6. The Origin of Sunni Islam | Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Muharram 2024/1446
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 окт 2024
- Subscribe now to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform 👉 www.sayedammar... -consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more!
Sayed Ammar Nakshawani Ramadan Lectures 2023
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I► Sayed Dr. Ammar Nakshawani - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: SANakshawani
Instagram: sayedammarofficial
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Sayed Dr. Ammar Nakshawani - Official RUclips Channel
![[4K] Watch SpaceX Catch A Starship Rocket From Space!!! #IFT5](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pIKI7y3DTXk/mqdefault.jpg)
Proud to be one of the converts. My Father changed the course of our entire family's belief from his siblings to distant cousins. Alhamdolillah 🙏🏻❤️
if you are convertor stop listen to this fake scholar, he is a british agent
@@zeeraxishow?
Proud to be a convert from the darkness of wahabism
My you be guided back to the truth. Aameen
Do you think, one reason why so many muslims are now apostatising from islame and convert to Christianity, is because no muslim can justify *surah 23:14* pagan moon god Lah has no clue how the baby is made, and, he is one _of_ many creatorS, plural ?
Mashaallah. Allah truly guides who he wills. Do you have any way I can contact you? I would love to hear your experiences.
I was born in a sunni hanafi brailvi sect of Pakistan Alhamdulillah now I'm a 12er shia
Salam give ayat of Quran proving imamah
@@rizwanrauf4940 SubhanAllah... Read the Qur'an yourself brother... I have found it insha'Allah you will also find it... By the way show me verse where it says that Abubaker would be the khalifa after Rasool Allah ص ?
@@rizwanrauf4940 wsalam
@@musmanarshadsair imamah is aqedah being caliph is political appointment
@@rizwanrauf4940khilaafah is also part of the Qur'an so why it is not an aqeedah, if someone rejects khilaafah can they be a muslim? Adam ع was the first khalifah and these 12 Imams are 12 khalifas...
Syed, honestly you made me cry by this whole scenario and the statement which is given by our Shia Household and I am truly grateful and proud that I am Syed/Shia I cannot be enough thankful to the person whom explain the truth with most logical facts. ALLAH'TALLAH protects you and your family from evil and keep giving me/us more knowledge that we desire most DEARLY so keep up this ethos always. YA ALI MADAD 😉👍🏼♥️
this series is one of the best along side the ramadan series.
may allah lengthen ur life sayedna
786
Aameen!
Im a sayyid, born and raised in malaysia with sunni education but alhamdulillah i never accept sunnism the very first day i had been introduced to sunnism. Alhamdulillah my serach for my amcestory lead me to the real islam.
MashaAllah, may Allah guide us all onto the right path. If I may ask brother, can you openly say you’re shia in Malaysia or is it as Sayed Ammar mentioned that you could be punished for it?
@@ihaz8 shia in Malaysia are oppressed, once the police raid Husseiniyah during fatimah az zahra tahlil, they jailed even children.
@@sfaiz3780 that’s horrible..I don’t know what to say except may Allah (swt) and Ahlulbayt (as) be with you, in this dunya and the hereafter
@@ihaz8 but alhamdulillah these past 5 6 years the anti shia sentiment is not as bad like they used to. During general election 2018, our x PM tun dr mahathir became pm for 2nd time. He brings down anti-shia sentiment and movement by move close with Iran diplomatically and promotes unity among Muslims nation in fighting with the Zionist and organized the famous KL islam summit in 2018. I can say during dr mahathir 2nd tenure as PM , he turns Malaysia 180°, he even sends our top generals to Iran for a military diplomatic mission. These change the mindset of people here. The problem with Malaysia is that anti shia movement is mobilized by the deep state within the government and these people are actually followers or supporters of Saudi. And these current situations in gaza even change the people's perspective on shia. They now slowly acknowledge that shia is their brother in faith not the enemy. More and more people started to realize that sunni shia riff is Zionist play.
@@sfaiz3780 take care of yourself and be careful. Don't over expose yourself to the public for safety reason. Sunni theocratical dictatorship in your country is really getting worse
Salaam Sayed, as a convert (from Sunni ‘Barelvi’ to Shia) I loveeeee all your lectures, especially the series you’ve begun since Ramadan, May Allah سُبْحَانَهُ وَتَعَالَىٰ bless you ABUNDANTLY! Whatever I’ve read in the books when I decided to convert, you reiterate those points so so well! Thank you for calling the Sunnis out, thank you for giving us the confidence to be proud of our faith & to face all those who mock us & most importantly thank you for strengthening our faith in following the path of Aal e Muhammad ﷺ 💚 JazakAllah Khair SAN🤲🏻♥️we pray for your good health & long life so that you keep imparting knowledge and helping us, Ameen!🤲🏻
Ur a lyk a food who became a shit a after eating 😂
I was also born in brailvi but I also became 12er shia
@@musmanarshadsair wow Masha’Allah! Would love to hear about your journey & whatever you read/heard that made you convert!! :D bless you!
@@zahrak4850 brother very long story, I use to think shia are kafir. But after knowing about the 12 Imams ع I became shia after a 10-15 years research... People normally mix the shia with ghulat/ ghali غالی. They don't know about the real Shia.
My family still Sunnis and they don't know it... What about you?
@@musmanarshadsair it’s sister😅 and yes my love for Imam Hussain ع drew me close to learning about Shiism & that’s how I started to read first & THEN started watching majalis. Researched for some time then converted, my family is still barelvi/sunni but my mom also converted, Alhumdulillah 😄 but under taqiyyah :( sadly for us because family is very anti-Shia like most Barelvis are
Every lecture gives me more confidence to say "Asshadu an la ilaha ila Allah. Asshadu anna Muhammadan rassulullah. Asshadu anna Ali waliullah"
The last phrase is not in the Quran or Sunnah
@@WaqasAli-ct7ly In the Sunnah of Abu Bakr of course not. But in the real Sunnah of the Prophet saw. it is clear from day one.
@@WaqasAli-ct7ly the narators of sunnah are ahl al bait are abu bakr? what said about naration?
@@WaqasAli-ct7ly ghadeer kum?
The last phrase is an innovation!
Ammar literally destroyed them. He literally destroyed them completely and ultimately. They are done ✔️
you are my pride which I found after my struggle of decades. I wanted someone to make n show me the real path of HUSSAIN. May Allah bless n protect you from evil eye. ❤
Why the real Path of Hussain ?? Why not the tru Path of Rasulullah s a w ? You Idiot ! Follow Rasulullah and not anyone else !
I’m always in awe of this man’s approach to these issues. Subhanallah such a talented lecturer. May Allah guide the misguided school called Sunni.I’ve been Shia 9years now as it’s largely because of this man! May Allah grant him a long life and even more knowledge and wisdom 🤲🏽
Sunnis are too afraid to watch Nakshawanis lectures 🤣🤣🤣😅😅😅
I am Sunni but I watch his lectures. In fact all scholars 😂
I'm " Sunni " I watched this video and read your condescendant message, for sure I wont watch other lectures. I dont like mockers. I wrote a comment about it.
and Nakshawani is to afraid to have a debate with Adnan Rashid :)
Did you know that Sheikh Amir Al-Qurashi, may God be pleased with him and satisfy him, is the terror of the Arab Sunnis, and they are even afraid of his voice?
I watch it but he is wrong. Very biased view
Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamat is Biggest Fitnah of Deen e Islam.
You Just Destroyed It Forever. May Allah Help You Become A Wali One Day.
You Have Delivered The Truth.
LOVE YOU
😂.... Come to Parachinar Pakistan..😢 you will find pieces of children due to Rafidhis... Because They spread hated very high... You should be know that Ahale Sunnat is the religion..... don't play with any one emotions
Great historical analysis of the ever changing sunni ideology
And the ever changing shia theology? Ismailis, zaidis, aga khanis, dawoodi bohra sulaymani bohra,
@@WaqasAli-ct7lythey’re not Shias
Umar Ibn Yazid said: “I came in to Abu Abdillah As-Sadiq (a.), whereupon he told me extensively about the merits of the followers (Shi’ah). Then he said: “Among the followers (Shi’ah) after us there are those who are worse than the enemies (Nawasib)”. I said: “My life be sacrificed to you, do they not claim to love for you, and acknowledge your guardianship (Wilayah) and renounce your enemies (Bara’ah)? He said: “Yes.” I said: “My life be sacrificed to you, explain it to us so that we may know. Is the work we do done by them? He said: “Not at all, O Umar, you are not one of them. They are a group that are leading into temptation (Fitnah) by using Zaid (a.) and Musa (a.).” [Ikhtiyar Ma’rifat Ar-Rijal of At-Tusi, Volume 2 Page 759 Hadith 869]
@@WaqasAli-ct7lybut non of them following the path of moawya and yazid lanti
@WaqasAli-ct7ly
the biggest hoax is sunni islam. Literally need to abandon rational and critical thinking to be a sunni.
@@WaqasAli-ct7lyto be a sunni, one needs to abandon rational and critical thinking
I was born Sunni, the more I study Islam, the more I love Shia, the two have many similarities, only a few differences are exaggerated. Only the stupid are easily taken in by Islam's divisive propaganda.
Wallah spot on 👌🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 they define their sect by contradicting ours 😅👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻, so if it wasn’t for us they wouldn’t of been able to define what a Sunni sect is 😂. Keep it up Sayyid 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Haha thats literally a principle of shiism. When in doubt do the opposite of the sunnis 😂
I just pray you live long❤
786
And that Allah protects him!
As a ex sunni, almost a shia, I appreciate the credit for the converts
bruh for what reason would be become someone who hits his chest and cry do music while calling it halal?
Same situation here brother 😅❤
You left Islam to become a Rafidah, Why? From rejecting the companions of the Prophet to blindly following 12 “infallible” imams.
The companions are praised & honoured by Allaah in the Quran. You would rather follow weak chains of narrations from Shia imams over the Quran & Sunnah…
@@waaryamay Allah guide you to the truth you brainwashed umari
@alibrahym Do Music what you on about there's no Music .
Crying is a Sunnah and remembering Karbala is a asunnah because the Prophet it did when Hassan and Hussain A.S were born it's your habits go look it up . Yes Zanjeer is wrong yes but only a few do that but our Ullemah made that clear they Do it it's between them and Allah. But we have no Music in our Mashids at all you made that up you hate Ahlul batt so much you making false accusations about his Shia.
Syedna cant thank you enough for every single one of your lectures and majalis, may Allah reward you for the effort
3:16 😢 it really fills us with tears when we know we love our Imam ameerul momineen Ali ibne Abi talib as and have his wilayah
Never enjoyed a religion majlis this much.
What is there to enjoy 😂
@@reshiwasim143exposing your lies
Hit the like on the video for the love of Mohamed and Ali Mohammed PBUT!!!!
I'm just grateful to be alive in the time of Sayed Ammar..Alhamdolillah ☝🏾
My imam is in Karbala yesterday today and forever!
You are exceptionally good Sayed! We love the way you tell the story! Keeps us all on edge! May Allah keep you safe and you continue spreading the TRUTH
Sayed is on fire 🔥
Always ❤
Which fire? Jahanam ⚫️🔥, shia playboys like this guy based their entire "religion" on attacking and abusing other muslims
Yes Majoosi ( fire worshipper ) on Fire .... 😂
@@sohanuikey3862becareful what you say. Read your sunni books of ahadeeth, rasoollah says the majority will be on the wrong.
Allah is watching
@@sohanuikey3862sunni worship Umar.
The attrocities on Imam Hussain(a.s), the Ahl al-Bayt and the companions should have united the Muslim ummah.
But sadly it divided the umma even more.
Yes because you guys are changing the way of deen ! Just follow Rasululölah and not Hussain or anyone else you fools ! May ALlah s w t guide you and us all Amin !
@@classicchrome716you are the fool!! Who did Hussein follow dumbass?
He will, you’ll see!! Imam Hussain is the reason for my conversion and he will insha’Allah be the reason for why the Ummah will unite.
@@Fizafeez Wow Imam Hussain was the reason for your conversation. Wow. That is soo wrong on so many levels I don't even know what to say. Let's leave it there. Inşaallah you will become a Muslim. I wish that for all shias. Because it's not worth it to go to hell forever just because you're ignorant of some things. And that's the case. Shias in general are ignorant about what really happened and what really was. It's sad to see you guys go to jahannam forever just because you lack knowledge. So please educate yourselves and inşaallah you will not enter jahannam. By the way why ask Hussain or follow him or choose him ? What about rasulullah? I hear from Shias only Hussain Hussain or Ali Ali. Why Dou you guys rely more on them instead of Rasulullah s a w ? I don't get that ? Why choose number 2 or 3 or 5 or 6 when you just can follow NUMBERS ONE Rasulluah?? Why do you guys say labbayke ya Hussain labbayke ? Why not Labbayke Rasulullah? ( Of course that would be wrong also ) But why ask number 2 or 3 for help and not number 1? I really don't get it ! Makes no sense at all. Why is Hussain so much more important to you OBVIOUSLY then Rasulullah s a w ? Yes I know you guys say " oh no Rasulullah s a w is of course the number 1 " and so on. But you guys keep asking Hussain for help. Why is that ? I really want to know. Sincerely.
I typed in RUclips origin of Sunni Islam and walaa that's what came up every video was the difference between Sunni and Shia.
Every Muslim on earth must watch this video.
Best lecture from you! What was Sunni Islam on the day of Jamal! 😎
Assalamun Alaikum
Sayed Ammar Thank you again
Salawat
O’ Allah, bless
Muhammad and the
progeny of Muhammad and hasten their reappearance.
And destroy their enemies, from the Jinns and humans; from the first and the last
Aameen Summa Aameen 🤲❤
Alhumdulilah for you Sayed! You have strengthened the hearts of Shias esp converts around the world with this series.
I will never return to the path of so called Ahlus Sunnah. “Ya Allah, bless me to die on the beloved path of Prophet Muhammad and the Ahlul Bayt”
From it's name also had a good name ahlussunah wal jamaah
Get lost fast
Masallah brother
Brother the shia are the real
ahl e sunnah wa al jamat
@@ss_nooranisunni also said that, so what is the difference sunni and Hinduism ?
Very interesting! From a Catholic.
If you are serious about the correct path stick to the Quran alone.
@@greengalaxy8873 No thank you! Catholic Church is enough for me!
@@declansceltic198 , I whole heartedly respect your choice. I was just pointing out that the Quran is the "sola scriptura" approach to many of us Muslims who brush aside all these politico-historical debates which is indeed interesting. Regards.
@@greengalaxy8873that just leads to christianity
May Allah swt bless you ❤️
Dr.Ammar, you are my hero❤
May Allah swt grant you a long healthy life in order to serve ahle bait (as).
786
Aameen!
May Allah give you long healthy life and keep you safe from any harm. ❤
Aameen
786
Aameen!
I love love love Sayed Ammar 🤲🏼🤲🏼🤲🏼 great knowledge, great lecture and very informative ❤❤❤
صلوات اللّٰہ و صلوات ملائکتہ و انبیائہ و رسلہ و جمیع خلقہ علیٰ محمد وآل محمد والسلام علیہ و علیھم و رحمت اللہ و برکاتہ ۔
786
I did finish listening to the entire lecture but forgot to enter my comment 😪.
Here it is now!
This lecture is awesome, Sayed, truly awesome!!!!! 👏👌👏 Shukar Mowla! Thank you ever so much for sharing such valuable information with us, Sayed!
Logical and respectful. Undeniable. Thanks for this lecture
Don’t call them “Sunni”
Sunni means following the actual Sunna of the prophet. In reality we (Shia) are the Sunni
where in the sunnah are Tattoos? especially on the hands ...where they block the water reaching the skin for wudhu
@@GhaaziWarriormaybe he got them in the past and did tubah. Tattoos are haram in Islam.
Tattoos are not haram@@Zaineb.D
What an exceptionally enlightening and informative lecture on the truth behind Sunni Islam. The non-Shia are broken into so many groups that they themselves don't have a clue what they are. Alhamdullilah, we held onto the Qur'an and Ahlulbayt. Alhamdullilah, we are Shia. 🙌🏻
Shia themselves have broken into many like zaidi,Ismaili,bohra,twelvers etc.,
We all follow one Jaffar As Sadiq (as) and one Imam Ali (as)
@@arafathamermohammed7763
@@arafathamermohammed7763The Shia theology started from the Karbala events. Before that, the Shiatul Ali was a politically based, pro-Ali supporters of Kufah.
@@peacefulindian318 tell me which one is correct. Prophet(pbuh) appointing Ali(a.s) at gadeer e Qum. Or Sunni believes prophet didn't choose a successor?
It starts here.
@@dawn-of-newdayCorrect one is Ghadeer khum...
Legend ❤
To all my sunni brothers....
It's clear as daylight...Rasulallah at Ghadir said that, "Man Kunto Maula Fa-haaza Ali-yun Maula".. meaning that whoever accepts Muhammad as their master, Ali is also their master...
As Muslims..this should be enough for us...we are no one to decide ...
"When God and His Messenger have decided on a matter that concerns them, it is not fitting for any believing man or woman to claim freedom of choice in that matter: whoever disobeys God and His Messenger is far astray."
Surah Ahzab, verse 36.
May Allah guide us all...!!
Ok so why then follow Ali? Why not just follow Rasulullah ?!
@@classicchrome716 because Rasulallah so !!!
Why is it so difficult to understand??
By extension of your logic, why follow Rasulallah?? Why not just follow Allah !!??
@@zee_ali because rasulullah so ??? What are you trying to say ???? Hahahahah
@@classicchrome716 because Rasulallah said so !!
Hope you get it now...but I know you won't!!
@@zee_ali yes I don't get it. Because I am so dumb and try to do what Rasulluah s a w did. And not what someone else did. By the way rasulullah never said do something that anyone else did. He said s a w do what I and my sahaba did. But you guys are thinking: " Nooo we know better then him s a w. So we do as WE THINK it's right. Hahahhaha. May Allah guide you. Amin.
Gr8 Knowledgeable legend.
May Allah bless u for spreading the true Islam
What a beautiful, insightful and knowlegeble lecture aga!
i wish every muskim watched your videos, they would change their minds
We would NEVER ELHAMDULILLAH. Because you guys are sooo Wrong !!!
Unfortunately, hate has replaced critical thought amongst many people who call themselves Muslims. They would rather follow their ancestors than the teachings of the alhlulbait. There is no point arguing with them. Let them believe what they want and we will follow what we know to be true. Every single Sunni scholar will admit the events of ghadeer happened and that the prophet appointed Imam Ali as his only successor. He also stated many times anyone against Ali and his family has strayed from the path. These hadiths are in their books, yet they follow the people who fought and killed the ahlulbait. This is enough proof for us, so let them do what they want. We will continue to follow the path of knowledge and love (which is also why there are 0 Shia terroriri$+s in the world while every single extremist violent group has been from other schools of thought.)
@@monkeyballer32 Bro it's not about hate or love. It's about being absolutely wrong and following Muhammad s a w ! Whoever doesn't follow him will end in jahannam. And Shia made up their own religion. I mean the 12 er shias. Most shias are like us Sunnis. They're just by name Shia. But the 12 er shias ? Audhubillah! They say Allah made a failure and their imams corrected him. They say the Qur'an isn't complete in the way we have it and the missing part is hidden from us. They say their imams know the hidden part. They say their imams know whenever someone will die and when someone will be born. They say their imams have the total knowledge of Allah s w t. Audhubillah! How can someone call such individuals a Muslim ? You can't. But they are trying to tell us Sunnis that we are wrong ! The imam Mahdi of the Shia is already here they say. In a cave somewhere. Nobody saw him ever. But what we see is that they transport truck loads of money in this cave. Come on bro. They have no narration chain. All they have is from 3 people which are liars through and through and of course they have this DONKEY OFEIR in the chain of narration! A DONKEY ! Come on bro. These 12 er Imam shias are so far away from Islam like the next Galaxy.
God bless you Sayed! ❤
Great session
Yes a true guide to Jahannam !
@@classicchrome716انتم الذين في جهنم لانكم اتبعتم المنافقون والكذبه
@@KarlisEliyah English please
Proud to be Shia Muslim and I am saying this after reading all the Sunni literature.
Mashaallah. Very beautifully conveyed.
As an Ex sunni , i can totally and entirely relate to what Ammar has said. " Mishmash" is perhaps the best word to describe the Sunni version of islam.
You lie, a sunni never leave sunni
@@izharcohen4572 oh great.. now you will speak for my faith choice and you will decide my truth !!!! 🤣👏
@@salmanchk if you are really ex sunni, what aqeeda do hanbali people believe?
@@izharcohen4572 ask hanbali
@@izharcohen4572 Izhar lets have contact brother
Don’t call them “Sunni”
Sunni means following the actual Sunna of the prophet. In reality we (Shia) are the Sunni
Call them Omari’s or Bakri’s.
Sayed Sistani may Allah lengthen his life and protect him, says, Sunnah are not our brothers but ourselves; because we are the true sect following the sunnah if prophet وآلـﷺـه 🤓
And the sunnis say we are rhetoric real Shia of Ali ibn Abi Talib, don't call them Shia call them rawafid.
It's pretty much the opposite.
@@thelion2087 you did not understand the statement did you?
@@yourstruly5706 rawafith and proud ya Ali madad
Ali had son named abu bakr what shia will gonna say?
Brilliant … thank you 🙏 so much for the legacy of these narratives.. May Maula accept and reward all your efforts to help us to educate ourselves
Beautifully explained..... Mashallah Syed ❤
One of my most favourite lectures 🙏
Shit, this sermon hit me so hard, because this sermon answered my question a lot 👏🏻
English transcript of sermon may kindly be inserted .
I am sunni and this is quite remarkable 😢
No, you're not. Stop the cap.
@@101academics. ruclips.net/video/jVxJTgrXySU/видео.htmlsi=O-E2ZNPvbviAGW9N
قرآن مجید کی تاکید ھے ،، لا تفرقو ،، تفریق میں نہ پڑو ۔ اپنے آپ کو شیعہ ، سنی ، اہلحدیث نہ کہو مسلم کہو اور اسلام سے شناخت قائم کرو اللہ تعالیٰ ھمارے علماء کو نیک توفیق عطا فرمائے آمین یارب العالمین ۔
2024 is the best off Ammar
Imam Ali married Abu Bakr’s widow and also had sons named Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman.
Shia imams are from madina and from the house of Prophet PBUH, but sunni imams came from faraway lands with no blood relations to the PROPHET PBUH.
There was a public opinion propgated by the early governments that the household of the PROPHET PBUH has turned into kafirs (nauzbillah) thats why most of the hadiths and literature has been preserved our the years is narrated by people other than the household of PROPHET/the Ahlul bayt a.s.
The general public who didn't like the ahlul bayt a.s was mostly sunni. It was the sufis who came later and ignited a small amount of light of love of ahlulbayt a.s in the some of the sunni people thats why they do respect ahlul bayt a little bit now a days. Hadn't been the sufis, all sunni will still have the same hate towards ahlul bayt a.s.
Assalamualaikum. Sayed ammar .
I'm a convert just wanted to know which tafseer you use, i wanna use that too.
Ps. The quran we see in your ramzan series
Allaykum Salaam. I think he is using the tafseer of Mir Ahmed Ali.
@@yusufkermalli5779 thanks🌝
Try reading Tafsir Al Mizan, it's in English, available online and it's quite good.
What did you convert from?
@@agostocobain2729 from sunni
My brother there is division amongst sunnis and also amongst shias and these divisions will stay as long as we are united against the enemies of Islam everything else will remain as it is i think.
الشيعه الجعفريه،،،،اما الآخرون مذاهب اخرى مختلفه
Ya Muhammad! Ya Rasulallah! Ya 'Ali! Ya Husayn!
Labbaik Ya Hussain
Mashallah
Much needed.. everyone must listen this..
I am proud to be shia
Amazingggg amazing maulana
Masha Allah ❤
As salam u alykum,
I am sunni, and a average muslim at best. Student of comparative religion. I love my Shia brothers and I ask Allah to unite the hearts and minds.
I have a few problems with this. With a great deal of respect to the sheikh.
Definition by negation is not uncommon.
That's not a W.
Sunni shia is not a theological divide but a political one. We both believe in one Allah. Creed of Imam Tahawi is generally accepted and in line with shia thought, if interested.
These differences in school of law and school of theology is not a hidden or concealed topic, nor one that the average Muslim needs to concern themselves with unless they need evidence of the chain of knowledge and how laws are developed.
Sunni's take from Imam Ali(RA) and from the Bayt. Shia do not have sole claim so sunni have knowledge from Bayt and the rest of the sahabi, the others you do not take from so the understanding is more expansive.
The arguments are formulated like these are problems but no Sunni considers these "problems."
My biggest issue in all of the brothers' lectures is the principle of having a good opinion (husn al zthan). Not cursing people we are no where near in caliber.
The brother in another lecture said Allah curses so and so, so I curse so and so. The wrath of Allah is not our wrath.
Allah may hate firaun, but he told Musa(as) to go and speak gently with him.
Follow the bayt, it is a valid path. Narrations from Aisha(RA) are valid hadith and explain so much we as muslims otherwise would not have known.
In regards to the prophet (SAW)'s parents. As muslims we do not place people in heaven or hell, aH we have Allah for that. There are rulings and ahkam based on the ahkam scholars may have gave opinions but every scholar of any intelligence says "Allah knows best."
Salam brother,
I would disagree that the Sunni Shia split is political. Although the Sunni Shia split seems political because one group followed Imam Ali AS and the rest followed Abu Bakr, you must understand that us Shia view the Ahlulbayt as having divine authority whereas you see it as who is the political leader of the Islamic state. The concept of Imamah in Sunni theology is not very stamped into the religion compared to the way us Shia take Imamah - it is a part of our usool Al Deen (roots of religion).
The Shia take on Sahaba is that we categorise them : some were very good, some were not necessarily bad but never followed Imam Ali AS, some were hypocrites and some were also power hungry. The Shia don’t have the general view that the Sahaba were the best of people after the Prophet SAW, because its actually not logical according to Islam and history of Prophets. For example, Bani Israel betrayed Nabi Musa AS, so what we can understand is that previous companions of previous prophets were not always the best of people otherwise there would be no need for Prophet Muhammed SAW to come after Musa AS and Isa AS to perfect the religion of Islam. Also im not too sure about this, but there is very little reports, narrations etc taken from the Ahlulbayt in Sunni literature, from this I mean, the Sunni won’t take any Hadiths or knowledge from someone like Imam Sadiq AS, ironic that he was the teacher of 2 of the Sunni schools of Fiqh.
As for cursing, listen to the lecture where Ammar talks about cursing Yazid Ibn Muawiyah.
As for Aisha, the Shia will reject anything from her because she fought the successor of the Prophet SAW, and therefore went against Allah SWT‘s hujjat(proof) on earth.
Now I’m not aware on the authenticity of this Hadith below, but it clearly highlights why our view on Aisha is not positive :
Sahih al-Bukhari 3772
Narrated Abu Wail:
When `Ali sent `Ammar and Al-Hasan to (the people of) Kufa to urge them to fight, `Ammar addressed them saying, "I know that she (i.e. `Aisha) is the wife of the Prophet (ﷺ) in this world and in the Hereafter (world to come), but Allah has put you to test, whether you will follow Him (i.e. Allah) or her."
In regards to the parents of the Prophet SAW, essentially what you are saying is that Allah SWT knows best, so we shouldn’t start talking about whether they would be in heaven or hell. But you must understand that in Sunni literature, it talks about the parents of the Prophet SAW dying as kaffir. Also, the uncle of the Prophet SAW, Abu Talib AS, in Sunni literature, is mentioned in being in the shallow end of hell. The only reason us Shia wish to argue on this matter is because in Sunni literature the family of the Prophet SAW ( meaning father, mother, grandfather and uncle are all described as ending up in hell). This is wrong brother. Let’s start with the mother of the Prophet SAW, Aminah bint Wahab, Sunni claim she was a kaffira, therefore would go to hell. But I ask you, the mother of Isa AS is amongst the best women in Islam, a whole surah called after her name, Maryam, so why would Allah SWT have the mother of the best creation of Allah SWT being a kaffira?. Secondly, the father of the Prophet SAW‘s name was Abdullah so I won’t event go any further on that. The grandfather of the Prophet SAW is the one who named the Prophet SAW Muhammed, obviously he must have been inspired by Allah SWT to come up with the best name. And lastly the uncle of the Prophet SAW, Abu Talib, is the one who raised the Prophet SAW, organised the wedding of Khadija with the Prophet SAW. The father of Imam Ali AS.
Inshallah, you can understand Shia Islam in the position of my heart and the hearts of those who love Ahlulbayt.
It isn't political, Abu Bakr and the rest left the prophet burials and choose to go saqifa. He saw the need of successor on his death bed.
Do u actually believe our prophet didn't appoint a successor but told which day to cut out nails.
Even Sunni have hadiths stating follow the Qur'an and Ahlalbayt. Only the infallible can deduce jurisprudence and sunnah from the Qur'an.
Prophet appointed Imam Ali(a.s) at Gadeer e Qum. That was his commands and that started the Imamat. Sunni believes in the 12 th imam, imam Mahdi who is the children of Fatima but not the imams.
Respected brother read this Ayat in Arabic too Allah is cursing clearly you can check the madudi version if you prefer it says the same
Sahih International: Indeed, those who abuse Allah and His Messenger - Allah has cursed them in this world and the Hereafter and prepared for them a humiliating punishment.
Pickthall: Lo! those who malign Allah and His messenger, Allah hath cursed them in the world and the Hereafter, and hath prepared for them the doom of the disdained.
Yusuf Ali: Those who annoy Allah and His Messenger - Allah has cursed them in this World and in the Hereafter, and has prepared for them a humiliating Punishment.
Shakir: Surely (as for) those who speak evil things of Allah and His Messenger, Allah has cursed them in this world and the here after, and He has prepared for them a chastisement bringing disgrace.
Muhammad Sarwar: Those who annoy God and His Messenger will be condemned by God in this life and in the life to come. He has prepared for them a humiliating torment.
Mohsin Khan: Verily, those who annoy Allah and His Messenger (SAW) Allah has cursed them in this world, and in the Hereafter, and has prepared for them a humiliating torment.
Arberry: Those who hurt God and His Messenger -- them God has cursed in the present world and the world to come, and has prepared for them a humbling chastisement.
Also about the prophet pbuhf parents their are verses to prove that Prophets pbut parents are all Muslims
I am neither shia nor sunni but i do think that sunni orthodoxy is defined by what it's not especially when it comes to shafii and hanbali sects and i view it personally as an attempt to monopolize the religion(futile of course since allah subhanah wa taalaa said his religion is one) i think hanbalis/salafis/wahabis(collectively of course i met many decent and respectable individuals from those schools of thought)really stand in opposition to unifying the ummah through discourse by the cheer amount of takfir salam
بسم اللّٰہ الرحمٰن الرحیم یا رب محمد وآل محمد صل علیٰ محمد وآل محمد و عجل فرج آل محمد علیہم السلام ۔
Alhumdulilah ex sunni
authobillah
Hey omeri@@AmaanKhan-gq3qv
take a bow sayed. truly a masterclass. thank you for the enlightenment
After Ali passed away, the Ummayad ruled. Most of the Ummayad caliphs were not religious. The Caliphs rely on the scholars for fatwas. Imam Malik lived in Medina. He was a scholar, and he gave fatwas.
Abu Hanifa lived in Iraq, and he gave fatwa.
The 4 schools are called school of jurisprudence.
There was one great caliph from umayyad , named umar bin abdul azeez
@@izharcohen4572 Yes, he was called the "Second Umar".
Most of the Ummayad and Abbasid Caliphs and governors were not God-fearing and lived lavish lifestyles. These people were political leaders, NOT religious leaders. That's why they rely on the 4 fiqh imams(scholars) for fatwas,solutions, etc.
All the 4 imams were tortured by the Caliphs and governors of their time. Abu Hanifa was poisoned.
Finally, Hulagu Khan invaded and destroyed the Abbasid Empire.
Allah is All Knowing. 🕌🤲
@@izharcohen4572 Why was great?
@@agostocobain2729 he bring prosperity to all people until there is no one accept zakat
I am so convinced by your "references"...woah....i am going to convert to a "Sunni"
We are Muslims and that for me is more important because Allah named us so. Allah will definitely judge us hence instead of holding grudges against one another, let’s consider the Quran and the prophet (SAW) and leave that which is doubtful. Allah knows best 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
طيب الله أنفاسكم سيدنا مأجورين
786
Salaam, Sayed!
I haven't finished watching the whole lecture, but I thought I would quickly enter here two observations (before I forget to 😉).
1. Re: Knowing the religious affiliation of people from their first names: it is really sad that many Muslims are forced to change their names to name associated to other faiths. For instance, in France, many Shia resort to French, Christian names, so as to avoid discrimination; in India, many change their names to Hindu names, for the same reason.
2. Various schools of Sunni Islam: none of the non Shia Muslims I have met in this country (Canada) have been able to state what school to belonged to: they would give me a blank look; some would simply say that they are Muslim. And the same applies to a few refugees from Syria who say that they are Shia. What school? No answer.
May Allah protect you, Sayed, and keep you from all evil. Aameen.
اللهم صل على محمد و آل محمد الطيبين الطاهرين و عجل فرجهم بظهور الحجه و العن اعدائهم من الاولين والاخرين الى يوم الدين
Amazing thanks for sharing all this informative information
Proud of the kid who was saying salawaat alone
How many of you have read the Quran?
Assalamualaikum wa rahmantullahi wa barakatuh #BrightFacedPeople #SHIA ☪️ 🕋🤲🏾🖤🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴
بسم اللّٰہ الرحمٰن الرحیم اللھم صل علیٰ محمد وآل محمد اولی الامر الذین فرضت علینا طاعتھم و عرفتنا بذالک منزلتھم علیہم السلام والعن علیٰ اعدائھم فی الدنیا والآخرۃ
Man just buried the entire 1400 years of a sect.
Ah. Less than 1300
How can the Original be a sect ? You are a Sect ! You came after. So you are Wrong.
@@classicchrome716you guys came after
@@huss313hamdellah oh the prophet Muhammad s a w came after shiaism ?? Because all I know the prophet s a w was a Sunni. You don't know what you're talking about!
Allah forgives all with their good Amal
🤲 JAZAKALLAH Sayed
Very nice lecture sayed
Masallah sheikh..
Thank you for this
Nice explain
I can’t thank you enough for this wonderful lecture. Please do a lecture on Ismaili Shia. I would love to know why they follow Agha Khan
He already has! Search on youtube it will apear, i also watched it 2 or 3 days ago
Ismailis are not Muslims
@@amnahabbas1877Ismailis are Muslims. They’re Ismaili shias like how zaiddiyah are Shia but different sect
Thanks but i want to know the lectures of shia islam to know more and to have full iman on shia islam am sunni on may way to shizm could you suggests me RUclips teachers
Question.. Why are the so few brothers who are on the Shia Manhaj who have memorized the entire Quraan?
SubhanAllah the logic of shia Islam ❤ I pray for the misguided Sunnis their beliefs are totally flawed in every sense.
Is it that some Muslims were created with the highest IQs and others no IQ at all? The more anyone tries to explain the Sunni faith the more awkwardly and weirder it gets. A faith where there’s no clear distinction between wrong and right. Mr Wrong and Mr Right are both Correct, and everyone must follow them both to attain Salvation. What the heck is that if it’s not a Pure Political Movement!
Very well said
Spot on
Let me guess, you're a high IQ individual?