Fire Emblem Gaiden vs Fire Emblem Echoes Soundtrack Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024

Комментарии • 180

  • @bardwayer
    @bardwayer 6 лет назад +603

    This is the best adaptation of an NES soundtrack I have ever heard. So many remakes just slap on updated synth sounds, but the composers here put so much care into arranging every single piece in a way that makes it sound like it was actually meant to be played by an orchestra. Even the more drastic changes they made had a lot of thought put into how they would improve on the intended tone in the context of what is going on in the story.

    • @lassellie5770
      @lassellie5770 4 года назад +25

      @@maximumbeans9310 The original soundtrack feels like it was meant to be played by an orchestra, which I can't really say I've felt the same for the first game. I wonder why they didn't put this game, and possibly even the first game, on the Super Famicom. The first game was released a few months before the Super Famicom was released in Japan and the Megadrive was out in Japan since 1988. The latest licensed game on the NES was Wario Woods in 1994 (or however that title is spelled gramatically). I have no idea why developers in Japan in the late 80s and throughout the 90s would be so reluctant to move to better hardware when they could create a more complete presentation.

    • @gamerprince-tl5hg
      @gamerprince-tl5hg 4 года назад +20

      I absolute love when remakes go the extra mile to replicate the music of the original game and capture that same feeling and spirit.

    • @TheWill0fStrength
      @TheWill0fStrength 2 года назад +3

      What other NES titles are remastered?

    • @ltraltier6009
      @ltraltier6009 Год назад +1

      ​@@lassellie5770 1 year development hell marches in the corporate gulag. That's why. Its also why many of them never work in the industry again like Team SILENT did. It goes from 2-4 years of making something good to wanting a "return on investment NOW NOW NOW NOW NOW!" and shitting out generic anime games over a single year like they have over the last decade that are all identical to each other.

    • @ironrex6979
      @ironrex6979 Год назад +2

      I didn’t like the game, story, or most of the cast BUT the OST is outstanding! Best Nintendo OST, best fire emblem ost, what any remake ost should be!

  • @APurpleFable
    @APurpleFable 6 лет назад +471

    I am blown away by how the soundtrack was adapted. Echoes took some great pieces and made them GRAND. I really have no words.

  • @oompaloompa7624
    @oompaloompa7624 6 лет назад +237

    i'm still really surprised at how fucking amazing the music ost was originally composed even though it dated back years ago. and the remastered versions just fucked me up man jhwrbfuierbg

    • @windmage0168
      @windmage0168 3 года назад +6

      The OST was produced decades ago, actually, but the music still slaps.

    • @k-leb4671
      @k-leb4671 2 года назад +2

      @@windmage0168 Years, decades. Either way. @oompaloompa was still correct.

  • @appapp5979
    @appapp5979 5 лет назад +175

    Chapter 1 (To Sofia - Alm's Setting Off) 0:00 [Gaiden] Where the Wind Rustles 1:42 [Echoes] Village 2:39 [Gaiden] Uprising 3:29 [Echoes] Alm Map 1 4:17 [Gaiden] March to Deliverance 5:11 [Echoes] World Map Chapter 2 (Celica's Journey) 6:10 [Gaiden] The Ark of Dawn 7:28 [Echoes] Celica Map 1 8:54 [Gaiden] With Mila's Divine Protection 9:56 [Echoes] Fight 1 11:10 [Gaiden] The Dauntless Blade 11:38 [Echoes] Chapter 3 (Liberation Battle - Each Road) 12:05 [Gaiden] Chapter 3 (War of Deliverance) 13:01 [Echoes] Celica Map 2 14:03 [Gaiden] The Sacrifice and the Saint 14:51 [Echoes] Encounter 16:47 [Gaiden] Unity 17:24 [Echoes] Chapter 4 (Land of Sorrow) 18:51 [Gaiden] A Song for Bygone Days 20:12 [Echoes] Tower 21:48 [Gaiden] The Pinnacle of False Belief 22:20 [Echoes] Boss Battle 24:20 [Gaiden] Warring Powers 24:36 [Echoes] Forest of Resurrection 24:54 [Gaiden] Melody of Water 25:07 [Echoes] Chapter 5 (Reunion, and Then...) 25:19 [Gaiden] Truth 26:31 [Echoes] Final Map 28:15 [Gaiden] Twilight of the Gods 28:58 [Echoes] Final Map Opponent 32:56 [Gaiden] Duma's Scourge 33:48 [Echoes] Final Boss Battle 35:14 [Gaiden] The Fell God's Tempest 35:38 [Echoes] Castle (March) 36:04 [Gaiden] With Pride in Your Heart 36:28 [Echoes] Ending Theme 1 38:09 [Gaiden] The Course of Gods and Men 40:49 [Echoes] Ending Theme 2 47:06 [Gaiden] The Voice That Calls You 50:42 [Echoes
    For mobile users

  • @motherofbimbos
    @motherofbimbos 6 лет назад +203

    Echoes OST is eargasm at its best

    • @stevenle3829
      @stevenle3829 5 лет назад +7

      Elliepopcorn shooters shoot

    • @squidee
      @squidee 4 месяца назад

      *worst
      Bliss at best

  • @Calvados656
    @Calvados656 5 лет назад +87

    Honestly considering what they had to work with back on the NES I think they did an absolutely astounding job on the soundtrack and SoV just makes them even better. This game deserves more respect imo.

  • @Copyrightbreaker22
    @Copyrightbreaker22 6 лет назад +109

    I love the charm of those old 8bit game music but damn they did this remakes well.

  • @redhawkmillenium
    @redhawkmillenium 5 лет назад +167

    "Twilight of the Gods" is a gift to mankind.

    • @finnTheConquest
      @finnTheConquest 5 лет назад +11

      redhawkmillenium super awesome for Final battle, played in nes when i young, i like this song.

    • @marcoasturias8520
      @marcoasturias8520 3 года назад +2

      Literally

    • @windmage0168
      @windmage0168 3 года назад +1

      @@finnTheConquest Lucky bastard. You got to play the Japan-only games on the consoles. Japan got so many great games that the U.S. never received. It's a bit sad. We didn't get FE1-6, DQ5, FF5, and many more amazing games.

  • @Ironmaiden654
    @Ironmaiden654 5 лет назад +55

    I think this has the best soundtrack of any game. Also the story is probably the most dynamic of all of the games. There's such a emotional state attached to both Alm and Celica and I really love both their characters.

    • @Paragon13
      @Paragon13 Год назад +5

      I wasn’t really a fan of Alm and Celica’s relationship. They knew each other for a bit as kids, meet up as adults and hate each other, then meet up again and wanna get married. They could’ve went a bit more in depth about why they were so special to each other and why their argument is significant enough to divide them but not enough to destroy their friendship.
      Still a fun game though.

    • @PrinzEugen39
      @PrinzEugen39 Год назад +3

      @@Paragon13 i kind of wish alm choose the real partner that fight alongside him, like either Claire or Faye

  • @hernobleness
    @hernobleness 7 лет назад +270

    I get blown away every time hearing how much Celica Map 2 improved. It was not that great to start with and they made Sacrifice and the Saint into one of the best tracks in the game

    • @Shuru10
      @Shuru10 5 лет назад +20

      I heard the Gaiden one for a few seconds then switched to the Echoes version and GOOD LORD my man you are absolutely right

    • @atomicbaconbits6695
      @atomicbaconbits6695 5 лет назад +10

      Sacrifice and the Saint is the best song in the series, in my opinion.

  • @ikefromsmashbros9237
    @ikefromsmashbros9237 7 лет назад +46

    Thanks for this video; it's really cool to see the difference between a game and its remake!

  • @ElwindMage
    @ElwindMage 5 лет назад +81

    Shadows of Valentia may have a better soundtrack, but does it have Alm crotch guard? Exactly: point proven...

  • @rubadub15
    @rubadub15 6 лет назад +25

    March to deliverance reminds me of death mountain in a link between worlds

  • @Magician2086
    @Magician2086 6 лет назад +49

    Alm kinda look like he was in Gaiden(at least for me) but Celica look so much different now, it's like it's not even the same girl anymore. And yeah Valbar haha, well glad they redesigned all the characters in Echoes.

    • @rowenachang2302
      @rowenachang2302 5 лет назад +17

      youb should see nuibaba's gaiden appearance

    • @k-leb4671
      @k-leb4671 5 лет назад +6

      They at least brought back her old outfit, plus a cape for some reason, in Fire Emblem Heroes.

    • @KeyleeTamirian
      @KeyleeTamirian 4 года назад +6

      Deen and Sonya look better in Gaiden. Check Fire Emblem wiki for reference.
      Especially Deen. Why did they change his amazing 80's High Flat Top hairstyle? He looked like Dolph Lundgren! Now he looks like a basic mercenary character... boring....

    • @raphaelsorel6907
      @raphaelsorel6907 3 года назад

      @@KeyleeTamirian Nah.

    • @braintrope4736
      @braintrope4736 3 года назад +3

      @@KeyleeTamirian Multiple characters in gaiden have the same portraits as others. Same with Deen and Blake, another boss character. Blake in Echoes is the one that kept the design of the portrait they shared in gaiden. Given what the characters are like and their roles in the game, I’d say Deen’s new look made more sense.

  • @BiggusWeeabus
    @BiggusWeeabus 5 лет назад +20

    One of the best remakes ever made

  • @smoogieoogie
    @smoogieoogie 5 лет назад +10

    That last track still gives me goosebumps, the orchestrated tunes are amazing, damn near perfect, but just the masterful playing of the guitar... *Shudders* It is so good!

  • @AkuNoHana
    @AkuNoHana 6 лет назад +8

    Pulling all the tracks together and even time stamping, this is a ton of work. Amazing stuff my friend, and thanks!

  • @Edatox
    @Edatox 6 лет назад +25

    Who else gets the feels when they hear Truth at 26:31? I totally need to use this in one of my vids!

    • @cosmos7611
      @cosmos7611 6 лет назад +1

      Shadow Strike me its land of sorrow

    • @Edatox
      @Edatox 6 лет назад +1

      louis de malestroit. Yep.

    • @chessk7059
      @chessk7059 5 лет назад

      sneaky advertisment

  • @peachysupreme7634
    @peachysupreme7634 6 лет назад +32

    I love 90's rpg music haha

  • @jarednewman7823
    @jarednewman7823 6 лет назад +159

    Why with the dong armor on almost every male character?

    • @celeztus
      @celeztus 6 лет назад +62

      Women kick hard xd

    • @ivorysoda1183
      @ivorysoda1183 5 лет назад +30

      Historically, that's how some armor was kind of made, so
      ruclips.net/video/lBtvS5yhTA8/видео.html This dude talks about it briefly at 4:30(and there's a lot of other interesting stuff, too!)

    • @chrisf.9595
      @chrisf.9595 5 лет назад +5

      CZ IT'S AWESOME AND NOBODY CAN DENY THAT

    • @SuperCer054Real
      @SuperCer054Real 5 лет назад +8

      Lmao D O N G

    • @ElwindMage
      @ElwindMage 5 лет назад +36

      The only reason why Faye only likes Alm in SoV is because his crotch guard from Gaiden protected him from thots.

  • @RubyChiang
    @RubyChiang 3 года назад +9

    The glow up that is The Sacrifice and the Saint.

  • @riton349
    @riton349 Год назад +6

    Damn, the FE2's music still holds up despite being NES. FE15 though is a masterpiece.

  • @Manlyman47
    @Manlyman47 4 года назад +8

    I think I never appreciated how good the soundtrack was when playing the game, but truly it is one of the most beautiful soundtracks ever made. 10/10

  • @vekterius8049
    @vekterius8049 8 месяцев назад +4

    Everyone here commenting on how amazing SoV soundtrack is, and while I 100% agree, you gotta remember the VAST improvement Gaiden made over Dark Dragon. Both of Celica's map themes, both 1 and 2 pushed the limits of the sound quality that was avaliable on NES systems at that time in the late 1980's early 1990's.

    • @riverresident4769
      @riverresident4769 4 месяца назад +3

      IS was also pushing the limits of the 3DS with Echoes, most certainly.

  • @loooooooooby
    @loooooooooby 6 лет назад +35

    This is definitely my favorite Fire Emblem soundtrack. However, I think I eventually got tired of hearing the same songs on the battlefields as often as I did.

  • @JakenTheGreat
    @JakenTheGreat 7 лет назад +320

    Im glad the redesigned the characters. They use to look just aweful

    • @seovania9601
      @seovania9601 7 лет назад +13

      Absolutely not.

    • @terraghost
      @terraghost 7 лет назад +127

      They looked horrible

    • @roydaboy4025
      @roydaboy4025 7 лет назад +126

      It came out in the 90s. Cut it some slack. xD

    • @RoyaleDva
      @RoyaleDva 7 лет назад +150

      My question is why is valbar on the cover?

    • @ajtriforcegamerofhyrule8538
      @ajtriforcegamerofhyrule8538 7 лет назад +13

      Jake Moore
      It's the 90s genius they had different original styles

  • @taebeebee
    @taebeebee 6 лет назад +6

    damn why do both osts slap so fucking hard

  • @Veight17
    @Veight17 6 лет назад +37

    Celica Map 2 is more similar to Mila's Ordeal than The Sacrifice and the Saint.

    • @kars3641
      @kars3641 5 лет назад +13

      A year late but whatever
      Both What lies at the end and The Sacrifice and the Saint are almost complete recompositions of Alm/Celica Map 2
      while Duma’s/ Mila’s Ordeal are almost 1 to 1 remixes of Alm/Celica map 2

  • @222pichu
    @222pichu 7 лет назад +27

    Is... Is that Valbar? Behind Celica and Alm? What in the everloving fuck is bara daddy doing there?

    • @valibaimoukhametov6795
      @valibaimoukhametov6795 6 лет назад

      Dat underbite on Valbar tho

    • @cscotch1127
      @cscotch1127 2 года назад

      To respond to your question four years later, I'm pretty sure it's not Valbar, but rather Deusaix, the disk 1 boss you have to kill to reclaim Zofia before marching into Rigel

  • @ninjagamergirl196
    @ninjagamergirl196 3 года назад +1

    I never heard Ending 1 anywhere only Ending 2... and my god! Thank you for this

  • @tomasgarcia7499
    @tomasgarcia7499 2 года назад +3

    Echoes is my favorite FE OST. I think from beginning to end it is just so beautifully crafted.

  • @deoxysoverlord8710
    @deoxysoverlord8710 4 года назад +13

    6:07 Perhaps The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess took inspiration from this track? It sort of sounds like Midna's Lament.
    Edit: Okay, not sort of...it sounds A LOT like that theme. Go and listen to Midna's Lament if you don't believe me.

    • @Prisoner-gk6lr
      @Prisoner-gk6lr 3 года назад +2

      2:45 from the Village also shares the main melody of Midnas theme.

    • @FirstNameLastName-oz5ij
      @FirstNameLastName-oz5ij 3 года назад +2

      @@Prisoner-gk6lr Honestly the village theme reminds me of Midna’s theme the most.

  • @ViperousVT
    @ViperousVT Год назад +1

    So glad I got the Limited edition in my collection today 🐍

  • @clerwer
    @clerwer 3 года назад +4

    3DS or NES, still being amazing 28:15

  • @__lim494
    @__lim494 5 лет назад +5

    43:55 huge ace attorney vibe here

  • @JTF374
    @JTF374 6 лет назад +4

    Just realized... Celica map was not the name of the remix they did for Smash Bros Brawl! They didn't credit the song right!

  • @nypad5
    @nypad5 6 лет назад +6

    I would like for some Fire emblem 4, 5 and Echoes music to make it into smash! I can already think of some good tunes to duke it out too :)

    • @tpayne7020
      @tpayne7020 5 лет назад

      nypad5 you got your wish man, a few echoes tracks made it in plus a couple or remixed versions and 1 genalogy made it as a remix too.

  • @topramen5344
    @topramen5344 3 года назад +1

    Gaidens soundtrack is extremely impressive considering it was on the nes, still holds up today

  • @latos0235
    @latos0235 3 года назад +8

    Celica not only has by far the best party in the game but also the best music in both games.

  • @dylanstucki8435
    @dylanstucki8435 5 лет назад +23

    Why is Valbar even on the cover

    • @rsr7263
      @rsr7263 4 года назад +15

      he was supposed to be a whole ass third path originally

    • @arandomguy8771
      @arandomguy8771 4 года назад +9

      You can not contain the chin of the legend

  • @benchjuice
    @benchjuice 6 лет назад +8

    Hey, did you miss Alm Map 2 and What Lies at the End, or are they just not in the description?

    • @bgfspacecowboy9446
      @bgfspacecowboy9446 5 лет назад +5

      Don’t think it was in Gaiden.

    • @shamussarrazine6623
      @shamussarrazine6623 5 лет назад +4

      It was but also kinda not. Alm Map 2 in Gaiden was just remixed Alm Map 1 rather than a different song

    • @aegrajag
      @aegrajag 3 года назад

      Alm map 2 is Duma's Ordeal in echoes.

  • @jamesfreeman6946
    @jamesfreeman6946 3 года назад +3

    Me and the homies go sicko when alm map 1 plays

  • @Avauladre
    @Avauladre 3 года назад +2

    26:31 eargasm

  • @frestfeld
    @frestfeld 4 года назад +2

    I think for 14:51 the shadows of valentia theme "Mila's ordeal" match better than "the sacifice and the saint"

  • @ravus9935
    @ravus9935 6 лет назад +4

    Truth is the best song in Echoes.

  • @lankthedank6931
    @lankthedank6931 5 лет назад +3

    Instead of The Fell God’s Tempest, you should have used The Mad God's Blessings. It's the REAL theme of Duma. and is twice as terrifying.

    • @troykv96
      @troykv96 22 дня назад

      The Fell God's Tempest position is understandable, it's actually the only theme that is a direct adaption of Duma's Boss Theme.
      The Mad God's Blessings is inspired by a very similar theme to that of Duma's boss battle and that theme is, funny enough, the same theme that Duma's Scourge (Duma Temple's exploration) is inspired of, the Enemy Phase theme of the Final Map; which is also used for exploring Duma Temple instead of the usual Dungeon Exploration themes (Story 2: Underground and Story 4: Tower)
      The Mad God's Blessing is the more direct successor of Final Map EP's rhythm as well as it's eerie and unnerving; Duma's Scourge instead is a more somber, slower (but also with added sauce with the chorus) version of Final Map EP, to make it fit better as an exploration theme.
      I imagine the reason why this video choose to represent Duma's Scourge instead of The Mad God's Blessing is because is the first of the two versions of the Final Map EP that we get to hear. I personally could have chosen The Mad God's Blessings because is easier to compare with the original.
      But the point is that The Fell God's Tempest position can't be replaced.

  • @dazbones6288
    @dazbones6288 5 лет назад +1

    Is there a comparison for Shadow Dragon and FE1's music or New Mystery and FE3's music?

  • @thetr1noob783
    @thetr1noob783 5 лет назад +2

    What Lies at the End is it’s own work!! Correct me if I’m wrong, but Alm Map 2 doesn’t exist??

    • @NotThatUser
      @NotThatUser 5 лет назад

      Tristan Smith
      It does indeed. Duma’s Ordeal is a 1-to-1 recomposition of Alm Map 2. What Lies At the End is a complete recomposition.

  • @crocworks
    @crocworks 4 года назад

    Does such a soundtrack comparison exist for FE3 Mystery of the Emblem and FE12 New Mystery of the Emblem?

  • @Edatox
    @Edatox 6 лет назад +3

    Am I allowed to use this in one of my art videos?

    • @BrickNGames
      @BrickNGames  6 лет назад +7

      If you're talking about the music, it's not mine so you don't need permission :P

    • @Edatox
      @Edatox 6 лет назад +1

      Oh ok. Thanks for telling me but I wanna use your video. If you just made this to tell the comparison, then I'll use it.

    • @BrickNGames
      @BrickNGames  6 лет назад +1

      you can use any part of this video

  • @k-leb4671
    @k-leb4671 5 лет назад +8

    I gotta say, Super Smash Bros. has the best version of Celica Map 1.

  • @crim8649
    @crim8649 7 лет назад +30

    Give us Top 10 Financial Mistakes Most College Students Make

  • @alexludeman7613
    @alexludeman7613 Год назад

    Im fine with most of the Echoes soundtrack with a few being worlds better than Gaiden's, BUT goddamn the enemy phase battle music was so good in Gaiden. I think they messed that one up making it too airy and unclear. That 13/8 figure did super well and actually GROOVED in an intense way when it and the drum accompaniment was 2/3 of the track's texture. In the remake the main impression are those thick horn chords which are pretty annoying to hear over and over again compared to the stripped down fusion-y stacked fourths of the original

  • @user-hj4tr3if5c
    @user-hj4tr3if5c 4 года назад

    These songs are bomb on 2 times speed

  • @windmage0168
    @windmage0168 3 года назад +1

    Alm's dong armor.

  • @toastbread2263
    @toastbread2263 4 года назад +1

    4:22

  • @HiroTwoThousand
    @HiroTwoThousand 4 года назад

    Fire emblem gaiden sound like Pokémon red music

  • @ltraltier6009
    @ltraltier6009 Год назад

    alm wasnt that radically changed

  • @Torinna_
    @Torinna_ Год назад +1

    This game had such a great soundtrack and story. Sadly the gameplay was so damn boring

  • @Kris-ds6wj
    @Kris-ds6wj 7 лет назад +16

    I prefer the original recruitment theme tbh

    • @seb1362
      @seb1362 7 лет назад +8

      Kris you must like ryoma, huh?

    • @ajtriforcegamerofhyrule8538
      @ajtriforcegamerofhyrule8538 7 лет назад

      Kris
      Naked lobster

    • @verhiptblits3551
      @verhiptblits3551 6 лет назад +3

      Kris the new one reminds me of magnus's theme in kid icarus

    • @alexsonic7
      @alexsonic7 6 лет назад

      I like Tower over The Pinnacle of False Belief.
      The organ and male choir doesn't beat the nice simple crunch of the original in my opinion.

    • @raphaelsorel6907
      @raphaelsorel6907 3 года назад

      @@alexsonic7 Nope, they add more flavor and an ominous feeling compared to simple 8 bit beeps.

  • @chessk7059
    @chessk7059 5 лет назад +1

    I don't care about nostalgia...that NES stuff sounds awful (don't get me wrong, if you like it then it's alright, but my ears hurt after a while)

  • @jaceon02
    @jaceon02 6 лет назад

    Echoes ost is trash
    Yeah, I fucking said it

    • @lankthedank6931
      @lankthedank6931 5 лет назад +2

      Wow, you got shit taste.

    • @saltyralts
      @saltyralts 2 года назад +3

      Man makes headlines with just 6 words!
      "Echoes' original sound track is trash" he states. There was a street brawl only 10 seconds later.

    • @jaceon02
      @jaceon02 2 года назад +1

      @@saltyralts and I still stand by my opinion

    • @joshuagarcia4077
      @joshuagarcia4077 2 года назад +2

      Explain.

    • @saltyralts
      @saltyralts 2 года назад +1

      @@joshuagarcia4077 nice username btw