Nic Pizzolatto on Casting Mahershala Ali in 'True Detective' | Close Up

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
  • Nic Pizzolatto ('True Detective') joins Close Up with The Hollywood Reporter's Drama Showrunners Roundtable to talk about casting Mahershala Ali in a role that was originally written as a white role, miscalculating fans reactions to Season 3's plot, and more.
    #TrueDetective #NicoPizzolatto #CloseUp #HollywoodReporter #THR
    Subscribe for Roundtables, Box Office Reports, & More! ►► bit.ly/THRSubsc...
    Stay in The Know With all Things Hollywood, Subscribe to THR News! ►► bit.ly/Sub2THRNews

Комментарии • 53

  • @IsaaqAttack
    @IsaaqAttack 5 лет назад +46

    Thank you John Singleton for your art! RIP.

  • @adaku75
    @adaku75 5 лет назад +114

    I love seeing black people in roles where the character is not screaming, I am black. Mahersala played such a full-bodied human. He was sexual, intellectual, weak at times, he knew racism existed. I just loved him in this role!

    • @ashellything
      @ashellything 5 лет назад +4

      Agreed!

    • @wagzel
      @wagzel 4 года назад +3

      I'm white and saw the same thing.

  • @cheekyboy5000
    @cheekyboy5000 5 лет назад +80

    Ali has this huge gravitas about his presence. You believe his characters.

  • @kudabeen
    @kudabeen 5 лет назад +34

    Mahershala absolute KILLED this role too...glad they got out of their way to see the possibility and made it work.

  • @GOD999MODE
    @GOD999MODE 5 лет назад +20

    True Detective S01 and S03 were awesome.

  • @missnevenka
    @missnevenka 5 лет назад +7

    RIP, John Singleton.
    Nic Pizzolatto is smart AND gorgeous. What a combination.

  • @cynguzman
    @cynguzman 5 лет назад +31

    Best decision ever. What a great actor and performance

  • @gmpm
    @gmpm 5 лет назад +33

    TD season 3 was pretty good - bordering on great. Performances undoubtedly carried the season. Can I also say that Stephen Dorff isn't getting enough love. The man was brilliant in his own right, played the character perfectly. Both Mahershala and Stephen complimented each other so well. Somehow, and quite ultimately though - at least for me personally - the season fell a bit short. Something about the story, the way it culminated, was somewhat anti-climactic. I think season 1 was just so insanely good, that everything else just doesn't measure up; we always want to contrast and compare with what has come before. TD has been it's own double-edged sword. Still, by TV standards TD is still miles ahead of the vast majority of programming.

    • @ROGUESPIRIT_
      @ROGUESPIRIT_ 4 года назад

      His acting was painful, always pulling the same angry face.

    • @511dydy
      @511dydy 4 года назад +1

      Pizzolatto's writing is overrated. Too pretentious

    • @yggdrasil2
      @yggdrasil2 Год назад

      I think season 3 might've been written to intentionally contrast the ending to season 1. In the first season, a series of murders and kidnappings turned out to be the results of a conspiracy with dark, occult undertones, which is horrifying but it still gives you the sense that the events were controlled. In season 3 on the other hand, the disappearance turned out to be the result of a series of very tragic coincidences, which in a way is even more nihilistic and depressing than season 3. However regardless of the answer to the final question at the end, we do see evidence that some of the people affected by the tragedy managed to move on to happier lives were they help the community in the ways they can.

  • @Beatle-Byrd
    @Beatle-Byrd 4 года назад +4

    Petition to get this guy to write a Philip Marlowe movie

  • @unknownxyz7
    @unknownxyz7 4 года назад +17

    Please bring Jake Gyllenhaal to season 4, he does a very good job as a detective character. Prisoners (2007) could easily have been a season of True Detective.

  • @JimNortonsAlcoholism
    @JimNortonsAlcoholism 5 лет назад +4

    He looks like Beck Bennett from SNL

  • @c450
    @c450 5 лет назад +7

    RIP

    • @cheekyboy5000
      @cheekyboy5000 5 лет назад +3

      Took me a second - Course, John Singleton RIP.

  • @ninaborovsky9992
    @ninaborovsky9992 Год назад +1

    Black Heritage Month

  • @mstoj1386
    @mstoj1386 5 лет назад +3

    I loved season 3!

  • @511dydy
    @511dydy 4 года назад +2

    Pizzolatto should be grateful that his actors did a top notch job. His script is overrated.

    • @heymeRaj
      @heymeRaj 3 года назад

      He plagiarized too. I hate when I repeat that to people but it's true.

    • @khalil4030
      @khalil4030 3 года назад

      @@heymeRaj he plagiarized? From who?

    • @hegeliandianetik2009
      @hegeliandianetik2009 3 года назад

      @@khalil4030 he'll probably say Ligotti's 'Conspiracy against the human race' for season 1 of TD

    • @lumoc.
      @lumoc. 3 года назад

      @@khalil4030 He also plagiarized an Alan Moore's Top Ten quote for the ending.

  • @eyecandyfinalgirl810
    @eyecandyfinalgirl810 2 года назад

    Plagiarism

  • @dylanthurgood5931
    @dylanthurgood5931 3 года назад

    Well said Nic

  • @alanvenzze11
    @alanvenzze11 5 лет назад

    Genius

  • @narutoenzo
    @narutoenzo 5 лет назад +13

    Nic is an amazing writer and storyteller !!
    All 3 seasons of True Detective where fantastic in my opinion. Name me any show with better character development in just 8 episodes.
    Most shows take 8 seasons and you still learn nothing about the characters.
    Also 4:09 is basically what happend to Game Of Thrones, but those two writers just showed they are not actually writers at all.
    Just show runners.

    • @shesemerald2011
      @shesemerald2011 5 лет назад +1

      Enzo Bagijn Season 2 of True Detective is unmentionable. There was no flow or empathy for any character as season 1 showed. Im starting S3 and will comment accordingly.

  • @pedrobarragan746
    @pedrobarragan746 5 лет назад +6

    Sam Esmail staring at him thinking: "I wish I was as cool as you Nic" Seriously, when Elliot Alderson talks about the world's flaws Rust Cohle comes around and shakes his hair and says: "You don't know half of it kid"

  • @stephdrake2521
    @stephdrake2521 5 лет назад +2

    Rip John Singleton. Damm this looks so real ... like they just made it.

  • @TinaTr84
    @TinaTr84 5 лет назад +5

    Ali was absolutely superb in this role, but the third season as a whole kind of let me down. Ali's performance was the only draw for me.

  • @dschrads13
    @dschrads13 5 лет назад

    Finds oil once, then thinks he's a sheik

  • @extenebrislux
    @extenebrislux 5 лет назад +6

    most overrated writer in the biz.
    him and D&D.

    • @marko96
      @marko96 5 лет назад +16

      lol wtf are you talking about, D&D are exact opposite from Nic. He literary said in the video that his works focus more on the human being rather than the retarded and shocking twists.

    • @anthonywarren9885
      @anthonywarren9885 5 лет назад +10

      Stop trolling loser.

    • @Osamah0
      @Osamah0 4 года назад

      Guys chill the fuck out what's wrong with him sharing an opinion

  • @remainselusive1
    @remainselusive1 5 лет назад +1

    Mahershala Ali is the most over-hyped actor in recent memory. I've seen marble busts with more expressiveness.

    • @ineverswag
      @ineverswag 5 лет назад +14

      Big lies

    • @Osamah0
      @Osamah0 4 года назад

      Anthony Warren
      😂😂 ur so stupid

  • @vomitedshit
    @vomitedshit 5 лет назад +3

    probably the worst casting i've ever seen in a high-level production,
    he almost made the show unwatchable

    • @DK_75
      @DK_75 5 лет назад +1

      Casting of Mahershala Ali?

    • @jacobmorales323
      @jacobmorales323 5 лет назад +6

      Unfortunately you’re a minority, I hope it’s not cause you’re a racist but it looks to be leaning that way

    • @eme.261
      @eme.261 5 лет назад +6

      @@jacobmorales323 -- FORTUNATELY, he is in the minority. As for him being racist? Who knows. But to believe Mahershala can't act? Dude is definitely a frigging idiot.

    • @Musso8771
      @Musso8771 Год назад +1

      Ya he was horrible. Not even the great Stephen Dorff could save him.

    • @vomitedshit
      @vomitedshit Год назад

      @@jacobmorales323 it's because he's a terrible actor, but continue being a racist yourself