Wow, it was very beautiful. Although I am an Indian Hindu, the Balinese dance was clearly more beautiful here, despite the music being not in favour. The Kathak one needs more speed and faster footwork, while Legong, I am afraid I don't know much about the dance except seeing some videos of it with gamelan music, so I can't really comment on the flaws, but it was really very enchanting. Om Swastiastu and Namaste 🙏:)
From what I can tell, the Legong dancer had great execution, and every single move was part of the library of Legong. I don't know Kathak very well but I do know that Classical Indian dance also has quite precise movements. I do wish I could have seen more of that, I think it would have harmonized greatly with those of Legong. Otherwise, this dance seemed excellently choreographed to me, especially the latter half. It is rare to see fusion dances that do both styles justice while working together to create something really beautiful and new. Legong also fit surprisingly well to the music, although it would have been cool to hear a fusion of music styles... though maybe that is impossible, Gamelan is so beautifully otherworldly.
The music was not in favor of the Kathak dancers either, since this is Carnatic Classical (aka South Indian Classical) music and Kathak is a North Indian dance form. Plus, since the dancers were from Bali, they tried their best but of course, they don't have the Kathak finesse of North Indians. I am sure if Indian dancers did Kathak and a Balinese dancer did Legong, plus the music was North Indian Hindustani Classical one which suits Kathak (maybe with some Gamelan mixed), it would've been perfect. But that would have been too hard to pull off so I respect the youtuber for trying anyways!
Maap klw boleh jujur..🙏🙏🙏 🙆Knp musik dan tarian nya lbh dominan india nya yah??? Mlh jd ga enak dan mbosankan loh! Asli! Ga boong! Shrsnya klw mw di kombine, dikit2 aja👌 india nya💃 krn tarian dan musik Bali itu jauh lbh indah, merdu, dan sakral. Kt hrs nya bangga dg apa yg sdh kita miliki..diatas rt 2 budaya lain nilainya, beneran loh ini..
dimbosankan? dengan serius? Saya merasa kasihan karena ada begitu banyak rasa tidak aman dan juga kebencian terhadap budaya sesama umat Hindu. Nah, inilah kenyataan bagi Anda - Bali (dan juga seluruh nusantara) menganut agama Hindu. India, sebaliknya, MENCIPTAKAN agama Hindu. Nilai-nilai, cerita, musik, tarian, estetika - semuanya berasal dari sana. Ketika Anda tidak malu melakukan Puja TriSandhya dalam bahasa suci Sansekerta India, mengapa Anda begitu kesulitan menampilkan perpaduan tarian religi Hindu dalam musik India? Gamelan tidak mudah untuk ditarikan oleh siapa pun di luar Bali. Umat Hindu di Jawa pun tidak bisa menari dengan iringan Gamelan Bali, lalu bagaimana bisa dipadukan dengan musik India? Gunakan otak Anda sesekali dan cintailah masyarakat Hindu global Anda. Video ini merayakan budaya dari tanah asli agama Hindu (alias India) dan menunjukkan rasa syukur dari Bali. Hentikan mentalitas rasis Anda. Kalau tidak kembali ke Kapitayan (agama pra-Hindu di Bali), kita umat Hindu tidak perlu berpikiran negatif seperti itu.
Hargai usahanya. Apa masalahnya kalau musiknya India? Gamelan merupakan gaya musik yang kompleks dan tidak mudah dicampur dengan bentuk musik lainnya. Masih terlihat sangat indah dan penari Legong tidak kehilangan kakinya saat mencoba menari mengikuti musik suci India ini. Pada akhirnya, video ini merupakan perayaan bentuk tarian religi Hindu. Dan agama Hindu adalah agama asli India. Itu datang ke Bali BERIKUTNYA! Maka tak heran jika estetika India terkesan sedikit dominan. Musik India juga dapat digunakan untuk menampilkan tarian Bali. Hal ini tidak berarti masyarakat Bali menjadi orang India.
Tarian India bukan sejenisnya Kathak dan Odissi saja. Ada Kuchipudi di propinsi Telengana, Bharata Natyam di propinsi Tamil Nadu, Kathakali di Kerala dan sebagainya menurut rantau mereka. Semuanya juga sakral tentang dewa-dewi serta dharma. Bali sakral iya emang benar tapi yang lainnya juga punya nilai tersendiri.
Apa saja komentar yang rasis dan diskriminatif tersebut? Bentuk tarian Klasik India juga sangat sakral, termasuk Kathak. Jika Anda beragama Hindu Bali, sayang sekali jika Anda meninggalkan komentar kata-kata buruk tersebut kepada saudara-saudara Hindu Anda sendiri dari negara asal agama tersebut. Mohon didik diri Anda sendiri sebelum mengatakan hal-hal seperti ini.
Legong and Bharatnatyam is so similar, like the facial expressions and mudras 💜💜💜💜💜💜
Wow, it was very beautiful. Although I am an Indian Hindu, the Balinese dance was clearly more beautiful here, despite the music being not in favour. The Kathak one needs more speed and faster footwork, while Legong, I am afraid I don't know much about the dance except seeing some videos of it with gamelan music, so I can't really comment on the flaws, but it was really very enchanting.
Om Swastiastu and Namaste 🙏:)
From what I can tell, the Legong dancer had great execution, and every single move was part of the library of Legong. I don't know Kathak very well but I do know that Classical Indian dance also has quite precise movements. I do wish I could have seen more of that, I think it would have harmonized greatly with those of Legong. Otherwise, this dance seemed excellently choreographed to me, especially the latter half. It is rare to see fusion dances that do both styles justice while working together to create something really beautiful and new. Legong also fit surprisingly well to the music, although it would have been cool to hear a fusion of music styles... though maybe that is impossible, Gamelan is so beautifully otherworldly.
The music was not in favor of the Kathak dancers either, since this is Carnatic Classical (aka South Indian Classical) music and Kathak is a North Indian dance form. Plus, since the dancers were from Bali, they tried their best but of course, they don't have the Kathak finesse of North Indians. I am sure if Indian dancers did Kathak and a Balinese dancer did Legong, plus the music was North Indian Hindustani Classical one which suits Kathak (maybe with some Gamelan mixed), it would've been perfect. But that would have been too hard to pull off so I respect the youtuber for trying anyways!
Love Indonesia 🇮🇩 from india 🇮🇳
Mesmerizing dance. Lots of love from India to my Balinese brothers and sisters. ❤️
Sukaaa, collab Bali & India 😍..Keren, keren. sukses selalu Septii!! 👏🏻
Thankkkkkss rannii
Legong dance remember me of Tamil and Malayalam Dance i mean malyalam dance ~
How beautiful... Love ❤ from India.. To Bali
This is our culture bali hindus
OMG Really well choreographed, very watchable! Would be interesting to see how well Bharat Natyam would go with it.
good job guys, it will be nice if the music/soundtrack also fusion of balinese music (eg. gamelans) combined with indian music.
🕉 Swastiastu • Rahayu • N'maskaram 🚩
Love from india ❤long live the culture of balinese
Wow the Balinese dance catches your eye instantly! Beautiful!
Wow.. They dance katthak. Like a indian ..
Water flow.
Keren bnget kathak mix tarian bali😍😍😍😍😍
Sukaaa bnget....kalian kereen. Collab tari india dan bali. Smangat berkarya yaa
Bellissimo! Guardo spesso questo video fantastico! Bravissimi!💕
Sya suka tarian bali dari tarian india sebab tarian bali unique dh so misteri
Btul shbt, sbb jauh sgt perbezaan antara garak tari India dan bali. Kerana bali byk berunsurkan budaya nusantara kita..
Beautiful, epic, incredible, i love it!
Excellent 🔥👌🏽
Such beautiful dance! I love you all. Legong with Kathak with Carnatic music! Hinduism come a long way
Love from India Kolkata
Thanks a lot for this video. This will really help my task assigned to me😊
bagus banget kak, warna bajunya matching semua, keren...
Hindu Indonesian🇮🇩 and Hindu Indian🇮🇳
🙏🙏beautiful✨
Waooo me encantó se be demasiado hermoso ❤❤❤❤️❤️
Extremely beautiful
superb beautiful 😍
Wow beautiful
Que lindo!!! Maravilhoso.
Masterpiece👍
Wonderfull!!!!
Beautiful!
LaraS💙
Bali💙
26OCT2019
Bagus banget
Mantep banget kak😍😍😍
Terima kasih dik ❤️
Mannnn ... ,,
I love it! ❤
very very beautiful
Mantaap dik adik.....
Suksma 🙏
Is the Indonesian gamelan from India originally or is it from Java and Bali?
That is india music
Gamelan originally from java, then spread to bali and sumatra, but it's have different sound and rythm just based of creatifity each regions.
They have one note known as Ślendro or Śailendra. Might be associated with the Śailendra court of Central Java
Bro ?
Maap klw boleh jujur..🙏🙏🙏
🙆Knp musik dan tarian nya lbh dominan india nya yah??? Mlh jd ga enak dan mbosankan loh! Asli! Ga boong! Shrsnya klw mw di kombine, dikit2 aja👌 india nya💃 krn tarian dan musik Bali itu jauh lbh indah, merdu, dan sakral. Kt hrs nya bangga dg apa yg sdh kita miliki..diatas rt 2 budaya lain nilainya, beneran loh ini..
Setuju..music India masuk smua..jujur aku jg nunggu music Balinya.aku pikir ada ternyata zonk..maav 🙏
Betul, tanpa mengurangi apresiasiku, akan lebih indah kalau musiknya juga dikombinasikan antara Baku dan India.
Hi terima kasih masukannya :) . Akan kami jadikan acuan untuk project kami berikutnya 🙏🏼🙏🏼
dimbosankan? dengan serius? Saya merasa kasihan karena ada begitu banyak rasa tidak aman dan juga kebencian terhadap budaya sesama umat Hindu. Nah, inilah kenyataan bagi Anda - Bali (dan juga seluruh nusantara) menganut agama Hindu. India, sebaliknya, MENCIPTAKAN agama Hindu. Nilai-nilai, cerita, musik, tarian, estetika - semuanya berasal dari sana. Ketika Anda tidak malu melakukan Puja TriSandhya dalam bahasa suci Sansekerta India, mengapa Anda begitu kesulitan menampilkan perpaduan tarian religi Hindu dalam musik India? Gamelan tidak mudah untuk ditarikan oleh siapa pun di luar Bali. Umat Hindu di Jawa pun tidak bisa menari dengan iringan Gamelan Bali, lalu bagaimana bisa dipadukan dengan musik India? Gunakan otak Anda sesekali dan cintailah masyarakat Hindu global Anda. Video ini merayakan budaya dari tanah asli agama Hindu (alias India) dan menunjukkan rasa syukur dari Bali. Hentikan mentalitas rasis Anda. Kalau tidak kembali ke Kapitayan (agama pra-Hindu di Bali), kita umat Hindu tidak perlu berpikiran negatif seperti itu.
Gamelan Balinya mana...??
Musiknya tidak ada balinya....
Tpi sayang gamelan balinnya mana jadinya gak balance ya sya kasi nilai 60 saja ya
Thankyouu inputnyaaa nanti kita bikin yang gamelan bali next time 💪🏼🙏🏼
@@septydiantari954 musik nya dicampur, awal bali, tengah india, akhir bali. Atau 50:50.
Meski gk ad gamelan tapi koreografi nya tetap nyambung, harmonis,. Bagus🙏
Hargai usahanya. Apa masalahnya kalau musiknya India? Gamelan merupakan gaya musik yang kompleks dan tidak mudah dicampur dengan bentuk musik lainnya. Masih terlihat sangat indah dan penari Legong tidak kehilangan kakinya saat mencoba menari mengikuti musik suci India ini. Pada akhirnya, video ini merupakan perayaan bentuk tarian religi Hindu. Dan agama Hindu adalah agama asli India. Itu datang ke Bali BERIKUTNYA! Maka tak heran jika estetika India terkesan sedikit dominan. Musik India juga dapat digunakan untuk menampilkan tarian Bali. Hal ini tidak berarti masyarakat Bali menjadi orang India.
🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀🐁🐀🐀🐀🐀🐀
tdk bagus, tarian Bali sakral
Sama kathak jg sakral, tari bali derived from hinduism di india, makanya org india klo liat tari bali langsung bilang mirip
Tidak setuju. Semua punya arti dan sakral masing2. Jangan jadi orang close-minded
Tarian India bukan sejenisnya Kathak dan Odissi saja. Ada Kuchipudi di propinsi Telengana, Bharata Natyam di propinsi Tamil Nadu, Kathakali di Kerala dan sebagainya menurut rantau mereka. Semuanya juga sakral tentang dewa-dewi serta dharma. Bali sakral iya emang benar tapi yang lainnya juga punya nilai tersendiri.
Apa saja komentar yang rasis dan diskriminatif tersebut? Bentuk tarian Klasik India juga sangat sakral, termasuk Kathak. Jika Anda beragama Hindu Bali, sayang sekali jika Anda meninggalkan komentar kata-kata buruk tersebut kepada saudara-saudara Hindu Anda sendiri dari negara asal agama tersebut. Mohon didik diri Anda sendiri sebelum mengatakan hal-hal seperti ini.