Should our Top Hitter be Traded? - MLB The Show 23 Franchise | Ep.5

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 янв 2025

Комментарии • 107

  • @TheGeneralNightHawk
    @TheGeneralNightHawk Год назад +139

    Cane I think when scouting make sure you’re looking at the top 18 year olds for a chance at generational talents. We all know that’s the only thing that could help the A’s (heck, the generational player could even be the highest rated player on your team as soon as you draft him)

    • @tstumpf75
      @tstumpf75 Год назад +24

      The game has a way of making you priortize 1 thing or the other... its either 18 yr olds who can be generational talents. If they arent they are like 3-5 yrs away.. if you want guys who can help right away, its b rated guys who are like 22 yrs old.. the game makes u pick ur poison.. i like that..

    • @johnshepard313
      @johnshepard313 Год назад +20

      Yes. I think Adolpho Cairo (18 year old CF from Puerto Rico) might be one. He's projected in the 50's (draft range) but generational prospects aren't always projected high.

    • @DirtyMonkeyIndeed
      @DirtyMonkeyIndeed Год назад +2

      He needs his own Griffey Jr. Essentially

    • @Monokazie
      @Monokazie Год назад

      @@tstumpf75people just need to check the ratings more , guys with really high future ratings have high potential and then their current ratings are all red don’t draft them they’ll take 5 years , generational prospects current ratings are like all 60’s for hitting or pitching then their future is all 80+ lit up green it’s super easy to find them , and the 18 year olds are stacked in middle rounds you can find plenty B potential guys that are like 68+ ready in a few years , just gotta check the current ratings don’t draft guys that don’t have at least some yellow in their ratings .

    • @dirtyrcs4182
      @dirtyrcs4182 Год назад

      no its not tradeing every singal good player we have had like aaron juge and sean murphy matt chapman and matt olson max muncy to also sadly i am a a's fan

  • @cadeadams4592
    @cadeadams4592 Год назад +129

    The good news is that your 0.291 win percentage is currently better than the real life A's (0.200; 2-8)!

    • @WhiteMambalmao
      @WhiteMambalmao Год назад +11

      glass half full mentality

    • @rdp430
      @rdp430 Год назад +2

      Bad news is I lost a bet on opening day for the angels to beat the athletics lol

  • @davidhall7497
    @davidhall7497 Год назад +61

    First, I love your draft strategy in general. The only thing I would tweak is prioritizing 18 year olds for the chance of generational talents. One hit makes up for a lot of misses due to wider ranges in potential.
    Second, regarding player management, I feel like flipping your saves leader at the deadline, plus Blackburn and Diaz is the minimum. Anyone with 3+ years of service time is a luxury this team can’t afford.

  • @busorenkin55
    @busorenkin55 Год назад +60

    As the Oaklands A’s GM you gotta try out every reliever as a closer and see if you can boost their value to trade them for prospect. If a veteran is having a career year? Trade them. If someone is due for a pay raise? Trade them

    • @Its_Steeeve
      @Its_Steeeve Год назад +1

      As an A’s fan, I completely agree with your advice. It’s painful…. But it has to be done.

  • @Barista.Nathan
    @Barista.Nathan Год назад +11

    Ramón Laureano's playing himself into getting us an A-potential prospect!

  • @joshuajacobs7912
    @joshuajacobs7912 Год назад +18

    Cane, I know others have said this, but Ken Willis looks like he could be a starter. His stamina range is already 75-89 with a potential of 78-92. Also…a rating range of 77-91 already is nuts. He looks like a cant miss starter.

  • @aaronsanders4122
    @aaronsanders4122 Год назад +44

    Well the good thing about having almost zero future players is that the young guys u draft should get a nice opportunity to make an impact at some point

    • @watr19
      @watr19 Год назад +1

      He can’t sign a million free agents to block them in this franchise either, unlike the Rockies franchise

  • @marshfellowman
    @marshfellowman Год назад +37

    Hey Cane, I've got a small idea I think you might like: whenever you create a custom stadium, you should create a custom pitching camera too. Every team has their own unique pitching camera angle and I think making your own would add an extra bit of flavor to the series.

  • @Springy26
    @Springy26 Год назад +9

    Imo, Pat McCain should be your top pick. He looks to be closer to MLB ready and has potential superstar ratings in every category. If nothing else he'll be a strong hitter and he can always play 3rd or 2nd if the fielding doesn't pan out

  • @logandavis4285
    @logandavis4285 Год назад +8

    that bubba thompson performance in the fujinami start was wild

  • @johnshepard313
    @johnshepard313 Год назад +27

    Did you see Adolpho Cairo (CF from Puerto Rico, he's ranked in the 50's)? You need to scout him, he has insanely high potential.
    No joke you may have to consider him at your first pick, definitely get him to 100%

  • @altman153
    @altman153 Год назад +12

    Hey not a huge huge request but it would be cool in this series to attempt to match the streak. It’s been something that has happened a few times in the Athlete’s history since Beane and for me with the 2012 season it was special. I just imagine finishing the Moneyball idea, winning with such a small budget. It’s something I do annually. Thanks for the series.

  • @islandtoisland
    @islandtoisland Год назад +4

    The Coliseum removed its 3rd deck tarps 5 years ago. I’m really surprised The Show hasn’t updated their stadium model after all this time.

  • @cookie4143
    @cookie4143 Год назад +3

    I will say, Ken Willis has 73-79 stamina, so you could change him from a reliever to a starter if you wanted to draft him.

  • @ProchHighlights
    @ProchHighlights Год назад +7

    A tip for scouting is when you’re scouting an individual player. Put them as your first priority so they gain more interest in your team. It’ll make things easier come the time you need to sign them!

  • @gliborb5853
    @gliborb5853 Год назад

    This has been the most fun series to watch while I grind runescape for a few hours at night. Subscribed now

  • @theonewhogotaway6384
    @theonewhogotaway6384 Год назад +5

    A legend has uploaded

  • @ashtonhurley9769
    @ashtonhurley9769 Год назад

    I absolutely love thos series, easily the best franchise series on RUclips. Hope it goes on forever

  • @TTGTimeToGo
    @TTGTimeToGo Год назад +3

    Have a day Ramon Laureano. Glad the As are starting to look like they belong in the MLB. One of my favorite teams from a historical standpoint

  • @rektorik84
    @rektorik84 Год назад +2

    Cane! remember i told you i was going to Grayson Rodriguez' home debut today? well i caught a foul ball that he pitched!!! LOL im so hyped.

  • @Springy26
    @Springy26 Год назад +4

    Also Cane, in keeping with the narrative, when do you think you'll jump into the stadium creator? Maybe once the team is on the cusp so that they can open their first true season of contention in a new home?

  • @R3D_J3T
    @R3D_J3T Год назад

    🔥 Canes cover photo thing for his videos are hella underrated 🔥

  • @jasontaylor7142
    @jasontaylor7142 Год назад

    Your one of the guys that made me love video game content since 2017. Keep being great bro.

  • @Saintaholik
    @Saintaholik Год назад

    Watching your games I have some advice.
    Pay attention to your opposing outfield defenders. If you have a runner on first base and you get a hit to the outfield. If your runner has at leat 50-55 speed and the defender has a weak-average arm, you should be running 1st-3rd almost every time.
    Just a little friendly tip for ya

  • @rebeccaweems3921
    @rebeccaweems3921 Год назад

    Can’t get enough of this franchise. Loving it Cane!

  • @dailymeme6476
    @dailymeme6476 Год назад +6

    Love the videos. This season is a painful watch but it will get better. Your RF is a good ball player, get at least 2 prospects for him, we need players for next season.

  • @wrtrext
    @wrtrext Год назад +1

    You can always test out auto-fielding, and anything else, during streams to get live feedback.

  • @rohunjog2757
    @rohunjog2757 Год назад +2

    ken willis looks like he could be a good starter as he has good hits walks, and control along with good stamina

  • @kevsgaming9288
    @kevsgaming9288 Год назад

    Great vid cane!!

  • @calebkitk1327
    @calebkitk1327 Год назад

    Ramone took the trade rumors to heart

  • @zuluhawk
    @zuluhawk Год назад +2

    My luck is bad, Laureano dislocated his ankle, gone. Peterson Torn MCL gone. Lol shit luck first half of the season. Oh Peterson got hurt twice, forgot to mention so he is gone for me next year.

  • @cadeadams4592
    @cadeadams4592 Год назад +1

    May need a remix to a Carrie Underwood song, Jesús has the Wheels!

  • @calebpenrod5705
    @calebpenrod5705 Год назад +1

    Fujinami with the 189 ERA in that blowout 😂

  • @ryansease7066
    @ryansease7066 Год назад

    Gotta say while Laureano would be good trade bait, you might want to consider hanging onto him as a rebuilding piece as he seems like a solid enough player. But, then again, if you can get a good haul with something like some really high draft picks it might be worth it. Just my two cents. In the meantime take care and I look forward to many more episodes yet to come.

  • @saulcarrasco4401
    @saulcarrasco4401 Год назад +1

    Thanks for making this series. I'm new to baseball and this is helping me understand how to play the game.

  • @Travis-rr7rd
    @Travis-rr7rd Год назад

    I think boosting certain players potential like Diaz and Blackburn will make the series better so they aren’t just playing well for no reason

  • @carterragle5355
    @carterragle5355 Год назад +1

    I found a reliable reliever Anthony Kay from Chicago he would be pretty easy to get

  • @Tripps-Table-Talk
    @Tripps-Table-Talk Год назад

    thoughts on making the picture view a little closer ?

  • @Dran_Kito
    @Dran_Kito Год назад

    This time might be able to get to 70 wins... a big surprise on my part. I agree with sending the young guys back down to develop properly.

  • @superiorsports5616
    @superiorsports5616 Год назад

    Loving this series

  • @patrickschattilly
    @patrickschattilly Год назад +3

    If we trade our best hitter we need prospects in return to stock our farm system

  • @guntrythurmond6554
    @guntrythurmond6554 Год назад

    I like seeing the scouting portions of the game, those are usually some of my favorite bits of running a franchise. In my NBA2K franchise modes I always trade everyone off for draft picks and then rebuild the team with all CPU-generated players that I scouted, so I like that as a focus for your A's team.
    Go for the generational talents as often as ya can, soon you'll be stacked with a Griffey Jr and Randy Johnson and Alex Rodriguez!
    I don't know the CPU trade logic with MLB The Show-- can you trade for bad contracts with draft picks attached to help other teams save money? In real life, NBA teams regularly do this (I know the NBA more than MLB is why I use the NBA as an example), but NBA 2K's trade logic unfortunately doesn't really reflect that reality. Your payroll is so cheap, you could afford to absorb some bad contracts as long as it's sweetened with juicy draft picks. If that's not how MLB the Show works, at least you'll be able to get more picks by trading some of your decent dudes away.

  • @Dawgers0012
    @Dawgers0012 Год назад

    If Ken Willis really has stamina like that, then he’s a starter and not a reliever. Could be why he’s so high on the board

  • @lghrns
    @lghrns Год назад

    You have a triple A team you can use if you need some fresh arms, I know they might suck but it's better than a tired reliever

  • @LordJudgement1818
    @LordJudgement1818 Год назад

    Astros Kyle Tucker holy moly does he look tall in the batters box.

  • @snook354
    @snook354 Год назад

    Hey hurricane what settings do you use? I want my games to play like yours

  • @trent6729
    @trent6729 Год назад

    What difficulty do you play on? Offensively and pitching

  • @AllAroundSports_
    @AllAroundSports_ Год назад

    You could look at free agents for a SP for the rest of the year so you can have stability and not waste options?

  • @henrywood1304
    @henrywood1304 Год назад

    You probably shouldn’t draft a reliever before like the 10th round. Especially with the shape your team is in. You should only focus on the bullpen once everything else is put together.

    • @ogreman2229
      @ogreman2229 Год назад

      The game doesn’t have 10+ rounds in the draft

    • @henrywood1304
      @henrywood1304 Год назад

      @@ogreman2229 well then I would honestly forgo relievers altogether in this draft unless one you love falls to the last few rounds

  • @ramonwells6647
    @ramonwells6647 Год назад +3

    Please no auto defense your a good enough player I get the want for rating but cpu fields trash and you can do better

  • @nicholasarmstrong5996
    @nicholasarmstrong5996 Год назад

    the title of the video reads like an email from the owner of the a's to the manager

  • @DirtyMonkeyIndeed
    @DirtyMonkeyIndeed Год назад

    I do love how there can be 18 year old kids with thick majestic beards.

  • @austinhodyniak8075
    @austinhodyniak8075 Год назад

    Aaron Don could be a generational player. There can be 1 or 2 in a draft. Im pretty sure they have to be 18 out of high school.

  • @Skrujmcduk
    @Skrujmcduk Год назад

    Watching this episode the day after an official scorer took the win away from Jeurys Familia for his "short and ineffective outing"

  • @KingKrakenSports
    @KingKrakenSports Год назад

    Glad you got a nice offensive game for once. You deserve it

  • @Matt11560
    @Matt11560 Год назад

    Cane, i started a rockies franchise and we lost 14 to 23 to the nats

  • @merlinveltman1184
    @merlinveltman1184 Год назад

    As an A's fan, idek why I'm watching this. It's even more depressing than real life 😞😂

  • @snappygrandpappy
    @snappygrandpappy Год назад

    Have you considered relocating? Or at the very least creating a new stadium in Oakland? Everyone says Vegas but I think Portland, San Jose, or Salt Lake City would be cool and unique.

  • @corybye5958
    @corybye5958 Год назад

    Cane probably wishes all the pitches he sees were all that easy to hit 😂😂😂!!

  • @neojudai
    @neojudai Год назад

    Everything that happened in this episode will never happen again lol. Wow what an episode

  • @tstumpf75
    @tstumpf75 Год назад

    A reliever and or a closer is an end at the first round at best

  • @nicholasbondarenko1995
    @nicholasbondarenko1995 Год назад

    The 7th inning of game 2 on the stream should've made the cut

  • @warmaster7775
    @warmaster7775 Год назад

    Hey man down in double a should be Gunnar Hogland he's actually pretty decent and you should consider bringing him up and trade Laureono for some bullpen depth.

  • @alisonrosa6780
    @alisonrosa6780 Год назад +1

    I’m not going to tell you to take a prospect but what I am going to say is there’s not trade ups it’s ok to reach

  • @astralflick
    @astralflick Год назад

    Meter would be better for pitching but if you are being ratings reliant I understand

  • @imperfectlygreat9530
    @imperfectlygreat9530 Год назад

    When it comes to relief pitching just trade old low potential players for relivers or even starters and move them to the bullpen

  • @G_G_Gaming.
    @G_G_Gaming. Год назад +1

    If you hold L1 you are able to advance all base runners

  • @uncleterryreal
    @uncleterryreal Год назад

    189 Era is insane

  • @jetjam725
    @jetjam725 Год назад

    When is the next video?

  • @lumberstudios7907
    @lumberstudios7907 Год назад +1

    Is Laureano on peds again

  • @wardsteel8884
    @wardsteel8884 Год назад

    If you aren't using the PCI because you want a more simulation feel that's cool. But otherwise if you go to hitting settings you'll find much more success in using the PCI

  • @dannyduggan1544
    @dannyduggan1544 Год назад

    If you are on Next Gen, you should create a new stadium for the A’s next season

  • @djmcconnell_
    @djmcconnell_ Год назад

    Doing a twins MTO and I have the Yankees in the ALDS…

  • @harrar8
    @harrar8 Год назад

    I honestly get scared for you when you go to the bullpen

  • @IDL716
    @IDL716 Год назад +1

    Aguilar 2 triples on the year 👌😂

  • @jikle4451
    @jikle4451 Год назад

    Bright side. You have as many wins as the Rays.

  • @bolts_hockey_91
    @bolts_hockey_91 Год назад +2

    PLEASE play less games and sim more! I want to be invested in this series but its too slow paced.

    • @dre2405
      @dre2405 Год назад

      Yea especially since most of those players won't be a part of the future or c and below potential.
      At this pace it's going to take a long time to get into season 2 and 3 when we really start to see the future and improvements.

  • @fredsystra7584
    @fredsystra7584 Год назад

    “Our Don, Aaron Don”

  • @goatmanindustries7182
    @goatmanindustries7182 Год назад

    Mariners tanking.. your team inspires them to be even more terrible. Still fun to watch.

  • @Beans981
    @Beans981 Год назад

    Maybe trade Laureano to a fringe playoff team like Miami

  • @Blakelyboy21392
    @Blakelyboy21392 Год назад +1

    So y’all using trash can system?

  • @Bryce_Shelton_gaming
    @Bryce_Shelton_gaming Год назад

    The rays are 11 and 0

  • @codyrogers3876
    @codyrogers3876 Год назад

    As Bill James (the father of Analytics) said "Tanking is an idiot strategy."
    As much as I like the idea of trading anyone of any value for prospects, the best rebuild is one that spares the fans of the most suffering while still taking them to the promised land in the end.

  • @auden_smith
    @auden_smith Год назад

    Brendan Donovan

  • @coltensenter38
    @coltensenter38 Год назад

    More

  • @jamesthegreat736
    @jamesthegreat736 Год назад

    Can you please say “Holy Toledo” with key home runs or something like that? Would bring some cool energy

  • @patrickjohnson1724
    @patrickjohnson1724 Год назад +2

    im suprised u havent made a pler version of yourself

  • @jhilikejohnny
    @jhilikejohnny Год назад

    “Idk if I’ve ever had 3 home runs by one player in a game”
    Sydney Jean Charles: 🧍