Water Filters VS Water Purifiers..THIS Is Why It Matters!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 янв 2025

Комментарии • 91

  • @ItsEverythingElse
    @ItsEverythingElse Год назад +5

    The problem with the straws is what if you want water for cooking, freeze dried food, etc.

  • @BarbellFinancial
    @BarbellFinancial Год назад +34

    There’s so much to learn and consider before choosing the RV life on the road

    • @cheflifevanlife
      @cheflifevanlife Год назад +10

      Yup, but there's so much that people can't let all this stop them from getting in the RVs, vans and minivans. I've been thinking about a water filter system for the minivan I've been living in for two years. 😄

  • @robertschulke1596
    @robertschulke1596 Год назад +14

    Re: the black carbon, that's activated charcoal, and it's what they give you in the ER to deal with poisoning. Not only is it safe, it's actually good for you.

  • @dxradioman6351
    @dxradioman6351 Год назад +14

    Good idea to pre filter the water going into the bag with cheese cloth or the like. Keeps the really big debris from going into the filter.

    • @Petesdrone
      @Petesdrone 6 месяцев назад

      There is a pre filter in bag

  • @johnshannon
    @johnshannon Год назад +14

    Backpacking thru hikers mostly take the Sawyer Squeeze (around $30), not to be confused with sawyer mini or micro.

  • @jeanwatson189
    @jeanwatson189 Год назад +9

    Be careful not to let the filter freeze, as it will be ruined. I left mine in a shed between trips and it must have frozen - next time I went out there was zero flow. Luckily I had enough gas to boil water instead. That was an expensive mistake!

  • @Lainer1
    @Lainer1 Год назад +5

    This is a very important subject that most people do not ever think about and I'm glad you addressed it.

  • @janblackkat7607
    @janblackkat7607 Год назад +5

    We sold our house and didnt find our dream house so 2 weeks ago we bought a 1966 17.5 ft Kenskill and we know absolutely nothing and are winging it! Just found you today so glad I did! Thanks for the info! Just trying to figure out the basic needs! ❤

    • @Timothyis
      @Timothyis Год назад

      Awesome. Sounds like an amazing story.
      Did You stay in it longer than You had to?

  • @DavidWaldrip
    @DavidWaldrip Год назад +8

    Another great video! Thank you for taking time to do this 🎥 - Price of MSR Guardian is now $299 dollars

  • @Swimdeep
    @Swimdeep Год назад +21

    Back-flushing the hollow reed filters should be done every other use for it to last. They clog fairly easily and ALWAYS have to be protected from freezing temperatures or they will FAIL. 🌿💦

    • @marka7519
      @marka7519 Год назад +1

      the backflushing on this one is different than the Sawyers, etc... and much much easier, not that those are hard. Seems to good to be true, but I've seen the MSR website product demos and they explain it. Bob demonstrates the super simple process for flushing this MSR Guardian Gravity at 7:15 in this video, and yes, as Bob reiterates, it should be done each time, but unlike all the others I've seen, you just twist a valve.

  • @janetkoball44
    @janetkoball44 Год назад +3

    Another great examination of very important nomad needs. You have a great assistant too. Thanks Bob

  • @badlands555
    @badlands555 Год назад +2

    Putting a water purification tablet in the filtered water would be a good idea. Best to use flowing water to fill the bag if possible. And having the bag in the sunlight is good to. Some nasty viruses are killed by uv light.

  • @SlowPCGaming1
    @SlowPCGaming1 Год назад +2

    You should get some test kits to see how well they are filtering out the things that can harm you.

  • @lastchanceshinythings47
    @lastchanceshinythings47 Год назад +3

    Backflush only with trusted water. Pre-filter water from a stream with a cloth and place open end of container downstream when capturing water.

    • @Petesdrone
      @Petesdrone 6 месяцев назад

      There is a screen in the bag ( pre filter )

  • @bsizzlehill2283
    @bsizzlehill2283 Год назад +2

    That backround is awesome. Going camping tomorrow. Cant wait.

  • @philguzman6932
    @philguzman6932 Год назад +5

    MSR makes awesome things. I've had an MSR Miniworks water filter for 22 years now. Love it! It's absolutely bomb proof.

  • @terrapintravels3829
    @terrapintravels3829 Год назад +7

    Very good demonstration and information Bob, thank you!

  • @johnnylightning1491
    @johnnylightning1491 Год назад +2

    If I'm not mistaken Lifestraw has a setup where you can filter water into containers, but I could be wrong. The Gravity Filter looks really nice even if it is a little pricey. Keep the good stuff coming Bob.

  • @gordonslomba2532
    @gordonslomba2532 Год назад

    I just watch you for my education some days while working in my apartment dreaming of being on the road

  • @wanderingoutyonder
    @wanderingoutyonder Год назад +2

    Super informative! We use a Grayl Geopress and filter water into reusable bottles. Fresh water on the go can be very challenging in some areas - thanks for sharing! We are always looking for things to better our experiences in the van! Keep making memories & adventure on! ~Karen & Shannon WOY

  • @akowboyshippielife7405
    @akowboyshippielife7405 Год назад +3

    Much love to everyone and their families from Cedar City Utah USA currently 🤠💪🙏🏵️🤠

    • @ChaseHansen-j2h
      @ChaseHansen-j2h Месяц назад

      You shouldnt camp in southern utah unless you have read "Desert Solitair"

  • @cheflifevanlife
    @cheflifevanlife Год назад +3

    I love these informative videos, I've been thinking about getting a water filter system of some sort for my minivan. This helps a lot, thanks Bob.

  • @TheCornucopiaProject-bd5jk
    @TheCornucopiaProject-bd5jk Год назад +1

    3000 liters, just over 700 gallons. At 1/2 gallon for drinking per day it’s good for 4 years of survival.
    It’s great for an outdoors lifestyle.

  • @kristenvincent3622
    @kristenvincent3622 Год назад +1

    Would love to see a Berkeley type filter review… I don’t like dealing with bags

  • @jimnjele.bean-dayone3505
    @jimnjele.bean-dayone3505 Год назад +1

    Love the purifier. Currently have a Sawyer. I'd like to get the purifier in the near future. As with my Sawyer, I imagine you do NOT want to let any filter freeze as it will ruin it.

  • @robertschulke1596
    @robertschulke1596 Год назад +11

    If you're really concerned, get a desalinator. The price goes up 10x, but nothing larger than an NaCl molecule can get through it. No viruses, prions, amoeba, bacteria, minerals, nothing. You actually want to add a little minerals back because otherwise the water can be so pure that it's not good for you. You also need to be careful not to use water with petrochemicals, or too much sludge in it. Prefilters are important.

    • @billredding2000
      @billredding2000 Год назад +5

      "You actually want to add a little minerals back because otherwise the water can be so pure that it's not good for you."
      That's a persistent myth: Nothing wrong with "too pure" water (aka: distilled water) -- it's not going to hurt you at all.
      -- BR

    • @MikeTrieu
      @MikeTrieu Год назад +4

      ​@@billredding2000Well, you will get an electrolyte imbalance if you don't also supplement with the range of electrolytes your body needs to run your muscles and organs. I drank a lot of distilled water one morning, did some pretty intense work out in the garden, and then a couple hours later, I was suffering from debilitating muscle cramps until I drank some electrolyte powder from Costco mixed with a glass of water. Muscles calmed down in about 15 minutes after that.

    • @KabobHope
      @KabobHope Год назад

      ​@@billredding2000Correct. The only reason to add minerals back is for taste and if you're talking about a survival situation that's the least of your worries.

    • @Dingeman-noname
      @Dingeman-noname 2 месяца назад

      @@KabobHope voor de smaak? Ben je je niet bewust dat jij en je lichaam mineralen nodig hebben? Ben je een robot?

  • @dagnolia6004
    @dagnolia6004 Год назад

    love the sawer squeeze

  • @MrMarkar1959
    @MrMarkar1959 Год назад

    MSR,,I've bought their portable filter 30 years ago!! worked fine until i dropped and cracked the housing. I'd still boil everything.

  • @roberthanna4882
    @roberthanna4882 Год назад +1

    Another great and informative video Bob. Thank you for posting it.

  • @ronaldhall2489
    @ronaldhall2489 Год назад +1

    I think both are good to have what say you

  • @dianaloureiro305
    @dianaloureiro305 Год назад

    Thanks so much for the hard work in making these videos to educating n helping people to live out on the desert n more.
    Take care n many Blessing for you n ur family.
    Thanks alitMany Blessings

  • @coyotelarry
    @coyotelarry Год назад +1

    Thanks for the video! I'll add this to my Amazon wish list.

  • @nobodyisprfct
    @nobodyisprfct Год назад

    The MSR filter would definitely benefit people in New Mexico in certain places.

  • @77goanywhere
    @77goanywhere 6 месяцев назад

    I have a military grade extremely fine water purifier that I take on kayaking trips and long river cruises etc. It is awesome EXCEPT it will clog VERY quickly if you put muddy water through it. So a lower grade pre-filter should be used to get 99% of the impurities out first THEN run it through the purifier. That way it will last for many thousands of litres of water.

  • @sharonarnold4502
    @sharonarnold4502 4 месяца назад

    Great info Bob, as always thank you.

  • @Camille_Lee_Æon
    @Camille_Lee_Æon Год назад +2

    I bought a water testing kit including a bacteria test. It was expensive. I am curious. Is there a way to test for bacteria cheaply?

  • @cinemaschool1283
    @cinemaschool1283 2 месяца назад

    Thanks Abraham

  • @shaunhall960
    @shaunhall960 Год назад

    I love heading for the high country for my water.

  • @Teri728
    @Teri728 Год назад +2

    If you have a dog, since they can’t drink through a straw, the filters that you have to suck through won’t get doggie a drink. I know they could drink out of stream but some places I’d want to filter out germs etc

    • @tk-lf1ny
      @tk-lf1ny Год назад

      I WONDER IF THERE IS A STRAW TYPE WHERE A HOSE COULD BE PUT ON AND LET IT SYPHON OUT OF A 5 GAL BUCKET THAT IS FILLED FROM THE STREAM.

  • @johnpeddicord4932
    @johnpeddicord4932 Год назад +3

    Thanks for the review

  • @kendonahve924
    @kendonahve924 Год назад +7

    Will the more expensive filter remove salt from ocean water.

    • @RICHat22
      @RICHat22 Год назад

      No. That process is called desalinization (sp?) and is a much more expensive and intensive process. But good question.

  • @Petesdrone
    @Petesdrone 8 месяцев назад

    Okay when you get the water from the creek leave the the hose detached on the msr

  • @morrisshepherd1637
    @morrisshepherd1637 Год назад

    Thanks for the demonstration on water filters.

  • @shdbmw
    @shdbmw Год назад

    Great information Bob!!

  • @janefreeman995
    @janefreeman995 Год назад +1

    The smaller filters mentioned are ruined if they freeze... It appears the gaurdian cartridge my also need to be replaced. ...

  • @dinosanchez8528
    @dinosanchez8528 Год назад

    I've been wondering about live action pumps with a screen over the hose, hooked up to my own filters

  • @AlejandroSanchez-rx6gv
    @AlejandroSanchez-rx6gv Год назад

    Like always, great advice. Thanks Bob!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @MrPOPSZILLA
    @MrPOPSZILLA 2 месяца назад

    GREAT VID! THANK YOU

  • @bobclarke2242
    @bobclarke2242 Год назад

    Thank you

  • @kielia727
    @kielia727 Год назад +4

    Will these filters handle water from lakes that have blue algae blooms ?

    • @jeanwatson189
      @jeanwatson189 Год назад

      I wouldn't try it! The filter would remove the algae but the algae would already have produced toxins. In public water treatment they have coagulants to remove such toxins, but that's not a home treatment. I believe the only methods we could use on the road would be distillation or reverse osmosis.

  • @sandeedobberstine5591
    @sandeedobberstine5591 Год назад +1

    Appreciate the review ❤

  • @phuckindrummer5537
    @phuckindrummer5537 Год назад +4

    I was taught to boil the water (then let it cool down) before drinking it, to purify it. Is that not safe to do?

    • @janefreeman995
      @janefreeman995 Год назад +2

      Yes, the cdc recommends boiling for 1 minute. It can be inefficient and inconvenient and of course uses the power source. I'm coming from a backpacking perspective. I've used a sawyer filter that claims a $30 -40 filter will last 100,000 gallons. It's only 2oz and can be set up as a gravity filter or squeeze a plastic bottle .... uses the same thread as most water bottles. It's time tested since thru hikers have been using them for over a decade. When I travel I carry a Katadyn befree that has a faster water flow but clogs up faster and lasts 1000 liters before changing the filter. I think wall mart carries sawyer.... I think there's a home version as well. One thing tho is they are ruined if they freeze. I'm not sure if his expensive one would be the same.

    • @jeanwatson189
      @jeanwatson189 Год назад +7

      Boiling water will kill protozoa, bacteria and viruses. It won't do anything about most chemicals, eg agricultural pesticide runoff, industrial chemicals, etc. If those are a concern you could follow boiling with an activated charcoal filter.

  • @timgillman
    @timgillman Год назад +3

    Don't you need clean water to backfill? Are you using unfiltered creek water?

    • @jeanwatson189
      @jeanwatson189 Год назад

      You reverse the flow to backflush, so you are using some of the clean water you just filtered.

  • @terryqueen3233
    @terryqueen3233 Год назад +1

    I have all types of water filters I should be covered for everything including bacteria

  • @Dr2024x
    @Dr2024x 10 месяцев назад

    Very good video!, regards from México!.

  • @sharonadcock8500
    @sharonadcock8500 Год назад +3

    Get a folding plastic step, And you can sit on your step stool and wash your hair, If you can't hang your bag too high

  • @lastchanceshinythings47
    @lastchanceshinythings47 Год назад +2

    The stats and lifespan on a Lifestraw suk compared to a Sawyer which is only a few dollars more. Backflushing.

  • @BlueSky-ff4oy
    @BlueSky-ff4oy Год назад

    Interesting thanks!

  • @ASHEVILLEMOVINGCOMPANY
    @ASHEVILLEMOVINGCOMPANY Год назад +1

    #Grateful 🙏 love you guys, thank you, #mahalo

  • @marye.castellow3875
    @marye.castellow3875 Год назад

    Thank you! Great information ❤

  • @stuartstuart866
    @stuartstuart866 Год назад

    Bacteria is stopped by a 0.2 micron filter, some viruses are smaller than 0.2 micron.

  • @duchess2367
    @duchess2367 Год назад

    How to keep water out of food in a cooler

  • @krisg3984
    @krisg3984 Год назад

    It’s like watching Santa give a presentation, eh ?

  • @jennifermagee9131
    @jennifermagee9131 Год назад

    Will these work with Giardia? Also, what's the deal with Berkey?

    • @jeanwatson189
      @jeanwatson189 Год назад

      Giardia is bigger than bacteria and viruses, so yes it is filtered out.

  • @bensonsspeedshop1191
    @bensonsspeedshop1191 Год назад +1

    👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @fghost9010
    @fghost9010 Год назад +1

  • @SteveA25414
    @SteveA25414 Год назад

    Be sure to keep those filters from freezing. It will crack the housing.

  • @George-ey4lx
    @George-ey4lx 2 месяца назад

    Just buy several bottles of store bought water before going on a trip.

  • @efjefe
    @efjefe 8 месяцев назад

    Dude followed you for years. Been a van dude for almost 20 years. Listen stop. These new hobos have been ruining my way of life. BLM and rangers have cracked down on stuff. I got a huge fine for having "temporary housing"

  • @KMWR1818
    @KMWR1818 2 месяца назад

    How would you compare THIS to another product called First Need Xle Elite Purifier

  • @Michaelajacksonfilms
    @Michaelajacksonfilms Год назад

    Thank you