Sadhguru and Pseudoscience | An Analysis

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 1,7 тыс.

  • @user-bm9cv9vn2k
    @user-bm9cv9vn2k 2 года назад +639

    Never take sides, take the points

    • @Carbondioxidinashvilli
      @Carbondioxidinashvilli 2 года назад +29

      Real based sigmas unironically take sides to avoid mental diarrhoea and constant fluctuations in emotions for individual mental peace 😌

    • @Tomiokasan99
      @Tomiokasan99 2 года назад +18

      Humans likes to take sides
      It makes them feel connected
      I don't know all the reasons

    • @user-bm9cv9vn2k
      @user-bm9cv9vn2k 2 года назад +6

      @@Tomiokasan99 Yes it does. Inclination towards is imminent. But don't fall over it such that you become blind to another side.

    • @dakshgupta8432
      @dakshgupta8432 2 года назад

      Alpha grindset..

    • @aliengod2039
      @aliengod2039 2 года назад

      If you are a researcher, then you take the side of highest truth. Both sides may help push you to end goal. Science is not false ever. But the way humanity is using science for materialistic desires, promoting LUST and Greed and Ego and Pride is causing downfall of human species. Science should be left to the sub-conscious to decide. Law of Karma exists to help humanity reach this end goal. But the moment humans touched crops and genetically modified them for their selfish desires, human devolution began.

  • @johnme60
    @johnme60 2 года назад +211

    The day guy said "your emotions are your making" in a way changed my life.
    I reflected on my life. How sometimes we live our life in reaction of someone else's action.
    It feels like slave when someone says a sentence and my day is ruined. Dont know If he is 100% right. But this 1% was too enough for me.
    Then my journey started of actually "responding" instead of "reacting" as sadhguru said.
    what was the world like before that :- "I can't express, and I don't wanna remember , and I don't think someone will understand"
    "Keeping a higher separate place for my father,"
    After him --->
    Swetabh was the first person I found on the internet. He was like a elder brother also, His teachings stand apart even from his own self. He was slowly feeding the nutrients to the my soul to get up and walk.
    like picking up again and again after falling.
    I don't know much about my ancient culture, but somehow I have something inside me about respecting my guru. I recognize him as my First guru.
    Second one was sadhguru . He was totally different deal. I'm still digesting him. Breaking the fake beliefs , breaking assumptions, breaking self victimization, breaking self identity. Break the self made walls of limitations .
    I can't say in this world of fraud and egoistic people How lucky I was to find two people.
    One says: "ham sabhi l*nnd hai, main l*nnd hun",
    Second one says "I don't know a damn thing, I'm the most uneducated person in any room"
    I never really had much of Ego as I thing (may be I am wrong) , But the remaining part these people scratched from me. And now I am scratching it day by day.
    I found those people whom I never need to defend neither fight and debate for them . They were always able to defend themselves. If I even separate their bodies from their teachings still a huge substance or "aura" remains that I can describe as "guru" in my life , which somehow exists without them. I may sound crazy , but I'm saying What I feel. may be it means something in some book. I don't know.
    Like my ancient culture , I wanna bow down to my both gurus.

    • @prateekgrewal4717
      @prateekgrewal4717 2 года назад +13

      You are explaining most of us brother.🙏🏻

    • @johnme60
      @johnme60 2 года назад +2

      @@prateekgrewal4717 😊 👍

    • @Van._ten
      @Van._ten 2 года назад +10

      You are so good in expressing what you feel😇I really loved when you said i want to bow down to my gurus as per our culture

    • @lsr7523
      @lsr7523 2 года назад +6

      You are on the right path👍humbleness is the trait of the 'right path'.
      'Right path' is where your ego doesn't find nourishment.

    • @theeternal6890
      @theeternal6890 2 года назад +2

      *I wish we get such clarity of mind too like u.* Kudos for being so respectful and also logical in ur statements.

  • @sagarsingh4951
    @sagarsingh4951 2 года назад +287

    Science can be considered the fact that a theory can be proved wrong.
    falsifiability is one of the most important ideas of science.

    • @arthurfleck8843
      @arthurfleck8843 2 года назад +26

      True.....like there's a saying, the only thing that refutes science is better science.

    • @erasernox2611
      @erasernox2611 2 года назад +3

      @@arthurfleck8843 so all the scientific theories will change in future?

    • @erasernox2611
      @erasernox2611 2 года назад +3

      @Piyush P but seriously tho, cos some sites including wiki says some theories are fundamental hence they wont gonna change like foreg,heliocentric or Darwin one, but that makes me think how much gonna change in future r

    • @arthurfleck8843
      @arthurfleck8843 2 года назад

      @Piyush P engineering is what focus in development of humans for benifit.
      Science on the other hand is just the level best human attempt to comprehend objective reality.
      That's why science is bound to change and evolve, it's the fundamental nature of science.

    • @arthurfleck8843
      @arthurfleck8843 2 года назад +5

      @@erasernox2611 possibly yes, likely no..... the fundamental theories of science are what propels the evolution of science, thus future discoveries will likely be formulated in mathematics in a way to work along the fundamental systems, otherwise we may have to start from scratch and rewrite fundamentals which will be kinda impractical.
      If such cases arrives, we will have to find workarounds without breaking the structure.

  • @shatofor100
    @shatofor100 2 года назад +746

    Thanks for making this video. And Sadhguru is a Spiritual guru we are not here to learn science from him. And most of the time public speaking is not about being factually correct, it's about sending the broader message. I am an Isha Meditator and I Totally Totally agree with you.
    Anti Sadhguru people call him a God not us. We see him as he is. 🙏

    • @FiscalFrontNet
      @FiscalFrontNet 2 года назад +70

      "Sadhguru is a spiritual guru we r not here to learn science from him" u gained my respect 😊🙏

    • @FiscalFrontNet
      @FiscalFrontNet 2 года назад +46

      @@omthakkar7801 that guy lacks respect for Sadhguru, and he is unnecessarily overrated 😊

    • @abouttraveling4787
      @abouttraveling4787 2 года назад +36

      I also know people don't go to sadhguru for science but hypocrisy comes when something you say is proven in science then science is good and if something he says has been proved wrong by science then science can be wrong but sadhguru can't be.

    • @FiscalFrontNet
      @FiscalFrontNet 2 года назад +11

      @@abouttraveling4787 there is always a 3rd option to right and wrong, and that is ignore the stuff 😁

    • @abouttraveling4787
      @abouttraveling4787 2 года назад +8

      @@FiscalFrontNet but i am not an Ignorant but you can be ignorant of my views.

  • @Shubhankar_mhkd
    @Shubhankar_mhkd 2 года назад +66

    In my opinion he shouldn't talk about science and mislead the masses
    I have no problem with him speaking on philosophy as it is one's own perception

    • @billybutcher289
      @billybutcher289 2 года назад +7

      The problem is every one with mouth talks. And there is audience for everything. I guess world would be better if humans did not discover language and did not talk. 🤣🤣🤣

    • @yourdivorcedmom5288
      @yourdivorcedmom5288 2 года назад +4

      Exactly if you have that large number of audience you can't mislead them your every single word have very big value

    • @ilmnaut8032
      @ilmnaut8032 2 года назад +6

      he knows jack about philosophy, he's a charlatan, obscurantist and a sophist.

    • @ddawg3230
      @ddawg3230 2 года назад +4

      @@ilmnaut8032 Bro, couldnt you just use normal words to describe him? lol

    • @prabhudasrangari9292
      @prabhudasrangari9292 2 года назад

      Tu apni life pay dhyan de vhi batara hai Sadhguru..

  • @anandabharath2404
    @anandabharath2404 2 года назад +376

    Both Sadhguru and Swetabh has contributed to my life immensely in terms of my perception towards life. Extremely Grateful for both of them. I was a very compulsive person since Childhood. Always wanted to work on myself and Become a better Human being. After hearing lots of videos from both( which helped me a lot), I also tried some methods offered by Sadhguru. I was able to achieve peace and stability in my body and mind after attending and practicing regularly, the Hata Yoga and meditation (Inner Engineering) programs offered by Sadhguru.

    • @gaming4life25
      @gaming4life25 2 года назад +20

      Swetabh has changed many lives. But we definitely need some of the over confidence of Sadhguru... 🤣

    • @priyanksharma5267
      @priyanksharma5267 2 года назад +7

      @@gaming4life25 overconfidence samne aa gya na mutt dega

    • @vish.yt1
      @vish.yt1 2 года назад +9

      @@priyanksharma5267 ha ise hi overconfidence khte hai🌚

    • @053pradhumansingh3
      @053pradhumansingh3 2 года назад +11

      Exactly I don't think people should make conclusions without trying what he has to offer.I started to understand his videos more after experiencing his meditations and benefits of hatha yoga.

    • @adwaitvedant3297
      @adwaitvedant3297 2 года назад +5

      @@gaming4life25 watch acharya prashant..If sadhguru doesn't make sense to you... acharya prashant is a perfect teacher as well as science activist...Being an IITian

  • @vatsalsanwaria537
    @vatsalsanwaria537 2 года назад +21

    Phenomenal video. The video structure itself gives something to learn about looking at a topic throughout, at all angles.

  • @Gorusuur
    @Gorusuur 2 года назад +234

    Sadhguru makes sense in at least 99% of what he says. His approach towards life is indeed a beautiful one.

    • @adarshv.s6437
      @adarshv.s6437 2 года назад +22

      99.99% 😂

    • @celestialkakashihatake4697
      @celestialkakashihatake4697 2 года назад +13

      What😭😭
      What did I just hear xD

    • @adwaitvedant3297
      @adwaitvedant3297 2 года назад

      @Raman Sharma Just because you don't like BJP doesn't make him a conman...He has brought rationality in many ones life...When there was no acharya prashant..Yes he has some flaws in his arguments doesn't push us to reject his ideas completely...Get out of this cancel culture...Radical left is getting bashed due to this reason...Due to their extreme venomous tongue....Radical left cannot add value in life ...Only can cancel others whom they don't like like authoritarian islamists

    • @akkkkk813
      @akkkkk813 2 года назад +1

      Indeed,

    • @madhur2981
      @madhur2981 2 года назад +30

      Well, according to me, sometimes he just changes the question according to his convenience and then provides a vague answer that does not make sense at all. The original question is different !!! His way to answer questions and divert our mind is incredible. I like his approach and communication skills. If you're really into spirituality, then you can check out "swami mukunananda" channel. Hope it helps. Just my opinions tho ✌

  • @rachit1042
    @rachit1042 2 года назад +510

    He’s extremely intelligent. He says a lot of science stuff so people start believing him, then he speaks spiritual things and people believe those because they link all of that with the previously said correct things!

    • @PrakritiSenpai
      @PrakritiSenpai 2 года назад +7

      Yes

    • @yashraj66
      @yashraj66 2 года назад +82

      Everything is ok with sadhguru,but his enlightment claim... thats just bull***t

    • @maeverajpal7032
      @maeverajpal7032 2 года назад +9

      @@yashraj66 yess

    • @evilentity4352
      @evilentity4352 2 года назад +4

      @@yashraj66 tf is you bro?? 😂😂

    • @ctjthecubingchannel4145
      @ctjthecubingchannel4145 2 года назад +12

      @@yashraj66 I mean, lets just try it pal! I either don't know this. And not knowing is the greatest thing rather than just denying.

  • @scienceisdope
    @scienceisdope 2 года назад +77

    18:28 Thanks for the shoutout man! I just released a review of Sadhguru on Joe Rogan!
    Edit: had a chance to watch it fully... I don't disagree with what you're saying. Sadguru is definitely an intelligent person. But I feel you're giving Sadhguru a lot of benefit of doubt. I don't give him as much....

    • @indicaedits8692
      @indicaedits8692 2 года назад +4

      Bruh,Do a collab with Swetabh on your channel or maybe swetabh's own?

    • @indicaedits8692
      @indicaedits8692 2 года назад +1

      Need to creat a scientific huamanist movement in India and you are the leader.
      Thanks so much broo for the enlightenment
      (evidence-based).

    • @piyush2413
      @piyush2413 2 года назад +1

      Whatsup man! Youre doing really great. We would love to see the collab.

    • @mayurkolhe1318
      @mayurkolhe1318 2 года назад +2

      Good to see you here

    • @Shubhankar_mhkd
      @Shubhankar_mhkd 2 года назад +1

      Hello Bhai
      Keep doing your work

  • @pranavbhat92
    @pranavbhat92 2 года назад +176

    I used to think "thinking" is a superpower until I encountered Sadhguru. Because of him, its vividly clear to me that what I call as "thinking" is happening mostly as an unconscious process. This was a huge shock to me because I spend most of my time with my thoughts. After this revelation, I stopped caring whether objectively it is science or pseudoscience, it has been subjective reality to me. And that is the most important thing to me.

    • @GaneshPatil-ip4kl
      @GaneshPatil-ip4kl 2 года назад +13

      Nd that's how i became begot should be title of ur lil essay.

    • @GauravKumar-vu9td
      @GauravKumar-vu9td 2 года назад +8

      Wow what a great revelation. Lmao.

    • @pranavbhat92
      @pranavbhat92 2 года назад +4

      @@GauravKumar-vu9td What a great sarcastic comment. LMAO

    • @janmejaypandey2424
      @janmejaypandey2424 2 года назад +2

      Science has mostly explored objectivity..Now it's exploring subjectivity!

    • @mdh_masalewale8681
      @mdh_masalewale8681 2 года назад

      what the fuck does your comment even mean? You stopped caring whether something is objective or pseudoscience? Matlab if sadhguru tells you water has memory that can be changed depending on who touched it has equal value to you as a scientist saying an objective fact that can be reproduced and that has evidence behind it?
      If you are talking about that 'life is nothing but thoughts' even in that case pseudoscience is literally a lie, and science is not. So you can't just treat them the 'same'. Ek cheez se active damage hota hai and dusri cheez se active help hoti hai.

  • @abhishekjha5305
    @abhishekjha5305 2 года назад +76

    I don't know how much effort you put into this, but sometimes you just blow me away!

    • @xyyxyxxy1616
      @xyyxyxxy1616 2 года назад +1

      Humanities ke log aise hi hote hai

    • @balor2178
      @balor2178 2 года назад +1

      @@xyyxyxxy1616 He has done humanities? Which course to be specific and from which college?

    • @Lotus_0
      @Lotus_0 2 года назад +3

      @@balor2178 As far as I know, he once said he never went to college due to financial situation of his parents.

    • @abhishekjha5305
      @abhishekjha5305 2 года назад +3

      @@xyyxyxxy1616 Ye kya logic h bhai

    • @Sylvie4975
      @Sylvie4975 2 года назад +3

      @@abhishekjha5305logic nahi heuristic Hai xD

  • @ijanijigar
    @ijanijigar 2 года назад +91

    Hats off for the super in depth analysis of human behaviour and psychology. Feeling and knowing something is different thing, but putting that into organised words to convey a thing is an art and you have mastered both of them. I will quote some of your things in my classes, of course with credit. :)

    • @prashanthn1832
      @prashanthn1832 2 года назад

      u do know people practice apart from whatever the lecture he gives in youtube right?

    • @Arjunavoice
      @Arjunavoice 2 года назад

      Pgl

    • @ijanijigar
      @ijanijigar 2 года назад

      @@prashanthn1832 what made you think I don't?

  • @ctjthecubingchannel4145
    @ctjthecubingchannel4145 2 года назад +72

    He, at some place, messes up but I dont't think I will stop watching him. I learned a different way to look at things. I brutally deny people saying "enlightnment" thing being fake, withou even trying it. I am going to try it, this year after my exams. I have ADHD, which makes it 100 times more difficult to meditate.

  • @smartenough722
    @smartenough722 2 года назад +31

    I need more videos like this rather than self help. Your opinions are really unbiased man. Appreciate your work 👍🙏

  • @aditya-rt4zb
    @aditya-rt4zb 2 года назад +76

    I really hope new gems who has rootedness in indian philosophy and it's intellectual traditions (like sampradayas and saddarshanas) get the same soft power status that sadguru has I think he can be a great inspiration to lot of ppl

    • @samalpool8450
      @samalpool8450 2 года назад +17

      Dude I think you meant gems,
      Germs gives a completely different meaning😂😂😂

    • @abhinavkumar2156
      @abhinavkumar2156 2 года назад +3

      China - Virus
      India - Germs
      Bhai aisa contribution nahi dena hai western world ko

    • @ctjthecubingchannel4145
      @ctjthecubingchannel4145 2 года назад +1

      @@abhinavkumar2156 haha....come on I think "gems" .bola

    • @omiphile7227
      @omiphile7227 2 года назад +7

      @R unemployment to africa ke bhi desho me h sadhu vha kyu nhi h
      Yehi baat h to raja sadhu kyu bnte h
      Eg buddha mahavir etc

    • @Dank.man45
      @Dank.man45 2 года назад

      @🌟 R 🌟 naa bro,jab log unemployed hoye hai to wo dusro pe bewajah ungli uthane lagte hai,khud ko hi dekh lo...

  • @yathishk8529
    @yathishk8529 2 года назад +7

    Excellent analysis, I need to recheck this video again to apply into my life🙏. Instead of making an icon, hear everything what he wants to say, if it works for you then accept it, if it not then just ignore. Because even working thing requires several dots to be connected of one's life.

  • @sharadaprasad9311
    @sharadaprasad9311 2 года назад +12

    The most important idea i have come across is that there are different levels of seeing the truth of the reality and both science and religion are necessary in this regard.

  • @sagarsingh4951
    @sagarsingh4951 2 года назад +37

    Very very vary maturely and well articulated video. Very well analyzed

    • @BenNeedsATheme4aDream
      @BenNeedsATheme4aDream 2 года назад +1

      But also a bit too defensive/apologetic in tone. Shwetabh knows majority of his audience are Sadhguru Fan. Also the way he refers to him, shows how much Shwetabh himself admires him and doesnt consider the past controversies of Jaggi. Hence he cant go directly and say Jaggi (Sadhguru) is in the Wrong here.
      I mean the guy was talking about contacting aliens!!😂

    • @erasernox2611
      @erasernox2611 2 года назад +1

      @@BenNeedsATheme4aDream jaggi guy also said some really weird stuff like with by only looking you can changes in molecules of water and well being will come to you and said that statement was scientific or he said how nobel prize winning scientist were urging jaggi to put a theory thats way better theory than any of quantum physics forex
      ruclips.net/video/mdZpWLwM47c/видео.html
      ruclips.net/video/6C1p4HUHlfE/видео.html

    • @erasernox2611
      @erasernox2611 2 года назад +1

      @@BenNeedsATheme4aDream shwetabh never brought those controversies and try to explain it thats the first red flag and seconf was when he said science kept on changing he didnt provided the link for how many scientific theories in most of the scientific fields were changed vs how many scientific theories still is valid to this day which is sad, given there are nuances to a scientific theory like for eg. newton law is still valid in macroscopic scale but it fell apart in planetary scale , whereas at tht scale einstien law is valid and in the extreme scale like near to bigbang or to quantum physics einsten relativity seems incomplete so does that mean the theories are constantly changing or has changed lol

    • @kakarotto8515
      @kakarotto8515 2 года назад

      @@BenNeedsATheme4aDream so 🥱

  • @itsaryanguptaaa
    @itsaryanguptaaa 2 года назад +32

    -smart person is getting things right >50%
    -80% right is the limit of human beings, as we have to leave 20% error of being a human
    -we humans think in heuristics, have predefined frameworks and think in stereotypes
    -epistemology fallibilism is everything which we have made has a possibility of falsity, not certainty by possibility. But you don't have to dismiss the whole thing if you find a little bit of falsity keep in mind the 80/20 rule
    -science has 2 principles, it is corrective in nature and says
    this is the best we can do or know so far
    we don't know
    - it is not true that without science no claim can be made. Thoughts can we be independent of the science
    -memory is the most betraying element of the human brain
    - humanize your heroes- don't make someone a superhero, give them space to make mistakes and be human. Every person has limitations
    -don't disregard science too
    -contrarians

    • @gaderik3980
      @gaderik3980 2 года назад +2

      Nice try kid ( sorry bhaiya, cool dikhne ke liye bol raha hun )

    • @dipanshuagrawal6659
      @dipanshuagrawal6659 2 месяца назад

      The first sign of smart person is that he will never teach about the thing that are not his expertise. Second, he is open to learn and has a growth mindset. Third, he is humble enough to accept the mistakes.
      Now come on to Sadguru, I watched his many videos become impressed by them also. Then came a video. He was telling about Rudraksha (which is a pious thing used symbolically in Hinduism) and he tried to establish supernatural powers in it. For it he gave a demonstration, he hold Rudraksha and said it automatically rotates in clockwise direction because of positive energy in it. WHATTT????
      Yes!!!! It is a very big claim. It violates Common Sense, Science and Laws of physics!!!
      It means he knows nothing about Science, Positive Energy, Rudraksha etc. additionally he can go that far to fool other persons. He is not a smart person but a clever, superstitious thug.
      So what a smart person would do? First he would not say anything about energy and rotation etc which he dont know clearly.
      Secondly, he could have upgrade his knowledge of physics and Lastly he could accept his mistakes.
      Now come on this video, Swetabh is saying to judge them with their debates and reasoning and talks. Well Swetabh! anyone clever can make words. Also, the core message of Sadguru is about spirituality, energy and all. Just judge him by it and not the clever stories which can be copy pasted by Osho and many others.
      You just messed up Swetabh, I think its your biasness or your 20% wrong zone!! Feeling very sad.
      People doing Sambhavi Kriya, following his food recommendations, sleep recommendation are very vulnerable and misguided. Feel sad about them.

  • @anshulsharma6400
    @anshulsharma6400 2 года назад +6

    What a video swetabh 🔥🔥🤯 want some more videos like this in future.

  • @sarthikmakur1331
    @sarthikmakur1331 2 года назад +14

    The original definition of science is discovery of truth

  • @h9production
    @h9production 2 года назад +12

    I would like you to please have a conversation with Sadhguru...

  • @gaminguceyt
    @gaminguceyt 2 года назад +16

    I Like The Idea Of Save Soil By Sadhguru

  • @priyanshunayak3165
    @priyanshunayak3165 2 года назад +28

    When you've an expertise it's wise to listen to him.. What really pisses me off is his opinion on things he doesn't an expertise on.. So yes he's highly intelligent in his areas of expertise... Nothing else....

    • @Crafterbhumiiii4143
      @Crafterbhumiiii4143 2 года назад +2

      What do you think , people who constantly attack him on basis of science are some sort of scientists or researchers. They just cherry pick him . If he was pseudo- scientific then why would microbiologists from UN , harward senior proffesors listen to him and invite him for speech . They should have been first one to sue him as he is an Indian as well . So don't believe in trolls, rather just think yourself that why so many scientists and researchers are with him .

    • @prashanthn1832
      @prashanthn1832 2 года назад +1

      people not coming to him to know about science or what not,just the wisdom is what guru's talk

    • @suparibhau
      @suparibhau 2 года назад +2

      @@Crafterbhumiiii4143 I like sadhguru but you don't have to be a genius to know that alot of his explanations involves pseudo science. And just because others disagreed with some statement that he made doesn't make them "trolls". When it comes to why hardware professors invited him for a speech, ghta is because it would simply be a good seminar, they don't actually consider him to be a pioneer in science...

  • @shrikantzankar7732
    @shrikantzankar7732 Год назад +3

    The point is: everyone one is selling something to people according to their need’s.

  • @janmejaypandey2424
    @janmejaypandey2424 2 года назад +6

    In yogic science thoughts are not given so weightage. It's the western thinkers immersed in the world of thoughts and that's why they say " I think so I exist". Sadhguru gives inner tools and methods which one can experience not just intellectually grasp.

  • @customizedquiz
    @customizedquiz 2 года назад +132

    His guided meditation cured my anxiety depression, he is really a genuine guru

    • @seeyouatthetop7
      @seeyouatthetop7 2 года назад +14

      Wow what a logic!

    • @customizedquiz
      @customizedquiz 2 года назад +18

      @@seeyouatthetop7 what do you want to listen?

    • @yourancestor6149
      @yourancestor6149 2 года назад +17

      @@customizedquiz they cannot accept that a person can do right as well as wrong things in his life

    • @Crafterbhumiiii4143
      @Crafterbhumiiii4143 2 года назад +14

      @@yourancestor6149 they will belive when some angrez will tell them .

    • @sukhpreetsingh-hd6ls
      @sukhpreetsingh-hd6ls 2 года назад +5

      Yeah his some videos are good but when i watch his video how he sleep only 2.5 hours a day. i definitely stop following him like is it possible to sleep only 2.5 hours a day.

  • @BrVr
    @BrVr 2 года назад +48

    What a Coincidence !! Shwetabh and Science Is Dope Making video on Sadhguru On same day same hour !!

    • @theroaster2562
      @theroaster2562 2 года назад +12

      ikr ! science is dope slayed it lmao

    • @erasernox2611
      @erasernox2611 2 года назад

      @@theroaster2562 pls explain what happen to me and who is science is dope?

    • @PrakritiSenpai
      @PrakritiSenpai 2 года назад

      What is the matter that happened

    • @BrVr
      @BrVr 2 года назад +1

      @@PrakritiSenpai Sadhguru went on Joe Rogan podcast

    • @Yogeshlu4
      @Yogeshlu4 2 года назад +9

      science of dope is getting subscriber on name of sadhguru...or kuch nai

  • @rahulchaudhary8227
    @rahulchaudhary8227 2 года назад +77

    Sadhguru's one idea that changed my life was about anger, it was something like that you should not give anyone the chance to control your own emotions, you can control your reaction. Thanks, Shwetabh for the video and cool shirt.

    • @vbizind3687
      @vbizind3687 2 года назад +6

      I have not given anybody this privilege that he or she can determine the way I feel within myself.- Sadhguru

    • @theinevitable8000
      @theinevitable8000 2 года назад +4

      Sadhguru himself couldn't control his anger when questioned by BBC men

    • @Hunteriscoming
      @Hunteriscoming 3 месяца назад

      ​@@vbizind3687Fraudguru Jaggi Vasanadev was reminded of the LADIES TOILET by a college kid 😂😂

  • @IBSaurabh
    @IBSaurabh 2 года назад +5

    Listen to all but do what you think is right, that's my motto in life. I listen to Sadhguru from time to time but i do disregard alot of stuff he says sometimes.

    • @akshaykumar465
      @akshaykumar465 Год назад

      Listening to Sadhguru is not even 1 % of knowing him . Go look at his website what he is offering, visit his ashram look at his works . Visit Isha Vidya schools Isha home school, Isha Samskriti, Velliangiri Uzhavan FPO and see how much impact Isha has made on people's lives

  • @tuhinsubhramandal4436
    @tuhinsubhramandal4436 2 года назад +5

    Falsification is generally why we read that to err is human... I really liked everything you said, it just made me so overwhelmed to sink in critical thinking that i just think, I need to know the source, I need to know how to make it even better, I need to remodel my memories. I know most of the people like us who are engaged in a lot of things, like working in a job, looking after family, doing work for future reassurances (I said most, because some people who actually spent a lot of their lives searching the truth, and applying them practically like is it true or false, just like old times sadhus and gurudevas) I mean hardly we ever get these type of discussions to engage ourselves. Still, people like you, are encouraging us to evolve our knowledge, because knowledge is completely fluid, it never remains in its own shape, it changes every time, every moment. I just want to know a thing.
    How can we be better at evaluating the knowledge we perceive, and how to go deeper in that knowledge within a small span of our time.

  • @mayankys8922
    @mayankys8922 2 года назад +10

    I have really never noticed any person has presence of mind like sadhguru in my whole life

    • @ishaartworks
      @ishaartworks 2 года назад

      ♥️♥️

    • @ashishhembrom3905
      @ashishhembrom3905 2 года назад

      Any idiot without common sense will find Sadhguru a genius.

    • @xyzguesswho9537
      @xyzguesswho9537 Год назад +2

      check out Acharya prashant ! u will have a change in perception and wld be the best thing u wld do in life.

    • @Indiantiger000
      @Indiantiger000 Год назад

      True sadguru brain function very effectively know one can prove him wrong in debate.

  • @vishva.g5306
    @vishva.g5306 2 года назад +18

    I see shwetabh's video, I click it.

  • @aumkartarkar2272
    @aumkartarkar2272 2 года назад +49

    सदगुरु also tells to not believe anything but to realise it and always say something that you do not know do not know ! Accept this that you don't know!🚩🕉️ #SaveSoil

  • @YouTubeEUserR
    @YouTubeEUserR 2 года назад +40

    I watched science is Dope's videos few weeks ago . I did brainstorming on this topic , my conclusion was even if Sadhguru is sensible or senseless he is really smart , he answers highly controversial & difficult questions with ease and clear thoughts in such a way that no one can deny it. The only other person who does the same is Sandeep Maheshwari .

    • @shivangssinha1915
      @shivangssinha1915 2 года назад +5

      Watch science is dope video's more.

    • @YouTubeEUserR
      @YouTubeEUserR 2 года назад

      @@shivangssinha1915 I have...
      I have watched his almost all of his recent one year videos.

    • @azeemuddinkhan923
      @azeemuddinkhan923 2 года назад

      What would you say if Sadhguru won't answer the difficult questions and stall. He does that a lot with his analogies.

    • @vivekbhatt7433
      @vivekbhatt7433 Год назад

      Bro I am in lot of confusion right now who is right wrong ... Sadhguru ... science is dope ... There a guys call visudhi ...and this swetabh ...🤯

    • @vivekbhatt7433
      @vivekbhatt7433 Год назад

      Bro I am in lot of confusion right now who is right wrong ... Sadhguru ... science is dope ... There a guys call visudhi ...and this swetabh ...🤯

  • @kosiscatharsis7943
    @kosiscatharsis7943 2 года назад +14

    It's not about being Sadhguru a "bewakoof". It's more about what one should speak when he has such a big following. If one is trying to serve his thoughts, intuitions and "godman" enlightenment as empirical facts then that person should be pulled out. That guy from science is dope is pulling out only the scientific fallacies, and that's what we expect from a channel named "science is dope". Sadhguru is intelligent and wise, no second thoughts on that. But spreading messages on science with non-sensible statements is actually an offensive crime! He is wise and intelligent, his words on lifestyle and cultural progressions are highly admirable. But at the same time a person of science won't stand with some claims he makes, and moreover those claims ain't at all acceptable from someone like him. Conclusion : Consider him as a normal human being who is highly skilled in his field of work. Don't follow anyone blindly without cross checking whatever he/she is saying. Follow Shwetabh, SCREW YOUR HEROES. :)

    • @Crafterbhumiiii4143
      @Crafterbhumiiii4143 2 года назад +3

      Sadhguru was invited at Oxford, harward where he discussed and debated on science with senior experienced scientists , they didn't cancelled him like and they listed politely and cross questioned him in respectful manner. Ecologists, microbiologists from UN , WHO and aslo from West countries are supporting him in #SAVESOIL campaign.If he was not scientific then why didn't developed west nation stopped him . Western nations are not fools , that they will entertain anyone random pseudo scientific. It means Sadhguru have some material otherwise he would have been kicked form west .

    • @Crafterbhumiiii4143
      @Crafterbhumiiii4143 2 года назад

      Now still you feel that you and that guy pranav are more intelligent than these scientists , than sorry you are not scientific but an egoistic, jealous human being.

    • @kosiscatharsis7943
      @kosiscatharsis7943 2 года назад

      @@Crafterbhumiiii4143 And to quote Sadhguru, " There is. But today if something comes from the East it is labeled superstition. If it comes from the West it is science ". And to quote you "If he was not scientific then why didn't developed west nation stopped him . Western nations are not fools , that they will entertain anyone random pseudo scientific. It means Sadhguru have some material otherwise he would have been kicked form west ". Contradiction bruh! :(
      And,
      maybe not always scientifically correct, but no one said that Sadhguru is an idiot. Talk on Pranav, his mocking is his style of sarcasm layered criticism. They're very much right at their own places. And now on me, I'm not at all anywhere near anyone whom you've mentioned😂. So, yes psychology says I should be a bit jealous of all of them :))).

    • @parthkhanolkar7916
      @parthkhanolkar7916 2 года назад +1

      @@Crafterbhumiiii4143 sadhguru was invited by the students from those universities. Nor the professors or researchers

    • @Qurankolikhnewala
      @Qurankolikhnewala 2 года назад

      @@parthkhanolkar7916 how do you know

  • @adityaspace
    @adityaspace 2 года назад +5

    The difference between Shwetabh and other youtubers is, Shwetabh comes from a point of curiosity while others come from a point of hate, he challenges the idea, others challenge the person.

  • @silent0141
    @silent0141 2 года назад +4

    Bhaisahab! Maja aagaya.
    After a very long time, absolutely enjoyed this video.💙🌟

  • @holyswordsman8568
    @holyswordsman8568 Год назад +1

    bhai vo online smarties was literally me 2yrs ago thank you itna mirror reflect karne ko now I also try my best to ask what and why in perspective of life

  • @prateekgrewal4717
    @prateekgrewal4717 2 года назад +89

    He is an excellent spiritual guru so people should only listen to his spiritual talks not science related stuff.

    • @theroaster2562
      @theroaster2562 2 года назад +50

      well then he shouldn't speak about science in the first place

    • @sushil6509
      @sushil6509 2 года назад +16

      @@theroaster2562 Video dekha sir pura apne?

    • @theroaster2562
      @theroaster2562 2 года назад +23

      @@sushil6509 Ji Sir, GuruJi random claims/facts/statistics krte hue or Valid Questions ko dodge krte hue dikhae die Joe Rogan k podcast m

    • @theroaster2562
      @theroaster2562 2 года назад +10

      @@VikasYadav-tc8zk that's what i said bro 💯 bhyi Log q smjhenge? Guruji ko ni pta Science k bare to uske bare m bolo hi mt na 😂🤦🏻‍♂️ as simple as that

    • @erasernox2611
      @erasernox2611 2 года назад +2

      @@theroaster2562 true that dude, this is what shwetabh should be stating

  • @krishansingh.jc96
    @krishansingh.jc96 2 года назад +82

    First i thought it is another Sadhguru hating video but I was wrong. You won my love and respect.

    • @ronakbothra6371
      @ronakbothra6371 2 года назад

      Don't make perspectives based on assumption

    • @saitamathecoder1386
      @saitamathecoder1386 2 года назад +3

      @@ronakbothra6371 ha bhai, sab ban jaao intellectual.

    • @dipanshuagrawal6659
      @dipanshuagrawal6659 2 месяца назад

      The first sign of smart person is that he will never teach about the thing that are not his expertise. Second, he is open to learn and has a growth mindset. Third, he is humble enough to accept the mistakes.
      Now come on to Sadguru, I watched his many videos become impressed by them also. Then came a video. He was telling about Rudraksha (which is a pious thing used symbolically in Hinduism) and he tried to establish supernatural powers in it. For it he gave a demonstration, he hold Rudraksha and said it automatically rotates in clockwise direction because of positive energy in it. WHATTT????
      Yes!!!! It is a very big claim. It violates Common Sense, Science and Laws of physics!!!
      It means he knows nothing about Science, Positive Energy, Rudraksha etc. additionally he can go that far to fool other persons. He is not a smart person but a clever, superstitious thug.
      So what a smart person would do? First he would not say anything about energy and rotation etc which he dont know clearly.
      Secondly, he could have upgrade his knowledge of physics and Lastly he could accept his mistakes.
      Now come on this video, Swetabh is saying to judge them with their debates and reasoning and talks. Well Swetabh! anyone clever can make words. Also, the core message of Sadguru is about spirituality, energy and all. Just judge him by it and not the clever stories which can be copy pasted by Osho and many others.
      You just messed up Swetabh, I think its your biasness or your 20% wrong zone!! Feeling very sad.
      People doing Sambhavi Kriya, following his food recommendations, sleep recommendation are very vulnerable and misguided. Feel sad about them.

    • @krishansingh.jc96
      @krishansingh.jc96 2 месяца назад

      @@dipanshuagrawal6659 BKL kaam pe dhyan de 😂
      Jitna time tune ye type karne me lagaya hai utna time Science or Spirituality me se kisi ek me bhi deta to tera bhala hota ❤️de 😘

  • @Vardhan_am
    @Vardhan_am 2 года назад +27

    For me Sadhguru is the only person present on the social media platform who has effectively made use of the platform and is helping millions of people around the world to turn inward - A Silent Revolution at its Best🙏🏼.
    His words alone brought about
    many changes within me, leave his Presence aside.
    He is Raising Alarming ENVIRONMENTAL issues that we choose to ignore in our quest to get more and more from the planet.
    Truly a true analysis. Shwetabh is so aware of the this Mass Media Medium through which he can influence a lot of people. But still he chooses to present facts and pointers and truly conducts the ANALYSIS.
    Honestly I was afraid when I saw the thumbnails of this video. I thought, " Another Influencer choosing his medium of mass communication to spread manipulated analysis ".
    But to my surprise the way Shwetabh has educated the audience about not to fall in the so called media Traps and think for themselves. I really Bow down to You for the effort. 🙏🏼
    Guess it's high time for the world to recognise the true meaning of what it is to be a "GURU". And not fall for manipulated meanings made by the west and so called Indian media.

  • @cartoonsong193
    @cartoonsong193 2 года назад +4

    There was a man like Sadhguru before he was known as Osho he was very influential and his phylosphy drives many people to his ashram even today many years after his demise

  • @purnendubiswas3600
    @purnendubiswas3600 2 года назад +11

    Great Video! 👍🏼
    I would also like to know your experiences of the programs that are being offered by Sadhguru & Isha Foundation. 🙏🏼

    • @boulaypatrick
      @boulaypatrick Год назад

      Isha foundation is here to feed "Sad Guru" with enough money to run it's lavish livestyle with Hummers , Mercedes , Rolexes ... I am not speaking of the all the money he earns with his special programs . He is possibly one's of the biggest spiritual scammers of the 21th century ...For someone with only a bachelor in english I "am impressed .

  • @ankitacharya975
    @ankitacharya975 2 года назад +5

    Most of the spiritual babas are good orators.they charm people with their wonderful oratory skills and sometimes it works.people are need for motivation,someone to tell them what to do that's where baba's comes

  • @aviraljanveja5155
    @aviraljanveja5155 2 года назад +3

    Would actually pay for a conversation between Shwetabh & J Sai Deepak 🔥

  • @anandabharath2404
    @anandabharath2404 2 года назад +4

    Wonderful Explanation as always Swetabh👍

  • @Qurankolikhnewala
    @Qurankolikhnewala 2 года назад +20

    I thought about same thing, but I was like 90%. Anyway don't expect things to be perfect, Sadhguru himself admits something he doesn't know well. I have seen it many times.

    • @mayankindian3750
      @mayankindian3750 2 года назад +3

      Bro I am also atheist but sadhguru is not stupid bhai sadhguru kayi baatein sense waali bhi karte hai science or spirituality me fark samjhna chahiye

    • @Qurankolikhnewala
      @Qurankolikhnewala 2 года назад +1

      @@mayankindian3750 bro atheism bhi ek kind of thought hai just like religion wale log, fundamentally koi faraq nhi hai, ek ke paas book hai balki aaj kal atheism ke liye bhi books milte hain. par dono admit karte nhi hai unhe sach me hi nhi pta ye creation kisne bnaya "exactly". so be a seeker, its a better title or its not even needed just a life with temporary body and mind.

    • @Dank.man45
      @Dank.man45 2 года назад

      @Pragnesh Kumar bhai ye kaisi choice hai teri?
      Puri ki puri bachkani lag rahi hai,yakeen man Bachpan se mein atheist tha,magar abhi theist hu,magar jo bhi ho,tujhe to sahi hi lag rha hoga,maano,tumhari zindagi hai...

    • @vipulgarg8575
      @vipulgarg8575 2 года назад

      It's okay to not be an expert in everything . But when you don't know about science, you should not talk about it or else you would make an absolute fool of yourself. Just say "I have no expertise in science". But he thinks he is too smart to give his feedback on every damn thing 😁😂

  • @nikhildhakal3727
    @nikhildhakal3727 2 года назад +12

    I give 70%-30% positive rating to Sadhguru. I love his talks on our mind, happiness and even soil etc but you cannot completely make up story as a fact.

  • @BrainHax
    @BrainHax 2 года назад +37

    I have attended Sadhuru's Inner Engineering and also had a conversation with Science is Dope
    Here I will give you some balanced points from both sides
    A) inner engineering was awesome for increasing the cognitive functions , concentration ,focus , to handle and know our compulsive patterns
    (I'm going to make a well edited video on that)
    B) The problem arises when Sadhguru talks science .
    At one end he uses science to back his claims and on other hand he bashes science
    This duality has triggered the scientific community
    Many of the scientific facts he presents like
    "your body is not made to eat non veg"
    "Don't have tea , coffee , onion , garlic ,tomato ,potato"
    These are not scientific facts ,but he claims that it's proven in science
    Above mentioned rules are provided to people who do inner engineering , and I'm telling you 70% of people stop following these rules and just do the Yogic practices that Sadhguru give
    C) Now this is just my opinion ,might be wrong or right
    After putting the fear of certain food items
    He introduces you to his line of products
    Which gives him a defacto power over you
    This part of Sadhguru ,feels a little bit unethical to me
    Rest all is fine
    Conclusion : Sadhguru should stick to spirituality , Yoga , mental well-being
    Consider the fact that I'm just a 23 year old boy ,so many of my points maybe wrong and could be right to some extent

    • @bhuvaneshs.k638
      @bhuvaneshs.k638 2 года назад +10

      Compared to science is dope this man did a better job in analysing sadguru. Cuz he addressed both pros and cons of Sadhguru

    • @bellahadid7787
      @bellahadid7787 2 года назад +1

      Ohh i understood, i kinda agree....

    • @BenNeedsATheme4aDream
      @BenNeedsATheme4aDream 2 года назад +3

      @@bhuvaneshs.k638 how exactly. Shwetabh is primarily telling us to take the good and leave out the bad. Which is unhealthy for us, its ill intent that matters here.
      Jaggi (Sadhguru) isn't some naive old man saying things, he is a leader of a multi million organization. These are words carefully thoughtout and consistent with his past comments. 'Science is dope' has specifically picked out and broken down the manner in which Jaggi is dispelling his nonsensical statements. Science is dope has even shared what are the logical fallicies used!

    • @gauravmitra2882
      @gauravmitra2882 2 года назад +9

      Point C is absolutely wrong, where did he promote his line of products? I have also attended Inner engineering, nowhere he has mentioned his line of products and neither I am using any of his products. Only thing you take away to home is Sambhavi mahamudra as a kriya yoga practice from Inner engineering.

    • @kinetic_kripesh8279
      @kinetic_kripesh8279 2 года назад

      @@bhuvaneshs.k638 science is dope only talks about science which is his domain and thus he has no interest in poking his nose into domains in which he knows jackshit...

  • @kuchbhi6732
    @kuchbhi6732 2 года назад +6

    This whole video was not an analysis but a defence statement from the start. An analysis consists of positive as well as negative aspects which hello…

  • @anonymous_4276
    @anonymous_4276 2 года назад +16

    It's not just about percentages though. What are we to think of someone who states that water has memory? We can say things that are less nuanced, slightly wrong or we can say incredibly silly things too. It's not just about percentages and that is why people criticise him a lot too. He does get a lot of stuff right, I'd agree there.

    • @Crafterbhumiiii4143
      @Crafterbhumiiii4143 2 года назад

      It has been proofed in latest research . Now I ask you , do u thing earth has a some kind of heart beat ?? You will call me stupid and pseudo scientific , right . But LATEST RESEARCH reveals earth has a heart beat. So don't just label something false just because scientists from the west cannot prove that thing . It has become a habit that anything that comes from West is idea , but anything from east is superstition.

    • @Crafterbhumiiii4143
      @Crafterbhumiiii4143 2 года назад +3

      And yes water has a memory , check the latest research

    • @prashanthn1832
      @prashanthn1832 2 года назад +2

      i dont think today's science is at a stage where they can confidently say water dont have memory so...........😊

    • @Enlightened23
      @Enlightened23 2 года назад +2

      science cannot proved that till today so it could be true.

  • @prasoonchoudhary1026
    @prasoonchoudhary1026 2 года назад +2

    Love the dark lighting making u look more serious and dc like

  • @abhi_el8
    @abhi_el8 2 года назад +18

    A spiritual enthusiast watching! 🙋‍♂️ Hope this is good 💯

  • @pushkarchhetri5357
    @pushkarchhetri5357 2 года назад +6

    like your vedios sir followed you since 2016 yet it is my first time writing it down however in your next podcast can you talk about connectivity where we can try to connect every discipline we have studied like arts, science, business and how they are related and how can we think in a way that it can be connected as it is very difficult
    love from bhutan

  • @desiconvicted
    @desiconvicted 2 года назад +6

    shwetabh bruhh i would love to have your thoughts on the movie ''a silent voice'' please watch it and have ur thoughts on it....its one of the best anime movies of all time, probably the most impactful ones...i have watched it 10 times but i always have tears in my eyes watching it !!

  • @suyashverma15
    @suyashverma15 2 года назад +6

    You nailed it too bro.. Nice explanation. 🙂👍

  • @aditya-rt4zb
    @aditya-rt4zb 2 года назад +5

    20:00 knowledge should be used for purposes. The old long platonic nyayika thing still in place

  • @puneetmaheshwari
    @puneetmaheshwari 2 года назад +3

    Came for right or wrong sadguru and leaving with new POV thankyou soo much

  • @mithunnair8587
    @mithunnair8587 2 года назад +7

    Bro please bring science is dope to your podcast, I would genuinely love to listen to u guys points and counterpoints on this subject ❤️

    • @Raj-wu2sd
      @Raj-wu2sd 2 года назад

      Science is dope has an agenda... Observe him properly

    • @Dank.man45
      @Dank.man45 2 года назад

      That person has an agenda,naah,he will spoil sane kids here...

    • @shivam_nagar69
      @shivam_nagar69 Год назад

      shwetabh will kill that guy😂😂

  • @legendarygamer640
    @legendarygamer640 2 года назад +3

    There's a book called 'lateral thinking' by Edward de bono that matches totally matches shwetabh's idea of perspectives

  • @antiwokehuman
    @antiwokehuman Год назад +6

    Everytime he talks about science and correlate it with scriptures and mythology, i get a headache. People should use logic when listening to these godmen. Also there are lots of things to be proud about this country. We don't need to support pseudoscience for this purpose

    • @dipanshuagrawal6659
      @dipanshuagrawal6659 2 месяца назад

      The first sign of smart person is that he will never teach about the thing that are not his expertise. Second, he is open to learn and has a growth mindset. Third, he is humble enough to accept the mistakes.
      Now come on to Sadguru, I watched his many videos become impressed by them also. Then came a video. He was telling about Rudraksha (which is a pious thing used symbolically in Hinduism) and he tried to establish supernatural powers in it. For it he gave a demonstration, he hold Rudraksha and said it automatically rotates in clockwise direction because of positive energy in it. WHATTT????
      Yes!!!! It is a very big claim. It violates Common Sense, Science and Laws of physics!!!
      It means he knows nothing about Science, Positive Energy, Rudraksha etc. additionally he can go that far to fool other persons. He is not a smart person but a clever, superstitious thug.
      So what a smart person would do? First he would not say anything about energy and rotation etc which he dont know clearly.
      Secondly, he could have upgrade his knowledge of physics and Lastly he could accept his mistakes.
      Now come on this video, Swetabh is saying to judge them with their debates and reasoning and talks. Well Swetabh! anyone clever can make words. Also, the core message of Sadguru is about spirituality, energy and all. Just judge him by it and not the clever stories which can be copy pasted by Osho and many others.
      You just messed up Swetabh, I think its your biasness or your 20% wrong zone!! Feeling very sad.
      People doing Sambhavi Kriya, following his food recommendations, sleep recommendation are very vulnerable and misguided. Feel sad about them.

  • @Ayushkumar-pb9hp
    @Ayushkumar-pb9hp 2 года назад

    Bhai, bahut hi tagda video hai. Speechless ho gaye hai hum 🙏🔥🔥

  • @abouttraveling4787
    @abouttraveling4787 2 года назад +5

    Bro we are not against Sadhguru But sometimes he makes claims that are too foolish that are just out of mind to bear and I can't understand why being critical to people hurts so much.

  • @yashsaxena6416
    @yashsaxena6416 2 года назад +5

    “If we’ve been bamboozled long enough, we tend to reject any evidence of the bamboozle. We’re no longer interested in finding out the truth. The bamboozle has captured us. It’s simply too painful to acknowledge, even to ourselves, that we’ve been taken. Once you give a charlatan power over you, you almost never get it back.” - Carl Sagan
    Sorry Shwetabh! will have to disagree with you on this one.

  • @netineti5953
    @netineti5953 2 года назад +19

    A year ago I was huge admirer of sadhguru. But now as I have opened myself to new stuff I find him less relevant and logical. Though I still appreciate his oratory skills and marketing knowledge. Traditional Sampradayas are something which anyone who is interested in spirituality should once consult too. It gives me immense pain if someone knows sadhguru and not Ramanujacharya or Shankaracharya learn philosophies of these legends . Do not neglect them

    • @arihantjain6462
      @arihantjain6462 2 года назад

      Listen to achrya prashant

    • @hrithikmaity609
      @hrithikmaity609 2 года назад

      @@arihantjain6462 still he is not from a particular sampradaya like see in jainism u guys have one sampradaya of mahavira but we have many sampradaya like that of Adi Shankara, Ramanujacharya, Madhavacharya, Nimbirka and many other of different sects like advait, shaivism, smartha, shaktitism and vaishnavism which are traditional in nature.... But still we should look at the guru first because sometimes traditional guru might not be real and sometimes he might be the best.... And it depends one's incilnation towards realizing the truth because everyone have different ideas and opinions how one idea can survive? I am following vaishnavism but I guess Sadhguru once said that he is from siddha tradtion Or something from the lineage of agastya muni... Still I don't know he is also good.... But acharya prasant is good for understanding vedantic books in a different prespective...

    • @dhruv1106
      @dhruv1106 2 года назад +1

      Yeah "Traditional Sampradayas" which still believes in extremely casteist rules, only allows "Brahmins" to chant Vedic mantras and dwijas to wear sacred thread and study Veda, and believe that shudras's duty is to only serve the upper varnas. These can f off. Adi Shankaracharya was a extremely intelligent and Enlightenment person but he was extremely hateful (unlike the Buddha).
      Ramakrishna mission is the best to get into Advaita Vedanta.

    • @lemonboy21
      @lemonboy21 2 года назад

      Same happened with me when I Opened myself and Rethink " Mahatma Gandhi"

    • @swapnilchaudhari9555
      @swapnilchaudhari9555 2 года назад

      The fact that you just got bored with him.
      99% of the times he makes but if you watch anyone for long time you will be bored irrespective of there quality.
      It happens with all people but intelligent one understand it that he got bored by watching this particular person and dumb people usually blame taht particular person.
      This happened with me.
      Few years ago I was regular viewer of sadguru and sandip but now I don't even watch there for whole years but still I don't blame them.
      Obviously there are few nonsense things but most of the time ridiculous sense.

  • @arnavrajegaming2213
    @arnavrajegaming2213 2 года назад +29

    Bhai just visit Sadhguru's Ashram one day not necessary for a program just visit the dhyanlinga once.Your mind will be clear as the sky and the joy and pleasure is just too much.Try visiting spirituality is all about experience man.

    • @Shikhar_fromIndia
      @Shikhar_fromIndia 2 года назад +7

      ब्रो वहा माल 🚬 मिलता है क्या? 🌝

    • @gauravsangal
      @gauravsangal 2 года назад +3

      @@Shikhar_fromIndia 🤣

    • @gauravsangal
      @gauravsangal 2 года назад +9

      Go to top of your home or on some hill you fell the same because more you connect to nature more you come close to your natural state

    • @arnavrajegaming2213
      @arnavrajegaming2213 2 года назад

      @@Shikhar_fromIndia haan woh maal jo tumhe har maal chudwane mai help karega.Us maal ka naam hai life

  • @sayanmondal2009
    @sayanmondal2009 2 года назад +3

    very beautifully explained 👏 thank you brother 🪴🍉🍇

  • @lilwen9728
    @lilwen9728 2 года назад +9

    Science and spirituality go hand in hand... Hit 👍 to yay or go home...

  • @Taskmaster763
    @Taskmaster763 2 года назад +3

    7:50 time is absolute - Newton
    ........................................,..........,,,.,.....
    Einstein- only a sith works in absolute

  • @abhirj87
    @abhirj87 2 года назад +4

    Very well made analysis. Absolutely loved it.

  • @lamoded7926
    @lamoded7926 2 года назад +14

    anything can be proved or made to make sense with logic and trickery of words but what all it comes down to is evidence

  • @whatwrongindreaming
    @whatwrongindreaming 2 года назад

    Thanks for making this video. This video change my perspective of choosing content or How should i analyze content authenticity.

  • @MadMax-fs3cy
    @MadMax-fs3cy 2 года назад +4

    That's what dhruv rathee and his gang does, judge a whole person coz of one thing he said wrong

  • @terigopula
    @terigopula 2 года назад +2

    Nailed it Shwetabh.. I like the way you organize your thoughts and convey them clearly. It also distinctly portrays the research that goes behind making this spot on crispness happen. Keep going..!
    Sadhguru is

  • @sudhanshusingh.0307
    @sudhanshusingh.0307 2 года назад +3

    Much needed video

  • @Way_Of_The_Light
    @Way_Of_The_Light 2 года назад +2

    Excellent critical thinking Shwethab 🙏

  • @Aditya-it9on
    @Aditya-it9on 2 года назад +3

    You talk in a very logical way Bhai.... This was the first comment... Let me finish the video

  • @Ajinkyakohale
    @Ajinkyakohale 2 года назад +2

    Sadhguru also have started global movement to #savesoil . Because soil is depleting ita quality if dont save our soil now our future generations will face lots of food crisis problems.
    Join the #savesoilmovement 😊🙏

  • @notrhythm
    @notrhythm 2 года назад +4

    Wow didn't expect this video but I'm glad to see this. Well analyzed. I listen to him and agree with most of what he says regarding human wellbeing and spirituality, it's very helpful and encouraging. I just ignore stuff that doesn't make sense to me like occult etc.. cause who knows maybe those things are real or maybe enlightened people aren't all knowing like we seem to think. Either way, I wouldn't be certain about anything unless I fully understand it.

  • @adarshjadhav3238
    @adarshjadhav3238 2 года назад +19

    Once sadguru's entire session rounded up upon just one scientific claim that iron is present in body and it gets attracted to the earth's magnetic field and we shouldn't sleep in that specified direction. So now he took this one evidence and spoke for an entire session. But the fact was that iron isn't present as an element and it's present in a compound state. So now it doesn't have a magnetic property. The 80 % that we were looking for in this session was dependent on that 20%. I feel your talk would even consider the political aspects of sadguru also.

    • @prashanthn1832
      @prashanthn1832 2 года назад

      he was talking about blood flow inside..u can easily give a reference to a video link right why are u avoiding

    • @nimishnandedkar9278
      @nimishnandedkar9278 2 года назад

      I have seen that video he is speaking about someone else , and btw sleeping while your head is rested on the north side is not good , which is also proven by many studies

    • @advaithsk7590
      @advaithsk7590 2 года назад +2

      @@nimishnandedkar9278 which study

    • @gurlalbajwa8627
      @gurlalbajwa8627 2 года назад +1

      Dude do u even know how magnetism work in atom ?

  • @yashraj66
    @yashraj66 2 года назад +21

    There is no problem in making mistakes as a human,but he himself claims he has experienced enlightment,then how can an enlightened soul can be biased/attached about certain thoughts like every other human,does'nt it contradict the whole point of being enlightened,so may be thats just an PR thing and thats ok,but he should'nt be misleading about this.

    • @subhadeepjasu292
      @subhadeepjasu292 2 года назад

      Can you give me some examples of this?

    • @yashraj66
      @yashraj66 2 года назад +4

      @@subhadeepjasu292 you can get a video about his enlightment experience in his channel,in a recent podcast with beerbiceps he even goes on to say that he clearly knows about his final moments, when asked about death.does that sound like a normal human thing? May be not

    • @erasernox2611
      @erasernox2611 2 года назад +1

      @@yashraj66 yea dude sadhguru even said the Psuedoscientific things like by only seeing the water you can change its molecules and well being will come to u or he knows a better theory that even nobel prize winning scientists wanna know, this is the crap I dont agree on with sadhguru neither to shwetabh unless discussing about those things with sadhguru in great length to properly understand his opinions...cos even if pseudoscientific things coming out from a nobel prize winning scientist or philosopher will still remain Psuedoscientific and it would be better for shwetabh to give list of theories that tend to constantly change in every field in science vs the list of theories that still stand the test of time, that would be better accurate explanation towards sadhgurus Psuedoscience opinions, but it is sad no links where given in

    • @erasernox2611
      @erasernox2611 2 года назад

      @@yashraj66 and also the Aristotle gravity point of shwetabh was not a good example I believe

    • @shriharsh7242
      @shriharsh7242 2 года назад

      He has also said about it in his book Inner Engineering and keeps saying it everywhere also in the Rogan show recently... I feel like he is very high in narcissism.

  • @kaldecoder5919
    @kaldecoder5919 2 года назад

    Kya khatarnak Batayi hai BROThER! Wait for Next Ghanghor Thinking Vdo🙏

  • @akaymoon9786
    @akaymoon9786 2 года назад +3

    One of the main teachings of sadhguru, don't believe or disbelieve on anything.
    So keep calm 🙏

  • @shivamsingh-cl4zw
    @shivamsingh-cl4zw 2 года назад +3

    Sir once a fictional villain said " There is no good or evil , there is only power and those who are too weak to seek it " Do you agree with this statement?

  • @FriedMomo04
    @FriedMomo04 2 года назад +13

    Some direct simple straightforward question: What tools can help people deal with problems?
    Sadhguru: The complexity of the present time seems to demand a flowering of our hopes if we are going to survive. Dogma is born in the
    gap where synchronicity has been excluded. Without intention, one cannot believe. Pain is the antithesis of growth. Where there is suffering, joy cannot thrive. Yes, it is possible
    to erase the things that can extinguish us, but not without aspiration on our side.
    You must take a stand against suffering. You may be ruled by greed without realizing it. Do not let it
    confront the richness of your mission. We can no longer afford to live with pain. The cosmos is approaching a tipping point. It is time to
    take coherence to the next level. Soon there will be an unfolding of truth the likes of which the dreamtime has never seen. We are at a crossroads of wellbeing and illusion. We are
    in the midst of a life-affirming ennobling of truth that will give us access to the world itself. Reality has always been full of entities whose
    bodies are nurtured by growth. Have you found your circuit? It can be difficult to know where to begin. Although you may not realize it, you are ethereal.
    Throughout history, humans have been interacting with the dreamscape via molecular structures. Humankind has nothing to lose. Our
    conversations with other travellers have led to a redefining of hyper-ancient consciousness. *And it is a scientifically proven fact by the survey of the university of Massachusetts*
    Blind followers: Holy smokes, What a befitting reply. Sadhguru just killed it, amazing. What an intelligent man.
    Sadhguru's marketing team uploading the same video and adds title like these: "Sadhguru shuts
    up the idiots", "Idiot questioned Sadhguru's ways, here's how Sadhguru gave befitting reply",
    "Sadhguru Shuts Up a Law Student When She try to Insults Him".
    comment section: "oye sadhguru tera baap hai".

    • @saikatghosh9073
      @saikatghosh9073 2 года назад

      😂😂😂😂😂
      Btw Don't use the word Bhakt
      It has a political connotation to it (I belong to the wing spectrum of politics)

    • @FriedMomo04
      @FriedMomo04 2 года назад

      @@saikatghosh9073 oops🤣

    • @FriedMomo04
      @FriedMomo04 2 года назад +1

      @@saikatghosh9073 and all the things he says is scientifically proven mind that🤣

    • @priyanksharma5267
      @priyanksharma5267 2 года назад

      This is what u want to hear le sadhguru tera baap hai and let me give u answer of your question. He said sit back relax and think about your self that's it. What do u think dumb your problems will fix after listening one or two liner answers. Go do something in your life keyboard warrior

    • @FriedMomo04
      @FriedMomo04 2 года назад +1

      @@priyanksharma5267 lol he once said
      "milk is different in each breast when a mother gives birth to twins"
      yehi sab maantey raho tum log tumhara hi baap hai yeh

  • @AP-eb8hd
    @AP-eb8hd 2 года назад +11

    Sadhguru speaks good English, has got amazing public speaking skills & he has excellent charisma as well. He may be very knowledgable in philosophy and spirituality, but that simply doesn't mean you make bold statements which are incoherent, baseless and wrong in areas you don't know. This is where I have a problem considering how influential he (& his PR) is & they manage to swindle people into donations and nonsensical causes on the pretext of science. This new "save soil" gimmck is one of them.

    • @mithunnair8587
      @mithunnair8587 2 года назад +6

      In some aspects, he should say that i don't have the knowledge about it now rather than saying something based on ur opinion about it

    • @desiDJ909
      @desiDJ909 2 года назад

      I don't think #savesoil is a bad or gimmick move
      Do you every damn man is a fool ........... we you are very disconnected from reality.
      some years before we used to collect much more grains from the farmers of our land ....... But as time increased it is now half of those we used to collect

    • @desiDJ909
      @desiDJ909 2 года назад

      don't worry till famines come.

    • @AP-eb8hd
      @AP-eb8hd 2 года назад

      @@desiDJ909 I don't deny there is an ecological issue.. mark my words.. All this campaigning just results in donations to Isha.. and the main cause forgotten.. just like Cauvery calling..

    • @desiDJ909
      @desiDJ909 2 года назад

      @@AP-eb8hd But cavery calling is not a failed.............. Cavery calling had 2 agendas -- 1-Government level law change for rivers
      2- Planting more and more trees...... And free distribution of trees for the farmers of Tamilnadu
      Both work is some what successful.......
      What are you expecting ?????

  • @Jaidip
    @Jaidip 2 года назад +15

    My problem with Sadguru is that he's not learning from his own mistakes and accepts that he's not good in scientific stuff. & his claims so many times doesn't make sense for even basic science POV. & it's human nature to doubt every the sentence coming from anyone who makes false claims or ignore obvious facts.

    • @navin7803
      @navin7803 2 года назад +1

      ane 11:35 se dekh

    • @Jaidip
      @Jaidip 2 года назад +1

      @@navin7803 I commented after watching full video. & I'm not saying Sadguru is wrong or right, I'm no expert. But as Shwetabh said 80_20% ratio, so how are you gonna make sure what is right & wrong? You are constantly doubtful about that intellectual talk of Sadguru. It's sad that Sadguru still making scientific claim he failed so many time. So I think he should try to explain without science which is not his expertise.

    • @Jaidip
      @Jaidip 2 года назад

      @Shivaditya Varman ek hi galti dus baar kr rhe hai. Inn kuch claim ki wajah se sab kuch doubtful ho jata hai. & hum sab logg basic science pdhte hai lekin human behaviour & psychology nhi pdhte to uss alien subject me believe krna bhi muskil ho jata hai.

    • @Raj-wu2sd
      @Raj-wu2sd 2 года назад

      Has science invested enough in spirituality and mysticism...

  • @trevorandi4692
    @trevorandi4692 2 года назад +2

    Ye bhi ho sakta hai ki x² jo 20% bata raha hai wo hum samajh nhi paa rahe ho , ya fir uska us chiz ko dekhne ka point of view doosra hai but jabtak hum us baat ko sahi tarike se samajh nhi lete tab tk uspe believe nhi karna chahiye chahe wo sahi ho ya galat

  • @aimexcellence1315
    @aimexcellence1315 Год назад +3

    halo effect hai jaggi vasudev aka sadguru ka logo me, sadguru can be good in spreading or re collecting some hindu mythological or literature texts and spread light on it, but other all issues where he had his teachings, opinions, suggestions and arguments are utter senseless. he just use logical techniques to shut down opponents and use his humor (which is a good quality ) to downgrade questioner, he links all positive things with indian culture an negatives with his prejudiced opponent.

  • @snehendudana
    @snehendudana 2 года назад

    You are absolutely correct. This is the topics which proves you realize the matter more than 80%

  • @devanandmahto2499
    @devanandmahto2499 2 года назад +3

    ravan not killed by ram ravan killed by it,s ego. jai shree krishna

  • @shivam00668
    @shivam00668 2 года назад +1

    भाई पूरी दुनिया में इस्लामिक आतंक एक बड़ी समस्या है, उस पर आप प्लीज एक एनालिसिस वीडियो बनाये 🙏

  • @apacheattackhelicopter8778
    @apacheattackhelicopter8778 2 года назад +24

    I am sorry Shwetabh, but I don't think we agree with you on this one.
    You're trying to portray Sadhguru as some fortune cookie where we decide which prediction of his is correct.
    Criticism around him is that he spouts pseudoscience even though he's intelligent enough to know where his expertise doesn't lie and you're telling us, "Eh, it's your job to check whether his teachings are bs or not". Yeah no shit, we know that.
    But there's a reason cigarettes have photos of damaged lungs on them, not everyone has the ability to see through the bs or take the right decisions. For that reason, we need to focus more on calling him out instead of victim blaming.

    • @nityamjain1561
      @nityamjain1561 2 года назад +9

      You missed the point of the whole video gracefully.

    • @Param.01
      @Param.01 2 года назад +5

      'I am so smart group' member spotted.

    • @nowwhat6716
      @nowwhat6716 2 года назад +3

      @@Param.01 so U don't have the argument 😂 going directly for insult huh good thinking 🎅

  • @ubiquitousgamer9176
    @ubiquitousgamer9176 2 года назад

    nice drip bhay, the lights in your room and all the things osm. 👍

  • @prateekgrewal4717
    @prateekgrewal4717 2 года назад +4

    React on Science is dope's video on Sadhguru, and do an analysis, that would be more clear to the audience.

  • @aadityasrivastava7112
    @aadityasrivastava7112 2 года назад +1

    Science is not meant to reject but to find, firstly
    And secondly If Bohr Model is proven wrong then too it is a drawback but not pseudo.
    Similarly, Vedas might be wrong right now but they are a theory which ignited curiousity.

  • @rudranarayandakua6841
    @rudranarayandakua6841 2 года назад +12

    Must admit today's video quality is on another class 🔥

  • @rajeshribajare809
    @rajeshribajare809 2 года назад +1

    Lovely video brother do more on Osho, Acharya Prashant , j Krishnamurthy , sandeep Maheshwari etc

    • @Flnancian
      @Flnancian 2 года назад

      Thanks for watching ❤️.. Make a note to my manager Arthur on how to earn up to 200% profit on digital currency (Crrypto).. his strategies are top notch 📌

    • @Flnancian
      @Flnancian 2 года назад

      WhatsApp✙17759864892