They will unfortunately, football punditry is about clickbait and engagement now . Real punditry died many years ago. Talksport and Skysports have contributed to ruining football.
Really great point take Neville for example he should not be allowed to do Liverpool games he acts like a 10 year old the way he hates on Liverpool all the time with utterly stupid comments as a liverpool fan I can see when they are good and more importantly when they are not so good but Neville acts like a child with them all the time but as you say its entertainment now not punditry
If it was someone Simon didn't like he'd have a very different opinion on it. Suppose he's after some free tickets. If we wanted to listen to a fan commentating we'd watch a fan channel.
Let’s not judge a book by its cover, Gallagher seems to be pretty articulate about the game, more so than most ex-players, and certainly when it comes to his team.
@@paulgarrood120 1-0 up? no, just no, at that point gyokeres had missed a one on one, better chance than you had all game, it was a stupid thing to say that early in the game, born out of pure arrogance
Bit like Stormy Daniels giving her 'political insights' on C4's election broadcast. Its a novelty act to bring in a few extra viewers. At least Noel can string a few sentences together and he's funny.
If this guy didn't make a few songs he'd be nowhere near football commentary or punditry, but that doesn't make him anymore worthy of it. Talk about jobs for the boys.
Commentary should be done by the experts. When you can't watch a game and only listen, their experienced commentary is vital. In the car or whilst working. Need that clear experienced communication skill level to inform the audience of exactly what's happening.
Sky have ovrdone it with Carra and Neville. They need a major reshuffle and new signings I think. These two try hard to be unbiased but their body language is so obvious. Pundits should be people who were top 5 in their position and not from a big team. That is why Roy Keane is much better than these 2. Says it as is.
They literally took it to bad comedy level. Neville thinks that he is some sort of Aristotle of football, Carragher is biased as hell, Keane is OK just OK, but sometimes unbearable and playing his character (moody “thats his job” uncle), Wright knows literally nothing NOTHING about football…
I always agree with Danny best pundit and commentator across the board. Should have more like this. Danny Mills and Gabby on the other hand is so bad I switch off
Some great pundits on talksport but now using youtubers and wannabees like abbey and her lot gone off of it,listen to 5 live over the weekend and wait for cundy,o'hara goldstein and bent during the week!!!!
I could not stand listening to him on comms last night & this is mainly due to the fact that I generally dislike the idea of having three people on commentary which has become more normalised by Sky & BT in recent years but having a guy who has no background in commentary like him added onto the panel genuinely made it unbearable because it felt like he kept chiming in at the wrong time or spoke for long stretches of time when I mainly want to listen to the other two.
Commentators cannot have a bias. I've seen so many trying to be "fans" instead of calling the game as it is. Commentators should never give their opinions IMO; let the co-commentator do it. Commentators can ask the questions, but they should never provide an answer. Martin Tyler has been terrible and Sky was right to let him go. I suspect it's an age thing as well. Look at Joe Biden in speeches. There's so much lag, the same with Tyler. He has no emotions when a goal is scored, unless it's from Manchester United.
Its great but only if they do their research with some facts and not full on bias, I could listen to it everyweek but even with cara and his expertese i hate the constant bias ALL game
Ridiculous to have people that are not commentators or ex players in the commentary box. Noel was cringe as fk to listen to. Doesn't have a clue what he is talking about. The "what a goal" when Foden scored was ridiculous. It was horrendous defending and goalkeeping from Sporting, and he is giving it the big one as if it was a worldie
@@wales123100 Exactly this, also McManaman, Chris Sutton and many others who are actually way worse than Noel was(on his first try) at reigning in their personal bias during comms. You can tell the red cartel supporters a mile off, f all self awareness. One small taste of what every other PL fan in the country has to put up with all the time and they spit their little dummies out. It's been like this for ages and especially noticeable during City games(I suppose none big6 fans will say it's worse for their clubs), we've had years of having to put up with a Liverpool/United fan etc not so subtly routing for the op on CL nights. Blatantly BSing about what the replay actually showed, barely mentioning or sometimes refusing to talk about a clear mistake from the ref. On some occasions not showing the replay(having to rely on US coverage to check it as fan) of something that was ignored by the ref until after the game(knowing it got picked up elsewhere so they had to).
Should be able to pick your commentary... stopped watching sky sports when neville signed up years ago.. would rather stream Spanish commentary or a bunch of Americans over listening to carragher and neville
Gallagher showed how small of a club city is. They can't find proper legends to represent City whenever they are playing. They have to turn to a musician who is a fan of the club 😂😂🤦🏿🤦🏿
Im not a man city fan, but there is no bigger man city legend than the chief. N G is and no worse than anyone else in what he did. I thought he was ok in my unbiased opinion😅
Bit rich from Talksport - the company that hire RUclipsrs to present their shows.
TRUE
A bit rich? They just supported it.
Rather listen to a you tuber than ‘I played the game’ dinosaur or a self centred so called expert freeloading journo or ex player
There should be an option to turn football commentary off. Watching a match on TV, I'd rather just listen to the crowd.
There is, its called volume... Have a look on your remote control and press down till you cant hear it
Volune button
@@donnawhite1926 and how does he listen to the crowd?
Used to have that on SkySports via red button back in the day
I remember that used to be an option, just listen to crowd, pick other camera angles to watch etc, they should bring it back
They will unfortunately, football punditry is about clickbait and engagement now . Real punditry died many years ago. Talksport and Skysports have contributed to ruining football.
😂😂😂
Really great point take Neville for example he should not be allowed to do Liverpool games he acts like a 10 year old the way he hates on Liverpool all the time with utterly stupid comments as a liverpool fan I can see when they are good and more importantly when they are not so good but Neville acts like a child with them all the time but as you say its entertainment now not punditry
Spitboy the same with United
If it was someone Simon didn't like he'd have a very different opinion on it. Suppose he's after some free tickets. If we wanted to listen to a fan commentating we'd watch a fan channel.
📠
Would've loved to hear his opinion if it had been Sam Smith instead of Noel Gallagher!
He`s no worse than all the ex players (men and women) and commentators who talk utter nonsense
But it's ridiculous that they have to find a celebrity fan because they can't find a proper recognisable legend of the club
They have former players that do it.
Female commentators 😂
There have been female comentators for a few seasons now...
There was only ONE Gerald Sinstadt..............
Let’s not judge a book by its cover, Gallagher seems to be pretty articulate about the game, more so than most ex-players, and certainly when it comes to his team.
"didn't think it was going to be this easy" - Noel Gallagher, 2024, right before getting 4 goals smashed against his team
@@nunoboss8any sensible person would have said the same as that stage
@@paulgarrood120 1-0 up? no, just no, at that point gyokeres had missed a one on one, better chance than you had all game, it was a stupid thing to say that early in the game, born out of pure arrogance
If Danny Murphy can do it anyone can.
Sounds like danny wants to bum him and get free tickets for the tour
Mark e Smith reading the football results
Sources have confirmed that City only
Lost yesterday because the players are
still feeling hung over from the FA cup final.
Bit like Stormy Daniels giving her 'political insights' on C4's election broadcast. Its a novelty act to bring in a few extra viewers. At least Noel can string a few sentences together and he's funny.
If this guy didn't make a few songs he'd be nowhere near football commentary or punditry, but that doesn't make him anymore worthy of it. Talk about jobs for the boys.
That’s how the world works sweetheart man up 😘
Unless youre a sporting lisbon fan watching in the uk, you have no reason to be offended by a man city fan on a man city game in europe..
Commentary should be done by the experts. When you can't watch a game and only listen, their experienced commentary is vital. In the car or whilst working. Need that clear experienced communication skill level to inform the audience of exactly what's happening.
If start getting Joe Pasquale I am switching off lol
Anything but squeaky women and the innit crew!
I see Noel has joined Daniel levy & Todd Boehly on Simon’s ‘I must defend at any cost’ list.
I agree with everything danny has said on this subject
next week Timmy Mallet, please!
Noel’s my mate 😂😂
Talksport have gone down the route of having 'man dem youts' in most of their shows now, which is the same. Only about 2 shows worth listening too.
Could you imagine Liam!! 😲🤣🤣As I've grown older and so has Noel, I've grown to like and respect him. 🙂
Sky have ovrdone it with Carra and Neville. They need a major reshuffle and new signings I think. These two try hard to be unbiased but their body language is so obvious. Pundits should be people who were top 5 in their position and not from a big team. That is why Roy Keane is much better than these 2. Says it as is.
They literally took it to bad comedy level. Neville thinks that he is some sort of Aristotle of football, Carragher is biased as hell, Keane is OK just OK, but sometimes unbearable and playing his character (moody “thats his job” uncle), Wright knows literally nothing NOTHING about football…
Talksport are contributing to this as well though?
Absolutely joke having him comment on the match. Make you turn offf, wont say what I think of so many woke commentators. Only there to meet the quota.
I always agree with Danny best pundit and commentator across the board. Should have more like this.
Danny Mills and Gabby on the other hand is so bad I switch off
Some great pundits on talksport but now using youtubers and wannabees like abbey and her lot gone off of it,listen to 5 live over the weekend and wait for cundy,o'hara goldstein and bent during the week!!!!
One of the best musicians ,that is more funny than his commentary Jim 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Pointless segment as they’re all mates with Gallagher so won’t say anything bad about him
Simon doesn’t have a problem with Noel. But has a problem with a black female ex pro footballer. And what’s wrong with Martin Tyler? FFS.
I thought Noel was excellent.
Its a PR stunt that suit all parties at the end of the day
Here was me thinking it was Lescott on comms 😂
in Aussie rules we call those guys special comments guys not commentators
I thought he was very good and unbiased is better than some of the boring normal commentators
I miss John motson
I could not stand listening to him on comms last night & this is mainly due to the fact that I generally dislike the idea of having three people on commentary which has become more normalised by Sky & BT in recent years but having a guy who has no background in commentary like him added onto the panel genuinely made it unbearable because it felt like he kept chiming in at the wrong time or spoke for long stretches of time when I mainly want to listen to the other two.
Simon talking about other people talking drivel??!!
Commentators cannot have a bias. I've seen so many trying to be "fans" instead of calling the game as it is.
Commentators should never give their opinions IMO; let the co-commentator do it.
Commentators can ask the questions, but they should never provide an answer.
Martin Tyler has been terrible and Sky was right to let him go. I suspect it's an age thing as well. Look at Joe Biden in speeches. There's so much lag, the same with Tyler. He has no emotions when a goal is scored, unless it's from Manchester United.
Totaly disagree. Tyler was a brilliant commentator for a very very long period of time. Legend.
get Liam on the mic
Noel is a miserably Tory.
Its great but only if they do their research with some facts and not full on bias, I could listen to it everyweek but even with cara and his expertese i hate the constant bias ALL game
I thought noel did a good job
Let's create jobs for non multi millionaires who have been through education to learn this trade.
Graham played foot ball Simon so don’t have a go at him then hypocrite
Isn't that Darren Fletcher a fan?
He's absolutely awful.. can't stand his commentary .. painful.
There hasn't been a decent pundit since ron manager
Ridiculous to have people that are not commentators or ex players in the commentary box. Noel was cringe as fk to listen to. Doesn't have a clue what he is talking about. The "what a goal" when Foden scored was ridiculous. It was horrendous defending and goalkeeping from Sporting, and he is giving it the big one as if it was a worldie
Better than robbie savage anyday
@@wales123100 Exactly this, also McManaman, Chris Sutton and many others who are actually way worse than Noel was(on his first try) at reigning in their personal bias during comms. You can tell the red cartel supporters a mile off, f all self awareness. One small taste of what every other PL fan in the country has to put up with all the time and they spit their little dummies out. It's been like this for ages and especially noticeable during City games(I suppose none big6 fans will say it's worse for their clubs), we've had years of having to put up with a Liverpool/United fan etc not so subtly routing for the op on CL nights. Blatantly BSing about what the replay actually showed, barely mentioning or sometimes refusing to talk about a clear mistake from the ref. On some occasions not showing the replay(having to rely on US coverage to check it as fan) of something that was ignored by the ref until after the game(knowing it got picked up elsewhere so they had to).
Should be able to pick your commentary... stopped watching sky sports when neville signed up years ago.. would rather stream Spanish commentary or a bunch of Americans over listening to carragher and neville
Listen to Simon’s comments hypocrite Simon you talk rubbish Simon
Must be getting low on money 💰
He was terrible
Makes no difference to me as always have sound off
Can’t believe how bad Noel was on commentary. Couldn’t have picked a better game for it thought haha.
To be fair, Frank Lampard and Steven Gerrard are basically celebrity football managers, who are famous for playing football.
There not tho because they’ve done there coaching badges and played the game 😂
Not every one likes him
Better than listening to Danny Murphy analysis on MOTD!
zzzzzzzzzz...
Gallagher showed how small of a club city is. They can't find proper legends to represent City whenever they are playing. They have to turn to a musician who is a fan of the club 😂😂🤦🏿🤦🏿
Im not a man city fan, but there is no bigger man city legend than the chief. N G is and no worse than anyone else in what he did. I thought he was ok in my unbiased opinion😅
@Asa93-u6c who is the Chief? Gallagher is not a football legend, he is a fan.
@MD_ENTERTAINMENT nor is gary neville.😅
This video made me forget about all the things I was doing. Now I have a new goal of watching it over and over again🍒
The most romantic thing my partner can do? Load the dishwasher without being asked💞
Sexting with me is like reading Shakespeare-lots of dramatic pauses and occasional confusion🌺
This video is the best thing that ever happened to my cat. Now she has a new idol🧡
When you watch the video and realize it's the best thing that happened to you all day💋