The first time I heard this song at swimming pool in 1993. I though this voice was Whitney in the beginning but realized when enter the reff this was Mariah 😁. They have some similarity at some area either in Inflection, low notes and growling. But Mariah looks younger voice and has whistle while Whitney looks Madam voice.. I love Mariah and Whitney.. I love both 😍❤️😍❤️
WOW. The YMCA I WAS ALSO SWIMMING AT, AND TALKING?? ABOIT AT THE EXACT SAME TIME AS FHIS POST???T?, how's life working as a human trafficker for Justin Patton and his crew serving you?? 🤔
haven't thought about this song in years... death gives a whole different meaning to a song... before it was about a lost lover, until death starts entering life...grandparents, parents, aunts, uncles just give to NEVER see them EVER again. it'll change you
Same here! Have you heard the sad, sad back story about this song? Both authors/artists of this song, from "Badfinger", committed suicide. So, it's even sadder after knowing that. My aunt's favorite singer was Mariah Carey. Every Sunday she'd wake us up by playing her music. My aunt & uncle got divorced about 10 years after this. My cousin & I loved playing her music loud as teens, but my uncle had to "ban" this song & "Against All Odds" from playing in his home, because he was heartbroken over the divorce & it was too painful to hear for him. :( Sorry for the sad comment, lmao. It is a sad song, after all. Really emotional songs, which Mariah Carey delivers flawlessly.
No, I can't forget this evening Nor your face as you were leaving But I guess that's just the way the story goes You always smile, but in your eyes, your sorrow shows Yes, it shows No, I can't forget tomorrow When I think of all my sorrow When I had you there, but then I let you go And now it's only fair that I should let you know What you should know I can't live if living is without you I can't live, I can't give anymore I can't live if living is without you I can't give, I can't give anymore No, I can't forget this evening Nor your face as you were leaving But I guess that's just the way the story goes You always smile, but in your eyes, your sorrow shows Oh, yes, it shows I can't live if living is without you I can't give, I can't give anymore I can't live if living is without you I can't give, I can't give anymore (Oh, I can't live) (Oh, I can't live) I can't live if living is without you (oh, I can't live) I can't live, can't give anymore
@Angel Jonson Well....the restraining order says 1982......it was the year Mariah and I fell in love, although she'll claim she has no idea who I am......we know better! I love you MIMI!
Why is the view count for this song and hero so much lower than the other songs on musicbox? Did it get reset? People sick of these songs? Everyone already knows them? What????!!
R A I agree with you in terms of singing and performing live. Whitney is the opposite of Mariah she put all of herself in her perfomances and Mc in her studio recording !
25 years later, this song never get old!
I Agree!
@@SamanthaGarmon-vc4dl30 Years later, this song still never gets old
Her voice brings out the emotions in her music's words
I Agree!
The greatest vocalist of all time
I'm going through the entire album😍 MC marathon baby!
Same
This is my favorite from the entire album.
Mine to
Me too
The first time I heard this song at swimming pool in 1993. I though this voice was Whitney in the beginning but realized when enter the reff this was Mariah 😁. They have some similarity at some area either in Inflection, low notes and growling. But Mariah looks younger voice and has whistle while Whitney looks Madam voice.. I love Mariah and Whitney.. I love both 😍❤️😍❤️
@Angel Jonson for someone new yea... But if are Lambly or Whitney fans... overall not really
They sounds totally different...
WOW. The YMCA I WAS ALSO SWIMMING AT, AND TALKING?? ABOIT AT THE EXACT SAME TIME AS FHIS POST???T?, how's life working as a human trafficker for Justin Patton and his crew serving you?? 🤔
haven't thought about this song in years... death gives a whole different meaning to a song... before it was about a lost lover, until death starts entering life...grandparents, parents, aunts, uncles just give to NEVER see them EVER again. it'll change you
This song brings tear like rain especially if you're experiencing a breaking up
Mariah Carey is breathtaking and is world class. talented.
remember the cassette tape I had of this I bought from Sam Goody. lol. shout out from 2019!!
Giirrrrl u took me back...same goodys
I remember it vividly...it was grey in color
One of my all time Mariah Carey remakes.
Same here! Have you heard the sad, sad back story about this song? Both authors/artists of this song, from "Badfinger", committed suicide. So, it's even sadder after knowing that.
My aunt's favorite singer was Mariah Carey. Every Sunday she'd wake us up by playing her music. My aunt & uncle got divorced about 10 years after this. My cousin & I loved playing her music loud as teens, but my uncle had to "ban" this song & "Against All Odds" from playing in his home, because he was heartbroken over the divorce & it was too painful to hear for him. :(
Sorry for the sad comment, lmao. It is a sad song, after all. Really emotional songs, which Mariah Carey delivers flawlessly.
@@JaseekaRawr I didn't know Harry Nilson was in Badfinger
@@joshuaherpolsheimer3541 Harry Nilsson's version was a remake of Badfinger's original.
The 90s.. what a decade😁🍾
No, I can't forget this evening
Nor your face as you were leaving
But I guess that's just the way the story goes
You always smile, but in your eyes, your sorrow shows
Yes, it shows
No, I can't forget tomorrow
When I think of all my sorrow
When I had you there, but then I let you go
And now it's only fair that I should let you know
What you should know
I can't live if living is without you
I can't live, I can't give anymore
I can't live if living is without you
I can't give, I can't give anymore
No, I can't forget this evening
Nor your face as you were leaving
But I guess that's just the way the story goes
You always smile, but in your eyes, your sorrow shows
Oh, yes, it shows
I can't live if living is without you
I can't give, I can't give anymore
I can't live if living is without you
I can't give, I can't give anymore
(Oh, I can't live)
(Oh, I can't live)
I can't live if living is without you (oh, I can't live)
I can't live, can't give anymore
I dont care what anyone says,this is literally her best song ever.
Jesus I can't live if living is without you...
Amazing song. My favorite female song bird you are.
This more than just a song for me. Beautiful.
Voice of an angel 👼.💯 classic masterpiece 2024❤️
Just listen to words of this song fantastic
Every time I listen to this song it just sounds more and more epic! :D :D
I used to sing music box to my daughter before going to sleep
Mariah e unica nossa rainha de todos os tempos
Better than the original. I mean, her voice, man....
all her covers are!
Music box 😍😍😍😍😍
Just pure talent in that voice
I love so much this song 🎉🎉 ❤❤
And now she is coming to Rock in Rio. I am finally going to see her in concert.
Tem amor tem jesus cristo ❤❤❤
👏👏❤👍so beautiful,pretty madam Mariah 🙏🏼💌💞
Love U, Mariah! (Congrats Badfinger)
i can live is living without you beautiful lyriics 🖒👏❤
love this 💘
Linda. ❤
Que voz doce
Mariah Lindonaaaa ❤️💋🌹🌷🌸
Bellaa❤
I had the good fortune of meeting Mariah Carey in her backyard....well, I actually was in her neighbors yard at the time, up high in a palm tree...….
@Angel Jonson Well....the restraining order says 1982......it was the year Mariah and I fell in love, although she'll claim she has no idea who I am......we know better! I love you MIMI!
@@treffbennett6534 ok 🙄
la version en español por favor es muy buena!
amazing
Sin palabras !!!!😍😍😍
I love so sothis song ❤❤❤
Mimiiii . Comeback with your great voices, please !!
Top 10 Best 1990s music to help you relax
I miss you Mookie always
Beautiful
Ken Lee....
My Deepest To Her Family 😢😢
Mariah Carey version
This song is better than he's song
I love you
Never tought I could actually feel the song
Artists must reluctantly allow MC to cover their songs
Christian Jährig bei DSDS 2024 sang im Recall das gleiche Lied und steht morgen im DSDS Finale!
Happy birthday to you
I want Higher Pitched please
I want High Tone songs please
Ya Allah aku jadi teringat dengan kak dini
2019
❤❤❤❤
איכראמכיכלגעכעט כמה ❤
😅Marrih este ca sora mea și o iubesc foarte mult. Și Brian este ca fratele meu ❤.
2023
I never did that!
musik fra hjertet og alle dem jeg kender mariah carey. Hilsen Arqalo
Miss u ma
foarte mult .Și Brian Adams este fratele
A toi ma fille chérie ❤ Manaia
2018
2024 ❤
Tshepo❤
MUSIC BOX
Why is the view count for this song and hero so much lower than the other songs on musicbox? Did it get reset? People sick of these songs? Everyone already knows them? What????!!
700gsteak probably because they have actual music videos that have millions of more views than the other music box songs
when i was middle school boy
Next door to FRITZ STEVEN'S TRANSPORTOBACCO BACK UP TO CANADA AND 48 STATES OF AMERICA!!
hi
😢😢
Yakuza 3 ending
Simone peternell
Musik CDs
Music
Why CEE LO GREEN SCHOOL UNIFORM'S
Mariah > Whitney
Whitney Houston !!!
R A I agree with you in terms of singing and performing live. Whitney is the opposite of Mariah she put all of herself in her perfomances and Mc in her studio recording !
whitney used to suck live, know your facts, she kinda got lost in the tempo usually
Mariah
Negative
poveste