3 LED test - Cheap COB vs. Philips ZES vs. CREE XHP70
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
- Support the channel making a donation at: paypal.me/kaliope
1. distance test: • LED bulb battle - Cree...
2. night ride test: • Philips LED bulbs in p...
3. Factory fiitted LED vs Chinese Philips: • Octavia LED vs Chines...
The cob were solid, the Philips shined more crisp overall and to the sides, the cree seemed to shine more towards the ground
Cree is great, but on camera the Philips look to have the better distance, which is most important at driving speeds, not a few lumen more brightness right in front of you.
Thanks for posting, very nice video - concise, music pleasant and not loud, practical demonstrations - perfect!
I have to agree. The phillips has way more brightness at distance even though the cree is suppose to be more powerful. BTW could you do power consumption tests on the leds?
I'm taking a closer look now, and you are right. I somehow didn't pay attention to the distance beforehand as generally CREEs were giving a more powerful light and I thought they were a better choice. Now I'm thinking of fitting the philips as they are sitting on a shelf in the garage. I can see that even cheap COBs light further than the CREEs
Noticed that about the COBs too lol, but they're noticeably dimmer than both. Let us know how te Philips' work out in practical use.
see if there is an adjustment, I am betting the position of the LED is affecting how it bounce off the reflector.
they flow the beam too high, you`ll blind everyone with the philips, adjust the light height from inside the car , all cars have that option
Personally, I would've stuck with Philips. COB seems to work surprisingly well, and is what I'd use for 'secondary' lights, such as high-beams or fog lights. The CREE seems to focus too much light directly in front of you, whereas Philips focuses it more ahead, which gives better downroad visibility. As far as I can tell, CSP LEDs, like those Philips work the best, since they accurately mimic the shape and size of the original bulb filament. COBs and Domed LEDs don't do this very well, so light generally isn't focused as it should.
thanks about the information, but do u know if CSP and ZES are the same? this guy have tested on projector or standart(reflector) ?
From the video, the Phillips and cob looks clean. The cree looks too scattered with dark spots. But the Phillips would be my first choice.
I think it is very possible that this is the way it was installed slightly different. How is it not possible for the cree to shoot as high but looks brighter closer to the car?
@@abeeftec never use straight on view as any sort of measuring medium for lighting performance. That's a rookie mistake.
The OP used the correct testing process to access performance. Unfortunately his assessment was in error.
Thats an awesome demonstration on the three different types of globes in action. Thanks mate.
Clearly, the Philips ZES has the better lighting performance over the CREE. WHY?
In your demo pics, the ZES had a brighter (hotter) center spot and a very sharp distinguishable cut-off.
The Cree had a weaker center spot and virtually little if any sharp cut-off line. Two key aspects that separate the average from the best.
Philips has always been the led chipset benchmark, others try to compete with.
You did a good job with your time. Showing what a simple test and what must people would understand. durability is another issue. Wonder if your CREE are still working as normally that surface area for those 2 chips would make them have a cold soldering! cheers.
Cree were definetly brighter. Phillips looked better overall in this video. I would like to see an adjusted cree headlight vs phillips. I'm sure cree would win.
Philips to me was the more crisp and brighter led. It seemed to have more distance as well.
That XHP70 is insane as high beam. I've had them for a few years. Beest heatsink honestly compared to the fan especially in a wet areas like the fog.
CREE is a brilliant cooling solution.
Thaks. Good works.
Thank you. Good work.
how was your experience driving through heavy rains with any of those lights?
ruclips.net/video/AAsdcbXowPo/видео.html
Philips seemed to give more distance. Driving would have given a better idea.
It makes no sense because the brighter one was the cree but the phillips shot the top of the crops as far as you can see.
It seems to me the aim was different. Brighter closer to the car for the cree but it appeared the high beams were on for the Philips.
may i ask id the projectors are OEM? if yes can i buy aftermarket projectors for my reflectors to fit in a xhp70?
ANOTHER problem I have with the CREE headlights is that the package was clearly opened before you received it. Your eBay seller may be selling fake Cree bulbs.
How about csp chip... do you have try?
Do youknow if CSP and ZES are the same? this guy have tested on projector or standart(reflector) ?
don't know
Now did these all cost the same as one has to calculate that also into the equation as how much extra does one pay to get say 10% brighter
i like the philips the most but cree is pretty good too
Haha, Cree is not the best. Have a look to the upper part of of the beam and the left side. Philips is the only one, not blinding oncoming traffic.
wow the Phillips is brighter and you put the cree on lol
Exactly! I saw the exact same thing.
@@jschrauwen this is why I did not go with the cree. how did they miss this.
@@warp103 I have no idea. Maybe he's promoting the Cree for other reasons other then performance.
You can't beat the Philip's family chipsets - Philip's, ZES, Luxeon and Lumileds.
Ok, so how is it possible that the Cree is brighter but does not shoot as far? The headlight aim should be the same but the Phillips shoots the top of the crops and the Cree does not but its brighter near the car. This seems like an aim issue. MAYBE because the headlights only aim one direction (unlike the halogens which shoot 360 around the bulb) but Maybe you had the bulb aimed in a slightly different location in the headlight shroud?
Mount the lamps correctly and adjust the headlights, the Cree Xhp-70 LEDs are much higher than the other two, the poorer the Cob LEDs.
Where did you get your headlight housing? I am looking for this one actually.
I see you chose passive cooling (with copper stripes) and that's what I'm choosing too, my doubt is, can I keep these copper stripes inside the headlight, or they need to be put them outside like you did in order to don't melt the headlight's plastic? And keeping them outside like you did makes it impossible to close the dust cover, right?
I guess they need to be outside to cool the led as effectively as possible
i have h11 bulb, firstly i bought bulbs with cooler fan and they had philips luxeon mz chip they bery strong but more less 6 months they started to give fails then i bought xhp70 buls as same as on your video .
my opinion philips chip bulbs was more brighter but short life time and working temperature is highger then cree.
now i see new generation of philips called luxeon zes i dont know is it better then luxeon mz ? i want to but 1 pair moe but i am tryng to decide which one to go cree or philips !
thanks
Xenon 4300k
I wonder what's the result if the car's headlight is not OEM projector (conventional headlamp).
you should try a demo with actual name brand Philips ZES chip leds and see how they compare
I'd love to, however you won't get genuine ZES in the H11 fitting.
Can you put up the links of where you purchased all 3 of them? Thanks!
This video shows one really huge issue i have with these "pure white" leds. See how the grass just kind of blends into a white blob in the distance. Your eyes literally cannot process this light color quickly. Driving in the country late at night you almost cant tell the difference between the road and grass. Doing 100mph and its real easy to screw up.
IMO halogen are better. However a good halogen bulb doesn't last long. Changing bulbs every 6 months gets ridiculous. Instead i run good led bulbs and yellow tint my headlights.
Great video !
PHILIPS
using camera with brightness will not give fair results, you must take photos at the same settings. no auto brightness,,, set it to manual or pro mode and shoot with the same settings,
very nice, thankyou for the demonstration..
Can you please, add the links to the aliexpress itens in the info? it will be super nice. i want or the fhilips or the last one, xhp70..
cheers
which is brighter philips or XHP70?
Brighter may not always be better
Siemka jak ci się sprawują te ledy z pasywnym chłodzeniem jakieś problemy?
Na razie pół roku chodzą wzorcowo, światła są mega. Ksenony mogą się schować
@@fixanddrive dzięki
Podrzucisz linka gdzie je kupiłeś?
@@pajejek27 pl.aliexpress.com/item/Car-LED-Headlight-bulbs-For-Philips-Chip-H7-H1-H3-H11-H8-H9-HB3-9005-HB4/32812819726.html?spm=a2g0s.9042311.0.0.43b15c0fTQbFwq
which one is the best result ? are u use H4 type bulb ?
why COB also look bright ? its that bcoz of the camera ?
I use H11 fitting. COB is quite good for this price. Cree is the lightest, but Philips give a better distance a have a clearer cut-off line. So I finally chose Philpis and put the COBS to the fog lights. See the distance test between CREE i and Philips: ruclips.net/video/pCI1j49UFMU/видео.html and see all led conversion ruclips.net/video/r1f2gP4oqT4/видео.html I also have COB lights fitted to the high beams lights: ruclips.net/video/sPzSxT549D0/видео.html
what are the wattage for each led?
Philips led better than COB, it is more brightness and nice beam pattern！
Laticebright xhp70 not cree.
fantastic
very good video
is philips better than cree?
Hard to say, see also: ruclips.net/video/pCI1j49UFMU/видео.html Cree seem to be brighter, but Philips have a bit better distance and cut-off line
Is this in reflector housings?
Did you watch the video ? hahahahaha, you can clearly see that it's lens projector.
philips looks better? or it's the camera issue?
Phiips are fanatastic, see the night ride test: ruclips.net/video/7wFAdR7QbZM/видео.html&ab_channel=FixandDrive
Can you post the links for both Philips and Cree?
pl.aliexpress.com/item/led-bulbs-I7-6000k-55w-5760lm-led-H1-H4-H7-H11-9005-9006-9004-9007-bulbs/32787824567.html?spm=a2g0s.9042311.0.0.4c275c0fBZONPd
pl.aliexpress.com/item/Car-LED-Headlight-bulbs-For-Philips-Chip-H7-H1-H3-H11-H8-H9-HB3-9005-HB4/32812819726.html?spm=a2g0s.9042311.0.0.4c275c0fBZONPd
Please what the best Philips or cree
I prefer Philips
Philips look better . Some led are coming with 360 degree chips
Review zy p6 LED
Philips best
OMFG - more fakes ...cant u see it ...Buy some original Phillips and see the difference
stfu it's philips ZES chip. go search what it is
@@ruicaseiro4204 lol