RollingStone is infamously, almost never right, and it took the BlackLivesMatter protests before they finally elevated this musical&political powerhouse to #1... Better VERY late then never though, right?
I don't see how to turn a subjective thing into an "objective" statement. There's no best album of all time. All these lists are opinions and preferences. That said, the best album of all time is definitely What's Going On. Or maybe Blonde on Blonde. Or maybe The White Album. No, it's Blue. Or Monk/Trane. Oh, I don't know.
When Marvin Gaye said he was touched by God making this album, I totally believe him. I can hear something celestial,universal in his songs.this whole album is a truly masterpiece.great work with your channel.love it!
"how sweet it is to be loved by you" was a staple in james taylor's set list, and a fixture of my childhood. so i was well primed to enjoy marvin's work in adulthood. FANTASTIC work this week! (and expert accompaniment by kitty)
I really really really loved your breakdown of this great record. In addition to the historical, cultural, and personal background, I loved the 3 musical demonstrations (vocals, bass, and keys). Simply awesome.
War is not the answer! ❤ So inspiring. Marvin's demise was so senseless 💔 but this album is so inspiring. Makes me wanna holler. Great video. Glad I stumbled on your She Said clip and now I am a fan of your channel
Right on, Fathom, right on! What a pleasure... If you want to get a diamond from coal you must put it under enormous pressure. I think most people would not read the state of Marvin's life at that time and think 'sign me up!' but from all he was going through the world certainly gained one if its most precious gems...
Glad I'm not the only person laughing at Marvin's football aspirations. We are all semi delusional or aspiring but celebrity adds a heavy layer of crazy or kneejerk to your thoughts, I would assume.
Excellent question! I got a Belafonte album after I passed the letter B! I will definitely have to go back at some point and revisit, because I love his work.
I don’t want to minimize the insightful musical analysis and spendid commentary, but let’s just admit that “Vinyl Friday” is basically a weekly cat video with bonus content.
one of the greatest singers. also at this conjuncture of politics and popular culture, a brave musician. the examples and highlighting of the significance of call and response music was a strong point in the video. james jamerson is almost as cool as marvin ! good reasons for claiming this great album was the greatest of all time but surely when you think of contenders it would have to eliminate to reach that lofty summit: nah surely? sometimes rolling stone is so far up its own.. anyway. the belief that god maybe could give the answer is a weakness imo. that's not being dismissive of the music but it's a building block of the message. there was i think an agreement at the conclusion of vinyl monday vinyl friday cinematic universe crossover event ( the chance of me remembering the correct title are a big 0️⃣) and it was that passion was the essential ingredient in music ( hey maybe in everything). it's in what's going on in spades, it overflows in your head when the sound isn't physically there. the album is a triumph and i get the passion playing everytime the needle goes into those grooves.
Spot-on review, Alan! I'm also not certain it would take my vote for the GOAT...there are a LOT of great albums out there, so it has a lot of competition. But likely the top 50! I'm glad the call and response was a highlight - it's certainly something I enjoy talking about; I just hoped it would translate to also being something good to listen to!
Were the readers of Rolling Stone correct? Is this the Greatest Album of All Time?!
why not? but for me why? charlotte hatherley got two votes btw
@@alanclayton9277 she is pretty spectacular. I have you to thank for the introduction.
RollingStone is infamously, almost never right, and it took the BlackLivesMatter protests before they finally elevated this musical&political powerhouse to #1... Better VERY late then never though, right?
I don't see how to turn a subjective thing into an "objective" statement. There's no best album of all time. All these lists are opinions and preferences. That said, the best album of all time is definitely What's Going On. Or maybe Blonde on Blonde. Or maybe The White Album. No, it's Blue. Or Monk/Trane. Oh, I don't know.
That is how you teach music.
I am stunned to find out that bass was being played by a person so drunk he had to lie down.
When Marvin Gaye said he was touched by God making this album, I totally believe him. I can hear something celestial,universal in his songs.this whole album is a truly masterpiece.great work with your channel.love it!
Great episode! I am an activist and a musician. Your vidéos are good for me on both fronts. Thanks!
"how sweet it is to be loved by you" was a staple in james taylor's set list, and a fixture of my childhood. so i was well primed to enjoy marvin's work in adulthood. FANTASTIC work this week! (and expert accompaniment by kitty)
The moment of return to the verse after the B section is just glorious !
Get it , lil mama 💃🕺
I really really really loved your breakdown of this great record. In addition to the historical, cultural, and personal background, I loved the 3 musical demonstrations (vocals, bass, and keys). Simply awesome.
I loved this song for decades. But after seeing this knowledgeable, enthusiastic and rousing review, I love the song even more!
Excellent bass demonstration -- now try it lying down!
I love your videos 🎶
War is not the answer! ❤ So inspiring. Marvin's demise was so senseless 💔 but this album is so inspiring. Makes me wanna holler. Great video. Glad I stumbled on your She Said clip and now I am a fan of your channel
Another wonderful review, and always fantastic to see real emotion.
That was an amazing episode. You are amazing. Thank you!
Great video, I love how you go into great detail about every aspect of the song. This channel deserves way more followers then it has.
First time viewer. That was a fantastic analysis and review. Kept me interested through out the whole video. Great job!
Right on, Fathom, right on! What a pleasure... If you want to get a diamond from coal you must put it under enormous pressure. I think most people would not read the state of Marvin's life at that time and think 'sign me up!' but from all he was going through the world certainly gained one if its most precious gems...
Glad I'm not the only person laughing at Marvin's football aspirations. We are all semi delusional or aspiring but celebrity adds a heavy layer of crazy or kneejerk to your thoughts, I would assume.
More Beatles and piano playing cat, please!
Excellent!
Wow Nancy! Now I gotta go listen to "What'sGoingOn" a couple times... Thanx
also harry belafonte episode when
Excellent question! I got a Belafonte album after I passed the letter B! I will definitely have to go back at some point and revisit, because I love his work.
you should do that jorge ben jor song sometime but i'm more than happy to have you tackle marvin's brilliant 1971 track! thank you.
Oh ... Of course "I Heard It Through the Grapevine" is the greatest breakup song. Should have thought of that as a response to your last.
I don’t want to minimize the insightful musical analysis and spendid commentary, but let’s just admit that “Vinyl Friday” is basically a weekly cat video with bonus content.
Busted!
one of the greatest singers. also at this conjuncture of politics and popular culture, a brave musician.
the examples and highlighting of the significance of call and response music was a strong point in the video. james jamerson is almost as cool as marvin !
good reasons for claiming this great album was the greatest of all time but surely when you think of contenders it would have to eliminate to reach that lofty summit: nah surely? sometimes rolling stone is so far up its own..
anyway. the belief that god maybe could give the answer is a weakness imo. that's not being dismissive of the music but it's a building block of the message. there was i think an agreement at the conclusion of vinyl monday vinyl friday cinematic universe crossover event ( the chance of me remembering the correct title are a big 0️⃣) and it was that passion was the essential ingredient in music ( hey maybe in everything). it's in what's going on in spades, it overflows in your head when the sound isn't physically there. the album is a triumph and i get the passion playing everytime the needle goes into those grooves.
Spot-on review, Alan! I'm also not certain it would take my vote for the GOAT...there are a LOT of great albums out there, so it has a lot of competition. But likely the top 50!
I'm glad the call and response was a highlight - it's certainly something I enjoy talking about; I just hoped it would translate to also being something good to listen to!
@@fathommusicnzwow thanks.
hey i think you're missing that bass player who plays the by now iconic green bass. honestly, people can be so ungenerous.