Great list! I don't have the SDCC Knightfall, but I do have the blue and grey. Mine fell off the shelf and one of the ears looks like it took some stress but thankfully it is still intact. I even purchased a backup.
The Joker henchmen is nice, who would have expected a figure like that to even be released? I don't agree with your number 1, but your insight about it is interesting and your input means a lot. I spent at least $500 on Mezco Batmans and need a Batman break, but a 70s Batman look is enticing.
I'm sorta in portion where a McFarlane Batman is just another Batman where I just want new characters, in the end. I'm glad you liked it enough to make it to your top figures though
I like the Mr Freeze BAF wave, it's the first one where I want all of the figures and the BAF equally! I really like the Knightfall Batman standard I have and though not a big fan of 2 face, I was really impressed by the 2 Face Batman, the color combo is so dramatic it just pops on my shelf, even still in the box! D, I really enjoy your videos and appreciate all the figure comparisons and size measurements. What was that rust colored console you used to use as a background? I can't place it, thought maybe Dr Who...
Those are all excellent choices. Are you going to sell the broken head? Didn't McFarlane say he was going to address the figure's sizes? My Top 3 DCM figures are Knightfall Batman, Gold Label Dick Grayson Robin, my custom Bizzaro made with infect Superman. Last is a cheat but I just got into the line.
Love the list!!! done right all the way trough. Specially being the top 20 instead of just 10. Too many good if not great figures to just do 10. Well done my man. Batman Hush, Gladiator Batman and Abyss Platinum edition would have been my 3 figures.
Not really 3 but Batman 6 pack, Mr. Freeze BAF and poison ivy. Mcfarlane releases so many cool figures that makes it hard to pick top 3. Thanks for posting. Hope you have a great 2024.
Great choices. I don’t have some if these since not a completist. Mcfarlane puts out so many figures it’s hard to remember when everything is from. Lol
My top five Mcfarlane 1) Collector's series Wonder Woman 2) Flashpoint Flash 3) Page Punchers Black Manta 4) Teen Titans Raven 5) Rebirth Shazam ( honestly I can't remember if this figure came out this year or last, all the same I didn't get until this year so I'm including it.) Top 5 none Mcfarlane 1) Maestro Union Veteran William (favorite figure of the year actually) 2 Cinemark Blue Beetle Bug Popcorn bucket 3) Naughty or Nice Classic Santa 4) Power Stars Phantom 5) Amazing Heroes Bullet Girl
@@dHuntersReviews I highly recommend Veteran William, he could be used for many things in your collection Anthony Lupis, Warren Griffith from the Creator Commandos, or just a badass werewolf.
The dark knight thug collection is awesome. Love the Mr Freezes. Would have been so excited to have the comic one as a kid. He's always been in my top 3, especially after the movie. The Abyss reminds me of Narcosis. (At least a couple appearances in Shadow of the Bat, 50-51 I believe maybe 51-52) would be awesome to see that one. A LOTDK line from the comic series would be incredible. To go back and do several of those stylized Batmans and other characters.
Oh no! so sad what happened.. the knightfall batman is one of my favorites.. I wish I had the Comicon version as I think the colors and shading on that was done perfectly. Hope you find a nice replacement. sadness..... Maybe Mcfarlane will release that to all...
My personal no. 1 is Bank Robber Joker but I've sourced a bag and Glock for him to get him up there. He should have at least come with the bag! no.3 is Jokerised Dark Detective and no. 2 is Dark Knights of Steel Batman
Get some epoxy and make a new ear, should take 2 mins to match. Then get some navy blue and some black acrylic paint and match the tone. Should take less than an hour.
Hey dhunter love this list but your missing the best McFarlane figure that came out in 2023 that is the gold label sinestro corps Batman that is my all time favorite Batman figure to date
My top 3 would be (1) Classic WW - easily the best by far but unfortunately blew the height scale as too tall imo (2) Knightfall Batman (shouldda been taller & more muscular imo) & (3) Hush Batman (Blue Variant) minus the wacko cape imo. Won't be picking up any of these but McFarlane Toys appears to be slowly improving in some respects so at leasr that's a positive. Don't pay much attention to your ratings after you gave the WW 84 (maybe the worst action figure of Gal Gadot ever produced imo) an over-inflated 7.5 & the AY Arkham Knight an underwhelming 6.0 (pretty funny). Happy NY & thanks much for the detail reviews & extensive comparables.
@@dHuntersReviews Pretty sure you're in the minority there re: McFarlane WW 84 but opinions vary. If you want to see what an actual quality WW 84 action figure looks like then pick up the SHF WW84. Looks like you may be coming to your WW senses though as your Classic WW Rating seemed pretty fair imo.
@@dHuntersReviews WW a member of the JL & DC Trinity so guess that would meet my definition of Bat related. Too small & expensive for a guy w/duplicates of all of his figs. & plenty of imports in 6" scale otherwise??? I try to factor in quality & est. value (rather than just cost) when making action fig. purchases but everyone has different priorities.
Yeah! Nor did the _Guillem March_ brighter colored Joker. From the most recent Joker 1 relaunch comic. Also odd that Captain Carrot & The Great Purple Catwoman figure (unless she was 2022) didn't make the list.
Hopefully we get a Bob The Goon figure. Even if it's an McFarlane toy store exclusive. It was a great year for McFarlane DC collectors. 👍
Yes please
Someone made me a custom McFarlane Bob
I did a video if you’re interested
Great list! I don't have the SDCC Knightfall, but I do have the blue and grey. Mine fell off the shelf and one of the ears looks like it took some stress but thankfully it is still intact. I even purchased a backup.
That is fortunate, luckily, I was able to find a replacement for a very fair price recently
Great list. The story with #1 is tragic. My top 3 are the new Wonder Woman, the movie Blue Beetle, and 89 Batman/Batmobile
Tear drop for sdcc Knightfall Batman
The Joker henchmen is nice, who would have expected a figure like that to even be released? I don't agree with your number 1, but your insight about it is interesting and your input means a lot. I spent at least $500 on Mezco Batmans and need a Batman break, but a 70s Batman look is enticing.
You don’t like Knightfall Batman?
I'm sorta in portion where a McFarlane Batman is just another Batman where I just want new characters, in the end. I'm glad you liked it enough to make it to your top figures though
Love that Catman. Could never find one for sale though, but maybe one day. For now I just have the Mattel one.
He’s fantastic!
I like the Mr Freeze BAF wave, it's the first one where I want all of the figures and the BAF equally! I really like the Knightfall Batman standard I have and though not a big fan of 2 face, I was really impressed by the 2 Face Batman, the color combo is so dramatic it just pops on my shelf, even still in the box! D, I really enjoy your videos and appreciate all the figure comparisons and size measurements. What was that rust colored console you used to use as a background? I can't place it, thought maybe Dr Who...
Rust colored console…?
I saw Them, the BAF set all together at Walmart..... EXCEPT Robin! 😫 Wut Duh!?
What?
@@dHuntersReviews typo
I want more green lantern figures but with the green tone of the Hal Jordan and John Stewart.
With diff heads?
Those are all excellent choices.
Are you going to sell the broken head?
Didn't McFarlane say he was going to address the figure's sizes?
My Top 3 DCM figures are Knightfall Batman, Gold Label Dick Grayson Robin, my custom Bizzaro made with infect Superman. Last is a cheat but I just got into the line.
No one wants to buy that broken head lol
Great list!
Thank you sir
Love the list!!! done right all the way trough. Specially being the top 20 instead of just 10. Too many good if not great figures to just do 10. Well done my man. Batman Hush, Gladiator Batman and Abyss Platinum edition would have been my 3 figures.
There are so many more I wanted to include!
The Guy That Printed And Painted Those Joker Gang Heads, Is AMAZIN'!
Yeasir!
Caveman Batman,Atomic Skull, AlanScott and CptCarrot made my Top 10.
They are good, none made my list
Not really 3 but Batman 6 pack, Mr. Freeze BAF and poison ivy. Mcfarlane releases so many cool figures that makes it hard to pick top 3. Thanks for posting. Hope you have a great 2024.
Yeah, I could’ve done top 40!
Hawkman Platinum, SDCC Knightfall Batman and Tim Drake Robin.
Excellent choices
Great choices. I don’t have some if these since not a completist. Mcfarlane puts out so many figures it’s hard to remember when everything is from. Lol
I used my videos to know what came out which year
My top five Mcfarlane
1) Collector's series Wonder Woman
2) Flashpoint Flash
3) Page Punchers Black Manta
4) Teen Titans Raven
5) Rebirth Shazam ( honestly I can't remember if this figure came out this year or last, all the same I didn't get until this year so I'm including it.)
Top 5 none Mcfarlane
1) Maestro Union Veteran William (favorite figure of the year actually)
2 Cinemark Blue Beetle Bug Popcorn bucket
3) Naughty or Nice Classic Santa
4) Power Stars Phantom
5) Amazing Heroes Bullet Girl
I don’t have anything in your second list
@@dHuntersReviews I highly recommend Veteran William, he could be used for many things in your collection Anthony Lupis, Warren Griffith from the Creator Commandos, or just a badass werewolf.
He’s nice, I have the gators, but don’t feel like I need the wolf.
nice man! my top 3 would be capt carrot, black abyss and jim gordon batman haha
Didn’t think anyone would out Gordon Batman on their list.
@@dHuntersReviews somehow for me he's fun to pose haha
That’s awesome
I’m not a fan of the figure but he’s ok
The dark knight thug collection is awesome. Love the Mr Freezes. Would have been so excited to have the comic one as a kid. He's always been in my top 3, especially after the movie.
The Abyss reminds me of Narcosis. (At least a couple appearances in Shadow of the Bat, 50-51 I believe maybe 51-52) would be awesome to see that one. A LOTDK line from the comic series would be incredible. To go back and do several of those stylized Batmans and other characters.
The Gothic Batman, Engines Batman, Solomon Grundy. Pretty obscure but they'd honestly make good figures.
Yes plz!
Knightfall Batman, movie 6 pack, Dark Knight Joker interrogation, and Superman injustice be my favorites
So many good ones!!
Midnighter is definitely in my top 3
He’s ok but not in my top 10
I am glad they made him
Incredible man 🔥
Thank you
Great figures maybe glue a small piece of plastic and paint it?
Oh no! so sad what happened.. the knightfall batman is one of my favorites.. I wish I had the Comicon version as I think the colors and shading on that was done perfectly. Hope you find a nice replacement. sadness..... Maybe Mcfarlane will release that to all...
One way or the other I need to replace it
My personal no. 1 is Bank Robber Joker but I've sourced a bag and Glock for him to get him up there. He should have at least come with the bag!
no.3 is Jokerised Dark Detective and no. 2 is Dark Knights of Steel Batman
He’s absolutely awesome
I have bags and guns for all 6 of mine!
@@dHuntersReviews Those heads are astonishing, truly
Maybe I should’ve ranked them at #1
So fond of that figure
It’s not the joker for me!
My Top 5 are Black Hush Batman, 89 Batman, Green Lantern Batman, Caveman Batman, Classic Riddler
Nice, barely any made my list
Hope the Black and grey Knightfall has the darker grey.
We shall see
Great figures, especially like the Batman 1989 and the Sonar Batman Forever figures.
Hope they give us their other suits…
@@dHuntersReviews 👍
Not a bad selection at all .
So many good releases.
Get some epoxy and make a new ear, should take 2 mins to match. Then get some navy blue and some black acrylic paint and match the tone. Should take less than an hour.
I haven’t painted figures in years
Need to start back up
You can mold the Batman horn with epoxy putty
Yes
You were playing too hard with that batman toy and dropped it...haha.
Pretty much
No laughing it’s a sad moment
I'm guessing you're not going to open your #1 Batman kept in the box for the total collection, now that the open and enjoy version is broken
If I do I’d have to replace it
I’ll find a new one somehow………
The vampire green lantern. Go add him and take one off rite now ! 😘
Vampire Batman, maybe…
I can't wait to show you my toys
-dHunter
Where does he get such wonderful toys?
Hey dhunter love this list but your missing the best McFarlane figure that came out in 2023 that is the gold label sinestro corps Batman that is my all time favorite Batman figure to date
It’s not bad but I’ll rarely use it
Didn’t even get on the opening honorable mention shot for me
Hey we all have different opinions but we can both agree that Batman with a yellow lantern ring is just awesome
Yes that we can
Dang the broken ear!!!!!! 😮😮
Tragic
My top 3 would be (1) Classic WW - easily the best by far but unfortunately blew the height scale as too tall imo (2) Knightfall Batman (shouldda been taller & more muscular imo) & (3) Hush Batman (Blue Variant) minus the wacko cape imo. Won't be picking up any of these but McFarlane Toys appears to be slowly improving in some respects so at leasr that's a positive. Don't pay much attention to your ratings after you gave the WW 84 (maybe the worst action figure of Gal Gadot ever produced imo) an over-inflated 7.5 & the AY Arkham Knight an underwhelming 6.0 (pretty funny). Happy NY & thanks much for the detail reviews & extensive comparables.
My ratings are my initial thoughts I’d love to revisit them and see how I feel now
I like 84 she was the best wonder woman until now
She’s underrated
@@dHuntersReviews Pretty sure you're in the minority there re: McFarlane WW 84 but opinions vary. If you want to see what an actual quality WW 84 action figure looks like then pick up the SHF WW84. Looks like you may be coming to your WW senses though as your Classic WW Rating seemed pretty fair imo.
Figuarts too small and expensive
Only get their bat stuff
@@dHuntersReviews WW a member of the JL & DC Trinity so guess that would meet my definition of Bat related. Too small & expensive for a guy w/duplicates of all of his figs. & plenty of imports in 6" scale otherwise??? I try to factor in quality & est. value (rather than just cost) when making action fig. purchases but everyone has different priorities.
I don’t duplicate all my figures
Just the bat and related stuff
I don’t get imports that aren’t bat related typically
Mr. Freeze BAF wave
The Sea Horse
89 Batman
Wasn’t sure if I should count the horse it’s kind of a vehicle
The Joker Interrogation room from the Dark knight, Eradicator or Blue beetle (Classic) didn’t made it to list?
Yeah! Nor did the _Guillem March_ brighter colored Joker. From the most recent Joker 1 relaunch comic. Also odd that Captain Carrot & The Great Purple Catwoman figure (unless she was 2022) didn't make the list.
Too much good stuff
I prefer the coat joker and he didn’t make the list
Eradicator? Not a chance
Catwoman was 2023 and should’ve probably been on the list
Cyborg Superman New 52 McFarlane xD
Not out yet…
You. Forgot. The. Rabbit.
He’s awesome
Love obscure characters
He didn’t make my top 10
THE RABBIT
He’s awesome
Love obscure characters
He didn’t make my top 10
I feel sorry for your number 1 batman 😢 unlucky Kentucky
Sadness
Lets agree to disagree
Meaning?
Will you ever have ol "jugs" back on the show again?
What?
@@dHuntersReviews I hope so! Those were nice!
I don’t understand