Jazak Allahu hayran brother Hassan . This is very important subject , which actually is clear from hadeeths , but so many peaple are not understanding. Im newly became shia alhamduli Llah, but even when i study and search this subject i see that which is in iran is wrong . When i was sunni , they are following the majority , one - two are taking decision and others following , and in shia world its happened the same . I think truth shia must to understand this important subject. But i have question which is still not clear for me . If the mutter not the revolution but protection ? If we take as an example Palestin . Israil took their land, houses . In this case also must be forbidden to go and make war , fight with them ? But what they need to do according to hadetgs from ahlul beyt as? If palestinian are shia , what they should to do ? And this point that they are protecting mesgid al Aqsa , from my understanding is wrong also . Pls correct me, if im wrong. Because again there is no hadeeth , instruction from ahlul beyt as to do this. Right? Allah protected Qaaba from ashabul fil. And nowadays , if Allah didnt protect Aqsa , they could destroy it very easy with one booming . Allahu Alim .
Aqsa mosque is in the sky , not in Palestine, the prophet did go up to sky and prayed infront the other prophets, not in Palestine!!!! Taghout government (satan) is everywhere , true shia has no rule or place in it!!! They (taghout ,satanic, and hypocrites) kill each other, god did defend us by following and waiting the rest of god on earth.
The Ahle Bait (as) refers to Shias who strive to establish a religious state as the 'Khawarij' (apostates) of our Shia community. In my opinion, secular Shias are those who ignore narrations and do whatever they like, while non-secular Shias are those who pay attention to these narrations. In my opinion, what makes someone secular is not the establishment or non-establishment of a religious state, but whether or not they listen to the teachings of Ahle Bait (as).
Br Hassan Allahyari , agree or not with him, is a mujtihid and he is not a liberal secular person. I don’t agree with everything he says, but don’t equate or misunderstand, he is NOT a liberal secularist.
Thank you teacher Mr Hassan Alahyari, from Jakarta Indonesia
Masha'Allah
ماشاالله
Excellent analysis
❤❤
خداریات
استاد
Jazak Allahu hayran brother Hassan .
This is very important subject , which actually is clear from hadeeths , but so many peaple are not understanding.
Im newly became shia alhamduli Llah, but even when i study and search this subject i see that which is in iran is wrong . When i was sunni , they are following the majority , one - two are taking decision and others following , and in shia world its happened the same . I think truth shia must to understand this important subject.
But i have question which is still not clear for me . If the mutter not the revolution but protection ?
If we take as an example Palestin . Israil took their land, houses . In this case also must be forbidden to go and make war , fight with them ? But what they need to do according to hadetgs from ahlul beyt as? If palestinian are shia , what they should to do ?
And this point that they are protecting mesgid al Aqsa , from my understanding is wrong also . Pls correct me, if im wrong.
Because again there is no hadeeth , instruction from ahlul beyt as to do this. Right?
Allah protected Qaaba from ashabul fil. And nowadays , if Allah didnt protect Aqsa , they could destroy it very easy with one booming .
Allahu Alim .
Pray for imam mahdi as. Im very glad that u become true shia❤️
Aqsa mosque is in the sky , not in Palestine, the prophet did go up to sky and prayed infront the other prophets, not in Palestine!!!!
Taghout government (satan) is everywhere , true shia has no rule or place in it!!! They (taghout ,satanic, and hypocrites) kill each other, god did defend us by following and waiting the rest of god on earth.
Aqsa in the sky.
I think Mr Allahari needs to provide examples of errors of the Marja. Because if the Marja are not making mistakes then you cannot criticize like this
Liberal / Secular Shia !!!
The Ahle Bait (as) refers to Shias who strive to establish a religious state as the 'Khawarij' (apostates) of our Shia community. In my opinion, secular Shias are those who ignore narrations and do whatever they like, while non-secular Shias are those who pay attention to these narrations.
In my opinion, what makes someone secular is not the establishment or non-establishment of a religious state, but whether or not they listen to the teachings of Ahle Bait (as).
@@mmcool Sure buddy. Ahl -al Bait would have called you American liberal Shia
Br Hassan Allahyari , agree or not with him, is a mujtihid and he is not a liberal secular person. I don’t agree with everything he says, but don’t equate or misunderstand, he is NOT a liberal secularist.
We are waiting the truth, we don't worship the devils talking in the name of god and the prophet and imams.@@BorneofSilenc