Arthur was never a bad man. Arthur was a good man doing bad things for good reasons. Eventually he stopped doing bad, and was true to himself. He did good.
Me too, I had the best ending and it was so depressing but incredibly beautiful. I remember him saying, in the camp, something about "face me to the west so I can see the setting sun & remember all the good times we had" which made the ending so much better. It left us a few seconds and we saw him looking in the suns direction. So, I believe he was indeed able to remember all of the good times he had.
@@OxtlawX it’s alright it’s very overrated and the game is way to easy don’t let the fanboys fool you it’s def a good game and looks amazing but it’s very overrated and there’s a lot of better games imo but hey maybe u might rlly like it and think it’s perfect 🤷♂️
arthur i thought he was a bad guy in the beginning but now i now think about it and he was never a bad guy he was more of a sad man who tried to help his people even though no one helped him in the end and for that he is a hero yes somtimes he isn't but in the end he is.
he is still a bad man friend, he spent 20 years robbing/killing and just doing crimes with dutch, we as the player only see 1-2 years of his life, where he started to "change" and question himself, is he a good man? no far from it, is he a very bad man? no, but he tried to redeem himself and succeeded I suppose, one of the most Memorable characters in Rockstar games.
There never well be another game like red dead redemption unless it’s red dead 3 I hope I see the day when it comes out I grew up playing it when I was 11 I am now 23 I have played the red dead 2 story probably a hundred times you can’t describe the love and soul that game has it is truely a work of art 🖼️
I have a cousin who’s got dementia and he loves playing games, I introduced him to RDR2 and he’s okay with it a little forgetful but I watched him beat the game and he cried massively and a few weeks later he called me up and said ARTHUR DIED. The emotion in his voice broke me knowing he loves this game and will play it forever. Living through the first time trauma over and over again but I’m a little jealous ❤
I dont think Arthur was never bad, he is just a child soldier manipulated by dutch to do what he says, he was raised by ducth when he was just a kid, and arthur even says that he doesn't enjoy killing nor robbing but he does what he has to do to provide for his family, and Micah in the contrary does enjoy robbing and killing, ig thats what the games tries to tell, the thin line between a good man who finally wakes up and a straight up bad man.
This is a very good take, he was born into hard circumstances, difference is he felt remorse for his sins while Micah did not. There’s a quote from parthurnaax in Skyrim that hits quite deep “What is better? To be born good, or to overcome your evil nature through great effort?
Arthur never cared for himself he did everything in his power for the good of others, as the plot goes along we slowly realise that Arthur was never in it for the money
![Arthur Morgan [Pinegrove - Need 2 ] "I had a son..."](/img/1.gif)
Arthur was never a bad man. Arthur was a good man doing bad things for good reasons. Eventually he stopped doing bad, and was true to himself. He did good.
🤨
I wish that I could experience rdr2 for the 1st time all over again.
Me too, I had the best ending and it was so depressing but incredibly beautiful. I remember him saying, in the camp, something about "face me to the west so I can see the setting sun & remember all the good times we had" which made the ending so much better. It left us a few seconds and we saw him looking in the suns direction. So, I believe he was indeed able to remember all of the good times he had.
Overated
@KeyUploads no wayyyy😭 that's an amazing detail!
Is the game actually good? Haven’t played it yet but hear positive reviews about it?
@@OxtlawX it’s alright it’s very overrated and the game is way to easy don’t let the fanboys fool you it’s def a good game and looks amazing but it’s very overrated and there’s a lot of better games imo but hey maybe u might rlly like it and think it’s perfect 🤷♂️
arthur i thought he was a bad guy in the beginning but now i now think about it and he was never a bad guy he was more of a sad man who tried to help his people even though no one helped him in the end and for that he is a hero yes somtimes he isn't but in the end he is.
he is still a bad man friend, he spent 20 years robbing/killing and just doing crimes with dutch, we as the player only see 1-2 years of his life, where he started to "change" and question himself, is he a good man? no far from it, is he a very bad man? no, but he tried to redeem himself and succeeded I suppose, one of the most Memorable characters in Rockstar games.
@@CARL-sd7gdwe actually only see like 4 months of his life
@@respawnexpress9173 a full year bruh
@mommatthew2756 yea he was a criminal his whole life and is going to hell it doesent matter how many people he helped when his kill count is higher.
@@CARL-sd7gdhe wasn't bad, he did what he was taught to do and didn't see the world enough to know much about good until he got tb
"Arthur saved my life,more than once."
Except he didn’t though lol
@@DeadX2 how?
@@Darren_117 hes a troll leave it
@@pandaiboi3281 "it" lol
@@Darren_117 lmao
"I wish things were different, but it weren't us who changed."
“I tired”
shut up
Me after a long day of work
@@Zghost276same.
out blacklunged
He says tried, not tired
There never well be another game like red dead redemption unless it’s red dead 3 I hope I see the day when it comes out I grew up playing it when I was 11 I am now 23 I have played the red dead 2 story probably a hundred times you can’t describe the love and soul that game has it is truely a work of art 🖼️
I have a cousin who’s got dementia and he loves playing games, I introduced him to RDR2 and he’s okay with it a little forgetful but I watched him beat the game and he cried massively and a few weeks later he called me up and said ARTHUR DIED. The emotion in his voice broke me knowing he loves this game and will play it forever. Living through the first time trauma over and over again but I’m a little jealous ❤
Only if there was a way to say to retire from life. (R.I.P Arthur morgan)
I dont think Arthur was never bad, he is just a child soldier manipulated by dutch to do what he says, he was raised by ducth when he was just a kid, and arthur even says that he doesn't enjoy killing nor robbing but he does what he has to do to provide for his family, and Micah in the contrary does enjoy robbing and killing, ig thats what the games tries to tell, the thin line between a good man who finally wakes up and a straight up bad man.
This is a very good take, he was born into hard circumstances, difference is he felt remorse for his sins while Micah did not.
There’s a quote from parthurnaax in Skyrim that hits quite deep
“What is better? To be born good, or to overcome your evil nature through great effort?
Christ is King...
Indeed
the truth
This game really made me change my mind about life and what it has to offer
No it didn’t lol stop being dramatic
@@DeadX2 it did
@@pandaiboi3281 it didnt
@@DeadX2 it did
@@pandaiboi3281 didnt
I've been looking for a long time and finally found it, thank you🙂
It werent us who changed
This is great!! Nice job mate!
Listening to it after beating hits different…
You mean beating your meat?
Most probably
i hope you mean beating the game
Real.
@@swordigowhat else
Rest I peace dear Arthur Morgan my second favorite video game character
Who is your first fav?
@@LiLa-jf2uf i guess artyom from metro :)
Kratos
Lee?
I tried too, arthur. I tried too. Fucking depressed rn.
Good job man!
ty bro
Sad part is that John Forgot about him Not even a mention Of Arthur In RDR1 He’ll always be the best RDR Protagonist Right Beside John
"I don't talk about him much, but I think of him often." John to Mary Beth.
We’ll be did tell John not too look back
it would be cool to see rdr1 have mentions of Arthur but the red dead series in everything it's years ahead of its time both games.
Arthur Morgan might be a fictional character, but he’s the realest person I’ve ever seen in my entire life.
I’m seeing things a lot more clearly now. I wish things were different.
just just, too much trust arthur..
What John and Arthur heard when they died:
Arthur never cared for himself he did everything in his power for the good of others, as the plot goes along we slowly realise that Arthur was never in it for the money
The funny thing is, “I tired”, works too.
Im not a good man wow God, how quickly it passed
Bro make more of these please
where can I find the background pic?
i made it with AI i can send it to you if you have discord
What ai?@@44speedy
“You’re my brother.” ‘I know………’
best
Typo in title
I tired:(
Gonzalez Robert Jackson Helen Miller Matthew
*tried*
Davis Sarah Wilson Scott Garcia Eric
Johnson Scott Garcia David Brown George
Hernandez Donna Wilson Susan Lopez Jose
Taylor Angela Hernandez Scott Lee Sandra
Me
Wilson Sandra Martin Maria Jackson Melissa
Moore Joseph Lewis Paul Robinson Jason
Moore Sharon Rodriguez Kenneth Jones Amy
Wilson Patricia Martin Christopher Thompson Michelle
Allen Richard Young Karen Harris Kevin
Tried*
Rlly ngga “ I tired” 💀💀
tried
Wilson Maria Clark Carol Martin Scott