JS Bach is a music God but there are many things like your work and interpretation that also deserve respect and admiration. Thank you for your achievement
Wow, first time I hear this piece in a solo arrangement, and I love your performance ! Both voices are well separated. Your concentration is visible, and it only adds to the charm :) Thanks a lot for providing the sheet music !
Thank you very much! If I remember correctly, I was probably so focused because I had to record the piece several times until I was satisfied with something I liked.
In my own experience with Bach, it depends on the number of voices in the piece. That's why some pieces that mostly consist of 2-3 voices work so well, such as the BWV998, BWV1003, or this Invention. Sometimes I try to arrange a piece, but it doesn't quite fit for solo guitar, so I either modify it for two guitars or choose a different piece.
@@journeymancellist9247 I'm glad you liked it. I usually try to keep my videos focused on the piece itself to respect viewers' time, but I'll definitely consider your suggestion. I appreciate your feedback!
Wow that's excellent! I love it! And I love the warm sound of the guitar. I'm learning this piece in piano now and I can't even imagine how hard it must be playing it in guitar (I've tried learning to play guitar before).
Thank you for watching! I guess since Bach originally composed this piece for clavier a lot of the hand movements are more natural in the keyboard. Guitarrists usually play this piece in a duet but since I wanted to play it solo it's a bit more difficult!
@@galapagator Muchas gracias! La verdad que vi la partitura para teclado y pensé que podía ir bien para guitarra aunque es algo más dificil de lo que me esperaba!
Thank you! If I remember correctly, Bach used to incorporate parts of his other works quite frequently. Therefore, it's very possible that he took some motifs from this piece for the BWV 997."
I am playing by ear since 1985. They tell a joke - How do you silence a room full of blaring electr. guitars? Just lay out before them some sheet music . Have a great day.@@jchacecosas656
Wonderful! I didn't know this could work on one guitar. Have you ever heard Bela Fleck's version? It's pretty cool but I think it's for multiple instruments
@@tomphillips6743 Thank you! I had to change some of the notes but it's very much playable on one guitar. I haven't check Fleck's version, I'll check it out!
I also wonder how to start practice this piece like you, should we first practice particular chords hand shape? or to realize how to play two parts with one hand in the beginning? thank you !!!
@@燕規輪_布袋戲分享 I almost always analyze the piece to understand the full structure, after I have all the phrases figured out I study them in small motiffs but always with all the notes and dynamics.
JS Bach is a music God but there are many things like your work and interpretation that also deserve respect and admiration. Thank you for your achievement
I'm glad you appreciate my work. It means a lot to me. :D
I never thought this piece can be played on one guitar. I loved it !! thank you very much.
ギターソロでのインベンション、素晴らしいです！
ベースラインのまとめ方がすごい。
アレンジ譜ＰＤＦもありがとうございます。自分も練習します！
Wow, first time I hear this piece in a solo arrangement, and I love your performance ! Both voices are well separated. Your concentration is visible, and it only adds to the charm :) Thanks a lot for providing the sheet music !
Thank you very much! If I remember correctly, I was probably so focused because I had to record the piece several times until I was satisfied with something I liked.
insane, and i dont feel alone anymore to do strong faces when i play an hard piece ! :p
I've tried to fix it but I just can't hahaha
@@jchacecosas656same here, I do the same faces you do and I can't play without doing it lol
@@silasward7316 we are cursed to make silly faces for eternity 🗿
1:30 ("is it still recording?" look, towards the end of this very nice performance :))) well done !
Yes, I had to check! 🤣 Thank you!
es increíble ver la reacción del cuerpo al estar analizando cosas tan complejas al momento de ejecutar un instrumento, simplemente extraordinario
Gracias! Aunque la verdad a veces hago muchos movimientos innecesarios 😅
Phew... got there in the end. I loved the tempo.
Yep, I thought that it was going to be an easy piece but it was surprisingly difficult!
Perfect transcription. Thanks so much for making it available.
Thank you for checking my video!
Aw man I love that you put the sheet music under
@@DrStabkill Thank you! I thought it might help some people, so I ended up putting it in all my videos.
Best Bach A minor Invention for guitar I've heard!!
Thank you!
Thank you so much for your beautiful performance, the simultaneous score editing at the bottom, and the download! 🙏
Thank you for watching!
I'm stunned.....
Thank you so much! Well done and I've never even heard this before, hence a true gift.
Thank you!
Superb performance for this hard piece !
Thank you!
Great playing I love that song
Thank you!
Great stuff! Never heard it for a solo guitar.
@@MrBachianas thank you!
Why does Bach come over so well on the guitar...is it just he brilliant work of transcribers ? Or is it meant to be playable for ordinary musician's?
In my own experience with Bach, it depends on the number of voices in the piece. That's why some pieces that mostly consist of 2-3 voices work so well, such as the BWV998, BWV1003, or this Invention. Sometimes I try to arrange a piece, but it doesn't quite fit for solo guitar, so I either modify it for two guitars or choose a different piece.
One bit of stage suggestion. When you’re finished, smile at the camera, because you’ve just done something to be proud of.. and you did. well done!
@@journeymancellist9247 I'm glad you liked it. I usually try to keep my videos focused on the piece itself to respect viewers' time, but I'll definitely consider your suggestion. I appreciate your feedback!
WHOA! YOU’RE A MADMAN! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Congrats for both arrangement and the performance. 🙂
Thank you!
Wow that's excellent! I love it! And I love the warm sound of the guitar. I'm learning this piece in piano now and I can't even imagine how hard it must be playing it in guitar (I've tried learning to play guitar before).
Thank you! It was a bit difficult at first due to some left hand positions, but it went well at the end.
thanks bro , this was amazing to watch very well played! I'll make sure to practice this beautiful piece with joy
Thank you! I hope you have fun learning it!
Lovely! 💐🧡Am learning this on piano presently. Can't imagine guitar! Challenging! Very good!
Thank you!
nice play!!!!!
I didn't know Top G Tate classical guitar.
you forgot the verb
From France : Magnifique !
Thank you very much!
Beautifully performed!
@@isaacfinkelstein1275 thank you!
Great performance. Interesting that I can do justice to Bach's two-part inventions on the piano, yet struggle with them on guitar.
Thank you for watching!
I guess since Bach originally composed this piece for clavier a lot of the hand movements are more natural in the keyboard.
Guitarrists usually play this piece in a duet but since I wanted to play it solo it's a bit more difficult!
Pianists play one part with each hand - how hard can that be ;)
Guitarists play BOTH parts with BOTH hands! No wonder, you struggle - we all do...
Really nice work - well articulated - bravo!
Thanks a lot!
Very nice playing. Thank you so much for the transcription. Much appreciated!
No sé como Dios has conseguido sacar esta maravilla. Enhorabuena, caballero. Voy a usar su vídeo para intentar poder emularle. Gracias.
@@galapagator Muchas gracias! La verdad que vi la partitura para teclado y pensé que podía ir bien para guitarra aunque es algo más dificil de lo que me esperaba!
thanks for the transciption hage!
Thank you Senjougahara
The voices are clear...
Thanks! In some places there are some mistakes but in general I'm happy with the final result.
Great performance, especially the music!👏👏👏
You can see by the expressions... The struggle of Bach over your fingers and your brain hehe cheers, incredible master execution
Thank you! To be fair, Bach is always hard for us guitarists!
Stunning transcription and performance! ❤
@@NiallsSongs thank you!
BRAVO!
Thank you!
You nailed that, bud!
Tocas la gitarra muy bien!
Muchas gracias!
Excellent. Thanks for share.
Thank you for watching!
You sound amazing! Thanks for the notes👍
Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it.
great job, thanks for the score
Thank you!
Редкая партитура и хорошее исполнение. 👏
this is just amazing.
Thank you!
nicely played
@@Ana_crusis thank you!
Muy buena la invención a dos voces! Me gusta la interpretación!
Muchas gracias!
nice work man
Gracias mi estimado por compartirnos esto
Wonderful. Very well done.
Thank you!
Exelente, me encanto, saludos desde Argentina!!!👍🎼🎶🎸
@@anibalsebastian369 muchas gracias!
Bravo! Great work!
Thank you.
Lovely playing :3
Thank you Mr. Cat!
this is so good!
Thank you!
Super nice!
Thank you!
I swear I can hear traces of 997 in there.
Excellent playing by the way.
Thank you! If I remember correctly, Bach used to incorporate parts of his other works quite frequently. Therefore, it's very possible that he took some motifs from this piece for the BWV 997."
That was absolutly amazing - From Israel.
Thank you!
I am playing by ear since 1985. They tell a joke - How do you silence a room full of blaring electr. guitars? Just lay out before them some sheet music . Have a great day.@@jchacecosas656
Looks fearsomely difficult, but you really went for it! Very nice, thanks.
Thank you!
Сейчас учу это прекрасное произведение 🤘🤘🤘
Тяжело даётся в обучении ? Сложная аппликатура ?
@@angelofjustice4066
Аппликатура в норме, но заучить сложно, но я не сдаюсь🤘🤘🤘
Brilliant.
@@jonathanbanks9500 thank you!
Brilliant!
That's very nice, thanks! Wowi
Very nicely played.
Thank you!
Excellent! I really enjoyed it! 👏👏
Glad you enjoyed it!
Parabéns. Nota-se a sua grande vontade de fazer bem feito e sempre melhor. Gostei
Thanks a lot!
Thanks for the sheet!
Thank you for watching!
good work
Buen arreglo!
Obrigado!
NICE!
Thank you!
perfect paying
Thank you!
Excellent!
Thank you!
EXCELENTE
Muchas gracias!
awesome !!!
Thank you!
Well done sir 👍🏻👍🏻
Thanks a lot!
Excellent
Excelente!
Muchas gracias!
Buen trabajo
Muchas gracias!
!!!!nice play @!!!!
Thank you!
Great pacing... sensitive interoretation
Thank you!
Wow😮
Incredibile 😮😮bravooooo
Thank you!
Unreal
Excellent. A real knuckle buster.
Thank you! It was a bit difficult but fortunately it was also a short piece.
super !
Epic
Thank you!
Wonderful! I didn't know this could work on one guitar. Have you ever heard Bela Fleck's version? It's pretty cool but I think it's for multiple instruments
@@tomphillips6743 Thank you! I had to change some of the notes but it's very much playable on one guitar. I haven't check Fleck's version, I'll check it out!
I also wonder how to start practice this piece like you, should we first practice particular chords hand shape? or to realize how to play two parts with one hand in the beginning? thank you !!!
@@燕規輪_布袋戲分享 I almost always analyze the piece to understand the full structure, after I have all the phrases figured out I study them in small motiffs but always with all the notes and dynamics.
Bravissimo🎉
Thank you!
Hey, what an awesome recording and sheet music ! Thank you so much !
Thank you for checking my video!
wow.
Guitar virtuoso
Thank you!
Amazing : )
Thank you.
Your faces playing it are so funny, well played, beautifuly
Hahaha, yes, it happens when the piece is a bit difficult! Thank you for watching!
Bravo🎵🎶🎵♥️
Excellent ! Congrats. Do you have it in tab ?
Thank you! I don't use tablatures often so I don't have them, sorry!
@@jchacecosas656 thank you for tour answer
Genial!
Thank you for sharing the score. It seems like getting harder every several bars. 😂
It really gets very hard at the end.
He has 'metronome face' - he is pushing himself past his comfor zone with reagrds to the tempo. You can slow it down, I won't tell. I promise!
😊
top