I started working in IT in 1999 and the IT workforce at my company was 95% American. That same year my father saw an article in the Wall Street Journal saying they were training people in India to do this work. Now they are more than 50% of the IT workforce at my company. This was planned a long time ago. And to say Americans are not willing to train for these job is a joke and a lie. This is all about cheaper labor. At the same time pulling the rug out on Americans.
Dude, pay attention. These are specialized skills. These are specialized skills in stem, quantum computing/AI. Jesus, You probably don’t even know what that term means.These people make no less than 300k a year. You need to pay attention to what he said. What he’s saying is MAGA Americans are too stupid and unqualified for these jobs. You get what you voted for.
BLAME MEDIA AND FAR RIGHT FAR LEFT MEDIA THAT CONTINUES TO DIVIDE EVERYDAY AMERICANS INTO HATING THEMSELVES, WHILE STAYING BROKE, OR FOCUSING ON PARTYING AND DOING DRUGS. WHILE VISA HOLDERS COME HERE TO THE USA FROM INDIA and ASIA, OWN HOMES, BUY NICE CARS, LAUGH AT DUMB AMERICANS. TRUMPY WAS SUPOSED TO FIX THIS, BY AMERICA FIRST, TRAINING AMERICANS TECH JOBS, NOW SOME IN TRUMPs CABINET WANTS TO REMOVE RESTRICTIONS ON VISA, THEN REPLACE US WITH PEOPLE FROM INDIA? 🤣DUMB VOTERS.
I used to live in Redmond, Washington where Microsoft headquarters is located, T-mobile and others. That area is dominated by Indians with visas who get hired over Americans because it's cheaper to hire and pay them instead.
Two druggies from Redmond Washington were robbing a woman in san Francisco in 2005 and killed a family member, they are out of prison now living in redmond
if theyre offering for a position then how is it cheaper to hire them? did they agree to work for cheaper or they just offered them less? do they treat a visa like an internship? another practice that needs to stop.. hey what about paying your workers remember when that was a thing?
This country has laid off hundreds of thousands of smart American people over the last two years. While these individuals could be rehired, Silicon Valley corporations choose not to hire them because it would require paying top dollar. Instead, they prefer to hire non-American workers on H-1B visas, paying them 50% less, including reduced medical benefits and other compensation.
The visa beneficiary is also bound to that company as the company holds the visa. If they quit, they’re sent home. Which means employers can treat them however they want.
Story goes that there were just hired at inflated salaries anticipating work and once the bubble burst they were let go.. This is plain irresponsible capitalism. First hire with inflated salaries ..give them no work and then ask them to leave..How does one even begin to solve this ? Pray everyone finds work.
It's really not a far right issue. Americans are simply concerned that large-scale illegal immigration will be replaced by large scale legal migration, and all the jobs will be taken away from Americans who live here.
Resentment towards minorities and DEI distracts from the reality that this is a class issue. Migrant workers are mistreated and American workers get sidelined.
@@zantiagotron07That’s not true. It’s not about hard work, it’s about wage depression for big corporations. You’re talking about the country that invented much of the modern world, now you’re trying to say that same country doesn’t work hard?
Get rid of visa program. We have thousands of engineers graduating every year and most can't get a job because of visa students who are hired and paid less. No, they are not better than American students.
Problem is the American engineers are products of yt privledge and expect things given to them, so of course the visa students will be willing to do more for less and work harder
@@flintfuentes7652 You're advocating for replacing American workers with indentured servants to destroy our labor market and turn our working class into a poor country's like India or Brazil.
It boils down to work ethics. Americans are not as ethical as they used to be and you can thank the unions for that. They made it common place by not letting companies fire bad employees. That resulted in the "Made in America" branding being recognized as junk. Sadly, it was Bill Clinton that save American corporations by enacting NAFTA. That allowed them to move shop over seas to escape the unions. Now we are back at a turning point where history could repeat itself if we don't correct the base problem "work ethics" which should be taught in schools like it used to be back after WW2.
BLAME MEDIA AND FAR RIGHT FAR LEFT MEDIA THAT CONTINUES TO DIVIDE EVERYDAY AMERICANS INTO HATING THEMSELVES, WHILE STAYING BROKE, OR FOCUSING ON PARTYING AND DOING DRUGS. WHILE VISA HOLDERS COME HERE TO THE USA FROM INDIA and ASIA, OWN HOMES, BUY NICE CARS, LAUGH AT DUMB AMERICANS. TRUMPY WAS SUPOSED TO FIX THIS, BY AMERICA FIRST, TRAINING AMERICANS TECH JOBS, NOW SOME IN TRUMPs CABINET WANTS TO REMOVE RESTRICTIONS ON VISA, THEN REPLACE US WITH PEOPLE FROM INDIA? 🤣DUMB VOTERS.
it's not whether to give to amercians, its literally because there is a vacuum of talent. America has been built on immigrant talent. this whole argument is outrageous
Incorrect. They can't find jobs because most degrees are useless. Yet, they refuse to take lower payer or less prestigious jobs because they have a "degree"
Lets train our own people!!! We need jobs too. When the foreigners get to middle management they only hire other foreigners & our graduates can't get jobs & then they have a huge loan to pay back !!!
EXACTLY. WHILE VISA HOLDERS COME HERE TO THE USA FROM INDIA and ASIA, OWN HOMES, BUY NICE CARS, LAUGH AT DUMB AMERICANS. TRUMPY WAS SUPOSED TO FIX THIS, BY AMERICA FIRST, TRAINING AMERICANS TECH JOBS, NOW SOME IN TRUMPs CABINET WANTS TO REMOVE RESTRICTIONS ON VISA, THEN REPLACE US WITH PEOPLE FROM INDIA? 🤣DUMB VOTERS WE ARE. TIME FOR TRUMPY TO SHOW LOYALTY AND FIRE THES INSIDER INDIANS IN HIS CABINET, REPLACE THEM WITH REAL WHITE , BLAK , BROWN AMERICANS,, IF THIS IS REALLY AMERICA FIRST? OR SOME SHAM SHOW FOR THE RICH , WHILE WE STAY BROKE AGAIN....
H1B's come here taking engineering and programming jobs that American kids pay a lot of money to become engineers and programmers, only to find they are getting passed over. Many H1B's have their educations paid for and are not saddled with the college debt that US students have coming out of college. US mid-level tech workers are getting pushed out and being replaced by H1B's, who are not top performers, refuse to assimilate, lack managerial skills and are incapable of thinking out of the box. American business is morphing into the caste system that exists in India.
I am american born citizen. I have a master's degree. I have engineered software. I can't even get a response from my job applications tbh. I won't make play a victim. I acknowledge that other jobs can be just as valuable and meaningfully but let's be real... As Americans we were promised that if we go to college, try hard, do what's right, we would have access to community and opportunity, I don't think that these immigrants - Elon and Vivek - actually have any idea what solidarity with your country men actually looks like. But boy was american charmed by them this election cycle. Sad. I hope trump makes the right call.
Because the one who is reviewing your resume has a 90% chance being Indian, so is the manager at that department, and so is 90% of the co-workers. There has been a sick infatuation for Indians since the late 90s. It never ended.
What happened to America first? So many unemployed Americans who want a job in their related field of study for someone miles away to get the job first. This is just corporate greed and their desire to pay someone cheaper for the same job.
Elon wants cheap labor and workers he can work long hours or work whenever Elon wants them to work. We have a lot of smart high American tech workers now and many of them are laid off. Elon just doesn’t want to pay them a fair salary.
There are barely any smart American tech workers compared to how many you can get from abroad. It doesn't make sense how a construction worker is afraid that a software developer making $300k+ is gonna take their jobs. You can blame liberals, and those that control mainstream American culture (Hollywood folks) for making Americans think that doing nothing and eating cheeseburgers all day is okay.
He did fire almost everyone from twitter 1 year back and make the existing employees sleep in offices. I think finally get it..All those twitter employees unfairly laid off by Elon must be behind this current uproar. This really nothing to do with H1b actually..because everyone will refuse to work under inhuman conditions. There must be a law against people who lay off workers unfairly. Last year's argument was that Big tech over hired and Elon was trying to demo how one can run a lean and mean tech machine with handful of team members. Boy this is gonna blow up beyond crazy. Is this how govt officials should behave ? Do they have nothing better to do ??
So let me get this straight, thousands of American students graduate every year as engineers, scientist, doctors, techs etc... from all over the US yet its not enough to fill in the labor gap? They act like there's only 10 universities. Lets be real its all about money where an H-1B visa person will be accept and be paid a lot less than an American. On the other hand for once I actually agree with that loon MTG.
H1B’s get paid out compared to Americans. Lmao Americans cry for days off, they’re lazy, and inefficient. Immigrants outwork them everytime. Also, Americans are severely uneducated. Cry about it. This is why America stopped hiring Americans for producing chips, they suck and now we outsource to Taiwan. Americans are only good at making steel and war
No it is not enough, do you know how drastically is a shortage in United States on Doctors, engineers, programmers, etc? You are talking about a nation of almost half a billion people
If you’re an engineer from another country, be in your country and make it better with your skills. Bottom line, if you’re an American company, doing American business, hire American and Pay them.
The last comment by Marjorie Taylor Greene was absolutely dead on. Young people are more worried about getting a video they made to go viral and be the next social media star and strike it rich. It’s like the gold rush days, only this time people are betting it all on becoming social media famous. American born individuals are lazy, compared to immigrants. Immigrant workers go above and beyond in pretty much any service, of course there are exceptions, but Americans are entitled, and act like they are doing you a favor by doing their job. I would rather someone who’s humble and hard working help me, I will be happy to increase my tip for better service every time.
January 29, 2024: "I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I've been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It's a great programme”. D.J Trump
The idea that having a problem with this is a “far right” idea does nothing but shut down the conversation. This should be a non-partisan issue. We have plenty of people here already, we don’t need any more. Why don’t we give those jobs to Americans. This is about importing cheap labor.
Because we shouldn't "give away jobs"-due to quotas and affirmative action or location (where one was born). We should look for the best and brightest and let those people EARN their jobs. In USA we should look beyond the color and or nationality.
@@johnmguzman7491Ridiculous argument and ignores all the negative impacts for Americans. You realize this is wage suppression right? This is rigging capitalism against the worker while big corporations inherit no risk. They seek to outsource because it means they don’t have to pay FAIR wages or invest domestically. Saying “we should look past color” is you trying to make up something that wasn’t the argument to begin with. This is an economic issue, nothing to do with skin color.
January 29, 2024: "I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I've been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It's a great programme”. D.J Trump
Government should impose higher taxes on those companies who hire foreign workers on very low salary and save huge money. Government needs money to run the economy and get rid of all debt.
It's an ongoing process, and it seems the cult of personality peoples true colors are coming to light. And so they should be discarded as soon as possible.
Maybe India should include patriotism in their highly skilled curriculum..so their super intelligent grads will stay there and help their country get better..teach them to love their country more and apply their education so India won’t be a 3rd world country anymore..
The only truly Elon creation we have is the Cybertruck, which is a disaster of a vehicle and product. He's a hack who just buys his resume bullet points
These folks are taken American jobs and the government brings them in!!! From mostly India. Wonder why our customer service industry has eroded??? Because we can’t understand them!
A lot of those customer service centers are wired directly to India. E.g., they are outsourced. Those are not H1B visa holders, those are Indians IN INDIA, working for US corporations. So then, how do you stop the outsourcing? More regulation? Because free market dictates more profit, and an Indian in India will be 2-3x cheaper than even an Indian in US with H1B.
It is quite insulting that two men who never shed any blood for this country and have benefited greatly from those who did can flippantly tell Americans that they aren't smart enough or good enough to work in their tech companies.
How is importing workers "making America great again"? Shouldn't we as parents, teachers and business owners be providing strong incentives to our young to pursue science and engineering degrees along with learning a trade. Giving up on American youth in favor of importing foreigners is not MAGA.
@NS-ju7vz Uh, excuse me but we are divided on this issue. Read the comments. Our side can be divided because unlike your side, which only thinks what you are told to think, we think for ourselves. Troll. If you'd start thinking for yourself, you could probably think up better ways to spend your spare time besides trolling for the sole purpose of starting 💩.
The US does have plenty of STEM graduates. Big surprise billionaires don’t wanna pay our graduates a wage that enables kids to live and pay student loans. Since other countries pay for uni foreign workers are cheaper.
Resisting unlimited remigration is not a far right position, its centrist. We've seen whats happening to Cananda, Britain, France, Germany, Sweden, Australia etc etc etc and we are NOT having it here. Every nation must have a homeland, do not let them take yours.
How different is this than Walmart paying below living wage and receiving government subsidies? SpaceX, Tesela ....etc. gets billions in government contracts. .... All the while people are not paid what they are worth, whatever their skill set.... Cheaper foreign labor = bigger bottom line. Billionaires become Trillionaires. Same old shell game, it's no different.
I'm sorry this is BS I know so many people who graduated with computer science degrees and stuff that can't get jobs in this country. And then they hire some Indian guy with a Visa who's willing to do anything anytime it's total BS it's about control
The tech job market cooled off in early 2024, in part due to inflation and rising interest rates. Our 2024 job report found that it was harder to find a job in 2024 compared to recent years. Job postings fell 15% at the end of 2023. In 2022, there were about 1 job for every 1 job seeker.
According to estimates from Newsom's office, Tesla has received "more than $3.2 billion worth of direct and indirect California subsidies and market mechanisms since 2009."
You believe Newsom’s office? California ain’t doin too good right now, but that sure isn’t Tesla’s fault. Talk to your governor. He does the math for California, not Tesla!
He didn't want those tax credits he's said it multiple times. Blame politicoan Newsome for that government policy not the entrepreneur who made America much much richer.
STOP H-1B's and get our own youth/people educated for these roles and THAT will tremendously help MAGA. STOP ALLOWING cheaper imported labor and give the jobs to American citizens.
Their argument is that we don’t have enough talent, but they also want to get rid of the Department of Education. Why not invest in education instead, especially STEM programs? Are we going to throw the towel and rely on India going forward? We need complete overhaul of our education system.
Are they not aware a bachelors degree in most cities is $50k-$60k? This doesn’t include interest on the loan & excessive fees…. $50k-$60k isn’t the norm in other countries. How is this fair for Americans?
January 29, 2024: "I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I've been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It's a great programme”. D.J Trump
No, Elon Musk was not a H1-B visa worker. He's a South African born Canadian-American entrepreneur who moved to the United States on an F-1 visa for education and later became a U.S. citizen. Ahmed Banafa ,SJSU Engineering Lecturer is either ignorant or lying if he teaches Musk is a product of a H1-B visa . He just proved he is not needed. An estimated 4.21 million people graduated from American universities in 2023 alone, in all shades of brown. Yes, there are enough American grads to fill tech positions in the U.S.
Elon could care less about background in education. He's all about thinking outside the box. He believes those degrees are worthless in the real world unless they yield results prior to the hiring fase
Most software "engineers" don't even need any advanced knowledge of science, technology, or math. Just be logical and know how to write code. I worked with a company once that was majority H1B. They just wrote Java code to interact with oracle database and submit claims to insurance companies. The right person doesn't even need a 4 year degree to do this sort of work
And here everyone was falling all over themselves for that Ramaswamy guy and how perfect he was! Right they only want to take over! Packem up and send them home!
@haribhanujan8575 Musk wants unrestricted H1B visa immigrants from India. That is not what Trump promised. He lied to Maga to help his billionaire pals.
I'm in stem and an american citizen. Its been hard finding a tech job and I have experience. Americans should have the oppurtunity to work in stem first before anyone else!!
@@truthhurtsohwell05 STEM doesn’t always mean computers. And even if it did in this case, in American universities you’ll learn more than one programming language.
I've worked with, interviewed, and hired many professionals needing Visa sponsorship. It's a fallacy to believe a large proportion of H1B visa holders are harder working, better trained, or higher skilled than US born counterparts. There is a lot of dishonesty in applications and interviews. And well-rounded professional skillsets- including soft skills- are needed for an organization to be productive, which are sometimes lacking in H1B applicants. Not saying there shouldn't be any, or that there aren't many Visa holders that are valuable professionals. But people are raising a straw man argument.
As an American master of mathematics student with experience and certifications in machine learning, reinforcement learning, and research in partial differential equations and graph theory, I am currently pursuing studies in quantum mechanics. Given that I am American, I would like to be prioritized over those of other countries.
This is all ridiculous. I've been in tech 22 years and there is no shortage of young American comp sci / math grads. Our schools are the global benchmark and are flooded with mostly Indian students for that reason. There is NO set of "special skills" that H1B workers possess, I have managed large H1B teams and would obviously know that. At my last position in NYC there were approx 10 H1B's for every American. They are also hired in batches as high as 400-500 and employers simply trust the giant outsourcing firms like Tata to verify education and skill sets. Not taking sides but those are facts.
@@ihorperec4990It's not xenophobia though? Not wanting to expand an already very lenient visa program for what's obviously an attempt at cheap labor is that far right of an idea? Is it so radical to think companies should focus on hiring domestically rather than import cheap labor?
I got news for you, he ain't American. He is in it for himself and only himself, and this is what you voted for. We warned you, but you wouldn't listen. Now we all get to live with your mistake.
Weird to frame it as "clashing with the far right." From what i can tell, people across the political spectrum are "clashing" with Musk and Vivek on this.
@@Marcelo-rv7rnDid the left support Elon? Or was it the right that supported Musk and Trump? Oh yeah, it was the right. And now y'all are surprised than an immigrant worth almost half a trillion dollars doesn't about the American people. The rest of us saw this coming a mile away. If this move surprises you, then clearly you haven't been paying attention. And you're the ones to blame.
There has already been quite a bit of investment in American schools, univs, colleges COMPARED TO OTHER NATIONS. If these Americans cannot rise with this much of help, maybe it is time to bring in foreign workers to shake things up.
The tech job market cooled off in early 2024, in part due to inflation and rising interest rates. Our 2024 job report found that it was harder to find a job in 2024 compared to recent years. Job postings fell 15% at the end of 2023. In 2022, there were about 1 job for every 1 job seeker. Elon’s a liar.
The reason is that large America companies do not want to pay American the money all American want, and deserve. The country outside of America are paid foreign employees as little as 6 dollars per hours. In America the pay would be be over 18 dollars per hour. Just call one of the large companies and you will realize you are speaking with a person from a country out side of America.
Interesting. For us, no immigrants! But for them, oh, it's okay. For us, no immigrants, for JD Vance, I like my Indian wife. Do you think they're trying to rub our nose in it?
@@alwaysright7063 they are focused on making the country better but not all Americans currently living on it… they know they need more talent to compete with China
Manufactured hysteria. Actual republicans are aware of the effect immigration and visas have on the workforce and economy. The far left is trying again to create a wedge among the right. Similar to the Musk is president narrative. Relatively few amount of visas are in the conversation, but the 20 plus million people sprinting across the border isn’t.
Yep. Elon wants to be the first trillionaire and he'll get it by getting his entire workforce to go indian on h1b visas. The same visas reps said we're being exploited by tech and Dems.
BLAME MEDIA AND FAR RIGHT FAR LEFT MEDIA THAT CONTINUES TO DIVIDE EVERYDAY AMERICANS INTO HATING THEMSELVES, WHILE STAYING BROKE, OR FOCUSING ON PARTYING AND DOING DRUGS. WHILE VISA HOLDERS COME HERE TO THE USA FROM INDIA and ASIA, OWN HOMES, BUY NICE CARS, LAUGH AT DUMB AMERICANS. TRUMPY WAS SUPOSED TO FIX THIS, BY AMERICA FIRST, TRAINING AMERICANS TECH JOBS, NOW SOME IN TRUMPs CABINET WANTS TO REMOVE RESTRICTIONS ON VISA, THEN REPLACE US WITH PEOPLE FROM INDIA? 🤣DUMB VOTERS.
@@deesteve4156 BIG $$ Tech companies are GREEDY . They always refuse to pay Americans livable wages. Why they love to pay foreigners. Then Foreiners come work for cheap then turn our towns into mehico, or india.
Fix our educational system and don't create a go around solutions. America first, Remember ? Make all schools, right to work, employers. Test teachers knowledge. Knowledge of subject matter should be the qualifications for employment not a degree. That and mental stability.
Yes you did because you failed to see they are all the same. That's why it's so important not to trust anyone just because they supposedly support your choice of politician. They lie just like everyone else does.
January 29, 2024: "I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I've been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It's a great programme”. D.J Trump
Yes you did! Musk and Vivek are president....Just wait until they start meddling in foreign shit, meddling with our sports , immigration, riots and bs...These two are gonna conspire against trump..Guaranteed!
If you voted for 45/47… yeah you kinda did lol it’s a package deal. As the comment section on NowThis would put it, this is the “finding out” part, lol.
They did the same thing in the trucking industry and the only reason is to hold Wages down and make people have to work 70 hours a week for straight time 😉
One of them is currently the Mascot, racing 'them' to 100% planetary surveillance, & domination of land air sea space, currency, down my heart rate as I'm typing this shit comment!
Both are citizens, Ramaswamy was born in Ohio. They're both dangerous oligarchs, and whether Musk lied in his immigration/citizenship process should be investigated, but they're both Americans for the time being.
My father was let go from his tech job in the early 2000's, but not before training his H-B1 replacement.- otherwise, no severence. My parents ended up falling behind their mortgage and lost their house. I have no tolerance for this. This is MAGA- that means America FIRST!!🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
LOL i support them for giving away YT JOBS to the INDIA NATION & MAGA are dur dur!. LOL & no social safety net programs... LOL you doomed us all back to the FARM LABOR WORKFORCE. LOL hahahaha laughing out the room i am LOL 😂😂 Now you going to feel the black and brown people shoes, it's hard to walk in our shoes but you will be OBEDIENT if not? Vivek & Elon & PreZOOdaunt tchump is going to sick the police on you & sick their dogs on you too welcome to color people America smells the poverty & the dangers of being color folks. LOL hahahaha! What time you want me to pick you up to work in the farm hot sun? LOL hahahaha!..dress in a T-shirt MAGA KARENS it's hot in the farm land.. LOL hahahaha!..😐😭😂😂🤷♂️🚶♂️🚪💢
I have worked for different companies that had hired immigrants with visas. One company had a big issue with this and that the person was stealing from the company and taken what they had learned back to their country to a rival company. It is a big problem that many people choose not to see over cheap labor.
H1-B Visas is just an excuse for greedy employers to hire and pay lower wage and no loyalty to this country. However, this is not always the case since there are some niche slots of specialties that are unfilled desperately.
@@Zdiri281 Actually they can. Any employee irrespective of immigration status has the right to complain to HR (whatever impressions people may have of this department) about abuse, work without pay..
Incorrect. India is not even close in tech and engineering. They are not superior they are cheaper. You need to educate yourself and stop believing the TV.
The tech job market cooled off in early 2024, in part due to inflation and rising interest rates. Our 2024 job report found that it was harder to find a job in 2024 compared to recent years. Job postings fell 15% at the end of 2023. In 2022, there were about 1 job for every 1 job seeker.
If the American government invest more money into our American educational system for their own students instead of making education so oppressive to achieve, then this wouldn't be the case where anyone on the outside could say. The reality is that foreigners look out for foreigners. American working class are not lazy, but are oppressed on every level.
If there's a 'dire shortage' of engineers in America, then why are colleges promoting 'gender studies' degrees instead of mathematics, science and engineering degrees?
It’s proven that most are smarter and more hard working than the average American. Just admit that if the person isn’t White…. You feel overlooked, even if the Non White person is smarter and more qualified. 😊
@ I know because I’ve looked at the evidence instead of just repeating MSM. The average iq in India is 76. Surveys have shown 95% of Indian tech workers lack basic skills. Just look at the state of the countries they come from. If they’re so skilled why do their countries suck so bad? Because they’re full of trash people. Why is America such a great country? Because it was built by white people. You may not like it, but it’s reality.
We need to educate our students for free like a lot of other countries do, and not allow one more foreigner into our schools starting in pre-k through college/university.
I started working in IT in 1999 and the IT workforce at my company was 95% American. That same year my father saw an article in the Wall Street Journal saying they were training people in India to do this work. Now they are more than 50% of the IT workforce at my company. This was planned a long time ago. And to say Americans are not willing to train for these job is a joke and a lie. This is all about cheaper labor. At the same time pulling the rug out on Americans.
And MAGA voted the exact same people who did this.
@@renshin5671all the time.
@SteveO-215 well said 👏
Americans are willing - the CEOs don’t want to pay Americans! It’s too expensive. People working on visas will put up with low pay snd abuse
@@renshin5671 and no body knew though, could you say you saw all this coming? Would I be wrong in assuming you did?.
Not, far right. American should be supporting the education of American workers. Paying an Indian 30k to be an indentured servant is immoral.
Dude, pay attention. These are specialized skills. These are specialized skills in stem, quantum computing/AI. Jesus, You probably don’t even know what that term means.These people make no less than 300k a year. You need to pay attention to what he said. What he’s saying is MAGA Americans are too stupid and unqualified for these jobs. You get what you voted for.
Americans don’t want free education that’s evil socialism lmao. So employers don’t want uneducated Americans. You get what you vote for
Then why are Americans education worse than the majority of the world? Sometimes you gotta face the truth even if it hurts feelings.
@@joshuajones518 Nothing new, it’s how America was built off the backs of low wage Migrants one way or another
Indentured servant 😂😂😂 delusional
I like to see Americans get those jobs first.
What's the difference between that & DEI?
@@dreamgirltrucking1889your comment doesn't make a bit of sense.
We can't even pay off Education debt
They won't get the jobs. That is the plan.
@@dreamgirltrucking1889What's the difference between DEI and intentionally trying to hire foreigners for peanuts? You tell me.
Not hiring skilled Americans over cheaper immigrants is no different than our border issues.
Maybe we can't find enough skilled Americans.
Maybe you not looking hard enough. Or even better in 40yr maybe you will not have a country you call America. @jeanettesmith765
So much for “America First” !!!
this isn't about "cheaper immigrants" its about the top 1% of scientists and engineers in other countries. Not some Indian it tech guy...
BLAME MEDIA AND FAR RIGHT FAR LEFT MEDIA THAT CONTINUES TO DIVIDE EVERYDAY AMERICANS INTO HATING THEMSELVES, WHILE STAYING BROKE, OR FOCUSING ON PARTYING AND DOING DRUGS. WHILE VISA HOLDERS COME HERE TO THE USA FROM INDIA and ASIA, OWN HOMES, BUY NICE CARS, LAUGH AT DUMB AMERICANS. TRUMPY WAS SUPOSED TO FIX THIS, BY AMERICA FIRST, TRAINING AMERICANS TECH JOBS, NOW SOME IN TRUMPs CABINET WANTS TO REMOVE RESTRICTIONS ON VISA, THEN REPLACE US WITH PEOPLE FROM INDIA? 🤣DUMB VOTERS.
I used to live in Redmond, Washington where Microsoft headquarters is located, T-mobile and others. That area is dominated by Indians with visas who get hired over Americans because it's cheaper to hire and pay them instead.
also incentivized with FICA and other finan breaks from .guv.
Two druggies from Redmond Washington were robbing a woman in san Francisco in 2005 and killed a family member, they are out of prison now living in redmond
Have they integrated well?
if theyre offering for a position then how is it cheaper to hire them? did they agree to work for cheaper or they just offered them less? do they treat a visa like an internship? another practice that needs to stop.. hey what about paying your workers remember when that was a thing?
@JTC33 true that Trump k ows this It's gonna be American 1st..
Makes sense that Trump would just back another upcoming altcoin instead of Bitcoin for more profits
This country has laid off hundreds of thousands of smart American people over the last two years. While these individuals could be rehired, Silicon Valley corporations choose not to hire them because it would require paying top dollar. Instead, they prefer to hire non-American workers on H-1B visas, paying them 50% less, including reduced medical benefits and other compensation.
The visa beneficiary is also bound to that company as the company holds the visa. If they quit, they’re sent home. Which means employers can treat them however they want.
That’s exactly what Elon wants !!!
Story goes that there were just hired at inflated salaries anticipating work and once the bubble burst they were let go.. This is plain irresponsible capitalism. First hire with inflated salaries ..give them no work and then ask them to leave..How does one even begin to solve this ? Pray everyone finds work.
@@LifeStyle-vi5rp That’s how corporations keep their profits 💲💲💲
Is not how smart americans arfe, is how they have zero ethics
It's really not a far right issue. Americans are simply concerned that large-scale illegal immigration will be replaced by large scale legal migration, and all the jobs will be taken away from Americans who live here.
Resentment towards minorities and DEI distracts from the reality that this is a class issue. Migrant workers are mistreated and American workers get sidelined.
As long as Americans work harder and smarter there’s nothing to worry about.
Survival is considered far right. Resisting displacement is considered far right
@@zantiagotron07That’s not true. It’s not about hard work, it’s about wage depression for big corporations.
You’re talking about the country that invented much of the modern world, now you’re trying to say that same country doesn’t work hard?
@@zantiagotron07You mean for cheaper and in poorer conditions. Skill has nothing to do with it, it’s about willingness to be exploited.
Get rid of visa program. We have thousands of engineers graduating every year and most can't get a job because of visa students who are hired and paid less. No, they are not better than American students.
Problem is the American engineers are products of yt privledge and expect things given to them, so of course the visa students will be willing to do more for less and work harder
Who has more fire under their feet? Immigrants who get sent back if they don't produce or Americans who can fall back on welfare?
@@flintfuentes7652 You're advocating for replacing American workers with indentured servants to destroy our labor market and turn our working class into a poor country's like India or Brazil.
@@flintfuentes7652 those are facts
It boils down to work ethics. Americans are not as ethical as they used to be and you can thank the unions for that. They made it common place by not letting companies fire bad employees. That resulted in the "Made in America" branding being recognized as junk. Sadly, it was Bill Clinton that save American corporations by enacting NAFTA. That allowed them to move shop over seas to escape the unions. Now we are back at a turning point where history could repeat itself if we don't correct the base problem "work ethics" which should be taught in schools like it used to be back after WW2.
If I remember right, ~80% of the 65,000 visas goes to Indians.
They're everywhere
@XiakZahviashih Yes, your daughter is dating one at school....
Why only Indians on H1B ? is rest of world busy with dating , drugs , dropout schools?
Over 1 million to India.
@@Gallo2023 yak 🤮
imagine calling average americans "far right" because we want jobs.
You can’t handle these jobs. 😉
It's called a competive work force. You don't believe in the free market either?😮😅
BLAME MEDIA AND FAR RIGHT FAR LEFT MEDIA THAT CONTINUES TO DIVIDE EVERYDAY AMERICANS INTO HATING THEMSELVES, WHILE STAYING BROKE, OR FOCUSING ON PARTYING AND DOING DRUGS. WHILE VISA HOLDERS COME HERE TO THE USA FROM INDIA and ASIA, OWN HOMES, BUY NICE CARS, LAUGH AT DUMB AMERICANS. TRUMPY WAS SUPOSED TO FIX THIS, BY AMERICA FIRST, TRAINING AMERICANS TECH JOBS, NOW SOME IN TRUMPs CABINET WANTS TO REMOVE RESTRICTIONS ON VISA, THEN REPLACE US WITH PEOPLE FROM INDIA? 🤣DUMB VOTERS.
True, but in this case they were legit (self proclaimed) white nationalists. Just some context 👍
@@cookiescraftscatswe created those jobs Indians can't create those jobs.
Give the jobs to Americans not H-1B visas. What will American citizens do without jobs.
They don't REALLY want to make America great again. They want to deport but not the ones in their companies.
it's not whether to give to amercians, its literally because there is a vacuum of talent. America has been built on immigrant talent. this whole argument is outrageous
If you wanna compete with China, you need smarter people… check the avg IQ in the US vs China… China is ranked 1st and US 20th or 30th
Ok, but those immigrants are potential americans themselves, so...
Legal immigrants vs non legal. Take a deep breath and think about what your saying.😂
Highly likely there will be partnerships between X or Tesla with Qarddin Token
Well damn, no wonder College Graduates can not find Jobs and we are missing somebody 'Americans'
Incorrect. They can't find jobs because most degrees are useless. Yet, they refuse to take lower payer or less prestigious jobs because they have a "degree"
Too many Americans are graduating with garbage degrees. Not too many take STEM.
American college graduates can’t find jobs because they majored in fine arts. Science and math majors don’t have a problem. Guess who they are?
@user-vr8zs3ei7n Didn't matter for Trump. He's dumb af and figured out that he just has to manipulate stupid people to get what he wants.
It's always been like this, where have you been?
Lets train our own people!!! We need jobs too. When the foreigners get to middle management they only hire other foreigners & our graduates can't get jobs & then they have a huge loan to pay back !!!
EXACTLY. WHILE VISA HOLDERS COME HERE TO THE USA FROM INDIA and ASIA, OWN HOMES, BUY NICE CARS, LAUGH AT DUMB AMERICANS. TRUMPY WAS SUPOSED TO FIX THIS, BY AMERICA FIRST, TRAINING AMERICANS TECH JOBS, NOW SOME IN TRUMPs CABINET WANTS TO REMOVE RESTRICTIONS ON VISA, THEN REPLACE US WITH PEOPLE FROM INDIA? 🤣DUMB VOTERS WE ARE. TIME FOR TRUMPY TO SHOW LOYALTY AND FIRE THES INSIDER INDIANS IN HIS CABINET, REPLACE THEM WITH REAL WHITE , BLAK , BROWN AMERICANS,, IF THIS IS REALLY AMERICA FIRST? OR SOME SHAM SHOW FOR THE RICH , WHILE WE STAY BROKE AGAIN....
H1B's come here taking engineering and programming jobs that American kids pay a lot of money to become engineers and programmers, only to find they are getting passed over. Many H1B's have their educations paid for and are not saddled with the college debt that US students have coming out of college. US mid-level tech workers are getting pushed out and being replaced by H1B's, who are not top performers, refuse to assimilate, lack managerial skills and are incapable of thinking out of the box. American business is morphing into the caste system that exists in India.
It's all about the money they don't want to pay Americans!
Our people are dumb. Most aren't trainable. Its not just about education but also class
@Hoop_23 Tell us you're not really American without telling us!
I am american born citizen. I have a master's degree. I have engineered software. I can't even get a response from my job applications tbh. I won't make play a victim. I acknowledge that other jobs can be just as valuable and meaningfully but let's be real... As Americans we were promised that if we go to college, try hard, do what's right, we would have access to community and opportunity, I don't think that these immigrants - Elon and Vivek - actually have any idea what solidarity with your country men actually looks like. But boy was american charmed by them this election cycle. Sad. I hope trump makes the right call.
They don't care and Musk owns Trump, he won't do anything. Remember Musk needs a ROI on the money he spent on Trumps campaign.
Because the one who is reviewing your resume has a 90% chance being Indian, so is the manager at that department, and so is 90% of the co-workers. There has been a sick infatuation for Indians since the late 90s. It never ended.
@@robl9141 Oh well, MAGA voted for this. Trump and Musk save on salaries. Well done.
What happened to America first? So many unemployed Americans who want a job in their related field of study for someone miles away to get the job first. This is just corporate greed and their desire to pay someone cheaper for the same job.
They person you voted for lied!!!!
MAGA are fools - AI is coming - you thought things could go back - time doesn't work that way - fools
You got what you voted for. Congratulations! Did you really think billionaire 1% Americans were looking out for the little guy??
It was a marketing slogan. AKA a scam. You got scammed. Don't say we didn't warn you.
@@Micklemooseas if Kamala would be any better lol
Funny how they are saying we're "far right". No, it's majority of Americans, left, center and right.
This right here. Sick of people trying to divide and control... The mandate is American jobs for American citizens!
They're saying that cause obviously center and left disagree with Elon, that's normal.
But the right disagreeing with Elon is news
Glad to see everyone in the country agrees that this is BS regardless of politics
It’s a class issue. This is the working and middle class against the upper classes. Political spectrum is a distraction.
@@MyWifesBoyfriend-pp8kq Exactly! They are distracting us from the real issues.
We wouldn't need smart people from other countries if our colleges will just start Teaching what they're supposed to be teaching.😮
This has nothing to do will skill, theyre importing people who will work for much less and will then lower everyone elses wages.
These guys who comment are illiterates... these are high skilled ppl who earns more than americans 😂😂
@@mrfunnybones859 ok, streetshtter.
😂😂😂😂
Best I can do is telling you about 92 genders, sorry.
Elon wants cheap labor and workers he can work long hours or work whenever Elon wants them to work. We have a lot of smart high American tech workers now and many of them are laid off. Elon just doesn’t want to pay them a fair salary.
This is about IQ not cheap labor… that’s illegal immigration and not H1B
There are barely any smart American tech workers compared to how many you can get from abroad. It doesn't make sense how a construction worker is afraid that a software developer making $300k+ is gonna take their jobs. You can blame liberals, and those that control mainstream American culture (Hollywood folks) for making Americans think that doing nothing and eating cheeseburgers all day is okay.
He did fire almost everyone from twitter 1 year back and make the existing employees sleep in offices. I think finally get it..All those twitter employees unfairly laid off by Elon must be behind this current uproar. This really nothing to do with H1b actually..because everyone will refuse to work under inhuman conditions. There must be a law against people who lay off workers unfairly. Last year's argument was that Big tech over hired and Elon was trying to demo how one can run a lean and mean tech machine with handful of team members. Boy this is gonna blow up beyond crazy. Is this how govt officials should behave ? Do they have nothing better to do ??
He fired 6000 before Thanksgiving!!! He is like Trump he doesn’t want to pay !!!
I live in a state where that's true with him!
No more USA citzens??? It is controlled by few billionaires come from another country?? 😂😂😂😂
Only illegal immigrants are able to have children tax payers pick up the check for.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I thought we were doing Americans first??? How does this benefit "we the people" & not Big money?
Love them some Wallstreet. Main Street not so much. Same ole, same ole. New boss same as the old boss...
Trump said America first not americans first
These H1-B applicants should be helping their own countries if they're so talented and motivated. America has plenty of talented technical people.
Are u one of them?
100% True.
Know the facts.. you merely see 1/10 applicants for these high skilled jobs..
US pays better.
India has its own silicon valley its called banglore i want h1b1 visa to ban bcoz then all the tech companies will move to india
So let me get this straight, thousands of American students graduate every year as engineers, scientist, doctors, techs etc... from all over the US yet its not enough to fill in the labor gap? They act like there's only 10 universities. Lets be real its all about money where an H-1B visa person will be accept and be paid a lot less than an American. On the other hand for once I actually agree with that loon MTG.
H1B’s get paid out compared to Americans. Lmao Americans cry for days off, they’re lazy, and inefficient. Immigrants outwork them everytime. Also, Americans are severely uneducated. Cry about it. This is why America stopped hiring Americans for producing chips, they suck and now we outsource to Taiwan. Americans are only good at making steel and war
No it is not enough, do you know how drastically is a shortage in United States on Doctors, engineers, programmers, etc? You are talking about a nation of almost half a billion people
😂😮
Don’t tell me we don’t have Americans that are smart enough to fill these high-tech jobs.. because we do.😡
If you’re an engineer from another country, be in your country and make it better with your skills. Bottom line, if you’re an American company, doing American business, hire American and Pay them.
The last comment by Marjorie Taylor Greene was absolutely dead on. Young people are more worried about getting a video they made to go viral and be the next social media star and strike it rich. It’s like the gold rush days, only this time people are betting it all on becoming social media famous. American born individuals are lazy, compared to immigrants. Immigrant workers go above and beyond in pretty much any service, of course there are exceptions, but Americans are entitled, and act like they are doing you a favor by doing their job. I would rather someone who’s humble and hard working help me, I will be happy to increase my tip for better service every time.
January 29, 2024: "I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I've been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It's a great programme”. D.J Trump
The idea that having a problem with this is a “far right” idea does nothing but shut down the conversation. This should be a non-partisan issue. We have plenty of people here already, we don’t need any more. Why don’t we give those jobs to Americans. This is about importing cheap labor.
Because we shouldn't "give away jobs"-due to quotas and affirmative action or location (where one was born). We should look for the best and brightest and let those people EARN their jobs. In USA we should look beyond the color and or nationality.
shutting down any conversation that threatens the continued funneling of wealth to the 0.1% is precisely the job of "news" people.
ABC 7 has no integrity. They are an enemy of the people.
@@johnmguzman7491Ridiculous argument and ignores all the negative impacts for Americans. You realize this is wage suppression right? This is rigging capitalism against the worker while big corporations inherit no risk. They seek to outsource because it means they don’t have to pay FAIR wages or invest domestically. Saying “we should look past color” is you trying to make up something that wasn’t the argument to begin with. This is an economic issue, nothing to do with skin color.
We are a country of immigrants. This is what legal immigration looks like. We will not be a xenophobic country with entirely closed borders.
There are plenty of smart Americans who can't catch a break for a well paying job. Let's end this!
January 29, 2024: "I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I've been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It's a great programme”. D.J Trump
Government should impose higher taxes on those companies who hire foreign workers on very low salary and save huge money. Government needs money to run the economy and get rid of all debt.
What happen to "America first"and "We will take our coutry back"??
It's an ongoing process, and it seems the cult of personality peoples true colors are coming to light. And so they should be discarded as soon as possible.
This is why I sat out this election. They are all the same.
That was all a lie
@@millennialodyssey5956 me too, they are all pretenders.
I can't believe ppl actually fell for the the ol "rope a dope" from Trump n Maga. I'm definitely here to say " Told u so!"
Look within our own pool of amazing people before taking them from other counties. Those other countries need their great minds too.
Great argument
But those "great minds" aren't so great without 🤍.
Maybe India should include patriotism in their highly skilled curriculum..so their super intelligent grads will stay there and help their country get better..teach them to love their country more and apply their education so India won’t be a 3rd world country anymore..
@@karensbackvery subtle way of putting it, and I agree completely 🥛🤍
We do that and will continue to do that in their plan. Its just about bringing in people where we are lacking talent.
Millions voted for trump, because they are out of jobs! Now you giving these jobs to Indians? Why not train our own people here? We suffering here
@@rashadchowdhury523 thanks pakistani
You yourself is Pakistani or from kangludesh 😂😂😂😂Typical muslim spewing hatred
And let's not forget that SpaceX and Tesla existed already, it's not like he invented them
Musk founded SpaceX in 2002, it did not exist before then. Tesla was never successful until Musk took it over.
The only truly Elon creation we have is the Cybertruck, which is a disaster of a vehicle and product. He's a hack who just buys his resume bullet points
buying a company and making it big is what its all about.. how is that supposed to be a bad thing?
Electric cars existed in the early 1900's! Let that sink in, Mr. Tesla guy!
These folks are taken American jobs and the government brings them in!!! From mostly India. Wonder why our customer service industry has eroded??? Because we can’t understand them!
@@e.williams6874 customer service is offshored overseas.
A lot of those customer service centers are wired directly to India. E.g., they are outsourced. Those are not H1B visa holders, those are Indians IN INDIA, working for US corporations.
So then, how do you stop the outsourcing? More regulation? Because free market dictates more profit, and an Indian in India will be 2-3x cheaper than even an Indian in US with H1B.
Trump is expected to mention Qarddin Token this week and the ICO is already almost sold out
It is quite insulting that two men who never shed any blood for this country and have benefited greatly from those who did can flippantly tell Americans that they aren't smart enough or good enough to work in their tech companies.
Not to mention Trumps utter contempt for anyone who served.
How is importing workers "making America great again"? Shouldn't we as parents, teachers and business owners be providing strong incentives to our young to pursue science and engineering degrees along with learning a trade.
Giving up on American youth in favor of importing foreigners is not MAGA.
MAGA costume comes off😂….all of you were fooled. You ain’t seen nothing yet
We will, but that takes years. We all know colleges turn out entitled idiots, but suddenly they're good enough?
mayors and governors are the most corrupt aspect of all of this.. local municipalities are more corrupt than federal by a million miles...
@NS-ju7vz Uh, excuse me but we are divided on this issue. Read the comments. Our side can be divided because unlike your side, which only thinks what you are told to think, we think for ourselves. Troll. If you'd start thinking for yourself, you could probably think up better ways to spend your spare time besides trolling for the sole purpose of starting 💩.
The US does have plenty of STEM graduates. Big surprise billionaires don’t wanna pay our graduates a wage that enables kids to live and pay student loans. Since other countries pay for uni foreign workers are cheaper.
Resisting unlimited remigration is not a far right position, its centrist. We've seen whats happening to Cananda, Britain, France, Germany, Sweden, Australia etc etc etc and we are NOT having it here. Every nation must have a homeland, do not let them take yours.
Thats not what President Musk has decided🔥
I've lost track of what centrist means anymore.
"nation" has more than one meaning. How are you using that in this context?
It's not up to what is realistic or the will of the people. It's up to Musk and we've got MAGA to "thank".
How about reporting what an American engineer would get paid including benefits vs what an H-1B Visa holder would get paid including benefits?
It’s the same. I work in tech as an engineer where 80% of my team are visa holders
X and Qarddin Token are going to be merged. Easiest money in my life
How different is this than Walmart paying below living wage and receiving government subsidies? SpaceX, Tesela ....etc. gets billions in government contracts. .... All the while people are not paid what they are worth, whatever their skill set.... Cheaper foreign labor = bigger bottom line. Billionaires become Trillionaires. Same old shell game, it's no different.
Exactly, Musk has just played MAGA into his hands to reduce the cost of his workforce.
I'm sorry this is BS I know so many people who graduated with computer science degrees and stuff that can't get jobs in this country. And then they hire some Indian guy with a Visa who's willing to do anything anytime it's total BS it's about control
Ok...please tell me how that computer science degree translates to needing an engineer? Degrees are not all equal
The tech job market cooled off in early 2024, in part due to inflation and rising interest rates. Our 2024 job report found that it was harder to find a job in 2024 compared to recent years. Job postings fell 15% at the end of 2023. In 2022, there were about 1 job for every 1 job seeker.
This is what you getting by voting a billionaire to be your president. FAFO! Congrats!
@@djayt1215Software Engineer. Maybe try to educate yourself on a topic before commenting on it.
@@MyWifesBoyfriend-pp8kq maybe wait 10 years and all these Indians on H1b will be far more successful and richer than Americans
We don't need more people from other countries to fill these jobs. We need more american citizens to fill these jobs!
And we can fill them. They know we can fill them. But, they don't want to pay us to fill them.
According to estimates from Newsom's office, Tesla has received "more than $3.2 billion worth of direct and indirect California subsidies and market mechanisms since 2009."
With much more to come I’m sure!
@@maggieg5719nah newsome’s gonna revoke those subsidies
Sounds like welfare to me
You believe Newsom’s office? California ain’t doin too good right now, but that sure isn’t Tesla’s fault. Talk to your governor. He does the math for California, not Tesla!
He didn't want those tax credits he's said it multiple times. Blame politicoan Newsome for that government policy not the entrepreneur who made America much much richer.
STOP H-1B's and get our own youth/people educated for these roles and THAT will tremendously help MAGA. STOP ALLOWING cheaper imported labor and give the jobs to American citizens.
So someone just give you a job because you’re MAGA? What happened to earning the job in merit 😂?
@@truthhurtsohwell05 you're not making a bit of sense. I see you are not a native English speaker...
Apparently America first isn’t Americans first, just our corporate overlords.
Those iphone developers arent necessarily cheaper
@@rowslow maga PEOPLE ARE TOO STUPID TO DO THOSE JOBS.
I think they get a better deal than US citizens and that’s, quite frankly, not fair.
Their argument is that we don’t have enough talent, but they also want to get rid of the Department of Education. Why not invest in education instead, especially STEM programs? Are we going to throw the towel and rely on India going forward? We need complete overhaul of our education system.
You voted for this 😮
Removing education will keep many Americans stagnant. The education is stale and needs to be refreshed
Exactly my submission. This should be the ideal approach.
Republican agenda needs the less educated for votes and cheap labor. This isn't new.
Are they not aware a bachelors degree in most cities is $50k-$60k? This doesn’t include interest on the loan & excessive fees…. $50k-$60k isn’t the norm in other countries. How is this fair for Americans?
It’s our country.
Not a few tech titans and assorted billionaires.
You r from europe how can it be yours
Repeal the 1990 Immigration Act that began this mess.
January 29, 2024: "I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I've been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It's a great programme”. D.J Trump
No, Elon Musk was not a H1-B visa worker. He's a South African born Canadian-American entrepreneur who moved to the United States on an F-1 visa for education and later became a U.S. citizen. Ahmed Banafa ,SJSU Engineering Lecturer is either ignorant or lying if he teaches Musk is a product of a H1-B visa . He just proved he is not needed.
An estimated 4.21 million people graduated from American universities in 2023 alone, in all shades of brown. Yes, there are enough American grads to fill tech positions in the U.S.
Musk is the antichrist any way he got here
Elon could care less about background in education. He's all about thinking outside the box. He believes those degrees are worthless in the real world unless they yield results prior to the hiring fase
Shades of brown.
@@christhompson6010he's lying. Look at the job postings at his companies.
Musk believes people should work 80 hours a week and sleep at work, basically having no life!
Most software "engineers" don't even need any advanced knowledge of science, technology, or math. Just be logical and know how to write code. I worked with a company once that was majority H1B. They just wrote Java code to interact with oracle database and submit claims to insurance companies. The right person doesn't even need a 4 year degree to do this sort of work
Musk never held H1B visa. He was working illegally while on student visa. Get your info straight!
He had a student visa but transitioned to an H1-B visa
Exactly
@@TheDirtysouthfanHe wasn't a student. Get it right.
@@TheDirtysouthfanYou cannot be legally employed in the United States if you are here on a student visa.
@@TheDirtysouthfan these are bot account you replying to. You notice how they are all now against immigrants or non-americans?
Musk is all about making India great again.
No, you are talking about Tulsi Gabbard, lol.
And here everyone was falling all over themselves for that Ramaswamy guy and how perfect he was! Right they only want to take over! Packem up and send them home!
@@Malachor8091 more call centers?
Musk has no investments/plants in India. Tesla cannot be sold in India unless imported by individuals and that too after paying humongous duties.
@haribhanujan8575 Musk wants unrestricted H1B visa immigrants from India. That is not what Trump promised. He lied to Maga to help his billionaire pals.
I'm no Democrat but everybody should know that nobody has become a billionaire by not stepping on the poor
I'm in stem and an american citizen. Its been hard finding a tech job and I have experience. Americans should have the oppurtunity to work in stem first before anyone else!!
What is your programming language? Are you going for a saturated field?
@@truthhurtsohwell05 STEM doesn’t always mean computers. And even if it did in this case, in American universities you’ll learn more than one programming language.
@@truthhurtsohwell05 funny how those saturated fields still need H1Bs.
This is true. But, Big tech Businesses and others plan on this being otherwise.
I can do without musk and tesla
Trump will keep them on
I've worked with, interviewed, and hired many professionals needing Visa sponsorship. It's a fallacy to believe a large proportion of H1B visa holders are harder working, better trained, or higher skilled than US born counterparts. There is a lot of dishonesty in applications and interviews. And well-rounded professional skillsets- including soft skills- are needed for an organization to be productive, which are sometimes lacking in H1B applicants. Not saying there shouldn't be any, or that there aren't many Visa holders that are valuable professionals. But people are raising a straw man argument.
It’s an anecdotal fallacy to use ur limited personal experience to make sweeping conclusions about a given topic.
How is importing workers for work that Americans can do helping Americans to get ahead.
A rising ride lifts all ships. Brain drain other nations. The US has had a lot of achievements by poaching foreign talen
Increases GDP
As an American master of mathematics student with experience and certifications in machine learning, reinforcement learning, and research in partial differential equations and graph theory, I am currently pursuing studies in quantum mechanics. Given that I am American, I would like to be prioritized over those of other countries.
This is all ridiculous. I've been in tech 22 years and there is no shortage of young American comp sci / math grads. Our schools are the global benchmark and are flooded with mostly Indian students for that reason. There is NO set of "special skills" that H1B workers possess, I have managed large H1B teams and would obviously know that. At my last position in NYC there were approx 10 H1B's for every American. They are also hired in batches as high as 400-500 and employers simply trust the giant outsourcing firms like Tata to verify education and skill sets. Not taking sides but those are facts.
Far-right? You have lost all credibility.
Not at all. Xenophobia is a far-right trait.
@@ihorperec4990America first. Nice try though
@@ihorperec4990 You also think grown men should go into the same bathroom as little girls. Stop talking.
@@ihorperec4990It's not xenophobia though? Not wanting to expand an already very lenient visa program for what's obviously an attempt at cheap labor is that far right of an idea? Is it so radical to think companies should focus on hiring domestically rather than import cheap labor?
YES. FAR RIGHT PSYCHOS LIKE YOURSELF
Make no mistake. Musk is in the for the benefit of Musk. Not his fellow Americans.
@@Dj-zz he wants to improve the country’s talent but may not Necessarily care much about the people currently living on it
I got news for you, he ain't American. He is in it for himself and only himself, and this is what you voted for. We warned you, but you wouldn't listen. Now we all get to live with your mistake.
So Silicon Valley can have immigrants, but not US farmers who need them just as badly?
Weird to frame it as "clashing with the far right." From what i can tell, people across the political spectrum are "clashing" with Musk and Vivek on this.
They are liars.
Everyone who doesn't agree with the oligarchs is considered "far-right" 😂
@@Marcelo-rv7rnDid the left support Elon? Or was it the right that supported Musk and Trump? Oh yeah, it was the right. And now y'all are surprised than an immigrant worth almost half a trillion dollars doesn't about the American people. The rest of us saw this coming a mile away. If this move surprises you, then clearly you haven't been paying attention. And you're the ones to blame.
@@2plus2doesnotequal53 the left ran on unlimited immigration. You can't pretend they would have been happier with them.
And now the Uni-party rhetoric begins. Who knew that America First didn't mean America workers first!
The far right isn't educated enough to see they got duped
@@Sheep-5491Progressives knew
"Far-right"
You mean normal, average, everyday Americans.
The US Legacy media has a complete disconnect with the public. And this is by design.
😂Being led by a guy from India and another from South Africa is really absurd. America first?
Vivik born in America
@@MangaBear wrong spelling 🙃🙃
@@MangaBear doesn't make him loyal to his birth country
Well who appointed them? Your messiah Trump. Why you not mad at Trump?
Voted by you guys while you were trying to discredit nonwhite people who have merit. 😂
I am against H-1B visa. Need to invest in our own people.
There has already been quite a bit of investment in American schools, univs, colleges COMPARED TO OTHER NATIONS. If these Americans cannot rise with this much of help, maybe it is time to bring in foreign workers to shake things up.
@@amitpadgaonkar8830nope.
The tech job market cooled off in early 2024, in part due to inflation and rising interest rates. Our 2024 job report found that it was harder to find a job in 2024 compared to recent years. Job postings fell 15% at the end of 2023. In 2022, there were about 1 job for every 1 job seeker.
Elon’s a liar.
@@amitpadgaonkar8830 no
The reason is that large America companies do not want to pay American the money all American want, and deserve. The country outside of America are paid foreign employees as little as 6 dollars per hours. In America the pay would be be over 18 dollars per hour. Just call one of the large companies and you will realize you are speaking with a person from a country out side of America.
So create a culture that motivates Americans to compete with the world like previous generations.
Interesting. For us, no immigrants! But for them, oh, it's okay. For us, no immigrants, for JD Vance, I like my Indian wife. Do you think they're trying to rub our nose in it?
Marriage is different
@@alwaysright7063 they are focused on making the country better but not all Americans currently living on it… they know they need more talent to compete with China
lmaoo who didnnt see this coming
RIGHT!!! Pass the popcorn please 😂
The ones that voted for Trump
Manufactured hysteria. Actual republicans are aware of the effect immigration and visas have on the workforce and economy. The far left is trying again to create a wedge among the right. Similar to the Musk is president narrative. Relatively few amount of visas are in the conversation, but the 20 plus million people sprinting across the border isn’t.
Yep. Elon wants to be the first trillionaire and he'll get it by getting his entire workforce to go indian on h1b visas. The same visas reps said we're being exploited by tech and Dems.
@@Marie68886yeah they were too busy keeping their fingers in their ears lol
Give all potential employees a compentcy test, regardless of their nationality.
They need to retract the leashes on these two.
We don’t need a competitive workforce from outside influences. We need to compete with ourselves.
BLAME MEDIA AND FAR RIGHT FAR LEFT MEDIA THAT CONTINUES TO DIVIDE EVERYDAY AMERICANS INTO HATING THEMSELVES, WHILE STAYING BROKE, OR FOCUSING ON PARTYING AND DOING DRUGS. WHILE VISA HOLDERS COME HERE TO THE USA FROM INDIA and ASIA, OWN HOMES, BUY NICE CARS, LAUGH AT DUMB AMERICANS. TRUMPY WAS SUPOSED TO FIX THIS, BY AMERICA FIRST, TRAINING AMERICANS TECH JOBS, NOW SOME IN TRUMPs CABINET WANTS TO REMOVE RESTRICTIONS ON VISA, THEN REPLACE US WITH PEOPLE FROM INDIA? 🤣DUMB VOTERS.
Nah...Because of the pay wage.....Those people will take any wage....It's literally the reason we barely get pay raises
@@deesteve4156 BIG $$ Tech companies are GREEDY . They always refuse to pay Americans livable wages. Why they love to pay foreigners. Then Foreiners come work for cheap then turn our towns into mehico, or india.
@@deesteve4156 avg H1b comp ~170k
Sounds like they need to support access to education for Americans. Make it more affordable. Add incentives for engineering.
Fix our educational system and don't create a go around solutions. America first, Remember ? Make all schools, right to work, employers. Test teachers knowledge. Knowledge of subject matter should be the qualifications for employment not a degree. That and mental stability.
And hold parents accountable for their childrens' behavior in school.
We need better public schools.
No, they have promised to defund the education system. They want dumb Americans to control. Trump loves the uneducated. the elite will control us.
@@tomcorrin498 that takes 15 years and US needs smarter people (high IQ) to be able to compete with China
We Americans are always getting sidelined. I am tired of this!!!
Pick up ur game!
There's nothing "far-right" about wanting to keep American jobs for those who are living and struggling here right now.
This is not what We Americans have voted for when we voted for Trump ? American's deserve these jobs !
I’m afraid you’ll be repeating that phrase often.
Yes you did because you failed to see they are all the same. That's why it's so important not to trust anyone just because they supposedly support your choice of politician. They lie just like everyone else does.
Should have been a bit smarter when you voted lol
Billionaires help billionaires. Always. We are just peasants to them.
Suffer in silence.
WELL THIS IS OUR PLATFORM AMERICAN BREED CITIZENS! SPEAK UP AGAINST ALL TIME IS HERE! GET OUR RIGHTS OF WHERE OUR TAX MONEY GOES!
@@Itsalotouthear WHY ARE WE YELLING??😮
Remember, when the media calls someone "far-right," it usually means that person is just normal.
Or Hitler
@icebergrose8955 Nah, he was socialist.
@goldspartan4858 oh sweetie, the nazis called themselves that to fool people. They were fascist capitalists.
January 29, 2024: "I have many H-1B visas on my properties. I've been a believer in H-1B. I have used it many times. It's a great programme”. D.J Trump
@@goldspartan4858 Free*Luigi
The term far right gets thrown around way too much & it most often isn’t true.
If you want to help India, go there open up a business, also take swami with you to run your business there , we never voted for you at first place.
Yes you did! Musk and Vivek are president....Just wait until they start meddling in foreign shit, meddling with our sports , immigration, riots and bs...These two are gonna conspire against trump..Guaranteed!
If you voted for 45/47… yeah you kinda did lol it’s a package deal. As the comment section on NowThis would put it, this is the “finding out” part, lol.
You empowered Ramaswamy and elon by voting for Trump.
How do Trump voters still not understand what they were voting for, it’s insane how deluded they are
Amen. These people got to go
They did the same thing in the trucking industry and the only reason is to hold Wages down and make people have to work 70 hours a week for straight time 😉
Both are not American
Boy are you uneducated
One of them is currently the Mascot, racing 'them' to 100% planetary surveillance, & domination of land air sea space, currency, down my heart rate as I'm typing this shit comment!
Both are citizens, Ramaswamy was born in Ohio.
They're both dangerous oligarchs, and whether Musk lied in his immigration/citizenship process should be investigated, but they're both Americans for the time being.
@@marymactavishlol you both^^^ are ret___ed
@@marymactavishHis folks came from India so send him and his family back to Ohio
My father was let go from his tech job in the early 2000's, but not before training his H-B1 replacement.- otherwise, no severence. My parents ended up falling behind their mortgage and lost their house.
I have no tolerance for this. This is MAGA- that means America FIRST!!🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Just another ruse to not hire employable citizens especially with unions on the rise.
Up until last night, I was a fan of Vivek and Elon. Not after this. No way. America FIRST.
LOL i support them for giving away YT JOBS to the INDIA NATION & MAGA are dur dur!. LOL & no social safety net programs... LOL you doomed us all back to the FARM LABOR WORKFORCE. LOL hahahaha laughing out the room i am LOL 😂😂
Now you going to feel the black and brown people shoes, it's hard to walk in our shoes but you will be OBEDIENT if not? Vivek & Elon & PreZOOdaunt tchump is going to sick the police on you & sick their dogs on you too welcome to color people America smells the poverty & the dangers of being color folks. LOL hahahaha! What time you want me to pick you up to work in the farm hot sun? LOL hahahaha!..dress in a T-shirt MAGA KARENS it's hot in the farm land.. LOL hahahaha!..😐😭😂😂🤷♂️🚶♂️🚪💢
Glad you woke up
100%.
I have worked for different companies that had hired immigrants with visas. One company had a big issue with this and that the person was stealing from the company and taken what they had learned back to their country to a rival company. It is a big problem that many people choose not to see over cheap labor.
H1-B Visas is just an excuse for greedy employers to hire and pay lower wage and no loyalty to this country. However, this is not always the case since there are some niche slots of specialties that are unfilled desperately.
🦄
and most important, h1b worker cant fill complain, company love them
@@Zdiri281 Actually they can. Any employee irrespective of immigration status has the right to complain to HR (whatever impressions people may have of this department) about abuse, work without pay..
We need to better educate our American children!!! Americans are behind in education and technology!
....the US leads in both of those. Quit drinking the socialist koolaid
Freaking entertainment industry, sports industry all have contributed to the downfall in average American IQ
Incorrect. India is not even close in tech and engineering. They are not superior they are cheaper. You need to educate yourself and stop believing the TV.
The tech job market cooled off in early 2024, in part due to inflation and rising interest rates. Our 2024 job report found that it was harder to find a job in 2024 compared to recent years. Job postings fell 15% at the end of 2023. In 2022, there were about 1 job for every 1 job seeker.
If the American government invest more money into our American educational system for their own students instead of making education so oppressive to achieve, then this wouldn't be the case where anyone on the outside could say. The reality is that foreigners look out for foreigners. American working class are not lazy, but are oppressed on every level.
American jobs for Americans.
American jobs to the best and brightest
@@flintfuentes7652 yeah exactly. It’s not that hard what they want to do
This is nothing compared to the jobs sent overseas to this country. Trump needs to get rid of these two immediately
I agree. They need to go.
Leftist media smear. Don’t fall for it.
Send them to India.
If there's a 'dire shortage' of engineers in America, then why are colleges promoting 'gender studies' degrees instead of mathematics, science and engineering degrees?
I voted for America first, not India first!
Should have read the fine print
You voted for Trump first. You got scammed and you are the last one to figure it out.
you voted for a billionaire who doesn’t care about you
100%.
@@TheVeggiekat as if I would take advice from a vegetarian. It isn't a done deal, because we will speak and Trump will listen.
You’re far right if you don’t want your job given to an incompetent foreigner.
It’s proven that most are smarter and more hard working than the average American. Just admit that if the person isn’t White…. You feel overlooked, even if the Non White person is smarter and more qualified. 😊
How do u know the foreigner is incompetent?
@@kynmasters8670 just compare the salary of a H1b holder and the Americans complaining about them… It’s easily 2x
@ I know because I’ve looked at the evidence instead of just repeating MSM. The average iq in India is 76. Surveys have shown 95% of Indian tech workers lack basic skills. Just look at the state of the countries they come from. If they’re so skilled why do their countries suck so bad? Because they’re full of trash people. Why is America such a great country? Because it was built by white people. You may not like it, but it’s reality.
Left and Right can agree that big business wants cheap, powerless labor.
If Americans are not smart enough, then college needs lower their fees 😂😂
We need to educate our students for free like a lot of other countries do, and not allow one more foreigner into our schools starting in pre-k through college/university.
Thats literally the point...
You can give it away free and people would still be idiots. Its our culture in general. We are breeding fools
Exactly.💯
And increase the standards
Talk about letting the foxes into the hen house! Trump should fire Elon and Vivek and replace them with H1Bs. 😂
Make them lead by example!
Trump won't fire Musk, he is owned by him. And now Musk wants his ROI in the form of cheap labor.