How to Make Roman Concrete (4 Different Materials, 4 Different Strengths)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 июн 2024
- Thanks to Bespoke Post for sponsoring this video. Get 20% off your first monthly box when you sign up at bspk.me/how2 and use promo code EVERYTHING20 at checkout!
We're exploring the ancient origins of concrete and testing out its strength compared to a variety of other building materials. Is Roman concrete the strongest natural building material out there? Let's find out...
Help us make more videos ► / htme
Instagram ► / htmeverything
Discord ► / discord
Merch ► shop.spreadshirt.com/HTME
H2ME (Second Channel) ► bit.ly/2GTcrcG
▾ Our Camera Gear: ▾
► GH5s: amzn.to/3BzY9Id
► GH5: amzn.to/3Eu0juJ
► Lens: amzn.to/2XXkVvM
► GoPro Hero 5: amzn.to/3EFkxSr
► Dracast Light Panels: amzn.to/3vUY2W4
▼ Send Us Some Mail ▼
How to Make Everything
PO Box 14104
St. Paul, MN 55114-1802
▼ Special Thanks to our Patrons at $15+ per month ▼
TyelorD, Daemon Rene, Amelia Grant, Kevin Shuttic, Erik Språng, Daniel Sixta, Lee Schnee, Iain Bailey, Sean Brooks, alex latzko, Stephen DeCubellis, Fruitymasterz, John Gregg, alkalinekats, Lana Sinapayen, Daffyd Wagstaff, Chad Nodo, David Beckett, Adrian Noland, Estoky Designs, Eric Moore, Phil, Benjamin Maitland, Sandy & Jayremy Lester, Larry Ullman, Skylar MacDonald, Maimus32, Stephen C Strausbaugh, Dylan Rich, Jason Kaczmarsky, Antonio Rios-Ochoa, Liz Roth, Jason Lewis, Andrew Nichols, Susan M. George, and Daniel Laux
▼ Credits ▼
Created and Hosted by Andy George
Co-Hosted and Assistance by Lauren Lexvold
Camera and Cinematography by Daniel Garritsen
Primary Editing by Joseph Knox-Carr
Music by Taylor Lewin: taylorlewin.com/htme
Get 20% off your first monthly box when you sign up at bspk.me/how2 and use promo code EVERYTHING20 at checkout!
as always thanks for the videos. im impressed at your level of preparation and skill for this video in the past you efforts were uninspiring while this is a functional usable product where you have used the beginnings of an assembly/production process where if you scaled time and cost could come up with a meaningful value for the product. and you have produced a product that was marketable and of market quality.
Damn I’m pretty sure your supposed to use river rocks instead of gravel
Roman concrete was also compacted, and had chunks of terracotta tile.
I think there's too much lime in your mix and perhaps pumice is less effective than actual volcanic ash?
@@sarchlalaith8836 lol the pumice would have been used as an aggro ate like we use gravel today , it was used in the pathanon in its upper dome areas because it is lighter . modern portland and ancient roman concrete are different and have different properties granted they both when hydrolyzed complete there chemical reactions and leave a coherent solid mass which continues to harden . sand and aggregate ..whatever was at hand broken tile was fine as was shell its a filler for the cement to bind . as for the amounts and proportions its like baking the recipe changes a little from cook to cook and day to day so as long as it sets theres not too much or not enough of any one component its cost or its strength or its time to cure are what drives the proportion requirements
@@mobiousenigma? Did you watch the video? He used pumice in place of volcanic ash and yeah, everyone tweeks things, true fact.
Compacting did increase strength though, not unlike pise, and it's thought that the tiles adsorb excess moisture.
Anyways, have a great day.
The professionally made red brick was at a bit of a disadvantage since you had it resting on a small stone in the back, creating a pivot point and a good place to snap. If it were laying flat I imagine it would have stood a better chance at breaking until higher pressures were applied.
The wood wasn't really given a chance either. He crushed it in it's weakest dimension.
I though the same. The test were not true as some brick were definitely focusing on one small point. others were perfectly flat spreading the load. So hard to tell the strength really. Great video though love this stuff 👍👍👍👍
Axe test in the previous episode was also kind of... unscientific is what I guess the term would be.
Yeah I noticed that too, big sad
The error he made when trying to compare the force needed to destroy each type of brick was termed "point loading". In order that the different breaking strengths are ONLY due to the nature of the material it is essential to apply the force over an identical area of the specimen AND have a sample preparation procedure that ensures the force is applied evenly across that identical area.
A small stone (e.g. a piece of the aggregate used in the Roman concrete) lying either under the top plate (between the pressure plate and the brick) or beneath the specimen (between brick and table) will produce erroneous results if it resists crushing for even a short period. Such point loading means all the rams force is directed at a very small area of the brick's surface (a very high pressure > the apparent final breaking pressure) causing the break to fail before it would have.
Lesson #1: Don’t use round rocks in concrete.
Roman cement is not used for its strength but its resilience to weathering as it cures over 30-50 years. A crush test is testing the wrong property.
If the cure time is measured in decades, a crush test of months-old at most concrete is also testing on the wrong timescale.
I was looking for this comment. I was going to say the same thing. A crush test for Roman concrete after such a short cure time doesn’t showcase its amazing properties and potential. Roman concrete continues to cure and strengthen over much longer periods of time.
Round river cobbles were used in concrete until at least the 1960's. They are not as good as angular aggregate for high strength applications, but for many structures round rock is 'good enough'. I just worked on a highway bridge built in 1961 with a river cobble concrete mix that is holding strong after 50+ years of heavy truck traffic.
there is no real point to buildings standing for that long. that is just wasting the land of future generations.
@@tanszism you must be American
This series is like Journey Mode in terraria, where you have to get X amount before unlocking an infinite supply
Yeah
I actually prefer Master mode to Journey mode, because of the challenge.
More like Journey Mode is like HTME, considering how old it is. :P
@@KainYusanagi yeah
@@therealArchmageTeslar if you want difficulty, play in journey mode with 2.95 difficulty, same damage and more Hp as master mode with none of the benefits of master mode
As someone who tested concrete for a living, I really wish you would revisit this using a modern testing lab and the advice of a professional engineer as to how to make your samples, and how long to cure your concrete. Modern concrete is designed for a 28 day ultimate strength but it will continue to gain strength (asymptoticly) for 56 years or more. I would be pleased to collaborate with you concerning modern and ancient building materials.
Cob also takes 1-2 years. Nothing was really given a fair chance here.
That would be very neat to watch
Noooooo. I don't want a pro helping !!I love the amateur nature of this channel.
@@reluctantheist5224 amateurs are about learning, as this channel. im sure he would want to know if he rlly likes knowledge
Hi, I would like to get in touch with you as I am looking for organic cement materials for my project. Will look forward to your reply. Warm regards
Shikha
I remember reading that the seawater is supposed to be used when making, not as a later soak. Can you try that recipe too? I'd love to see what happens!
It's both; seawater soak after the fact continues to make it even stronger.
@@KainYusanagi do you remember a source for that? I've never heard this, roman concrete is a weird love of mine, and I wanna read it!
When you use that method it can become stronger then concrete
That’s what I was going to say. The secret to Roman concrete is using salt water while making it.
@@sevandor there was an article a few years ago discussing that the recipes for Roman concrete discuss using “common water” as it translates. And that for year they just assumed it meant fresh water but then the realized that with fresh water still being a precious resource during the Roman times that it must have meant the far more abundant and undrinkable salt water. After some experiments it was showing to be significantly stronger than previous tests using fresh water and even some modern concretes
You: makes a bulletproof chest plate without even trying
Me: looks for my phone while im holding it
That's awesome.
The version I read fairly recently (not sure where, though) was that the water they used for Roman concrete was seawater.
Why does that help?
@@kbee225 Makes the seawater and Volcanic ash reaction happen before you expose it to seawater. + it will be more than just the outer layer that gets the benefits from the reaction.
Yeah ive read/heard that too at some point maybe a documentary or something...
I was about to say the same thing but see you beat me to it. I can't remember where but remember someone doing extensive studies to eventually determine that seawater was most likely used and then they tested the same recipe with regular water and the seawater one was considerably stronger
I heard somewhere that Roman Concrete for the bathhouses also used a little bit of clay when mixing it together.
thumbs up
13:35 - materials showcase
13:41 wood ~4800 psi
14:01 cob ~180 psi
14:20 sun dried brick ~220 psi
14:40 fired brick ~250 psi
14:58 professional modern brick ~500 psi
15:19 plaster ~160 psi
15:53 stone ~1000 psi
16:00 roman concrete ~1200 psi
16:47 modern concrete ~2500 psi
There is a chapter about roman concrete in my school latin book lmfao
Ecce Romani?
tbh, latin is so useless nowadays they might as well discuss different types of shit in those books
@@turencmpressor4152 barbare...
Now... your ass is gone
Caecilius est in horto
Doctor stone this week was awesome
Yes and l learn about Medusa
Chrome got that Yo guy so good!
It was *elegant*
The pozzolan ash was used for the underwater concrete they used. For the above ground concrete they used specific types of ash ( harena fossicia and carbunculus) that had to be freshly mined to make sure it was chemically active.
You can try to calcine the ash you have to see if you can get a reaction. The aqueducts were lined with one part lime to three parts testa- underfired clay tiles milled to a powder. Essentially calcined clay that contained a sodium or potassium containing mineral used as a flux.
i wonder what crap he will have to go through when he gets to the steam area he will have to build a fricken train XD
I hope he doesn't make a Heron's engine (aka 'aeolipile') and call it a day. I would like to see something atleast similar to a oscillating cylinder engine.
@@vysakhak191 followed by a pulse rocket made with that crappy bronze knife :)
You mean "go through"?
the greeks had a steam engine the concept is simple but the materials and sizes for "trains" requires metal work and machining . the first engines were for water pumps and were hand forged wrought iron things more related to a pressure cooker than a train
@@drk5orp-655 yea my english kind sucks its not my main languge
10 weeks later: "In the 1960s they used this kind of primitive tools to shoot a man to the moon. See if we can reclaim this ancient technology for our own moon mission!"
*In addition to your chosen ingredients, "Roman Concrete" might have been made with salty sea water And VOLCANIC aggregate material. Some claim that the layer of play-do consistency blend was added in layers and into each layer the workers pounded up to fist sized volcanic stones ... then the next layer of mortar mix was pounded in such a way as to fill the pores of the volcanic stones. This layering continued until the desired size and shape was complete.*
When you revisit the cured Roman concrete brick I would also see a clay brick that was fired broken back down and mixed in with a new brick, then refired. This was a common practice Where you would use failed bricks that were ground and reused. They were supposedly a lot stronger.
Yeah, they mentioned using crushed fired clay as a strengthening agent previously but somehow misunderstood and thought it was only applied to the surface, not mixed in.
He needs to redo the factory brick test- it was sitting on something that caused uneven pressure, and premature failure.
So one thing you can try for your concrete is using aggregate with sharper edges rather than smooth and soft, because it will help it to lock together better and be stronger. Also it looks like your concrete was a little dry maybe.
This is one of those times my local city comes into play as I live near Bath in the UK that has one of the only Roman Baths that still stands today. Thanks to this invention.
*laughs in Pompei*
@@alfredorotondo Careful, or you may lose your head like it's namesake. :P
@@talyn3932 no worries I don't live in Pompei, I went there only twice
I live in sicily, only near the highest active volcano of Europe
Naturally occurring porous glass! That’s so cool! Modern concrete additives also includes low density glass micro bubbles that helps make it light. You can even build a canoe out of this special concrete!
This episode reminded me of that time in class when a concrete cylinder exploded from the pressure of the press. Kinda nervous with him just sitting next to it like that without a shield.
30 years from now: "today we Will make a GPS satellite, and launch it into orbit"
For everyone hating on the methodology here.. it's fine. Certainly good enough for a qualitative test of different materials. What they are using here isn't that different from ASTM C39. In construction we test concrete specimens after 28 days of curing, and that is good enough for the bridges we drive on and the buildings we live in. As a a broad comparison on youtube, I think these guys did a great job.
So when are _you_ making a steam engine car? XD
Im waiting for a hydrogen powered car which would solve fuel problem
Honestly 📠
@@razor-wd2pc it would not since hydrogen is produced with electricity. which is reliably produces with fossil fuel.
Cant wait!
@@razor-wd2pc the way hydrogen or water fueled cars work is through electrolysis but the thing is you use more power to split water molecules apart then you get out of it
it is alwasy beautiful when you return home after 7 hours of school (next week there will be 9) and find Andy welcoming you home with a new video, and more importantly with a topic you like. Thank you.
I have Online School
I graduated.
@@masondipperpines5009 We go school 2 times a week online and 3 times a week in person, and i think is BS
@@MrLins-wv3tg i am remote
@@Rugiball i said this
I thought what made roman cement unique (stronger) was the addition of salt, which formed a type of crystallize structure that reinforced the cement and made it more resilient?
Nice to see you back in action with the traveling and doing stuff more! Cool to see
i truly love that you put a timer on your sponsorships, you're the best about that
The beetle part was really nice. Thank you for that.
In Practical Engineering video about Roman concrete, he says that the biggest problem in modern concrete is the amount of water and the using of steel structure, which deteriorates the concrete overtime.
Another thing Romans used to do was to put concrete under pressure and relive tension, that's one of the reasons why they build huge monuments.
we still do that, its called prestressed concrete
@@randomcow505 the Seattle space needle is made from prestressed concrete. It had a fail. Designed by a guy named Holmquist. he was a friend of mine’s dad. My friend is no slouch in the BRAINY department, either.
@@cynthiaaiken2424 uhhh cool?
The sponsor segment is actually interesting, I watched the whole thing without skipping. 👍
Ikea bags are ridiculously sturdy and I am glad to see I'm not the only one who's noticed this
Dr stone and htme is the same mission from starting from scratch
Yes, dr.stone fan yes!!
just watched it the third time
I would love to see you remake it in light of the new discoveries about roman concrete regarding them using quick lime.
Liked the style of this out in the field and talking about the history of concrete etc. nice vid
Asari gen: Honey bake it Honey okay I understand.
Making plastic in stone age
That was tungsten toothpaste, cook the powder in sodium hydroxide, add sea shells, hydrochloric acid and ammonia to crystalize it then bake it and mix with honey xd
Awesome video man keep up the good work. I'm always fascinated by your projects and stuff you make.
I am so fascinated by this. You've got me hooked!
I love this series so original and interesting keep up the good content ! 👍🏻
Ive been watching your channel for around 2-3 years now and I absolutely love what you guys do. I know you get hate all the time, but I learn more and more every video. Keep up the good work!
This channel is way too underated.
I feel like we're watching a real world version of a video game progression with your channel. "Congratulations you've unlocked concrete"
NOW the fun is starting
Mans gonna make a biplane soon enough
Them googly eyes are a nice touch!
I know its probably been said a million bajillion times..but man this series is awesome. I would say its "TV" quality but that almost feels like an insult. Keep it up man!
Thank you for the great videos. Makes me really appreciate the most simple of things.
Thank you for gifting me this video. I finally can explain and understand why concrete works. :) But with your video I have a way to communicates this better to my future students :) Yes I am gonna make them mix concrete :) And then we will use them as safety plates for experiments. ^^
You sound like an amazing teacher
You might want to check out the Practical Engineering channel. He has an excellent series on concrete too.
@@cameronknowles6267 haha I am still on my way to bachelor. ^^' but I have a goal in sight.
@@gavinli1368 I will do that. Thank you :)
@@Mrwaffleandmilk as an Italian I'm even more confused because cement in italian is malta cementizia or simply malta (yeah like the country) and concrete is cemento
Remember guys: lift with your back.
Manual handling is a must, no point wearing down a great tool like our body faster than need be
There are companies using glass from recycling to make a kind of lightweight fill material that, essentially, is artificial pumice. I have hauled bulk bags of it to jobsites, and an antire tractor trailer load was under 15k lbs.
I think you should explore the development of Ikeatite, which is the main ingredient in those extremely useful Ikea bags.
Edit: not a "fun fact" because people are no fun, and now I shall call it a "fun opinion I heard"
Fun opinion I heard: I recently heard an argument stating that the limestone blocks of the pyramids were maybe poured, not cut. Wut.
Not how stone works
It's a very compelling argument!
It’s not likely due to limestone cracking on its own In such large ammounts
You mean fun opinion,
There's no evidence of that.
Literally every stone I've ever seen from the pyramids has clear chisel marks.
Who told you this?
0:18
It could also be said that we live in the Glass age, as Glass is used damn near *Everywhere* ...
Hell, there is more glass in the windows of a single skyscraper than there was produced throughout the entirety of history up until like the late 1800s.
That just blew my fkn mind so ta for that 😂😂😂 this is like the rime someone told me there were more dead people than alive no matter how big the population gets. Which i mean is obvious af but like you dont think like that so when its pointed out its like super spooky and you cant unknow it.
Again great video! I love the doodle eyes running joke :D. You guys and gals are awesome! Keep up the great work
Can't wait for the heavy machinegun episode.
Hi there
Hello
Howdy
Ello
"The plastic age" is the saddest thing I've ever heard. 😆
only because humans of lower iq in various states around the world pollute their environment. Plastic in itself is a magical compound, lasting centuries, which made many technological marvels possible. do not blame the material for inferior cultures which give it a bad name by dumping it all around.
@@StoicNatsoc I totally agree. I think people just take it for granted and didn't know how to handle it. And BTW I was just replying to what was said in the video, not bashing plastic.
How about the Polymer Age instead?
@@josephbenson4413 meh.. lol
@@josephbenson4413 That's more accurate. There was neolithic plastics in use in the form of resins. Plastic has a term usage beyond polymer plastic. It leads to some confusion.
I id just like to say that this dude is awesome he has made so much progress as a person since this has started and has gained so many new skills doing so it, i dont think making new goals for yourself is easy but dang this dude does it all the time for that gg
Love that short clip of a Dash 8 Q400 Crosswind landing @ 0:23
*Advancement Made: Roman Empire*
"Welcome to the hydraulic press channel..."
Today we will be testing this brick to see how well it holds up, ready?
The comparison to also the modern stuff is extremely cool, so we can see directly how it comes up
Nice to see a good old IKEA bag being put to good use. Can't imagine many others have been used to collect pumice..... they have now probably been used to carry everything 🤣
As a Civil Engineering Major, this personally hurt to watch. Entertaining and informative nonetheless.
Oh man, same. "That Roman concrete needs more water." "Why aren't you tamping!" "Fill in the voids! Come on!" "Did you keep it moist while curing???"
Make damascuss steel.
Damascuss steel (woot steel) doesnt exist unless its artifacts....the "damascuss" now is just patern welded steel....just looks pretty
@@NoName-sy3di you misspelled wootz.
Oh man, i'm so excited for the upcoming projects now that you can make concrete!
You are awesome as always!!!
These guys are like dr.stone
Anyone else worried about Andy's legs during this? Like worried things would shatter and shrapnel would go into his legs
No
i love the idea of your channel this always bguis me when i cant make something myself
best channel on youtube. would be curious about concrete made using baked shells, lots of oysters here in the PNW
i hope he can get to the point of really making some money off all this
dude.. he have sponsor, ads, paternon, item shop, and a mail box where fan send stuff.. whit 1.5 milion sub and 500k of vies for evry vid and one sponsor in almost evry video he make nice money.. (proof? he have a stuff for shooting the video and editing and also helper)..
channel name edit "how not to make anything" or "we totally unlocked iron from scratch, right??" watching for years and it just gets worse every episode, its like watching a train wreck..
THANK YOU SO MUCH!
Another ROCK SOLID episode!
Roman concrete,when the advanced techniques used is tougher and more durable than modern concrete no question.There are many examples of 2000 Year old Roman structures in tact,while many modern concrete structures start cracking apart within 10 to 50 yrs for example
Michael P That is not universally true, most buildings you encounter tend to be made to only stand for a few decades so the concrete is optimized for strength so you need less but we can also optimize for durability and that is done with things like nuclear bunkers and dams which need to stand for a long time. Roman concrete also has the benefit of having been used in very mild climates which don't have to deal with a lot of rain and frost which is usually what leads to structural failure.
Also there are a lot more examples of Roman structures that aren't intact you just don't ever think about those because well they aren't here anymore, something like 99,99% of all Roman structures have collapsed totally and of the remaining 0,01% a lot of those have partially collasped. The ones that stayed owe just as much to maintenance as they do to the durability of their materials.
While we're here it's important to remember that concrete is wonderful, but comprises over 8% of global greenhouse emissions.
It's cold right now so it's obvious we're not using enough concrete.
@@Serahpin ok boomer
When compared at exactly the same size say 3x3 for example, a patio made from concrete has a lower carbon footprint than one made from timber, requires less maintenance and will last considerably longer.
@@jesst5474 Watch out, you'll be reported for posting hatefacts.
I absolutely love this channel
Watching this channel sometimes feels like a Dwarf Fortress crafting chain in slow motion.
I miss the times when thumbnails didn't need an exagerated fake reaction face
Fake, he didn't use a diamond pickaxe for the obdisian
(joke btw)
(thanks for the btw)
Im excited when you build electronics
8:39 - If I could afford a car like that, I definitely wouldn't drive it THERE! x'D
Great video btw. I love your channel.
Hearing the term “ Concrete Age” made me so incredibly sad for a sec because it’s honestly the perfect description for the modern era
Why? Concrete is an ancient material that we have now mastered in our own new and amazing ways to build incredible structures. concrete is something that has been with us humans for a long time and our modern concrete world is a built on the backs of thousands of years of human ingenuity and engineering. Stone masonry is something ancient and beautiful but still, nothing really represents the long-standing human pursuit of construction like concrete. Especially when you consider how tied together modern concrete construction is with iron working, another very old and special human skill, a concrete building is a marvel of the history of humanity and our innovation.
@@seanprudden6335 in the sense that, a vast majority of our current world consists of concrete…as opposed to say, a “green age”
@@seanprudden6335 we cover the ground with concrete, just to have the population buy expensive cushioned shoes cause the ground is too hard
@@seanprudden6335 I’d much rather and age of balance, where we can fuse human society with nature rather than covering nature with it
Really looking forward to seeing the sea water concrete
Can you revisit this topic now they finally rediscovered the way of Roman concrete?
Great video 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Ikea bags are awesome, who would have thought a bag in the shape of a box would be so versatile.
I was just watching a whole series of your videos about how to make glass and you said something interesting in this one about how obsidian is formed. You said it forms when volcanic lava cools under pressure. This takes me to the video where you tried to make a knife out of obsidian that you melted and poured into a mold. If obsidian forms when it's under pressure then it makes sense that if you reform it, it should be pressurized when it cools. The other a method I was thinking of was to heat the mold so the obsidian cools faster and doesn't crack from the air in the environment.
was hoping to see more about the under water hardening concrete they had
this is just an amazing channel
I think that video was perfect example to do collab with hydraulic press channel!
im loving these thumbnails
Smaller sharper rocks give the cement more to grab onto and will improve their overall performance.
Yes, I'm always watching
Can't wait for the olive press video
What a solid video
Jesus Christ the footage at 03:03 is so trippy I had to look at it five times to realise what I was seeing and the perspective of it.
There's the machine's foundation. And there's a limestone source closer to Minnesota. Northern Indiana! It used to be the coast of a massive sea that covered almost all of Michigan.