Комментарии •

  • @ZEKESPILLEDINKMUSIC
    @ZEKESPILLEDINKMUSIC 14 лет назад +8

    I love Fazil Say's interpretation of the Ravel "Sonatine." He not only plays the music; he feels it, What wonderful pianism!

  • @fazil-say
    @fazil-say 16 лет назад +7

    really nice and singing
    lots of atmosphare
    imaginative

    • @wulfred3681
      @wulfred3681 6 лет назад

      Fazıl Say senin sayende klasik müzik dinler oldum usta. hayata bakışımı değiştirdin

  • @lucas__machado
    @lucas__machado 3 года назад +3

    Genuine pianist and artist, he takes liberties while scrupulously respecting the score. He has his own style and I love it

  • @Spongebobbkn
    @Spongebobbkn 13 лет назад +3

    The second movement is absolutely sublime... a real treat - and even when I'm listening in the background, I have to stop and watch him play it. I just can't have other windows on top.

  • @GiantRock62
    @GiantRock62 13 лет назад +6

    Extraordinary, possibly a genius..

  • @stevenhaff3332
    @stevenhaff3332 6 лет назад +7

    So very nice Mr Say. You admirably seek to bring out the various important musical threads

  • @ercravano
    @ercravano 13 лет назад +8

    Professor Snape!!!!

  • @haznac
    @haznac 13 лет назад +5

    @MusikalischesHaus He LIVES the music, that's what his moving around is all about. He is not posing or anything. I can only applaud such dedication.

  • @thornlesser8994
    @thornlesser8994 7 лет назад +2

    F.Say is so remarkable.Og O wish he would play in Miami. his color and atmospheremake this themost enigmatic , bewitchigand yet clear ad communicative Sonatine .Woderful!

  • @kobetiha
    @kobetiha 13 лет назад +3

    I saw him at Symphony Center in Chicago. His playing was genuine for the main program where he played all Schumann. His first encore was the final variation of Mozart's "Ah vous dirai-je, Maman". The second encore was Mozart's Alla Turca: Allegretto from Piano Sonata in A K.331. I've not seen improvising like this since Glenn Gould who routinely improvised works, especially those by Bach. If that was not enough, he came out to play the final movement of this work by Ravel. Flawless and colorful.

  • @MrAkihiros
    @MrAkihiros 14 лет назад +3

    Stunning interpretation of Ravel. One of the best I've heard. The physical interpretation can be distracting but I really don't mind.

  • @ChamberForMusic
    @ChamberForMusic 9 месяцев назад

    Superlative playing and wonderful music!

  • @anacojocariu09
    @anacojocariu09 13 лет назад

    just wonderful !

  • @necipyesiltepe16
    @necipyesiltepe16 13 лет назад

    Virtuosity ! Ravel and Say. Turkish and high quality music lovers all around the Worls should be proud of them.

  • @seongtaek84
    @seongtaek84 6 лет назад +2

    So beautiful, wow.

  • @jannokas85
    @jannokas85 15 лет назад +1

    LOL! Funny man! He seems to really have enjoyed playing to that audience.

  • @antoinezygfryd
    @antoinezygfryd 16 лет назад

    Fazil Say est un cadeau du ciel.

  • @reev9759
    @reev9759 9 лет назад +4

    Them faces, expressions, and singing: Lang Lang meets Richard Goode.

    • @yagiz885
      @yagiz885 3 года назад

      Face expressions means nothing. A performer has to play with his hands and heart not with his face.

    • @reev9759
      @reev9759 3 года назад

      @@yagiz885 That wasn't especially profound

  • @lucas__machado
    @lucas__machado 3 года назад +1

    Inspired, sincere playing

  • @10Aytek10
    @10Aytek10 14 лет назад +1

    DÜNYADAN TANINAN 10 TÜRK den BIRIDIR !!!!! SENINLE GURUR DUYUYORUZ!

  • @GottaFindPeace
    @GottaFindPeace 14 лет назад

    love him

  • @boogyman19946
    @boogyman19946 15 лет назад +1

    I myself consider music great art where style deals a great matter. You implement your style so the piece is to your own liking, not someone else's.

  • @teramike11
    @teramike11 13 лет назад +5

    He really makes the music come alive. This is what Ravel must have intended.

  • @ACE29q
    @ACE29q 13 лет назад +2

    Looking each movement?
    00:11 First Movement
    03:37 Second Movement
    06:12 Third Movement
    Now, enjoy this extraordinary interpretation.

  • @kyung1104
    @kyung1104 15 лет назад

    fantastic

  • @chenwu9867
    @chenwu9867 Год назад

    ❤️Ravel

  • @pioreczko94
    @pioreczko94 13 лет назад

    awesome

  • @Gorbachev
    @Gorbachev 14 лет назад +1

    He reminds me of the Hunchback of Notre Dame.

  • @y1g1tcn
    @y1g1tcn 15 лет назад +5

    he knows how to touch piano

    • @yagiz885
      @yagiz885 3 года назад

      Evet bütün eseri ppp çalarak inanılmaz iyi dokunuyor piyanoya ya :D :D :D

    • @yagiz885
      @yagiz885 3 года назад

      @@berkeumutsahinturk921 Tempest genel olarak yorumlaması çok zor bir eser değil. Temaları boğacak materyaller yoğun olmadığı için çok üstün bir çaba sarf etmeden dinleyiciye ana fikri vermek mümkün. Ki Ravel'in sonatini öyle değil, bir sürü motif iç içe giriyor ve temaları öne çıkarması zorlaşıyor.

    • @yagiz885
      @yagiz885 3 года назад

      Sürekli aynı tonlarda çalmak bu yüzden büyük bir problem, çok renkli ve spontane bir teknik lazım bu eserin ana mesajını dinleyiciye ulaştırmak için.

  • @sonaeren
    @sonaeren 13 лет назад

    Su gibi, toprak hava gibi nereye giderse gitsin yaratıcı bir olağanüstü müzik insanı ne kadar övünsek azdır. .... söylenebilecek son söz budur .....

  • @cuauhtle
    @cuauhtle 15 лет назад +1

    To begin with I am just a beginner at music theory/history. But, I think after this piece we should ask Say "Do you think what you just played was classical music?". I do not think he would answer "yes". But in his regular concerts he already sticks to original sheet -in a concerto it would already make no sense ignoring the original tempo. I think he understands the pieces very clearly, so he can interpret them in their original form. And, he can add his expressions influenced by modern styles.

  • @TheCitybike
    @TheCitybike 13 лет назад +1

    wow!

  • @TheSkyline001
    @TheSkyline001 13 лет назад

    Ein Genie.Harika.

  • @ErsenAsper
    @ErsenAsper 11 лет назад

    just cool...

  • @TeeteringBulb
    @TeeteringBulb 14 лет назад

    Beautiful phrasing. He plays Ravel like the old boys!

    • @yagiz885
      @yagiz885 3 года назад

      I disagree, old boys don't play unmemorable and uncreative. Not with a single boring line without anything extraordinary but with rational ups and downs.

  • @chiuchiu123
    @chiuchiu123 16 лет назад

    very good performance

  • @pichuchoni
    @pichuchoni 15 лет назад

    bravo fazil....

  • @2kibele2
    @2kibele2 13 лет назад +1

    Tek kelimeyle muhtesem.Sanattan anlamayanlarin cahilce elestirilerini onemsemiyorum. O bir deha.

  • @MLBuckProductions
    @MLBuckProductions 13 лет назад +3

    @Piano194 Just like singers take music already written and make it their own, so can pianists, like Fazil Say

  • @comment_sylph
    @comment_sylph 4 года назад +1

    空中に手やる動きウケる

  • @joan.madrid
    @joan.madrid 15 лет назад

    Vaya pose del pianista.

  • @jannokas85
    @jannokas85 15 лет назад

    I agree.

  • @jannokas85
    @jannokas85 15 лет назад

    Yea, he plays the right hand notes slightly later in some places...

  • @Black-bm8wc
    @Black-bm8wc 5 лет назад +1

    Makes me laugh how people pretends that he doesn't play it right and call it arrogance. Yes ravel wouldn't play it this way. But the music belongs to the one that plays it on the piano, this is his vision of the sonatine, it's called bzing free

  • @Spongebobbkn
    @Spongebobbkn 10 лет назад

    Suspended sentence... he will not be in prison.

  • @KeithOtisEdwards
    @KeithOtisEdwards 16 лет назад +1

    I have the sheet music, from the library, to this piece before me. It's the 1913 Editions Durand printing. Would you kindly point out to me where Fazil Say deviates from the score?

  • @TheRevelation0
    @TheRevelation0 14 лет назад

    Wow, amazing. Very nice phrasing, but I kind of thought in the 1st movement he could have brought out the melody a little bit more though.

  • @user-cn2te8ue2c
    @user-cn2te8ue2c 7 лет назад

    너무잘친다..

  • @Almarillion
    @Almarillion 11 лет назад +1

    actually thats usually what he intends to do.

  • @bryanabeling
    @bryanabeling 15 лет назад

    People don't be so freakin' nit-picky! It's annoying! JEEZ!! Just appreciate it for what it is... a very beautiful piece played by an amazing pianist!

  • @BluncheonMeat
    @BluncheonMeat 14 лет назад

    Sure, the strange expressions and gestures are not the best for the sake of the performance, but he sure seems to be enjoying it. Plus it's quite amusing to watch.

  • @karadavutkaan
    @karadavutkaan 15 лет назад

    süper

  • @boogyman19946
    @boogyman19946 15 лет назад +2

    he always looks like he's drunk. genious skills though.

    • @yagiz885
      @yagiz885 3 года назад

      Yeah what a genius. he can't show up the themes well, his playing is not memorizable at all.

  • @1234musicnote
    @1234musicnote 13 лет назад

    He is amazing

  • @KeithOtisEdwards
    @KeithOtisEdwards 16 лет назад

    I have, from the library, a copy of the sheet music before me. Would you kindly point out where, exactly, Fazil Say deviates from the score? I have the 1913 Editions Durand version.

  • @aygalip3915
    @aygalip3915 11 лет назад +1

    Fazıl say canlı performansdan gelenleri göreyim

  • @hetemovich
    @hetemovich 14 лет назад

    se llama sonatine 1

  • @Dectavius
    @Dectavius 12 лет назад

    Does any one else think Terry Jones from Monty Python when they look at this guy? Great rendition BTW.

  • @lilypoppyfabby4853
    @lilypoppyfabby4853 2 года назад

    3:38 s~ second movement

  • @ACE29q
    @ACE29q 15 лет назад +1

    woow the best ravels sonatine interpretation ive heard

    • @yagiz885
      @yagiz885 3 года назад

      Have you listened Perlemuter's interpretation? It's way better than his.

  • @baglamaci87
    @baglamaci87 16 лет назад

    18 cene katiliyorum...laflar hemen arkadan anlasiliyor.. bu adam zaten her zaman bizim ülkeyi disarida destekledi ve temsil etti.Kendisi her zaman icin türk virtuozu olarak tanildi.hakli tabi ya..müzik dersi yerine din dersiymis..böyle bir sey olamaz..dindar olan zaten dindardir..olmayani da zaten yapamassin..dini siyasete sokupta mecbur etmek en sacma olay...fazil hoca helal sana

  • @KeithOtisEdwards
    @KeithOtisEdwards 16 лет назад

    Humm, another poseur, probably Mammoth's boyfriend. Starting at 2:25 the chords are ambiguous, as one might expect, and the progression is as follows: Bdim7, Edim7, Bdim7, Edim7, leading to the climax of C-F-C. Nowhere are there straight major or minor chords.
    Of course, Mammoth10 originally claimed not that there were merely two or three wrong notes (which there aren't), but that Say was playing something not in the score, and was "making his own transcription of the piece."

  • @KeithOtisEdwards
    @KeithOtisEdwards 16 лет назад

    Dear Mammoth 10,
    I have, from the library, a copy of the sheet music before me. Would you kindly point out where, exactly, Fazil Say deviates from the score? I have the 1913 Editions Durand version.

  • @harleydav
    @harleydav 15 лет назад

    Hahaha you guys funny. He is Fazil Say. He is pro. Cheapest ticket goes not less 1000$ if you can find seat. He is very famous. I guess he is turkish.

  • @enak1989
    @enak1989 14 лет назад

    como se llama esta obra??
    alguien sabe??

  • @Atylakan
    @Atylakan 14 лет назад

    il est fouuuuuu

  • @filthysoap
    @filthysoap 16 лет назад

    haha it was a beautiful performance but the hand movements crack me up lol

  • @Spongebobbkn
    @Spongebobbkn 12 лет назад

    @fikradas I agree, he ruins my favourite section at 4:50 by just shotgunning right through it... love his enthusiasm, but it's definitely at a cost.

  • @holzy4565
    @holzy4565 12 лет назад

    more of a fan of David Fung's interpretation of this.

  • @RidinOn20s
    @RidinOn20s 14 лет назад

    @10Aytek10 öbürleri kim...?

  • @Cagdas_AKCAY
    @Cagdas_AKCAY 15 лет назад

    I never heard that before maybe he is a savant some sort.:D

  • @MrAkihiros
    @MrAkihiros 13 лет назад

    he looks like oscar wilde on a diet. but excellent performance.

  • @KeithOtisEdwards
    @KeithOtisEdwards 16 лет назад

    O.k., fair enough. Unlike Mammoth 10, you know the piece. At the risk of inviting M.10 to suggest all sorts of imaginary wrong notes, I'll be honest and admit that in 5 simultaneous tones played rapidly, my ear is too poor to tell if that is an F# or not, or a B-nat. in the next measure. But I'll still give the benefit of the doubt to Say. From what I can hear, as compared to the score, he plays no wrong notes.
    I am able, however, discern all the rhythms and those Fazil Say nails perfectly.

  • @KeithOtisEdwards
    @KeithOtisEdwards 10 лет назад +36

    The trouble with classical music at RUclips is that there is always some guy (it's always a guy) who has been appointed by God to point out the flaws (as imagined by him) in a performance by a celebrated artist. Of course, when you click on the critic's channel, he invariably has nothing to show for his soi-disant genius.
    I own a copy of the score for Ravel's *Sonatine,* and I can attest to the fact that Say plays the piece precisely as Ravel wrote it. Each variation in tempo is as indicated by Ravel. I challenge all the puerile critics below to specify exactly where they imagine this performance varies from what Ravel wrote.

    • @1nsdrb246
      @1nsdrb246 10 лет назад +2

      yeah, always hate it when this random guy out of nowhere goes: "an error at 3:whatever time".. Irritates me so much, like they can play it as good as the performer

    • @KeithOtisEdwards
      @KeithOtisEdwards 10 лет назад

      Firelord0EX It might be OK if the critic has his own performance video of the piece that he wants to show off. That I could tolerate. But you click on the critic's channel and, without exception, no videos; maybe something about how he liked a Lorde video. That's true not just here but with all critical comments under classical videos.
      It's typical for some poor apple, with no talent or skill, to gain self-esteem on the cheap by deprecating the accomplishments of gifted people.

    • @earthwormjxm
      @earthwormjxm 9 лет назад

      It's called a troll.

    • @KeithOtisEdwards
      @KeithOtisEdwards 9 лет назад +1

      "Troll" is too kind. When I read such comments, I think, "Loser" -- or more accurately, "rectum."

    • @ethansaltmere
      @ethansaltmere 9 лет назад

      Keith Otis Edwards
      Okay, I also have the score. A few things I noticed in the first movement. Perhaps you can cross-check them.
      Bar 5 - does not observe mf at end of bar
      Bars 24 - 25 - does not synchronize chords but instead breaks left and right hands
      In the middle of the development where it is written a tempo does not observe pp marking and instead crescendos to forte
      Does not observe anime tempo marking in the development
      Does not observe only ff marking and instead plays considerably quieter then the music that goes before.

  • @icedfirion
    @icedfirion 12 лет назад

    wtf does jajaja mean...

  • @KeithOtisEdwards
    @KeithOtisEdwards 16 лет назад +1

    After examining the score to Ravel's "Sonatine," and after following the score as the video plays, and after repeated requests to Mammoth10 to reveal just where he thinks Say deviates from the score, I can report that Fazil Say plays each note perfectly just as Ravel wrote it, and that Mammoth 10 is just another poseur and troller looking to get some attention.

  • @coocoobananas101010
    @coocoobananas101010 13 лет назад +1

    he has super bad posture, but it doesn't matter because he is an amazingly talented pianist.

  • @10Aytek10
    @10Aytek10 14 лет назад

    @RidinOn20s
    kimse kim ... arastir bul.

  • @londonerci
    @londonerci 13 лет назад

    @Piano194 u know what interpretation means m8..if u dont ,look at the dictionary

  • @MsMasterjo
    @MsMasterjo 13 лет назад

    quelle interprétation sensuelle, intimiste et vraiment inspirée !! une des meilleures versions de cette pièce

  • @doranos
    @doranos 14 лет назад

    @bs2k6 je sais que je me ferais cracher avec mon français que j'apprends depuis 2 mois. ça changera bientot.
    mais toi tu vas continuer melanger le nationalism et la musique avec cette point de vue. je pense pas que ça va changer.

  • @ELPsteel
    @ELPsteel 15 лет назад +1

    Nice technique, and he plays the rhythms well! I have some minor, debatable issues...I think he's a bit too showy - instead of all the movement he could be concentrating on bringing the melody out more. Also, he ignores some important articulations. In the second movement, the end of the first theme has the two bass notes marked staccato which he plays legato AND pedals! There's a difference between interpretation and playing something incorrectly. It was written that way for a reason!

  • @George12String
    @George12String 13 лет назад

    Hey! He looks like Nicholas Cage!

  • @zappvar
    @zappvar 14 лет назад

    He looks like Snape. Haha lols

  • @zappvar
    @zappvar 15 лет назад

    Ehh, because i've played it. If you had, you would have noticed it too.

  • @vineyardst1
    @vineyardst1 14 лет назад

    It is you who should be ashamed of having written that derogatory message.
    He doesn't have to hide behind a folding panel.

  • @boogyman19946
    @boogyman19946 15 лет назад

    i don't agree.
    there is a difference between recreating and improvising. Because those notes were marked staccato they weren't set in stone to be played that way. Here's the thing, a lot of people play from notes but add nothing of their own making music dull and boring over time because nothing changes. Maybe he didn't change much in this piece, but his version of the Turkish March is off the scale of awesomeness.

  • @MoaiMaea
    @MoaiMaea 15 лет назад

    Maybe he is xD

  • @boogyman19946
    @boogyman19946 15 лет назад

    just maybe =] hehe

  • @Turco949
    @Turco949 15 лет назад

    What is amazing is that you are still talking/replying back to me!
    I hope, at least, all that name-calling and insults were making you feel better about yourself! Anyhow, if you decide to continue this moronic chat, by all means but I will not indulge myself any further...

  • @ethansaltmere
    @ethansaltmere 9 лет назад

    (for Keith Otis Edwards and all those who have the score) Okay, I also have the score. A few things I noticed in the first movement. Perhaps you can cross-check them.
    Bar 5 - does not observe mf at end of bar
    Bars 24 - 25 - does not synchronize chords but instead breaks left and right hands
    In the middle of the development where it is written a tempo does not observe pp marking and instead crescendos to forte
    Does not observe anime tempo marking in the development
    Does not observe only ff marking and instead plays considerably quieter then the music that goes before.

    • @KeithOtisEdwards
      @KeithOtisEdwards 9 лет назад +3

      Ethan Those who are interested in the accuracy of the great musician "Ethan" and his nitpicking of this performance but who do not have access to the score can check maestro Ethan's accusations against the timings shown in the video. Judge for yourself how accurate and significant his complaints are:
      The score indicates that between 0:18 and 0:20 the music should become louder. Dr. Ethan maintains that Fazil Say fails to play louder. ("does not observe mf at end of bar")
      At 2:16 the score calls for the music to become quiet. The renowned virtuoso Ethan says that it is instead played louder. ("does not observe pp marking and instead crescendos to forte") (At 2:18 it is supposed to become louder.)
      At 2:27 the score is marked *Animé* ("animated"). Professor Ethan complains that this marking is not observed and that the playing is not "animated."
      The first movement is supposed to reach its dynamic peak at 2:31. Ethan (the great composer) accuses that it "instead plays considerably quieter then [sic] the music that goes before." (At 2:32 it is then supposed to become softer and slower, so maybe Ethan is just slow.)
      Such young geniuses (or just "Ethan" under different names) have for years been disparaging this performance as "a mess," but that's all they can come up with.
      I think it's a fine performance, and that Ethan should instead shut up and practice his scales.

    • @ethansaltmere
      @ethansaltmere 9 лет назад

      Keith Otis Edwards I appreciate your willingness to defend individuality. But I'm not happy with your hypocrisy. You obviously no little to nothing of this music (or have no hearing) so how can you judge others on their criticism? 'I own a copy of the score for Ravel's Sonatine, and I can attest to the fact that Say plays the piece precisely as Ravel wrote it' is simply wrong. Can you please not post uninformed imperatives in the future as it misinforms all the young people on the site. Thank you

    • @KeithOtisEdwards
      @KeithOtisEdwards 9 лет назад +1

      Ethan Now that I've posted the timings in the video as they relate to your criticism, the whole world can decide for themselves how valid your nitpicking is. It is unnecessary for me to comment further, as people can now make up their own minds as to what your criticism is worth.

    • @KeithOtisEdwards
      @KeithOtisEdwards 9 лет назад +1

      Once you mature, trolling won't seem so cool anymore.

    • @olivierverhaeghe755
      @olivierverhaeghe755 8 лет назад

      +Keith Otis Edwards TROLOLOLOOLOLOLOLOLOL I'M 65 YEARS OLD XDXDXD PTDR.
      peasant.

  • @zappvar
    @zappvar 15 лет назад

    At 8:23 he plays a G instead of a G sharp.. And he does arpeggioes all over the peace. I like somewhat like his interpretation, but sometimes it's just out of proportions..

  • @doranos
    @doranos 14 лет назад

    @bs2k6 cest toi qui a utilise ce phrase "honteux d'etre francais"
    cest ironique que tu ne comprends pas ton stereotype.

  • @mistou26
    @mistou26 13 лет назад +1

    Usually i like Fazil Say a lot ..
    here i find him tottaly having "passed by" ..
    Of course it is certain that he really lives what he plays .. adn that he has a vision of this master piece ...
    So, to me, there stay an interesting curiosity: The probably most "anti-Ravelien" great performance i have ever heard ... LOL ...

  • @egitnyc
    @egitnyc 15 лет назад

    then close your eyes and just listen. If you still don't like it, that's fine. But I really don't think what he looks like should have any bearing on what you think of his playing. Since I've scrolled all the way down to your comment, I can't see his face in the video window. And he sounds okay. Maybe not the best... but his gyrations on the bench really aren't the point.

  • @KeithOtisEdwards
    @KeithOtisEdwards 12 лет назад +2

    @Piano194 The trouble with classical music at RUclips is that there's always some guy (it's always a guy) who has been appointed by God to point out the flaws (as imagined by him) in a performance by a celebrated artist. Of course, when you click on the critic's channel, he invariably has nothing to show for his soi-disant genius.
    It seems typical for some poor apple with no talent or ability to gain self-esteem on the cheap by deprecating the accomplishments of gifted people.

  • @timespaice
    @timespaice 10 лет назад +8

    4:07 lol

  • @Medsas
    @Medsas 16 лет назад

    is it me or it sounds like he's putting arpeggiated chords all over the place?

  • @MrFireonice
    @MrFireonice 14 лет назад

    Good playing without looking at you. lol
    I like David Fung's version better.

  • @witoldzio
    @witoldzio 11 лет назад +1

    what about following what the composer wrote in the score? a fortissimo when Ravel says pianissimo? - that's called arrogance.
    Otherwise, very impressive pianism....