‘Embarrassment for Labor’: South Australia’s push for state-based Voice ‘backfires’
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июн 2024
- Sky News host Rowan Dean says the South Australian Labor government’s decision to push ahead with a state-based Voice has “backfired”.
Mr Dean described it as an “embarrassment for Labor”.
“We all voted against the Voice but no Labor … thinks it knows better,” he said.
“Just over nine per cent of Indigenous Australians in South Australia turned out to vote following a resounding no vote in the federal referendum.”
Liberal MLC Ben Hood joined Sky News hosts Rowan Dean, Rita Panahi and James Morrow to discuss South Australia’s state-based Voice.
![Kehlani - Next 2 U [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MpI7ekFG8A0/mqdefault.jpg)
Big middle finger to the SA Voice by the legendary Australian Aboriginals! Well done brothers and sisters!
I love ❤️ South Australia.
Good on ya from Western Australia.
But as usual the Labor party won’t listen to the indigenous people and push ahead which what they tell them they should have!
The Representative for Central Adelaide Moogy Sumner
Up yours Peter Malaka
Good on you from NSW
We voted No to apartheid
No to racism
No to the Voice
...and vote NO, to undemocratic practices.
You voted "No" to a Voice enshrined in the Australian Constitution!!
@@ralphmogridge8364 ...and why did they do that? What were their reasons for voting, "No", to that proposal? If you ask people, you'll find they are largely the same reasons, for their rejection of these state sponsored initiatives.
Alternatively, perhaps you prefer being an out of touch lefty, increasingly dependent on support from inner-city, champagne socialists and an Islamic community preaching homophobia and misogyny with 10 times the vigour of Tony Abbott.
I doubt I've told you anything that you did not already know. So, stop feigning ignorance and just say what you really wanted to say.
...and they're trying to force all three on you anyway.
@@ralphmogridge8364 Why did they vote that way?
This could not be a clearer sign of how useless the Voice is when when not even the aboriginal people are willing to participate in it
The REAL aboriginal people i would listen to, not fake one's, mayo , pasco.etc
Don't forget that clown with the hat he is whiter than me
🎯 the aboriginal people are being used by the WEF lead government to push an collectivist agenda. It is disgusting 😒
Yes absolutely agree
Don't forget Pearson, that grifter who lives in the most caucasian place in Oz. Wouldn't want to get any red dirt on his hat!!
What doesn’t our governments understand about the word “No”… 60 percent of Australian voters voted no.
Come on Australia vote these socialist/ communist out.
Labor continues to humiliate themselves all around the country. South Australians said NO, and now South Australia’s Aboriginal population have also said NO.
It was for a Representative not a Yes or No why are you people so thick
www.savoiceelection.sa.gov.au/voting/results
please they are not the "first peoples", first colonists maybe, but there are records of people being here before them, which just turns them into the "first known invaders".
(time to read the diaries of Matthew Flinders for a history lesson).
@@bettysteve322716you want to compare 65,000 and 1060 generations to 6-8 generations of British colonisation or the non-substantiation a mythical pygmy race!!! Show your evidence please!
@@ralphmogridge8364 ahh the old "prove it cause l'm too lazy to disprove your evidence" ploy. How about checking out the journals of Matthew Flinders who wrote of seeing "the tall natives hunting and killing the small natives" for starters, l wasn't there so what do l know, and that's just to start with.
But then, l'm not a white saviour who is virtue signalling how good they are and how much they are helping the poor ignorant black and brown people who need my help to get ahead, they are so oppressed they can't do anything without my help. check.
@@ralphmogridge8364 65,000 years so where did you pull that number from? "prove your number", see how it works?
The SA premier must resign he’s a National disgrace
Here too - WA.
And God help us in Vic...
@@TheKarls22 Definitely..we here next door in SA have seen the political destruction that Andrews left you. And now Allen is no different. One would have to be a moron over there to believe that Andrews did any good for the state at all.
The whole Australian government needs to go. The lot is an embarrassment to us all
@@iggyguy88897 all servants of the UN and NWO - not us, the people or this nation.
Another humiliating defeat for the aborigine grievance industry activists.
Well said! It is truly the "aboriginal grievance industry" and it is designed to last for eternity. Everyone is hurting because of the food cartels, the bank cartels, the fuel cartels, we are being gouged everywhere and these corporate scum are posting huge profits everywhere while record numbers of aussies are being pushed to the poverty line and Labor can only focus on some ridiculous ideological crap that 30 billion a year every year cant fix. Sack every minister for Aboriginal affairs in every state in the country and at federal level for gross incompetence.
Aboriginal industrial complex
They may not have voted but it still passed
what defeat? it still went through.
@@user-bn4jk8gn1k
No one is taking this seriously now. It’s pissing in the wind.
How much did this Bullshit cost the people who work.
If it cost more than $1.00 it was too much
well over a million dollars of taxpayers money
Got to remember they r more important than ppl who r not aboriginal …..It’s only our taxes that pay for this rubbish…Labor equals racism….
Ask someone who actually works.
These Dickheads should not be allowed to use taxpayers money.😢
Why would Labor listen to what the people voted for? They never listened before
Socialists always believe they know how to handle things worse than everyone else.
This low turnout is perfect for them. They will install who they want without any fuss
@@baddaddy8718 When Liberals win the next election in S.A. they will repeal it if Malinauskas doesn't get some ballz and do it himself before.
there is only one way to make them listen stop voting them in federal and state, they are so arrogant just look at the PM.
Very true, and as for the Greens, they listen to the little voices in their heads.
Shameful waste of taxpayers money..
The list of reasons to vote labor out just got bigger!
Why can't Labor except NO is NOOOOOO Simple as that.
Because the UN won't accept NO! And the UN will keep knoring away until they have Australia girt by sea firmly in their NWO grip.
Because they are dumb f**kwits.
It goes against their dogmatic ideology. They believe the majority of people DON'T KNOW what's good for them so "they vill do vhat they are told"....or else.
Because they have no ears ,
Because Labor are borderline communists.
As a South Australian and NO voter…I am fuming 😡 Peter Malinauskas hides a forked tongue behind his smile…he’s as slimy as they come!
pity for us that the libs are so pathetic as they only won 1 term... what is wrong with them?????! and i always vote liberal... state and federal....
@@albertbresca8904, agree that the SA Libs are weak. David Speirs is too whiny and does not inspire confidence. The SA Libs need someone like Alex Antic to run the show.
@@cliff2891 i thought marshal had the cohones ... well at least enough to last more than 1 term... but he fell so fast... do you know why ? i usually avoid australian politics as it is quite boring compared to american stuff that just makes me laugh (and cry...sometimes...)
well there is part of our issue. libs and lab have been in power for too long. time to ditch them for a smaller fresh party that cares, even if its only a little bit more. we keep voting for the same crap parties over and over and complain when nothing gets better.
PHON and UAP have been getting my vote for the last few elections and will continue to for the forseable future. libs n lab are at the bottoe with greens
@@mmorgz6622 sadly i don't think the UAP or phon are ever going to win government... Phon is not known of much out of qld...
They should just bury 'The Voice". Nobody wants it, its ridiculous!
The comment is good b7t some do want it, the vast majority over 2/3 don’t and they only come out now and again to say so. Just like the referendum.
the globalists want it, so they can steal the land under U.N.D.R.I.P. (look it up it's even on wikki, the untrusted source of government propaganda)
not even the aboriginals want it.. they can see that the left are just wanting to run this - i guess that explains why labor want it so bad as it is a backdoor power system for them... totally understandable in that context i guess...
When will the Labor, Greens, LNP start listening to the people?
Vote One Nation.
pauline was good the first time when she started but their message seems to have gotten lost...
Yes, spell it out. South Australia is not a democracy any more. Banana republic of South Australia.
Nooo, not really. It shows we are a strong democratic federation of states and not a republic. That's what Labor wants. To turn us into a Republic. So Alt Albo can write all these far left idealistic dreams into an executive order. Because he will be El Presidente. So I guess there's more than a bit of blue sky out of all of this. It also shows that our indigenous community has as little faith in their own that represent them as we do in ours
Be careful for what you wish for . Australia is not a democracy , it's a Constitutional Monarchy although our unlawful politicians and parliaments don't care . Read our Constitution . The Commonwealth Of Australia Constitution Act 1900 ( UK ) , the red cover not the fake green one .
The "REGIME" of South Australia.
Democracy is a poor form of government.. It's just marginally better than every other form
@DernRern Was there ever really a democracy or was it all just an illusion?
It would be nice if every day people had a voice
They did brother. We in SA voted 63% NO. It’s just the current woketard socialist Labor cnuts dont get what democracy is.
Unfortunately that would be seen as discrimination and racism
Only then to endure having judgemental woke celeb spinning around in leather chair bemoaning whichever "ism, phobic and/or pro-noun misgendering" has them offended..???
we did have a voice, but the lefty loons in SA hate democracy.
How much is this costing the South Australian taxpayer ? and what happened to Democracy ?
It's a mot for profit
Big swinging 🍆
What democracy , it's communistic action by Labor .
Approx 10million over 4 years. When SA has more issues than this to deal with.
Shame Labor.
www.statebudget.sa.gov.au/our-budget/indigenous-communities#:~:text=The%20Voice%20will%20be%20a,First%20Nations%20Voice%20to%20Parliament.
How has democracy been threatened?
@@indiathylane2158representation by taxation, taxation by representation. Stop taking what you never gave.
theirs no end to the evilness of Labor
Its what Democrats do in America also - race baiting & dividing people.
For political power & money. It's an industry.
The people have spoken, twice.
They wont listen - they have their own political agenda.
It won't stop them appointing dozens of people to hundred thousand plus dollar jobs.
Yep just great - and we just got a notification that our local council rates here in SA are going up by at least 8%. Taxpayers money could be better spent on infrastructure maintenance such as jetties in SA.
Politicians are overstepping their mark.
Politics is becoming to powerful needs to be pulled up people are sick of the corruption in government
Its what Democrats do in America also - race baiting & dividing people.
For political power & money. It's an industry.
As a NO voter (the highest No vote of all states), I am disgusted at SA going ahead with this.
Melbourne City council is doing the same.
What did you vote "No" for again??....are you and other "No" voters saying you voted for no progress in Aboriginal health, education, justice, etc etc progress across Australia.....or was it just a voice in the constitution!
@@ralphmogridge8364 this is why you lost. you are itching to call us all racists aren't you?
@@ralphmogridge8364 umm... it might be becasue a LOT of Aboriginals told people to vote no... as they saw it for what it was ... just a voice for the left.. and not to help the actual people who it said it woudl help....
sad you don't realise this....
@@user-bn4jk8gn1k yep it seems so...lol
and there were so many Aboriginals telling people to vote no as they dond't want this...
so much for a united voice huh?
it was just another ATSIC anyway
Not even aboriginals want aboriginals in parliament. Even at the state level, the numbers don't lie.
Labor, the naughty child that just won't listen. 🙄
More like a superiority complex
why should they? people still keep voting for them... they woudl only learn if there was an reasonable alternative government... to the lnp and labor
What a waste of peoples time & money!
Labour seem very slow to learn the lesson that NO means NO.
Aboriginals don’t want the mark of the Beast 😂
Notice the trend? All Labor governments in this country are an utter embarrassment.
and? Vic voted Dan back in after his covid disaster. Qld voted Anna back in, and with the Olympics disaster... they'll still vote labor back in, or the LNP will inherit the Olympics disaster, find a way to fix it, and then get voted out after one term. And same for SA. hopeless! people are uninformed and generally stupid.
again...lol
We DON'T need the voice , we just need to learn to get along simple as that
That's right !!💯👍
Because of the deceptive Labor government in SA ill be definitely voting Labor out.
and what, vote back the libs who, after 2 (failed) referendums into GMO crops being grown in South Australia, that, rather than try a third loss, they just legislated it against the publics wishes.
and when we tried to vote the minors in, "preferential voting" gave us THIS mob.
maybe we can give them only 1 term as well...lol
When your own people dont show up to vote for division 😂😂😂😂😂
Thank you to those aboriginal people who declined to vote in this divisive exercise. I appreciate your rejection of a race-based division of Australians.
More money wasted
The trouble with a weak shitty Labor party just means we will get a slightly less weak shitty Liberal party. There is no pressure for either of them to improve.
As a South Australian with indigenous blood, I voted no as did most the people I know.
Was sneaky and shady from start to finish, now they're trying to illegally push it through my state?
Nah, not on.
it's done.
thankyou dude... this just seems anotehr backdoor power thing for lefties and not for Aboriginals...
Labor will install these activist representatives regardless, pay them a fortune ,
all whilst (clearly) not representing 90% of all indigenous South Australians.
That can’t be considered even a quorum. The vote is null and void. The whole idea needs to be dumped.
It seems that way but according to Labor it's right that 2,583 voters should have their representatives tell 1,860,100 South Australians what they can and can't do.
This is not the labor party that I voted form in the 70, 80, and 90's, they to to far left, to be of any good the the majority of Australian...!!
They stopped being Labour since Kevin Rudd, and Albo has a history in-the socialist left, so here we are.
Voting for anything in this country is a complete waste of time.
literally the only reason i vote is to avoid the fine!😅
@@ThatGuy-ze5kk Same here.
no.. it is not that bad..
at least we have a democracy.. and freedom...
look at venezuela that labor and the unions used to crow about... they dont anymore
@@albertbresca8904 Are you sure we have a democracy? We get to vote, sure, and then the politicians do the opposite of what we voted for.
@@johnsmith-ub7vr labor do the opposite yes.. lnp usually what they promised... and sometimes what labor promised 9ndis and the monopoly nbn... ) ..
usually labor spends and drives us into debt...libs save as they are conserv.ative.
so two sides of the same thing i guess - one spends and other saves... well they used to but the libs seems to be spending as well... sigh...
at least we have a choice... neither is perfect true but they hate eachother with a passion...
it is not as if we have a crazy dictatorship like venezuella...
we are still the lucky country - although not as lucky as we once were sadly it seems....
Federal Voice failed
State Voice failed
What's next, maybe a council Voice.
That's what Clover Moore is pushing for in Sydney
We voted NO
South Australia voted no !
Next election can't come fast enough.
People power..push back S.A
Nah - the stupid SA suckers just keep voting labor or greens so just bend over and take it.
I can't believe the general population in Sa have had no consultation on this process going forward . We voted against the voice so why should we be doing this , The money being paid to this program is ridiculous and apparently the numbers now don't add up. Thank goodness for that. Wipe it out completely .
Yes. "Wipe it out completely...", and make the ALP & the Greens, pay the bill from their own pockets.
Agree. A comunist Labor Government which is ignoring theit voters. Roll on an election to remove them.
Time for the SA ALP, to hold another, "Sorry Day" and apologise to taxpayers. They loved attacking others for not being able to apologise.
You were given a chance to have a say and you lot voted the ALP drones in again so you have to live with it for a few years. Clearly more thought before you have another chance to vote is needed.
Malanuskas is a millionaire- he can pay for his virtue project.
Why aren't the Outsiders talking about the passing of the freedom robbing Digital ID Legislation ?
A full audit on the cost to the Australian taxpayer on the $40 Bn per year on this nonsense!
We already had a costly referendum on 'The Voice and It was soundly defeated. Kindly GAGF.
Malinauskas has never given a cr-p about South Australians or what we want.
its a WEF young global leaders initiative graduate same as macron, spewdeau, sunak (the installed without a vote).
ALP/GRNs loves racial division!
Labor.. something has gone seriously wrong with those clowns.. All operating under the influence of Albenese.. 🇦🇺
Who is a puppet for the WEF
Candidates didn't even vote for themselves???? Another ALBO joke...... and of course, he'll reimburse the costs of this stupid exercise????
Hard to believe. they did not vote for themselves
Some were voted in on less than 10 votes that is not a democratic election that is picking sides for a football game funded by working SA people.
The Australian Human Rights Commissions definition of racism is as follows: " Racism is the process by which systems and policies, actions and attitude,, create inequitable opportunities and outcomes for people, based on race." The South Australian Government is in BREACH of the Australian Human Rights Commission and should be prosecuted for its RACIST ACTIONS.
This country has become a laughing stock
Woah so it turns out even the aboriginals dont want this voice...good on them for seeing through this wyt fella deception
Maybe now Albo might realize that Australia and South Australia want no part of The Voice, No means No and don't try and keep it in Albo will never give up with his plot to divide Australia he is a sick man
As I see it, these Race Hustlers don't need a 'Voice' (they already have a Megaphone). They need a 'Mirror' to have a good, hard look at themselves.
Further, imagine the money we'd have if all of Australia's Race Based Departments were to close, and the resources spent on All Australians.
now that would close the gap
Very well said you make a great point
What seems to be totally forgotten or ignored, by the SA state government is that a lot of ABORIGINAL people voted NO in the Referendum? Perhaps that's why they didn't vote in the state state based voice, as they don't want it. And how will a couple of hundred Activists voted in. Represent approximately 300 different tribes that have their own elders and decision making process. You talk about being arrogant, SA PREMIER is off the charts with his arrogance. We all voted and the answer was NO for good reasons. ABORIGINAL people will be poorly represented by this.
Another Labor lie, "we will listen to the people decision".....but NOT IN SOUTH AUSTRALIA it seems.
What is going in Australia=fullstop =beyond banana Republic
Labor may keep on pushing this BS and we keep mocking its failures BUT people keep voting labor into power!…
The same is coming for albo and his clown show
It was classed as a failure as a State referendum because it saw an abysmal 8.7 percent turnout of the 30,000 people who were eligible to vote, but only 2,583 formal ballots were cast
Voting was voluntary and only open to South Australia's Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander population
But those elected despite the poor turnout were joyous declaring we're the first jurisdiction to create … a First Nations Voice,"
Many in SA would beg to differ in a state in which the ABC coverage of the Federal Voice Referendum took just 54 minutes to declare almost 65% of the state voters voted NO, the second highest of the nation voting States
And how many Torres Strait Islanders live in SA? It's all part of a narrative that when put to the test just doesn't stack up.
'Elected' is a loose term if they got in on only 6 votes for some, zero for others. Madness.
@@Larrikins54 so a descendant of Europeans who arrived in 1836 has no voice, but someone from far north Queensland could have arrived last year and gets a say.....
BRING BACK DEMOCRACY!
🤣 Keep on it Ben Hood great job mate ,Peter Malinauskas could not see the obvious coming😂
I want unity in our country, our politicians are breaking us down gradually.
We need serious change in our government this is getting out of hand. 😮
Labor Australia wide need to listen not implement there socialist agenda. Labor is changing Australia for the worst.
Its all a joke, trying to cause drama, anxiety and hatred for each other!
Shame on these fools trying this 🤦♀️
We don't really know whether those who voted for this were Aboriginal.
I would vote for this guy except for this policy. Just another Labor clown ignoring the wishes of the public. He gets up there and says that this is the wish of the South Australian public. No one asked me! If i recall, we had a national referendum which said no.
Too much money and power to be had for the grifters to give up on it. 🙄
The turnout tends to make one believe that the Aboriginal people are not really interested in a voice. And where are all the pro voice voices now with the trouble increasing in Alice Springs?
Who's Paying for all this B. S?.... Yes any new Government should wind it back and save us all money!!
What election? The rest of us couldn’t vote. Some democracy
Australia says no, Labor says "No you really want this"! Sick of the corruption in Australia.
The Indigenous are well known for their low voter turnout. It's why it is easy for activists to capture the perception they are representing Indigenous issues.
it's easier to complain then actually do anything about it. Being heard is more important than closing the gap, we would lose prominence if that happened.
so basically only 10% off the possible 4% of the population decided to give a toss
HOW DO YOU GET ELECTED WITH ONLY 6 VOTES OUT OF A WHOLE STATE SOUNDS LIKE A FUCKIN JOKE
Sounds like a joke because it is. Farcical to the max.
Things work out best , when No means No.
How much did that fiasco cost?
Premier Malinbumkiss… wants to be the Labor/union poster boy, thinks he’s media candy but the reality is he’s the most useless premier in Australia.
Jacinta Allan is up there " things cost what they cost" style budgeting.
Arrogancy by the labor 30000 get their own committee at a cost. How much more taxpayers money gets thrown at so few people.
Imagine if these people had to get jobs to pay for themselves 😮
Did not make a Quorum so to speak.Not representative.
$10 Million to pay the voice panel, that only a couple thousand people bothered to vote for. 😑
Labor have completely lost their way ...........................
Disgraceful. You asked and got your answer now move on.
reality the voice has failed...focus on state infrastructure ,like regional JETTIES and LOCAL COMMUNITIES, listen to the people of SA.
Happy's Easter Rita Rowan James
Great show ❤
Talk about No means No
There is clearly no legitimacy to this body.
So just 1% of the 3% voted
What a shit show labor is , totally out of touch with not just the main stream people but the aboriginal community as well😂
Even the Abo's don't want voice !
You have to wonder about the collective intellect of Labor Politicians in South Australia. The Australian voters voted clearly and and unambiguously in a National constitutional vote. $400 million it cost taxpayers, not politicians or political parties. No siree. They have been given another dose of political reality. Will they listen. I doubt it. They march to the beat of their own ignorant drum.
It is not easy under Albanese
Not backfired, more people on the board than voted, the joke is on the electorate
Let's stop the separation withe the Torre islander, Aboriginal and alphabet flags on all government websites items, email and recognition statements. We are ONE We are all Australian.
We already voted No but they just don't listen to the people
Makes 'The Voice' look successfull!!!!!!!
😅😅