I saw someone question why sieun is the main vocalist and said it's because of her soft voice but she the main vocalist because of her superior technique compared to the other girls
popularity ranking: 1. Isa (her got number 1 jn Stereotype era including kprofile voting) 2. yoon (her got the second in Kprofile 3. J 4. Sieun 5. Sumin 6. Seeun
my rankings: vocal: 1. sieun (clearly) 2. isa (not even questioned, have you heard her live?) 3. yoon (she's not bad she's just pitchy and i don't feel like she's found her tone yet, but she's a very powerful vocalist and doesn't hold back, which i love) *edited - i moved her up since the twinkle live show, she ate!* 4.seeun (i think she has a decent technique that usually gets overlooked) 5. j (her deep voice is very appealing, though i don't think she's found her tone or style yet.) 6. sumin (she sounds great in the studio versions, but very underwhelming during acoustics. shes a tricky one as her voice is very powerful during live stages, but weak during live acoustic performances. i think she has an idol voice, ie typically underaverage in terms of singing, yet powerful for live stages. no suprise since she has the most idol training.) dance: 1. isa (such an icon) 2. sumin: idk why she's ranked so low, literally go look at any of her dance videos lol 3. sieun (that clip was not a good example. i'm sure there are more examples of sieun's dancing capabilities but she seemed very stiff and over danced in alot of the parts of the more & more cover. *she's my bias i can say these things*) *edit - moved her up bc she eats live! 4. seeun (great example clip) 5. yoon (naughty is a pretty hard choreo, but she owned it.) 6. j (typical idol dancing, nothing bad or crazy good
For visual mostly kswith saying Seeun,they also believe she the main visual.. when obviously highup always highlight her when its came to visual position,1thek ,Esquire korea new one WKorea isa write Seeun position as incharge of Visual..there's no ways she introduce herself as Beauty of STAYC ,Face genius and Visual in different interview if its not true..member also agrees..when her graduats Highup they Ceo even calling Seeun as Best Visual.. remind y'all Seeun trainee position previous Play M is Visual and Center ..
visual rank (ot6 stan, my opinion not standarts) 1. Seeun 2. Sieun 3. J 4. Isa 5. Yoon/Sumin again, not solo stan but all the members are pretty in their own way, it isn't bc yoon and sumin are the last that they aren't my favs, sumin is my 2nd bias
My opinion: Vocal: 1-Sieun (her tecnhnique is impeccable) 2-Yoon (her technique is too good) 3-Isa (she has a pretty voice,but have to improve power and agility) 4-J (her technique is at Yoon’s level,but have to improve on the high notes) 5-Sumin (has an acceptable technique) 6-Seeun (has an acceptable technique,but she has no vocal agility) Rap: 1-J (her voice is perfect for rap,has fluency,good intonation and power) 2-Sumin (she has a good technique,emotion in her voice,but lacks in flow) 3-Sieun (her voice is so sweet,and she got a little flow,so it’s nice to hear her rap) 4-Yoon (she has power and good intonation,but her voice isn’t cut out for rap) 5- Isa and Seeun (I never heard them rapping) Dance: 1-Sieun (she has a good technique,has flow power and agility,she’s a good idol dancer) 2-Isa (the same for her,but specially her facial expressions are soo good) 3-Sumin (she’s good,but lacks in fluidity) 4-Seeun (she’s also good,but doesn’t have a remarkable dance style) 5-Yoon (she’s good,but her measurements make her dance look clumsy,it’s something that happens very often to tall people) 6-J (she had little training time,so her technique needs to improve) Visual: 1-Yoon (her visual caught the attention of international and korean fans,she meets all the standards except the length of her face) 2-J (Koreans find J so pretty,she resembles a puppy. Meets all the standards except face length) 3-Seeun (Koreans thought that she was the visual from the beginning,they find her face so elegant and pleasant. Meets all the standards except the shape of her body) 4-Isa (Isa is sooo pretty,she’s more popular amount the international fans than korean fans,she meets all the standards except her nose) 5-Sumin (Sumin is pretty,but her face size is big,she hasn’t high nose bridge and she is less than 165cm) 6-Sieun (her face is in the cute side,and she’s less than 165cm). I got the sources of the visual ranking from a video where Stacy looks for their name on websites,and according to the fans,Stayc’s visual line is Yoon,J and Seeun.
i'm not an expert in dance so i'll give my opinion about vocal and rap vocal: -sieun (she has a perfect technique, knows how to control her voice and is very stable and good with high notes) -yoon (she has a great techinque too, her vocal range is wide and can reach easily high notes) -isa (she has a pretty voice and is very good at changing from chest to head voice, but have to improve power and stability on stage) -J (she knows too how to control her voice and has a great technique, her voice is deep so struggles in high notes but still is very stable and clear) -seeun (her technique is not bad but still has to improve agility and learn how to control her voice, she is very stable tho) -sumin (she has an unique and deep voice, her technique needs to improve, she has quite a wide vocal range but needs to learn how to control it) rap: -J (she has good intonation, power, good diction and flow, and her voice is perfect for rapping) -sumin (she has emotion in her voice, power and a great technique but needs to improve flow and sense of rithm) -seeun (lacks power but has flow and good intonation, great diction) -sieun (her voice is soft and suits sweetest types of raps, has good diction, needs to improve flow) -isa (we never hear her rap but her voice doesn't suit rap and she hasn't power)
I feel like Isa and Sieun have cute visuals, so high up "force" them to do a cute voice ??? I think Isa yes, bc her voice is different when she's talking, and they have a cute voice, so it doesn't fit as a rapper (My opinion as a both stan)
Isa is number 2 for me, because i find yoons voice too nasally for my taste, i can still appreciate a good voice though. she is a very talented girl and shes so pretty. Just because shes not my personal favourite does not mean in any way that shes bad
STAYC ranking for my opinion: Dance: 1. Isa (her had so much energy and her expression is good) 2. Sieun (her is good too) 3. Sumin/J (they did they best and they are so cute) 4. Seeun (her is okay but maybe not better) 5. Yoon (her had to practice but it's okay) Vocal: 1. Sieun (I don't know why her being a main Vocalist of STAYC, but maybe because her soft voice) 2. Isa (I think Isa is better than Yoon) 3. Yoon (I like Her voice too but hmm I think Isa is better) 4. Seeun (like her voice too) 5. Sumin (her had a great job. I like her voice but maybe her didn't suit being a vocal) 6. J (her had a deep voice but I think her can be rapper) Rap: 1. J (just like I said) 2. Sumin (just like I said too) 3. Isa (her can rap Lisa love to hate me rap part) 4. Seeun (her had a deep voice) 5. Sieun (if her main/lead dancer, why her can't rap?) 6. Yoon (I don't know that her can rap or not?) Visual: 1. Isa (her visual is reached Korean beauty standard) 2. Yoon/seeun (they just had cute face and visual too) 3. Sumin (I think Sumin is more pretty than J) 4. J (her is pretty but I think Sumin is better) 5. Sieun (her is just had a cute face
@@antuanetfarfancandia3322 Lol It's really obvious. Isa is definitely not better than Yoon in vocals. She is slightly better than Seeun. Actually technically Yoon is 1st.
Based on these ranking I calculated scores for stage presence, rap, vocals and dancing, to see which idol is the “best” overall 1: Isa 10 points 2: Sieun 11 points 3: Yoon 13 points 4: Sumin 14 points 5/6 Seeun and J 18 points Would you agree with this?
![[UPDATE] LOONA RANKING IN DIFFERENT CATEGORIES](/img/1.gif)
I saw someone question why sieun is the main vocalist and said it's because of her soft voice but she the main vocalist because of her superior technique compared to the other girls
seeun is underrated singing, and I think high up could add yoon as a main vocalist too, as a sieun ult.
popularity ranking:
1. Isa (her got number 1 jn Stereotype era including kprofile voting)
2. yoon (her got the second in Kprofile
3. J
4. Sieun
5. Sumin
6. Seeun
It changed its
1. Isa
2. Yoon
3. Sumin
4. J
5. Seeun
6. Sieun
@@pinkyuna1937 sieun was famous before her debut I wouldn't put her that low
@@ir4txe that’s what Kprofile says
@@pinkyuna1937kprofile can spam vote
I truly believe that Isa meets all beauty standards.
I think J is a great vocalist
It's just her voice doesn't fit the concept and she has a deep voice that should be used rarely in songs
she really is but in this group they're all great vocalists so compared to the others she's ranked low
My opinion
Vocal
1. Sieun
2. Yoon
3. Isa
4. Seeun
5. Sumin
6. J
Rap
1. Sumin
2. J
3. Yoon
4. Isa
5. Sieun, seeun
Dance
1. Isa
2. Sieun
3. Sumin
4. Seeun
5. Yoon
6. J
Visual
1. Isa
2. Yoon
3. Sieun
4. J
5. Sumin
6. Seeun
Bias
1. Isa
2. Seiun
3. J
4. Seeun
5. Sumin
6. Yoon
1. Sieun
2. Isa
3. Yoon
4. Sumin
5. Seeun
6. J
1. Sieun 25
2. Isa 26
3. Yoon 26
4. Sumin 26
5. Seeun 30
6. J 35
isa what a treasure
my rankings:
vocal:
1. sieun (clearly)
2. isa (not even questioned, have you heard her live?)
3. yoon (she's not bad she's just pitchy and i don't feel like she's found her tone yet, but she's a very powerful vocalist and doesn't hold back, which i love) *edited - i moved her up since the twinkle live show, she ate!*
4.seeun (i think she has a decent technique that usually gets overlooked)
5. j (her deep voice is very appealing, though i don't think she's found her tone or style yet.)
6. sumin (she sounds great in the studio versions, but very underwhelming during acoustics. shes a tricky one as her voice is very powerful during live stages, but weak during live acoustic performances. i think she has an idol voice, ie typically underaverage in terms of singing, yet powerful for live stages. no suprise since she has the most idol training.)
dance:
1. isa (such an icon)
2. sumin: idk why she's ranked so low, literally go look at any of her dance videos lol
3. sieun (that clip was not a good example. i'm sure there are more examples of sieun's dancing capabilities but she seemed very stiff and over danced in alot of the parts of the more & more cover. *she's my bias i can say these things*) *edit - moved her up bc she eats live!
4. seeun (great example clip)
5. yoon (naughty is a pretty hard choreo, but she owned it.)
6. j (typical idol dancing, nothing bad or crazy good
For visual mostly kswith saying Seeun,they also believe she the main visual.. when obviously highup always highlight her when its came to visual position,1thek ,Esquire korea new one WKorea isa write Seeun position as incharge of Visual..there's no ways she introduce herself as Beauty of STAYC ,Face genius and Visual in different interview if its not true..member also agrees..when her graduats Highup they Ceo even calling Seeun as Best Visual..
remind y'all Seeun trainee position previous Play M is Visual and Center ..
visual rank (ot6 stan, my opinion not standarts)
1. Seeun
2. Sieun
3. J
4. Isa
5. Yoon/Sumin
again, not solo stan but all the members are pretty in their own way, it isn't bc yoon and sumin are the last that they aren't my favs, sumin is my 2nd bias
My opinion:
Vocal:
1-Sieun (her tecnhnique is impeccable)
2-Yoon (her technique is too good)
3-Isa (she has a pretty voice,but have to improve power and agility)
4-J (her technique is at Yoon’s level,but have to improve on the high notes)
5-Sumin (has an acceptable technique)
6-Seeun (has an acceptable technique,but she has no vocal agility)
Rap:
1-J (her voice is perfect for rap,has fluency,good intonation and power)
2-Sumin (she has a good technique,emotion in her voice,but lacks in flow)
3-Sieun (her voice is so sweet,and she got a little flow,so it’s nice to hear her rap)
4-Yoon (she has power and good intonation,but her voice isn’t cut out for rap)
5- Isa and Seeun (I never heard them rapping)
Dance:
1-Sieun (she has a good technique,has flow power and agility,she’s a good idol dancer)
2-Isa (the same for her,but specially her facial expressions are soo good)
3-Sumin (she’s good,but lacks in fluidity)
4-Seeun (she’s also good,but doesn’t have a remarkable dance style)
5-Yoon (she’s good,but her measurements make her dance look clumsy,it’s something that happens very often to tall people)
6-J (she had little training time,so her technique needs to improve)
Visual:
1-Yoon (her visual caught the attention of international and korean fans,she meets all the standards except the length of her face)
2-J (Koreans find J so pretty,she resembles a puppy. Meets all the standards except face length)
3-Seeun (Koreans thought that she was the visual from the beginning,they find her face so elegant and pleasant. Meets all the standards except the shape of her body)
4-Isa (Isa is sooo pretty,she’s more popular amount the international fans than korean fans,she meets all the standards except her nose)
5-Sumin (Sumin is pretty,but her face size is big,she hasn’t high nose bridge and she is less than 165cm)
6-Sieun (her face is in the cute side,and she’s less than 165cm).
I got the sources of the visual ranking from a video where Stacy looks for their name on websites,and according to the fans,Stayc’s visual line is Yoon,J and Seeun.
agreed with all!!
J is an all rounder
I think Isa should be the visual because she fits the Korean Beauty Standards the most
isa and sieun are really aces
i'm not an expert in dance so i'll give my opinion about vocal and rap
vocal:
-sieun (she has a perfect technique, knows how to control her voice and is very stable and good with high notes)
-yoon (she has a great techinque too, her vocal range is wide and can reach easily high notes)
-isa (she has a pretty voice and is very good at changing from chest to head voice, but have to improve power and stability on stage)
-J (she knows too how to control her voice and has a great technique, her voice is deep so struggles in high notes but still is very stable and clear)
-seeun (her technique is not bad but still has to improve agility and learn how to control her voice, she is very stable tho)
-sumin (she has an unique and deep voice, her technique needs to improve, she has quite a wide vocal range but needs to learn how to control it)
rap:
-J (she has good intonation, power, good diction and flow, and her voice is perfect for rapping)
-sumin (she has emotion in her voice, power and a great technique but needs to improve flow and sense of rithm)
-seeun (lacks power but has flow and good intonation, great diction)
-sieun (her voice is soft and suits sweetest types of raps, has good diction, needs to improve flow)
-isa (we never hear her rap but her voice doesn't suit rap and she hasn't power)
Agreed for your all opinion👍
GREAT video, I didn't know the 6 of them could rap.
my visual ranking
1. Isa
2. Seeun
3. Yoon
4. Yoon
5. J
6. Sieun
but theyre all absolutely stunning
sumin said: 👻
Two "Yoon"? And where's Sumin? Lol
Sumin vocal is better than j
yes she's really stable in live
Most popular is worst
1 is Isa
2 is yoon
3 is sumin
4 is j
5 is seeun
6 is sieun
Vote from profile
Kprofile can Spam vote
I feel like Isa and Sieun have cute visuals, so high up "force" them to do a cute voice ??? I think Isa yes, bc her voice is different when she's talking, and they have a cute voice, so it doesn't fit as a rapper (My opinion as a both stan)
Isa is number 2 for me, because i find yoons voice too nasally for my taste, i can still appreciate a good voice though.
she is a very talented girl and shes so pretty. Just because shes not my personal favourite does not mean in any way that shes bad
Ｓｔａｙｃ ｖｉｓｕａｌ ｍｅｍｂｅｒ ｉｓ ＩＳＡ
There are things that you put like Rap that is just a melodic song.
STAYC ranking for my opinion:
Dance:
1. Isa (her had so much energy and her expression is good)
2. Sieun (her is good too)
3. Sumin/J (they did they best and they are so cute)
4. Seeun (her is okay but maybe not better)
5. Yoon (her had to practice but it's okay)
Vocal:
1. Sieun (I don't know why her being a main Vocalist of STAYC, but maybe because her soft voice)
2. Isa (I think Isa is better than Yoon)
3. Yoon (I like Her voice too but hmm I think Isa is better)
4. Seeun (like her voice too)
5. Sumin (her had a great job. I like her voice but maybe her didn't suit being a vocal)
6. J (her had a deep voice but I think her can be rapper)
Rap:
1. J (just like I said)
2. Sumin (just like I said too)
3. Isa (her can rap Lisa love to hate me rap part)
4. Seeun (her had a deep voice)
5. Sieun (if her main/lead dancer, why her can't rap?)
6. Yoon (I don't know that her can rap or not?)
Visual:
1. Isa (her visual is reached Korean beauty standard)
2. Yoon/seeun (they just had cute face and visual too)
3. Sumin (I think Sumin is more pretty than J)
4. J (her is pretty but I think Sumin is better)
5. Sieun (her is just had a cute face
yoon can rap: slow down(stayc)
she can rap fast to!
Eres Isa biased?
Bruh why you gotta disrespect Yoon and Sieun’s vocal abilities like that.
@@antuanetfarfancandia3322 Lol
It's really obvious. Isa is definitely not better than Yoon in vocals. She is slightly better than Seeun. Actually technically Yoon is 1st.
Yoon is better than isa factually
Unpopular opinion: Isa is the best vocalist of StayC
Ok, but factually she isn’t (no hate, just saying).
@@eatingyourpizza9260 who do u think is the best?
@@bigkostan8401 Sieun or Yoon
Not really
@@ir4txe isa is better because she is less nasal and whiny
Isa its my bias
Sieeu is so kewl
Honestly if I’m being absolutely unbiased, I really don’t like Sumins voice. Plus she does this yo-yo thing with her voice that I really dislike.
Based on these ranking I calculated scores for stage presence, rap, vocals and dancing, to see which idol is the “best” overall
1: Isa 10 points
2: Sieun 11 points
3: Yoon 13 points
4: Sumin 14 points
5/6 Seeun and J 18 points
Would you agree with this?
I think Yoon vocal could better than Sieun, cuz i think Siuen don't have vocal support
really not accurate...
in my opinion J has a good voice really good even her low note is good and her presence is very noticable. can agree.
her voice is good, just not as good as the others above her. also her stage presence seems to just be her doing the 1 note girl crush look
Tudo errado