The Trans Allegory in Nimona (2023)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 окт 2024

Комментарии • 97

  • @ProfessorBird
    @ProfessorBird  Месяц назад +1

    Did you like this video and want to stay updated on when I make more videos like it? Consider subscribing to @TheCowardlyValiant, the new landing page for my video essays

  • @EternalDensity
    @EternalDensity 2 месяца назад +38

    the bit where Abrosius tells the director if she uses the weapon innocents will die and she replies "and so will the monster" was chilling and hit really hard as a reflection of real life attitudes and actions towards us

  • @stxrstruck6755
    @stxrstruck6755 2 месяца назад +56

    Nimona makes me cry everytime i watch it. I dont think ive ever watched a movie that felt like it was for people like me. Its my comfort movie now-

    • @Alquek-lw7wu
      @Alquek-lw7wu 2 месяца назад +2

      HEY THATS THE GUY FROM DAYBREAK! (sorry I saw the pfp and got excited lol-)

  • @carmosilva3589
    @carmosilva3589 2 месяца назад +59

    I'm trans and my trans friend was the first to reccomend me this movie, we joked it was not queer at all, I think we both related a lot to it despite one being amab and the other afab

  • @sevith5277
    @sevith5277 2 месяца назад +25

    One of the best things I have heard about Nimona was this, "Nimona has no 'true form' every form is Nimona." That isn't the exact quote but that is the jist of it.

  • @EmmaDelamare
    @EmmaDelamare 2 месяца назад +6

    What happened between Nimona and Glorith reminded me so much of the first time I was caught wearing a dress when I was 5 or 6.

  • @EleanorDresselhaus
    @EleanorDresselhaus 2 месяца назад +92

    hi I am non-binary

  • @silvesterstalone7109
    @silvesterstalone7109 2 месяца назад +15

    Not queer or trans in any way. Great video. Thank you

  • @Equines_and_Animals
    @Equines_and_Animals 2 месяца назад +9

    I can’t help crying every time I watch nimona, and I rarely ever cry while watching movies. The suicide attempt scene hits really hard, and the ups and downs of the movie and how nimona feels throughout it feels all too familiar. Genuinely my favorite movie, next to wolfwalkers perhaps. The way they present everything is nearly flawless, the animation style is incredible, the message it sends is very important, the representation is very important. I can’t get enough of this movie

  • @WolfieZaps
    @WolfieZaps 2 месяца назад +8

    I saw clips of this movie in trans video compilations. In particular, I saw the scene where Nimona turns into a small boy and says, "I am today." As soon as I saw this part of the movie, I was hooked. I needed to do whatever it took to watch the movie. I'm genderfluid (trans/enby), but it was only in the last year of my 30+ years of life that I figured that out.
    My entire life, I've loved anything to do with shapeshifting and never knew why. Mystique from X-Men, druids in table top and video games, and even had a pretty hefty obsession with the Pokemon, Eevee (You don't have to point out how obvious this is. Trust me. I know.) I loved the idea of being whatever I wanted to be and on top of that for no one to know that's not just who or what I am. It sounded like heaven to me because I spent my whole life being told I had to dress a certain way, wear certain clothes, like doing certain things, etc. because of my gender assigned at birth.
    For me, this movie is the representation that my inner child desperately needed when I was younger. To realize that it was ok to just be myself no matter what that looked like for me and no matter what others would say about it. I sacrificed so much of my own comfort for the sake of other's comfort. This has become my favorite movie of all time. I connected with Nimona the moment she appeared on screen in front of me. Even down to the chaotic queerlike gremlin energy. This movie meant so much more to me than I think I could ever even express with words. I no longer feel so alone.

    • @Fabystephy
      @Fabystephy 2 месяца назад +2

      Just remember that a random person on the internet believes that you're valid.❤

  • @billcipher4368
    @billcipher4368 2 месяца назад +12

    Hmm...for a such a high quality video it kinda surprised me that it isn't as wide spread at it should be . Hope it becomes a bit more popular as I think your work is high quality with thought put into it. Keep the hard work☺!
    Also for me I got the message from Nimona that the world will hate you for being different , a lot of people with betray you but that doesn't mean your alone and there will always be someone who supports you.
    I didn't learn that message , I reabsorbed it . I knoew what the world does to people like me but I fully embraced it with this film.
    *Love that the film didn't bomb in Netflix showing disney that outright blatant representation is better then making a random backround character LGBTQ which only can be seen for less then a minute and removed in wide releases.*

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      Oh my goodness thank you so much?? And yes there are lots of good morals to be pulled from this film

    • @Ashiscool0720
      @Ashiscool0720 2 месяца назад +2

      I agree, this video should be more popular.
      Also, if you’re looking for disney movies where there is representation from important characters, I would suggest strange world.

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад +2

      On the topic of Disney, The Owl House was a Disney channel series with a lot of good queer representation including a major nonbinary supporting character in the second and third seasons and a queer relationship between the main character and a major supporting character
      But with all of these it's also important to remember that the credit for such things should primarily go to the creators of those individual properties as opposed to Disney, which is a pretty homophobic corporation and makes it way harder for these sorts of things to make it to screens

    • @Ashiscool0720
      @Ashiscool0720 2 месяца назад +1

      @@ProfessorBird i completely forgot the owl house came from disney lmao totally agree tho

  • @CluelessAku
    @CluelessAku 2 месяца назад +7

    I love this movie so much !! personally i do see it as a trans allegory, but also as an allegory for borderline personality disorder. i also can kind of relate it to being a system a little bit,, but i connect it with bpd the most :3 i can really see all the people calling her a monster as bpd being demonized, and her relationship with bal as a sort of favorite person relationship. AA i could talk about this all day but i dont feel like typing it out

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад +2

      Interesting!! I never thought of it that way, it's always nice to hear fresh perspectives

    • @Equines_and_Animals
      @Equines_and_Animals 2 месяца назад +2

      I think what’s beautiful is that this movie can be interpreted for any sort of topics. Personally I see it as lgbtq rep, but I also entirely think it’s a good rep of bpd or autism potentially.

  • @Indigo42Kitsune
    @Indigo42Kitsune 2 месяца назад +10

    I am aroace agender (so trans nonbinary) Autistic, and I have ADHD, the more that I learn about the intersection between being neurodivergent and being LGBTQ+, the more that I am able to see how we are often vilified in media and the world, no wonder we all tended to have a high rates of anxiety, depression, and all of the bad stuff that comes along with those mental illnesses masking being one of the biggest and most harmful ones. I think that everyone here disabled like me or not, can agree that having to mask just to make it through the day is one of the most exhausting and mentally and emotionally draining things that a human being can possibly do. Honestly, can we all just create a world where we can all be LGBTQ+ and disabled without judgment? I am not asking for something perfect, I am just asking for something that is better then what we cruelty have because it isn’t working, and I am not looking forward to hearing how many members of the LGBTQ+ and disabled community are no longer with us, because someone didn’t see their lives as being equal to the lives of people that the powerful people in our society see as being more worthy than our lives. I think that I am going to scream inside of my heart right now and hope that all of these anti-LGBTQ+ laws are declared unconstitutional and that the cap on social security disability finally goes up.

  • @nikiuniversus
    @nikiuniversus 2 месяца назад +1

    this was a great video to watch, i love nimona sm, really helped me accept myself more

  • @lspoulin
    @lspoulin 2 месяца назад +2

    I'm a trans woman and this movie talked to me to my very soul.

  • @wolfofrose3199
    @wolfofrose3199 2 месяца назад +1

    I love this movie, I watch it whenever I feel scared or depressed it's done wonders for me

  • @Twigs-workshop
    @Twigs-workshop 2 месяца назад +3

    Me personalty? I'ma say Nimona is Gender-fluid bc *i'm* gender-fluid and her responding to "and now you're a boy." with
    "I am today" is proabaly something I've said once.

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      Headcanons are very valid!! I also definitely read her as genderfluid, even though it's not technically canon

    • @Twigs-workshop
      @Twigs-workshop 2 месяца назад +1

      @@ProfessorBird the magic of headcannons and the 'all of above' option.

  • @CoreyRossRTC
    @CoreyRossRTC 2 месяца назад +1

    Ok I left a bit of a troll comment but I started crying at the 5th chapter. Great video.

  • @sages_hangout
    @sages_hangout 2 месяца назад +1

    I fully believe Nimona is genderfluid

  • @garrettbeckermusic204
    @garrettbeckermusic204 2 месяца назад +2

    If you want to upgrade your audio without commiting to building a full setup, check out some usb mics! Good video tho!

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      I'm currently a broke high schooler but I do want to get a proper mic eventually!!

    • @garrettbeckermusic204
      @garrettbeckermusic204 2 месяца назад +1

      @@ProfessorBird a rode nt USB mic would be a great step up, and it's 100, so could potentially be a bday gift from a group of ppl 🤟

  • @lilaott6495
    @lilaott6495 2 месяца назад +1

    i adore this because i was able to show my boyfriend how the movie was for me (nonbinary), such a great video!

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад +1

      I'm so glad you could find such utility in my silly little ramblings 💙🙏

  • @bdariamihaela
    @bdariamihaela 2 месяца назад +3

    11:55 Nimona doesn't have one true form, they are all her in one way or another, that is just the form the kingdom put her into

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад +1

      Ah okay okay
      I always interpreted it as like "if she does have a true default, this is it" but that was either a misinterpretation or just how I read it
      Either way I like your interpretation a lot more

  • @unparker
    @unparker 2 месяца назад +9

    YOU SHOULD LIKE TEACH ME HOW TO PLAY CASTLE CRASHERS :3

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      I mean it's pretty straightforward ngl. You get the game, and then it gives you like tutorial instructions for whatever platform you're on

  • @Kriscrop
    @Kriscrop 2 месяца назад +1

    Dude, there was no need to make a video essay, we all noticed the allegory
    And yet here I am, watching the video anyway

  • @f0ren51c5candy
    @f0ren51c5candy 2 месяца назад +1

    This film is so good I cried so much

  • @BugT-11
    @BugT-11 2 месяца назад +1

    Helloo! I love this movie!
    Btw do u know any states that allow u to transition without requiring surgery?

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      Wdym

    • @Definition_of_1930_jk
      @Definition_of_1930_jk 2 месяца назад +1

      If I’m understanding your comment right (pls correct if I’m wrong), then I believe you are asking if there are any states where you can be trans without needing surgery. And well, that’s everywhere! Gender-affirming surgery isn’t a requirement for being trans at all. In fact, you don’t even have to change your outfit! (Although many do because it helps with dysphoria) Just do whatever you feel comfortable with and you’re all set!

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      Okay yeah ^ There's no legal requirement for being trans. If you want to, say, change your legal gender marker/name/etc. then there might be some requirements depending on the state but you don't *have* to do anything to identify as trans
      And if you mean, like, hormones, I've never heard of any sort of doctor requiring that you get surgery before going on hormones.

  • @Jakepearl13
    @Jakepearl13 2 месяца назад

    That thumbnail is absolutely devious 😈

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      how?

    • @Jakepearl13
      @Jakepearl13 2 месяца назад +1

      @@ProfessorBird the expression is devious

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      Ah, yes yes
      Originally I was gonna use a less menacing screencap but this one was easier to get rid of the background

  • @maxm4804
    @maxm4804 2 месяца назад +1

    I'm trans, and when Nimona came out it was very early into my transition. And I cannot express how much this movie means to me and how I have recommended it to every single one of my friends. Great video, and to everyone out there who's struggling
    You're loved, and you are seen 🩷🩵

  • @guney2811
    @guney2811 2 месяца назад +2

    this movie made me realise I'm trans :3

  • @AmbrosiaMooshine
    @AmbrosiaMooshine 2 месяца назад +1

    This is a great video, :)

  • @ninjakiwigames5418
    @ninjakiwigames5418 2 месяца назад +2

    7:05 Movie/Show name pls?

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад +1

      MTV's Faking It
      I have not actually watched that show, I just used the clip to make my point, but I am of the impression that that character doesn't show up until several seasons in and is a fairly minor character

    • @ninjakiwigames5418
      @ninjakiwigames5418 2 месяца назад +1

      @@ProfessorBird Damn, well thanks anyway!

  • @whiteisneutral_3727
    @whiteisneutral_3727 2 месяца назад +1

    this is a great video, i really love the way you wrote the script and how clearly you explained your thoughts. i don’t know whether every video you make is like this, but for the love of god, less text in the edited video. just add it into the script. having to pause the video every couple of seconds to read text that vaguely has something do with what you’re saying is really tiring - especially because you *do* bring up important things to note - makes the video less enjoyable :(

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад +1

      Sincere apologies for that- I wrote a note about it in the description. Typically, no, there's not nearly as much clutter, those were primarily for clarification because it's such a sensitive topic so I wanted to give people the option to pause for elaboration if they're iffy on a certain point without bloating the video too much by putting it into the actual script. In the future, I shall not put nearly as much text 🙏 Thank you for your comment

    • @whiteisneutral_3727
      @whiteisneutral_3727 2 месяца назад +1

      @@ProfessorBird i think there’s nothing wrong with “blabbing”; personally (and as far as i’ve seen) longer essay videos do better, even, so if you’re afraid of making the video “too long” - fear not becuase it might just be for the better!!! i think i’ll check out some of your other videos too, i really enjoy listening to your voice, and this video is really high quality.

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      Thank you 🙏
      I definitely want to make longer videos it's just hard to find time with like school and whatnot (I'm still in high school lol). Definitely something I wanna strive for more tho

    • @whiteisneutral_3727
      @whiteisneutral_3727 2 месяца назад +1

      @@ProfessorBird oh wow, you’re really talented if you’re doing this while still in high school!!! that’s amazing. rare to find skill like that, you should be very proud of your craft!

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад +1

      @whiteisneutral_3727 oh thank you 😁

  • @cielthefangirl2876
    @cielthefangirl2876 2 месяца назад +2

    To me it was just a movie, that I watched once 😂

  • @dreamersescape2771
    @dreamersescape2771 2 месяца назад +1

    Is it an alegory is they say they're not a girl?

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      Those lines are in reference to the fact that she can shapeshift into any form (including other genders) and is also partially just a nod from the writers but, canonically speaking, she is a girl and the trans storyline is just an allegory

  • @CoreyRossRTC
    @CoreyRossRTC 2 месяца назад +3

    hey this video is pretty queer

  • @eliozdherion4843
    @eliozdherion4843 2 месяца назад

    Nimona this edible ain't shit!

  • @Tourettes-syndrome-gaming
    @Tourettes-syndrome-gaming 2 месяца назад +1

    Nah bro it’s about Tourette’s syndrome

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      Different interpretations are valid!!

    • @Tourettes-syndrome-gaming
      @Tourettes-syndrome-gaming 2 месяца назад +3

      @@ProfessorBird love from the Tourette’s community to the trans community 🏳️‍⚧️

    • @ProfessorBird
      @ProfessorBird  2 месяца назад

      I actually have a tic disorder (almost definitely Tourette's, I just haven't been able to get a diagnosis beyond "unspecified tic disorder" cause of insurance haha), nice to meet a fellow one

    • @Tourettes-syndrome-gaming
      @Tourettes-syndrome-gaming 2 месяца назад

      @@ProfessorBird lol sounds like young Sheldon