no no and no again. if i fly especially somewhere and pay shit loads of money i expect her(and every singer) to sing live each and every single note. singers using pre-recorded is like giving scores to athletes according to their training videos. you cant/dont want to , don't do a live shows.
@@og3673exactly, like how mariah lip her whole show in vegas now. I do agree with you thats its unethical for the amount of money people pay. I dont understand why is there not a law on this.
Her actual live performances are sooo much better. I don’t blame her for lip syncing, in fact, I support her. She did *hundreds* of shows, she *needs* to preserve her voice.
Céline is extremely professional. She uses playback only in the high notes of her classics, which no longer need publicity, and she much less needs to prove that she has talent. The woman has performed more than 1,300 shows, of which more than 1,000 were in Vegas, singing 4x a week, for 16 years, I still think her voice has lasted a long time. I know her dubbing script inside and out. She never dubbed the entire show, so much so that when she had vocal problems, she canceled the show. There's no point in limiting it to playback. Everyone uses TV programs, or in isolated situations. Unlike others out there, Celine has the full capacity to sing her songs 100% live whenever she wants.
I am not a fan, but the Falling Into You album is very good. Lipping is a way for singers to take care of their voice. Don't judge them for that. Nobody is perfect. Even my Mariah Carey lips a lot. Anyway, I still love her, and I will love her forever no matter what. You do not stop loving your mother when she is getting older and grey hair starts to come out, and her beauty starts to fade. Well, I will not stop loving my fave singers bc they lip either.
I honestly don’t see or hear the difference whether she sings live or not . Which just shows that her skill is untouched if she can still sound like a prerecorded live
That you do not find the difference does not mean there are not big differences in quality, resonance, and health at the time of belting. Lipping is ok, but there are certainly a lot of differences.
Her haters might diss her for this, but they should remember that Celine using pre recorded vocals it doesn’t she can’t sing anymore. For example, she used pre recorded vocal for MHWGO in Vegas since 2011 (?), and all sudden she performed the song LIVE in April 2019 which proofs that she still can sing the song live (And yeah, even she used pre recorded vocals, she still can sold out venues 🙃)
Well I tell you I would've never known playback or live performances, all I know is that I love 💕 to hear Celine Dion singing. Lots of love 💕 from Trinidad and Tobago in the Caribbean. The best Diva as far as I'm concerned.
أنا متزامن مع صاحبتي أمريكا تزامن إلهي 🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠 التزامن لغة الله العظيم 🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️ التزامن ليس لغتكم بل لغة الله وحده 🇮🇱🧝♂️🇺🇲✅✅✅✅ سيلين ديون لا تحاولي سرقة سيكارتي من يدي 🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🚬🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠 سيكارتي في صحة أمريكا ⚕️ سيكارتي مضرة بالصحة 🚬 ولكن أنا قد أعتدت عليها ولن أتنازل عن حقي في التدخين التدخين يمنع عن كل أحد إلا أنا لئه على راسي ريشة 🪶
My opinion, The Show Must Go On, live The Power Of Love, live, My Heart Will Go On, both lives easily, It’s All Coming Back To Me, live, All By Myself 1 live, second playback, the live performance sounds slightly strained, Because You Loved Me, playback, To Love You More, playback, Where Does My Heart Beat Now, live, Ammore Annascunnuto live, Alone, playback, the notes aren’t sustained for as long in the live performance, Taking Chances, tie, they are very different, I Surrender, live for the parts shown, but she dodged some notes, Misled playback, Falling Into you, playback, and Only One Road live easily.
She is suffering from muscle spasms in her legs due to the stage from Vegas. I believe she is doing better now tho! She’s such a troop tho! She’ll get through all this.
PORTIONS of her show being pre-recorded when literally performing for 16 years nearly nonstop is acceptable to me.
no no and no again. if i fly especially somewhere and pay shit loads of money i expect her(and every singer) to sing live each and every single note. singers using pre-recorded is like giving scores to athletes according to their training videos. you cant/dont want to , don't do a live shows.
@@og3673Easy, then dont go see her. Even if she's lipping, Its still her vocals after all. 😶
@@og3673exactly, like how mariah lip her whole show in vegas now. I do agree with you thats its unethical for the amount of money people pay. I dont understand why is there not a law on this.
Celine doesn't lip all of her performance's in vegas. IJBOL
Her actual live performances are sooo much better. I don’t blame her for lip syncing, in fact, I support her. She did *hundreds* of shows, she *needs* to preserve her voice.
Céline is extremely professional.
She uses playback only in the high notes of her classics, which no longer need publicity, and she much less needs to prove that she has talent.
The woman has performed more than 1,300 shows, of which more than 1,000 were in Vegas, singing 4x a week, for 16 years, I still think her voice has lasted a long time.
I know her dubbing script inside and out.
She never dubbed the entire show, so much so that when she had vocal problems, she canceled the show.
There's no point in limiting it to playback.
Everyone uses TV programs, or in isolated situations.
Unlike others out there, Celine has the full capacity to sing her songs 100% live whenever she wants.
Her effing RESONANCE when her voice is recorded through fan videos. Is so good and full!
Селин голос просто фантастика. ❤❤❤❤❤
I am not a fan, but the Falling Into You album is very good. Lipping is a way for singers to take care of their voice. Don't judge them for that. Nobody is perfect. Even my Mariah Carey lips a lot. Anyway, I still love her, and I will love her forever no matter what. You do not stop loving your mother when she is getting older and grey hair starts to come out, and her beauty starts to fade. Well, I will not stop loving my fave singers bc they lip either.
She sa g a lot live
No difference ❤️ Best Diva 😍
I honestly don’t see or hear the difference whether she sings live or not . Which just shows that her skill is untouched if she can still sound like a prerecorded live
That you do not find the difference does not mean there are not big differences in quality, resonance, and health at the time of belting. Lipping is ok, but there are certainly a lot of differences.
i really wish mariah could learn from CD lol, it's just so obvious when she switched from current vocal back to the prerecorded/studio track 🙄🙄🙄
hahahahh Mariah does not even care anymore. She knows we know she lips some parts of her songs.
😂 same I wish Celine taught her some tips how to be lip sync.
Mariah doesn't really care if we notice tho 😅
Most of your clips labeled as pre-recorded is actually done live although some are pre but most of them are live
All of her pre-recorded tracks are so well done!!
Except to love you more 2018. Maybe it’s not perfect intentionally, as to make people think it is actually live?
@@alexbodi5526 yeah.Or maybe it was recorded during a rehearsal or Soundcheck!?
@@kezoorfilipe1847 I guess it’s not impossible, but I doubt it.
I think amor annascunto was ore recorded in 2005😃
@@alexbodi5526 what’s wrong with the to love you more track? 🤔🤔 The E5 has a lot of strain but it’s still pretty good isn’t it?
Her haters might diss her for this, but they should remember that Celine using pre recorded vocals it doesn’t she can’t sing anymore. For example, she used pre recorded vocal for MHWGO in Vegas since 2011 (?), and all sudden she performed the song LIVE in April 2019 which proofs that she still can sing the song live
(And yeah, even she used pre recorded vocals, she still can sold out venues 🙃)
(I also wrote that comment to shade Celine’s hater, especially Airis Airis)
She’s a freak hands down! A goddess
I’m sure some of those pre-recorded tracks were actually live...
No. I promise you none of them are.
Well I tell you I would've never known playback or live performances, all I know is that I love 💕 to hear Celine Dion singing. Lots of love 💕 from Trinidad and Tobago in the Caribbean. The best Diva as far as I'm concerned.
It’s kind of sad she got away with using a pre-recorded track from 1994 in 2008 and 2009.
What do you think of her performance of to love you more at the junos and rosie odonnel show?
@@kezoorfilipe1847 They are ok, but Junos is the best of the 2.
@@alexbodi5526 i agree.
At least its her voice but it doesn't fit her anymore 🙄🤣🙄🙄
Michael Jackson got away with using studio vocals from 1978-79 in 1997
سبحان الله والحمدلله ولا إله إلا الله والله أكبر كما ينبغي لكرم وجهه وعز جلاله 🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠💺🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠
I can't tell the difference, well i can barely tell.
You’re very wrong on a lot of the 90’s pre recorded vocals you are claiming- most of those performances were live.
Its so obvious in 2008/2009
Her vocals at that time is much Deeper and Fuller than the 90s
Nope, they were all pre-recorded, with a lot of proof.
Those are not pre-recorded vocals. They are pitch corrected after the show is over as everything gets recorded on a separate track
And BTW no ones perfect. Celine is still one of the best ever to do it
Ngl shes a really good lipper
أنا متزامن مع صاحبتي أمريكا تزامن إلهي 🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤👥👤🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠
التزامن لغة الله العظيم 🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️🏴☠️
التزامن ليس لغتكم بل لغة الله وحده 🇮🇱🧝♂️🇺🇲✅✅✅✅
سيلين ديون لا تحاولي سرقة سيكارتي من يدي 🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠🚬🌠🌠🌠🌠🌠
سيكارتي في صحة أمريكا ⚕️
سيكارتي مضرة بالصحة 🚬
ولكن أنا قد أعتدت عليها
ولن أتنازل عن حقي في التدخين
التدخين يمنع عن كل أحد إلا أنا لئه على راسي ريشة 🪶
Every celebrity have to lip sync 🫠 she is still my romain empire ! 😭🫶🏻😍
Because you loved me was live!
No, she began lipping it in 2015 and only sang it live twice since then.
It wasn't😅
3 times@@alexbodi5526
2:32 This is may 17, 2016??
ommg at 2:38 ❤❤ woww real live fuckin great note
Her fans get super mad whenever you call out that she’s been lip synching to pre-recorded vocals for ages.
What fans?
@@heeheeriah Most of them actually.
OMG her facial expression @1:55 was very funny and such a giveaway that she lipped
ahahaha its obvious lol
My opinion, The Show Must Go On, live The Power Of Love, live, My Heart Will Go On, both lives easily, It’s All Coming Back To Me, live, All By Myself 1 live, second playback, the live performance sounds slightly strained, Because You Loved Me, playback, To Love You More, playback, Where Does My Heart Beat Now, live, Ammore Annascunnuto live, Alone, playback, the notes aren’t sustained for as long in the live performance, Taking Chances, tie, they are very different, I Surrender, live for the parts shown, but she dodged some notes, Misled playback, Falling Into you, playback, and Only One Road live easily.
Why do you prefer Falling Into You Playback?
@@kezoorfilipe1847 Idk, it just sounds better to me I guess.
Tu sei super io non kambiaretue kansone kon nesun ajtra
stealer is this your real vid i know who is the owner
Yes, this is their second account.
Where is the It's All Coming Back To me Now pre recorded performance from?
The performance is from a new day las vegas possible filmed around 2003 or 2004, and the prerecorded track was made in 2003 and used until 2009.
Anyone know the reasoning behind the pre recorded vocals? Just to help persevere her voice?
Yes.
Probably... Her catalogue is super demanding and she does a lot of shows.
That makes sense.. Wouldn’t want to damage something as precious as her singing voice. Not to mention her recent illnesses. Bless her 😇
She is suffering from muscle spasms in her legs due to the stage from Vegas. I believe she is doing better now tho! She’s such a troop tho! She’ll get through all this.