👀Do you think Hailey Bieber has a successful rebrand? 👉🏻protect + enjoy online freedom without restrictions on 7 devices with CyberGhost VPN for 4 months free www.cyberghostvpn.com/zoeunlimited
Sending death threats about anyone just because you get “bad vibes” is actually delusional. Half of the people on TikTok need to go outside and stick their hands in dirt because wth 🤦♀️
getting bad vibes because someone was racist multiple times isn’t delusional, even if her remarks are old it still happened and people still have the right not to like her. i don’t agree with the death threats but for you to act like the only reason behind them is that she gives people “bad vibes” just makes me icky. like what?😭
Her mental is so inspiring for me. Like how did she do, seriously I’ve witnessed all the cyber bullying she went through. How did she just ignored that and move on ?
Definitely is because of her faith. I’ve heard her talk about how she gives all her worries to Jesus and it definitely gives her strength. Many people should have a spiritual base then they wouldn’t go around the world being so lost and resentful.
No cause I felt so bad for her. The way people were freaking out over the photo kylie posted which i’m pretty sure was for her mascara is crazy. I’m not even a kylie or hailey stan (I like hailey a lot though) but omg it was so weird & Selena purposefully adding fuel to the fire by commenting on tiktok about Hailey & all this extra stuff *sigh* I will say though it was very smart of Hailey to just move on & not freak out about it or cry on social media over it cause that would’ve made them bully her more.
@@rayeeiffel480I never understood anything about the hate, I even thought everyone wanted to be hailey Bieber and I was not chronically online lol but I felt in the rabbit hole and to me it seem like they both were trying to do things that would make ppl talk.
Um no they don’t……she doesn’t even have a pr. If she did, the whole hate train wouldn’t have happened. If she had a pr team, Selena’s past bad actions would’ve been amongst some of trending topics.
@@Kiran37369 Like the fact that despite preaching kindness and telling her fans not to attack Hailey, she was still liking posts hating on and attacking Hailey, posting vague posts (such as that one Taylor Swift video which was literally filmed 5 years) to encourage not only her fans but swifties to attack her
@@awhimsyreader9015 exactly! She was commenting on videos that were clearly hating on hailey. And after a while, she was yapping about how “I’m a feminist, I don’t support this blah blah blah” what a bad excuse of a feminist. Embarrassing us feminists smh
yall are sensitive and drama seekers, who said that tiktoks abt her? and whats with selena's body? so let me tell u this "u think her body is a problem, but u wanna fool yourself, so instead u wanna to defend her body when theres nothing to defend in the first place" so basically yall creating a drama to defend it and look as good person
What are you even talking about? She didn't bodyshamed Selena. It's not her fault Selena's fans are obsessed with a relationship that ended years ago so they relate everything Haley does to Selena.
Honestly I always felt kinda bad for Hailey, so I’m happy for her now that she’s doing well. Selena is a queen too, they both deserve the respect and love they get
For Selena, she is extremely lucky even when she's already an old woman. If you watched her documentary she acts like an entitled child, (1) people are patient with her even she's reactive and passive aggressive that they didn't mirror her despite her victim mentality, (2) her friends are there to wake her up to remind her to take her pills, (3) have lots of money and health treatment so she is fine, (4) she is extremely lucky to have such an excellent PR team to take down or hide her mess so easily and clean her reputation. I really hope she will seek help, she already said that she's in therapy since she was like 18? she is 32 now.
@@patu.121They meant grown. And they’re right. She is lucky she has the best PR team in the world that can turn even her most messed up moments into a victim narrative for her. They knew exactly that if they overplayed her health issues they could get her unlimited sympathy. But she’s actually very cold and calculated. She’s brainwashed her fans so much that they care more that he cheated on her but don’t care that she literally hit him and screamed at him in public and there’s a video of that still online. So many things she’s done that are terrible but her fans can see no wrong. It’s scary.
I’m actually happy for Hailey. After all she went through I think it’s only fair for her to have her peace now. Everyone deserves peace and happiness. So good on her.
She hasn't been held accountable. I recommend watching the videos on her stalking bieber from when she was young. Also justin is in a conservative church and an Uber zionist all while hailey is his submissive wifey and is friends with gigi hadid who as we all know is palestinian. She isn't the only celebrity who is this spineless but to rebrand a spineless make up guru as a heroine who finally punched herself out the trenches is icky
proud to say i never jumped on hailey bieber hate train. i'm tired of people seeing selena as saint, and hailey as evil. how can people be so dull and assume others are this shallow and not complex? anyways, i'm happy for hailey and justin!
Another example of prejudice, constant comparison and bullying is Victoria Justice. Finally, people are realizing how horribly and unfairly she was treated!! Hope, she gets everything best in life as well ❤
I’ve witnessed how the internet hated her, but what inspires me the most is how she handled those backlashes with courage. She never gave attention to the negativity or sought revenge. Instead, she focused on loving herself even more despite the hate from people who don't contribute to her life. Her mindset is what truly inspires me-she never let a single hateful comment destroy her. Instead, she stayed focused on her own life, converting the negative attention into something positive and beneficial. That's why she has an even bigger brand now.
I have come to this conclusion about people including myself of course and it came after living for 30 years on this earth, people are sheep, but they don't like to graze the same pasture all the time (we wont keep liking/hating the same thing for a very long time at the same rate). As long as something doesn't happens to us personally we will move on from anything. Our minds move over literally anything.
@finalgirl13 being mean to someone mean doesn't make you less mean. And her being racist as a teenager doesn't warrant a witch hunt of her as an adult. Like the racist claims are valid but they go out the window when you look at the amount of hate which isn't even direct criticism of her past. People will say stuff like "ugly, bully wannabe. That's what you get for being racist" (odd example 😭) but you get my point. They won't address the distasteful things but just randomly have them there like a tag on in their slander.
@@finalgirl1390% of people do not hate her for her racist comments but rather for being the wife of JB. They couldn’t care less about it and it does in fact help them justify their hatred towards her .
Ok i never understood how ppl completely forgot that selena was the one who started the drama back in 2023.She was commenting on tiktoks which were 10years old of hailey trying to start beef like how is no one talking about that?(im not tryna hate on anyone but saying hailey was the attention seeker while selena was doing all this is just wrong)
@@RT-yq4coyou need to google celebdeepdive Justin Selena hailey and actually read where the roots began. You will see how hailey was involved from the start with Kendall. Don’t talk shit until you done your research or you look stupid.
The extreme Hailey Beiber hate showed me how mentally ill and chronically online we’ve become as a society. We don’t know this girl personally. She really doesn’t have any impact on our life. Yet she made one tik tok with one popular sound, people just assumed was about Selena Gomez. And the internet had a visceral reaction to her for months. People that commit war crimes don’t get nearly the online hate Hailey Beiber did.
Determining love or hate towards a celebrity without personal interactions and knowledge is a conversant concept in hollywood. We blindly go defending or hating people based on what we see, or assume. Hollywood has entirely reckoned itself on superficiality and forgery. Returning to your comment, her choice of audio was clearly too accurate to be a happenstance. And believe it or not, the hate or the love we give to these strangers turn into millions of dollars. Hollywood is an aforethought industry, so whatever you see on social media is probably planned to attract attention, negative or positive. Whatever that happened, made her one of the most talked people on earth. So, I'd advise you to not pity these people.
as a long term Justin fan i could be biased but when their pictures came out them crying on the side of the road after getting married my heart broke for them. I was like this is the kind of hate thats gonna last sadly but i never imagined it would last this long.
My hot take on this: Selena’s fans have been screaming her name at Hailey for years and treating Hailey like shit for just being married to Selena’s ex… and Selena “the good girl” never said a thing. Selena is not the angel everyone says she is, because she literally only spoke against her fans coming for Hailey when it was trending… and thats kinda tea 😳
So true!the way selena first cries and acts sad about all the rumours which ofc makes her fans target hailey then says dont spread hate guys....like wtf u literally initiated it.
I have always found Selena of the victim mentality and even if not, let's not deny that she marketed off her ex. The songs, the dramatic interviews/ stage performances all to gain more sympathy from the public. She's either a true mean gal or a really smart businesswoman,, either way, I never liked her.
Hailey's nails single handedly got me into doing my own nails 😂 I saw those glazed donut nails and went straight to Amazon. I feel like such a baddy whenever I do them now. She is a self care icon.
I was never on a Hailey hate train. Not bc I am a fan or I hate Selena but. Whole internet hating on grown woman bc of her ex boyfriend and imaginary fights on internet while we legit have grapist and mrders in Hollywood. It’s easy to hate on women cuz I saw A LOT of MEN talking about this situation (??????????) but when it’s man fault no one talks about it. What about Cody Ko? He will NEVER get the same amount of hate for fcking a teen than Hailey did for “stealing hair style or dress from Selena” 😂
I hate this one so much. “Oh she stole looks from Selena” as if they weren’t all in Hollywood following the same fashion trends and wearing similar stuff constantly.
BAM. This. It’s because we don’t see criticizing women as a problem- if men do something messed up then it was just a mistake but if it’s a woman, her entire morality is questioned
nah I think she's bad for Justin, since she's SPEAKING FOR HIM/CONTROLLING HIS SOCIALS. Her uncle is Diddy's friend, so are her karjenner friends- deep ties to diddy. She's one of diddy's people who diddy got to replace Sel in Justin's circle so justin parties more. She also stalked Sel on socials, when Sel went to rehab, when Sel went to a restuarant, & when nearby Sel's house. She's batshit. She sounds nice but she also said RACIST things. She's diddy's chess piece. Personally i don't like her or care abt her but she's an annoying stalker who also stalked justin nd got him to Diddy's pleasure. I liked JB before she came along, I always liked his music even when he got hate. It baffles me all her fans think Sel is coming btwn them but they're quite that Kourtney may have Justin's baby LMFOOOO The Karjenners SHARED JUSTIN WITH HAIELY- GROSS- but hailey fans act like Sel is coming btwn her "fairytale" romance. JB ignores Hailey, again haiely is his moutpiece, and SEL IS HAPPY WITH BENNY so why do hailey fans mock Lupus an ILLNESS and also bodyshame fans? I always see them talk about fans being ugly or fat, or Sel being _ or bodyshame her. And they mock Lupus all day. Sounds like Haiely is manipulating things to attack Sel fans or Swifties. W/e was said 5 years ago still was mean, like Hailey's racist comment. Swifties know it was 5 yrs ago. More importantly haiely's uncle has ties to Diddy, and hailey's karjenner friends have deeper ties to diddy and hailey speaks for justin/controls his socials. As well as stalks Sel on social media + when she went to rehab then to a restuarant + near her house
There’s a video by scandalous media that shows time and date stamped that most of the “haley copied selena” things were actually Selena copying Hailey- which really makes a lot of sense.
@@reshell7338 I see, you’re out here policing people on their opinions that you feel offended by, it seems. In fact, I did. She told me all about it in a private convo. But this is still my personal opinion about it. Happy now, officer? 🫡
@@blubird6448 it was a genuine question??? I wasn’t being shady or anything. Like did she say that online ?But anyway , if it’s your opinion state it ? Because you writes this as if it is a fact . Which we don’t know if it is unless she said it publicly.
I never hated hailey. She was smart with her leveling up strategies, her friendship, men, etc, and selena wasn't 🤷🏻♀️ selena is still dating someone who is wasting her time and people kept attacking hailey because justin choose to marry her. I am glad 😊 she is getting fame and recognition she wanted.
But the weird thing is that both justin and selena are both over their relationship and copying ur boyfriends ex isn't that deep and many girls kinda did it at least once, so the drama is almost entirely made up.
Even then in a lot of the outfit pictures if we look at dates Hailey wore most of them first anyways. Like it’s hard for me to feel bad for rich people at all but like dang people were really just trying to find reasons to attack this girl
The thing is, in a lot of the outfit copying pictures if we look at dates Hailey wore most of them first anyways. Like it’s hard for me to feel bad for rich people at all but like dang people were really just trying to find reasons to attack this girl
Tbh, Selena always gave me ick with her constant victimization of herself and manipulation of public. Hailey always felt more upfront and genuine. I am glad that Hailey managed to take off and Selena is pretty much irrelevant right now
When I still used TikTok I saw sooo many Videos about Her and how she allegdly bullys Selena.. then I saw the same about Selena. I never knew Hailey, but of course I knew Selena. Still I didnt care, they are both grown Woman and never attacked each other directly, as far as i know. I dont understand why so many People think they have to fight for Big Stars like them. They have all the Money to defend themselves. *but i always pitied Hailey for the way Justin treated her in so many Videos.
this is my favourite video of the series.loved that you pointed out the sensory marketing because i was definitely influenced by it so much that i didn’t even realize i started associating all the juicy, glazed things with her brand. keep making such videos
At last the girl has a name of her own. Good for her, she doesnt need the man when she now has character and individuality that people hadnt seen until now. Its like gaining confidence in YOURSELF for the first time.
Yeah I kinda feel like they stopped the bullying once she got pregnant. Their willing to harass grown women but a baby is where a lot of people draw the line
Not a fan of Selena or Hailey nor am I picking sides but to defend Hailey, she's actually pretty talentedand ppl calling her talentless don't do their research. I mean, Hailey used to be a ballerina but needed to permanently quit bc of an injury I think.
The whole hate train was caused by losers were assuming hailey was bofy shaming SG. And then when SG saw that it just filled the fire more! Alot HB copying accusations isnt even legit lol. Her G tattoo (HB) was gotten to praise a girl from their church who has an illness , alot of their members have a G to represent thay child. I can go on about it but hailey was never a mean girl like everyone says.
I love Hailey ❤ She is extremely resilient and patient!! I don’t know how she was able to move forward despite years of unprecedented hate… A true Icon ✨
People like to make their fav celebrities God, like they cant do no wrong or turn a blind eye to their toxic behaviours. Im glad Haily finally found her peace and her lane
What I find weird is that it's women in their late twenties and mostly in their thirties who were in the forefront of the Hailey Bieber hate train. Don't they have bills to pay? To me it seems as if they just want their childhood crush, Justin Bieber, to marry their bitter selves instead.
I think the reason Hailey (& Kendall) were considered mean girls for a while is simply the fact that they were not really interactive. They were just pretty, rich girls who lived in their own bubble & seemingly lost no sleep over other people's opinion of them & it ate people up inside. The minute they started showing a bit more personality & engaging more in parasocial relationships the whole 'mean girl' thing vanished.
no, karma is a bitch!! she got hated on (mainly from jelena fans, who even call her a man...), and now she gained more people who like her and she's soon-to-be mother!! truly blessed :) she deserves this, with all the hate she faced over silly things that shouldn't even concernt us random people in the first place tbh.
Don't even compare Haley and Selena. If Selena went through same shit that Haley went through, she would have been a permanent resident in Psych ward. That gurl still stuck during her Disney lala land. I used to like Selena as a kid but not anymore, i meant Selena is a 30 something woman who still act like an entitled child. The shade she threw at Haley just so her childish fans would go and torment Haley.
I never watched all these girls and dramas.. but kendall jenner videos were in my feed and saw few. out of those sister I ended up liking Hailey, she is atleast somewhat real and kind.
Oh my gosh, would love to see Taylor Swift! She's just the smartest business women and although I'm not a huge fan of her, she's amazing when it comes to staying relevent.
I'm so glad I never hated on hailey beiber. I feel like she honestly got to much hate, and everyone thinking of selena as a saint. Just because she's married to justin. There are much worse people who don't even get half the hate as hailey did, and I am happy for her now.
I think apart from rebranding and pr team, she is actually constantly trying to move on to other things and people got tired of hating her for no reason. And time, it passes and things that matter now, will not tomorrow. And i dont want to take her credit for perseverance but to move on despite falling over and over again is really helped by money. If you have money you can climb up from deepest of hell.
I genuinely felt like it's so dumb and sexist how most of the hate Haley got was the result of Justin's actions fr. But they would never criticize a man 🙄
Honestly, I'm a new subscriber but I do hope Hailey or Hailey's team see this video and get ideas because I fear she might do the mistake with the baby line. Other than that, your videos are so interesting! Keep them coming, you're teaching very useful things about the current world!
21:12 was thinking the exact same . Just a basic set of some skincare as pregnant women can not really take out much time with a extravagant set as after pregnancy entire focus is shifted towards the child and people usally ignoring the mother both lauches will be so apt. Especially if the price point is afordable as bearing a baby is already expensive.
20:08 i think it can be her stretch marks healing. because it's such a feared thing in society and woman relate to. she has a skincare brand and skincare does not only apply to face. i think it would be a good strategy to create that relatability with her again. like "she may be a icon but she's still a woman who struggles with the same things as we do."
Honestly she is inspiring for me after all the hate she got she was never negetive if you actually go and look for her interviews and how she really is aside from such speculations and the toxic hate you will find how amazing she is
👀Do you think Hailey Bieber has a successful rebrand?
👉🏻protect + enjoy online freedom without restrictions on 7 devices with CyberGhost VPN for 4 months free www.cyberghostvpn.com/zoeunlimited
Are you okay moving away in California? It’s hot with fires, expensive & much crime.
I think Hailey has always been super nice but Selunatics were harassing her
"if you brand yourself after someone else, you'd only ever be second best."
truer words haver never been spoken
this changed my perspective wow
tell this to ppl in dress to impress
@@ehywuehehewhhwomg foreal
Yes! Very proud of her success
Sending death threats about anyone just because you get “bad vibes” is actually delusional. Half of the people on TikTok need to go outside and stick their hands in dirt because wth 🤦♀️
I despise death threats, or insults. But the criticism had reasonable grounds.
getting bad vibes because someone was racist multiple times isn’t delusional, even if her remarks are old it still happened and people still have the right not to like her. i don’t agree with the death threats but for you to act like the only reason behind them is that she gives people “bad vibes” just makes me icky. like what?😭
@@sphxx7995still not a reason to send death threats. She was a kid, she’s an adult now.
I read this as 'stick their heads in dirt' and I was like you know what not a bad new take on the saying lol
Her mental is so inspiring for me. Like how did she do, seriously I’ve witnessed all the cyber bullying she went through. How did she just ignored that and move on ?
Definitely is because of her faith. I’ve heard her talk about how she gives all her worries to Jesus and it definitely gives her strength. Many people should have a spiritual base then they wouldn’t go around the world being so lost and resentful.
Money 😂
@@moonshadow6430 insecure…
Because shes a psychopath with histrionic disorder lol
because she knew what she was doing and foresaw the bullying part, she knew what she is getting in when she went for Justin Bieber
Watching Hailey's hate campaign unfold on TikTok was absolutely CRAZY! Her PR team deserves a good raise!
No cause I felt so bad for her. The way people were freaking out over the photo kylie posted which i’m pretty sure was for her mascara is crazy. I’m not even a kylie or hailey stan (I like hailey a lot though) but omg it was so weird & Selena purposefully adding fuel to the fire by commenting on tiktok about Hailey & all this extra stuff *sigh* I will say though it was very smart of Hailey to just move on & not freak out about it or cry on social media over it cause that would’ve made them bully her more.
@@rayeeiffel480I never understood anything about the hate, I even thought everyone wanted to be hailey Bieber and I was not chronically online lol but I felt in the rabbit hole and to me it seem like they both were trying to do things that would make ppl talk.
Um no they don’t……she doesn’t even have a pr. If she did, the whole hate train wouldn’t have happened. If she had a pr team, Selena’s past bad actions would’ve been amongst some of trending topics.
@@Kiran37369 Like the fact that despite preaching kindness and telling her fans not to attack Hailey, she was still liking posts hating on and attacking Hailey, posting vague posts (such as that one Taylor Swift video which was literally filmed 5 years) to encourage not only her fans but swifties to attack her
@@awhimsyreader9015 exactly! She was commenting on videos that were clearly hating on hailey. And after a while, she was yapping about how “I’m a feminist, I don’t support this blah blah blah” what a bad excuse of a feminist. Embarrassing us feminists smh
No matter how much you hate someone, bodyshaming someone with serious health issues is just toxic and wrong
Yes but we don't know if their tiktok was about her.
yall are sensitive and drama seekers, who said that tiktoks abt her? and whats with selena's body? so let me tell u this "u think her body is a problem, but u wanna fool yourself, so instead u wanna to defend her body when theres nothing to defend in the first place" so basically yall creating a drama to defend it and look as good person
What are you even talking about? She didn't bodyshamed Selena. It's not her fault Selena's fans are obsessed with a relationship that ended years ago so they relate everything Haley does to Selena.
she didn't
@@whywoulducareanyone notice how only girls who relate to hailey’s mean girl behavior are the ones defending her?
Honestly I always felt kinda bad for Hailey, so I’m happy for her now that she’s doing well. Selena is a queen too, they both deserve the respect and love they get
For Selena, she is extremely lucky even when she's already an old woman. If you watched her documentary she acts like an entitled child, (1) people are patient with her even she's reactive and passive aggressive that they didn't mirror her despite her victim mentality, (2) her friends are there to wake her up to remind her to take her pills, (3) have lots of money and health treatment so she is fine, (4) she is extremely lucky to have such an excellent PR team to take down or hide her mess so easily and clean her reputation.
I really hope she will seek help, she already said that she's in therapy since she was like 18? she is 32 now.
Me reading that Selena is an old woman LMAO. She's not even 35. What have we come to
@@patu.121 i think they meant "grown" woman
Yes!! Love seeing both win
@@patu.121They meant grown. And they’re right. She is lucky she has the best PR team in the world that can turn even her most messed up moments into a victim narrative for her. They knew exactly that if they overplayed her health issues they could get her unlimited sympathy. But she’s actually very cold and calculated. She’s brainwashed her fans so much that they care more that he cheated on her but don’t care that she literally hit him and screamed at him in public and there’s a video of that still online. So many things she’s done that are terrible but her fans can see no wrong. It’s scary.
her pr team never gave up and i want to congratulate them tbh, it took time but now she’s one of the most loved people on 2024
True. They did her wonders, good for her mental health.
Also Jack Blues helped a lot. Pregnancy awakenes the empathic instincts.
@@ela01921True like it’s kinda iconic she gave us baby bieber.
Which 2024 are you in? Cause whatttt
I’m actually happy for Hailey. After all she went through I think it’s only fair for her to have her peace now. Everyone deserves peace and happiness. So good on her.
She hasn't been held accountable. I recommend watching the videos on her stalking bieber from when she was young. Also justin is in a conservative church and an Uber zionist all while hailey is his submissive wifey and is friends with gigi hadid who as we all know is palestinian. She isn't the only celebrity who is this spineless but to rebrand a spineless make up guru as a heroine who finally punched herself out the trenches is icky
proud to say i never jumped on hailey bieber hate train. i'm tired of people seeing selena as saint, and hailey as evil. how can people be so dull and assume others are this shallow and not complex? anyways, i'm happy for hailey and justin!
Look. Selena is not hating on them. They are hating on her. So basicaly... That's all i need to know
@@lucijak3444 selena not hating on them?? hmmm didnt knew it was april
Ive always liked Hailey as well, Selena has always rubbed me the wrong way.
Same❤
@@lucijak3444selena is aware of the power she holds, still choses to let things be and directs her fans to hate on hailey
I like that you said the universe gives us the same love we give ourselves.
I need a video about Sabrina Carpenter!!! Her journey is really inspirational
Omg u got a heart frm her means there r chances 😂
@@MelophileKuku let's hope so!!! 🙏
Yes she deserves all the love and support after the hatred she got that she didn't deserve
Fr the hate on sabrina for no reason was crazy :(((
yo! she made one. did you see it?
Another example of prejudice, constant comparison and bullying is Victoria Justice. Finally, people are realizing how horribly and unfairly she was treated!! Hope, she gets everything best in life as well ❤
Justice for Victoria Justice !
I’ve witnessed how the internet hated her, but what inspires me the most is how she handled those backlashes with courage. She never gave attention to the negativity or sought revenge. Instead, she focused on loving herself even more despite the hate from people who don't contribute to her life. Her mindset is what truly inspires me-she never let a single hateful comment destroy her. Instead, she stayed focused on her own life, converting the negative attention into something positive and beneficial. That's why she has an even bigger brand now.
I have come to this conclusion about people including myself of course and it came after living for 30 years on this earth, people are sheep, but they don't like to graze the same pasture all the time (we wont keep liking/hating the same thing for a very long time at the same rate).
As long as something doesn't happens to us personally we will move on from anything.
Our minds move over literally anything.
she won sort of
@@DianaOsazenaye that's what I am saying people's opinions keep varying, the smart ones are those who knows when is the right time to make money.
wait this is so true omg
In China we say: 人云亦云
I found it odd that the hate she got "mean girl" based on "vibes" people got from her led people to ACTUALLY be mean to her in return?
she is a racist zion man
She is a mean girl tho. She had so many racist tweets
@finalgirl13 being mean to someone mean doesn't make you less mean. And her being racist as a teenager doesn't warrant a witch hunt of her as an adult. Like the racist claims are valid but they go out the window when you look at the amount of hate which isn't even direct criticism of her past. People will say stuff like "ugly, bully wannabe. That's what you get for being racist" (odd example 😭) but you get my point. They won't address the distasteful things but just randomly have them there like a tag on in their slander.
@@finalgirl1390% of people do not hate her for her racist comments but rather for being the wife of JB. They couldn’t care less about it and it does in fact help them justify their hatred towards her .
@@carollitchfield6649 and yet brook Schofield is a thing. White women don’t get to decide who black people forgive for being racist
Ok i never understood how ppl completely forgot that selena was the one who started the drama back in 2023.She was commenting on tiktoks which were 10years old of hailey trying to start beef like how is no one talking about that?(im not tryna hate on anyone but saying hailey was the attention seeker while selena was doing all this is just wrong)
lol this is so wrong. bruh 🤦♀🤦♀
@@Mia15239It's very true,I also seen the same at that time lol
@@RT-yq4coyou need to google celebdeepdive Justin Selena hailey and actually read where the roots began. You will see how hailey was involved from the start with Kendall. Don’t talk shit until you done your research or you look stupid.
Wasn't TikTok created in 2016?
I started watching Hailey's vlogs last year,since then I love her sm.She is so strong cuz if I went through what she went,I would not survive.
, äv. D
The extreme Hailey Beiber hate showed me how mentally ill and chronically online we’ve become as a society.
We don’t know this girl personally. She really doesn’t have any impact on our life. Yet she made one tik tok with one popular sound, people just assumed was about Selena Gomez. And the internet had a visceral reaction to her for months. People that commit war crimes don’t get nearly the online hate Hailey Beiber did.
Fr
Yep
Determining love or hate towards a celebrity without personal interactions and knowledge is a conversant concept in hollywood. We blindly go defending or hating people based on what we see, or assume. Hollywood has entirely reckoned itself on superficiality and forgery.
Returning to your comment, her choice of audio was clearly too accurate to be a happenstance. And believe it or not, the hate or the love we give to these strangers turn into millions of dollars. Hollywood is an aforethought industry, so whatever you see on social media is probably planned to attract attention, negative or positive. Whatever that happened, made her one of the most talked people on earth. So, I'd advise you to not pity these people.
If I were her, experiencing such a hate on Internet and a real life, I'd end up with depression, for sure.
I'm so happy for her because the hate she has gone through was just unacceptable.
I always liked Hailey. She has very calm vibes for me and would like friend like her. Very calm and friendly ❤ like her makeup choices and aesthetic ❤
Me too
I love that she’s getting this appreciation 🥰 there are still haters but they’re just nobodies with nothing to do with their life 🙄
as a long term Justin fan i could be biased but when their pictures came out them crying on the side of the road after getting married my heart broke for them. I was like this is the kind of hate thats gonna last sadly but i never imagined it would last this long.
Hating is so dumb.
My hot take on this:
Selena’s fans have been screaming her name at Hailey for years and treating Hailey like shit for just being married to Selena’s ex… and Selena “the good girl” never said a thing.
Selena is not the angel everyone says she is, because she literally only spoke against her fans coming for Hailey when it was trending… and thats kinda tea 😳
Hailey Bieber has racist tweets and real Selena fans don’t give fuck about her. Bieber is also a Zionist
They are the reflection of their idol.
So true!the way selena first cries and acts sad about all the rumours which ofc makes her fans target hailey then says dont spread hate guys....like wtf u literally initiated it.
@@chrissis1944 who? Because I’m black and can’t stand Hailey and Justin’s racist selves
I have always found Selena of the victim mentality and even if not, let's not deny that she marketed off her ex. The songs, the dramatic interviews/ stage performances all to gain more sympathy from the public. She's either a true mean gal or a really smart businesswoman,, either way, I never liked her.
2:07 Good. *You finally put your degree in a plastic sleeve* Throwing that thing around too much 🤦🏼♂️🤣
It was about to turn to shreds 😅
LMFAOO I laugh every time she throws that thing around and then quietly picks it up 😅😭🤣💀💀
Hailey's nails single handedly got me into doing my own nails 😂 I saw those glazed donut nails and went straight to Amazon. I feel like such a baddy whenever I do them now. She is a self care icon.
Drop the links lol I need to start doing my own nails
I was never on a Hailey hate train. Not bc I am a fan or I hate Selena but. Whole internet hating on grown woman bc of her ex boyfriend and imaginary fights on internet while we legit have grapist and mrders in Hollywood. It’s easy to hate on women cuz I saw A LOT of MEN talking about this situation (??????????) but when it’s man fault no one talks about it. What about Cody Ko? He will NEVER get the same amount of hate for fcking a teen than Hailey did for “stealing hair style or dress from Selena” 😂
It is also stupid, that she stole looks from Selena. As if 2 people couldn't wear the same outfit. People have too much time
I hate this one so much. “Oh she stole looks from Selena” as if they weren’t all in Hollywood following the same fashion trends and wearing similar stuff constantly.
BAM. This. It’s because we don’t see criticizing women as a problem- if men do something messed up then it was just a mistake but if it’s a woman, her entire morality is questioned
This!!
nah I think she's bad for Justin, since she's SPEAKING FOR HIM/CONTROLLING HIS SOCIALS. Her uncle is Diddy's friend, so are her karjenner friends- deep ties to diddy. She's one of diddy's people who diddy got to replace Sel in Justin's circle so justin parties more. She also stalked Sel on socials, when Sel went to rehab, when Sel went to a restuarant, & when nearby Sel's house.
She's batshit. She sounds nice but she also said RACIST things. She's diddy's chess piece.
Personally i don't like her or care abt her but she's an annoying stalker who also stalked justin nd got him to Diddy's pleasure. I liked JB before she came along, I always liked his music even when he got hate.
It baffles me all her fans think Sel is coming btwn them but they're quite that Kourtney may have Justin's baby LMFOOOO
The Karjenners SHARED JUSTIN WITH HAIELY- GROSS- but hailey fans act like Sel is coming btwn her "fairytale" romance. JB ignores Hailey, again haiely is his moutpiece, and SEL IS HAPPY WITH BENNY
so why do hailey fans mock Lupus an ILLNESS and also bodyshame fans? I always see them talk about fans being ugly or fat, or Sel being _ or bodyshame her. And they mock Lupus all day. Sounds like Haiely is manipulating things to attack Sel fans or Swifties. W/e was said 5 years ago still was mean, like Hailey's racist comment. Swifties know it was 5 yrs ago. More importantly haiely's uncle has ties to Diddy, and hailey's karjenner friends have deeper ties to diddy and hailey speaks for justin/controls his socials. As well as stalks Sel on social media + when she went to rehab then to a restuarant + near her house
There’s a video by scandalous media that shows time and date stamped that most of the “haley copied selena” things were actually Selena copying Hailey- which really makes a lot of sense.
ikr! i saw their content too!
Omg I saw that and it’s so creepy ngl
Guys....she was a fan of Justin and Selena before this all things...of course it would make sense...
Scandalous media presented facts and i gasped when u realised. I watched that Love triangle one too. Selena fans are insane
I am so happy to see the hate against hailey finally coming to an end. Let's be honest she didn't deserve all that.
She deserves it cause she’s racist
I think it’s more of she just finally became comfortable with being her authentic self rather than trying to play into being JB’s girlfriend
She is his wife tho ?
@@reshell7338 Yeah and she was his gf before that, which negatively impacted her self esteem imo
@@blubird6448 How did it affect her self esteem ? Did she tell you that?
@@reshell7338 I see, you’re out here policing people on their opinions that you feel offended by, it seems. In fact, I did. She told me all about it in a private convo. But this is still my personal opinion about it. Happy now, officer? 🫡
@@blubird6448 it was a genuine question??? I wasn’t being shady or anything. Like did she say that online ?But anyway , if it’s your opinion state it ? Because you writes this as if it is a fact . Which we don’t know if it is unless she said it publicly.
The visuals in this video are phenomenal. Extremely well done.
She is an inspiration to look ahead and achieve it than to look back and regret...period ❤
Oh Hailey, they can never make me hate you
I never hated hailey. She was smart with her leveling up strategies, her friendship, men, etc, and selena wasn't 🤷🏻♀️ selena is still dating someone who is wasting her time and people kept attacking hailey because justin choose to marry her. I am glad 😊 she is getting fame and recognition she wanted.
i feel weird being this early i feel like i should come back thirty minutes from now or something lmao
Ikr lol
Same
are you back yet
This just dropped at 4 am (my time) and I clicked immediately😂
lol yes this is making me very anxious
But the weird thing is that both justin and selena are both over their relationship and copying ur boyfriends ex isn't that deep and many girls kinda did it at least once, so the drama is almost entirely made up.
Even then in a lot of the outfit pictures if we look at dates Hailey wore most of them first anyways. Like it’s hard for me to feel bad for rich people at all but like dang people were really just trying to find reasons to attack this girl
Huh ? I've never copied someone else's ex and I would never do that wtf 💀
There's no need to be such a wannabe, find a damn personality.
Selena hasn’t moved on tho ? Like maybe in 2024 she has but back then she absolutely did not
Selena is a wannabeeee nd a bully pick me
@@reshell7338pretty sure they both moved on. She just took her time to heal
The thing is, in a lot of the outfit copying pictures if we look at dates Hailey wore most of them first anyways. Like it’s hard for me to feel bad for rich people at all but like dang people were really just trying to find reasons to attack this girl
Seriously like in a lot of instances its hailey doing the things first then selena..so according to their theory whos the one copying here.
Tbh, Selena always gave me ick with her constant victimization of herself and manipulation of public. Hailey always felt more upfront and genuine. I am glad that Hailey managed to take off and Selena is pretty much irrelevant right now
Both selena and hailey deserves respect
When I still used TikTok I saw sooo many Videos about Her and how she allegdly bullys Selena.. then I saw the same about Selena. I never knew Hailey, but of course I knew Selena. Still I didnt care, they are both grown Woman and never attacked each other directly, as far as i know. I dont understand why so many People think they have to fight for Big Stars like them. They have all the Money to defend themselves. *but i always pitied Hailey for the way Justin treated her in so many Videos.
I agree, I think the same as you
Please do Selena Gomez next cause she is so shady who always act like she’s a saint and her obsessive fans are something to be studied
Yes yes yes!!!!
Wow this was so brilliantly put! 🌟 I am in Marketing, and I've learned so much from this 22 minute video, brilliant.
this is my favourite video of the series.loved that you pointed out the sensory marketing because i was definitely influenced by it so much that i didn’t even realize i started associating all the juicy, glazed things with her brand.
keep making such videos
At last the girl has a name of her own. Good for her, she doesnt need the man when she now has character and individuality that people hadnt seen until now. Its like gaining confidence in YOURSELF for the first time.
It's not the "genius" rebranding, It's just that people are stupid. That's it.
Yeah I kinda feel like they stopped the bullying once she got pregnant. Their willing to harass grown women but a baby is where a lot of people draw the line
people blindly believeing selena are stupid. make your own judgement based on what you see, not what people tell you happened
Its both
Finally someone said it :D
@@julia8292just like you kiddo
I don't use IG or whatever, I am not doing makeup at all, but I really like Hailey's style. Kinda classy, would say
Not a fan of Selena or Hailey nor am I picking sides but to defend Hailey, she's actually pretty talentedand ppl calling her talentless don't do their research. I mean, Hailey used to be a ballerina but needed to permanently quit bc of an injury I think.
She’s classy af
I wanna hear the story of success about Lady Gaga. How she turned from Monster Queen to a Jazz Queen. Please 🙏
I felt bad for Hailey.. I felt bad for Selena. I hope both their stories end in peace and happiness.
The whole hate train was caused by losers were assuming hailey was bofy shaming SG. And then when SG saw that it just filled the fire more! Alot HB copying accusations isnt even legit lol. Her G tattoo (HB) was gotten to praise a girl from their church who has an illness , alot of their members have a G to represent thay child. I can go on about it but hailey was never a mean girl like everyone says.
Gurl same
lol
I have never understood the whole “I hate Hailey” thing. Ppl need to grow up😂
Once who realize who the real problem is, you will never hate hailey you may not have opinions about her or like her but won't "hate" that's for sure.
I love Hailey ❤ She is extremely resilient and patient!! I don’t know how she was able to move forward despite years of unprecedented hate… A true Icon ✨
Say what you want about her persona, but she's a genius businesswoman and has a great team.
I've only watched a few videos of her talking, and all the comments are always about how eloquent she is, doubt she was copying an ex dosney star
okay, i love ur videos, i need a brat marketing video pleaseeeee!!
People like to make their fav celebrities God, like they cant do no wrong or turn a blind eye to their toxic behaviours. Im glad Haily finally found her peace and her lane
I’ll never get tired of watching you toss that MARKETING DEGREE like a used tissue
😂😂
I like percy Jackson
Ahhh of course
The random I love Percy Jackson
Me too!!!
ME TOO!!!!!
Best comment
same
Real
Hailey bieber never even shaded selena it was the internet that said that argue with the wall
Wow, ppl hated her so much for just being rich and unbothered to a point that she became a businesswoman, just so that people could admire her, lol 😅
Never hated Hailey. She’s always been mature and carried herself with class. Love her❤️
Can you analyze Sabrina Carpenter next? Please 😊
I agree
You ment please please please
What I find weird is that it's women in their late twenties and mostly in their thirties who were in the forefront of the Hailey Bieber hate train. Don't they have bills to pay? To me it seems as if they just want their childhood crush, Justin Bieber, to marry their bitter selves instead.
I don't understand dude... Hailey is one of my favourite celebrities out there
I think the reason Hailey (& Kendall) were considered mean girls for a while is simply the fact that they were not really interactive. They were just pretty, rich girls who lived in their own bubble & seemingly lost no sleep over other people's opinion of them & it ate people up inside.
The minute they started showing a bit more personality & engaging more in parasocial relationships the whole 'mean girl' thing vanished.
no, karma is a bitch!! she got hated on (mainly from jelena fans, who even call her a man...), and now she gained more people who like her and she's soon-to-be mother!! truly blessed :) she deserves this, with all the hate she faced over silly things that shouldn't even concernt us random people in the first place tbh.
And the amount of hate she got I would literally die she is so strong and deserve happiness for sure
For the marketing analysis videos, you should do Taylor Swift next 👀
not me wearing the same EXACT grey shirt and gold necklace as the girl getting the smoothie rn
21:50 Not to the world, just to the US.
I would love to see an analyze of Kendall brand ! Thank you for this video
This is such a well made video. Loved every bit of it.
OMG you're analysis are genius! Please create a course to teach us. I'd love to learn how to assess personal brands like this
Don't even compare Haley and Selena. If Selena went through same shit that Haley went through, she would have been a permanent resident in Psych ward. That gurl still stuck during her Disney lala land. I used to like Selena as a kid but not anymore, i meant Selena is a 30 something woman who still act like an entitled child. The shade she threw at Haley just so her childish fans would go and torment Haley.
Its kinda inspiring how she managed to embrace the hate even if I don't personally like her. No hate, she just isn’t for me
Leave. The. Girl. Alone!
Thank you for all your beautiful work -- your videos and the deep and original thought AND playfulness behind them do not go unnoticed
I never watched all these girls and dramas.. but kendall jenner videos were in my feed and saw few. out of those sister I ended up liking Hailey, she is atleast somewhat real and kind.
People on Internet change as the weather 🫤🫤, really hope 3 of them have happy healthly live.
WAKE UP THE QUEEN POSTED
i like your marketing videos! a very nice format!!!
Oh my gosh, would love to see Taylor Swift! She's just the smartest business women and although I'm not a huge fan of her, she's amazing when it comes to staying relevent.
hailey went through so much bullying (and still does), kudos to her for being strong
What a beautiful episode. Thank you!
I'm so glad I never hated on hailey beiber. I feel like she honestly got to much hate, and everyone thinking of selena as a saint. Just because she's married to justin. There are much worse people who don't even get half the hate as hailey did, and I am happy for her now.
I think apart from rebranding and pr team, she is actually constantly trying to move on to other things and people got tired of hating her for no reason. And time, it passes and things that matter now, will not tomorrow.
And i dont want to take her credit for perseverance but to move on despite falling over and over again is really helped by money.
If you have money you can climb up from deepest of hell.
I’ve never hated on hailey im so happy for her !!!❤
There is no way to explain away Justin slamming the car door on Hailey. No matter what was going on, no way.
I genuinely felt like it's so dumb and sexist how most of the hate Haley got was the result of Justin's actions fr. But they would never criticize a man 🙄
Honestly, I'm a new subscriber but I do hope Hailey or Hailey's team see this video and get ideas because I fear she might do the mistake with the baby line.
Other than that, your videos are so interesting! Keep them coming, you're teaching very useful things about the current world!
I’ve always loved Hailey, I think she’s always been a sweetie
21:12 was thinking the exact same . Just a basic set of some skincare as pregnant women can not really take out much time with a extravagant set as after pregnancy entire focus is shifted towards the child and people usally ignoring the mother both lauches will be so apt. Especially if the price point is afordable as bearing a baby is already expensive.
They all hate her because they ain't her😂❤! They can never make me hate her.
I love this series! Keep it going
First of all, she didn’t invent the glazed dewy face look… she robbed it from Koreans who have been doing this for decades. Plain n simple.
Bro it’s marketing where korean beauty products are marketed as glass skin providers she REBRANDED it as dewy skin
20:08 i think it can be her stretch marks healing. because it's such a feared thing in society and woman relate to. she has a skincare brand and skincare does not only apply to face. i think it would be a good strategy to create that relatability with her again. like "she may be a icon but she's still a woman who struggles with the same things as we do."
Hailey's stunning skin is 90% good genes and 10% good dermatologist and expensive skincare that definitely isn't her own brand.
Honestly she is inspiring for me after all the hate she got she was never negetive if you actually go and look for her interviews and how she really is aside from such speculations and the toxic hate you will find how amazing she is