I agree with your rationale for how to assemble the single album version (although it absolutely could and should be 15 tracks instead of 14, which then enables a more equitable 6 for each Paul and John). And your side 1 is great and nearly the same as mine, but your side 2 falls apart completely with what was included versus what was left off. On my side 2, Martha My Dear, I Will and Rocky Racoon would be Paul's Songs, and Everybody's got something to Hide, I'm So Tired, and Cry Baby Cry would be John's and Savoy Truffle would be George's, with album ending with Cry Baby cry. . My version would then have Birthday/Helter Skelter released as a non-album single, as well as Mother Nature's Son/Yer Blues as another single. But ultimately, every attempt to do this best single white album game fails, because no one can agree on which songs to include, because there are just too many great songs to ever fit onto a single album. I've done this many times with many different people, and every single one of them picks a different selection of songs as 'the best 14 or 15'. So, yes, the white album is the greatest double album ever, even with all its imperfections.
My selection for a single White Album would be: Side one 01. "Back in the U.S.S.R." 02. "Dear Prudence" 03. "Glass Onion" 04. "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da" 05. "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" 06. "Happiness Is a Warm Gun" 07. "Martha My Dear" 08. "Blackbird" Total length: 24:23 Side two 01. "Birthday" 02. "Not Guilty" 03. "Mother Nature's Son" 04. "Sexy Sadie" 05. "I Will" 06. "Savoy Truffle" 07. "Cry Baby Cry" 08. "Good Night" Total length: 23:05
@@andrewashdown3541 It's an outtake from the White album sessions written by George Harrison, which he re-recorded in 1978 for his 1979 album George Harrison. It can be found on The Beatles Anthology 3 and then on The Beatles: 50th Anniversary Edition.
For me you've got this close to my selections. I would've dumped 3 Lennon songs (Glass Onion, Yer Blues & Good Night) - and put in 3 other Lennon songs (I'm So Tired, Everybody's Got Something To Hide & Sexy Sadie). Eight songs per side would have worked. I would include "I Will" & "Savoy Truffle" (George deserves 3).
This attempt makes more sense than any other attempt I've ever seen! Even though I'd personally have had more John songs on the second side and got rid of some Paul songs. But very interesting
There are usually two ways of compiling a single white album. One is based on what could reasonably be expected that the Beatles themselves would release given the circumstances of the time, the other is based on songs you personally like or dislike. This can be further broken down into two formats, one being what could fit on a vinyl record, and the other being a digital playlist or CD that has no strict time limits. In every case each Beatles fan comes up with a different list! I even come up with a slightly different list myself every time I think about this, most songs remain the same but some get swapped out. Luckily we have playlists and each fan can make a White Album to suit their own preferences, and it can be of any length. My own WA playlist remains consistent, too much for a single album, not enough for a double, but on a playlist the time doesn't matter. I got rid of songs I don't particularly care for and added in Hey Jude and the unreleased Not Guilty and Child Of Nature. If anyone cares, this is my WA playlist: Back in the U.S.S.R. Dear Prudence Glass onion Ob-la-di, ob-la-da Child Of Nature While my guitar gently weeps Martha my dear I'm so tired Blackbird Piggies Don't pass me by I will Julia Birthday Not Guilty Mother nature's son Everybodys got ~ monkey Sexy Sadie Helter skelter Long long long Revolution (single) Honey Pie Cry baby cry Hey Jude Deleted Wild honey pie, The continuing story of Bungalow Bill, Happiness is a warm gun, Rocky Raccoon, Why don't we do it in the road, Yer blues, Revolution 1, Savoy truffle, Revolution 9, Good night.
Mine Side 1 1. Back in the USSR 2. Dear Prudence 3. While my Guitar Gently Weeps 4. Martha My Dear 5. Don’t Pass me by 6. BlackBird 7. Julia Runtime| 22:58 Side 2 1. Revolution 1 2. Helter Skelter 3. Long Long Long 4. Revolution 9 5. Good Night Runtime| 23:29 I like the idea of having a normal Side 1, and a deranged Side 2.
White Album double album is just a crazy album and I really love it. Don’t Pass Me By is one of the weaker songs do it would definitely have to go and Good Night is such a perfect ending to the album,
Nice thoughts, pretty reasonable good selections. If, per chance a Single album came to be, Back in the USSR starts Side One and Birthday would start Side 2. The other six songs on Side One should have included Dear Prudence, Why Don't We Do It in the Road, Bungalow Bill, While My Guitar Gently Weeps Happiness is a Warm Gun and Good Night by Ringo ending side one. Side Two, following Birthday, would be Yer Blues, Blackbird, Helter Skelter, Savoy Truffle, and Revolution I at the end with Paul's Ob La Di Ob La Da at the end.
Back in the USSR Dear Prudence Obla Di Obla Da While My Guitar Gently Weeps Happiness is a Warm Gun BlackBird Julia Birthday Everybody’s Got Something To Except for Me and My Monkey Sexy Sadie Helter Skelter Long Long Long Piggies Revolution(Single Version) (15)Why Dont We Do It In the Road I would take criticism for the running order, but I am comfortable with the selections. I would include Yer Blues if the recording was more like what John performed with Dirty Mac for the Rolling Stones Circus thing. I still think this leaves off alot of good material like Rocky Racoon, Cry Baby Cry, Im so Tired, and Mother Nature’s Son. Not to mention that they should have included Hey Jude. It bothers me that so many singles of theirs can not be found on any album. Especially the B-sides. In my opinion, they should have made 2 singles out of many of them. We can work it out/Day Tripper, Strawberry Fields Forever/Penny Lane, Paperback Writer/Rain, I Feel Fine/Shes a Woman, Get Back/Dont Let me Down, Hey Jude/Revolution, and Come Together/Something, just off the top of my head. If they thought so lowly of B-sides, why put the other song that was competing to get the A-side as the B-side? I know they found alot of their performance material in the early days from B-sides, but that comment from George about either elbowing a song or making it a B-side, is pretty illuminating on that.
I’d like to respectfully challenge you on a couple of comments that you have made. You say, Paul was the leader of the band at this time and led the musical direction of the band. Although Paul did have the ideal of Sergeant Pepper and magical mystery tour, one success, and one arguably a failure. It wasn’t Paul that wanted to get back to the basics on the white album. It was John’s idea, the fact that revolution 9 was included should prove my point. In the single revolution with this political message, Paul didn’t want to get into politics as the Beatles, but John did, so is John the leader of the band? Paul definitely was more pushy and aggressive in the recording studio, hence Ringo Starr walked out on the white album and George Harrison walked out on the let it be sessions. A leader of a band does not inspire that. It seems like the songs on the White album where the whole band was involved, like yer blues and happiness is a warm gun, John more than Paul invited the whole band to work together and create the songs. Paul Was more pushy, aggressive the studio, but John was the true leader of the band.
Lets build a new Beatles album, one to follow Abby Road. We can only use songs from each Beatles' solo work that was released upon or immediately after the break up. What songs do we have?
Thanks, @therecordspinner. I propose that you expand this mind experiment, and re-imagine your new album as a BETTER two-record set. My two-LP version (greatly superior imo to the two-LP set that actually came out) would start with every song you mentioned. That accounts for one LP's worth of material. But it's possible to make the second LP just as good. We next select the songs that SHOULD have been on the White Album but weren't. We deliver the four sides of their two most recent singles: "Lady Madonna," "The Inner Light," "Hey Jude" and "Revolution." Yes, that means there would be two versions of "Revolution" on the album (the other being "Revolution No. 1"), which people would have found very cool when this album came out. (Remember how cool "Sgt. Pepper" seemed sporting two different versions of the title track?) Plus we'd do this twice thing twice to prove that this wasn't a mistake! There would also be two versions of "While My Guitar Gently Weeps." The two versions would be the original White Album version but also -- and this is crucial = the acoustic version with the George Martin string arrangement (!) that appeared only on the album "Love." This might be the best version of them all and would be a highlight of the whole collection. The rest of this album would be the best of the rest. We could easily fill up the rest of it with non-filler. Without a doubt, if the Beatles had done it that way, the White Album would today be considered the best rock album ever released with no possible competitors.
For all its illuminating tracks, the White album is definitely a mess. However, with over 55 years now under the bridge, trying to make a single album out of it is sure to have someone ready to kill. And yes that includes “Revolution 9”.
First time watching your channel, I liked how you did the side with the Apple records and dropping the tracks on it. I thought that was a great idea, what I know about the album is that the double album is what I heard is in their contract they had to do a double album, thanks
Hi I tried this so many times but in the end, I wasn't satisfied. Maybe 20 to 25times, I've tried. But I gave up. Like Paul said: It's the bloody White Album. Take care.
Mother Nature's Son While My Guitar Gently Weeps Happiness Is A Warm Gun Cry Baby Cry Martha My Dear Helter Skelter Everybody's Got Something To Hide Except Me And My Monkey Julia Dear Prudence I'm So Tired I will Let It Down (Original Guitar And Vocal; 2014 remastered) Rocky Raccoon Yer Blues Blackbird Long, Long, Long
Lose acouple that are obvious junk -- Rev 9, Wild Honey Pie. Shorten a few of the tracks that are too long. Maybe take some of the weaker tracks an medley then ala' the Abby Road medley, and...voila'! A great single album.
![Summer Walker - Heart Of A Woman [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SFddctbZzw8/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m glad it was released in exactly the form it was. Why would we want fewer Beatles tracks in the world? I’ll take ‘em all!
I agree with your rationale for how to assemble the single album version (although it absolutely could and should be 15 tracks instead of 14, which then enables a more equitable 6 for each Paul and John). And your side 1 is great and nearly the same as mine, but your side 2 falls apart completely with what was included versus what was left off. On my side 2, Martha My Dear, I Will and Rocky Racoon would be Paul's Songs, and Everybody's got something to Hide, I'm So Tired, and Cry Baby Cry would be John's and Savoy Truffle would be George's, with album ending with Cry Baby cry. . My version would then have Birthday/Helter Skelter released as a non-album single, as well as Mother Nature's Son/Yer Blues as another single. But ultimately, every attempt to do this best single white album game fails, because no one can agree on which songs to include, because there are just too many great songs to ever fit onto a single album. I've done this many times with many different people, and every single one of them picks a different selection of songs as 'the best 14 or 15'. So, yes, the white album is the greatest double album ever, even with all its imperfections.
My selection for a single White Album would be:
Side one
01. "Back in the U.S.S.R."
02. "Dear Prudence"
03. "Glass Onion"
04. "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da"
05. "While My Guitar Gently Weeps"
06. "Happiness Is a Warm Gun"
07. "Martha My Dear"
08. "Blackbird"
Total length: 24:23
Side two
01. "Birthday"
02. "Not Guilty"
03. "Mother Nature's Son"
04. "Sexy Sadie"
05. "I Will"
06. "Savoy Truffle"
07. "Cry Baby Cry"
08. "Good Night"
Total length: 23:05
'Not Guilty'? Never heard of that one
@@andrewashdown3541 It's an outtake from the White album sessions written by George Harrison, which he re-recorded in 1978 for his 1979 album George Harrison. It can be found on The Beatles Anthology 3 and then on The Beatles: 50th Anniversary Edition.
@@a.k.1740 Oh no wonder it foxed me. Let Sleeping Dirges lie!
@@andrewashdown3541 "Not Guilty" is still better than the crap "Revolution 9" or that awful "Don't Pass Me By"!
@@a.k.1740 Oh yes indeed. Those two are the worst. Lennon was trying it on; Ringo, well ...
For me you've got this close to my selections. I would've dumped 3 Lennon songs (Glass Onion, Yer Blues & Good Night) - and put in 3 other Lennon songs (I'm So Tired, Everybody's Got Something To Hide & Sexy Sadie). Eight songs per side would have worked. I would include "I Will" & "Savoy Truffle" (George deserves 3).
This attempt makes more sense than any other attempt I've ever seen! Even though I'd personally have had more John songs on the second side and got rid of some Paul songs. But very interesting
There are usually two ways of compiling a single white album. One is based on what could reasonably be expected that the Beatles themselves would release given the circumstances of the time, the other is based on songs you personally like or dislike. This can be further broken down into two formats, one being what could fit on a vinyl record, and the other being a digital playlist or CD that has no strict time limits.
In every case each Beatles fan comes up with a different list! I even come up with a slightly different list myself every time I think about this, most songs remain the same but some get swapped out.
Luckily we have playlists and each fan can make a White Album to suit their own preferences, and it can be of any length. My own WA playlist remains consistent, too much for a single album, not enough for a double, but on a playlist the time doesn't matter. I got rid of songs I don't particularly care for and added in Hey Jude and the unreleased Not Guilty and Child Of Nature.
If anyone cares, this is my WA playlist:
Back in the U.S.S.R.
Dear Prudence
Glass onion
Ob-la-di, ob-la-da
Child Of Nature
While my guitar gently weeps
Martha my dear
I'm so tired
Blackbird
Piggies
Don't pass me by
I will
Julia
Birthday
Not Guilty
Mother nature's son
Everybodys got ~ monkey
Sexy Sadie
Helter skelter
Long long long
Revolution (single)
Honey Pie
Cry baby cry
Hey Jude
Deleted Wild honey pie, The continuing story of Bungalow Bill, Happiness is a warm gun, Rocky Raccoon, Why don't we do it in the road, Yer blues, Revolution 1, Savoy truffle, Revolution 9, Good night.
Mine
Side 1
1. Back in the USSR
2. Dear Prudence
3. While my Guitar Gently Weeps
4. Martha My Dear
5. Don’t Pass me by
6. BlackBird
7. Julia
Runtime| 22:58
Side 2
1. Revolution 1
2. Helter Skelter
3. Long Long Long
4. Revolution 9
5. Good Night
Runtime| 23:29
I like the idea of having a normal Side 1, and a deranged Side 2.
White Album double album is just a crazy album and I really love it. Don’t Pass Me By is one of the weaker songs do it would definitely have to go and Good Night is such a perfect ending to the album,
Only glaring omission for me would be "I'm So Tired", but then its all subjective innit!
Nice thoughts, pretty reasonable good selections. If, per chance a Single album came to be, Back in the USSR starts Side One and Birthday would start Side 2. The other six songs on Side One should have included Dear Prudence, Why Don't We Do It in the Road, Bungalow Bill, While My Guitar Gently Weeps Happiness is a Warm Gun and Good Night by Ringo ending side one. Side Two, following Birthday, would be Yer Blues, Blackbird, Helter Skelter, Savoy Truffle, and Revolution I at the end with Paul's Ob La Di Ob La Da at the end.
Back in the USSR
Dear Prudence
Obla Di Obla Da
While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Happiness is a Warm Gun
BlackBird
Julia
Birthday
Everybody’s Got Something To
Except for Me and My Monkey
Sexy Sadie
Helter Skelter
Long Long Long
Piggies
Revolution(Single Version)
(15)Why Dont We Do It In the Road
I would take criticism for the running order, but I am comfortable with the selections. I would include Yer Blues if the recording was more like what John performed with Dirty Mac for the Rolling Stones Circus thing. I still think this leaves off alot of good material like Rocky Racoon, Cry Baby Cry, Im so Tired, and Mother Nature’s Son. Not to mention that they should have included Hey Jude. It bothers me that so many singles of theirs can not be found on any album. Especially the B-sides. In my opinion, they should have made 2 singles out of many of them. We can work it out/Day Tripper, Strawberry Fields Forever/Penny Lane, Paperback Writer/Rain, I Feel Fine/Shes a Woman, Get Back/Dont Let me Down, Hey Jude/Revolution, and Come Together/Something, just off the top of my head. If they thought so lowly of B-sides, why put the other song that was competing to get the A-side as the B-side? I know they found alot of their performance material in the early days from B-sides, but that comment from George about either elbowing a song or making it a B-side, is pretty illuminating on that.
Come Together/Something certainly IS on an album, it's called Abbey Road.
I’d like to respectfully challenge you on a couple of comments that you have made. You say, Paul was the leader of the band at this time and led the musical direction of the band. Although Paul did have the ideal of Sergeant Pepper and magical mystery tour, one success, and one arguably a failure. It wasn’t Paul that wanted to get back to the basics on the white album. It was John’s idea, the fact that revolution 9 was included should prove my point. In the single revolution with this political message, Paul didn’t want to get into politics as the Beatles, but John did, so is John the leader of the band? Paul definitely was more pushy and aggressive in the recording studio, hence Ringo Starr walked out on the white album and George Harrison walked out on the let it be sessions. A leader of a band does not inspire that. It seems like the songs on the White album where the whole band was involved, like yer blues and happiness is a warm gun, John more than Paul invited the whole band to work together and create the songs. Paul Was more pushy, aggressive the studio, but John was the true leader of the band.
Lets build a new Beatles album, one to follow Abby Road. We can only use songs from each Beatles' solo work that was released upon or immediately after the break up. What songs do we have?
Thanks, @therecordspinner. I propose that you expand this mind experiment, and re-imagine your new album as a BETTER two-record set. My two-LP version (greatly superior imo to the two-LP set that actually came out) would start with every song you mentioned.
That accounts for one LP's worth of material. But it's possible to make the second LP just as good. We next select the songs that SHOULD have been on the White Album but weren't. We deliver the four sides of their two most recent singles:
"Lady Madonna,"
"The Inner Light,"
"Hey Jude" and
"Revolution."
Yes, that means there would be two versions of "Revolution" on the album (the other being "Revolution No. 1"), which people would have found very cool when this album came out. (Remember how cool "Sgt. Pepper" seemed sporting two different versions of the title track?)
Plus we'd do this twice thing twice to prove that this wasn't a mistake! There would also be two versions of "While My Guitar Gently Weeps." The two versions would be the original White Album version but also -- and this is crucial = the acoustic version with the George Martin string arrangement (!) that appeared only on the album "Love." This might be the best version of them all and would be a highlight of the whole collection.
The rest of this album would be the best of the rest. We could easily fill up the rest of it with non-filler.
Without a doubt, if the Beatles had done it that way, the White Album would today be considered the best rock album ever released with no possible competitors.
For all its illuminating tracks, the White album is definitely a mess. However, with over 55 years now under the bridge, trying to make a single album out of it is sure to have someone ready to kill. And yes that includes “Revolution 9”.
First time watching your channel, I liked how you did the side with the Apple records and dropping the tracks on it. I thought that was a great idea, what I know about the album is that the double album is what I heard is in their contract they had to do a double album, thanks
Hi
I tried this so many times but in the end, I wasn't satisfied.
Maybe 20 to 25times, I've tried. But I gave up.
Like Paul said: It's the bloody White Album.
Take care.
Can you do this For All Things Must Pass? The White Album is fine as it is, just fine. ATMP, however, is seriously bloated.
Well, no Revolution 9, no idle talks.
I like even this one.
Idk i feel like it’s the perfect penultimate track to the album.
Side 1 (24:12)
"Back in the U.S.S.R."
"Dear Prudence"
"Glass Onion"
"While My Guitar Gently Weeps"
"Happiness Is a Warm Gun"
"Martha My Dear"
"Blackbird"
"Julia"
Side 2 (24:01)
"Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da"
"I Will"
"Mother Nature's Son"
"Sexy Sadie"
"Revolution 1"
"Honey Pie"
"Savoy Truffle"
"Good Night"
3 Macca songs at the start of side 2 ..... nahhh
What if it was released as a single!! You could have Piggies backed with Dont Pass Me By!!
😃Blackbird is perfect side 1 closing✨
I personally prefer Julia as a closer to side 1.
Mother Nature's Son
While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Happiness Is A Warm Gun
Cry Baby Cry
Martha My Dear
Helter Skelter
Everybody's Got Something To
Hide Except Me
And My Monkey
Julia
Dear Prudence
I'm So Tired
I will
Let It Down (Original Guitar And
Vocal; 2014 remastered)
Rocky Raccoon
Yer Blues
Blackbird
Long, Long, Long
😃Dont Pass Me By is a great side 2 opener
Why.... don't they do it in the load ??
Lose acouple that are obvious junk -- Rev 9, Wild Honey Pie. Shorten a few of the tracks that are too long. Maybe take some of the weaker tracks an medley then ala' the Abby Road medley, and...voila'! A great single album.
Love it or hate it, the White Album is not the White Album without Revolution 9
Booo,,,