Kane scored 50 goals for Bayern. Bellingham Spanish player of the year - with a higher goals per game ratio than Cristiano Ronaldo. Foden PL player of the year. We have the players, it was the coach at fault (who is league one at best). Get Tuchel in. Ten major trophy wins, former world coach of the year, no compensation to pay out. He will command his technical area and manage the players far better than Southgate ever could. Southgate just sat there praying for miracles.
@@treble20 All 3 are brilliant players. But Kane at Munich will always scores goals if the system they play suits him and the chances he will get. Bellingham at one of 2 clubs who will always have the top player award. He had a great start but in the new year perhaps after teams learn about him he was nowhere near as effective and not many goals. Foden is my favorite but he plays in a unique system City play, he learnt from youth. No one else can play that way. Can he be as effective consistently in other set ups?
yeah, spot on and the reality,majority of English media and fans wouldn't want to accept, after excess hype and overating of their players, they all believed the illusion that it's coming home and then the real game is played, boom, England beaten as usual, serial losers, 😅
England have had the best players in the world for about the last 40 years according to them. They should always win the Euro and World Cup according to them. 😂😂😂😂😂
Our team is incredible. We expect to win every game we play. I don’t see anyone in the world as good as us on paper. We lost because of rubbish manager. Otherwise we would have won the last two euros and World Cup.
Absolutely spot on John Barnes. England fans and pundits expectations are unrealistic due to them over hyping the players ability, and underestimating the quality of other nations. Its happened every tournament during my lifetime and doesn't look like ending any time soon. Kane Bellingham Foden Rice Hugely overrated.
Quantify how they are “overrated” when Kane has scored 40+ goals in Germany, Bellingham has scored 20+ from midfield in la liga, Foden one of if not the best midfielders in the premier league last season scoring best part of 20 goals. I’m not massive on rice I must admit but to say they are overrated, the facts don’t add up.
@@madtingsadtingmany see Bellingham as the best or one of the best midfielders in the world and use his goal stats in la liga to justify when he's been playing as a false 9 for the most dominant team in Spain by a mile, so he's obviously gonna get more goals playing higher. If you watch the games though, he is very limited for a midfielder technically as highlighted during the euros. He's a dele Alli frank lampard type, gets into the box. But nowhere near the elite. Kane same thing, scored plenty goals but his performances especially on the big occasion for years has been underwhelming. Foden is a terrific footballer but he's playing for the best manager & the best team, he's only really shown glimpses for England. Good players, but to think they're the best squad of players in Europe is naïve.
@@kol9382 lets see how good fodden would be playing for a mid table premership club you want see a real baller who enabled deportivo De la coruna a mid table spainsh team win the club only la liga title and enabled them to be runners up five times go look at djilminha thats what i call sheer class thats what i call a baller there no one currently playing in international football ,or any team in the euros just passed who could lick that brazilian boots
@mad you mentioned some players who are world class players yes! But england never ever had world class players who keep the ball, midfielders like Piro Alonso Rodri Modric Kroos Xavi Etc!!!! Those players you named have world class intelligent foreign players pulling the strings behind them
that team he mentioned was better than this current crop but then again the standard back then was better Brazil, Germany, Italy Argentina had incredible sides
I hope Japan shows up in the next World Cup. They've been on the precipice for long enough to catch up with the big boys. This era was Belgium and Portugal chance to shine, and of course France needs a different manager
So right! Remember that Brazil team that eliminated England in 2002. They had 3 balon d'Or winners in the starting 11 (Brazilian Ronaldo, Rivaldo, Ronaldinho) and 1 on the bench (Kaka). That's without even mentioning Roberto Carlos and Cafu😢 How are you supposed to deal with that??
@@MrDumile that Brazil team were not great - they had ten men vs England with Ronaldinho sent off for the second half!! We went 1-0 up and that game was there for the taking vs ten men. Sven blew that World Cup. An awful German team got to the final. The other countries were terrible.
John Barnes was one of the very few truly world class players England ever had. He knows what he is talking about. He is probably too polite to say this, so I will say it for him: Despite what you read in the media, Foden is not the best player in the EPL, Bellingham is not the best player in La Liga and Harry Kane is definitely not the best player in the Bundesliga. There are simply ordinary good players.
Exactly... How on Earth, people look us in the eye and tell us Phil Foden is the best player in the premier League. He is not even among the top 3 best players at city. Rodri, De Bruyne and Bernado Silva are easily clear of him.......... Odegaard and Saliba are clear of Saka,,, ..... Take any premier League team, check who the best players are at that club and you'd find only two or three teams with English players
Agree with Barnes, with all he said particularly about England not having the stand out best players in the world. If England fans could accept this fact they would be more grateful for reaching two finals recently.
He didn't maximize the potential of the sides he was given to work with. Other teams have gone on to win cups with way less talent.The one final and the semi-final they got to ,we actually had the stronger squads if you ask me.His in-match management has also not been the best , he just lacks that key element winners have to get their teams across the line.
I wouldn't say Gareth's tenure was a failure outright but over 8 years , it was satisfactory at best. I would be interested to see how he would fare at club level going forward.
We need someone with a proven record of winning major trophies - regardless of nationality. Tuchel is the man, surely? Ten major trophy wins under his belt. No current ties to any club (therefore no compensation to pay out) and can start immediately. He commands his technical area and gets the best out of his players. Southgate was just sat there praying for miracles.
Southgate analysis is simple. 1. He must be respected and praised for achieving more than any England manager since Alf Ramsey; 2. He's a class act and gentleman in the way he unified the team, managed the players and media; 3. He resigned with dignity at the exact right time as he's taken us as far as we can go; 4. The negative, defensive style of football he employed is simply not appropriate for the best attacking options we've had for generations; 5. We now need a manager that can create a system and environment that actually maximises our world class players' talents so we can see the best of Bellingham, Foden. Oh and who picks based on form and performance, not favouritism or brand.
Totally agree with Barnes but he forgot Owen, joe coke, aol Campbell. People have no perspective Southgate done well for navigating such a young team to the final. He could of made changes earlier no doubt, or started players rested players to keep them more energised. But 2 finals and one semi is an accomplishment. Yes we might have won had he made changes, but let’s not take away the enjoyment we experienced in the journey.
Robson also had elite success in Holland, Portugal and Spain..He would likely have won the First Division title with Ipswich in the late 1970s and early 1980s but for a Clough led Forrest, Paisleys Liverpool and Villa, all European cup winners in that period as well..
I agree how good Robson was, but over his 4 Tournaments he had disasters. 84 never qualified, 86 QF well out played in that match, 88 3 losses, 90 Easy route, struggled past Belgium and Cameroon. Lost in SF. I write in the same way as it applies to Southgate. It was after in his later jobs as he improved with experience it was shown how good he was, the press were against him quite often as well.. Although he was good all the way as I remember, sometimes it's the players..
@@markpodlesak7204 In his defence for failing to qualify for '84'..they was a shedding process going on..Keegan/Brooking/Thompson and others were being discarded..Italy failed to qualify as well..my biggest criticism of him was over the poor start in Mexico when the team's form was good and not following the logic of pre/tourney matches and qualifications, but dropping Robson/Wilkins would have taken exceptional bravery but they would have swept the group if they had done so..The '88' campaign was a disaster but it was a bloody hard group with the two teams that produced the two finalists and England held their own for 70 mins against the Dutch and played the Irish off it for most of their match..Never cracked how to play Waddle and Barnes together..Robson made England a highly effective international team in the 1980s though they were not Germany etc al..
@@kailashpatel1706 Yes I get and remember all this. But I wrote from the reasoning used today against Southgate. In 82 they coped quite well without Keegan or Brooking, but did miss some quality.
Please get more John Barnes on Talksport. He thinks before he opens his mouth and doesn't have the parochial expectation of so many English commentators that there is some divine right for England to win.
We’re not blessed I’ve been saying it for years. For starters kane being compared to shearer is outrageous. Comparing grealish to Gascogine at one point is crazy. Saying saka is better then beckham is silly.
Some people are celebrating, yet they should hold their horses and be careful what they wish for. Southgate has raised standards and expectations. Under Southgate England has gone deep into tournaments. There is now an expectation to win and het to finals. If the next man doesn't qualify or get out of the group-stage, people will be crying out for Southgate in a few years time! There will have to be pragmatism at times, not all teams can merely be turned over. In terms of the new manager: If English, has to be: Eddie Howe or Carsley. If non-English: Klopp (though doubtful he would ever take, as he wants to relax, so no idea why his name is being constantly thrown into the mix). No way Lampard, Rooney or Gerrard. They have poor man-management and inter-personal skills. No way: the Argentian Pochettino.
The past players Barnes is talking about had very different draws. The opposition was also far better than those we play now so it isn't a great comparison
This is wrong. Sven faced a ten man Brazil for 45 mins in a World Cup in Japan where all the decent teams had already gone out. Argentina and France went out in the group stages! Italy to South Korea. It was a golden opportunity missed. Southgate would have got vilified for that. I could mention the Portugal defeats but tbh I’m still annoyed by them 😊
Everyones been wanting southgate sacked, now were stuck with potter, lampard, rooney etc and the majority of entitled England fans are linking us to klopp and anchilotti. Barnes is right, were not entitled to win every tournament. Give your spains out there some credit
precisely you think its easy to win a trophy there only two of them either the copa america if your in southh america ,the euro then the most prized possession and hardest of them all the world cup and not every big team can arrive at the final at once france didnt make it ,germany didnt make it portugal didot make it ,italy, holland , Croatia
That's why I said it will be many years down the road before Southgate's work gets appreciated. There were better teams with world class players in the past that never won a major tournament. England shouldn't feel so entitled to win.
Potter? Which major trophies has he won? We need someone with a proven record of winning major trophies - regardless of nationality. Tuchel is the man, surely? Ten major trophy wins under his belt. No current ties to any club (therefore no compensation to pay out) and can start immediately. He commands his technical area and gets the best out of his players. Southgate was just sat there praying for miracles.
@@humptydumpty20 We need someone used to managing elite players and winning trophies. Tuchel is a former world club manager of the year and has won 10 major trophies. If he was English there wouldn't be a debate. He's available (so no compensation to pay out). Get him in!
@@treble20 He's German, he will get bashed by the media and fans if he meets Germany and England loses. And expectations in the 2026 WC will be huge based on the back-to-back Euro finals. Any manager reaching less than a Final will be criticised heavily again - it would be wiser to take over after the 2026 WC. Tuchel can get higher paying club jobs anytime without this toxic BS.
@@treble20 I know - the media also report that Pep is interested. The journalists need stories to write. Let's wait and see who is appointed in the end.
Barnes was right about how we should of brought Sterling, Rashford, Grealish and Maguire as it was a team, Southgate built a team and basically sold 4/5 players all at once and tgen expected to just gel. It also would of affected the mood in the camp and it's Bellingham was a problem on and off the pitch and there was no one there to calm his ego down. You don't just pick players on form as you will never have a team. Other countries don't automatically pick best players
Most critics are not saying England should have won, but that they could have but mostly didn't play to their potential. It's not unreasonable to regard England as one of the tournament favourites, they had 3rd best FIFA ranking (European team)
Should have asked john if he was happy with how england played during these euros. He said himself the england players were better than the spanish players. And then nullifies the effect of the manager. Yamal was non existent in the final he says? He set up the first goal. Love John because as a liverpool fan i adored him when he played there. But his thoughts on football since then and now dont impress me.
Potter is the perfect manager. He has won buggerall in his career-just like England-and plays boring, negative football-just like England. Can't think of a better suited manager for England.
It's an indictment on our media space that such intelligent and forthright personality as Mr Barnes is not a regular or mainstay analyst on such programmes. I think of most of the other "analysts" and it feels me with such dismay. He makes them all sound so stale.
As a nation we have to get over the mentality of ‘a manager getting the sack so their rubbish’. Some of the greatest manager like Ancelloti have been sacked multiple time yet still gets hired. Potter has a style and philosophy that’s attacking which this team needs.
Barnes is bang on! Portugal and France. Dreadful. Turkey..i liked that performance at the big stage..after so many dark horse times..finally Turkey turned up. Holland were solid. Germany at home were not embarrassed.
All us England fans wanted to see in the tournament was true grit and determination. Regardless if we are the best or not England never turned up and that is on the Manager, ultimately he is in charge. If you get bad customer service in a business you don't ask for the next assistant, you ask for the manager. You assume they are in charge and responsible for the training and quality of service the staff are giving. As a Leicester fan I know you can win things on grit and determination and playing as a team, and not just who has the best players.
He's correct about world class players and we (England) don't have any. The standard of the premiership is dropping each season with over inflated players being sold at over inflated prices and you can see why players are now moving abroad. We need a manager who won't be afraid to drop players and after the Euros you could be looking at 4 or 5 players not being guaranteed a place in the starting eleven, a players wins his place on performances and not hype and name.
Well done John Barnes. Us 🏴 do have one of the very best squads in the world , yes but there are a few other groups that are a bit ahead of us , and some others that are not far behind us, at all. England does have BIG potential, tho.
Problem was the overhyped players, not GS. Rice, Bellingham, Kane, Gallagher, Maguire, etc. were the problem not GS. England was an average team that didn’t deserve to reach the finals.
The Old grey hair lady/man needs a reality check. What top players do England really have, that’s why Jude played pants as did numbers 1-11 plus the bench. All were Mickey Mouse level 🐭🐭🐭
It won’t make one bit of difference whoever takes over. The FA need to restructure the Prem, when a major tournament is in the same calendar year. Then maybe, just maybe, Fresh players, fit athletes, ALL giving it 100%, may just bring home a trophy, and change the past 58 years of burnt out players in our footballing History. 🤔 Thanks Gareth, huge efforts, much respect 🙏🏻🙏🏻
I think what JB is referring to with management style is a generational thing, we generation Xers now have to manage millennials and gen z and I think GS had the recipe right, the players were engaged and wanted to play for him
Lol Nico william new in international, yamal, olmo, a CB in Saudi, a RB, they swore that they wont swap with walker, etc. Talking fast doesnt = making sense.
Barnes is correct, Southgate and England benefited from the great Foreign managers that have turned our football around,the Dinosaur hoof ball managers are long gone thank god, and long may that last! The irony is Pickford hoof it up the field and give posetion away his manager is a British dinosaur in Sean Dyche 🤣
@@Youafool500 Thats his club manager,that should have smacked out of him,These dudes are on ridiculous wages, and your Keeper should be the most level headed player on the pitch..
@@chenks76 yeah that’s why I specifically said first half he was better in the second half but what I’m saying is I think we dealt with him quite well overall
@@leepowell1408 point is, Barnes is talking his usual nonsense. surprised he never tried to say it was because he was black that the team failed, that's his usual explanation for everything
Get Klopp or Pep or Carlo or Conti or Mancini or Lippi. Get a serial winner to end 60 yrs of hurt vs. Messi & Argentina in the USA World Cup final 2026. Or 62 yrs of hurt in Euro 2028 if Leo does what Leo does & defeats 3 🦁.
Losing to one of the worst Italian sides in history, an italian side that couldn't even qualify for the world cup. at Wembley in the euro final was one of the biggest failures in english football.
One of the worst Italian sides consisting of Donnarumma, Chiellini, Bonucci, Verratti could beat England. That says a lot about the level of the England team 😁😀
Best player in England: English. Best player in Spain: English. Highest goal scorer in Germany: English. But we don't have the best players in the world. OK, John, okay. I'd argue as a collection, we had the best team in the Euros. And our best player couldn't even start!
I got to say this man speaks sense but to say yamine lamal was inexistence in the final makes no sense, created a goal, had 3 very good scoring opportunities. I do say he was inexistence in the 1st half but in the 2nd half he showed up
When Southgate dragged football into politics and race issues he really P off a lot of football fans. Even black mates were embarrassed in the pub when they did the kneeling fiasco.
Nice one mate! Your analysis on Aston Villa is great & it would seem you have a liking for our great club, cos you make alot of Villa content & proves you have good taste &. with much happening at Villa nowadays many talking points.... UP THE MIGHTY VILLA!!! 😉
Only 2 Spanish player was in Real Madrid champions league starting 11 which means majority of Spanish team will be from other Clubs such as the 5 from Atletico Club.
I’ve been hearing these same arguments and excuses all my life. English players never play well enough as a national team…they lost again. Now everyone starts talking about the young players, the next tournament, the next manager, the promise for the future blah blah blah…They were saying the same about Lineker, Gazza and Barnes Hoddle and Waddle, Beckham et al… and we are still in the same situation.
Exactly. Top international teams dissect their team performance post tournament and come back stronger to actually win something. England always looks for someone to blame and find a ton of excuses for not winning. The same old story.
Finally someone from england actually said the players are NOT the best in the world
Kane scored 50 goals for Bayern. Bellingham Spanish player of the year - with a higher goals per game ratio than Cristiano Ronaldo. Foden PL player of the year. We have the players, it was the coach at fault (who is league one at best). Get Tuchel in. Ten major trophy wins, former world coach of the year, no compensation to pay out. He will command his technical area and manage the players far better than Southgate ever could. Southgate just sat there praying for miracles.
@@treble20nah English only. If we can’t win it as England I don’t want to win it
@@treble20 All 3 are brilliant players. But Kane at Munich will always scores goals if the system they play suits him and the chances he will get. Bellingham at one of 2 clubs who will always have the top player award. He had a great start but in the new year perhaps after teams learn about him he was nowhere near as effective and not many goals. Foden is my favorite but he plays in a unique system City play, he learnt from youth. No one else can play that way. Can he be as effective consistently in other set ups?
yeah, spot on and the reality,majority of English media and fans wouldn't want to accept, after excess hype and overating of their players, they all believed the illusion that it's coming home and then the real game is played, boom, England beaten as usual, serial losers, 😅
England have had the best players in the world for about the last 40 years according to them. They should always win the Euro and World Cup according to them. 😂😂😂😂😂
Barnes was right about we aren't as good as we think. Several Counties have fantastic players. Well done for pointing it out!!
Yep. Interviewers realising too late that when getting Barnesey on he often doesn't go with the media narrative
@@markpodlesak7204 which countries and what players?
@@yawnthedinosaur9566 He can't say because the reality is England does have some of the world's best players.
This Barnes guy does not sound like an English man! He SPOKE TOO MUCH SENSE!!!🔥🔥🔥
😂😂😂damn that's rough
It's the Jamaican blood in him
@@shakwaiv_music85 oh! That makes so much sense!! NO WONDER!!!
🧂
No, he's a proud Jamaican.
Barnes spitting nothing but facts in the last 48hrs but England to arrogant. "What, what do you mean we're not the best" type attitude
*but England are too arrogant
Our team is incredible. We expect to win every game we play. I don’t see anyone in the world as good as us on paper. We lost because of rubbish manager. Otherwise we would have won the last two euros and World Cup.
@bobbypukes605 Haha, the likes of you are exactly what the op and Barnes are on about you absolute melt
@@chucky7826 you got got 🎣🎣🎣
1:30 Barnes was cooking. Speaking facts!
John barnes talks sense,the rest of these pundits are talking rubbish
for real
John Barnes is qualified to speak on the very best players as he was up there in his day in world football
Also scorer of the greatest ever England goal v Brazil
Class player.
He was until the fa filled his pockets
@@ashwilliams4959 elaborate…
@@waynemarshall8836 and where is he now🙄
Aww. That poor girl genuinely believed England had the best players in the world. Thanks for deprogramming her.
Absolutely spot on John Barnes. England fans and pundits expectations are unrealistic due to them over hyping the players ability, and underestimating the quality of other nations. Its happened every tournament during my lifetime and doesn't look like ending any time soon. Kane Bellingham Foden Rice Hugely overrated.
Quantify how they are “overrated” when Kane has scored 40+ goals in Germany, Bellingham has scored 20+ from midfield in la liga, Foden one of if not the best midfielders in the premier league last season scoring best part of 20 goals. I’m not massive on rice I must admit but to say they are overrated, the facts don’t add up.
@@madtingsadtingmany see Bellingham as the best or one of the best midfielders in the world and use his goal stats in la liga to justify when he's been playing as a false 9 for the most dominant team in Spain by a mile, so he's obviously gonna get more goals playing higher. If you watch the games though, he is very limited for a midfielder technically as highlighted during the euros. He's a dele Alli frank lampard type, gets into the box. But nowhere near the elite. Kane same thing, scored plenty goals but his performances especially on the big occasion for years has been underwhelming. Foden is a terrific footballer but he's playing for the best manager & the best team, he's only really shown glimpses for England. Good players, but to think they're the best squad of players in Europe is naïve.
@@kol9382 lets see how good fodden would be playing for a mid table premership club
you want see a real baller who enabled deportivo De la coruna a mid table spainsh team win the club only la liga title and enabled them to be runners up five times
go look at djilminha thats what i call sheer class thats what i call a baller
there no one currently playing in international football ,or any team in the euros just passed who could lick that brazilian boots
@mad you mentioned some players who are world class players yes!
But england never ever had world class players who keep the ball, midfielders like
Piro
Alonso
Rodri
Modric
Kroos
Xavi
Etc!!!!
Those players you named have world class intelligent foreign players pulling the strings behind them
Kane = German league player of the season
Bellingham = Spanish league player of the season
Foden = English league player of the season
that team he mentioned was better than this current crop but then again the standard back then was better Brazil, Germany, Italy Argentina had incredible sides
I hope Japan shows up in the next World Cup. They've been on the precipice for long enough to catch up with the big boys.
This era was Belgium and Portugal chance to shine, and of course France needs a different manager
So right! Remember that Brazil team that eliminated England in 2002. They had 3 balon d'Or winners in the starting 11 (Brazilian Ronaldo, Rivaldo, Ronaldinho) and 1 on the bench (Kaka). That's without even mentioning Roberto Carlos and Cafu😢 How are you supposed to deal with that??
@@MrDumile that Brazil team were not great - they had ten men vs England with Ronaldinho sent off for the second half!! We went 1-0 up and that game was there for the taking vs ten men. Sven blew that World Cup. An awful German team got to the final. The other countries were terrible.
Barnes is class
And Pearce on here, not sure about many of the others
😂 that shut her up top pundit John barnes
Sick of hearing women talking football
Who is she?
@DanielS10291 someone who confused talksport with the tea room...
@@Royboy50here here
@@DanielS10291 Lianne Sanderson former women's football
John Barnes was one of the very few truly world class players England ever had.
He knows what he is talking about.
He is probably too polite to say this, so I will say it for him:
Despite what you read in the media, Foden is not the best player in the EPL, Bellingham is not the best player in La Liga and Harry Kane is definitely not the best player in the Bundesliga. There are simply ordinary good players.
interesting something our domestic media will not like
Exactly... How on Earth, people look us in the eye and tell us Phil Foden is the best player in the premier League. He is not even among the top 3 best players at city. Rodri, De Bruyne and Bernado Silva are easily clear of him.......... Odegaard and Saliba are clear of Saka,,, ..... Take any premier League team, check who the best players are at that club and you'd find only two or three teams with English players
Well said absolutely. I’ve watched Bellingham in about 15 games now and he has no impressed me slightly
Wow was he that good ??
Good player, never world class
I wish Southgate all the best for the future 😊
Agree with Barnes, with all he said particularly about England not having the stand out best players in the world. If England fans could accept this fact they would be more grateful for reaching two finals recently.
He’s got the world in motion ...
Barnes should have given us a little sing and dance at the end.
As a Chelsea fan, i would suggest you keep Potter a million miles away from any squad, let alone the England squad.
Did he ‘maximise potential’ by leaving Kane on for 60 minutes?
Exactly s
The only potential there was the potential to loose ,Kane was a liability from the first game and should not played another minute
He didn't maximize the potential of the sides he was given to work with. Other teams have gone on to win cups with way less talent.The one final and the semi-final they got to ,we actually had the stronger squads if you ask me.His in-match management has also not been the best , he just lacks that key element winners have to get their teams across the line.
JB, just telling it as it is. In time of deceit, the truth is a revolutionary act.
Barns is the boss
JOHNY B SPITTING FACTS
Nah you need Brian Clough type manger
What do you mean 'a Brian Clough type manager' ? Give the man himself, Brian Clough the England job now. He has been overlooked for far too long!
@@leeneon854 😂 Cloughie had no tactical nous. Depended on his right hand man like no tomorrow
Warnock or Rednapp for me...
Proper Managers.
@@waynemarshall8836untrue and it's a myth about him..His support staff were excellent Inc Peter Taylor and his chief scout though..
I wouldn't say Gareth's tenure was a failure outright but over 8 years , it was satisfactory at best. I would be interested to see how he would fare at club level going forward.
Barnes is the best pundit I have listened to on Talksport
Why do we want a manager with a soft approach no we need a manager with ball's
@@Keiron-pw6sl like Capello 😂
@@waynemarshall8836 yes he wouldn't play players on reputations
We need someone with a proven record of winning major trophies - regardless of nationality. Tuchel is the man, surely? Ten major trophy wins under his belt. No current ties to any club (therefore no compensation to pay out) and can start immediately. He commands his technical area and gets the best out of his players. Southgate was just sat there praying for miracles.
@@treble20 I don’t understand how English people want a German managing there team. Genuinely laughable
Southgate analysis is simple. 1. He must be respected and praised for achieving more than any England manager since Alf Ramsey; 2. He's a class act and gentleman in the way he unified the team, managed the players and media; 3. He resigned with dignity at the exact right time as he's taken us as far as we can go; 4. The negative, defensive style of football he employed is simply not appropriate for the best attacking options we've had for generations; 5. We now need a manager that can create a system and environment that actually maximises our world class players' talents so we can see the best of Bellingham, Foden. Oh and who picks based on form and performance, not favouritism or brand.
Totally agree with Barnes but he forgot Owen, joe coke, aol Campbell. People have no perspective Southgate done well for navigating such a young team to the final. He could of made changes earlier no doubt, or started players rested players to keep them more energised. But 2 finals and one semi is an accomplishment. Yes we might have won had he made changes, but let’s not take away the enjoyment we experienced in the journey.
Sir Bobby Robson also managed and won things at club level, producing and coaching some of the worlds best. Southgate got Middlesbrough relegated 🤷♂️
Robson also had elite success in Holland, Portugal and Spain..He would likely have won the First Division title with Ipswich in the late 1970s and early 1980s but for a Clough led Forrest, Paisleys Liverpool and Villa, all European cup winners in that period as well..
I agree how good Robson was, but over his 4 Tournaments he had disasters. 84 never qualified, 86 QF well out played in that match, 88 3 losses, 90 Easy route, struggled past Belgium and Cameroon. Lost in SF. I write in the same way as it applies to Southgate.
It was after in his later jobs as he improved with experience it was shown how good he was, the press were against him quite often as well.. Although he was good all the way as I remember, sometimes it's the players..
@@markpodlesak7204 In his defence for failing to qualify for '84'..they was a shedding process going on..Keegan/Brooking/Thompson and others were being discarded..Italy failed to qualify as well..my biggest criticism of him was over the poor start in Mexico when the team's form was good and not following the logic of pre/tourney matches and qualifications, but dropping Robson/Wilkins would have taken exceptional bravery but they would have swept the group if they had done so..The '88' campaign was a disaster but it was a bloody hard group with the two teams that produced the two finalists and England held their own for 70 mins against the Dutch and played the Irish off it for most of their match..Never cracked how to play Waddle and Barnes together..Robson made England a highly effective international team in the 1980s though they were not Germany etc al..
@@kailashpatel1706 Yes I get and remember all this. But I wrote from the reasoning used today against Southgate.
In 82 they coped quite well without Keegan or Brooking, but did miss some quality.
Please get more John Barnes on Talksport. He thinks before he opens his mouth and doesn't have the parochial expectation of so many English commentators that there is some divine right for England to win.
Graeme Potter is undoubtedly the man to take us forward. Very impressive manger skills.
Barns was correct about the so-called golden generation here. How many of the current team would have played ahead of anyone in that team. Very few.
yep
Barnes..........."Maximized Potential"?! he got nowhere close to that in this tournament
Sport on John Barnes👏🏾👏🏾 But that Graham Potter part beings a spin to the conversation smh
We’re not blessed I’ve been saying it for years. For starters kane being compared to shearer is outrageous. Comparing grealish to Gascogine at one point is crazy. Saying saka is better then beckham is silly.
Exactly this but it suits the anti Southgate narrative to pretend Trippier at left back is better than Ashley Cole
Some people are celebrating, yet they should hold their horses and be careful what they wish for.
Southgate has raised standards and expectations. Under Southgate England has gone deep into tournaments. There is now an expectation to win and het to finals. If the next man doesn't qualify or get out of the group-stage, people will be crying out for Southgate in a few years time! There will have to be pragmatism at times, not all teams can merely be turned over.
In terms of the new manager:
If English, has to be: Eddie Howe or Carsley.
If non-English: Klopp (though doubtful he would ever take, as he wants to relax, so no idea why his name is being constantly thrown into the mix).
No way Lampard, Rooney or Gerrard. They have poor man-management and inter-personal skills.
No way: the Argentian Pochettino.
3 wins in these Euros. One Score Draw. One no score draw. One Loss. That is SG’s achievement in this tournament.
@@GaneshJU I'm talking since his tenure not judging just on this tournament.
Barnes doesnt think his time at Celtic and Tranmere as a manager was a failure, his opinion on management is irrelevant .That is all
The past players Barnes is talking about had very different draws. The opposition was also far better than those we play now so it isn't a great comparison
This is wrong. Sven faced a ten man Brazil for 45 mins in a World Cup in Japan where all the decent teams had already gone out. Argentina and France went out in the group stages! Italy to South Korea. It was a golden opportunity missed. Southgate would have got vilified for that. I could mention the Portugal defeats but tbh I’m still annoyed by them 😊
If England fans are going to bring the quality of opposition into the debate, it will be a never-ending story.
The guy screen left knows his stuff and I love the fact he’s wearing an England top too👏👏👏
Everyones been wanting southgate sacked, now were stuck with potter, lampard, rooney etc and the majority of entitled England fans are linking us to klopp and anchilotti. Barnes is right, were not entitled to win every tournament. Give your spains out there some credit
precisely you think its easy to win a trophy there only two of them either the copa america if your in southh america ,the euro then the most prized possession and hardest of them all the world cup and not every big team can arrive at the final at once
france didnt make it ,germany didnt make it portugal didot make it ,italy, holland , Croatia
That's why I said it will be many years down the road before Southgate's work gets appreciated. There were better teams with world class players in the past that never won a major tournament. England shouldn't feel so entitled to win.
Get in, John. So well said.
Potter? Which major trophies has he won? We need someone with a proven record of winning major trophies - regardless of nationality. Tuchel is the man, surely? Ten major trophy wins under his belt. No current ties to any club (therefore no compensation to pay out) and can start immediately. He commands his technical area and gets the best out of his players. Southgate was just sat there praying for miracles.
Lee Carsley - he won the U21 Euros against Spain. England haven't won that trophy for a long time and he won it.
@@humptydumpty20 We need someone used to managing elite players and winning trophies. Tuchel is a former world club manager of the year and has won 10 major trophies. If he was English there wouldn't be a debate. He's available (so no compensation to pay out). Get him in!
@@treble20 He's German, he will get bashed by the media and fans if he meets Germany and England loses. And expectations in the 2026 WC will be huge based on the back-to-back Euro finals. Any manager reaching less than a Final will be criticised heavily again - it would be wiser to take over after the 2026 WC. Tuchel can get higher paying club jobs anytime without this toxic BS.
@@humptydumpty20 It is reported that he is interested in the job.
@@treble20 I know - the media also report that Pep is interested. The journalists need stories to write. Let's wait and see who is appointed in the end.
Refreshing to hear a smart man speak about football
John Barnes react very very well. Time Will tell.
Barnes was right about how we should of brought Sterling, Rashford, Grealish and Maguire as it was a team, Southgate built a team and basically sold 4/5 players all at once and tgen expected to just gel. It also would of affected the mood in the camp and it's Bellingham was a problem on and off the pitch and there was no one there to calm his ego down. You don't just pick players on form as you will never have a team. Other countries don't automatically pick best players
Barnes gets it spot on!!
wow never thought JB would talk that much sense
Most critics are not saying England should have won, but that they could have but mostly didn't play to their potential.
It's not unreasonable to regard England as one of the tournament favourites, they had 3rd best FIFA ranking (European team)
Should have asked john if he was happy with how england played during these euros.
He said himself the england players were better than the spanish players. And then nullifies the effect of the manager.
Yamal was non existent in the final he says?
He set up the first goal.
Love John because as a liverpool fan i adored him when he played there. But his thoughts on football since then and now dont impress me.
Potter is the perfect manager. He has won buggerall in his career-just like England-and plays boring, negative football-just like England. Can't think of a better suited manager for England.
We have some excellent players but if i'm honest if I was doing an all time best England 11 none of the current crop would be in it.
he is always cooking, damn chef Barbes
John there is no Zidane, Rivaldio, Ronaldo, figo, Rui Costa, Xavi, Inesta etc now
It's an indictment on our media space that such intelligent and forthright personality as Mr Barnes is not a regular or mainstay analyst on such programmes.
I think of most of the other "analysts" and it feels me with such dismay.
He makes them all sound so stale.
As a nation we have to get over the mentality of ‘a manager getting the sack so their rubbish’. Some of the greatest manager like Ancelloti have been sacked multiple time yet still gets hired. Potter has a style and philosophy that’s attacking which this team needs.
Exactly Ancelotti was the nearly man at Juventus and Parma before he started winning. Same with Inzaghi.
Barnes is bang on! Portugal and France. Dreadful. Turkey..i liked that performance at the big stage..after so many dark horse times..finally Turkey turned up. Holland were solid. Germany at home were not embarrassed.
All us England fans wanted to see in the tournament was true grit and determination. Regardless if we are the best or not England never turned up and that is on the Manager, ultimately he is in charge. If you get bad customer service in a business you don't ask for the next assistant, you ask for the manager. You assume they are in charge and responsible for the training and quality of service the staff are giving. As a Leicester fan I know you can win things on grit and determination and playing as a team, and not just who has the best players.
John barnes for england manager. We need a former player & legend!
IF BARNES WANTS POTTER ...WE DONT WANT HIM.
He's correct about world class players and we (England) don't have any. The standard of the premiership is dropping each season with over inflated players being sold at over inflated prices and you can see why players are now moving abroad. We need a manager who won't be afraid to drop players and after the Euros you could be looking at 4 or 5 players not being guaranteed a place in the starting eleven, a players wins his place on performances and not hype and name.
John has always been a top notch pundit right from super sport. This guy should be a regular cause the other are below par tbh.
John barnes.
That doyen of football management.
😅
Well done John Barnes. Us 🏴 do have one of the very best squads in the world , yes but there are a few other groups that are a bit ahead of us , and some others that are not far behind us, at all. England does have BIG potential, tho.
John Barnes scored one goal people remember and that's it he really has nothing to say IMHO.
A damn site more than you.
go look up the one he scored for england against uruguay
Problem was the overhyped players, not GS. Rice, Bellingham, Kane, Gallagher, Maguire, etc. were the problem not GS. England was an average team that didn’t deserve to reach the finals.
The Old grey hair lady/man needs a reality check.
What top players do England really have, that’s why Jude played pants as did numbers 1-11 plus the bench. All were Mickey Mouse level 🐭🐭🐭
😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆 she might sue you for misgendering him/her 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Am I the only one who can see this ?
Who is worse? Liane Sanderson or Gabby Agbonlahor?
She didn't say anything ridiculous.
@@fugitivemoses7515 Hi Liane👋
Both
@@Hod101 Explain one thing she said that didn't make sense?
@@fugitivemoses7515 all I know is the 5 minutes her microphone wasn’t working was the best part of the whole show
It won’t make one bit of difference whoever takes over. The FA need to restructure the Prem, when a major tournament is in the same calendar year. Then maybe, just maybe, Fresh players, fit athletes, ALL giving it 100%, may just bring home a trophy, and change the past 58 years of burnt out players in our footballing History. 🤔 Thanks Gareth, huge efforts, much respect 🙏🏻🙏🏻
I think what JB is referring to with management style is a generational thing, we generation Xers now have to manage millennials and gen z and I think GS had the recipe right, the players were engaged and wanted to play for him
Graham potter is good for club football. Get Stevie G and Lampard to do the job.
Eniola Aluko should be the next England manager!
Don’t give them any ideas!
Who?
This man has sense
Lol
Nico william new in international, yamal, olmo, a CB in Saudi, a RB, they swore that they wont swap with walker, etc.
Talking fast doesnt = making sense.
John the egghead Barnes 😂😂😂
Barnes is correct, Southgate and England benefited from the great Foreign managers that have turned our football around,the Dinosaur hoof ball managers are long gone thank god, and long may that last! The irony is Pickford hoof it up the field and give posetion away his manager is a British dinosaur in Sean Dyche 🤣
@@sirbaconbutties7071You can’t blame Dyche for that, Pickfords always been doing that
@@Youafool500 Thats his club manager,that should have smacked out of him,These dudes are on ridiculous wages, and your Keeper should be the most level headed player on the pitch..
Dude is a legend still
Potter ? Nooo
Not potter
lol Yamal provided the assist to Nico for the first goal and almost had 2 goals in the final
Potter is miles better than Southgate tactically.
did Barnes just say that Yamal was non-existant in the final? did he have his eyes shut for the whole game?
To be fair he couldn’t get passed shaw In first half it was that Williams on the other side that caused the most trouble
@@leepowell1408 yamal made the assist for the first goal
@@chenks76 yeah that’s why I specifically said first half he was better in the second half but what I’m saying is I think we dealt with him quite well overall
@@leepowell1408 point is, Barnes is talking his usual nonsense. surprised he never tried to say it was because he was black that the team failed, that's his usual explanation for everything
@@chenks76 yeah I get you point I do think it is wrong choice of words to say he was completely non existent
Potter lampard howe will all be better then Southgate
Potter and Lampard 😂? England's so called golden generation is gonna be ruined even further 😂 and I'm loving it 🇮🇪
Good shout for Potter
England will need Harry Potter to win a trophy
@@user-lt4px7ld4u 😂😂
Potter not big enough for Chelsea is starting to sound at about the righy level for England. Cos the work at Brighton might be right level we need.
Get Klopp or Pep or Carlo or Conti or Mancini or Lippi. Get a serial winner to end 60 yrs of hurt vs. Messi & Argentina in the USA World Cup final 2026. Or 62 yrs of hurt in Euro 2028 if Leo does what Leo does & defeats 3 🦁.
Agree with Johnny B
Don’t know what Barnes is taking
I do
open your ears up is pretty clear
Commonsense..
Something that eludes most..
Thats quite normal every now and then someone speaks sense.
Losing to one of the worst Italian sides in history, an italian side that couldn't even qualify for the world cup. at Wembley in the euro final was one of the biggest failures in english football.
how did one of the worst italian sides make it to that final if they was so worse
One of the worst Italian sides consisting of Donnarumma, Chiellini, Bonucci, Verratti could beat England. That says a lot about the level of the England team 😁😀
Well said John B..
Why dont the media have a T V programme....called SOUTHGATE.
god its boring talking baout him all day every day.
Are we honestly comparing someone like Declan Rice to ANYONE in that Spanish side?
Weve just heard why john barnes was a failure as a manager
Best player in England: English. Best player in Spain: English. Highest goal scorer in Germany: English. But we don't have the best players in the world. OK, John, okay. I'd argue as a collection, we had the best team in the Euros. And our best player couldn't even start!
cherry picking aint a good argument mate
Best player in Spain is English? Is he? 😂
Best squad doesn't = best team. I ain't going into the debate that Portugal and France had a better squad.
A team with players that no¹ will remember??? Leigh ann?? England got beat by a team of nobody's then?? What is this women talking
I got to say this man speaks sense but to say yamine lamal was inexistence in the final makes no sense, created a goal, had 3 very good scoring opportunities. I do say he was inexistence in the 1st half but in the 2nd half he showed up
Bellingham.....best player in La Liga, Kane top scorer in Europe n Germany, Foden ..
best player in PL 😂
When Southgate dragged football into politics and race issues he really P off a lot of football fans. Even black mates were embarrassed in the pub when they did the kneeling fiasco.
yes all aload of nonsense
and if he had any real effect why have they all sopped doing it
i take you was p off
Football fans sound like a sensitive bunch then if they are still gurning about it
Nice one mate! Your analysis on Aston Villa is great & it would seem you have a liking for our great club, cos you make alot of Villa content & proves you have good taste &. with much happening at Villa nowadays many talking points.... UP THE MIGHTY VILLA!!! 😉
Only 2 Spanish player was in Real Madrid champions league starting 11 which means majority of Spanish team will be from other Clubs such as the 5 from Atletico Club.
I’ve been hearing these same arguments and excuses all my life. English players never play well enough as a national team…they lost again.
Now everyone starts talking about the young players, the next tournament, the next manager, the promise for the future blah blah blah…They were saying the same about Lineker, Gazza and Barnes Hoddle and Waddle, Beckham et al… and we are still in the same situation.
Exactly. Top international teams dissect their team performance post tournament and come back stronger to actually win something. England always looks for someone to blame and find a ton of excuses for not winning. The same old story.
No
So let's replace one boring manager with yet another one... Potter won't do any good, but he won't give the FA a hard time.
I agree with Barnes. Potter was my first thought.
Me too.
Harry Potter.
@@pato2200😆😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
Looking forward to all the memes when Potter is appoint as the next England manager.