Same as Westminster government and pensioners freezer and starver in London called keir starmer and Rachel reeves and the whole labour party or nearly rh all for Diane abbot has tried to stick up for the pensioners winter fuel payments
And the £5 BILLION Westminster sent to Scottish Government for Covid relief for businesses, which wasn’t distributed? Audit Scotland cannot identify where this huge sum went!
Too true, robbing your own supporters is not a route to success, but still there's numpties who obviously lost nothing who continue to support them, even some who run RUclips channels. Meantime don't forget the £17.6 BILLION specifically for the NHS was siphoned off from the Barnett monies by the SNP to spend on other undisclosed projects; same as they did with the WFA for pensioners.
Millions spent on a police investigation that has turned up no evidence of criminality. Nothing more than an establishment and Unionist smear campaign.
The SNP government under FoI refused to provide me with details of legal advice in respect of the imposition of surface water charges in conflict with contract law. The told me such information could discourage lawyers from giving such information in the future
£ 255,500,000 Spent on Public Enquiries and legal fees for failed appeals, including costs resulting from the SNP appointed Lord Advocate admitting the Crown Office maliciously prosecuted some of the individuals involved in the Rangers takeover and damages damages for falsely accusing Mr Salmond and associated costs, legal expenses spent pursuing Mr Salmond.
@ we had a referendum. The SNP had their chance 17 years of SNP Holyrood and it’s a shambles, so is Scotland under their watch. If you still want Indy based on the SNP you’re a 4 by 2.
@fortune-614 we got lied to by David Cameron who said we would have to come out of the European Union and as the scots wanted to stay in the European Union we voted to stay in the union big mistake never trust what comes out of a tories mouth and if we had a referendum now with keir starmer as prime minister and not a good one at that he can't do the job he is hopeless it's a forgone conclusion if we had another referendum now Scotland 🏴 would be free
If the SNP are so transparent why have they redacted so many papers, when we now know that the ones that have subsequently revealed, were only redacted so as not to embarrass them. This actually exposés their incompetence and arrogance to the public.😡
As a lifetime Nationalist, Sturgeon and her globalists have ruined the movement... it's either get rid of councils or shut down the parliament, we don't need both
We should never have came out of the European Union it was the best thing that ever happened it gave the ordinary people rights that they didn't have before i am old enough to remember what ot was like before we joined the European Union and the government wad glad we came out of the European Union as they dont like the ordinary people having rights
Why do they never refer to the dates of each of the letters? Mentioning the dates of the letters would make the discussion look more like a proper audit trail.
Should there not be a seperation of powers in this case. The SNP should not be allowed to interfere cover up or influence criminality. If they do then they should be chargrd with aiding and abetting
@robertdavis3809 it's a mess under labour as well and also we had fourteen years of a glorious mess of everything with the tories at least th snp helped me when I needed it when labour and the tories didn't
@barbaraurquhart2276 I'm glad you got help .But they pushed the jab .Ferries a disgrace .Windfarms a disgrace .Next step is take our holmes for the migrants .
Why have Holyrood when ministers can’t even be bothered to attend. This country needs a clear out and get genuine leadership in who will speak for the GENUINE people of SCOTLAND but god forbid Nationlists who have all but destroyed our country SCOTLAND. Fabulous wages and expenses and for what exactly?
Better to shut it down, it has been a horrendous experiment that has failed Scotland miserably, especially with the grifting , lying , thieving idiots that are the snp.
Empty chamber again. They really don’t give a F***.
They certainly love the free money.
Christmas shopping is high on their list right now
They only appear when its their pay that's being discussed
Scottish Necrosis Party, all dead to morals, work, law, care of Scottish folk or of Scotland and basically GRIFTERS.
SNP are just greedy liars don’t care.
Sturgeon has made a mockery of the Holyrood parliament. The SNP look seriously shifty here
they dont need to look shifty they always have been shifty
Same as Westminster government and pensioners freezer and starver in London called keir starmer and Rachel reeves and the whole labour party or nearly rh all for Diane abbot has tried to stick up for the pensioners winter fuel payments
Try again so is Westminster and downing Street and keit starmer and Rachel reeves
I meant to say keir
And what they have done to the pensioners disgusting
Another minister reading a statement prepared by civil servants
And lawyers.
What's happened to the missing £600,000? It's taken 1,250 days and Still No Progress.
and the money useless sent abroad
And the £5 BILLION Westminster sent to Scottish Government for Covid relief for businesses, which wasn’t distributed? Audit Scotland cannot identify where this huge sum went!
Too true, robbing your own supporters is not a route to success, but still there's numpties who obviously lost nothing who continue to support them, even some who run RUclips channels. Meantime don't forget the £17.6 BILLION specifically for the NHS was siphoned off from the Barnett monies by the SNP to spend on other undisclosed projects; same as they did with the WFA for pensioners.
Millions spent on a police investigation that has turned up no evidence of criminality. Nothing more than an establishment and Unionist smear campaign.
and the £46 million "ring fenced" money from the rural budget that has gone missing.
Come 2026 let’s forget them once and for all.
And labour and the tories get rid of them
We dont need the LAW to sort out SNP street justice will work just fine without all the red tape
YOU WILL NEVER EVER GET TO THE BOTTOM OF ANY OF THE SPECIAL NEEDS PARTY.
Lying has no consequences. 🤬🤬
@david watson1538, yes just ask Boris Johnson.
The FOI officer in the Scottish Government needs to be brought to Parliament to answer any questions asked of him .
be funny if that was Sturgeon working remotely from home as she sit on her arse eating bags of crisps and watching telly
What does FOI stand for in this context? Answers on a postcard, please, or just make your suggestions below.
@ …….the FREEDOM OF INFORMATION act .
Where are all the MSP’s. Must be great to go on holiday days before Christmas 😡
How much do they get paid to not turn up, no wounder Scotland has lost the plot.
That's the house of Lords as well shut that place down abolish the house of Lords and Westminster government
Not many at this important sitting, must be at the bingo.
In the hoose still in their jammies 🐷🐖🐽🤬
So we have Sturgeon………lawyer and we have Starmer…….lawyer. Is this telling us something by any chance? Mmmmmmm!
Never trust a snake lawyer
Looks like another busy day in Holyrood !!!
Worth every penny! Aye right.
Well done Tories. Simply asking the questions most of us have been asking long and weary.
Yes say good bye tories
And labour
FOI criticisms by the Commissioner are like water off a duck's: a total lack of embarrassment by the SNP minster in a chamber empty of his SMPs.
Better them than the tyrant keir starmer the pensioner starver
The SNP government under FoI refused to provide me with details of legal advice in respect of the imposition of surface water charges in conflict with contract law. The told me such information could discourage lawyers from giving such information in the future
All 10 of them that bother to turn up for "Topical" questions.
Nothing changes DEFLECT, BLAME and LIE!!
£ 255,500,000 Spent on Public Enquiries and legal fees for failed appeals, including costs resulting from the SNP appointed Lord Advocate admitting the Crown Office maliciously prosecuted some of the individuals involved in the Rangers takeover and damages damages for falsely accusing Mr Salmond and associated costs, legal expenses spent pursuing Mr Salmond.
And counting!!
Why was he not embarrassed by the SNP malfeasance so Cleary outlined. More thug than minister in my opinion
Holyrood is a waste of time
Always has been, always will be
So is Westminster time we scots ruled ourselves
@ we had a referendum. The SNP had their chance 17 years of SNP Holyrood and it’s a shambles, so is Scotland under their watch. If you still want Indy based on the SNP you’re a 4 by 2.
@fortune-614 we got lied to by David Cameron who said we would have to come out of the European Union and as the scots wanted to stay in the European Union we voted to stay in the union big mistake never trust what comes out of a tories mouth and if we had a referendum now with keir starmer as prime minister and not a good one at that he can't do the job he is hopeless it's a forgone conclusion if we had another referendum now Scotland 🏴 would be free
@fortune-614 we the scots would win our freedom
Neil Gray working out his limousine itineray for the week.
If the SNP are so transparent why have they redacted so many papers, when we now know that the ones that have subsequently revealed, were only redacted so as not to embarrass them. This actually exposés their incompetence and arrogance to the public.😡
The only thing that's transparent about the SNP is the fact that people with more than 2 brain cells can see straight through them.
Corrupt to the core
Along with keir starmer and Rachel reeves
Empty seats , must be business for the people not their own money
Only 9 seats now???
Is there no way we could vote them out sooner?? Vote of no confidence perhaps
Shut down that place it’s a wast of time & money
As a lifetime Nationalist, Sturgeon and her globalists have ruined the movement... it's either get rid of councils or shut down the parliament, we don't need both
Along with Westminster government and downing Street and get rid of the tories and labour
I'm just waiting for them to blame [please insert] Tories, Labour, Brexit, The English, Westminster....
We should never have came out of the European Union it was the best thing that ever happened it gave the ordinary people rights that they didn't have before i am old enough to remember what ot was like before we joined the European Union and the government wad glad we came out of the European Union as they dont like the ordinary people having rights
Basically, they know there finished. Therefore no longer give a damn about Scotland or its people.
Why do they never refer to the dates of each of the letters? Mentioning the dates of the letters would make the discussion look more like a proper audit trail.
Scottish government should be abolished, no use for these corrupt nutters.
Dissolve Westminster government and downing Street and Dissolve the stupid union
Nothing will happen to the queen of dreghorn.
waste of money kid on parliment full of chancers pathetic
I'm really struggling to see the point, or the benefit to Scottish people of this Assembly.
They need to make a new year special of this, this is so hilarious
The SNP must cringe with embarrassment every time Fergus gets to his feet, telling a different but accurate narrative to theirs 😅😅
Corrupt to the core 🤬 🤬👎🤬 the whole of the brittish establishment and the doll's house in Edinburgh 🤬🤬🤬🤬👎👎👎🤬🤬🤬
Is she still around ? she must hold a lot of dirt on a lot of people
Nicola let's go to France 🇫🇷
The SUN ffs it’s a rotten rag, how are sales going in Liverpool??
Should there not be a seperation of powers in this case. The SNP should not be allowed to interfere cover up or influence criminality. If they do then they should be chargrd with aiding and abetting
Too many big words ....call a spade a spade not a horticultural instrument 😅
She should sit next to Axel
Disgusting
Ah, the "Scottish" sun, so it must be true then!
Accused? Any evidence?
The Scottish Facists paper 🙄
Imagine a Tory going on about tax payers money
They can't open their mouthes after fourteen years of a tory mess disgusting and keir starmer the pensioner starver is worse
@@barbaraurquhart2276And the snp who are STILL giving bus companies £300 million EVERY YEAR for the under22s bus pass. 🤡
Here is sturgeon and yousaf now?
So THE ANTI SCOTTISH SUN doesn't believe innocent until PROVED guilty.
I would never buy the sun
@barbaraurquhart2276 , as does nobody in Liverpool.
So the Scottish sun tell lies, but the snp government who run this country are ALWAYS totally honest 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@daffytree2605 They have NEVER been honest, the idiots of the snp do NOT know the meaning of Honesty.
Waist of money and space .Work from London Save us all money .
Get Rid of London Scotland 🏴 rule ourselves have our freedom then we can pick our own government
@barbaraurquhart2276 look at the record .A mess .
@robertdavis3809 it's a mess under labour as well and also we had fourteen years of a glorious mess of everything with the tories at least th snp helped me when I needed it when labour and the tories didn't
@barbaraurquhart2276 I'm glad you got help .But they pushed the jab .Ferries a disgrace .Windfarms a disgrace .Next step is take our holmes for the migrants .
This overpriced kennel needs to be closed down.
Think the vast majority in Scotland would love to see that, get these useless grifters back on the scrap heap where they all belong.
Another Tory trying to make a name for himself reading his pre written speech.
Why have Holyrood when ministers can’t even be bothered to attend. This country needs a clear out and get genuine leadership in who will speak for the GENUINE people of SCOTLAND but god forbid Nationlists who have all but destroyed our country SCOTLAND. Fabulous wages and expenses and for what exactly?
Why have Westminster government they are a total embarrassment and shambles
True but include the limos bills
Better to shut it down, it has been a horrendous experiment that has failed Scotland miserably, especially with the grifting , lying , thieving idiots that are the snp.
Why so few people attending the parliament. Where are they?
Away in their camper vans?