One Nation Many Histories | The Paradox of Uniformity | Vikram Sampath | Historian and Author

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 дек 2024
  • #thinkedu2023 #thinkedu
    One Nation Many Histories | The Paradox of Uniformity | Vikram Sampath | Historian and Author

Комментарии •

  • @mayankkhanna2570
    @mayankkhanna2570 Год назад +53

    Vikram Sampath is this Bharat's treasure that we should protect, he is one of the best things to happen in this generation.

    • @tarunsharma5780
      @tarunsharma5780 Год назад

      ruclips.net/video/iO2UfCbrjy8/видео.html

  • @laxmankumardas719
    @laxmankumardas719 Год назад +10

    After retirement, I finished reading books on Savarkar by Vikram Samphath,so exciting and interesting,

  • @shivakumar-pn9bi
    @shivakumar-pn9bi Год назад +22

    Vikram Sampathanna is a gem.
    Let us get enlightened with facts that are being brought to fore today with the suppression of history by our Lutyens.
    Let all the true Bharatiyas protect this nation with all like minded across the all sections without religion barrier without taking an inch of land that doesn’t belong to Akhanda Bharat and live peacefully with the famous anecdote
    VASUDHAIVA KUTUMBAKAM.

  • @mahendranawander9582
    @mahendranawander9582 Год назад +26

    Absolute Brilliance of VIKRAM SAMPATH to be able to put up real history in such convincing words

    • @tarunsharma5780
      @tarunsharma5780 Год назад

      ruclips.net/video/iO2UfCbrjy8/видео.html

  • @surajbsing
    @surajbsing Год назад +20

    Vikram Sampath sir, hats off.

    • @tarunsharma5780
      @tarunsharma5780 Год назад

      ruclips.net/video/iO2UfCbrjy8/видео.html

  • @prakashdas2703
    @prakashdas2703 11 месяцев назад +3

    Im from Assam...glad to know that our history is getting recognition

  • @itanayverma
    @itanayverma Год назад +32

    An absolute gem he is. ❤

    • @tarunsharma5780
      @tarunsharma5780 Год назад

      ruclips.net/video/iO2UfCbrjy8/видео.html

  • @smritidravid9744
    @smritidravid9744 Год назад +11

    Salute excellent welldone vikramji,

  • @dilipchiplunker-h3g
    @dilipchiplunker-h3g 6 месяцев назад

    Absolute Brilliance of VIKRAM SAMPATH to be able to put up real history in such convincing words. Absolutely agree with what you are stating. Applies with what you are stating. Have lived outside India since age 7 and the attitude applies to me . Brillient. Thank you. Have purpose to change the national and local attitudes mental attitudes of the natives.,.

  • @amitpratap7551
    @amitpratap7551 Год назад +6

    Facing the historical truth is the only way to heal, learn the lesson, make a plan for the future and move on. Otherwise it becomes a hidden unhealed wound.

  • @Volv0x.
    @Volv0x. Год назад +5

    I used to skip history lesson and read few chapters just to pass, that's how boring history was. After reading our true history author like you, many more. I find history now so much interesting. I'm from Assam and Saraighat is at a very less distance from my home

    • @pavitraranjanswain4010
      @pavitraranjanswain4010 Год назад +1

      How do you know that it is the true history? Is it from any record of that time? or from any Manuscript of that time.

    • @prakashdas2703
      @prakashdas2703 11 месяцев назад

      Yes it's more old than the mainstream timeline.Every fact us backed up by written documents and oral traditions

  • @pankajsalecha7499
    @pankajsalecha7499 Год назад +2

    Very good sense of Indian history vikramji

  • @subrataroy5948
    @subrataroy5948 Год назад +4

    Yes, tell the truth for the sake of reconciliation and integration.

  • @organicdodia1177
    @organicdodia1177 Год назад +3

    i would love to watch the movie about the naval muitiny, correction "The Last War For Independence".

  • @aniketaggarwal1224
    @aniketaggarwal1224 9 месяцев назад

    This is good journalism. Kudos to maam

  • @agadurapparamachandra8291
    @agadurapparamachandra8291 Год назад +1

    Great Sampath

  • @padmanabharaju329
    @padmanabharaju329 Год назад +1

    Truly Bharathiya sir

  • @GautamMazumderArchitect
    @GautamMazumderArchitect Год назад +1

    I think we should also have a glimpse of the British civilization during the same time frame.

  • @agadurapparamachandra8291
    @agadurapparamachandra8291 Год назад

    Great programme

  • @HemanthMB
    @HemanthMB Год назад +10

    Moderator is not letting the Vikram to complete.

  • @parulsharma1392
    @parulsharma1392 Год назад +5

  • @swaradanargolkar9884
    @swaradanargolkar9884 Год назад +13

    She is always biased.
    Watch her interviewing Vivek Agnihotri. She being a kashmiri how try to trap, blame vivek for toxic atmosphere after kashmir files.

  • @rishabtalawat
    @rishabtalawat Год назад

    🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @Lostcountryman800
    @Lostcountryman800 Год назад

    People must see a British video called Mountbatten…it’s his sort of biography where they spell out who were British friends in India at that time.

  • @Lostcountryman800
    @Lostcountryman800 Год назад +2

    Request government to engage historians like Sampat sir to rewrite Bharat’s history. Stop eulogising traitors and invaders. Give due credit to our heroes and make us a proud race of glorious past. We must know the dark era of slavery to Mughals and then whites their atrocities and period of shame to serve them and not treat it with pride that they are superior. Expose the treachery of the ones who for their own benefits fed us with false narratives

  • @megnathpm
    @megnathpm Год назад

    That might be reason people who live souther part of India don’t even bother to read history books in school. At least I was not interested at all. It is just for exam.. I love our stories like Mahabharata and Ramayana. The culture is fantastic.. they have included all the history in every festival.. Still it is great to learn about sic Islamic and British rulers.

  • @sumitsuri256
    @sumitsuri256 Год назад

    what happend in history and past the so called peaceful people still feel proud of it and have the same psyche...

  • @maitri74
    @maitri74 Год назад +2

    The wolves are shedding wolff's tears in the same land they tried to conquer, from Rama to Modi and Shah. What is the agenda of Kashmiri named Kaveri and Maha bhaerath chonicler which ralke of two invasion Arjun and karan.

  • @biswajeetdassh9305
    @biswajeetdassh9305 Год назад

    🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️

  • @pavitraranjanswain4010
    @pavitraranjanswain4010 Год назад

    If you ask the incident of War between Kanchipuram and Kalinga, People of Kanchipuram will give their version, People of Puri will give their version in absence of any contemporary diaries.

    • @tarunsharma5780
      @tarunsharma5780 Год назад

      ruclips.net/video/iO2UfCbrjy8/видео.html

  • @aniketaggarwal1224
    @aniketaggarwal1224 9 месяцев назад

    10:45 And that is used now to justify Khotestanis 😢

  • @tangofan63
    @tangofan63 Год назад +2

    Why does a hindu have to stick his neck out and say, that a Muslim living today is not responsible for Ghazni and Ghouri...
    The fact is that a lot of Muslims living in India today also feel extremely proud, of the áchievements" of their ''ancestors'' like Ghouri and Ghazni...
    If these invaders are the ancestors of.. these muslims already have had at least 10-15 generations to apologise for the sins of their forefather! Have they done so..
    We are not going to get any healing unless this happens..

  • @umstrangeguy9581
    @umstrangeguy9581 10 месяцев назад

    Vikram Sampath is a living Gems

  • @maitri74
    @maitri74 Год назад +1

    vikram Read Tamil history the first war of independence polygar wars.

  • @AnkitSharma-od7vg
    @AnkitSharma-od7vg Год назад

    & here I got one of the dialogues of अक्षय कुमार 's new movie😅
    अब आप मेरी कहानी सुनो 😂🤣
    Bollywood don't have good story writers even today 🤣😂

  • @SN-xo3vv
    @SN-xo3vv Год назад +1

    The reason about the differential treatment meted to Christians and Muslims is that Christians do not associate their identity with Britishers . Unlike Muslims who are proud to declare that they are kith or kin of the invading Muslim marauders. Just see how they glorify acts by Tipu and Aurangazeb

  • @raghuka4916
    @raghuka4916 Год назад +1

    We should praise our ancestors who defended our faith
    If we talk about faith every one will understand
    You are too soft on this woman. She always supports Lutyens

  • @anandaprasadaraoappasani1923
    @anandaprasadaraoappasani1923 Год назад +1

    The young lady who asked the question seems to be vague in her thoughts. Regarding reservations, she is still obsessed with caste based reservations of different religions. Pathetic. Aren't there deprived students in the so called forward castes? With such ill informed mind and without a broad spectrum knowledge of present day realities, we will not move ahead.

  • @babahanuman83
    @babahanuman83 7 месяцев назад

    Science or politics: fanatics never good for a nation! For a diverse nation like India a curse. Think about it.

  • @rishichandroo3852
    @rishichandroo3852 Год назад

    as a historian can he say openly and truthfully... who brought in caste system.....which still terrorizes .commoners..........

    • @rishabtalawat
      @rishabtalawat Год назад

      who brought in caste system??and who still terrorizes?? pls let us know

    • @keithhunt5328
      @keithhunt5328 Год назад

      You're a blot on kashmiri pandits

  • @srinivaskatti9137
    @srinivaskatti9137 Год назад

    If muslims r hurt on critìçism of mughźls , it meàns they r perßuiñg th polixies

  • @Melody-uv5jz
    @Melody-uv5jz Год назад

    If this man is a historian, then everyone is a historian

    • @ambhat3953
      @ambhat3953 Год назад

      thats why he is invited there and you getting orga##m over a keyboard

    • @moumitamukherjee5957
      @moumitamukherjee5957 Год назад

      Tujhe q mirchi lagi be leftist ki nazayez aulad 😂😂😂

  • @realisticweirdo
    @realisticweirdo Год назад +39

    Definitely a biased interviewer.

    • @SeekerWay
      @SeekerWay Год назад +9

      How? Just because you don't like facts and love colonized views doesn't makes anyone biased

    • @realisticweirdo
      @realisticweirdo Год назад +24

      @@SeekerWay Nope. I agree with what Vikram Sampath says. I'm just trying to point out that the lady conducting the interview is trying to be dense on purpose.

    • @pwnweb5734
      @pwnweb5734 Год назад +17

      who else invites great historians like vikram sir to their show.. Rubbish kumar? Dhruv tati?

    • @mowiththeflow4446
      @mowiththeflow4446 Год назад +4

      Not every interview has to be combative/ confrontational. I think the interviewer did establish an atmosphere for the guest to speak freely.

    • @ChintanYoutubeStar
      @ChintanYoutubeStar Год назад +3

      I wouldn't call it biased, Bias is not the right term to use here. What they together have tried to do is to revive the true history of Bharat to educate, to bring awareness and to heal hindus who are hurt because of all the atrocities happened in the past.

  • @raghuka4916
    @raghuka4916 Год назад

    You want Holocaust to be remembered forever but want to push all this information under carpet shame

  • @pavitraranjanswain4010
    @pavitraranjanswain4010 Год назад

    This happens because Indian do not like to write diaries . Even each IAS officers keep their diaries and incidents, minute history of Bharat will be kept for future.
    In the past The rulers of Indian sub-continent never used to keep records of their reigns. Only Madalapanji of Puri used to keep records of incidents affecting the Temple or the people around Puri.
    But it is not in Public Domain.

    • @viswanathanseshadri1047
      @viswanathanseshadri1047 Год назад

      Not really about records being kept. Even if written records and diaries are kept, those are not proof about the accuracy or correctness thereof. 200 years down the line when people look back for "written records", they will find plenty of written records n the form of newspapers and other media reports charging Hindus with committing genocide on Muslims. But that won't be a correct record of events would it be?
      Frankly as the Indian Evidence Act notes a written record is proof of its contents but not to the truth of the contents. Truth is something that has to be discerned. And this is where we seem to be faltering and where the corrective action can be applied.
      Forget about records about past events, are you able to look around and correctly discern what is happening right now in the present? When Islam and Christianity accuse of Hindu majoritarianism and majoritarian oppression, they are basically carrying on war against Hindus by other means. Are you able to see that ? Why are Hindus having to do this explaining? You explain one set of events your enemies mov on to the next event, for even they know that the allegations being levelled against Hindus are false. It is Hindus who take them seriously and attempt to proffer an explanation.

    • @ambhat3953
      @ambhat3953 Год назад

      it only shows your ignorance of history

    • @pavitraranjanswain4010
      @pavitraranjanswain4010 Год назад

      @@ambhat3953 : Can you refer the libraries where the written diaries or written chronicles of various kings of India is kept. I can tell you about the Kings of Kalinga/Utkal/Puri. Their major incidents are recorded in Madala Panji which is kept at Puri Temple. Even present day events are recorded and added to the ancient collections.
      Can you give me details of the manuscript and their locations?
      If I am ignorant, please enlighten me by giving reference of the manuscripts.
      By telling simple qualitative statement like "Ignorance of History" serve the purpose of WhatsApp University.

    • @ambhat3953
      @ambhat3953 Год назад

      @@pavitraranjanswain4010 why is it my job to give you reference? What do you think of yourself ? If you want to get rid of ignorance, you search for it. I'm not here to give gyaan to unworthy candidates

    • @pavitraranjanswain4010
      @pavitraranjanswain4010 Год назад

      @@ambhat3953 : Because your qualitative statement comes from ignorance. "it only shows your ignorance of history". "I'm not here to give gyaan to unworthy candidates". These are the sentences used by ignorant, uncultured WhatsApp university Scholars of Brahmin Origins. They do not have any historical reference. They only have different Provachans as reference.

  • @agadurapparamachandra8291
    @agadurapparamachandra8291 Год назад

    Great programme