J.K. Rowling won't be arrested under new hate law | Jeremy Vine
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 апр 2024
- Police have said that Harry Potter author J.K. Rowling won't be arrested under new hate crime laws in Scotland following a challenge to police.
Jeremy Vine on 5 is on television every weekday at 9:15am until 1:30pm on Channel 5.
Subscribe to the channel for more celebrity interviews, hot topics and debates: bit.ly/34DvAv4
Twitter: / jeremyvineon5
Facebook: / jeremyvineon5
Instagram: / jeremyvineon5
#JeremyVine #JKRowling #hatecrime
![Rich Dunk (Ft. DaBaby) - BIG DAWG [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Pz2ewsSKAEM/mqdefault.jpg)
The SNP need to be taken to court for hating the Scottish people.
I absolutely agree. But then, they were voted in democratically. It seems like bad karma for wanting to be nationalist 😂 sorry, I couldn't help it
That isn't a crime babe
@@cwispichiwibiff So a socialist-leaning nationalist government led by a man who makes speeches about members of a certain race being too prevalent in the country, that was voted in democratically, and then goes on to make free speech illegal. I'm sure I've heard this one before.
@@mariannehavisham8323
Oh but it is, unless you mean this law is only to prosecute natives.
Surely such unfairness will never be allowed.
@@cwispichiwibiff
I lived in India for years.
‘Karma’ …
The whole world, and everything in it is karmic. In fact the entire universe is karmic.
Therefore bad things happening; good things happening and no things happening are all equally karmic.
Ergo. All you are saying with ‘it’s karma’ is *IT IS*
Which might sound frightfully profound, but, as you can see, it is utterly meaningless once you’ve dissected it…
…and I have.
You’re welcome.
HUMZA YOUSAF MUST BE ARRESTED.
What for?
Then deported somewhere any where
@@mariannehavisham8323 Hate speech against white males!
She's too rich. They're just going to target poor people who express the same views as her. It's easier.
Wrong. Yes to your observations but JKR is setting the president. She's got Rishi saying no charges. Things will follow on from this. There are almost 4000 reports already. The law is unsustainable and completely unworkable.
I just heard on another channel she has declared she will support any ordinary person getting hassle for speaking out.
Yes, like all bullies.
And doesn't carry the same adverse publicity.
For the first time, I agree with Carol Malone!
There bottle went when JK said arrest me because of the lawyers would trash the law
Haha, J K Rowling and Carole are absolutely right, and every sane person knows it .
If the police take Rowling to court they know she is rich and high profile enough to take them on, if they lose against her it could have long term implications for this stupid law.
She will not be arrested but will get another NCHI added to her existing record. It's a good job she doesn't need to apply for a job like the many thousands of others Scotland and UK where the police continue to record non-crime despite instructions from the courts and home secretary.
Don't you think JKR is actually acting as a buffer. Yes she's self employed she's rich and most importantly she's influential. What's needed is other high profile people to stand with her against all this stupidity.
It's all just opinions. Activists started crowing first. You can be what ever you want. Just leave the rest of us out it. We know you're there - we don't need to hear it day in and day out.
That's the real problem. They aren't being discriminated against. They just want to change the whole world so that they are the centre of attention.
Once they have arrested enough poor people and made that normal then they will go after rich people.
I just heard on another channel she has declared she will support any ordinary person getting hassle for speaking out.
The point of this law is to protect Islam. Why do you think Useless made this law ffs? Wake up.
Are you saying I can no longer mock religious belief systems?
it could also be used to prove these silly religious books are nothing other than hate manuals.
True. Hamza could care less about "trans rights"
@@jemzargo Allah is a figment of Mohammed's imagination - prosecute me!
This law was actually made to block any criticism of Islam and encourage sharia in the UK
yup, that's why we r moving to Corfu.
Didn't know Islam was Pro-trans...
@@peterang6912this whole law as really been about stopping criticism of Islam right from the start. Of course this agenda has been sidetracked with the trans bullshit.
it could also be used to classify bible, torah and quran as hate speech. that would be amusing.
@@peterang6912 The law says "RELIGION"! among other things!
I think what this panel has missed pointing out is that this law is insidious for freedom of speech and it is highly stated in this law how insidious it is because one thing you didn't reveal was that you could be in your own home having a dinner party or a party and you saying something to that offends and this person reports it you can be investigated and that in itself can be punitive as you could have your devices taken and looked at which means you wont be able to work especially if you are self employed and nothing might even come of it but going through all that is stressful enough so the process is now the punishment.
To the guy that said " well this is what this community going through for a long time now " what you are saying with that is that statement is that this bill is ok as long as trans people are protected especially at the expense of others. Absolutely absurd this kind of context needs balance and protection not to be given at the expense of others freedom what you said was just narrow and one minded to be honest.
In my life, I've met two, 30 odd yrs ago, Big gangly farmer in a long frock, feet like canoes & hands like shovels, going into Tesco's.The locals knew him (her).They didnt bat an eyelid.The other, dressed to the 9s in heels he used to copple in. Again! Nobody bothered. In these enlightened times have we become more intolerant? And this was in rural Cumbria! Was it more common than was though, today, & people just shrugged?
While trans agenda wasn't pushed down our throats no one was bothered.
Where are the stats that trans people are more likely to be targeted for crimes?
True. The word "marginalized" is over-used.@@beverly9
It started ,with a statistic in Brazil that a lot of trans women in the sex industry had been beaten up. They were in a high risk occupation, but obviously ,that's led to the belief that they are more likely to be targeted.
There is none
Probably something to do with the behaviour of the "community" they belong to. I don't condone it, but you can see why it's happening. I don't have a problem with trans people, but the vast majority of them are part of the "trans community", a radical political group with cult-like practices. If it was a "community", they wouldn't kick trans people out for disagreeing with the accepted narrative. The fact that J.K. Rowling can say that women (especially victims of domestic/sexual violence like her) should be allowed to express support for female-only spaces, and then receive tens of thousands of death threats from the "community" just goes to show how radical and insane they are. People don't usually like that kind of thing.
Best to be clear where problems lie. I don't think many people have much of a problem with men dressing up as women, wearing lipstick and high heels and getting their breasts enlarged, even with having surgical removals.
BUT some do have a problem with them also attending female toilets or changing rooms and competing against genetic females.
That sounds like more of a YOU problem
@@JB-wy8fc nope. most women i know dont want biological men using the same toilets and prisons. as a man i dont care if a biological woman wants to use my toilet, i mean they all do in clubs anyway, its not a threat to me is it? it can be to women.
also, female sports will be dead in the next 10 years if it gets rammed full of biological males.
@@JB-wy8fc Well not really: being male, males going into female toilets obviously does not affect me but I believe some females are greatly concerned.
Ridiculous. Just the usual pro-trans rhetoric. You're saying that if little girls have a problem being exposed to adult male penises in the changing room, then it is obviously their own fault. No body is buying your baloney today, dear. @@JB-wy8fc
snp, the taliban of scotland or is it the stazi.
The two guys are complete maroons. The lady is the only one talking sense. The trans are being targeted because of the extremist angle and are innocent but because the extremists keep pushing there is collateral damage.
The trans community is literally as extremist as you can get. And if there were five people on the panel would they be "maroon" 5?
Lol, I laughed when Carol tried to contradict a court judge over the penalty for defacing the United States flag!!
J K Rowling to stand against Humza Yousaf at next election😂
Why is it interesting that it’s on page 17?
Yes threatening is bad ... however calling a man in a dress..a man ..doesn't deserve a person going to prison for speaking the biological fact .. same if someone says Islam was crated by a con man who turned into a tyrannt.. as its not a threat..its a historical fact ..and doesn't attack a group of people who follow Muhammad..as Islam isn't a race ..as Christians aren't a race ..in geography teems Muhammad was born in Saudi Arabia making him an Arab.. this laws ultimate goal is to stop people saying uncomfortable facts ...
Because of woke stupidity, JK Rowling is becoming one of the most politically powerful people in Scotland. Wow just think a politician with common sense! Nice thought isn't it!
They need a trans woman on these debates especially when there's a woman on the debate trashing them the whole time
I would bet the trans "community" has not faced anywhere near as much vitriol and flat out destruction of their rights in comparrison to the MRNA hesitant.
Imagine if someone fired from their job for being trans, let alone millions of them from various companies.
Not saying i want a law to protect the MRNA hesitant (because more law less justice), just pointing out that claiming trans identity seems to come with various privileges compared to a lot of group identities
It was perfectly legal to fire someone from their job for being trans in America until only a couple of years ago LITERALLY
“Most women in Britain are on JK Rowling’s side”, including mothers of trans people in that are you Carole?
Bit silly to say - if Rowling did - that she will repeat anything someone says about Transgender women - surely will depend on what they say?!!
I will say it and never stop saying it. There's no such thing as a transgender woman. There are men, women, men who want to be women, and vice versa.
Well said Carole and JK I 💯 stand with you 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Yet more proof the law is political ,under this ridiculous law they could arrest her but the backlash that would have happened frightened off the usual cowards
its not a crime because it suits them the upper ranking monday morning meeting boys club tea and biscuits lot they dont want the publicity or the trouble that would come with arresting her trust me on that! but u or me our feet would not touch the ground !!!!!! I know this as I am retired officer!!!
(2:08) *BINGO!!!* 🎉
Humza the Anchor of Scotland. Dragging this nation to the depths. Police Scotland have enough work investigating the SNP.
Want to say something that might fall foul of Yousaf's law? Nip over the border to England, tweet what you like and then head on home in time for tea…Make a day of it.
Unfortunately I'm wayy down south otherwise I'd invite unwoke sensible folk in for a cuppa while they said all the unlawful in Scotland stuff.
I am wondering if you could be charged in Scotland for something you said in another country.
@@paulohagan3309 You could well be extradited if you are living elsewhere 😱
@@deb7834 Interpol in action! Joking aside, I've heard the Chinese Communist Party find them very useful for getting dissidents from other counries.
@@paulohagan3309 You can't.
Never give your details to the police. Do not speak with them. Don't engage with "we are just having a chat" or "I'm only being polite"
They will never have your best interests at heart.
Freedom of speech
What it proves is that no matter what the police say they have discretion to investigate crimes. Any crimes. As a practical matter. If the police were obligated to investigate every report half the population of the country would need to be working for the police to get the job done. IE you'd need a police state. It does not prove that another person who said the same stuff as Rowling could not be charged. The police don't have to be consistent. So the fact they've not charged her YET does not prove what she said was lawful
It wasn't unlawful. It was factual.
This law is to prevent any criticism of feminists, LGBTQ+ and Muslims.
I like her books
I wouldn’t mind humza yousaf if he actually respected Scottish people
Well said Carol the other to panel don't give a stuff!
I don't normally watch this with Rob at the helm he's sooo full of himself.
JK Rowling is right what she said is true and it is not a hate crime.
The guy in blue defending them is a clown.. they’re instigating the agression.. that’s the difference. J.K Rowling isn’t.
First they have have to normalise evil before they can go after evenryone
Rowling hasn’t proved the limits of the law because no one knows the limits of the law, particularly the ones who created it. The wording is so vague and imprecise it can encompass everything and nothing. What Rowling did is call their bluff and they caved.
Trans people are not the most marginalised. I don’t know where he got his stats from but it’s utter bullshit. I’d love to see where those stays come from 🙄
Not the rich big wigs .. you common ppl only. They decide whos in the wrong
jk rowling has be quiet difficult with transgender communitty
I dare any Jane/John Doe to tweet what JK did and watch what happens!
So the way i see it.
You are NOT breaking the law if you say to a Trans woman (you are a MAN in biological terms) irrespective of how they see themselves now.
PS: Someones opinion is NOT a crime, if i see a trans woman and i say in my opinion you are a man (then again that is not a crime)
Youaf doesn't careless about lgbq or anything else,, it's all about Islam,, to stop population expressing their views.. That my opinion..
So disappointed that Rowling is such a disgusting individual.
So disappointed that you are such a disgusting individual.