"CHARLOTTE TILBURY IS OVERRATED"
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Over the years on my channel, I've found a lot of ways to assert that Charlotte Tilbury's makeup was overrated, overhyped and overpriced. But I've also had UNCANNILY bad luck testing her products out, in ways that weren't always the fault of the products themselves. So I decided to overcome my cynicism, spend a TON of money on Charlotte Tilbury's website, and see for myself if the viral products and the enduring HYPE (read: TIK TOK) is actually legit.
What's on my face & mentioned:
Charlotte Tilbury Magic Cream: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Reusable Mask: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Charlotte's Beautiful Skin Foundation (Neutral 1): go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Charlotte's Beautiful Skin Brightening Concealer: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Hollywood Flawless Filter: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Filmstar Bronze & Glow: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Bronzer:
Charlotte Tilbury Beautiful Skin Sunkissed Glow Bronzer: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Exaggereyes: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Eyes to Mesmerize: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Light Wonder Foundation: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury AirBrush Flawless Powder: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Beauty Light Wand Trio: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Brightening Powder: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury PILLOW TALK PUSH UP LASHES! MASCARA DUO (the burgundy one): go.magik.ly/ml...
Persona Cosmetics Eyeliner (PLUM): shop-links.co/... Causemetics Liquid Lash Extensions Mascara (Crystal): prf.hn/l/rpOOloe
My headband: go.magik.ly/ml...
My sweater: go.magik.ly/ml...
My jewelry: www.analuisa.com code KACKIE10
Other Discount Links:
10% off BK Beauty Brushes with code KACKIE10: bit.ly/3ATiMOQ
20% off at ATHR Beauty: shrsl.com/3p1gc (Code KACKIE)
$10 off at Beauty Pie: bit.ly/3kReoLQ (Code KACKIESENTME)
$25 off at Daily Harvest: bit.ly/38WXVQq
$15 off at Jungmaven: RWRD.IO/J4Z6JZP
10% off at Salt New York: bit.ly/2OvuWIs code (KACKIE10)
10% off at Glossier: glossier.79ic8...
10% off at Thrive Causemetics: prf.hn/l/6kR3BZg
20% off at ICONOLAB: bit.ly/2YV2MJE Use code KACKIE
1 month FREE at Rocksbox: www.talkable.c...
$2,500 off your complete smile makeover at The Cosmetic Dentists of Austin: Mention my name on your first call!
FTC Disclosure: This video is not sponsored. Some items have been gifted. This video contains affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission for purchases made through my links.
![Run Away - Tzuyu(TWICE) ツウィ 쯔위 [Music Bank] | KBS WORLD TV 240906](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KnHNNyAYiu0/mqdefault.jpg)
I was turned off by this brand early on because every product I tried looked orange, patchy and sparkly on my fair skin. It took me back to the vampy orange “it girl” makeup that pervaded every US high school in the early 2000s… the stuff that paired well with the Victoria Secret body spray that smelled like you were running a brothel inside of a coconut. I guess that’s not a vibe I care to return to 😂 That or, more likely, CT makeup just isn’t a fit for my skin tone.
😂 Running a brothel inside a coconut! Someone was wearing that scent vibe on an AIRPLANE yesterday 😩. Thank goodness for masks 🤷🏻♀️ Great description for a horrendous scent.
“Running a brothel in a coconut” has me CACKLING💀💀💀
You guys weren’t in the spell of the love? Ha! Only worse smell is axe
“Running a bother out of a coconut” - loved this! You gave me a good laugh for the start of my day! And I bought plenty of those VS body sprays way back when. Apparently I enjoyed smelling like a slutty tropical fruit in my younger days😎
Same.
I also agree. Some good products but mostly they are mediocre... pretty packaging, striking names, and some pretty colors. Notice that EVERYTHING (well, almost) is extremely warm toned. Even the cool toned lipsticks have a strong orange base. Pillow talk looks like peanut butter on me.
I like pillow talk on me, but for all her other products I agree. Very orangey, patchy, especially her other nude lipsticks.
Pillow talk looks straight up grey on me 😂 it makes me look like a corpse
The Magic Cream has been broken down by skincare experts and it is one of the most criminally over-priced products on the market. I can understand the cult appeal though because of the lore around it and because a lot of people who use makeup and don't really worry much about skincare can benefit from using a basic moisturizer. It's great that she popularized hydrating before doing anything with makeup, which is not something people were doing back in the day. Now everyone is moisturizing before they put makeup on...Also: her packaging rocks. There is an old school Hollywood glam vibe from it that just makes it feel expensive and exclusive...I think I buried the lead on this but, your strategy for choosing under-eye concealer is impeccable. I have noticed as I get older that very bright concealer does more harm than good. I've been using the wayne goss foundation that matches my skin, a thin layer over a little color correction and it does the trick. A light hand with powder and I usually try to have quite blown out eyeliner anyway. The not perfected look, with a little help is my friend.
HAHAHAHAAHA criminally overpriced is so savage
I bought a trial size and I hated it 👎🏼
Wayne Goss didn't work for me, gave it to my friend who said the color was good but saw it in her bin! Need I say more?
I think the fact that her personality is so interwoven into it has made it really easy for me to avoid ever buying anything from this brand. There so many awful testimonials about working for her during pull-up-for-change that I just picture her screaming at staff every time I’m tempted to give her my money. (I’m sure tonnes of brand owners are like this, they just aren’t so integral to the marketing)
Congratulations Kackie on 70k 🎉 such a big milestone it is so well deserved !! Thank you for your hard work honesty and amazing personality ❤ wish you many more subbies 🎉
I cackled when you talked about the Flawless Filter as foundation. I 100% wear it as a foundation to this day.
Same!!
hey kackie I’m gen-z and I love your content major big sister/older cousin vibes
AW THANK YOU
Another Gen Z - I get the same vibes!
@@amelie4363 backing this xx
I'm asking you because you said your gen-z so I was hoping you'd know: I was born in 1992, I'm 30, I'm I gen-z? 😂 I can't figure it out on Google...
@@fleetwoodmacncheese4159 you're fully a millennial hun!
(Edit: I just realized the 'hun' there could be seen as really patronizing. I was talking to my sister when commenting, and it's a term of endearment in that context and just spilled over. Fwiw, I'm a female millennial and it was said with love!)
To me RMS Strobe is the better version of CT Oyster Pearl. It's a little brighter but quite similar in color, much more metallic and dimensional, and does NOT crease at all!
Once I'm able to sell huge paintings like Auntie Kackie maybe I'll feel confident I can afford to wear Charlotte Tilbury skincare. I'll stay in my elf lane til then lmao
OMG, that thumbnail. I love it! TGIF fam ❤️
And yes, I was here for high-intensity blush gate. 😂 Wait, burgundy mascara?! I need!
Congrats on 70k 🎉
Also I despise that website. It’s so off putting I can’t purchase anything on there
BLUH it's a mess!
@@kackie a Virgos nightmare. Why are you putting an exclamation there and then keeping the next word lowercase 😵💫
Love this! I have had no luck with any of her products that I’ve tried - except for her pressed setting powder which I do like because it works well for my dry skin. I used the Flawless Filter (used up the whole bottle) and never felt it made my skin look any better with or without foundation. Every lipstick and liner I tried was so dry (only tried the mattes) I could not use them and I love matte lipsticks. Just not CT matte lipsticks. Her mascara smudged terribly on me and her magic cream worked no magic on me. However, based on how much I like her pressed face powder I’ve always wanted to try the Filmstar compact because the shade looks nice and cool toned. But I’m tired of being disappointed by my CT purchases.
#1 “overhyped makeup, mad I spent money on it” was a Charlotte Tilbury eyeshadow quad (the green one-Rebel). I can’t tell if I just got a dud or what, but everyone else completely raves about them. I did hear somewhere that they were reformulated shortly after I got it, and I’ve since tried some of her other color cosmetics that I actually liked quite a bit, but I have enough eyeshadow that I know I love already, so that isn’t something I’m willing to retry.
All of that said, I really appreciate your point about how her branding strategy has essentially become de rigeur. I hadn’t really thought about that, but CT really did pave the way for other brands, especially makeup artist-owned ones, to do what they do.
I'm a Daria by nature. I feel like I'm deconstructing ennui on a continual basis, so I can relate to your opening sentiment 🤓🖤
Right??
I've tried around 40 Charlotte Tilbury products (counting different shades in the same range) and I love 1/3 of them, i like 1/3 of them and the remaining 1/3 are pretty bad or unusable for me. Some things were gifts or things handed down to me by my mum so it wasn't all bought with my preferences in mind, and the stuff I picked myself tends to be the stuff I like more. I think her base products are okay at best (the setting spray is very effective though), and her mascaras, brow products etc. are unremarkable. Her lipsticks have some nice nuanced colours, but formulas can be hit or miss, the eyeshadows are pretty but only worth the price if you can find a quad/palette where you'll use all the shades, and her blushes and highlighters tend to be well formulated. It's not the sort of brand where trying everything is worth it, but there are some unique shades and innovative formulas, these are just becoming more readily available and at cheaper price points now
Omg I tried the airbrush flawless foundation and it had such a strong smell of floral Raid bug spray I could not get past it lol and I think I’m the only person to smell that because nobody else mentioned the scent in it 😂
I’ve been enjoying the rare beauty foundation brush (ya the one we all bought but don’t use anymore😅) with the CT cream bronzer. I find it gives a really smooth application and you can control the placement to give a nice sculpted contour effect.
I think the Magic Cream is the only product I've tried from the brand, and I was underwhelmed, especially given its price point. There are moisturizers out there that I really like and cost less.
Yeah!! I felt like I already had thick foundation on when I used the magic cream , it was not pleasant
I just want you to know how much I appreciate the video photo 😂 I opened RUclips and instantly busted out laughing.
My favorite CT product is definitely the unisex healthy glow. Shelbey Wilson sold me on it and often I skip foundation when I wear it!
THANK 👏🏼 YOU 👏🏼 FOR 👏🏼 STATING 👏🏼 THE 👏🏼 TRUTH 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 (I liked her products better when she was creating for Tom Ford)
Okay but THANK YOU for calling out the CT website, what on god's green earth is going on over there
I do not have any CT products and never will. Overrated and way overpriced. Same for WA.
I was there for high intensity blush kerfuffle 😂 I remember us all like 🧐 at the label. Was SO weird!
The only thing I’ve been able to justify to but from her is the bronzer (powder) because it’s not too orange for my neutral tones
I agree this brand is very hit or miss. But that said some of my favorite products of all time are by this brand. She does powders very well. Her bronzers, blushes and highlighters are amazing. Her eyeshadows skew way too orange on me and I’m allergic to most of her creamy products but her lipstick colors are very dialed in and blend well with my skin tone and many others.
I agree with starting off with a luminous concealer! I got the mini Flawless filter in a shade too light so my new favourite thing to do is mix it with my concealer. It means I can powder and it is still stunning.
PEAK Soft Autumn "natural" makeup! That plum eyeliner, rather than a starker one? Clinched it 😁❤
One thing I must disagree on-the humbly-named Magic Serum Crystal Elixer is a HG for mature skin. I purchase it over and over like a drugstore product. I really notice a difference, maybe it takes more of a commitment (with cumulative effects over time)? I love the smell of it-like a nourishing, natural high end spa. ❤ Maybe pop a question mark on the end of the title, because you’re totally not bashing the brand. You’re curating what is worth it. Great content, great thumbnail 😂, you ROCK! Congrats on 70k. You’re headed to 1MM.
Yeah I totally remember when u got that blush bc I got the same one. I definitely ordered the regular but somehow ended up with the intense also. And it doesn’t say intense. I still have it and it is pushed to the back of an ikea drawer bc I can’t make it work either 🙃
The rabid sex kitten aesthetic of this brand has always made me barf. It stinks. I feel the same about Victorias Secret Lobotomy. I am not my WAP.
I only have her Smokey eyes are forever palette and shadows as beautiful as they are, NARS and Nabla are even more beautiful! Nabla for matte shadows and OUTRAGEOUS SPARKLE from NARS✨
Nothing but praise for your amazing ability to compare the effects of skincare to a Katamari ball. 🤣
THANK YOU FOR APPRECIATING MY UNIQUE GIFTS
I have become obsessed with your videos the last few months. I think your analysis of makeup is brilliant and so engaging!! I’m wondering if you’ve ever done any videos about Sigma? I haven’t seen any and I’d be really interested in your perspective ❤🧙♀️
Kackie would you be open to comparing the hourglass powders with the Ct micro powders ? I am a tan girl with matured (53) skin so the way you described the CT made me think of the HR ambient powders I have. maybe the HR I have serve the same purpose and I don’t need to buy CT? CTs lack of tan friendly eyeshadow quads (for the longest time) and the initial launch of the film star bronze and glow and pillow talk has always annoyed me and end up side eyeing and not trusting the subsequent tan girl releases.😛
I had the happy kiss in pillow talk and I absolutely hated the formula! I was so confused because everyone said how nice and balmy and non-sticky it is and I thought it was super thick and sticky. It also wouldn’t apply evenly and kind of skip on the inner part of my lips that wasn’t super dry. It probably didn’t help that it was my first time trying pillow talk and it just doesn’t suit me that well but it reminded me of a rather smooth glue stick ^^
I am not the biggest fan of her complexion products either, the eyes is where charlottes products really shine in my opinion!
That thumbnail!!! Ho.Lee.Shizzz.....cant stop laughing!!!! 😆😆😂🤣😂❤️❤️❤️
This thumbnail is maybe my favorite thumbnail of yours 😂😂😂 I love it!
My opinion on Charlotte Tilbury is her eyeshadows blend very well but do not have staying power they wear off very quickly, not worth the price. I do like her eyeliners.
Listening to the video while I’m working: “wait-did she just-“ rewinds 15 seconds-“YES she did mention Eddie Izzard!!” If I would have had any doubts about your impeccable taste, they would have been squashed that very second. Eddie is the best.
Eddie Izard is indeed the Best. I still have his comedy VHS…yes VHS tapes. Collecting dust because there is no way to watch it.🤣 but can’t let go of this legend that he is
@@marlbboro8091 I had Dressed to Kill on a bootleg DVD. I loaned it to a friend and I’ve not seen it since!
@@maeganmchugh I am so sorry for your loss! Like losing an heirloom. 😢
I have a love/like relationship with CT. I love the Hollywood Bronze & Glow, Exaggerize is my absolute favorite quad, and I really enjoy her nude lip liners, but I feel that the light wands are overpriced and overrated (I returned the one I bought) and the Hollywood Flawless Filter is ok, but I agree that it’s a thinner consistency than I prefer. I was extremely disappointed that she/her company refused to speak out in favor of women’s reproductive rights, so I will not be purchasing new products from the line, but I enjoy most of what I have.
So true about cream eyeshadow, it is so tough to blend them even as one and done. And usually they are tough to use as precise eyeliner, at least on my weird skin. Never understood them too
The other shaded HappiKiss are not sheer- they are pretty pigmented but really hydrating.
Watching this 9months later in order to check out the CT sale and BOY is this helpful. Thank you!
As a super cool toned person most of CT looks orange on my face and the airbrush powder darkens my foundation - so to me the brand does not live up to its hype. The products are pretty but I'm not seeing any where near the value to the prices they charge. Also can we ditch the 'pilow talk' thing for awhile??
I agree light wonder is breath taking and beautiful! Wonder why people don’t talk about it more ???? The newer one to me is not for me….. too greasy . Light wonder literally melts into the skin and blurs imperfections. ❤❤❤ you’re reminding me I need to repurchase.
Just for future reference, the happikiss balms in the other shades are pretty pigmented and super pretty!! Similar to the em cosmetics lip cushion things but more balmy/shiny. Pillow talk is super pretty
Also I remember the high intensity pillow talk blush debacle 😂
I’ve been fairly disappointed by every CT product I have ever tried. The flawless filter simultaneously made me look dry and crusty as well as like the tin man; the powder blush and the light wands both emphasize texture; and the eyes to mesmerize was nice but over priced. The pillow talk lipliner though? Such a beautiful, life- and face-changing product that I will continue trying things from the brand because I stubbornly have faith that I’ll find another Pillow talk in there!
I tried more stuff than I'd like to admit... Flawless filter- mwah, lovely, used up a bottle of fair shade (im not super fair but its the only light shade that isn't fkin orange), took me 3yrs. The giant wand gave me the ick so i transferred it into an airless pump. Spotlight highlight wand- something was off with this, it's pretty and smooth but I guess a bright highlight doesn't look great on me. I share the sentiment with oyster pearl cream eyeshadow, such an underwhelming thing in terms of being dimensional, blends out into murky mess, creases, doesn't play well with my brushes and it also leans warm on me... i will probably finish it in 100 years. I have a favorite tho, lip stain in shade blushed rose, a site exlusive. I prefer using stains as blushes, stays all day, gives a pretty glow and it's such a pretty nude pink muted shade that's pretty impossible to find in the world of tints. Don't want to support the woman tho and buy anything new so I'm on the lookout for resells. Still want to try the cream bronzer in fair shade, prob the most olive bronzer I've seen and repurchase filter in shade 4 as an olivey bronzer-highlight-glowything to put on the perimeter of the face
The light wonder is so beautiful 😍
I spent a fortune on CT and ended up giving it all away. I’m very cool toned and all of her foundation colors are way too warm/yellow for me. Her magic cream was ok but way overpriced. Her mascaras give me raccoon eyes which really sucks. That night cream scared me 😂. Sticky is an understatement! The only things I’ve kept and use are the flawless finish powder compact, pillow talk blush, lips and eye liner and the walk of no shame blush and lips. I gave up trying her new stuff.
The mascara seriously sucks, it is impossible to build.
@@kat3325 I tried it once and I’ve never had a mascara run and smear so bad. Never again!
I find some products, especially the newer products are not there quality wise. I love light wonder foundation, I actually love magic cream it really hydrates my skin. Pillow talk blush is lovely and I like they happy kiss balms and the tinted love as blush. Her mascaras are not good at all.
So so pretty! Love Plum on you, wow 😍💗
Oh yes, I remember very vividly that time you tried that Pillow Talk blush 🤭
Wait did you just combine melancholy and ennui?? As someone who did their doctoral dissertation on melancholy in French lit, I’m jealous I didn’t come up with that
Millennial and ennui 😝
@@kackie Oh. Well this is awkward… a perfect example of millennui though
So I wasn't here for the high intensity blush. But, yesterday I did watch the worst of the year from that year and that blush was sooo dark amd orange 😫
The fact that you know and can also quote Eddie Izzard just proves and solidifies the fact that you are amazing ❤
Aw I take little credit - my best friend growing up exposed me to the best niche humor. Her parents had the best taste hahaha
THE THUMBNAIL FOR THIS HAS ME DYING 💀😵🪦
HAHAHA
I love to mix Light Wonder and Beautiful Skin foundations together! Wowza! The lipstick shade Very Victoria, is a nice mauve color, if one likes cool toned lippies. And as a dry skin person... I'll take the CT glow, all day. 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣 The only time I use her skincare, is as an assured working base for her foundation to lay on top of. On the regular though, I favor medical grade skincare... 👍
Hey Kackie, this is pretty off topic of this video, but as our Tubing Mascara
Queen do you have any recommendations for a similarly easy-to-remove/low residue eyeliner formula? I have terribly sensitive eyes and I'm trying to find something sort of similar to those formulas that washes off pretty cleanly.
Liquid eyeliner?
@@kackie sorry said formula, meant brand
I find the Clinique quick liners to be good quality and pretty easily removed!
I NEED Cool Bronzers & Contours!!! Beautiful! 💜 But NOT for that price! 😭
I have been over CT after everything was a Pillow Talk reissue… (sort of like an ex-boyfriend I wonder now why we even dated in the first place) until I remember… it was my Smokey eye obsession at the time… but the pink is what made me run away. I’ve never been into her complexion products though.
The thumbnail! Epic!🤣🤣🤣🤣 clicked only because of that, but stayed for the commentary❤️
I would love this style video for Bobbi Brown. She’s the first makeup artist I remember having a signature look that I’m still rocking today.
OMG I just noticed the thumbnail… this is the type of unhinged I’m here for
the eyes to mesmerize crease on my hooded lids so bad... barely wear them b/c of that :(
Hey Kackie, the fall weather here in France is making me shop for candles, what brand was that amazing coffee/chocolate candle you described once? Can't seem to track down that video😊 love your content, keep it up!
I think you're talking about "The Usual" from The New Savant! :)
@@jordanwhitacre5702 Omg yes! Thank you so much!
And I now realise they don't ship to France...oh well, we tried 😂
@@annamarialowe-manolis4628 Oh nooo, I'm sorry!
@@jordanwhitacre5702 It sounded so good and autumnal...Thanks anyway, I guess i'll have to wait and hope they start shipping internationally!
YES! Hard agree, how overpriced and overrated CT is... Not going to lie but I did make a purchase here and there, and literally every product (with maybe the only exception being her pressed setting powder) was incredibly meh.
I haven't watched the video yet but I totally agree with the title. :)
Fragrance!!!!!!! Pink!!!!! THAT WEBSITE!!! All so clever, yet so lacking, yet so naff!!!! Thanks, I hate CT makeup!!! ❤ your deep dive 😅
Besides the horrifying thumbnail, this was a great video😂 thanks!!
What a great, comprehensive review! Thank you, thank you.
omg your charlotte tilbury impersonation sounds like jennifer coolidge in friends!!
I love and adore exaggereyes! So underrated!
And yes 42 here… dryness pretty much happens overnight when you’re 30 and gets worse over time 😄😂😂😂😂🤣
How would you compare the CT bronze and glow to your ND contour?
“I felt like a katamari!”😂
Omg the ally mcbeal face bra. Lololol.
finally someone said it
I like a lot of CT beauty products ( adore her mascara HFF and eyes to mesmerize pencils) but her magic cream and the white clay mask are bs. I spent years literally years trying to justify buying her magic cream and finally bought it. Omg 🤬🤬🤬 and the hidden sunscreen bugged me no end because I wanted it for the night but couldn’t because of that unnecessary sunscreen. Honestly the Rephr moisturizer is miles and miles and miles …and even more miles….better. And the CT white clay mask is rubbish. A lot of the Asian face masks come with ears and/or also a way to get the chin portion to hook around the ears so I guessing this CT mask is the same. What is inside that matters but I have been so burnt by CT skincare that I am not willing to pay her for it.😕
Millennui oh my god I've never felt so understood
Okay I’m not sure if I’m the only one that noticed a weird echo, I particularly noticed it around the bronzer portion
Am I the only one who still doesn't understand what the hollywood flawless filter is?
I couldn’t stand the beautiful skin foundation- I spent the whole day wanting to wash my face 😂 I’ve never felt that or at least not so intensely with any other foundation.
This thumbnail is my favorite…
I am so disappointed in their products. The consistency is clay like, and leaves your face looking greasy. The color is a bit off also. I really wanted to like it.
Pat McGrath is a better makeup artist anyway.
One of the funniest thumbnails 😂
I haven’t bought anything from her. Everything is orange on me I swear
The smell of the magic cream was enough to immediately make me not use it.
CT products are TERRIBLE. Everything seems to be orange. The products are poor quality and overpriced. I'd rather buy from Dior, Hourglass, Cle De Peau, and Pat Mcgrath. Far superior products for the same price point. Everything I've bought from CT I've hated. The ONLY plus point is in the UK, they accept used returns. Most companies here don't
Am I right in thinking that Charlotte has actually sold the Charlotte Tilbury company?
Lmaoooooo the thumbnail 🤣 🤣🤣
I remember the high intensity issues >.
Not even hit play yet, but the answer is yes. And I feel less alone now. :)
💗💗💗💗
I remember the blush fiasco. 😂😂
Gen-z here, love the content !
The worst foundation I have ever tried! Cakey and thick. Setting spray also not worth it, better cheaper brands
Lol I keep looking at the thumbnail and it's making me laugh. Also I'm drunk
Her stuff is absolutely overrated and over-hyped.