Stanley Fat Max all the way. My buddies make fun of me, but I have been using the same 3 Stanley tape measures for at least 10 years while they seem to buy new ones every year of red and yellow brands
The Stanley Fax Max has an 1/8" cut in the nose of the tape. If a person doesn't realize that fact, it can create all kinds of confusion. Love the video Vince. Very comprehensive. I've used the Fax Max for a lot of years
Yo Vince! The Milwaukee 25 ft. compact as the overall winner? Ha ha! I have 2 of them. 💪Bought a twin pack of them for $20 during black Friday event a couple years ago. Thanks for all you do. I watched every second of this video. Peace and God be with the Carneglias and all #theverycoolgang. 🙂👍✌️
You're 100% correct. Stop being brand loyal. My Milwaukee tape measure filled up with junk that the blade was dragging into the inside (and getting inside the mechanics via that silly finger brake hole). I got tired of it, so I placed it on top of a tree stump and shot it. I've been using a Harbor Freight HERCULES tape measure since then, I got it on sale for $10, and love it!
@@VCGConstruction thank you for sharing it I will take mine down now since she was as official for you I was just trying to look out to help people out that didn't understand
Stanley fatmax are the best hands down im a cladder and mine get wet all the time and still last a long time. Tried all these over the years and non of them compare to Stanley
Hello again, Vince and Vcg Thank you for another Great Video 👍 I guess the question is just how accurate do they measure. If they are off, I would have to get a better measuring tape. Again thank you 👍
Update my local hardware store had the Milwaukee compact 30’ for 10 bucks . Great deal not as nice reading as the fat max but not a fat max price . Thanks again Vince
Those tapes suck. Got one free from a builder we worked with 5 years ago. Marks fade away and edges are razor sharp I cut my finger all the time with that tape. Stanly fatmax is the best and only tape I use 10 years+
The black tape with yellow markings sure looks like no other but mine didn’t even last 2 months under light duty use. I had to replace mine with Milwaukee stud
I had one and I never use it anymore because it has an exposed metal hook that WILL bend when dropped. Any tape measure that has an exposed hook is automatically garbage because on a real jobsite shit happens. Tools get dropped. My Milwaukee 25' has a recessed hook that's totally protected. Love it.
One metric I use when picking a tape measures is how easy it is to grab the hook and pull it out when wearing gloves or hooking onto something with the end of the tape when it is reeled up, after all you have to pull it out to use it, so its ease of use.
If you need such long stand outs, why not just invest in a laser distance measurer? I know you'll still need a tape for certain applications. But an LDM can do so much more and much more quickly.
I’d like to see Fastcap tapes included in these. They’re cheap, accurate and easy to read with my middle aged eyes lol. Being a woodworker, mine don’t leave shop much, so they don’t take a ton of abuse. I’d like to see how they’d hold up compared to the others.
I had the wide blade and stud and they both had issues with the tape getting twisted and kinks within a couple of months. I just recently bought the tough series and within a day the thing broke so I returned it and the 2nd one a rivet in the hook broke off within a few weeks. I now use a Kobalt at least I know it’s cheap and if they all suck it may as well be cheap to replace.
I am a big time Milwaukee fan boy. However, I am seriously disappointed with their tape measures. The blades all twist about 12”. This causing them to not stay hooked when I grab an end of a piece of lumber. I have purchased 4 Milwaukee tape measures and they all got twisted. Nome of my Stanley tapes have this problem.
I'm a Nite-eye Shockforce G2 tape user, purely because the neon numbers against the black background is just easier for my eyes. I do like the FatMax and Atomic when using other people's tapes. I will say the Shockforce does have the same issue of the clip sticks below the tape body and is susceptible to damage if you are clumsy.
tb tape is almost just right, the way the hook sits when its rolled up is too flush, can be a bitch to pull out but otherwise great tape.. good as any anyway
I just wanted to share some of my knowledge on how tape measures are rated now. As stated, manufacturers use "reach" over "standout" commonly. Reach is actually standout plus 3 feet, the approximate length of an arm. This also explains why the standout tests looked as if it fell short of the ratings. Whenever purchasing, if you're looking at that metric, make sure you check which word they use in their rating.
Watched this, after watching best tape measure by Project Farm. While I was satisfied with the testing he performed, I really enjoyed your readability test. That said everyone talking about Milwaukee and Stanly, I'd suggest watching Project Farms video. While readability is important, as a plumber, standout, and dirt resistance, and tape fading, are really important factors and TLDR Dewalt xp premium was basically flawless, with Stanley not working good as new but still good enough, and Milwaukee not useable anymore. Different crafts call for different tape measures.
Please help me decide between "Bosch GSB 185 li" and "Makita HP333DWYE" which are available in India at approx similar price of 11700 indian Rupee INR (approx 140 US$) GSB 185 is brushless hammer drill on 18v batttery , vs Makita HP333D is a brushed hammer drill on 12v battery Talking to Makita India folks they said DF332DWYE is deprecated and so entry level brushless option from Makita I don't have. Bosch is pretty commonly available in India compared to Makita , so Makita brand is attractive between the two options.
One note reach is not same as standout as it adds 3' for the reach of the arm. So to get standout you have to subtract 3' when it says reach. So at 10.1' the Dewalt met it's claim.
Own both plus others. Not biased to any brand but i dont like the Milwaukee as much as the DeWalt in these current versions as they seem to wear out quicker (coating) plus rather have a slightly slower retraction to prevent tip damage. But use what tou like. And yes my antique Stanley still works great so will take that over both of these.
Love Milwaukee's 6'/10m mini tape measure. I have 4? of them. Ones always close by. I 3D print a lot so having metric is awesome. It's really readable compared to competitors. I got a Dewalt and Milwaukee 25' tape measure- there both fine. But I use a laser more than a 25' tape measure.
Exactly for as long as I can remember I was using the power lock I my first upgrade was a Stanley level lock to me it was and then I got a Lufkin Black widow
@@bluemantom77 I use a Milwaukee tape because it came in a bundle with some other Milwaukee stuff. It does just fine. No I don't know why I have six total though 🤣🤣🤣
@@greezy937 exactly use whatever works for you some of those extreme tests that people put these through not all of us will experience for the most part we're fine with what we use
I have used all of these. Stanley Fatman is by far the best, dewalt second. I love milwaukee and have almost everything, but their tape measures will cut ya after so long.
Should have actually performed a high drop test. The plinko board doesn't really give it the impact of a 25 ft plus drop. So your testing is good but incomplete.
Komeleon tapes the only ones to buy now. The discount price on the contractor ones is too good to pass up. Can be found for around $10 on discount. I have one that's 5 years old been in rain, sand, cold and still out performs a fatmax(one of the worst tape measures made)
Ultimate tape would be a fat max classic with the scale printed on the bottom off the tape and a revamped hook like the lufkin shockforce g2… maybe a fat max nite eye too. Milwaukee compact is trash cluttered to read rusts in a week. The only tape I hate more is the tajima g25 overpriced mid tier tape that broke first time hooking a board.
Funny enough, the Milwaukee tape measurers have pretty poor reviews on their site. They mainly talk about the locks failing shortly after purchase. All of these are from several months ago, though. Maybe the newer products are better?
Milwaukee tapes look nice, unfortunately, they are very resistant to water, dirt, and scratches. Additionally, the retraction speed test is unnecessary because hitting the tape's end after several hundred hits will cause the measuring tape to become uncalibrated. I have owned tapes from Stanley and Dewalt for several years and would not switch them for Milwaukee. If you think otherwise, then do a test by retracting the tape using sandpaper with equal pressure on each measuring tape and then throwing them into water for 24 hours. Because this is comparable to real-life conditions.
if your using the same one accuracy doesnt matter I like original silver 25ft Stanley after using fat max for years.....too expensive and they dont last.....went back to original a year ago
I have wanted to say that so many times but lost my nerve, thanks, I got a charge out of it. Always makes me nuts, same with there, they're and their, it is constant!!!
Doesn’t matter what you test and most test Stanley’s always outlast second of all who reads the tape from that far out. Some of the test you do are ridiculous.
I have all Milwaukee tools but still continue to use the Fat Max
Agreed. I went through a stud and a wide blade pretty quickly. Both blades ripped
Same here. I’m a commercial plumber here in Houston and all I use is Milwaukee hand tools and power tools and fat max
Stanley Fat Max all the way. My buddies make fun of me, but I have been using the same 3 Stanley tape measures for at least 10 years while they seem to buy new ones every year of red and yellow brands
Yup me too
The fat max doesn't even need to be tested it's the best for carpenters 100percent
Fat Max not included? I stopped right there. Take a field trip to a job site!
The fat Max has ascended from testing and became a control
Spot on. Fat Max all the way. I'm a brand loyal Milwaukee guy, but tapes are the exception.
The Stanley Fax Max has an 1/8" cut in the nose of the tape. If a person doesn't realize that fact, it can create all kinds of confusion.
Love the video Vince.
Very comprehensive.
I've used the Fax Max for a lot of years
FatMax all day. I've got four and they all still work great. I ain't fixing nothing that isn't broke.
Yo Vince! The Milwaukee 25 ft. compact as the overall winner? Ha ha! I have 2 of them. 💪Bought a twin pack of them for $20 during black Friday event a couple years ago. Thanks for all you do. I watched every second of this video. Peace and God be with the Carneglias and all #theverycoolgang. 🙂👍✌️
Still use the old school powerlock. Thanks for the tests!!
Thank you!
You're 100% correct. Stop being brand loyal.
My Milwaukee tape measure filled up with junk that the blade was dragging into the inside (and getting inside the mechanics via that silly finger brake hole). I got tired of it, so I placed it on top of a tree stump and shot it.
I've been using a Harbor Freight HERCULES tape measure since then, I got it on sale for $10, and love it!
Where is my Stanley lever lock. 😢
. . . and where's my Stanley FatMax
I have one right now along with Lufkin shockfoce
They did a video on this channel and the Stanley level lock came out on top it is on vcg channel
ruclips.net/video/aut78kmVHXI/видео.htmlsi=vmlSOhIzR__s0VQC
@@VCGConstruction thank you for sharing it I will take mine down now since she was as official for you I was just trying to look out to help people out that didn't understand
Vince, your tape review was awesome thanks for taking the time👍🏻
Glad you enjoyed it Bill, thanks!
Stanley fatmax are the best hands down im a cladder and mine get wet all the time and still last a long time. Tried all these over the years and non of them compare to Stanley
Hello again, Vince and Vcg
Thank you for another Great Video 👍 I guess the question is just how accurate do they measure. If they are off, I would have to get a better measuring tape. Again thank you 👍
I've never had bad luck with the 25ft auto locking fatmax
I love my 30’ fat max has been my go to for years . But I would like to give the compact millwakee compact a try . Thanks Vince
Update my local hardware store had the Milwaukee compact 30’ for 10 bucks . Great deal not as nice reading as the fat max but not a fat max price . Thanks again Vince
Could you review the Reekon Tomahawk T1 tape measure? Is it worth it
happy to provide if interested in testing out vcgconstruction!
have the stud works like a charm wearing very well after 4 years
Wish you would have tested Lufkin Night Eye as in my experience beats others.
Those tapes suck. Got one free from a builder we worked with 5 years ago. Marks fade away and edges are razor sharp I cut my finger all the time with that tape. Stanly fatmax is the best and only tape I use 10 years+
The black tape with yellow markings sure looks like no other but mine didn’t even last 2 months under light duty use. I had to replace mine with Milwaukee stud
I had one and I never use it anymore because it has an exposed metal hook that WILL bend when dropped. Any tape measure that has an exposed hook is automatically garbage because on a real jobsite shit happens. Tools get dropped. My Milwaukee 25' has a recessed hook that's totally protected. Love it.
Thank you, Vince, for all your testing imput 👍 It helps us all out when purchasing 😊
Glad it was helpful Brian!
TV NEWS: "Protests erupt in front of the VCG Headquarters due to the absence of 'Stanley representation"
☠️
For real the Stanley tape measure has been impressive. From experience is all.
They definitely Didn't ask around. They just chose what they like. Everyone knows Fatmax is king.
I got the Milwaukee stud on Christmas sale 20 bucks for two
One metric I use when picking a tape measures is how easy it is to grab the hook and pull it out when wearing gloves or hooking onto something with the end of the tape when it is reeled up, after all you have to pull it out to use it, so its ease of use.
As a Milwaukee guy, Fat max is king.
If you need such long stand outs, why not just invest in a laser distance measurer?
I know you'll still need a tape for certain applications. But an LDM can do so much more and much more quickly.
I prefer my Lufkin Shockforce G2. The neon green on the black is quite nice
I like these but they twist on me so fast it's ridiculous
Yea mine lasted about a month before peeling
I’d like to see Fastcap tapes included in these. They’re cheap, accurate and easy to read with my middle aged eyes lol. Being a woodworker, mine don’t leave shop much, so they don’t take a ton of abuse. I’d like to see how they’d hold up compared to the others.
I had the wide blade and stud and they both had issues with the tape getting twisted and kinks within a couple of months. I just recently bought the tough series and within a day the thing broke so I returned it and the 2nd one a rivet in the hook broke off within a few weeks. I now use a Kobalt at least I know it’s cheap and if they all suck it may as well be cheap to replace.
I am a big time Milwaukee fan boy. However, I am seriously disappointed with their tape measures. The blades all twist about 12”. This causing them to not stay hooked when I grab an end of a piece of lumber. I have purchased 4 Milwaukee tape measures and they all got twisted. Nome of my Stanley tapes have this problem.
I'm a Nite-eye Shockforce G2 tape user, purely because the neon numbers against the black background is just easier for my eyes. I do like the FatMax and Atomic when using other people's tapes. I will say the Shockforce does have the same issue of the clip sticks below the tape body and is susceptible to damage if you are clumsy.
Stanley is the standard
I wanna see the toughbuilt tapes tested
tb tape is almost just right, the way the hook sits when its rolled up is too flush, can be a bitch to pull out but otherwise great tape.. good as any anyway
Im all Dewalt from toughsystem to all my cordless, but i love that milwaukee Stud with wire pocket clip. Held up the best to mud and concrete dust
Looking jacked Vince 💪🏼
He is looking a bit pumped up these days.
I just wanted to share some of my knowledge on how tape measures are rated now. As stated, manufacturers use "reach" over "standout" commonly. Reach is actually standout plus 3 feet, the approximate length of an arm. This also explains why the standout tests looked as if it fell short of the ratings. Whenever purchasing, if you're looking at that metric, make sure you check which word they use in their rating.
No Vince I am using REEKON T1! It’s the best measure on the market! But the Milwaukee ones are really good! I use them too!
Watched this, after watching best tape measure by Project Farm. While I was satisfied with the testing he performed, I really enjoyed your readability test. That said everyone talking about Milwaukee and Stanly, I'd suggest watching Project Farms video. While readability is important, as a plumber, standout, and dirt resistance, and tape fading, are really important factors and TLDR Dewalt xp premium was basically flawless, with Stanley not working good as new but still good enough, and Milwaukee not useable anymore. Different crafts call for different tape measures.
I've been trying literally every tape measure and my new favorite is Tajima strong tape.
I like the self lock Komelon.
idk....but this needs to be the new eye test at the doctor
🤣
Please help me decide between "Bosch GSB 185 li" and "Makita HP333DWYE" which are available in India at approx similar price of 11700 indian Rupee INR (approx 140 US$)
GSB 185 is brushless hammer drill on 18v batttery , vs Makita HP333D is a brushed hammer drill on 12v battery
Talking to Makita India folks they said DF332DWYE is deprecated and so entry level brushless option from Makita I don't have.
Bosch is pretty commonly available in India compared to Makita , so Makita brand is attractive between the two options.
One note reach is not same as standout as it adds 3' for the reach of the arm. So to get standout you have to subtract 3' when it says reach. So at 10.1' the Dewalt met it's claim.
Own both plus others. Not biased to any brand but i dont like the Milwaukee as much as the DeWalt in these current versions as they seem to wear out quicker (coating) plus rather have a slightly slower retraction to prevent tip damage. But use what tou like. And yes my antique Stanley still works great so will take that over both of these.
I own the Milwaukee 25 ft compact.
On readability, cover up the tape measures to ensure brand bias doesn’t place into someone’s opinion
vince how big is your upper arm size
Is your upper arm size big enough to smash the like button?
52 cm
Love Milwaukee's 6'/10m mini tape measure. I have 4? of them. Ones always close by. I 3D print a lot so having metric is awesome. It's really readable compared to competitors. I got a Dewalt and Milwaukee 25' tape measure- there both fine. But I use a laser more than a 25' tape measure.
I enjoy the komelon contractor series tapes. I use the stainless spring for trim and the fatmax lookin one for framing
I got two of the Milwaukee 25ft mag studs for $19.99 a few months back. Sounds like I scored.
How did stanley do
It doesn't matter what tape you use. Just me consistent with your tape.
Exactly for as long as I can remember I was using the power lock I my first upgrade was a Stanley level lock to me it was and then I got a Lufkin Black widow
@@bluemantom77 I use a Milwaukee tape because it came in a bundle with some other Milwaukee stuff. It does just fine. No I don't know why I have six total though 🤣🤣🤣
@@greezy937 exactly use whatever works for you some of those extreme tests that people put these through not all of us will experience for the most part we're fine with what we use
I have used all of these. Stanley Fatman is by far the best, dewalt second. I love milwaukee and have almost everything, but their tape measures will cut ya after so long.
8:30 he says 14/16
I got the Milwaukee 25' Compact for $9.72 during the holidays, lucky pick 👍🏼
This was excellent! Thank you!
Should have actually performed a high drop test. The plinko board doesn't really give it the impact of a 25 ft plus drop. So your testing is good but incomplete.
Lowes tough built is really good if anyone whos not brand loyal. Thank you for the video!
Measure once cut once…..16’ studs been my go to since it came out a few years ago.
I love my black Crescent tapes. They stand by their lifetime warranty so I really can't complain when I need a new one in 6 months.
cases are tough as hell, . tape could be tougher though
Komeleon tapes the only ones to buy now. The discount price on the contractor ones is too good to pass up. Can be found for around $10 on discount. I have one that's 5 years old been in rain, sand, cold and still out performs a fatmax(one of the worst tape measures made)
👍 Bob Barker was the man! Barker's Beauties!
Fat Max is still the king.
What about metrics?
I do really enjoy my milwaukee stud, but mainly for durability or else I would have stuck with a compact.
If a tape isn't accurate out the box, should be failed immediately. Literally your only job is to give me correct measurements.
I like the lime green one.. can see that thing a mile away and in the dark.
Great job my brother.👍🏻🇺🇸🇺🇸
Thanks Joseph, really appreciate it! Hope you’re doing well my brother! 👍🏻
Idk I got my toughbuilt, 25ft and it was only $16
Wow I didn't know you worked for Price is Right. Did you start right out of high school?
Did I just hear 14/16ths?😂😂
Ultimate tape would be a fat max classic with the scale printed on the bottom off the tape and a revamped hook like the lufkin shockforce g2… maybe a fat max nite eye too.
Milwaukee compact is trash cluttered to read rusts in a week. The only tape I hate more is the tajima g25 overpriced mid tier tape that broke first time hooking a board.
FatMax all day long
Lufkin Nite Eye & Tough Built missing from this comparison.
Your BUYING and USING the WRONG Tape Measure!
ruclips.net/video/aut78kmVHXI/видео.html
Funny enough, the Milwaukee tape measurers have pretty poor reviews on their site. They mainly talk about the locks failing shortly after purchase. All of these are from several months ago, though. Maybe the newer products are better?
Almost as good as Milwaukee stud Milwaukee magnetic goes on sale 2 for $20 or 10 for $70 at Home Depot during fall sale
I will say that Milwaukee was much better than the Dewalt when I used them. I wish Dewalt would update and bring back their XP with dual sided scales.
Milwaukee tapes look nice, unfortunately, they are very resistant to water, dirt, and scratches. Additionally, the retraction speed test is unnecessary because hitting the tape's end after several hundred hits will cause the measuring tape to become uncalibrated. I have owned tapes from Stanley and Dewalt for several years and would not switch them for Milwaukee. If you think otherwise, then do a test by retracting the tape using sandpaper with equal pressure on each measuring tape and then throwing them into water for 24 hours. Because this is comparable to real-life conditions.
if your using the same one accuracy doesnt matter
I like original silver 25ft Stanley after using fat max for years.....too expensive and they dont last.....went back to original a year ago
The time in between retraction is minimal. The question is that would a slower one have a less chance of damaging the end than a faster one?
That’s a very good point
Fast Cap lefty righty all day. Unless I'm framing, then it's a fatmax.
Let's just rename this "The Milwaukee Olympics" 😅
Klein makes the best tapes. Hands down. Sorry, I have everything Milwaukee. It their tapes.
The first reading of A3 was closer to 13-7/8”.
I use all four of these tape measures.
I broke the Milwaukee stud. Ripped the tape.
Billions & Billions served, How you Dern?
@@VCGConstruction good cuz. Living the dream. Glad to see you doing the same 🤙
I love doorable tools.
LOL Vince always picks Milwaukee over DeWalt
B1 - 🤔 23-14/16" ? ? ?
I'm a total Milwaukee guy, but I have used many different tapes. In all honesty, the milwaukee 25ft stud tape is the best I've used imo.
Did I just hear Vince say 14 16ths
Test all tape ever made! Get busy😂
🤔
Fatmax auto lock >
Just eye 👁️ ball 🏀 it.
Traceable NIST...
Haha he said 14/16
15:23
*you're or you are not your...
I have wanted to say that so many times but lost my nerve, thanks, I got a charge out of it. Always makes me nuts, same with there, they're and their, it is constant!!!
MY using the wrong tape measure.
The overall winner is Stanley Fat Max
Bauer is king
Doesn’t matter what you test and most test Stanley’s always outlast second of all who reads the tape from that far out. Some of the test you do are ridiculous.
*You're?
You’re using “your” wrong. 🙂
Al but my drill run on a cord. So i buy what I want no brnd loyalty here