Did Imam Malik and Abu Hanifa Issue Rulings That Contradict Hadith? | Sh. Shadee El Masry

This is NBF 297. Improve your knowledge of Islam by signing up for classes at www.arkview.org/
#allah #muhammadﷺ #muhammad #foryou #nigeria #ramadan #viral #dawah #islamicvideo #ashari #sufi #sufism #podcast #salafi #islam #islamic #islamicstatus #islamicquotes #islamicvideos #sufism #westafrica #africa #muslim #muslimah

[@rg8128]

Well well well. Didn't Shadee go off on Mufti Abu layth for basically saying the same thing....

[@tezooka310]

abu layth isn't a mujtahid

[@rg8128]

@@tezooka310 who said he was?🤦

[@Ibrahim-ho7bu]

Maybe the hadith dont have absolute authority

[@DC-wp6oj]

Its more likely to have better authority as Imam Abu Hanifa and Imam Malik were closer to witnesses maybe only 1 generation removed from the Prophet saws. As opposed to an isnad of 3/4 narrators in a chain.

[@jtb229]

Imam Ahmed had this ruling not the Shafi’s

[@WaqasAli-ct7ly]

Both have this

[@jtb229]

@@WaqasAli-ct7ly No Habibi we don’t have this ruling in the Shafī Madhab.
The Shafī uphold unanimously that the jumuah is wajib and isn’t to be left off for the Eid salah.
As outlined by:
Imam An-Nawawi in his Al-Majmu3
Mughni Al-Muhtaj by Al-Shirbini and more

[@UsamaKhan-xs9do]

A beneficial talk in explaining madhab rulings. However, I do think the Shaykh is downplaying the impact of group mentality and how that can, in certain situations, lead to people rejecting clear evidences in an order to prove their group correct. Extremism in madhabs does exist in some segments and it is not far fetched to think that they'll be ready to perform mental gymnastics to defend their position.
Also, I don't think it is unreasonable to believe that an Imam didn't come across a certain hadith in some matters. For instance, Imam Abu Hanifa lived in an age where hadith compilation was still in its infancy. It's easy for us to say now, living in the 21st century with hadith books easily accessible, that it would be far fetched to think that the Imam wouldn't have come across a certain hadith. In Imam Abu Hanifa's example, hadith was still being compiled and it is likely that certain hadiths did not reach him.

[@hxyzazolchak]

@UsamaKhan-xs9do he admitted to the possibility of that. You have to remember, though, that we have the methodology of these imams that lives on in their students, and they would judge that hadith in light of these methodologies

[@alhassangangu4357]

@UsamaKhan, do you think the madhahib were one imam show? All the 4 imams had their students differed from their imams in some issues. If you were to study the books of Hanafi madhahib, imam Abu Yousuf and imam Muhammad would disagree with their Shaykh, Ibn Quasimodo in some masa’il would disagree with imam Malik, imam Muzani with imam Shafi’i and so on.