Wonderful voice. She sang beautifully about all of our suffering under oppression. But Mark Knopfler’s creation is a lesson on any voice you can think of. Thanks to both of them
When I was going to Vietnam, Joan was protesting, but with style. I loved the lady and the music, then , and she is still just as beautiful inside and out now, as then.
sie ist vor allen Dingen normal geblieben, obwohl sie mit völlig abgedrehten Typen zusammen ihr Leben gestaltet hat. Sie ist glaubwürdig in ihrer Aussage und in dem was ihre Lieder ausdrücken. Insbesondere das Mitgefühl, was ihr dem Cellisten in Sarajevo ausgedruckt hat. Not und Leid hat sie nie zu Ihrem Vorteil genutzt, sondern immer der Hoffnung auf eine bessere Welt.
AS someone who has been in the forces, this song brings tears to my eyes. Joan gives it justice. No complicated lyrics with hidden undertones, just simple words that mean so much to us. Friends I have lost and live in different worlds now---to me anyway.
This morning (12/25/16) I saw the ESPN 30 for 30 episode: Once Brothers about Yugoslavia, Serbo-Croatia. Vlade Divac and Drazen Petrovic. (I was a peace-time Russian linguist). So after the show, I went out to the lake for a cigarette. The first guy to walk by had a basketball jersey on. The 2nd guy was a Russian from Moscow. I could tell by his accent that he was almost for sure Slavic, so I asked him in Russian what country he was from. We spoke for a moment, enjoyed a good chuckle over a joke that one of my schoolmates had made about peace-time "spies". Peace.
Once every five years or so I stumble upon a song that actually makes me cry. This is one of them. A stunningly beautiful performance. Joan looks and sings like an angel and one can only dream of the emotional impact this would have with Mark's guitar added on top. I'm truly grateful to have heard this.
Respect from Hamburg Germany for Singing and Fighting 60 Years for Peace and Justice in these cruel World.Joan you are an Angel sent by GOD.A Warrior of Peace!!! GOD bless you and your Sisters Mimi Farina.
OMFG,,,, 47, ex service and sat here blubbing like a frikkin baby,, this song has meaning to me and to hear it sang like this, it really is , im lost for friggin words ,, so will end it at that,, love this version,,
Jimmy Cricket Lopez, I believe you are paid for your job also. Soldiers made our lifestyle a life of choice! Thank you to all who served so we that we may have freedom
you and every vet has earned those tears. Shed them proudly! My hope for all of you is that the rest of your life is filled with good health, happiness and longevity.
Music and art can't change the world. Except in the minds that receive it. So many people are blind to feeling and empathy but once in a while something bursts through. This is so strong and will hopefully touch someone who was unaware.
I swear that Joan Baez should be a saint. Her dedication, her continuous non- violent protests, her voice and her quest for peace, are unsurpassed by anyone on earth. God bless you Joan Baez and thank you for everything you have given us!!!!!
WOW! im into heavy metal and guitar bands but this lovely woman really moves me, she still has that lovely voice from all those years ago . now we have two perfect versions of that amazing beautiful song
Me also Metal-Head (mostly, not all the time). Her performance on the Silent Running- Soundtrack is taking my breath away every time. Of course this one too! There are only very few singers that can touch my heart and make me (almost) cry... 👍
One of the greatest songs ever written. You could pick any one of a hundred people to sing this and it would still sound incredible. Amazing how someone can sit and put something like this together.
This album was newly out when I was in US Paratrooper training. We all stood at the head busters bar jukebox and listened, beer in hand. There was a silence as this song played and we all knew right away that this was our song.
Erreur, ce n'est pas Mark Knopfler qui est a l'origine de la chanson, Elle a été écrite par dire en 1982 (guerre des Malouines) Ce tube a été reprise par Mark et Johan Baezz
60 Jahre soziales Engagement mit glasklarer Stimme u. herrlichem Gitarrenspiel, Das ist einmalig auf dieser Welt! Deine Musik begleitet mich schon das ganze Leben. Dir noch ein langes gesundes Leben. Danke Joan Baez!!!
This would never be played on major radio today....such a shame the culture has settled for hip hop crap etc as mainstream choice of music. If not for auto tune most singers today could not carry a tune......
When you have a voice as rich as this lady's you dont need a guitar solo, but having said that can you imagine her and Knopfler doing this song together. Excellent song
"There's so many different worlds So many different suns And we have just one world But we live in different ones" How wonderful are those words . When humans would understand that the world is one!
its ok, but i dont think an emotional vocal like this suits the song, I've hardly heard any cover of MK or DS that does it better. This song would be nothing without the minimalistic chill vocals of the legend:)
This song is one of my favorites. And Joan Baez has one of the greatest voices I ever heard. That broughts me tears in my eyes even if I'm not sure to understand all the lyrics.
What an idea. That would be a meeting of, possibly, the sweetest electric guitar sound of all time and, most likely, the sweetest folk rock voice ever on planet earth. It might be almost too good.
Une grande dame... Engagée qui sait si bien chanter l'amour... Un moment inoubliable au campo santo de Perpignan! Plus qu'une voix une belle âme! Merci pour ce moment...
I didn't think I'd hear a performance of this song to compare with the Dire Straits 1985 album version but I should have known better. The amazing Joan Baez brings the spirit of the 1960s into a 1980s song and makes it timeless.
Congrats, Dr. Lee, or returning home and making something of yourself. My brothers, twins, both served, one for two years as an FO, first on the ground and then in the air, and the other for 18 months flying slicks. Each made a career of flying choppers, then, first as oil workers in the Middle East, then as forestry workers fighting fires, and lastly as civilian medivacs. I'm as proud of you as I am of them, sir.
Mark Knopfler can play guitar like few others with a voice which matches Guitar George, often just pure emotion, but Joan Baez's voice is just pure honey dripping with emotion - Knopfler's raw vocals taken somewhere else. Stunning, absolutely breathtaking.
Joan use to buy tickets from me at a little bass outlet in Palo Alto. I got to know her a little. She’s a wonderful kind lady. I’m sad I never got to play music with her. She offered to jam a little but I had too much on my plate at the time. The last time I saw her she said take care Tommy, you’re a good egg. I miss her
Stumbled across this by accident, but why anyone would dislike what is probably the greatest anti-war song ever, escapes me. On a par with Tom Paxton, check out his stuff, legend.
I saw this after seeing the video clip from SEAL Team where David Boreanz' character walks up the ramp of the Galaxy and takes his spot in the team leader's position as they take the coffin of Bravo 1 off the plane...this is the version they should have used....
I already had heard and have Joan Baez cd;s and LP's.... well I am amazed that I thought a song that was an original is not at all. I love this version this artist has the most amazing sound and clarity. She is an icon.
While I was fighting with my brothers in arms against russia for our independence I listened this song many times. And I remembered my lioved city - Dnipro
Recuerdo a esta cantante y hoy la redescubro porque mi madre la escuchaba cuando yo era pequeño , que hermosa voz y que lindas letras interpreta!!!!!!!!!!!!
Seit 3 Jahrzehnten mit Herz und Hirn bei Ihr und bei mir. Brothers in arms is my live. Wie schön und wunderbar, dass es sie bis heute für mich und uns gibt! We all love she! In Austria, we have so much love to her!
I have loved this lady, her beautiful voice since her beginning in the era of folk music along with Peter,Paul, and Mary, Simon and Garfunkel, and other of the ‘60’s and time of the Viet Nam era and still now in the 2024 year, GOD bless her always
She changed the lyric "we have just on world/but we live in different ones" to "why live in different ones?" Changes it from a simple observation to a challenge to mankind. Makes more sense, too.
Wonderful voice. She sang beautifully about all of our suffering under oppression. But Mark Knopfler’s creation is a lesson on any voice you can think of. Thanks to both of them
When I was going to Vietnam, Joan was protesting, but with style. I loved the lady and the music, then , and she is still just as beautiful inside and out now, as then.
respect to you Ronald Nickell
nICE OF YOU ,RESPECT!
got that exactly right!
@@meme-nt3pq 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
👌💎👋
Joan has one of the purest, most beautiful female voices of them all. Magic
so eva cassidy had.
sie ist vor allen Dingen normal geblieben, obwohl sie mit völlig abgedrehten Typen zusammen ihr Leben gestaltet hat. Sie ist glaubwürdig in ihrer Aussage und in dem was ihre Lieder ausdrücken. Insbesondere das Mitgefühl, was ihr dem Cellisten in Sarajevo ausgedruckt hat. Not und Leid hat sie nie zu Ihrem Vorteil genutzt, sondern immer der Hoffnung auf eine bessere Welt.
Don't anyone forget the late great Kate Wolf. Look her up on RUclips.
Judith Durham (from The Seekers) too
Joan, Emmeylou, and Judy Collins
AS someone who has been in the forces, this song brings tears to my eyes. Joan gives it justice. No complicated lyrics with hidden undertones, just simple words that mean so much to us. Friends I have lost and live in different worlds now---to me anyway.
hall mut we are brothers in arms
Bravo Zulu
This morning (12/25/16) I saw the ESPN 30 for 30 episode: Once Brothers about Yugoslavia, Serbo-Croatia. Vlade Divac and Drazen Petrovic. (I was a peace-time Russian linguist). So after the show, I went out to the lake for a cigarette. The first guy to walk by had a basketball jersey on. The 2nd guy was a Russian from Moscow. I could tell by his accent that he was almost for sure Slavic, so I asked him in Russian what country he was from. We spoke for a moment, enjoyed a good chuckle over a joke that one of my schoolmates had made about peace-time "spies".
Peace.
ur a bitch, liza
Kevin Falk m
Kevin Falk
Once every five years or so I stumble upon a song that actually makes me cry. This is one of them. A stunningly beautiful performance. Joan looks and sings like an angel and one can only dream of the emotional impact this would have with Mark's guitar added on top. I'm truly grateful to have heard this.
Es verdad sólo falta la guitarra de Mark y sus variaciones increíbles...Joan maravillosa y privilegiada con su voz celestial❤
What are the others...that bring tears?
@@s2pacificif you have to ask then there's no point in trying to explain.
Beautiful version. Joan has the most beautiful voice!!🌼💛
Oh yeah! I agree with you...
just beautiful. tears run down my face. and men DO cry.
🤔😥😥😥 🇫🇷🍷 si mom ami Arnold Bourbon Amaral
Well said brother thank you
This song always gets me. Mandolin Rain by Hornsby does as well.
yes brother
agree
Respect from Hamburg Germany for Singing and Fighting 60 Years for Peace and Justice in these cruel World.Joan you are an Angel sent by GOD.A Warrior of Peace!!! GOD bless you and your Sisters Mimi Farina.
Absolutely agree - She's an angel sent to this world 😍🤩
ruclips.net/video/U6WHWxl-Ej0/видео.htmlsi=J0K3jDPKaUAhCEb- greetings from Elmshorn (Germany)
OMFG,,,, 47, ex service and sat here blubbing like a frikkin baby,, this song has meaning to me and to hear it sang like this, it really is , im lost for friggin words ,, so will end it at that,, love this version,,
Nam Vet. Had the same reaction when the original came out.
Remind me...did you get paid to fight?
Jimmy Cricket Lopez, I believe you are paid for your job also. Soldiers made our lifestyle a life of choice! Thank you to all who served so we that we may have freedom
you and every vet has earned those tears. Shed them proudly! My hope for all of you is that the rest of your life is filled with good health, happiness and longevity.
Music and art can't change the world. Except in the minds that receive it. So many people are blind to feeling and empathy but once in a while something bursts through. This is so strong and will hopefully touch someone who was unaware.
Wonderful words
One of the great moments in my life was when I realized I was on the wrong side of that war. So was the other side.
I swear that Joan Baez should be a saint. Her dedication, her continuous non- violent protests, her voice and her quest for peace, are unsurpassed by anyone on earth. God bless you Joan Baez and thank you for everything you have given us!!!!!
💎
You have to read the lyrics to fully appreciate this song and why it is meant for all of man's history:
What a wonderful version by Joan.
60年代，私が小学生の頃，私の心からの憧れであり，歌姫でした。この曲は彼女のオリジナルといえるほどフィットしていますよね。ありごとう。ただただ感謝です。
The song in the right voice, no one better than Joan Baez to sing Brothers in Arms. It touches the soul, wonderful! A direct hug from Brazil! 🇧🇷
É nóis. 😊
The original version by Dire Straits was better.
Hug from Italy! 🇮🇹
I never get tired of this version. Play it whenever I`m in the mood. Joan Baez has such a lovely voice.
Great version of a fabulous song. No matter wich side you're from, fallen soldiers have a family, loved ones, poeple they love. Bothers in arms...
WOW! im into heavy metal and guitar bands but this lovely woman really moves me, she still has that lovely voice from all those years ago . now we have two perfect versions of that amazing beautiful song
Deshalb wurde sie in Hall of Fame aufgenommen 😇
Me also Metal-Head (mostly, not all the time).
Her performance on the
Silent Running-
Soundtrack is taking my breath away every time.
Of course this one too!
There are only very few singers that can touch my heart and make me (almost) cry...
👍
Une des plus belles chansons jamais écrites par un terrien , interprétée par la voix d'un ange : Bouleversant !
One of the greatest songs ever written. You could pick any one of a hundred people to sing this and it would still sound incredible. Amazing how someone can sit and put something like this together.
so true
Not like Joan
Kikka otsvaatteeteet
This album was newly out when I was in US Paratrooper training. We all stood at the head busters bar jukebox and listened, beer in hand. There was a silence as this song played and we all knew right away that this was our song.
I get it. 👍
Incredible rendering by one of the finest singing voices of all time of a great anti-war song by Mark Knopfler.
not exactly an anti-war song. more of a solidarity song with fellow soldiers
Erreur, ce n'est pas Mark Knopfler qui est a l'origine de la chanson,
Elle a été écrite par dire en 1982 (guerre des Malouines)
Ce tube a été reprise par Mark et Johan Baezz
Dire Strait
@@tomawackandy1327 Mark Knopfler wrote this song… as with all other Dire Straits songs. 🤦🏼♂️
Beautiful Joan, so fortunate to have been born in a world with her beautiful voice.
60 Jahre soziales Engagement mit glasklarer Stimme u. herrlichem Gitarrenspiel, Das ist einmalig auf dieser Welt!
Deine Musik begleitet mich schon das ganze Leben. Dir noch ein langes gesundes Leben. Danke Joan Baez!!!
I love Joan Baez and Dire Straits. They have different styles but they are wonderful.
+joy watson The voice form joan plus the music style from Dire Straits would be the greatest music ever.
+John Constantinides Sheryl Crow sucks! NO talent beotch.
I wish they would get together, Joan's voice and Mark's guitar - WOW!
Muana
A perfect song matched with a perfect voice and performed perfectly!
Wonderful voice for one of The Most beautiful Song of Mark
Simona Battistelli n
Simona Battistelli
This would never be played on major radio today....such a shame the culture has settled for hip hop crap etc as mainstream choice of music. If not for auto tune most singers today could not carry a tune......
RON Dennis Wheeler If I were a veteran I would choose to have this played at my funeral
Awesome rendition...made the hair on my neck stand up. Wonderful!
When you have a voice as rich as this lady's you dont need a guitar solo, but having said that can you imagine her and Knopfler doing this song together. Excellent song
"There's so many different worlds
So many different suns
And we have just one world
But we live in different ones"
How wonderful are those words . When humans would understand that the world is one!
The World is ONE and the Universe too
This world may well be one but it's one of many identical ones...and in some we understand this.
This is one fantastic version of this song. I love the guitar parts in the Dire Straits version but her voice is unbelievably stunning. wow
its ok, but i dont think an emotional vocal like this suits the song, I've hardly heard any cover of MK or DS that does it better. This song would be nothing without the minimalistic chill vocals of the legend:)
The Dire Straits version? they fucking wrote it !!
i forgive you because you're a woman
Holy shit - Two of my favorites singing a wonderful underrated Knopfler song. Brilliant!
This song is one of my favorites. And Joan Baez has one of the greatest voices I ever heard. That broughts me tears in my eyes even if I'm not sure to understand all the lyrics.
Her voice together with the guitar skills of Knopfler, possibly a dream duet?
What an idea.
That would be a meeting of, possibly, the sweetest electric guitar sound of all time and, most likely, the sweetest folk rock voice ever on planet earth.
It might be almost too good.
I could’nt say better, exactly what went to my mind when I heard this 😊
Une grande dame... Engagée qui sait si bien chanter l'amour... Un moment inoubliable au campo santo de Perpignan! Plus qu'une voix une belle âme! Merci pour ce moment...
I didn't think I'd hear a performance of this song to compare with the Dire Straits 1985 album version but I should have known better. The amazing Joan Baez brings the spirit of the 1960s into a 1980s song and makes it timeless.
listen then to Knopflers live version Berlin, its timeless too
Joan Baez was the first singer/songwriter of this song!
Source? Her own website states 'reprise'' joanbaez.com/Discography/BIA.html
Philip R dvfbfvt ta de GC hb gz eh km de tu hay tb te tb kg HD tú id ya yo uffff
www.songfacts.com/detail.php?id=2549 ( you`re incorrect as much as i love JB its written in 1982 about the falklands war my mark knopfler)
I like this version the best. Joan does a fantastic job.
I humbly dedicate this song to my brothers in arms who never came home. A Marine corpsman who survived two tours in country. Ira Lee, Ph.D.
The Spirits of the lost are among us all.
@@dbarrystock Sometimes for a moment or so I believe that but most of the time I know the loss is just that - gone.
Congrats, Dr. Lee, or returning home and making something of yourself. My brothers, twins, both served, one for two years as an FO, first on the ground and then in the air, and the other for 18 months flying slicks. Each made a career of flying choppers, then, first as oil workers in the Middle East, then as forestry workers fighting fires, and lastly as civilian medivacs. I'm as proud of you as I am of them, sir.
I could´ve never imagined that someone could performe this song as well as MK, different version, but an awesome cover
maji1959
Even better!
Right on!
Joan Beaz has an absolutely beautiful voice.
And she has had that voice for almost 60 years.
fucking A hasn't changed at all the true great folk singer . if you are a guitar player you will love diamonds and rust step down chords
yes
Aktueller wie vor 50 Jahren ✊
Thank you Joan for sharing such a beautiful rendition of an extremely inspirational anti-war song for everyone's benefit. God bless everyone from Pat
Excellent rendition of a phenomenal song. I never thought anyone could do it as good as Knofler..this is very good
Joan does a great job with this tune, hauntingly beautiful, wonderful performance..
a beautiful touching song that takes me back to Vietnam 1969, to the people I knew and won't be seeing again on this earth.
Brilliant cover version of the Dire Straits song, exceptional lyrics by Mark Knopfler
I was a little boy when someone gave me a tape with songs from Joan. The memory and especially the chills remains...thank you Joan..... xx
What a beautiful lady. I have been blessed by her voice since the 60's and given many thanks for the experience.
Have been listening to Knopfler sing this for bloody years and can now understand the words
Tonight (Dec 2022) is the first time I heard this version and Baez’ is superior by far
Mark Knopfler can play guitar like few others with a voice which matches Guitar George, often just pure emotion, but Joan Baez's voice is just pure honey dripping with emotion - Knopfler's raw vocals taken somewhere else. Stunning, absolutely breathtaking.
Magnificent. Joan did the song justice. The way she holds the notes. Sweet yet poignant.
Trés grande Dame de la chanson internationale, et quelle carrière, merci pour ce bon moment.
Joan is one of the few singers whose voice never fails to touch my heart.
Linda versão. Joan Baez é maravilhosa, transmite uma emoção particular a música.
Verdad
Thank you so much Joan for your beautiful and touching honoring of Mark Knopfler Brothers in Arms. God bless you and everyone from Patrick
Great Cover Joan ... your like a good wine ... get better with years ...
It's difficult to listen to this version without singing the guitar lines!! Mark Knopfler is a Genious!! :)
The voice of Joan add more feeling to this fantastic song. Great interpretation.
Ouvir essa música sozinho em um dia chuvoso com essa voz é se conecta com a verdade por alguns instantes.
What God given talent is this. To create a window into mans soul through music such as this.
One of the most haunting songs. Takes me back to childhood when I discovered the Dire Straits album on which the recorded this song.
what a great version. Stunning Joan, as usual
GREAT VERSION. I LOVE IT.
Joan use to buy tickets from me at a little bass outlet in Palo Alto. I got to know her a little. She’s a wonderful kind lady. I’m sad I never got to play music with her. She offered to jam a little but I had too much on my plate at the time. The last time I saw her she said take care Tommy, you’re a good egg. I miss her
She's alive and well Tommy ffs 😂
@@tomandaj1 precious memories tommy
She does this song well; with justice...
+Garegh62
Joan's beautiful voice makes up for the absence of Mark's guitar,
however, both versions are beautiful in their own right.
Now here is a musical soul with a reply that cuts through those with a less perceptive one ?
I agree. Both versions are fabulous depending on your music fix for the day or night.
I think the melody and harmony are brilliant in their own right (together with the lyrics!)
Stumbled across this by accident, but why anyone would dislike what is probably the greatest anti-war song ever, escapes me.
On a par with Tom Paxton, check out his stuff, legend.
I saw this after seeing the video clip from SEAL Team where David Boreanz' character walks up the ramp of the Galaxy and takes his spot in the team leader's position as they take the coffin of Bravo 1 off the plane...this is the version they should have used....
I already had heard and have Joan Baez cd;s and LP's.... well I am amazed that I thought a song that was an original is not at all. I love this version this artist has the most amazing sound and clarity. She is an icon.
Everyone in the world should listen to these lyrics and let them sink in. There's Hope.....
Had forgotten the beauty of her voice, thank you
Guapísima Joan Baez , con esa maravillosa voz que te llega a lo más profundo del alma.
la lengua espagnola es asi cerca al corazon......gracias de Allemagna
A truly amazing cover of the original...it brings a lump to my throat when i listen to it.
❤❤❤❤Danke für den schönen Song ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Beautiful lady with a timeless voice
OH WOW! I can only dream of Joan's angelic voice over Mark's devilish guitar!
Canzone bellissima e in questa versione di Joan Baez forse ancora più bella. Meraviglia!
A beautiful rendition of one of my favorite songs.
While I was fighting with my brothers in arms against russia for our independence I listened this song many times. And I remembered my lioved city - Dnipro
Que bellezón de mujer,además canta como los angeles..Bravo Joan Baez
Фантастика! Потрясающий голос! Великолепное исполнение!
This is amazing. Such a talented lady.
started looking at top 10 crying songs and found this in a circle of beauty.
Recuerdo a esta cantante y hoy la redescubro porque mi madre la escuchaba cuando yo era pequeño , que hermosa voz y que lindas letras interpreta!!!!!!!!!!!!
Every time I listen to her version of this unique song, it makes me cry ... I love her so ... And this song echoes even more now ...
Seit 3 Jahrzehnten mit Herz und Hirn bei Ihr und bei mir. Brothers in arms is my live. Wie schön und wunderbar, dass es sie bis heute für mich und uns gibt! We all love she! In Austria, we have so much love to her!
Incredible voice for this beautiful song.
Joan Baez is timeless. Her voice is as relevant today as it was when she started, much like so many of the songs she sings. This one is no exception.
Brano e voce sublimi!
I have loved this lady, her beautiful voice since her beginning in the era of folk music along with Peter,Paul, and Mary, Simon and Garfunkel, and other of the ‘60’s and time of the Viet Nam era and still now in the 2024 year, GOD bless her always
Still brings a tear to my eye. BROTHERS!
She changed the lyric "we have just on world/but we live in different ones" to "why live in different ones?" Changes it from a simple observation to a challenge to mankind. Makes more sense, too.
Quando una voce meravigliosa incontra un testo intenso e profondo, viene fuori una magia.
Magnifique Joan !! Un vrai délice !!!
Beautiful version of a beautiful song by a beautiful woman. Stunning.
That was awesome. I didn't know she covered this.
She knocks this out of the park so beautifully!
Wow. Really great version of The classic Directly Straight song!
Muito linda esta canção na voz suave de Joan Baez!!!
What a wonderfull Cover ...
Absolutely beautiful . Wonderful voice 🥰
A fabulous surprise! Joan singing Mark Knopflers song.