPhoenixxxWe must retain the freedom to accept others but also not lose the freedom to reject what we find abhorrent without repercussion from the pure facsit ideal of uber acceptance at any cost.

    • @Thenoobestgirl
      @Thenoobestgirl 2 месяца назад +1

      So what IS their Achilles heel?

  • @ronmurp
    @ronmurp 2 месяца назад +25

    Islam is political by design: a system for whole life, including governance and governance. How is Islam NOT Islamism?

    • @imhoteparchitect1787
      @imhoteparchitect1787 2 месяца назад +3

      That👆

    • @mahmoodabbasi6120
      @mahmoodabbasi6120 2 месяца назад

      Islamism is a ramification of Political Islam a subset of the Divine System that is Islam.
      So it's only a small part of it.
      Islam is far greater and broader than petty things

    • @jacstvofficial4490
      @jacstvofficial4490 2 месяца назад +1

      This is what people are refusing to admit. It not a religion like others. It is political in nature.

    • @iuliaionelapetcu1411
      @iuliaionelapetcu1411 2 месяца назад

      ​@@jacstvofficial4490 Let's be honest, almost all religions are political, especially the major, abrahamic ones. Islam happens to be the most cancerous though.

    • @imhoteparchitect1787
      @imhoteparchitect1787 2 месяца назад

      @@iuliaionelapetcu1411 Yes and No, a peaceful religion like Christianity after the martyrdom of all the apostles got mixed in dirt by politicians, but Islam is something else it's designed to invade other nations for wealth and women by warmongers Arabs.

  • @mistymoor7114
    @mistymoor7114 2 месяца назад +31

    Quote at 38.26…..”all ideas fade eventually”, how many centuries of jihad have we had and of Jew hatred. And does Hamas want an agreement, really? Arabs have continually rejected a 2 state solution and Hamas pledged to repeat 10:7 again and again…..so where is there room for agreement?

  • @prof.jezebel
    @prof.jezebel 2 месяца назад +91

    40:03 (re: giving to and working with Palestinians): but the people of the kibbutzes were employing Gazans and taking them to Israeli hospitals and advocating for peace and those same Gazans used their knowledge of the kibbutz to commit a massacre, torturing, raping and killing these well-meaning Israelis. Not just Hamas but Gazan citizens too. How can a good life be an incentive to de-radicalize people who want to end lives, want to die, so they can enslave virgins after death? This isn't like the Palestinians of the West Bank fighting against the incursions and injustices of the settlers. The cruelty, the sexual violence, the hate and glee, completely sick and twisted. Something going on there beyond religious belief, oppression, etc. I really don't understand how the students can't see that they are exactly like the well-meaning people of the peace/music festival and would be violated and ended.

    • @Rojomanzana438
      @Rojomanzana438 2 месяца назад +15

      The west bank Palestinian mindset is the same as the gaza Palestinian mindset.

    • @ebrearley3134
      @ebrearley3134 2 месяца назад +10

      One of the hostages poignantly said “but I have friends here”-we don’t understand the medieval mindset

    • @eden3685
      @eden3685 2 месяца назад +12

      Many of the atrocities were committed by civilians

    • @kazsherris34
      @kazsherris34 2 месяца назад +21

      @@Rojomanzana438 That's 100% accurate and should never be fogotten. Muslims wanted Israel destroyed long before the idea of an independant 'Palestine' was ever thought of.

    • @bellyfiore1
      @bellyfiore1 2 месяца назад

      Try envy, Try brothers and sisters children marrying, 42% in the Arab world .76% in Pakistan. Try Islam. Try living in a society that spies on each other. Where you are defensive and lie to survive. Try Polygamy, brother and brother from different Mothers in hereditary competition. Welcome to failed societies, welcome to Islam.

  • @MedeaJaff
    @MedeaJaff 2 месяца назад +24

    So glad that you're interviewing Faisal, I've known him for over a decade through our shared beliefs. He's one of the few sane voices left in the mess we see around the world; I'm honoured to call him my friend ❤

    • @ca8944
      @ca8944 2 месяца назад +5

      Have you listened to Brigette, Ayaan Hirsi, Yasmine Mohammed, Glaad Saad and Apostate Prophet, David Wood and Robert Spencer? . There’s a few more but I can’t remember their names.

  • @johnricercato740
    @johnricercato740 2 месяца назад +33

    Young people are always binary thinkers, and utopians. It takes experience of life to understand how complex humankind is, and how flawed.

    • @arknabul2760
      @arknabul2760 2 месяца назад +6

      Or decent parenting.

    • @fabricliver
      @fabricliver 2 месяца назад +5

      It's all about reading A LOT of Books from as many sources as possible.
      Not that complicated. Not that hard.

    • @johnricercato740
      @johnricercato740 2 месяца назад +2

      @@fabricliver With respect, it’s not purely about reading books across a range of perspectives, important though that is. You need to live in various countries and take a real interest in people and culture.

    • @user-gd3ln4dj1c
      @user-gd3ln4dj1c 2 месяца назад +4

      I agree. Even though I was properly raised by good parents, I protested a lot in the 80s. I saw the world as pretty much black and white. I am in my 50s now, raised a child myself, and I have realized that there is an infinite amount of gray areas…

    • @user-gd3ln4dj1c
      @user-gd3ln4dj1c 2 месяца назад +1

      @@johnricercato740 maybe not live in many countries, but visit a lot of countries to meet real people there. Just traveling broadens the experience.

  • @Bethoflife
    @Bethoflife 2 месяца назад +14

    This sounds very credible to me. There's something nefarious going on
    worldwide and it's very concerning to me.

    • @lesleymaclennan7899
      @lesleymaclennan7899 2 месяца назад +4

      Ye it's all hushed tho , but we all smell something is off

  • @roxee57
    @roxee57 2 месяца назад +10

    Faisal is such a treasure. He has such an analytical mind and is often able to express insights about situations I had thought of before, including in this conversation. What a life he has lived & is living and the work his organisation is doing is a light in the world - that’s a purpose right there. I loved his comment that there’s such a thing as having too much purpose.

  • @TessaTickle
    @TessaTickle 2 месяца назад +28

    Mate, it *is* a holy war and it always was.

    • @bobby5678-ck2tc
      @bobby5678-ck2tc Месяц назад

      exactly it is a holy war and a race war and the worst part if we invited that into our own countries look at the grooming gangs all over europe and the murders and rapes torture etc this will radicalize our people just like nazi Germany and Israel right now. We will have no choice but to go back to homogenous countries that's how it works best for everyone to have their own ethno states.

  • @EllaGreenn
    @EllaGreenn 2 месяца назад +16

    Please invite this guest again very soon, this conversation was much too short. I'm very hungry to learn more from this amazing human. Thank you so much, both of you!

  • @timcowell2626
    @timcowell2626 2 месяца назад +14

    Leo Kearse did an excellent expose on the left in Iran and Mahyar Tousi has even implicated the US in the muslim over-throw of the Shah of Iran.

  • @Raven44453
    @Raven44453 2 месяца назад +24

    How do you mutually trade with a people controlled by men who live in luxury in Qatar, whos wealth depends on the conflict , they have no incentive to give that up , and others that follow them that are addicted to the power they have over the population

    • @jj-yi1ne
      @jj-yi1ne 2 месяца назад

      get on your knees and start slurping

    • @Tamara-qd5dc
      @Tamara-qd5dc 2 месяца назад

      I think the idea behind Abraham Accords was to destroy the leverage that Iran and Hamas had. If Saudis signed, Hamas would have been rendered irrelevant.

  • @LyndaHurstwaite
    @LyndaHurstwaite 2 месяца назад +11

    I lived in the states 9/11 - it was everyone together - people were queuing to give blood in the aftermath .

  • @neildunford241
    @neildunford241 2 месяца назад +24

    Interesting, Faisal essentially suggested an EU for the Middle East, to encourage commercial interdependencies. Nice theory, but Islam needs the equivalent of the reformation. Or ancient faith based issues - will always be there.

    • @fabricliver
      @fabricliver 2 месяца назад +5

      The more we feed them with capitalism and wealth, the more they will breed.
      Islam needs a radical, complete reform

    • @joesilver4376
      @joesilver4376 9 дней назад

      Most Arabs states are already super rich in oil and natural gas which the West consumes and pays for. Money os not their problem. Running a Mafia ideology is their problem.

  • @lorrainemclean3914
    @lorrainemclean3914 2 месяца назад +12

    Andrew!!! Another brilliant Heretics podcast….this is fast becoming my go to to learn/see what’s really going in. ❤

  • @Aijan100
    @Aijan100 2 месяца назад +17

    What an interesting topic. Can’t wait

    • @utopian2222
      @utopian2222 2 месяца назад

      Its not the definition of a topic, it is a fact base true evaluation of the left and Islam which has been ignored for decades, which if continued to be ignored and allowed will continue to spread like an uncurable cancer in our culture leading to civil unrest..

  • @LyndaHurstwaite
    @LyndaHurstwaite 2 месяца назад +15

    When billionaires want to inflict their “ great ideas “ on the world - it’s a real worry .

    • @Thenoobestgirl
      @Thenoobestgirl 2 месяца назад

      Unless they're like Bill Gates who did a whole lot of good in the world and especially in 3rd world countries

    • @LyndaHurstwaite
      @LyndaHurstwaite День назад

      @@Thenoobestgirl ♥️🤣🤣

  • @melcraig9855
    @melcraig9855 2 месяца назад +20

    The Iraq regime he describes sounds a lot like the beginning of the Nazi regime. Ratting out neighbors, don’t speak the truth or your (opposing) opinion… scary.

    • @fabricliver
      @fabricliver 2 месяца назад +3

      More like communism

  • @DanielMacAndrew
    @DanielMacAndrew 2 месяца назад +12

    Andrew is doing the essential work that his hero Louis Theroux refuses to. Louis considers the investigation of the extreme left "unhelpful ". Very sad.

  • @kimsmith8972
    @kimsmith8972 2 месяца назад +57

    We would not allow any country to interfere in our war, I think we owe the same respect to Israel. They were attacked.

    • @user-xc6wd3hb4s
      @user-xc6wd3hb4s 2 месяца назад

      No, they have illegally occupied Palestine for decades, they have continued to murder Palestinians and steal their land for "settlers". The Palestinians finally resisted.

    • @jj-yi1ne
      @jj-yi1ne 2 месяца назад +1

      israel is not america

    • @MattieShiloh
      @MattieShiloh 2 месяца назад +8

      @@jj-yi1neso they shouldn’t have a right to defend themselves against Islamist terror?

  • @tomsmith6882
    @tomsmith6882 2 месяца назад +11

    Read a book a couple years back that quotes MBS of Saudi speaking about the Qataris: “their plan appears to be making sure they have their throats slit last” seems relevant to this video…

    • @tumslucks9781
      @tumslucks9781 2 месяца назад

      Mohammed Bone Saw is a genocidal maniac who murders journalists, political dissidents and starving women and children in Yemen like Satanyahu murders women and children in Gaza.
      Mohammed Bone Saw and Satanyahu are very chummy indeed!

  • @TheContrariann
    @TheContrariann 2 месяца назад +6

    Extremely Important Podcast All of West needs to watch👏

  • @liamhenderson3753
    @liamhenderson3753 2 месяца назад +9

    Radical thinking spreads so fast because of its simplicity. Much easier to see everything as oppressor/oppressed than to actually gain a deep understanding of things. Couple that fact with unbridled publishing (social media) and there you have it.

  • @nba25678
    @nba25678 2 месяца назад +19

    Biggest load of nonsense when your guest talks about Israel going against the trend in the region by going right wing and countries like Saudi Arabia are going left! Israel is a liberal democracy with a robust judiciary, proportional representation with a parliament that has representation from all communities including Arab and conservative religious Jews but the bulk of the population is not right wing! It’s a small element within a coalition government that is religious and right wing. Unfortunately they do have more power than they should because it’s a proportional democracy and that’s how democracies work. Israel is surrounded by tyrannical regimes where its population have no rights. The fact that Saudi is finally allowing basic rights like women being permitted to leave their homes without a chaperone is a step in the right direction but they’ve got a looong way to go! Surprised the host did not push back on this.

    • @Thenoobestgirl
      @Thenoobestgirl 2 месяца назад

      Israelis have gone further right than ever (including far leftists) because of the October 7th attack

  • @metgirl5429
    @metgirl5429 2 месяца назад +12

    Checked my phone at 3.30 am
    Will need strong coffee in a few hours
    Love your work🕊
    This is going to be good

  • @grauenritter9220
    @grauenritter9220 2 месяца назад +18

    the part of the timeline you miss is that it was OBAMA 2012 who SPECIFICALLY made the "Minority" coalition thing explicit.

  • @narapetrovic74
    @narapetrovic74 2 месяца назад +9

    Qualified conversations about the Middle East and islamic countries are crucial these days! I'm following closely whatever goes on in Islam lately. It is where major shifts are happening and the therein heresy is taking a hugely important role.

  • @rivka8576
    @rivka8576 2 месяца назад +24

    Tbh there was a lot of misinformation about Israel here. Firstly even secular Jews in Israel have 4+ children. The reason people are voting more right wing is because of things like October 7th- I mean, realistically, which way would you vote if you were attacked like that? Would you vote for the people promising protection or not? Netanyahu is also not a religious leader- he's secular and centre right. I also don't expect he'll win the next election- but it's likely to be someone else who promises strength- and that's not going to be inherently different whether they're right or left wing. The problem is obsessing over the left/right divide, because in Israel, and in many other places I'm sure, you can be left wing and religious. Also Israel still has a lot of socialist policies, regardless of whether you vote right or left wing.

    • @Thenoobestgirl
      @Thenoobestgirl 2 месяца назад

      I can't think of a single secular family that has over 4 children

    • @Thenoobestgirl
      @Thenoobestgirl 2 месяца назад +1

      (that I personally know of)

  • @grimmlight4541
    @grimmlight4541 2 месяца назад +3

    Islam is our greatest threat currently. We may have to yet again. Defend ourselves as we did with the crusades.

  • @anonony9081
    @anonony9081 2 месяца назад +7

    Wow this channel is killing it. Great interviews

    • @jj-yi1ne
      @jj-yi1ne 2 месяца назад

      it also killed your pus

  • @DrJackJeckyl
    @DrJackJeckyl 2 месяца назад +15

    Best video ever

  • @user-bm7en1lh8d
    @user-bm7en1lh8d 2 месяца назад +3

    This has been the most informative, but oh, so scary one yet. Fantastic

  • @FallenRobot
    @FallenRobot 2 месяца назад +6

    What a nice, intelligent thoughtful guy Faisal is, great interview.

  • @kenmonk3668
    @kenmonk3668 2 месяца назад +3

    Yes. We have failed miserably to convey to the young about the importance of freedom. Why should they question it, because they have it. The young always seem to need a cause. We are giving them some, so it’s not going to play out well I’m afraid. 🇦🇺

  • @doctorwoohoo1152
    @doctorwoohoo1152 2 месяца назад +13

    Let's goooo!

    • @jj-yi1ne
      @jj-yi1ne 2 месяца назад

      lets goo put some wet moist balls in your mouth

  • @NeraBuffy
    @NeraBuffy 2 месяца назад +15

    In anthropology among resource methods described such as agrarian, urban, horticultural there is a form of cultural adaptation called trade and raid. For example raid free inernationalaid and sell it to your own people. Also explains a unique institution like Palestinian Authority Martyrs Fund. There's literally oil and gas reserves under gaza that they were free to develop. There are ancient societies still existing today in which lying and stealing are skills not vices and hard work is only understood as something umake others do as punishment and sign of power over them. They are literally such group. Begging is above work in that world. Why else do arabs always always rule their own with an iron fist and pay dearly when they don't.

  • @zeromarker
    @zeromarker 2 месяца назад +4

    The biggest mistake people do about Israeli politics is thinking Bibi is far right. He is not.

    • @abupinhus
      @abupinhus 2 месяца назад

      Absolutly, he is centrist or just slightly right of center. Of course, all radical leftist call anyone right of them a radical far right!

  • @RhiannonSenpai
    @RhiannonSenpai 2 месяца назад +17

    3:35 Austro-Hungarian Empire, there was never a Hungarian Empire by itself, without the Austrians, the Hungarians would have stayed a tiny kingdom in Central Europe.

    • @DK-nh4bc
      @DK-nh4bc 2 месяца назад

      You are right about the Austro-Hungarian Empire, that was one of the mistakes this guest made. On the other hand, although the Habsburgs were the ruling dynasty, the Hungarian kingdom was much bigger than the Austrian territories.

    • @RhiannonSenpai
      @RhiannonSenpai 2 месяца назад

      @@DK-nh4bc No, without Transylvania, the Hungarian Kingdom was much smaller. Transylvania became a Principality, apart from the Hungarian Kingdom.

  • @281992pdr
    @281992pdr 2 месяца назад +5

    This bloke has nailed it. A great analysis. Thanks. (NB: The country is Colombia - with an 'o' - and the university is Columbia - with a 'u'.)

  • @yaisit2
    @yaisit2 2 месяца назад +7

    The discussion and understanding of Israeli right wing politics is pretty shallow. Does Andrew know that some of the haredi parties (hassidisch is not really the right word to use) supported the idea of land for peace when they thought it might save lives. And Netenyahu is not far right by any means. I'd encourage Andrew to do a bit more research into Israeli politics

  • @marianlonge3060
    @marianlonge3060 2 месяца назад +4

    How correct is this lovely guest ..

  • @limop20
    @limop20 2 месяца назад +1

    such a grim outlook. The entire situation is absolutely desperate all over the western civilization

  • @sn4rff
    @sn4rff 2 месяца назад +3

    always interested to watch your videos, thanks.

  • @freyagoldilocks
    @freyagoldilocks 2 месяца назад +5

    Lot of Iranians desperate to be heard! My Aunt and Uncle went round Iran and said the people were lovely and country beautiful! Such a shame!

  • @kalankaneni
    @kalankaneni 2 месяца назад +1

    Such an eye opening conversation
    Thank you

  • @thunderstreet78
    @thunderstreet78 2 месяца назад +1

    Fantastic conversation. Thank you both.

  • @gisselleivancovsky2453
    @gisselleivancovsky2453 2 месяца назад +6

    It was a great talk, just wanted to make a point about Israeli politics and demography that I dont think were accurate, the majority of Israelis are secular and still vote right, it's not about religion, you can be a right wing person with liberal views, the extreme right is reletivly small portion, they seem bigger because of the coalition system we have.

  • @silenzioaffogato
    @silenzioaffogato 2 месяца назад +3

    Hi Andrew, please do invite Iranian, Iraqi, Lebanese, and African and etc intellectuals to have a dialogue and work on making peace among all people of the world, and start with Middle East.

  • @waynemcauliffe-fv5yf
    @waynemcauliffe-fv5yf 2 месяца назад +8

    Glad i`m a working class old bogan Aussie

  • @oldtrowt
    @oldtrowt 2 месяца назад +2

    Love the way this guy thinks. Great conversation.

  • @jwsuicides8095
    @jwsuicides8095 2 месяца назад +1

    Such an informative discussion. Faisal expressed thoughts that I've had put he put them together with such clarity and, of course, sharing his direct knowledge. Thank you, gentlemen.
    Greetings to Mrs Andrew!
    🍷🍷

  • @moonbeep641
    @moonbeep641 2 месяца назад +12

    There should be an absolute separation of State and Religion in all countries. The minute any politician invokes "god" or religious beliefs, they definitely lose my vote.

    • @Rex_Racer
      @Rex_Racer 2 месяца назад +5

      The US was founded by people that spoke of God consistently and in the founding documents. Not all religions are created equally.

    • @pendejo69
      @pendejo69 2 месяца назад

      @@Rex_Racer USA is a swamp.

    • @briancox9357
      @briancox9357 2 месяца назад

      The US is hardly perfect. God probably doesn't exist

    • @LisaBeta-42
      @LisaBeta-42 2 месяца назад +6

      Politicians should read about the 10 commandments, that exist in all 3 monotheistic religions - especially about NOT killing other people or robbing and raping (not allowed).
      And how come YOUR own agenda is more important than the laws GOD gave us? Even if you do not believe in the God everybody speaks of - the laws attributed to him are still sound and should be respected, to give all around us a good life - free of violence, if possible- The Golden Rule: treat others, as you want to be treated yourself by them😇

    • @commentarytalk1446
      @commentarytalk1446 2 месяца назад

      You say that but look at Science misused as Pseudo-Religion today. The more fundamental problem? Is Centralization of Power in the hands of a few over the many. Do note in the West with Woke, it's the creation of "Western Secular Religion" in place of Traditional Religion!

  • @kimsmith8972
    @kimsmith8972 2 месяца назад +8

    You must have legal immigration but I am against the invasion of people from all over the world with different cultures, different languages, and we had know idea of their background. I had a housekeeper from Mexico and came here legally. She and her family are very unhappy that Biden is allowing all the illegal in.

    • @peteralbrecht473
      @peteralbrecht473 2 месяца назад

      Why does everybody in the west maintain you must have immigration? Most nations around the world believe there should not be immigration. Time to rethink.

  • @dollylove3430
    @dollylove3430 2 месяца назад +1

    This was so good. Thank you🙏💕

  • @thesebone5
    @thesebone5 2 месяца назад +4

    Faisal!! ❤️❤️

  • @iangatere6459
    @iangatere6459 2 месяца назад +1

    Very informative guest, with such astute judgment. Doing good work too.

  • @maviragutt
    @maviragutt Месяц назад

    He is showing an amazing and awe approach and is showing us that we lean more towards the dark side of the problem because the environment does not look so great.

  • @Mrs.CGraves
    @Mrs.CGraves 2 месяца назад +2

    When Sadaam killed the “traitors”
    The WORST was the people clapping because they Co-Sign that the uncontrolled Power Structures are Ok.
    They are not.
    Perfect example is a Church Congregation clapping for Sin.
    We have to hold our own hearts to account daily to not ever get to that point.

  • @unravel3416
    @unravel3416 2 месяца назад

    This was Another excellent show. Thanks so much for your interesting views and points to both Host and guest. Binged a few of these now, Subbed.

  • @user-sc5xu6hc1n
    @user-sc5xu6hc1n 2 месяца назад +3

    Naive youths with a saviour mentality.
    But not knowing or researching history is just plain ignorance. One would wish that students at University would be better informed.
    Lots are in their " safe " echo chambers.

  • @insouciantme6015
    @insouciantme6015 2 месяца назад +3

    The "To do-list" of the islamists is long

  • @wade2bosh
    @wade2bosh 2 месяца назад +14

    Islamism is what mo created in Medina

    • @michellemooresings
      @michellemooresings 2 месяца назад +1

      It truly became the world's most dangerous faction of Islam.

    • @user-fq5px2yy4l
      @user-fq5px2yy4l 2 месяца назад +4

      Exactly, Meccan period he was ok, Medinian period he was spurred by resentment, bitterness, power hungry, anger. The law of abrogation means that “true Muslims” who accept the Quran as the word of god (which is a promise when one “reverts” - everyone is born Muslim they just go astray- hence the word revert rather than convert) , have to take Medinian period to be more accurate over the contradicting Suryas from the earlier Meccan. Hence jihadist are taking things logically and sincerely:
      I actually find it astonishing that it is even allowed as a book it is that violent towards specific groups …

    • @michellemooresings
      @michellemooresings 2 месяца назад +1

      @@user-fq5px2yy4l that's interesting. I agree, it's shocking that some of it is allowed.

    • @ksmax6310
      @ksmax6310 2 месяца назад +3

      it is a cult

    • @user-fq5px2yy4l
      @user-fq5px2yy4l 2 месяца назад

      @@ksmax6310 a cult of death

  • @nannyplum0194
    @nannyplum0194 13 дней назад +1

    Blind them with science ....
    Baffle them with BS...

  • @EsseQuamViderity
    @EsseQuamViderity 2 месяца назад +7

    Having kids is not “scary.” Just because you’re a weak man doesn’t mean everyone else has to be.

  • @joanr3189
    @joanr3189 2 месяца назад

    This is a worthwhile talk. The guest explains the subject of Islam and its complexity.

  • @LyndaHurstwaite
    @LyndaHurstwaite 2 месяца назад +1

    I always teach my kids to question everything ; even me . Doesn’t go well sometimes but at least they have their own mind .

  • @LyndaHurstwaite
    @LyndaHurstwaite 2 месяца назад +2

    Not many conservative professors

  • @MattHunX
    @MattHunX 2 месяца назад +1

    When I was still deeper in the whole science vs. religion debate world, I recall watching a documentary, about how young guys, in the UK, got radicalized - not just in Islam, but INTO the islamic faith itself, joining it out of a sense of belonging, male empowerment, masculinity, wanting to feel more like men (or their idea of it), some of them having had misogynistic views, to begin with. And I cannot help but wonder, how a lot of young men, TODAY, can find belonging and empowerment in masculinity, when many are likely hearing it's toxic, all the time, and how certain (overly) liberal ideas, taken to their extreme form, may be downright emasculating to them, and how that can push them in an equally undesirable direction, maybe as far as getting radicalized by and into a religious faith that gives them more of a semblance of power than they feel like they're getting in their life. I wonder if there's the danger of that. Like the imam trying to hook you is an (even more) extreme version of Andrew Tate and the kind of masculinity he's pushing jives with you. Jordan Peterson had some thoughts on 'him.'

  • @MegaMARLEEN1
    @MegaMARLEEN1 2 месяца назад

    Wow wonderful.
    This interview gave me a live feeling of the atmosphere of what might've been happening inside this authoritarian regime of Sadan Hussein. I felt a lot of fear and confusion. It's such a pitty that, after he was removed, (killed), a chaos brake loose. And i think with that a lot of precious history books and monuments got destroyed.😢
    Hope one day this country can also function in a modern and effective way. Maybe it is already, i don't know.
    Good insight in other subjects too. A moderate voice for the middle east.

  • @Uncivilize
    @Uncivilize 2 месяца назад

    Excellent. Thank you.

  • @ddh9308
    @ddh9308 2 месяца назад +4

    Egypt, AUE, Jordan's (all ME) most populations have deeply old school behavioral patterns and are deeply religious. Pragmatic to whome, to what? They say or practice to their own people something different than what is said to the West.... Openly criticism or secularism isn't allowed. All are ruled by dictators.
    Let them in the ME first change school books' content and the context said in mosques which concern jews and israel. Let them first bring some 'enlightment' to it all 😉 (which the West is losing nowadays too😒) How about that???

  • @karenrobertson1673
    @karenrobertson1673 2 месяца назад +3

    Yes it would be great if secular society had more kids.

  • @michellemooresings
    @michellemooresings 2 месяца назад +5

    Hey. My husband worked Counterterrorism. There were weapons.....

    • @jj-yi1ne
      @jj-yi1ne 2 месяца назад

      your husband buttfucked ppl

  • @mattanderson6672
    @mattanderson6672 2 месяца назад

    Brilliant discussion, thank you

  • @katherinecollins4685
    @katherinecollins4685 Месяц назад

    Enjoyed this

  • @rachelbuzaglo904
    @rachelbuzaglo904 2 месяца назад +6

    Andrew you are wrong about Israel! I am from Israel and totally not religious and not radical right,you are right about Bibi,BUT you don’t live here,and we will not forget Bibi his grates failure in the history of Israel,you forgot what was in Israel before 07.10. There was protests every day,l think we are the only state that the left didn’t “awake” .we will never let anyone to kill our democracy.so please ,you can be sure that you and your family can get in here. Bibi will not be p.m never never again.

    • @ca8944
      @ca8944 2 месяца назад

      If you guys would’ve listened to the right, there probably wouldn’t have been an attack.

    • @juniusvindex769
      @juniusvindex769 2 месяца назад

      As an atheist myself, I agree. Andrew has these guests on for confrontation. To me all religion is division.
      I care nothing of Israel or Palestine, were you worried in Israel about the segregation of Ulster?? No. And many share the same about Israel. It's not our fight .

  • @jessicapickle680
    @jessicapickle680 14 дней назад

    I had previously read the book The Achilles Trap by Steve Coll that Faisal references in the interview. It is a very informative book which I do recommend.

  • @SALS-rf9yy
    @SALS-rf9yy 2 месяца назад +4

    So happy you interviewed him . Faisal is such a genuine guy

  • @cantthinkofaname750
    @cantthinkofaname750 2 месяца назад +1

    It’s funny when I see protests against school boards and gender ideology in classrooms and it’s full of Muslim parents.

  • @menid2691
    @menid2691 2 месяца назад +1

    What a great conversation, I learned so much. I would just like to correct a common misconception about Israeli politics and the right in general. The left did a good job at taking the term right wing and turning it into something bad, when it's actually just a different way of viewing the economy and the level of government involvement. Netanyahu is right wing because he believes in capitalism and open markets, he's not extreme and he's not religious. The religious parties usually just want more benefits for their public and they have participated in all governments whether they're left or right. Then we have the far right parties like Ben Gvir's but that guy is mostly talk and because of the strong democracy there's very little he can do without getting agreement from the Knesset and approval from the supreme court

  • @lawrencefrost9063
    @lawrencefrost9063 2 месяца назад

    Amazing man, I have been following him since 2012 or something. I know him because of Hitchens. Hitchens was the greatest heretic of all time the goat

  • @PecosChico
    @PecosChico 2 месяца назад +1

    They made a hypocritical pact with the North Vietnamese Army and Viet Cong. Why not radical Islam?

  • @miiriinada7193
    @miiriinada7193 2 месяца назад +1

    For the students destroying properties, you send them the bill. That will educate them.

  • @Tony-1971
    @Tony-1971 2 месяца назад +6

    💯👍🏻

  • @mesmarriott127
    @mesmarriott127 2 месяца назад

    Excellent video.